r/philosophyoflanguage • • Dec 30 '23

Frege and Russell’s descriptive theory of names

1 Upvotes

Hi there,

Need some help understanding these theories for an essay, any help much appreciated 🙏


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Apr 10 '22

A Map of the Universe - A new paper focusing on the importance of language to the human experience.

1 Upvotes

Considers languages as necessary for perceiving the Universe, the signifier slippage induced by language, and the manner in which truths are defined within the axioms of language.

Paper: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4077540

Abstract: A Map of the Universe explores the fundamental laws of the Universe, the mechanisms which allow a subject to perceive the Universe, and the features of post-perception existence. The Map is constructed from a set of axioms that optimally capture knowledge of the Universe with respect to the constraints of perception.This project is situated inside a historical continuum of metaphysical exploration and draws on findings from the fields of logic, semiotics, mathematics, metaphysics, philosophy, and literature. Out of the Map falls theories of perception, consciousness, determinism, self, the role of language, and the nature of the Universe as a whole.


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Apr 05 '22

Kripke on Hypothetical Languages

Thumbnail self.askphilosophy
1 Upvotes

r/philosophyoflanguage • • May 02 '23

Exploring the Language of Reality: How Our Mind Shapes Our Perception

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/philosophyoflanguage • • Jul 11 '19

Wittgenstein

1 Upvotes

I do want to study Wittgenstein, where should I start, are there any community I can join, an online series of lectures I can watch?


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Dec 11 '20

Philosophy of Language and Personality Disorders

2 Upvotes

Has anyone done any studies on the way language operates in people with different personality disorders? I'm especially interested in language aquisition in those with such disturbances, but I'm not sure where to look for insights. Is that even something that interests contemporary psychiatry? Do you think philosophy of language could be helpful in that domain or at least result in some interesting observations?

I also have in mind the field of cognitive science, with all the studies focused on the embodiment of cognition, prototypes, and basic-level categories, what do you think?

Thanks.


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Nov 18 '22

Wittgenstein and Williamson

2 Upvotes

Timothy Williamson isn’t exactly known as a Wittgenstein fan, but has anyone drawn the connection between some of his work/positions and some of Wittgenstein’s remarks? Thinking especially of the unanalyzability of ‘knowledge’ into further N/S conditions.

Also and perhaps more interestingly, his view that the a priori/a posteriori distinction might exist but still isn’t “useful”


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Nov 15 '22

Can you help me with this phenomenon? One can have a sense of something without good language for it; but once the language is discovered (or created), it becomes much, much easier to understand

2 Upvotes

I am trying to understand something, and cannot find people in my circle to address it. I am not a philosopher. But I have seen this phenomenon many times myself, and it seems pretty central in life.

When we have proper terms with which to meaningfully discuss something in a certain way, it radically facilitates our ability to discuss that thing. It can open up whole new vistas in terms of ways to discuss it.

And yet, we can certainly try to think about that thing, prior to having good terms to discuss it with. My best example is systems thinking. I am in systems thinking course right now with Fritjof Capra and learning all the work that has been done over the past 70 years or so to describe how life behaves, using some much more satisfying models than the ones we had in the past.

A great example is the emergence of chaos theory in the 1960s to describe weather patterns. Around this time, computers were becoming powerful enough to help modelers accurately represent these very complex nonlinear equations that closely represent the behavior of chaotic systems. Since then, a really fascinating body of study has evolved in biology, chemistry, and elsewhere to describe the behavior of living systems — networks of interrelated parts, each organism dynamically maintaining its homeostasis by interacting in unpredictable ways with its environment.

Reductionist models simply cannot adequately describe the emergent properties of elements in relation to one another. For example, take the atoms that make up a sugar molecule. On their own, they do not taste sweet; the sweetness comes into being as an emergent property of their relationship.

So... years before I had ever learned what systems theory was, I had an intuition that there were complex, dynamic interrelationships between things that were important, but were not well described by the thought patterns prevalent in my culture at the time.

