r/nbadiscussion • • Jan 02 '25

Hot take: Nerd media is part of the NBA’s discourse problem too

0 Upvotes

Full disclosure: I am a Cavs fan. I of course unreasonably expect everyone to sing their praises at all times.

But I find myself really frustrated with Ben Taylor of Thinking Basketball this season — and I think the reasons touch on the broader discourse about the league.

In brief, I think Ben demonstrates that the “ringz” culture problem isn’t isolated to only the First Take hot take artists. It influences how even the most thoughtful and analytical minds approach the game, despite their best efforts to avoid it.

The pod’s most recent episode opened with Ben and his cohost Cody discussing the Cavs at length and whether they should be considered title contenders.

Ben can’t get there — and here is my problem. His argument can be reduced to “the regular season doesn’t matter.” He’s skeptical about their playoff equity for the most generic of reasons, even if they are “fair”: weak schedule, hot shooting, etc. Even as he occasionally pays lip service to “I think they’re great”, his real take is clear: I am not impressed by or particularly interested in their hot regular-season start, even though we are now nearly halfway through the schedule.

Yes, it sucks to hear that as a Cavs fan from “one of the good ones.” But I think it also belies a comfortable fiction for people like me, people who post here. I think many of us would like to believe that if only the Ben Taylors of the world had ESPN shows, then the discourse would be so much better.

It would undoubtedly be more data driven. But we are kidding ourselves if we think the ringz toxicity has not tainted the smarter analysts. Here we have the Dean of NBA Nerds, somebody who contracts with the league itself, playing the role of debunker for a 29-4 small market team. I am a frequent listener to the show, and I dont think I’ve heard him go on an extended monologue about what they’re doing well all year. He can’t deny they are good, of course, but he is constantly undercutting their success so far this season. He says openly on the podcast he believes only two teams can win the title this year — and one of them is not the team with the best record in the league.

Again, maybe it’s just me. I’m prepared for that to be the consensus of the crowd, that I’m simply a sore homer. But in the context of the wider conversation on the league, I can not help but see a connection.


r/nbadiscussion • • Feb 16 '23

There is a suspicious level of disregard towards Giannis from the media.

44 Upvotes

I don’t think it’s a hot take to say Giannis is clearly the best player in the world. Nobody in the league provides what he provides on both ends night in and night out. So how is it that the best player in the world, who has a better record than all the other MVP candidates save for Tatum (who won’t win it), and has had his second best player, who was an all star, out or off the bench for basically the entire season, is not clearly the MVP?

Giannis is averaging 33/12/6/1/1 on 54% shooting, with some of if not the best individual defence in the league, leading his team to the 2nd best defensive rating this year (and despite being the true key to all of Milwaukee’s defensive prowess, his own teammate is getting the credit over him but that’s another story).

Jokic, who is somehow the favourite by 77% of voters for the MVP, is averaging 25/11/10/1/1 on 63% shooting (8 fewer points on 9% better shooting), but is one of the worst defensive centers in the league.

Jokic has a worse record, his stats are similar but I’m taking 8 more ppg any day, and there is an entire half of the game that he is SIGNIFICANTLY worse than Giannis at. To top it all off, Denver has had next to no injury issues this year.

Also consider that Jokic has won back to back MVPs already, winning 5 total playoff games. Giannis basically got the “you’re not allowed to win MVP because you failed in the playoffs” treatment after his second, despite winning 15 playoff games between his 2 MVPs.

Furthermore, Jokic won his second MVP almost entirely because of the injuries to his team. This is odd because for some reason, Jokic as a 6 seed could win the MVP because his teammates were all hurt, but Giannis who was tied for the 2 seed didn’t get any consideration despite this year’s DPOY runner up missing the whole season, forcing Giannis to change his entire defensive role.

I don’t mean this to shit on Jokic, he just happens to be a great point of reference to show the problem, and there’s a problem here. The poll just released from the MVP voters showed that 3 voters didn’t even have Giannis top 5. You read that right. Not top 5. He’s missed 3 more games so it can’t be that, as I’ve mentioned he’s got all time stats and the league’s 2nd best record, his second best player has missed most of the season having played only 17 games and 10 of those on minutes restrictions off the bench. For even a single voter not to have him top 5 is inexcusable, and 3 is honestly getting to the point that it’s almost suspicious.

It goes beyond this though. On the Lakers broadcast yesterday they showed a graphic of the top MVP candidates, and Giannis wasn’t on there. Embiid, Tatum, Luka, Jokic, they were all there, but not Giannis for some reason. He’s not even an honourable mention in the most recent DPOY ladder for crying out loud. What on earth is going on?

Every single issue here is relating to the media too. He was first in fan voting for the all star game, but 2nd to Tatum for the East front court according to the media. His 11 game winstreak has gotten next to no media coverage either despite him averaging 37 points per game during the streak.

You can’t chalk it up to market size, cause Denver isn’t much better and Jokic is doing just fine according to them, you can’t chalk it up to voter fatigue cause he hasn’t won MVP or DPOY since 2020 and the guy who’s won the last 2 MVPs is leading the race again, and you can’t say he hasn’t proven himself in the playoffs, as it’s pretty well agreed upon that the Bucks were at the very least finals bound if not for Middleton’s injury in game 2 of the 1st round as they took Boston to 7 without him and are not a deep team.

All that said, what exactly is going on? Why is it Giannis has to do so much more to receive so much less recognition. Again, I can’t stress this enough, several people who genuinely have a vote for MVP do not currently have him as a top 5 candidate. This is suspiciously bad.

I personally believe the NBA media is trying to avoid him as a face of the league, as there really just isn’t another reasonable explanation. There’s no way that, without ulterior motives, multiple “respected” analysts don’t believe he’s been one of the league’s 5 best players this year. What do you think?


r/nbadiscussion • • Jun 22 '24

Nick Wright Should Be Embarrassed

32 Upvotes

The original article Nick Wright used for reference of which I don't think there should be any inaccuracies: https://sports.yahoo.com/a-closer-look-at-michael-jordans-1988-dpoy-award-raises-questions-about-its-validity-has-lebron-james-been-chasing-a-ghost-140452567.html

I find Nick Wright's entire monologue disingenuous and embarrassing considering he didn't say anything accurate besides the fact he took away from the article (steals and blocks were inflated at home for MJ).

