r/nbadiscussion • • Apr 01 '25 More of this please

Basketball Strategy Everytime I watch old basketball I feel like someone who's being deprogrammed after leaving a cult

3.3k Upvotes

So this whole post was inspired by the Thinking Basketball video on the NBA's YouTube channel regarding the defense of the '04 pistons, particularly during the finals against the Lakers...and I feel like I'm actually insane. Like somehow my YouTube got a different version of the video than everyone else's.

The more I watched the more I realize that Detroit had such a great defense because they were executing what are considered basic defensive actions today. Switching, pre-rotating, sagging off bad shooters, trapping PnRs, doubling and rotating, big men coming up to the level of the screen ECT. These actions happen hundreds of times in today's NBA, and modern players get lampooned when they don't execute them properly. Yet the world famous, historical Kobe-Shaq Lakers couldn't handle it.

First of all, there was no spacing. It was hilarious to watch the Pistons sag off the perimeter players so much that they were essentially executing a box-and-one for most possessions. Gary Payton passed on multiple open threes, and like lazily passed on them too. He just kept the ball moving seemingly without intent or urgency, which gave Detroit plenty of time to rotate. There were multiple examples of Lakers defenders, including Kobe (who was all-defense first team that year) getting beat badly off the dribble on the perimeter by Chauncey, Rip and even Tayshaun. Oh and there was barely any help behind them. Sometimes the defenders in the paint would take a step in and think about contesting the shot, but usually they just got open layups...in game three of the finals.

Shaq was an absolute joke defending the PnR. It almost looked like he already knew he couldn't defend in space so he didn't even bother trying. This is the Shaq that gets paid millions of dollars to talk about rangz™ and shit on modern players on TV? Correct me if I'm wrong but Chauncey isn't some once in a generation athlete, and all he needed was one screen to make Shaq look like me at the Y.

I think the Monty Williams Pistons had a more complex offensive system than the Lakers in the video I watched. Seriously, the would take ten seconds to execute one simple play and if that didn't work they gave the ball to Shaq or Kobe and stood around for the rest of the possession. The sheer lack of movement and intensity was astonishing. No wonder players got injured so much less back then, they spent half the game not moving.

There was one play where number 3 on the Lakers (Devin George? I don't care) passed to Karl in the post from the corner then immediately cuts to the rim. Karl passes him the ball back, and George went in for the layup. The problem was he drove directly into Rasheed Wallace who, having just been guarding Karl in the post, needed to literally take one step over to block the shot.

There was another play where Kobe gets the ball in the corner and gets around Tayshaun. The problem is the Lakers spacing is so bad that the other four pistons are literally each standing in one of the corners of the paint. There are three wide open Lakers, including first ballot hall of famers Gary Payton and creepy uncle Karl, just standing around twenty feet from the hoop. Chauncey doesn't have to move to help on the Kobe drive, Kobe tries to force a pass to Shaq (literally his only teammate that isn't open) and it practically hits Ben Wallace in the face and goes out of bounds.

Finally (I could sit here for hours and dissect the Lakers offense possession by possession, but I'm capping myself at three examples) there was a play where George gets doubled at half court as he's bringing the ball up. I should put doubled in sarcastic quotations because it was the slowest double I've ever seen. There are two Detroit defenders, each about seven feet away from George, and they're about to double him. George has a full three seconds to hold the ball and think before he dribbles directly into the double team. Pistons swarm, ball gets knocked out of bounds. A starter on the lauded 03-04 Lakers team was so discombobulated by the idea of a trap at half court that he takes a deep breath, checks the wind, then tries to dribble through it instead of pass to the two other Lakers who were with him in the backcourt. It's truly unbelievable.

What's really upsetting is the comments are absolutely orgasming to this footage. Literally people talking about how this Pistons defense is a work of art and how modern teams (who execute this type of defense practically every day) could never compare to this kind of basketball. Somebody literally said the 05 Pistons and the 05 Spurs that went to the finals the following year were the best defensive teams ever. He actually emphasized the ever. I couldn't believe we were watching the same footage. It's unfathomable.

