r/nepali • • Jan 16 '25

Did Newars Displace Rai Limbus from Kathmandu?

0 Upvotes

No, Newars did not displace Rai Limbus from Kathmandu. The claim that Rai and Limbu people were displaced by Newars from Kathmandu Valley is historically inaccurate and baseless. Here’s a detailed explanation that dispels this misconception while tracing the true origins and migration patterns of the Rai and Limbu people.

1. Rai and Limbu Origins: Migration from Yunnan, China

The Rai and Limbu communities did not originate in Kathmandu Valley. Instead, they trace their roots to Yunnan Province, China, where they were part of the Yi ethnic group.

  • Historical evidence points to the Hmong rebellion in China during the Ming Dynasty (14th-17th centuries) as the primary reason for the displacement of various tribes, including the ancestors of the Rais and Limbus.

  • As the Ming Dynasty crushed the rebellion, many Yi groups fled southward and westward into regions like Myanmar, Northeast India, and eastern Nepal.

  • These migrants settled in eastern Nepal, which later became known as "Limbuwan," after the Limbus. This settlement was far removed from the Kathmandu Valley.

2. No Historical Presence of Rais and Limbus in Kathmandu Valley

The Rai and Limbu communities have no historical or archaeological evidence linking them to the Kathmandu Valley. The claims of their connection to the valley or displacement by Newars are unfounded for several reasons:

  • The Kirata dynasty, which allegedly ruled Kathmandu Valley before the Licchavis, was not associated with the Rais and Limbus. The identity of the Kiratas aligns more closely with the Bhils, an indigenous community of the Indian subcontinent, rather than the Rai or Limbu people.

  • Rais and Limbus did not migrate to eastern Nepal from Kathmandu Valley; instead, they came directly from Yunnan. Their journey bypassed the central and western regions of Nepal altogether.

  • If Rais and Limbus had a prolonged presence in Kathmandu or interaction with its historical societies like the Licchavis, Soma dynasty, or Mahispal dynasty, they would exhibit significant South Asian admixture. Genetic studies, however, show that Rais and Limbus have almost no South Asian genetic influence, underscoring their distinct East Asian origins.

3. The Mundhum: Evidence of Yunnanese Roots

The Mundhum, the oral scripture of the Rai and Limbu people, provides further evidence of their Yunnanese origins:

  • The Mundhum lacks any resemblance to the religious texts or oral traditions of the Newars or other communities in Nepal. Instead, it shares striking similarities with the Meigi oral traditions of the Yi tribes in Yunnan.

  • This connection further invalidates any claims that Rais and Limbus were indigenous to Kathmandu or had historical ties to the Kirata dynasty.

4. Kirat Identity: The Bhils, Not Rais and Limbus

The Kirat identity mentioned in ancient Sanskrit texts, such as the Puranas and the Mahabharata, refers to indigenous forest-dwelling tribes of the Indian subcontinent. These tribes were closely integrated into Hindu society.

  • The Bhils, an indigenous community native to India and Nepal, fit the description of the Kirats far more accurately than the Rais and Limbus.

  • The Rais and Limbus, who have 0% South Asian admixture, could not have been the Kirats described in ancient texts, as the Kirats had significant interactions with Hindu rulers and merchants.

  • The association of Rais and Limbus with the Kirat identity is a modern political construct, popularized by figures like Iman Singh Chemjong, who sought to align the Rai and Limbu communities with the ancient Kirats for political and cultural legitimacy.

5. Mercenary Traditions: Yi Tribe vs. Kirats

The mercenary traditions of Rais and Limbus also highlight their Yunnanese origins:

  • During the Yuan Dynasty (Mongol rule in China), the Yi people of Yunnan served as mercenaries for the Mongols. This tradition of military service is mirrored in the history of Rais and Limbus, who later became prominent as mercenaries in the British Indian Army.

  • The Kirats, on the other hand, were jungle-dwelling tribes known for raiding and robbing merchants in ancient Nepal. Their traditions and lifestyle differ significantly from those of the Rais and Limbus.

6. The Role of Iman Singh Chemjong

The modern association of Rais and Limbus with the Kirat identity was heavily influenced by Iman Singh Chemjong, a Rai scholar and Christian missionary.

  • Chemjong’s writings sought to reinterpret the history of Rais and Limbus by aligning them with the Kirats mentioned in ancient Hindu texts.

  • In doing so, Chemjong made numerous historical errors, such as claiming that the Kambojas (a Punjabi ethnic group) were actually Khambu Rais. This claim is laughable and demonstrates a lack of understanding of South Asian history.