The Nets game he references for the "10 steal game" is here: https://www.basketball-reference.com/boxscores/198801290CHI.html. This game had 22 TOs for the Nets. He's complaining about a 4 minute highlight reel video which had more than just steals or Jordan highlights. If someone could actually watch the game and count his stats we can truly see if this was stat inflation but as it stands this is not a valid argument at all. I also think his phrasing made it seem like (at least to me) that the Nets in total had 9 TOs which is false.

There were no Hawks games I could find in the 1987-88 season where they had only 3 TOs (which is an insane claim if you think about it) during the whole game. You're welcome to look through that season of games if you want

https://www.basketball-reference.com/boxscores/198801190ATL.html

https://www.basketball-reference.com/boxscores/198802150CHI.html

https://www.basketball-reference.com/boxscores/198712290CHI.html

https://www.basketball-reference.com/boxscores/198711200CHI.html

Also something funky about the article - the article claims a huge disparity between MJ's stats at home vs away with regards to stocks but those percentages are going to look insane when the difference is 1 or 2 more stocks. I don't disagree that there was some stat miscounting going on here but this article is written in a very deliberate way.


r/nbadiscussion • • Apr 08 '24

Victor Wembanyama is going to get robbed of DPOY this year

0 Upvotes

I feel like it can't be denied anymore. Wemby is the most deserving player of the Defensive Player of the Year award.

Obviously he is not only leading the league in blocks, he is completely lapping the field, and I couldn't even imagine the number of times players wouldn't even attempt a shot with him lurking around. He's 2nd in the league in defensive rating, which is mind-blowing given how awful his team's overall defensive rating is. He's top 5 in the league in damn near every important defensive metric...

... but unfortunately, deserved or not, Rudy Gobert will likely win his 4th DPOY award this year. The Wolves are just too good defensively this year, nevermind the fact that their defensive rating is only a mere 1.7 pp100 poss better with him on the court vs on the bench.

Now you may ask yourself: what sets Victor's season this year from other recent block artists that didn't win DPOY, but instead finished 2nd? Guys like 2016 Hassan Whiteside and 2012 Serge Ibaka?

Well, Wemby this year has had to carry a defensive roster far worse than either of those guys did, and his impact far exceeds those guys as well. The 2016 Heat were actually worse defensively with Whiteside in the game vs on the bench, their defensive rating was better with Whiteside on the bench. Ibaka in 2012 only improved OKC's defense by 2.5 pp100. With Wemby on the court this year, San Antonio's defense improves by a whopping 7.0 pp100, and without him, San Antonio is statistically the worst defense in the league.

He's only a rookie, but Wemby is already a generational defensive player, already on par IMO with a peak Anthony Davis, and we still probably haven't seen the best of him on that end. Obviously if he doesn't win DPOY this year, he'll likely win it at least once in his career anyways, but I think he has the best case for it this year.


r/nbadiscussion • • Apr 27 '24

Wemby is ready to be a top 7 to top 15 player. He’s young and can play mad defense. Spurs have a lot of options to build around him. Who should they add?

0 Upvotes

Spurs have a lot of draft picks for trade capital and cap room. They could easily add veterans who want to chase the ring. Wemby is so good he’s ready to build a team around like they did with Wade and by adding Shaq. Wemby’s defense is pretty elite at this point that he helps fill that role.

Some ideas

  • trade for Kevin Durant. Phx is toast. They look horrible and will bounce from first round. They probably should break up the team

  • sign cp3 to help the bench

  • convince Bron to join, not resign with Lakers

  • just like phx, there are some players they won’t resign on the Clippers

  • draft Bronny to increase marketing and tv viewership. He won’t really add value. I just wanted to drop this in

Let’s be realistic. They aren’t going to be able to trade for Luka or Ant. Stick to what’s possible.


r/nbadiscussion • • Jun 09 '23

Is there real substance behind the notion that Boston’s crowd is especially racist?

1 Upvotes

I’m familiar with some player accounts and some of the racial strife in Boston more generally.

But is Boston’s crowd really more racist than in other cities?

I’ve sat in the lower bowl at many NBA games. As we all know, it’s crazy expensive. It’s a real wine and cheese crowd, for the most part.

In other words, the people sitting close enough to the court for the players to hear them are definitely not the demographic you would expect to scream anything at all, let alone racial insults.

I’m just having a hard time understanding how it’s possible that the lower bowl crowd in Boston, Massachusetts is somehow actively screaming racist obscenities with the regularity that has brought on this reputation.

What am I missing? Is this really as bad as it’s been reported?

Edit: Here’s what I’ve learned so far.

  • There are enough first person accounts to confirm that BOS crowds are relatively worse with racist behavior

  • I am dumb for suggesting that rich people are less likely to demonstrate racist behavior relative to other fans

As for WHY it’s relatively worse, some thoughts are:

  • BOS fans are more likely to be openly hostile, so a racist BOS fan is morel likely to be openly racist

  • BOS has a history of more open public racism than some other NBA cities


r/nbadiscussion • • Sep 15 '21

Does the Sixers-Nugget trade for summons make each team better?

0 Upvotes

JM + Picks or MPJ + Picks for BS seems like a great pickup for both franchises. Philly will get over the BS situation and have a great scorer in the playoffs. Almost there as an all star and some FR picks. And Nuggets get and all defense all nba player with great athleticism next to a fit MVP in Jokic, who can keep the ball at end of the games. And I believe BS will have no such issues again in the playoff where he can be just played off the floor.

Edit: Thanks for the responses. It seems obvious that I value BS's play a lot more than this sub does. Looking forward to the next season starting soon to see how the dominoes fall.


r/nbadiscussion • • Aug 24 '23

Player Discussion Do we recognize Isiah Thomas who shot 39 percent from the field in 22 games playoffs games against the bulls. Didn't play very well in those Bulls Series?

0 Upvotes

Isiah Thomas is 12-10 against Mj and he shoots 39 percent from the field in these 22 games.