But most upsetting was knowing I was watching the legends of the sport. "Mamba Mentality" "12 time all defense" Kobe getting beaten so badly on the perimeter that he's barely moved his feet before the guy is passed him. Shaq and Karl repeatedly just jogging back on defense, often allowing open shots in the process. Karl and Payton just standing around in offense on multiple occasions. Nobody, and I do mean nobody, rotating to help defend the rim even though the spacing was so bad they were already in the paint. The Lakers not actually starting their offense until 14 seconds left on the shot clock, and completely panicking when the first action doesn't work.

These are the legends that I keep hearing about? These are the guys that go on TV and shit on the modern game constantly? These are the heroes of the modern players in the league that I love now? These are the players that were winning awards every year? This is how they play in one of the biggest games of their time? It's embarrassing. Idk how anyone can watch that and try to tell me with a straight face that it's better basketball.

Has anyone seen the video I'm talking about? Am I crazy? Please tell me that I'm not alone, because if one more person tells me that Lakers team would beat the Steph-KD Warriors in a seven game series I'm going to set something on fire 💀

Edited for typos

Also here's the video in case anyone wants to see it

https://youtu.be/R61MHsTfrF4?si=lAJFPjmB7G1zsKZa

Edit 2: just to be clear, my main point of this post was to criticize the people who constantly shit on the modern game while telling me the old game was better. I understand how and why the game has evolved, and that comparing players from 20 years ago to modern players is a bit unfair. I just hear so much praise for old basketball that when I saw these legendary teams I was taken aback at their performance. I see now that I could have communicated that better.


r/nbadiscussion • • May 07 '25 This Take My Energy

The Lakers got exposed going small because they don’t have a Draymond Green

3.2k Upvotes

One thing that always stands out to me is how the Warriors can get away with small ball even against teams stacked with size like the Wolves. Gobert, Naz Reid, and now Julius Randle should be a nightmare for a small lineup to deal with but somehow it works for Golden State and that “somehow” is Draymond

It’s not just that he defends bigs. It’s how he anticipates plays, how he communicates, how he positions himself to shut things down before they even start. He’s basically the defensive quarterback and that kind of control lets the Warriors stay true to their identity instead of reacting to the other team

You can’t say the same for most teams. The Lakers tried going small against Minnesota and got picked apart. It’s not that small ball doesn’t work, it’s that they don’t have a Draymond. Nobody on that roster brings the same mix of defensive IQ, strength, and leadership. Without that kind of anchor the whole idea falls apart

Draymond covers up the size mismatch with timing, awareness, and just pure toughness. That gives the Warriors the freedom to stay fast and skilled without completely giving up the paint. People say “just switch everything” like it’s easy but it only works if you’ve got a guy who ties it all together

He’s not doing it for the box score. He’s the reason they can still play their brand of basketball against any team no matter the matchup.


r/nbadiscussion • • Jul 23 '21

A detailed look at the Top 50 players in the NBA

2.3k Upvotes

1. Giannis Antetokounmpo (Milwaukee Bucks)

Stats: 28.1/11/5.9 with 56.9/30.3/68.5 splits and 63.3%TS

Team Performance: 46-26, 3rd seed in the East, NBA Champions 4-2 over Phoenix

Wow. All I can say is wow. What Giannis Antetokounmpo did this year was nothing short of remarkable. Giannis had yet another great regular season, but what really makes this year special for him is the playoff run. After the Bucks suffered a disappointing 4-2 loss to the Heat in the bubble last year, they managed to rise above and crush their demons against Miami in a 4-0 first round win. Then up against the Brooklyn Nets, the heavy title favourites, Giannis outduelled the great Kevin Durant, averaging 32 points in the series including 40 in Game 7 to close it out. After suffering a gruesome looking injury in Game 4 of the Eastern Conference Finals vs the Atlanta Hawks, many feared that he would not see the floor again this year. But this was the furthest from the truth. Giannis missed the last 2 games of the Hawks series, but had one of the greatest finals performances in history against the Phoenix Suns. He averaged 35 points on 62% from the field, including 2 40-point games and a remarkable 50-performance in Game 6 to close out the series and clinch the NBA Championship.