  • Chemjong also attempted to indigenize the Yunnanese religion of Bimoism into the so-called Kirat religion, reinventing the Mundhum as an ancient scripture of the Kirats.

7. Newars and Their Actual History in Kathmandu

The Newars are the indigenous people of Kathmandu Valley, with a rich history that predates the arrival of the Licchavis and other dynasties.

  • The Newars were never in conflict with the Rai and Limbu communities because the latter had no historical presence in Kathmandu Valley.

  • The Newars developed a unique culture, architecture, and economy in the valley, distinct from the eastern hill tribes like Rais and Limbus.

8. Genetic Evidence: No Connection to South Asians

Genetic studies further debunk the claims of Rais and Limbus having ties to the ancient Kirats or Kathmandu Valley:

  • Rais and Limbus show East Asian genetic markers with no significant South Asian admixture.

  • This genetic profile aligns with their migration from Yunnan and contrasts with the Kirats described in Sanskrit texts, who had significant interactions with South Asian communities.


r/nepali • • Jul 28 '25

छलफल/Discussion Daughter-Are You Enough?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/nepali • • Jan 30 '25

Mongolians and Aryans

1 Upvotes

How come when Rai, Magar, Gurung, Limbu people wear lengha, kurta, and saris which are from India/ aryan people of Nepal (the saris were brought over by bahun, xettri, kami all aryan/khas people) no one says anything or gets mad but when someone from an aryan/ khas group wears their clothes they get mad? Just wondering when did this double standard begin.


r/nepali • • Feb 14 '25

Ma tw bihan chado uthnai sakdina k garney hola 😥

2 Upvotes

Kati din dekhi kasam khaisakey xito uthera driving janwy bhnera .sakdai sakdina siddai 9 ma akha khulchha alram pani tha paundina k garney hola .

seriousissue


r/nepali • • Jan 30 '25

Aryan culture of Nepal

3 Upvotes

Hello, I was wondering if anyone from Nepal could share some things about Aryan culture in Nepal, like how we got there, what’s our cultural dress when we arrived, if we’re the same as khas or not. I’ve grown up in America my whole life. I came here when I was only 3, so learning about my culture and history is always something I’ve been interested in.

नमस्ते, म सोचिरहेको थिएँ कि नेपालबाट कसैले नेपालको आर्य संस्कृतिको बारेमा केही कुराहरू साझा गर्न सक्छ कि हामी त्यहाँ कसरी पुग्यौं, हामी आइपुग्दा हाम्रो सांस्कृतिक पहिरन कस्तो छ, हामी खस जस्तै छौं वा छैनौं। म मेरो सम्पूर्ण जीवन अमेरिकामा हुर्केको छु। म यहाँ आएको थिएँ जब म केवल ३ वर्षको थिएँ, त्यसैले मेरो संस्कृति र इतिहासको बारेमा सिक्नु सधैं मेरो रुचिको विषय हो।


r/nepali • • May 29 '25

सारै गार्हो !The weird '12 Barshe' education system of Nepal #nepali #nepal

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/nepali • • Apr 18 '25

Can someone translate this??

2 Upvotes

My girlfriend said this and I had no idea what it meant, would anyone be able to translate “buri najar wale tera mu kala” for me please ??


r/nepali • • Jul 18 '25

प्रश्न/Question “Dui chara” (Two Sparrows) rhyme

2 Upvotes

My guys and gals.. the child in me wants to song this children’s rhyme again...we used to sing it at the top of our lungs while at school. I only remember this line now: … चरा चार्नु हुँदैन है यता उता नहेरी, वुर्र गर्छु म फेरि वुर्र गर्नु त फेरि। … If you still remember it, can you please complete this rhyme?


r/nepali • • Oct 02 '23

What do these 100 Nepali words mean?

5 Upvotes

Dear Nepali speakers,
I am a German student documenting languages, such as Nepali. I cannot speak Nepali and have 100 Yes/No questions about the meaning of words, such as:

What words refer to authority? - प्रभुत्व - Yes/No

Could you answer them for me, please?
I've also considered using machine translation, but native and bilingual speakers often have a more nuanced understanding of the word's meaning.
I appreciate your expertise and help.
Kind regards,
JJ


r/nepali • • May 22 '25

Converting full videos into Anki decks with this website (details in comments)

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/nepali • • 1d ago

Some few Differences between Standard Nepali vs Darjeeling dialect

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/nepali • • Aug 22 '25

childcare translation

4 Upvotes

hi guys! i’m not sure if anyone can help but i thought i may aswell come on and ask, i work in childcare and we have a 2 year old girl who’s just joined the centre, she’s very nervous and only speaks nepali at home, i live in australia and we speak english so it’s a very scary place for her as she can’t understand what anyone is talking about, lately she keeps looking at my earrings and saying a word that sounds like “ittay” it may be “it- tai” or “intay” but it’s something similar to that, every single time she looks at my earrings she repeats that word, i have tried translating a variety of words including earring, shiny, pretty, jewellery and many more but nothing sounds anything like what she’s saying, if anyone can help me translate what she might be saying i’d appreciate it so much! thankyou!


r/nepali • • Nov 04 '24

दशैँ-तिहार कस्तो भयो त साथीहरू?