His True Shooting percentage is 48 percent in these 22 games.

In the 4 years he played the bulls in the playoffs his field goal percentage was .44 percent in the regular season. So it went down by 5 percent

In fact Isiah Thomas only shot above 50 percent from the field one time when playing MJ. In the game he made 4 3’s and shot 61 percent from be field.

If you actually watched Isiah Thomas played you know he wasn’t a good shooter.

He shoots .290 from 3, and while I don't have access to his midrange stats if you actually watch him play you know he isn't a good midrange shooter either.

Isiah Thomas would take most of shots at the rim.

As he was most effective at transition similar to Russ.

Because like Russell Westbrook neither of them at good shooters in general so there half court offense can kind of stink at times.

Especially during the playoffs when the pace would slow down

What he was good at was getting to rim, but even then he only made most of his 2 pointers one season which was in 1986.

Isiah Thomas was the worst defender in the starting 5 of the Pistons. There seems to be an idea by people who didn't watch him play that Isiah Thomas was sort of good defender, based off pistons reputation

Thomas was not a good on on one defender like at all. Despite being one arguably one of the greatest defensive teams between 1988 to 1991.

He was best at playing off ball defense getting steals from behind/passing lanes.

When watching Isiah Thomas played imo would take stupid shots, and really benefited by having one of the best defensive teams of all time.

He had a dpoy coming off the bench and there was a reason why piston starting rotation all have a similar usage rate.

They were a well rounded team.

MJ was objectively a better offensive and defensive player in each of there series.

MJ shot 48 percent from the field across the 22 games.

He averaged 12 more points then Isiah Thomas did, only 2 less assist then Isiah thomas did.

He only shot less then 39 percent FG(Isiah Thomas career FG against the bulls in the playoffs) 4 times in the 22 playoff games against the piston.

This was against a Bulls team which had the top 3 defense each and every year based of defensive rating.

Probably a top 1 defense based off the eye test.

Isiah Thomas lives so rent free in MJ head because MJ is so much better than him.

His team was better especially defensively and as a result theyone.

Joe Dumars deserves more credit for being the primary defender for Michael Jordan.

Go watch those bulls series. Watch his bad shot selection and his inability to shoot the ball.

Isiah Thomas was a good player, on a equally balanced great team.


r/nbadiscussion • • Dec 13 '24

Player Discussion Wilt Chamberlain is an all-time playoff choker

0 Upvotes

Wilt Chamberlain is one of the worst playoff underperformers in NBA history and he should not be viewed as a top 10 player or top 4 center imo. I keep seeing people here overrate him so I'd explain why I have him at #15 on my list (and expect Jokic to pass him in the next few years once his longevity catches up).

Looking at his basic counting stats alone, Wilt’s career numbers drop from 30pts on 54% fg%, 51% FT%, and 55% TS% in the regular season to only 22.5pts, 52% fg%, 46.5% FT%, and 52% TS% in the playoffs. Wilt never reached his regular season ppg average in a single postseason of his career. A significant drop-off to be sure, but maybe not “the worst postseason player ever” until you also look at his performances in big games and series specifically throughout his career. For example:

• 1962 (Wilt’s 50ppg season) – 12pts in the first half of game 1 in a blowout loss. 22pts total in game 7 (the first of four game 7s against the Celtics in his career, all of which where he would be outscored by Sam Jones).

• 1964 (37ppg on 53% fg% in the regular season) – 30pts on 43% fg% and 6/13 from the FT line in game 5 to lose the finals.

• 1965 – game 7, Wilt shoots 6/13 from the FT line in a 1pt loss.

• 1966 (33.5ppg regular season on 54% fg%) – Game 2, Wilt scores 23pts on 43% in a blowout loss to go down 0-2 while having homecourt advantage. Game 4, Wilt scores 15pts to go down 3-1. Game 5, Wilt scores 46pts but shoots 8/25 from the FT line in an 8pt loss.

• 1968 (24pts on 59.5% shooting in the regular seasons) – Game 6, Sixers lose their 3-1 lead as Boston ties the series 3-3, Wilt scores 20pts on 29% from the field, 8/22 shooting from the FT line. Game 7, Wilt has 14pts on 44% fg%, shoots 6/15 from the FT line in a 4pt loss.

• 1969 (20.5pts on 58% fg%, 45% FT% in the regular season) – For the series Wilt averaged 12pts on 50% fg%, 36% from the FT line. In game 7, Wilt is often given a pass because he got injured near the end of the game and his idiot coach took him out and refused to put him back in. However, in the minutes he did play he shot 4/13 from the FT line and the Lakers ended up losing by 2pts.

• 1970 – Willis Reed, the New York Knicks starting center, tears a thigh muscle in game 5 and misses game 6, where Wilt drops 45pts on the Knicks backup center. In game 7 Willis takes a cortisone shot to be able to play through the pain and, while playing on one leg, holds Wilt to 4pts on 2/7 shooting in the 21 minutes he guarded him. Wilt also shot 1/11 from the FT line in this game.

• 1973 – NBA finals, Wilt has 5pts in both game 2 and 3, both 4pt losses, and shot 1/9 from the FT line in game 2.

Despite having arguably a top 5 peak and being an ATG defender, the massive underperformances in the postseason most years of his career hold him back significantly, and I do not think he should be considered on-par-with the other 4 centers in the top 15.


r/nbadiscussion • • May 17 '24

Main Reason why the Nugs Lost Last Night

2 Upvotes

As much as the Wolves played well and dominated this game, the main reason the Nugs lost comes down to statistically terrible shooting rather than excellent defense or any other factors.

Nugs shot 7-36 from three last night. Excluding garbage time they were 7-32, or 21.9%. In the regular season, the Nugs shot 37.4% from three and 34.1% in the postseason (including this game). It’s normal to see variance like this, but the reason why I say last night games comes down to poor shooting is because of their shot quality.