After years of being labelled a playoff choker, Giannis flipped that narrative on his head. Now he has one of the greatest resumes for a 26-year-old ever. The sky is the limit for how great he can be.

He does everything. He is the most dominant paint scorer since Shaquille O’Neale and he’s one of the best defenders in the NBA. He just dictates every game he plays in.

This signifies the beginning of Giannis’ reign over the NBA. We’ll see how long his position at #1 lasts, but for now Giannis Antetokounmpo, the kid from Greece, is the best player in the world. One thing’s for certain, it will be a pleasure to watch the rest of his career play out.

2. LeBron James (Los Angeles Lakers)

Stats: 25/7.7/7.8 with 51.3/36.5/69.8 splits and 60.2%TS

Team Performance: 42-30, 7th seed in the West, 4-2 loss in the 1st round to Phoenix

Oh boy, this is an interesting one. I have considered LeBron James the best player in the NBA every single second since 2009, but I believe that reign has come to an end. With that being said, I don’t think it’s over for LeBron as the best player on the planet. I think he can come back healthy next year, prove me wrong and regain that top spot. Many will say he is not deserving of being ranked at 2nd, but after all he has done, he’s earnt the benefit of the doubt for me. If he doesn’t have a great year next year, then I will move him down.

LeBron was still the best player in the world up until his injury and was a top MVP candidate. But it all went downhill from there. He sprained his ankle on the 20th March against the Atlanta Hawks and did not return until April 30th against the Sacramento Kings. He played just 4 regular season games upon return from injury, however he clearly wasn’t his usual self, averaging just 21 points in this span. The Lakers found themselves in the play-in where they would face the Golden State Warriors. This was the first time that LeBron had looked like LeBron post-injury. He posted a triple-double including a deep-three to seal the win and a playoff berth. Heading into the playoffs as the 7th seed against the 2nd seeded Phoenix Suns, they were favoured. While LeBron still wasn’t playing his best, Anthony Davis’ back-to-back 34-point games got them out to a 2-1 series lead. But then Davis fell injured and LeBron was left to put a team on his back once again. Except this time he is 36-years old and playing on a bad ankle. He was not able to do it as the Suns handed LeBron the first 1st round loss of his career.

Many believe that the underwhelming season for LeBron is a sign that he is over the hill, but I don’t believe this. While I do think that Giannis has surpassed him, he is still comfortably one of the best players in the league and could very well come back and prove us wrong next year. It’s LeBron James, after all he has done, I feel like he has earnt the benefit of the doubt and still deserves to be considered a top player in the world. Consider this ranking a place holder for him. I’d rather rank him at #2 and be wrong, then rank him at #3 or #4 and be wrong.

3. Kevin Durant (Brooklyn Nets)

Stats: 26.9/7.1/5.6 with 53.7/45/88.2 splits and 66.6%TS

Team Performance: 48-24, 2nd in the East, 4-3 loss in the 2nd round to Milwaukee

No one could’ve predicted that Kevin Durant would be this good after suffering a devastating Achilles injury in Game 6 of the 2019 Finals and subsequently missing the entire 2019-20 season, but he proved the doubters wrong. While Durant did still struggle to stay on the court a bit, playing just 35 games, when he was on the court he was the Kevin Durant of old.

Injuries were the story of the year for the Brooklyn Nets. The trio of Durant, Kyrie Irving and James Harden played just 8 regular season games together before being thrown out onto the court together in the playoffs. Injuries came back to bite them once again in the post season as James Harden suffered a hamstring strain in the opening seconds of the 2nd round series against Milwaukee. Harden returned in Game 5 when Irving had to sit with an injury of his own, but his play was subpar at best. It was Kevin Durant who rose to the challenge, keeping their hopes alive. In Game, Durant posted an outstanding 49 points, 17 rebounds and 10 assists, the greatest game of his career and one of the best playoff performances in the history of the sport. The series went to seven games, but despite Durant’s best efforts with 48 points in the win-or-go-home game, the Nets fell to the Bucks.