3 Upvotes

मेरो चाँहि समग्रमा राम्रै भयो। दशैँ अगाडि डरलाग्दो पानी परेर पनि होला, हिलो माटो धुलोले यसपाली दशैँमा सारा काठमाण्डौँ भरिएको जस्तो लागेको थियो। अनि आजकल काठमाण्डौँमा साह्रै धेरै गाडी भएको, यो वर्ष चाँहि धेरै नै, सानो ठुलो बाटो जता पनि जाम परिहाल्ने। काठमाण्डौँ पहिले दशैँमा जति सुनसान हुन्थ्यो यो पालि त्यस्तो सुनसान चाँहि लागेन।


r/nepali • • Jan 22 '25

URGENTLY

1 Upvotes

My friend wrote this to me in nepali (but in english) so i couldn't translate it. What does it mean?

Malai kina ho timi ali ali man parxa


r/nepali • • Jan 20 '25

नेपाली व्याकरण संस्कृतभन्दा के कति भिन्न छ?

5 Upvotes

प्रश्न झट्ट हेर्दा सजिलो लागे पनि उत्तर लेख्न, विश्लेषण गर्न र धारणा व्यक्त गर्न त्यति सजिलो लागेन।

नेपाली व्याकरण धेरै हदसम्म संस्कृतबाट प्रभावित भए तापनि यी दुई भाषाका व्याकरणमा केही महत्त्वपूर्ण र मौलिक भिन्नताहरू छन्। यसले नेपाली भाषालाई संस्कृतको छायाँबाट छुट्टै स्वरूप दिएको छ। यहाँ केही प्रमुख भिन्नताहरू उल्लेख गरिएका छन्:

१. शब्दरचना (Morphology)

संस्कृत:

संस्कृतमा विभक्ति र लिङ्गका आधारमा शब्दको रूप परिवर्तन (declension) अत्यन्त जटिल छ। प्रत्येक संज्ञा, विशेषण र सर्वनामका लागि ८ विभक्ति, ३ वचन र ३ लिङ्गका विभिन्न रूप हुन्छन्।

उदाहरण: रामः, रामं, रामेण, रामस्य, रामे इत्यादि।

नेपाली:

नेपालीमा विभक्तिहरू सरल छन् र सीमित रूपान्तरण हुन्छ। विभक्तिहरूमा सिधै शब्दका पछाडि आएर झुन्डिन्छन् (पोस्टपोजिसन) अथवा पछाडि थपिन्छन्।

उदाहरण: रामले, रामलाई, रामसँग।

२. क्रियारूप (Verb Conjugation)

संस्कृत:

संस्कृतमा क्रियाको रूप व्यक्त गर्न १० धातुरूप (verb classes), ३ काल (कालगत रूप), ३ वचन र ३ पुरुष हुन्छन्।

उदाहरण: पठति, पठतः, पठन्ति (पढ्छ, पढ्छन्)

नेपाली:

नेपालीमा क्रियाहरू धेरै सरल छन्। लिङ्ग, वचन र पुरुषअनुसार क्रियाको रूप केही हदसम्म परिवर्तन हुन्छ।

उदाहरण:

म जान्छु, ऊ जान्छ। हामी जान्छौँ।

३. लिङ्ग (Gender)

संस्कृत:

संस्कृतमा ३ लिङ्ग हुन्छन्: पुंलिङ्ग, स्त्रीलिङ्ग र नपुंसकलिङ्ग।

प्रत्येक शब्दको लिङ्गका आधारमा व्याकरणिक रूप परिवर्तन हुन्छ। संस्कृतमा शब्दको लिङ्ग हुन्छ।

उदाहरण: बालकः (पुंलिङ्ग), बालिका (स्त्रीलिङ्ग), फलम् (नपुंसकलिङ्ग)। देशः (पु.), राज्यम् (नपु.), नदी (स्त्रीलिङ्ग)।

नेपाली:

हुन त नेपाली भाषामा लिङ्गलाई ३ भागमा विभाजन गर्न सकिन्छ:- जस्तै: पुंलिङ्ग, स्त्रीलिङ्ग र नपुंसकलिङ्ग। तर संस्कृतमा जस्तो सामान्यतया नेपाली भाषामा शब्दको लिङ्ग हुँदैन। भाले जनाउने शब्दलाई पुंलिङ्ग, पोथी जनाउने शब्दलाई स्त्रीलिङ्ग र अन्यलाई नपुंसकलिङ्गमा राखेको पाइन्छ।

जस्तैः राम (पु.), सीता (स्त्री.) र पानी (नपु.)। जन्तुमा पनि पुंलिङ्ग र स्त्रीलिङ्ग जनाउने शब्द भए तापनि मानवेतरमा क्रियापदको प्रयोग गर्दा पुंलिङ्ग (निम्नादर) कै प्रयोग हुन्छ।

जस्तैः राम आयो। सीता आई। गाडी आयो। भैँसी आयो। राँगो आयो। आकाशबाट पानी पर्‍यो।

लिङ्गको प्रभाव क्रिया, विशेषणमा केही सीमित छ।

उदाहरण: राम ठुलो छ। सीता ठुली छे। पहाड ठुलो छ। हिमाल अग्लो छ।

४. वाक्यरचना (Sentence Structure)

संस्कृत:

संस्कृत वाक्यरचना अत्यधिक लचिलो छ। विभक्ति र प्रत्ययका कारण वाक्यको पदक्रम (word order) कुनै पनि हुन सक्छ।

उदाहरण:

रामः वनं गच्छति।

वनं गच्छति रामः।

गच्छति रामः वनं। (तीनै वाक्य सही मानिन्छन्।)

नेपाली:

नेपालीमा वाक्यको पदक्रम सामान्यतया SOV (Subject-Object-Verb) हुन्छ।

उदाहरण: राम वन जान्छ। (अन्य क्रम प्रायः अशुद्ध मानिन्छ।)

५. उच्चारण र ध्वनि-प्रणाली (Phonetics and Sound System)

संस्कृत:

संस्कृतमा हरेक स्वर र व्यञ्जनका लागि स्पष्ट ध्वनि नियम छ। वर्णहरूको परिपूर्ण र व्यवस्थित प्रणाली छ।

उदाहरण: दीर्घ र ह्रस्व स्वरको ठ्याक्कै भिन्नता (इ vs ई)।

नेपाली:

नेपालीमा स्वर र व्यञ्जन उच्चारणको नियम लचिलो छ। दीर्घ र ह्रस्व स्वरको भिन्नता प्रायः हराइसकेको छ।

६. समास (Compound Words)

संस्कृत:

संस्कृतमा समास अत्यन्त व्यापक छ। शब्दलाई छोट्याएर नयाँ शब्द बनाउने चलन छ।

उदाहरण:

चन्द्र + उदयः = चन्द्रोदयः। ग्राम + इन्द्रः = ग्रामेन्द्रः।

नेपाली:

नेपालीमा समास कम प्रचलित छ। समासको ठाउँमा सहायक शब्द (जस्तै: को, ले, मा) प्रयोग हुन्छ।

उदाहरण: चन्द्रको उदय, गाउँको नेता।

७. प्रत्यय र उपसर्ग (Suffixes and Prefixes)

संस्कृत:

प्रत्यय र उपसर्ग संस्कृतमा अत्यन्त जटिल र विशद् छन्।

उदाहरण: गमनम्, गमकः, गमनीयः (गमनबाट उत्पन्न शब्द)।

नेपाली:

नेपालीमा प्रत्यय र उपसर्ग साधारण छन्। तिनीहरू भाषाको चलनसँगै सरल भएका छन्।

उदाहरण: जानु, जाने, जान्छ।

८. अर्थग्रहण (Semantic Differences)

संस्कृत शब्दहरूको अर्थ अत्यन्त गहिरो, साङ्केतिक र व्यापक हुन्छ।

नेपाली शब्दहरू व्यावहारिक, सहज र प्रायः प्रत्यक्ष अर्थ दिने खालका हुन्छन्।

९. शब्दग्रहण

नेपाली: *नेपाली भाषा/व्याकरणले अन्य भाषाबाट आएका शब्दलाई सहजै ग्रहण गर्छ। *केही शब्दलाई जस्ताको तस्तै भित्र्याउँछ। जस्तैः कम्प्युटर, इन्जिनियर, बस, आल्मारी, रेडियो, टेलिभिजन, मोबाइल, ल्यापटप, खुसी, सहिद (शहीदको विषय अर्कै भयो), अदालत, एम्बुलेन्स आदि।