NBA Advanced Stats tracks on a shot by shot basis the distance of the closest defender to a shot. Here’s the breakdown for the Nugs 3PA’s last game (excluding garbage time):

  • 0-2 Ft. (Very Tight): 0-0

  • 2-4 Ft. (Tight): 0-4 (0%)

  • 4-6 Ft. (Open): 2-9 (22.2%)

  • 6+ Ft. (Wide Open): 4-19 (21.1%)

28/32 (87.5%) of their three point attempts were open shots. Of those shots, the Nugs went 6-28 (21.4%). This is a substantial drop off from Nugs averages. In the regular season, in the 4-6 Ft. range they shot 35.1% and 6+ Ft. they shot 39.5%.

On an individual basis nearly every player, had a poor performance:

4-6 Ft. “Open” (Game %, Reg Szn %)

  • Jamal: 1-2 (50%), (43.3%)

  • Jokic: 0-2 (0%), (32.3%)

  • KCP: 0-3 (0%), (32.4%)

  • MPJ: 1-1 (100%), (39.3%)

  • Holiday: 0-1 (0%), (35.7%)

6+ Ft. “Wide Open” (Game %, Reg Szn %)

  • Jamal: 1-5 (20%), (41.3%)

  • AG: 2-4 (50%), (32.1%)

  • MPJ: 0-3 (0%), (44.7%)

  • KCP: 1-2 (50%), (44%)

  • Jokic: 0-2 (0%), (40.6%)

  • Braun: 0-1 (0%), (39.5%)

  • Holiday: 0-2 (0%), (42.4%)

Even with average shooting the Nugs most likely lose this game, but it would be a lot closer. They just couldn’t gain any momentum with all these misses on open threes. Wolves played well across the board and looked disciplined, capitalized on turnovers and 2nd chance scenarios, and didn’t take their foot off the gas. Game 7 should be a good one.

On a side note, Jokic only had 2 assists last night. His expected assists were 15. Pretty insane margin.


r/nbadiscussion • • Jun 21 '23

Are LeBron's 8-straight conference champions as impressive as Russell's 8 straight titles?

134 Upvotes

I think most people would agree that they answer is a resounding 'no.'

However, my position is 'No. LeBron's run is more impressive."

And I know that I will be in the underwhelming minority.

But I would encourage everybody to really compare.

RUSSELL'S STREAK

At the time when Russell's streak began, there were only EIGHT teams in the ENTIRE league.

Almost each season, the playoffs BEGAN with the Eastern and Western conference finals.

That was the first round.

Russell only had to win TWO playoff series to win the first 7 championships in that streak.

In the 8th title, he had to win three playoff series.

In that season there were only 9 teams in the league.

LEBRON'S STREAK

Each conference championship that LeBron won (and he has 10 now), required that he win THREE seven-games series (Russell only won 3 seven-game series in the last of the 8 straight titles).

In addition, there were 15 teams in the conference, 6 more than were in the entire league in Russell';s time.

Added to that, there is greater depth in the league for many reasons, two of which are (1) players playing longer, and (2) international players filling out the rosters.

I think both are special and frankly hard to compare, but I forward this more as a polemic argument because so many people seem to be dismissive of LeBron's 8-straight finals because he lost in 5 of them, but a conference championship really means something.

What the Heat did this year and in the bubble is something special.

What the Suns did two years ago is something special.

But people seem to see this high level of success as an abject failure if teams don't take it all the way.

Thoughts?


r/nbadiscussion • • Oct 20 '24

Players Today Aren’t That Much Better Than Players Back Then

10 Upvotes

I don’t buy that players today are just substantially better than players from prior eras, to the point that a role player today would be a star back then and an all star today would be a GOAT candidate back then. Things like “Anthony Edwards would be the GOAT if he played in the 90’s” or “Kyrie would be called a wizard if he played in the 70’s” always sounded ridiculous to me.

I think most people who say this don’t get just how much the rules have changed the past 10 years especially. I’ll go through two areas of the game that I think have most significantly improved in the past decade or so, shooting and dribbling.

Dribbling

Dribbling was SO much more restrictive before basically 1996. Today, you can put your hand under the ball for a second while dribbling, allowing you to do some crazy crossovers and hezis. Every single player has started doing it, resulting in everyone from guards to centers having much better control over the ball.

Back then, you had to keep your hand either on top or on the side of the ball - that lets you do some basic crossovers, in-and-outs, power dribbles, etc., but most hezis were basically illegal for a really, really long time. It was super strict in the 70s and before, where you had to have your hand on top of the ball at all times with no pauses allowed while dribbling. So if you put Kyrie, or really, any player today in the league in the 70’s, he wouldn’t be a wizard - he would literally travel every single time he touches the ball.

Further more, the gather step was basically introduced in the late 2000s or so, and really exploded in the late 2010s. This means that a bunch of euro-steps, spins, step-backs, and fake shots were largely illegal. You had to gather the ball straight up then the count would start ASAP, meaning you had much less time and fewer moves to get off a good shot.

These rules effectively meant:

  • Big men had to be really, REALLY good at handling the ball if they wanted to have a game that wasn’t post-dependent. Because they aren’t as nimble as guards, and because their dribbling couldn’t be as creative, it was really risky to dribble around players who had a bit more freedom as defenders to bother your dribble.

  • Guards didn’t have as many moves to cross-up or create a shot against a bigger opponent. Without very effective step backs that benefit from the gather step rule, if you couldn’t get your shot off quickly or if you weren’t very good at pull-up shots, you were limited as a shot creator. You also couldn’t be as creative with your lay up gathers, so it was much easier for big men and your man to defend your lay ups.

Imagine someone as good as Curry or Kyrie without their step backs, behind the back gathers, spin moves, hezis, etc. they’d still be very good undeniably, but could you run an offense around them as well as you can now? Probably not. They’d have to be more like traditional guards more likely, focused more on setting up plays for their team.

Shooting

Shooting has definitely been the most significant improvement today that would most directly translate to results in any era, no matter what (except those without a three point arc in general of course). But shooting has also benefited from some rule changes, allowing teams to more reliably count on the three point shot.

First, dribbling changes have dramatically improved shot-creation. Again, stepbacks and looser gather rules means players are much more free to disguise a shot with fakes, and have much more mobility, which means better separation. This can be very subtle: for example, players today are allowed more steps when they first catch a ball before they have to start dribbling. Think of Klay or Duncan Robinson curling around a screen on a catch. They usually don’t take just two steps, they have one step to catch, and can take two more to align themselves better, even three sometimes if the ref feels that they don’t have complete possession of the ball the first few steps (if for example the catch is a bit low and the shooter has to twist his body to catch the ball properly.)

