r/philosophy • • Jan 21 '23

Video The Drowning Child Thought Experiment argues that if you'd save a drowning child, you should give nearly all your disposable income to charity. It has a convincing logical structure, but runs into to trouble as it is indifferent to institutions and demandingness.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • Jan 30 '22

Blog The Ethics of Vaccination Passports

Thumbnail
prindlepost.org
6 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • Jan 17 '24

Video Questions of gender identity seem to place the mind above the body. Yet the desire to transition isn't confined to the mind; it's deeply rooted in a set of dispositions and urges that cannot be neatly attributed to either the mind or the body. | Sophie Grace Chappell

Thumbnail
iai.tv
2 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • Feb 11 '26

Video Understanding the hidden, sexual economy of U.S. Slavery and its modern effects- a Feminist analysis

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • May 24 '26

Video Butler on gender as a social performance and not a biological reality

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • May 28 '18

Blog Totalitarianism In Our Time: Arendt and Trump

Thumbnail
blog.apaonline.org
491 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • May 13 '18

Blog Having children is not life-affirming: it’s immoral

Thumbnail
aeon.co
77 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • May 22 '24

Blog The universe is made of experiences, not things. | The scientific materialist worldview mistakenly robs reality of its colour, temperature, and smell, leaving us with a picture of reality that is radically at odds with our common sense understanding of the world.

Thumbnail
iai.tv
0 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • May 24 '19

Blog Setting a maximum wage for CEOs would be good for everyone

Thumbnail
aeon.co
22.7k Upvotes

r/philosophy • • Oct 20 '11

In every Philosophy course I've ever taken, there is one a guy like this who has very strong opinions, but doesn't really understand the subject matter we're discussing

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • Feb 27 '23

Blog AI cannot achieve consciousness without a body.

Thumbnail
gizmodo.com
0 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • Nov 29 '24

Video A video critiquing Jordan Peterson's analysis of French Philosopher Michel Foucault

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • Feb 12 '09

The Five Year Ban: Because A Billion Less People Is A Great Place To Start

Thumbnail blogs.psychologytoday.com
5 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • Oct 09 '14

Recent news about Bill Maher, atheism, and Islam are great examples of why Philosophy needs to be taught from primary school onward.

0 Upvotes

I've been fairly reluctant to make any sort of mention about this whole deal with Bill Maher and Ben Afleck on Islam. For me, Maher's whole mantra surrounding his justifications for his beliefs are why so much in this world seems to be so wrong - from a human standpoint.

First, up until roughly two weeks ago I was an atheist. It was after an in depth reading into Euthyphro, Apology, Crito, Protagoras, Meno, and the first four books of The Republic that I was forced to reevaluate many of the notions of what I thought constituted liberty, justice, and most of the core principles the US is founded on. It was through this questioning that my thoughts wandered into my own atheism. I came to the conclusion that in an attempt to be intellectually honest with myself I couldn't call myself an atheist because I don't have any solid proof for the non-existence of any supernatural deities. Though I don't see any evidence for them, I cannot be certain and have to entertain the possibility that there may be a god(s) - however slight that may seem.

How does this relate to Bill Maher and Islam?

If there is anything that being a Philosophy major has taught me in the past three years, it's that nothing is ever black and white. There are (at least as I see it) no absolutes, even though the notion of this applied to morality would seem to invalidate any sort of moral authority. By this I mean, if morality isn't absolute, it must be dependent on the majority opinion of whatever culture one looks at. Because this can shift back and forth over time, it seems that morality isn't much of a thing to appeal to when justifying actions or classifying them as god or bad.

The thing is though, I am at least willing to entertain other's ideas about why mine might be wrong. Bill Maher and a whole host of others don't. They seem so caught up in the notion that they're right that they don't seem to be able to even entertain conflicting notions. And that principle applied on a global scale seems to be pervasive.

Certainly there are things I think have intrinsic values or qualities, but that doesn't mean that I am not open to hearing what other's opinions on these may be. Anecdotal as it may be, those I run into who are willing to entertain the ideas and criticisms of others just generally seem to be more amiable and all around genuine people. Those who can't or won't seem to be miserable to be around and often seem to cause some sort of conflict.