Just watching the linguistic philosophers video you shared, they seemed to suggest that any abstract concept is purely a human construction, but I am sure I am oversimplifying. At any rate, it is clear to me that I could have intuitions about these systems-level phenomena prior to having any great language to describe them. And indeed, you could say that these systems behaviors are abstract, but not really. They are not purely conceptual at all. If you take a walk in nature and appreciate how everything dances harmoniously and flows in interrelationship, that is clearly accessible to our "mind", which of course includes our body, our whole senses, and that physio-spatial sense that we share with other creatures. You can feel it, to put it a certain way.

So there were plenty of ways for me to experience and "sense" that there was something I could observe in life, even though that was not described well by the language I had available to me at the time. And while the phenomenon was not as abstract as "truth" or what have you, it was also certainly not as concrete as a rock or a table.

So to repeat myself, I had intuitions about the dynamic, interrelating weblike nature of life before I had great words to describe it. And yet... Here is the main point, which I think is so interesting. Once I started learning the language of systems thinking, it became much, much easier to think about it.

There. was a rapid acceleration in the connections I could make, and how I could make the knowledge that came from those connections useful. Sure, part of it was feeling I wasn't crazy. But it was more than that. Once I had a conceptual framework and vocabulary, it was much, much easier to understand life in terms of those interrelated flows. Once I inherited the embedded knowledge around how to see the world in this way, it facilitated my own understanding greatly.

So, I find this phenomenon so interesting, and potentially so helpful, and I was wondering who speaks about this? Linguists? Philosophers? Anthropologists? Honestly, I have no idea. I was wondering if you might be able to point me to the right (practical) areas where people are talking about this phenomenon.

I thank you for any help you can provide.


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Jul 12 '22

How was the order of the letters of the alphabet established?

3 Upvotes

The wikipedia page for "alphabetical order" merely states when the alphabetical order started being used (1st millennium BCE), but my question is HOW the order of the letters was decided upon. It can't have been arbitrary... it is how it is because of certain factors. Any ideas as to what those factors may have been?


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Apr 24 '21

Reading group on Naming and Necessity

5 Upvotes

Hello everyone, we are a group of avid philosophy readers and in mid-May we will start a reading group on Kripke's classic work. The meetings will be weekly and last 90 minutes each.

It will be an in depth reading without prior knowledge required. To achieve the reading will proceed slowly, a few pages per week. The group moderator (who btw is not me) has a Master in philosophy, works as a researcher at university and has a long standing interest in the philosophy of language.

If this sounds appealing to you, let me know either by commenting below or by sending me a PM. We will try to establish a day and time that works for as many people as possible(bearing in mind we live in very different time zones).


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Dec 20 '22

Tractatus: What is the logical picture of a negative propostition?

2 Upvotes

I was wondering how do you picture a logical picture in general. And if you do it spatially - like my professor - what is the logical picture of a negative proposition like: It doesn't rain outside.

What objects do get involved (everything except rain?) and how can i imagine it. Can you make a picture of negation of something? Do you imagine a crossed picture where it rains - exaggerated. Or do you think about every other possible situation except rain at once? - since it must be a logical picture of a fact which is just a combination of objects.

I hope the question makes sense. The thing is I dont really get the idea of a logical picture i think.


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Jan 04 '23

Video: The Kripkenstein Paradox

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/philosophyoflanguage • • Jan 20 '23

Concepts talk in Philosophy of Language vs. CogSci

2 Upvotes

Hey! Is anybody else struggling to reconcile talk about meaning in 'traditional' phil of language (e.g. Donaldson's 'meaning is knowledge of truth conditions' & the role concepts play there) and different theories of concepts in cogsci/psychology/AI (i.e. resemblance/ prototype/microtheory) This has always been tricky for me and I've finally mustered the courage (under the cloak of anonynity) to sound stupid and BEG for someone to bridge this for me. I'm aware people like Fodor straddled the two, but dont yet feel competent enough to engage with his work critically... any reading suggestions?/SOMEONE EXPLAIN pls


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Aug 08 '23

Saul Kripke's classic Naming and Necessity (1980) — An online reading and discussion group, meetings on Sunday August 13 & 27, open to everyone

Thumbnail
self.philosophyevents
2 Upvotes

r/philosophyoflanguage • • Oct 19 '22

The Linguistic Turn: Solving Metaphysical Problems through Linguistic Precision — An online group discussion on Sunday October 23, free and open to everyone

Thumbnail self.philosophyevents
2 Upvotes

r/philosophyoflanguage • • Mar 13 '20

Russell's Philosophy of Language

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/philosophyoflanguage • • May 26 '20

Can you close the window?