Before the mid 2000’s or maybe a bit earlier, the shooter HAD to firmly catch the ball and either place two feet down or take two steps only to get fully oriented. Before the 90s, if the ball fumbled a bit in your hands and you had to take a few more steps: travel. If you had to take an extra step around the screen to point yourself to the rim: travel. If the point guard threw the ball a bit too soon before you were fully over the screen and made you catch the ball before you had proper balance: travel. There was much less freedom of movement for shooters, meaning if they didn’t have proper alignment as soon as they caught the ball, the shot pocket was very small.

Another important change was screening. Nowadays, basically every screen is a moving screen in any other era. Players today can use their arms to block, and can move a lot more when screening. Think of Draymond body checking players chasing Steph, AD side stepping screens for Lebron, centers handing off the ball to a guard peeling behind them and immediately swinging their ass in the way of their guard’s defender, etc. It is a lot easier nowadays to create separation via screens.

Before, you had to plant your feet almost as soon as you start screening. If you moved at all, forget it, it’s illegal. Guards had to wait to make sure their big was properly planted before using their screen, slowing down the offense dramatically. And off ball screens had to be set very, very early, making it less of a blindside for players chasing shooters.

This effectively means…

  • The classic shooting role players nowadays would have much less space when using off ball screens because their bigs wouldn’t be able to screen so quickly. They also had to make sure to stop moving as soon as they caught the ball unless they wanted to risk a travel, meaning less separation.

  • Less dribbling moves means guards are much less able to create their own shots on the perimeter, where some seperation is very important for getting off a good three. Smaller guards would also really struggle in the mid range since taller defenders don’t have to worry about stepbacks as much.

Counterpoints and Bottom Line

Now, I will fully disclose some counterpoints to clarify my argument more:

  • I do think players are better today, and that they are MUCH more skilled. I don’t think the increase in skill directly correlates to how much better they are today though because technical skill is a lot more valuable today in the NBA; back then, other skills, like strength, size, and athleticism was more valuable for offensive players, whereas now technical skill allows much more variety in offensive guard skills.

  • Teams today are MUCH better than teams in any other era. If you put any three-peat MJ Bulls team against a mid-team in today’s league, the Bulls would lose. Not only are the rules completely different, but teams just know better tactics nowadays, like the value of the three, and teams back then were not built for this style of play. This isn’t because Jordan is a scrub and his teammates are plumbers, it’s just that teams are much better run now. If you put the mid team today in the 90s and made them play the Bulls, the modern team would lose; but they would do better than expected because, again, they have 30 more years of tactical knowledge.

  • Dribbling benefited a lot from rule changes to get to where it is today, but shooting would still be a universal skill in any era. Again, shooters wouldn’t be as good as they were today, but they’d still have a dramatic effect on NBA tactics in any era if a bunch of shooters were put in a Time Machine and sent back.

  • There are a lot of other rule changes which benefit offenses nowadays (for example, shooting fouls are more generously given), so modern players also benefit from that.

  • The 90s and early 2000s were a bit more physical than today, but not dramatically so; especially in the playoffs, physicality in the post is pretty similar across eras, it’s just some handchecking on the perimeter, less strict flagrants, and shoving during rebounds that was different. And also, there was no defensive three seconds rule. But differences in playing styles are more due to restrictions on offense in prior eras, not necessarily “better defense”: the illegal defense rules for example shows that older eras weren’t inherently more tough defensively.

My ultimate point is that players today, while better than those in the prior era, aren’t gods compared to the plumbers back then; rule changes have played a more significant role in changing the way the game is played rather than players getting infinitely better or more athletic. It is stupid to seriously think that players back then weren’t good at basketball, just as it is stupid to think that players today are soft and “wouldn’t survive” prior eras.


r/nbadiscussion • • Dec 17 '23

Megathread Thunder should have a top 3 candidate for every award this season

0 Upvotes

I’m going to preface this with a disclaimer, I’m a huge Thunder fan but you guys can tell me if I’m being too delusional.

MVP: atm there’s about 5 legitimate candidates for MVP in Jokic, Doncic, SGA and Giannis and obvious front runner Embiid.

ROY: this is the Thunder best bet but Chet and Wemby are head and shoulders above (literally) every other candidate. I think Wemby has pulled away recently but I feel like the lead in this race is gonna change several times through out the year and I personally think both players absolutely deserve to win.

DPOY: Chet has taken the Thunder for a 13th ranked defence to a top 5 one. Clearly making a massive impact and even tho he’s a rookie he should be getting some serious consideration for the award. I think Gobert should win the award but anything could happen with the rest of the season and if Chet can pull off another few 9 block games he will make top 3.

MIP: least likely award for us to win, JDub has gone from 12ppg to nearly 18ppg and he’s average has been increasing all season. Would not be surprised if he ends up with a 20ppg by the end of the season. Unfortunately second year players don’t win the award and it looks like Maxey has already won it

6MOY: Isaiah Joe. That is all

COY: Marky D is already betting favourite, I personally would pick Finch given the wolves unexpected rise to 1st but I think Mark will win if the wolves don’t finish 1st

CPOY: SGA is Him. Dame, Fox, Hali will all have good case for this award as well. This is the award most based on vibes over stats so I guess who ever wins will be the guy with the most media attention which will probably be Haliburton. (don’t have a problem with him winning an award, he’s elite and deserves some recognition)


r/nbadiscussion • • Oct 30 '23

Way too early Bucks pessimism

1 Upvotes

Are the Bucks actually better with Dame? I know the timing is a bit suspicious, being only 3 games into the season and after a heavy loss, but tbh I had this question nagging me the moment the trade happened, but my laziness kicked in and prevented me from posting.

In theory, Dame's trade was meant to bolster the Bucks' offense while giving back some on the defensive end. However, I think the front office seriously miscalculated how important Jrue was to the Bucks. Imo, he wasn't part of their defensive system, he was the entire defensive system.

