Interdisciplinary Inquiry at the Intersection of Philosophy (Aesthetics), Artificial Intelligence, and Art
Dear Colleagues,
Jason Allen’s Théâtre D’opéra Spatial, generated via Midjourney, was awarded the blue ribbon in the Emerging Digital Artist category at the Colorado State Fair art competition, provoking intense contestation within the art world. Many artists levelled accusations of “cheating” against him. To a considerable degree, generative artificial intelligence has begun to displace human literary and artistic production. With only limited human oversight, such systems are capable of composing music, manipulating photographic imagery, generating moving images, drafting screenplays and producing films, and in certain domains, they achieve outputs that surpass human creative performance. These creative practices and their resultant artefacts have been conceptualized by scholars under the rubric of “generative AI art”. While spectators marvel at the striking works yielded by generative models, they simultaneously face a disquieting prospect: the artistic realm, traditionally bound to human affect and subjectivity, is progressively being reshaped by AI technologies, thereby destabilizing humanity’s standing as the primary agent of artistic creation. This development has elicited anxiety, apprehension and pushback from creative practitioners, together with broader public contestation and interdisciplinary scholarly scrutiny.
This Special Issue of Arts advances interdisciplinary philosophical-aesthetic research on AI-generated art, structured around four interconnected lines of inquiry: ontological, epistemological, axiological, and normative. It fosters cross-cultural dialogue by bringing Western aesthetic traditions—including phenomenology, hermeneutics, neuroaesthetics and the philosophy of art—into conversation with classical Eastern aesthetics, namely Taoist aesthetics, Chan aesthetics, and aesthetics from the Wei-Jin to Tang-Song periods. Topics of interest for publication include, but are not limited to:
(1) Ontological investigations of AI art: whether generative AI art can constitute an independent art form; the ontological conditions, identity criteria and mode of being of algorithmic artworks; the implications of distributed agency and non-human generative processes for the general ontology of art.
(2) Epistemological inquiries into artificial intelligence art, Assuming that aesthetic appreciation involves a distinctive kind of aesthetic knowledge, how does generative AI reshape its sources, warrant, transmission and justification? Can generative AI possess aesthetic knowledge, and what epistemic status attaches to aesthetic knowledge gained by humans from AI artworks?
(3) Axiological studies of artificial intelligence art, encompassing the examination of its value attributes, the identification of the subjects and institutions charged with valuation, the theoretical foundations governing the determination of artistic value, and the formulation of pathways for establishing standards of hierarchical classification and appraisal.
(4) Normative studies of artificial intelligence art, addressing issues including the aesthetic, technological, ethical and legal norms governing its creation, the problem of stylistic appropriation, the allocation of copyright, and the attribution of liability.
Yinchun Wang
Guest Editor