r/philosophyoflanguage • • Jun 05 '21

Why in general, repeated humor doesn't work ?

7 Upvotes

Hi guys, I have to do a kind of short essay on humor and expecially parody.

I was wondering why with repetition, a joke can become "old" and sound corny.

My hypothesis is that with repetition, the meaning and ultimate goal of the joke shifts the attention to whom is making the joke and not the what the actual mean of the sentence is.

Is like if with repetition, the meaning of the joke shifts towards the desire of the joker of being socially accepted and or considered funny; hence the joker becomes the subject of the joke himself.

This probably does not make any sense.

Actually I have no idea on where to start studying this phenomenon and I'm interested to read anything about that.


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Apr 24 '21

Reading group on Naming and Necessity

5 Upvotes

Hello everyone, we are a group of avid philosophy readers and in mid-May we will start a reading group on Kripke's classic work. The meetings will be weekly and last 90 minutes each.

It will be an in depth reading without prior knowledge required. To achieve the reading will proceed slowly, a few pages per week. The group moderator (who btw is not me) has a Master in philosophy, works as a researcher at university and has a long standing interest in the philosophy of language.

If this sounds appealing to you, let me know either by commenting below or by sending me a PM. We will try to establish a day and time that works for as many people as possible(bearing in mind we live in very different time zones).


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Nov 05 '20

New Ordinary Language Philosophy (OLP) community

5 Upvotes

I've set up a new community to discuss Ordinary Language Philosophy (OLP): https://www.reddit.com/r/ordinarylanguagephil/

I didn't see any forum for this elsewhere, so took it on myself to create one. If you're interested, join the community and join the discussion!


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Apr 17 '23

Has there been any philosophical progress that has been made in philosophy of language?

4 Upvotes

Recently, I was thinking of getting into philosophy and studying it at university, however, one of my friends, who is a scientist (physicist) ridiculed me for thinking about this as he believes philosophy is useless or worthless at best and actively harmful at worst. He sees science as being the only or best source of knowledge. He justified this by claiming that science makes progress and philosophy makes no progress.

I was therefore wondering has philosophy of language made any progress at all in the past few centuries? If so, what are some examples of this? Has it made any recent progress in the twentieth century/twenty-first century? Does it have any practical benefit to science (or society) today? Thanks.


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Apr 02 '23

"Hegel in a wired brain" - what if we could read minds? | Seduction, jokes, pokes, sarcasm, lyrics and other quirks of language

Thumbnail lastreviotheory.blogspot.com
4 Upvotes

r/philosophyoflanguage • • Jul 29 '21

Question about Philosophy of language

4 Upvotes

I wanted to understand the expression and use of the term ‘taking.’

I will give 2 examples in contrast to illustrate the confusion.

Jim: How are you getting home?

Billy: I am taking a cab

2)

Tommy: where are you going?

Jeff: I am taking a shit

In the first instance, we could say the meaning of ‘taking’ would be Billy is claiming a specific taxi for himself to use. Billy is taking the cab and no one else is. At least right now.

In the second example, Jeff is not really claiming his own excrement, we would all agree he has ownership of that object. We would also not assume that once Jeff exits the restroom, he would be holding his excrement as it was taken with him. In all instances of ‘taking a shit, aside from the disorder of Coprophilia, the shit is left and disposed of, not taken.

So why do we say, “I am taking a shit” when everyone is “leaving a shit?”


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Jul 12 '22

How was the order of the letters of the alphabet established?

3 Upvotes

The wikipedia page for "alphabetical order" merely states when the alphabetical order started being used (1st millennium BCE), but my question is HOW the order of the letters was decided upon. It can't have been arbitrary... it is how it is because of certain factors. Any ideas as to what those factors may have been?


r/philosophyoflanguage • • May 12 '22

Articulating the World: Conceptual Understanding and the Scientific Image by Joseph Rouse — new online reading group starting Sunday May 15, free and open to everyone!

Thumbnail
self.philosophyevents
3 Upvotes

r/philosophyoflanguage • • Jun 06 '21

Meno's Paradox || Plato, Bono, and the Equivocation Fallacy

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/philosophyoflanguage • • Feb 28 '21

My book in philosophy of language keeps making the argument that if an ant made a mark that spelled out Winston Churchill it would not have meaning but if a history teacher wrote it, it would. I don’t see why the ants markings wouldn’t have meaning? (I may have misunderstood).

3 Upvotes

(From my notes)

What is the difference between marks and sounds that have meaning and those that do not?

For an example as Hillary Putnam puts it, if an ant falls into a pot of ink and crawls out and leaves a trail that looks like this, Winston Churchill, then the marks are qualitatively identical to the marks a history teacher makes when he writes Winston Churchill on a whiteboard. Nevertheless the marks the history teacher has made are about Winston Churchill, the marks the ant has made are not. They’re not about anything at all; they lack meaning.