Brook is a solid shot blocker and drop defender, but without Jrue navigating screens, he actually has to switch and guard smalls on the perimeter - something I doubt he can ever do. Giannis is a great help defender, secondary paint protector, nail defender and can do just about anything defensively when he's guarding off-ball. And yet, now that the Bucks guard duo is Beasley and Dame he can barely do any of that since he has to be high up on the screens to cover for the lack of perimeter defense.

Imo Jrue wasn't just the best guard defender in the league at Milwaukee, but also meant that there was no weak point for opponents to attack with that Bucks team, which is what 90% of playoff offense seems to be predicated on. I know he had his struggles offensively, but I feel like he more than made up for them on the defensive end, not to mention a huge part of Milwaukee's offensive struggles for me had more to do with Bud's lack of variability and Middleton's injury woes than the actual talent in the squad.

To add insult to injury, Bucks also lost Grayson Allen in that trade, who was at least an average defender and now have Beasley, who wouldn't start for 90% of NBA teams due to his limitations. And just to reiterate, the trade turned the Bucks biggest strength (paint protection and size in the front court) into a glaring weakness (having 2 bigs is a tough task in the modern NBA and I'm not talking about offense). And when you consider that the Bucks also let go off Jevon Carter for nothing, it means they lost every single good point of attack defender they had, and they were a team that dominated opposing sides by controlling precisely those possessions.

I honestly think this is going to be yet another example of a super-team failing due to lack of balance and poor roster construction on the fringes. However, unlike other super-teams, this one hurts because they ruined a functioning system for it. Am I overexaggerating this team's flaws, or are you equally worried(or happy if you're a Boston/Philly fan)?


r/nbadiscussion • • Apr 03 '25

Team Discussion [OC] Narrowing down the true title contenders based on just 3 data points

5 Upvotes

We are going to narrow down the teams that truly have a chance to win a title this year based on these 3 data points: Seed, Preseason Odds, All-NBA Defender. Let's break down the historical data first.

Preseason odds

Basketball reference has preseason odds data going back to 1985. Since then, here are the "worst" teams to win a title:

YearChampionPreseason Odds
2015Golden State Warriors2800
2011Dallas Mavericks2000
2019Toronto Raptors1850
2023Denver Nuggets1800
2004Detroit Pistons1500

Since 1985, 95% of NBA champions had better than +2000 odds to win the title in the preseason.

Looking at just preseason odds would narrow down potential champions to these teams: Boston Celtics, New York Knicks, Denver Nuggets, Minnesota Timberwolves, Oklahoma City Thunder, Dallas Mavericks, Milwaukee Bucks, Philadelphia 76ers.

Playoff Seed

When you look at every NBA/BAA champion dating back to 1947, here is the breakdown by seed:

1 seed- 52 (67%)

2 seed- 16 (21%)

3 seed- 8 (10%)

4/6 seed- 2 (3%)

So 97% of all NBA champions were a top 3 seed with the two exceptions being the '69 Celtics and '95 Rockets.

Looking at just the top 3 seeds would narrow down potential champions to these teams: Cleveland Cavaliers, Boston Celtics, New York Knicks, Los Angeles Lakers, Denver Nuggets, Los Angeles Clippers, Memphis Grizzlies, Golden State Warriors, Minnesota Timberwolves

possible top 3 seed (currently within 2 wins of the 3 seed)

All-NBA Defender

Last metric we are looking at is championship teams with All-NBA defenders. Since the NBA introduced All-Defense teams in 1969, here is every championship team that did NOT have an All-NBA defender:

YearChampionBest Defender
2023Denver NuggetsAaron Gordon
2016Cleveland CavaliersLeBron James
2006Miami HeatAlonzo Mourning*
1995Houston RocketsHakeem Olajuwon*
1981Boston CelticsRobert Parish
1978Washington BulletsElvin Hayes
1975Golden State WarriorsJamaal Wilkes

Mourning and Olajuwon were both top 10 in DPOY voting, but missed out on All-Defense due to playing in a stacked position.

If we fudge the numbers a bit to say they were All-Defense players, than 91% of all NBA champions had at least 1 All-Defense player.

This one is a little harder to predict at this point, but looking at just the players likely to make an All-Defense team would narrow down potential champions to these teams: Golden State Warriors, Cleveland Cavaliers, Oklahoma City Thunder, Atlanta Hawks, Memphis Grizzlies, Portland Trail Blazers, Houston Rockets, Boston Celtics, Minnesota Timberwolves, Miami Heat, Los Angeles Clippers, Milwaukee Bucks, New York Knicks

potentially have All-Defense player

Looking at just these 3 data points (better than +2000 preseason odds, top 3 seed, 1 All-Defense player), I think the potential champions can be broken down into 4 buckets:

Clear title favorite (meets all 3 criteria)

Oklahoma City Thunder

Very strong contenders (meets 2 out of 3, but possibly all 3)

Boston Celtics, New York Knicks

Finals contenders, but unlikely to win it all (just 2 out of 3)

Minnesota Timberwolves, Cleveland Cavaliers, Houston Rockets

Long shots (meets 1 out of 3, but possibly 2)

Denver Nuggets, Milwaukee Bucks, Golden State Warriors, Memphis Grizzlies, Los Angeles Clippers


r/nbadiscussion • • May 15 '24

Why the Inside the NBA are not making in-depth analysis like the Mind the Game podcast?

1 Upvotes

Don't get me wrong. Inside the NBA is great entertainment. I just feel like I enjoy their joking side more than their basketball analysis because they put more effort in those segments.

Ernie uses statistics most of the time. But for the other three, their basketball analysis is quite basic? It's always about the 'force', 'desire', 'aggressiveness', 'passion', 'momemtum' that wins/loses the game. Kenny will analyze a few clips during halftime, but I don't think it provides too much of an insight for the game, or basketball knowledge in general.

Yes it's difficult to give in-depth analysis live right after every game. But at least they can mention some of the adjustments or schemes that coaches made that changes the game? I just want to learn more from the perspective of former champions, Hofers, and MVPs.