I can't think of anything in my life that has caused me to be this way other than studying philosophy. And as simple as it seems, I feel like our world might have half the problems it does now if more people studied philosophy. Sure, there would be people who don't fit the mold and would still be just as much like Maher, but then would they really be true to the underlying principles of philosophy?

Everything Plato, Socrates, Glaucon, and thrasymachus said about power and justice, virtue and mediation, democracy and tyrants... it all seems to be so right when I look around at the world today.

Just my thoughts. Sorry for the wall of text.


r/philosophy • • May 31 '24

Blog “Materialism is not science, it’s not even close” | Philosopher James Tartaglia makes the case for the much maligned metaphysical idealism, and how society could benefit from making it the metaphysical paradigm

Thumbnail
iai.tv
0 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • Jan 22 '24

Video The idea that the women's rights movement solely advocated for freedom and equality overlooks the racist worldview embedded in its social vision. Early feminist discussions ultimately centred on white women's duty to uphold white supremacy at any cost. | Tommy Curry

Thumbnail
iai.tv
0 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • Mar 04 '12

Faces of r/philosophy (parody)

0 Upvotes

There is a massive wankfest going on over at /r/atheism, with people posting portrait pictures of themselves with elementary arguments against religion/christianity/theism/etc. I thought I would make tongue-in-cheek /r/philosophy parody versions of them ;)

http://i.imgur.com/QvxrS.png

http://i.imgur.com/ksZ21.png

http://i.imgur.com/45xSs.png

http://i.imgur.com/Oqn2k.png

http://i.imgur.com/FPbes.png

http://i.imgur.com/TkRIr.png

http://i.imgur.com/GHVDs.png


r/philosophy • • Jan 25 '17

AMA I am Samantha Brennan, philosopher at Western University. AMA anything about normative ethics and feminist ethics.

538 Upvotes

My time is now up - thanks everyone for the questions!


Samantha Brennan grew up on the east coast of Canada graduating from Charles P. Allen High School in Bedford, Nova Scotia in 1982. She studied at King’s College and Dalhousie University in Halifax, Nova Scotia moving from Journalism to Political Science and then to Philosophy. Brennan did her PhD at the University of Illinois at Chicago, working with Shelly Kagan who supervised her dissertation, “Thresholds for Rights.” In 1993 started work at Western University as an Assistant Professor. Brennan was Chair of the Department of Philosophy from 2002-2007 and 2008-2011. She is now Professor of Women’s Studies and Feminist Research and keeping up her tradition of wandering around academic disciplines has graduate supervisory status in Political Science, Women’s Studies, and Philosophy. Brennan is also a member of the Rotman Institute of Philosophy at Western and is a currently a Visiting Faculty Fellow at the University of Toronto Centre for Ethics.

Over the course of her career, Brennan has produced a body of scholarship that spans a wide range of areas in normative theory and applied ethics. Known for her contributions to normative ethics and to feminist philosophy, Brennan has produced scholarship in three main areas: moderate deontology and thresholds for rights; children’s rights and family justice; feminist ethics and inequality. In addition, Brennan’s work covers such as themes as gender identity, fashion, the moral significance of human mortality, and sports ethics.

Her work on a moderate account of rights, that is non-absolute rights, or rights that can be overridden when a great deal is at stake, began early in her career. Specifying under what conditions a right can be overridden is a project that has spanned many refereed journal articles and book chapters. Brennan’s work is frequently cited in debates between consequentialist and non-consequentialist approaches to ethic as evidence for the claim that a middle ground is possible.

When Brennan argued for a moderate account of rights one of the claims she made was that non-absolute rights are more flexible moral tools better able to do work in intimate settings such as the family. With her work on children’s rights, parent’s rights, and family justice, she set out to make good on that claim. It is this body of work for which Brennan is best known. Brennan’s paper, “The moral status of children: Children's rights, parents' rights, and family justice,” co-written with Robert Noggle has been cited more than 120 times. Her work on children’s rights and parental obligations resulted in two edited volumes and a series of highly influential papers. Brennan’s work was part of the resurgence of interest in the family by philosophers and this work helped set the stage for what is now a flourishing area of philosophical scholarship. Most recently Brennan is part of a group of philosophers writing on the intrinsic goods of childhood, urging philosophers and others writing about ethical obligations to children to take childhood more seriously.