1 Upvotes

Suppose we are in the same room, and I say to you: “Can you close the window?”. In most circumstances, this interrogative sentence would be intended and understood as a request. Why is that?


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Dec 18 '17

Logic Cannot Explain Natural Language

Thumbnail
ideasinhat.com
1 Upvotes

r/philosophyoflanguage • • Dec 23 '19

What do words mean? - Semantic change and definitions

Thumbnail
bebeflapula.blogspot.com
1 Upvotes

r/philosophyoflanguage • • Feb 05 '22

Philosophy Discussion Discord Server for Academics, students, autodidacts, and general learners

1 Upvotes

I would like to invite you to a philosophy discord server. For teachers, students, and autodidacts.

The purpose of this discord chat is dedicated to the engagement of philosophical discourse and the exploration of ideas in the history of philosophy. Our main goal is to become more knowledgeable about historical thinkers and ideas from every philosophical domain through interpersonal dialogues. We are not a debate server. Argument is a method used by philosophy, but this isn’t to be confused with debate. The latter is competitive in nature, whereas the former is a cooperative endeavor. Philosophy is a group project that aims to determine what is true, and this server is a place for this activity. 

https://discord.gg/NyesZ6e5cp

Invite link is hopefully permanent, so you won't have to worry whether the link is working if you're reading this sometime in the future.

See you all there!


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Oct 28 '23

Quine's criticism of analyticity

2 Upvotes

About Quine's criticism of the notion of analyticity dependent on word meaning...

Is he arguing that such a notion is contingent on the dynamic, conceptual nature of word relations which are difficult to define without resulting in circularity?

So to explain why "dogs are animals" (dog being a hyponym of animal) or "all bachelors are unmarried" (unmarried being a property of bachelors by definition) is true we have to explain what exactly it is about the word relations that make it so that these statements are true? And by defining these word relations by examples of such relations we may result in circular reasoning?

That doesn't change the fact that the truth values of these sentences follow from knowing the meanings of the words and their relation though...


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Dec 08 '23

Books or learning material suggestions

2 Upvotes

I am very excited to learn about the philosophy of language, but every book I touch is very hard for a beginner. Can any suggest books or other material that are 101 level in this field may be 201 as well. thanks


r/philosophyoflanguage • • Aug 20 '20

Someone knowledgeable and patient to talk to

3 Upvotes

Hi, I was wondering if anyone would be willing to dedicate some time to talk to me about philosophy via email or other channels of direct communication.

I am graduating in comparative literature and art history this fall (hopefully), and I am interested in continuing my studies but in philosophy. I would apprieciate someone's advice on it, since I took additional courses in philosophy on my own, read a lot on my own, preoccupied myself with the topics of my interest in my free time, etc. (basically, I have realized by now that philosophy offers a far better lens for what I am interested in).

Now, my knowledge is not comparable to someone who has actually been trained in the field and I cannot talk to any professors now due to the pandemic (they do not really prefer to communicate via email). I need someone whom I can ask various questions, who could recommend me what to read, what to pay attention to, etc.

My focus is philosophy of language. Also, I am preoccupied with representation in art, I find Nelson Goodman to be interesting, etc. I have a strong background in semiotic theory, but I feel stuck with it and feel like I am missing something there. I hope there is someone who would not be too bugged if I reached out! Any help is appreciated.


r/philosophyoflanguage • • May 30 '16

In search of good counter-arguments against semantic internalism.

2 Upvotes

Hello! I am in the midst of writing a paper on Merleau-Ponty's internalistic stance on the relationship between meaning and expression (that is: The meaning of expressions is internally or immanently present in all expressions). Meanwhile, I am having a bit of trouble locating a good source for arguments against this sort of stance. That is: I need some good arguments in support of semantic externalism....


r/philosophyoflanguage • • May 04 '17

The reality dissection fallacy — Language is a scalpel

Thumbnail
medium.com
3 Upvotes