You can argue that JJ has all the time he needs to prepare for his podcast, and him being a coach at the youth level also helps. Maybe the show also don't want to make it too difficult to understand for the general public?


r/nbadiscussion • • Aug 20 '23

What player won a title with the least amount of help in the playoffs. Side note: Who had the most help?

0 Upvotes

Looking at the last couple of decades it looks like LeBron had the least amount of help in 2013.

LeBron was 26/8/7 on 52/38% shooting. On paper it looks like he should have had a lot of help with Wade/Bosh/Allen but Wade only contributed 16, Bosh 12 and Allen 10. LeBron also lead the team in rebounds, assists, steals and defense. I’m not trying to discredit anyone on the Heat, both Wade/Bosh had injuries in the playoffs.

Everyone says Dirk didn’t have help in 2011, so let’s compare. Dirk was 28/8/3 on 49/46% shooting. JT added 18pts, Shawn Marion 12, Kidd and Barea with 9. Dirk didn’t lead the team in anything other than points.

As far as the most balanced, originally thought it would have been one of the Spurs teams, but take a look at the 2023 Nuggets.. Jokic obviously lead the show with 30/14/10 on 57/46%. Murray added 26, Michael Porter Jr added 13, Gordon added 13, Bruce Brown 12, and KCP 11.

So did anyone win a title with less help in the playoffs than LeBron/Heat in 2013? Does a team compare to the 2023 Nuggets?


r/nbadiscussion • • Mar 25 '25

If Shai is a foul merchant, then isn't every great scorer one too?

2 Upvotes

DWade, Kobe, Jordan, and other great scorers, all had their bag of tricks to draw fouls.

What makes Shai a foul merchant? Is it the amount of times he does it? If that's the case then how can we objectively measure that?

Is it just because of losing recency biasness? Y'know everytime when your team loses, it feels like the refs are helping the other side more and vice versa.

Even the definition of foul merchant is filmsy; you can't call something a foul merchant if you can't define what it is.

  1. If a player pumps fakes and another play bites, is that bad defense or foul baiting?

  2. If a player pushes off the defense and the refs fail to call it, is that bad reffing or foul baiting?

We run into two problems calling Shai a foul merchant.

First we can't define what it is. If we can't define what it is, then by definition we don't know what we are talking about.

Second every star player does what he does and every player is allowed to do what he is doing, so why is this a specific SGA problem and not a league problem?

I heard this is the best place to settle debates, so give me your best shot


r/nbadiscussion • • Feb 18 '24

The NBA has become wholesome and I love it

0 Upvotes

Watching the skills competition and other events so far is showing me that being tough and showing dudes up is just not in the DNA of the NBA anymore.

Most of these dudes love each other and are hardcore cheering for each other to do well. They’re out there having fun.

Halliburton, Maxey, Trae, Barnes, etc., are all just these super friendly guys.

Jimmy B is the face of the NBA playoffs these days and the coffee connoisseur cowboy State Farm commercial mother fucker is such a great face for the NBA. His Whoopi Goldberg dreads in media day last year and the My Chemical Romance emo look this year are absolute gold.

This is a wonderful era of the NBA and I’m here for it.


r/nbadiscussion • • Dec 08 '21

Why does Steve Nash seem to be chasing wins with how much he’s playing Kevin Durant and James Harden?

95 Upvotes

After Durant played 41 minutes tonight against the Mavericks I wanted to check just how much he’s playing per game. According to bbref, Durant is actually averaging the 6th most minutes played per game at 36.0 minutes, while James Harden holds the 10th spot with 35.7. What’s even crazier is that this actually marks as the 7th highest season in minutes played per game for Durant, with it being the highest since his penultimate season with the Thunder. When asked about how much he was playing his stars, Nash reasoned by saying that his choices were to either loss or play Durant high minutes. I guess I’m just wondering if in a league where stars typically sit on back to backs, why it seems that Durant and Harden are playing 3 full quarters of basketball each night? Shouldn’t he just take the losses instead of risk an injury to his 30+ year old players?

Edit: it does look like Kevin Durant is out tonight 12.8 https://twitter.com/thesteinline/status/1468651214082613262?s=21


r/nbadiscussion • • Jan 06 '24

Player Discussion Is Sengun what Jahlil Okafor would be if he reached his full potential ?

0 Upvotes

Both super advanced post up games coming into the NBA. With a soft touch around the rim. I think it’s easy to forget how highly touted he was at Duke.

And prior to the end of his Freshman season there was legitimate talk about him going pick 1. Obviously KAT ended up surpassing him but there were still believers in his game during his rookie year.

I do think Sengun is an upgrade on his game on the defensive end. But I certainly don’t think he’s ever going to be more than average on that side. They’re both a bit soft in that regard.

I think it’s obvious for Houston to take the next step, they need to pair a defensive anchor next to Sengun so they can reach their full potential. As amazing as Sengun is on Offense. I don’t think it’s enough for them to win a championship.

But this is just my opinion, what do you guys think? Would love hear your opinions and have a discussion.


r/nbadiscussion • • Feb 17 '23

Player Discussion Why Pistol Pete was (IMO) one of the most overrated players

10 Upvotes

Pistol Pete was a prolific shot chucker who averaged about 40 FGAs a game in college because his dad was the coach for LSU and let him stat pad as much as he wanted. Yes he scored 44 PPG without a 3 point line. It doesn’t matter, because this style of play does not lead to winning.

Low efficiency high volume scorers - Elgin Baylor, Pistol Pete, Tmac, Iverson, Westbrook etc have historically not done well when it came to winning because it goes against how the game is supposed to be played - as a team. Wilt actually learned this throughout his career when he was a very high volume scorer but didn’t win much until Alex Hannum became his coach and asked him to focus more on defense and rebounding - and that’s when he started winning.

Kobe and Rick Barry were the only exceptions to this. These were the only high volume low efficiency scorers to win championships as the main players on their teams. Both needed a lot to win. Kobe needed both Phil Jackson’s triangle offense as well as 3 rebounders surrounding him in order to offset his bad shots, and Rick Barry’s passing abilities was at its peak in 1975 and the league at its weakest the year he won the championship.

https://youtu.be/O25GH26xYEU

I always enjoy listening to this Dan Issel story (Issel and Pistol both came out in the 1970 draft): Issel said Kentucky Wildcats HoF coach Adolph Rupp told him when they faced LSU to let Pete score as much as he could. So they let him do that. Pete averaged 55 PPG. And Issel’s Wildcats won.