Brennan’s recent research on micro-inequities sets out to develop the idea that small wrongs can be morally significant when they add up to large harms. Brennan develops this idea in the context of moral theory and applies to workplace and university settings to help understand barriers to inclusion and diversity. This scholarship connects her earlier work on moral aggregation and value theory to her practical commitment to improving the situation of women in Philosophy. Improving the situation for women, and others marginalized in the field, was a priority during her eight year term as Chair of the Department of Philosophy at Western University. Brennan was a founding member of the Women in Philosophy task force, an active member of the Canadian Philosophical Association’s Equity Committee, and a board member of the International Association of Women in Philosophy (IAPh). Brennan’s work equity and inclusion led to an invitation to be a member of the Implicit Bias & Philosophy International Research Project. She underwent training as part of the APA Site Visitor program and has participated in the climate assessment program. Brennan started the very successful Southwestern Ontario Feminist Philosophers Workshop. She is also a founder and co-editor of Feminist Philosophy Quarterly, a peer reviewed, online, open access journal.

Brennan has a strong international research profile owing in part to her visiting fellowships at The Australian National University and the University of Otago. Starting in January 2017, Brennan began a Visiting Faculty Fellowship at the University of Toronto’s Centre for Ethics. Brennan also has a long standing commitment to public engagement. She has been frequently interviewed on radio. Most recently her work on sports ethics led to her being interviewed in the New York Times. She’s been a participant in a CBC Ideas series with moral philosophers. In addition, Brennan maintains an extremely active presence on social media across a wide range of platforms. Brennan has been blogging since the very first days of blogs and though not an explicitly academic blog, her blog Fit is Feminist Issue, reaches thousands of readers and connects them with feminist ideas. It was recently profiled in Canadian Living’s January 2017 issue.

Brennan has also supervised more than a dozen PhD students in a wide range of areas. She has frequently co-written with many of her students and has ongoing research relationships with them.

Currently Vice-President of the Canadian Philosophical Association Brennan will become President in June 2017. She has also been an active member of the American Philosophical Association working on two committees, the Public Philosophy Committee and the Gay, Lesbian, Bisexual, and Trans* Philosophers Committee.

Some Links of Interest


My time is now up - thanks everyone for the questions!


r/philosophy • • Jan 13 '20

Blog Why the foundations of physics have not progressed for 40 years: Physicists face stagnation if they continue to treat the philosophy of science as a joke | Sabine Hossenfelder

Thumbnail
iai.tv
35 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • Sep 27 '24

Blog True faith transcends reason. | Dostoevsky's radical commitment to Christ over truth reveals how true belief defies logic and language, offering a deeper, mystical understanding of religion that Tolstoy's rational Christianity fails to capture.

Thumbnail
iai.tv
3 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • Aug 09 '23

Blog The use of nuclear weapons in WW2 was unethical because these weapons kill indiscriminately and so violate the principle of civilian immunity in war. Defences of Hiroshima and Nagasaki create an dangerous precedent of justifying atrocities in the name of peace.

Thumbnail
ethics.org.au
1.1k Upvotes

r/philosophy • • Feb 18 '25

Blog Reparations are not a matter of personal guilt. Just as our taxes repay the national debts incurred before we were born, reparations can redress debts incurred by past injustices. We are responsible as citizens, not as wrongdoers. — An article from The Pamphlet

Thumbnail
the-pamphlet.com
0 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • Jan 20 '25

Blog Alien languages could revolutionise our understanding of reality. | Whether developed by extraterrestrials, AI, or theoretical constructs, these languages could unveil new ways to perceive reality, exposing the limits of human language and metaphysics.

Thumbnail
iai.tv
0 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • Aug 28 '16

Blog Ten Under Appreciated Philosophers from the Islamic World

Thumbnail
blog.oup.com
513 Upvotes

r/philosophy • • Oct 07 '23

Article Toward an Account of Gender Identity

Thumbnail quod.lib.umich.edu
4 Upvotes