But I don’t understand why the marks the ant has made can’t still have meaning in English, the meaning of Winston Churchill even if the ant didn’t intend to write that and has no idea who Winston Churchill is? Is it because then any gibberish word could potentially have meaning?


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Aug 20 '20

Someone knowledgeable and patient to talk to

3 Upvotes

Hi, I was wondering if anyone would be willing to dedicate some time to talk to me about philosophy via email or other channels of direct communication.

I am graduating in comparative literature and art history this fall (hopefully), and I am interested in continuing my studies but in philosophy. I would apprieciate someone's advice on it, since I took additional courses in philosophy on my own, read a lot on my own, preoccupied myself with the topics of my interest in my free time, etc. (basically, I have realized by now that philosophy offers a far better lens for what I am interested in).

Now, my knowledge is not comparable to someone who has actually been trained in the field and I cannot talk to any professors now due to the pandemic (they do not really prefer to communicate via email). I need someone whom I can ask various questions, who could recommend me what to read, what to pay attention to, etc.

My focus is philosophy of language. Also, I am preoccupied with representation in art, I find Nelson Goodman to be interesting, etc. I have a strong background in semiotic theory, but I feel stuck with it and feel like I am missing something there. I hope there is someone who would not be too bugged if I reached out! Any help is appreciated.


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Jul 05 '18

Are All Generalizations False? The Epistemic Elimination of Un-Quantified Generalizations

Thumbnail
gregconan.wordpress.com
3 Upvotes

r/philosophyoflanguage • • May 04 '17

The reality dissection fallacy — Language is a scalpel

Thumbnail
medium.com
3 Upvotes

r/philosophyoflanguage • • Mar 11 '24

Do words in natural languages have "correct" definitions?

2 Upvotes

I always though that talking about "correct" definitions of words was the same as talking about the "correct" thing to eat for breakfast but I'm willing to be wrong. Do words in natural languages have "correct" definitions?


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Dec 08 '23

Books or learning material suggestions

2 Upvotes

I am very excited to learn about the philosophy of language, but every book I touch is very hard for a beginner. Can any suggest books or other material that are 101 level in this field may be 201 as well. thanks


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Oct 28 '23

Quine's criticism of analyticity

2 Upvotes

About Quine's criticism of the notion of analyticity dependent on word meaning...

Is he arguing that such a notion is contingent on the dynamic, conceptual nature of word relations which are difficult to define without resulting in circularity?

So to explain why "dogs are animals" (dog being a hyponym of animal) or "all bachelors are unmarried" (unmarried being a property of bachelors by definition) is true we have to explain what exactly it is about the word relations that make it so that these statements are true? And by defining these word relations by examples of such relations we may result in circular reasoning?

That doesn't change the fact that the truth values of these sentences follow from knowing the meanings of the words and their relation though...


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Aug 08 '23

Saul Kripke's classic Naming and Necessity (1980) — An online reading and discussion group, meetings on Sunday August 13 & 27, open to everyone

Thumbnail
self.philosophyevents
2 Upvotes

r/philosophyoflanguage • • Jun 14 '23

Thoughts on the semantics/pragmatics of diagnosis and its ability to create new identities and communities?

2 Upvotes

Do we need a diagnosis to be justified in feeling we belong to a space? Especially since many people don’t seek out help because of reasons that are often results of the very same disorder. Besides insurance purposes, what is diagnosis meant to be doing? At both a psychiatric and semantic/pragmatic level? Do our doctors, who may or may not vaguely be fellows of the same professional associations grant us this fellowship and communion? How? Through a speech-act?


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Jan 20 '23

Concepts talk in Philosophy of Language vs. CogSci

2 Upvotes

Hey! Is anybody else struggling to reconcile talk about meaning in 'traditional' phil of language (e.g. Donaldson's 'meaning is knowledge of truth conditions' & the role concepts play there) and different theories of concepts in cogsci/psychology/AI (i.e. resemblance/ prototype/microtheory) This has always been tricky for me and I've finally mustered the courage (under the cloak of anonynity) to sound stupid and BEG for someone to bridge this for me. I'm aware people like Fodor straddled the two, but dont yet feel competent enough to engage with his work critically... any reading suggestions?/SOMEONE EXPLAIN pls


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Dec 20 '22

Tractatus: What is the logical picture of a negative propostition?

2 Upvotes

I was wondering how do you picture a logical picture in general. And if you do it spatially - like my professor - what is the logical picture of a negative proposition like: It doesn't rain outside.

What objects do get involved (everything except rain?) and how can i imagine it. Can you make a picture of negation of something? Do you imagine a crossed picture where it rains - exaggerated. Or do you think about every other possible situation except rain at once? - since it must be a logical picture of a fact which is just a combination of objects.

I hope the question makes sense. The thing is I dont really get the idea of a logical picture i think.