This just drives home the point that basketball is a team game. Pistol Pete, for all of his flashy passing skills and high scoring, was not a great team player, and that’s why he never won anything in college or the NBA. He played with (newly minted HoFer) Lou Hudson, HoFer Walt Bellamy, Gail Goodrich, Truck Robinson, etc and never made it past the first round. Like T-mac after him, the only time Pistol Pete got past the first round was when he jumped to ride the coattails of a dynastic team as a bench player (T-mac on the 2013 Spurs, Pistol on the 1980 Celtics). Pistol Pete never made any of his teams better.


r/nbadiscussion • • Feb 12 '23

Have the Lakers gone from the worst depth in the league to top 4-5?

0 Upvotes

For the majority of the season, the consensus was that the Lakers had the worst 3-15 in the league, and there’s certainly a case. Between several G league players riding the bench, or even occasionally getting meaningful minutes, and their entire roster shooting poorly for the first quarter of the season, it was hard to watch. Their 3rd best player would very often end up being sophomore Austin Reaves, who shows flashes of excellence but is still clearly not at that level yet, or Dennis Schroder, who’s on a minimum.

Now, they are legitimately 10-12 guys deep. LeBron and AD are, of course, incredible. Schroder and Reaves have upped their production significantly and are looking like they could be quality starters or high minute 6th men anywhere, and Lonnie’s able to get hot and bring momentum to a slow quarter.

D’Angelo Russell looks like the perfect compliment to LeBron and AD, Vanderbilt is a godsend of energy, defence, and great IQ on both ends, Beasley is getting quality shots and will begin knocking them down (though hasn’t been great on defence), and Troy is a nice low volume “gives you okay production and doesn’t get in the way”.

Rui’s a solid big body to throw at strong opponents, and can bail you out with his tough shot making abilities. Mo Bamba has yet to suit up, but since effort was the only major thing he’d been shown to lack and he’s now playing on a team trying to finish strong and save the season, giving more incentive to put in that missing effort.

Finally, Wenyen and Christie are probably the least playable players that can get meaningful minutes at points, and both have great stretches, as Christie is quite a low error, versatile player, and Wenyen is a rebound magnet for his size and can make great defensive plays.

Basically: 2 superstars, 3-4 quality starters, 4-5 quality role players, an unproven but very high upside potential starting center, and 2 bench players able to fill needs without too much lost in terms of production.

Consider too that 7-8 of these guys are above average shooters, 6 players who can legitimately play the 4 and/or 5, and several high pace energy guys to inject a spark that can put a team away or bring your team back.

Looking at the players they gained and lost before or at the deadline, the number of problems they fixed were unbelievable.

They lost Damian Jones and Juan Toscano-Anderson who were routine DNPs, Westbrook who was making actively hurting the team with bad decision making and spacing, Nunn who started picking things up but was not providing much consistently at all, Thomas Bryant who while great offensively was horrific defensively, and Beverly, who had been a low offensive volume guy but provided some of the best guard defence you could ask for.

Biggest losses are the offence at the center position from Bryant, a bit of shooting lost from Beverly, and the playmaking of Westbrook.

D’Angelo Russell is arguably a better playmaker than Russ, certainly a more consistent one, so that’s fixed. Mo Bamba has higher potential than Bryant on offence, but that’s still a gamble, however his defence will be night and day compared to Bryant. Beasley more than makes up for the occasional Beverly 3s, at a higher percentage and much higher volume.

So all the major losses covered, now the other problems they fix.

First and foremost, they are no longer tiny. They got rid of 3 short guards and replaced them with players around 6’4”-6’6”, as well as adding a quick and lengthy defensive wing, and a 7’1” center with insane length.

Second, they got rid of Westbrook, meaning the “will Westbrook stop to tie his shoe while the ball’s live or something stupid like that” factor is gone, and drivers have way less resistance now that Westbrook’s man in the paint is gone.

Finally, they added several guys who can create shots for themselves, meaning they can more easily punish teams trying to hide weak defenders. Rui and Russell are always safe options to bail out a dying possession, and even Vanderbilt can drive and finish well inside, and nab offensive boards at an elite rate and create a quality shot for him or a teammate quickly.

All together, I’d like to put in perspective this turnaround. Taking LeBron and AD off the team, you’ve got a few options to lead you, quality role players to make winning plays, versatile scorers and defenders, and excellent IQ all around, which is basically your typical play in or just below play in level team who stays competitive but doesn’t have a star to get them there yet.

Taking away LeBron and AD, Rob Pelinka basically just turned a team worse than the Rockets into the Wizards while giving up only a protected first and some seconds.


r/nbadiscussion • • Jun 15 '26

Team Discussion Interesting Finals.

1 Upvotes

So, everyone figured it would be an OKC finals at start of year and whoever broke out of east. I think most did anyway.

Well, surprise! You had a spurs team supposed to be maybe a play in team challenging OKC for west dominance all year going 3-1 in regular season meetings. Wemby was spectacular.

I think we can all admit we knew he was going to be this or something close, but not this soon. On top of that you had a rookie in Dylan Harper step up in the playoffs in a spectacular way.

And then on the other side you had an east ravaged by injuries and man did the Knicks elevate their game to blow through the east.

Then we get to the finals, can’t take anything away from what the Knicks did it was historic but man was Fox bad in end game situations and even wemby at times. I give wemby a bit of a pass on it because it’s his literal first playoffs and he was beyond spectacular against OKC. But this Knicks team was merciless at end games, coming back from double digits FOUR times meaning every game they won.. you saw the inexperience of spurs and experience of Mike Brown and Knicks.

Overall I think it was good for both teams, wemby got some valuable experience way ahead of schedule and the Knicks took advantage of a playoffs rife with injuries on eastern side to do something historic. The way they elevated their game to win the ways they did they were looking like the new warriors which is insane to say about this Knicks team.

Congrats to both. But especially those Knicks jeeez.