*केही शब्दलाई नेपालीमा रूप परिवर्तन गरेर आत्मसात् गरेको पाइन्छ। जस्तैः कप्तान (क्याप्टेनबाट), अस्पताल (ठ्याक्कै हस्पिटलबाट नआए पनि), जिल्ला (जिलाबाट), मुलुक (मुल्कबाट), ऐन (आइनबाट), नजिक (नजदीकबाट) आदि।

संस्कृत:

*संस्कृतले अन्य भाषाबाट कुनै पनि शब्दलाई सोझै ग्रहण गर्दैन। लिङ्गानुशासनले गर्दा पनि हुन सक्छ।

*संस्कृतले विदेशी वा अन्य भाषाबाट आएका शब्दलाई सकेसम्म आफ्नै शब्दले जनाउनुपर्छ भन्ने ठान्छ। जस्तैः सुसाङ्ख्यम् (कम्प्युटर), लघुगणकः (क्याल्कुलेटर), दूरभाषा (मोबाइल), दूरदर्शनम् (टेलिभिजन), आकाशवाणी (रेडियो) आदि।

*संस्कृतमा उल्था गर्न सम्भव नभएका शब्दलाई संस्कृतमा लेख्नै पर्ने भएमा ती शब्दका पछाडि कुनै संस्कृत शब्द जोडिन्छ नै।

जस्तैः बस - बसयानम्, रेल - रेलयानम्, कार - कारयानम्। ट्रम्प - ट्रम्पमहोदयः, अमेरिका - अमेरिकादेशः आदि।

सारमा नेपाली व्याकरण संस्कृतबाट जति प्रेरित भए तापनि यसले आफ्नै सरलता, लचिलोपन र व्यावहारिकता विकास गरेको छ। नेपाली भाषा संस्कृतको छायाँमा जन्मिएर आफ्नै स्वरूप र चिनारी बनाएको विशिष्ट भाषा हो।

जय नेपाली भाषा।

  • नेपाली भाषा सुदृढीकरण अभियानबाट साभार


r/nepali • • Feb 03 '25

Where do I find film production houses in Nepal??

1 Upvotes

I am 19 and I want to be actress and I’m really talented too but I can’t fond any opportunities in Nepal. How do I begin my career?


r/nepali • • Feb 12 '25

Please help with ideas for baby boy onesies

2 Upvotes

Hello all!

My friend is having a baby, and I want to make some custom onesies for her parents, who speak Nepali.

As an example, for another friend I made onesies that said “Grandma’s boy” and “Grandpa’s little dude”.

Could someone please help me with ideas? If there are any common phrases, text or images related to grandkids, babies, etc. I’d be happy to consider that as well.

Thank you!


r/nepali • • Sep 05 '24

प्रश्न/Question देवनागरीमा अलि ठूलो अनुच्छेद लेखेर पोस्ट गर्दा‌ "server error" अनि "can't create comment" भनेर देखाउने मेरोमा‌ मात्र हो कि अरुको मा पनि भएको छ यस्तो?

2 Upvotes

यदि अरुले‌ पनि भोग्नुभएको छ भने‌ किन होला भनिदिनु होला। सामाधान थाहा हुनेले त्यो पनि भनिदिनु होला।


r/nepali • • Nov 29 '24

र्‍ आकार

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/nepali • • Feb 03 '25

अनुवाद/Translation Sannani

3 Upvotes

What is the meaning of sannani(it's a Nepali word)


r/nepali • • Dec 01 '24

केर्फाछ मेर्फारो सार्फाथी हर्फारू?

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/nepali • • Feb 13 '25

Nepali influenced English

1 Upvotes

Hello community, I am a speech language pathologist who is assessing a 3 year old child to determine if she has a language impairment. She is a bilingual English/Nepali speaker but Nepali appears to be her stronger language. I need to understand Nepali grammar in order to know if some errors she’s making are actual errors or if they’re dialectical in nature. This child did not mark plurals (e.g., said “cat” for “cats” and “horse” for “horses”) and did not mark possessives (e.g., “the boy cat” instead of “the boy’s cat”). I would like to no if these omissions are common in bilingual English/Nepali speakers. How are these grammatical morphemes marked in Nepali? I’m struggling to find this information online and appreciate anyone’s help!


r/nepali • • Nov 25 '24

छलफल/Discussion What's your lang's literature about?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/nepali • • Dec 01 '24

Would anybody be interested in this Youtube to Anki converter designed to improve listening comprehension in Nepali? (details in comments)

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/nepali • • Sep 03 '24

णबाट सुरु हुने शब्द।

Post image
12 Upvotes