Yes, he only played 35 regular season games. Yes, he was a 2nd round exit. But it’s clear as day that Kevin Durant is the same Kevin Durant he was before the injury.

4. Stephen Curry (Golden State Warriors)

Stats: 32/5.5/5.8 with 48.2/42.1/91.6 splits and 65.5%TS

Team Performance: 39-33, 9th in the West, Play-In loss to the Lakers and Grizzlies

Following a disappointing season where he only played 5 games, Stephen Curry bounced back in a huge way and boy, was it fun to watch. He averaged the highest points per game of his career, while playing on a team that fielded a less than adequate supporting cast. Curry was constantly double teamed and was the sole focus of opposing defenses all year long which makes his performance just that much more remarkable.

His presence is what gave the Warriors life. From the three 50+ point games, to his unprecedented gravity that drew the defenders in and allowed for open shots for his teammates to the “Heart of a Champion” leadership all year long, Steph truly did it all for the Warriors.

Unfortunately, his brilliance wasn’t enough. They finished the regular season as the 8th seed but couldn’t capitalise on the opportunity as they fell to the Lakers and then the Grizzlies in the play-in, missing out on the playoffs. Not one bit of blame can be attributed to Steph for that.

Stephen Curry is an All-Time great and it’s an absolute pleasure to watch him play. Hopefully his teammates can help him out a little next year.

5. James Harden (Brooklyn Nets)

Stats: 24.6/7.9/10.8 with 46.6/36.2/86.1 splits and 61.8%TS

Team Performance: 48-24, 2nd in the East, 4-3 loss in the 2nd round to Milwaukee

Some may say that after a disappointing playoff run and injury riddled season, that Harden should be lower. I don’t agree with that. Harden is what makes the Nets run. His playmaking and gravity is so useful to this Nets team and if they were healthy, I think we can all agree that they’d likely be the champions.

After monster scoring years in his last 2 years with Houston, Harden’s scoring numbers took a dip to just 24.6ppg this year. He took a backseat to Durant and Irving to focus solely on playmaking. While Harden is an elite level playmaker, I believe that he has to score more and be more aggressive next year, while still facilitating at a high level of course. There’s no reason why Harden can’t be a top player in the league again next year assuming he stays healthy.

6. Luka Doncic (Dallas Mavericks)

Stats: 27.7/8/8.6 with 47.9/35/73 splits and 58.7%TS

Team Performance: 42-30, 5th seed in the West, 4-3 loss in the 1st round to the Clippers

Ok, this may be a controversial one. Luka Doncic at 6th over Kawhi Leonard isn’t a popular opinion. I’ll be honest I’m sceptical about it as well, but I think Doncic just edges him out for now. Despite falling to the Clippers in the first round for the second straight year, Luka was simply remarkable. He averaged 35.7 points, 7.9 rebounds and 10.3 assists a night in the series but they fell just short in Game 7, a game where Luka fought hard with 46 points. Everything was going great for the Mavericks; they were up 2-0 and had a 15+ point lead in Game 3. But it all unravelled after the Clippers gathered themselves and made necessary adjustments. Luka has shown he can take his game to a whole new level in the playoffs twice now, but I think he needs to win a series next year or else the media is going to start letting him have it.

In terms of why I believe he is better than Kawhi Leonard, I think scoring wise they’re equal. Luka averages just under 28 on 58.7%TS while Kawhi averages just under 25 on 62.2%TS. Luka’s elite level playmaking is what sets them apart on the offensive end. I can count on one hand how many players distribute the ball better than Luka. Defensively, Kawhi is obviously better but with that being said, he’s not quite the same guy on that end that he used to be. Another significant reason is Kawhi’s health. He played just 9 games in 2018, was load managed every year since then up until this year where he played in back-to-backs, but that resulted in him tearing his ACL in the playoffs this year which will likely keep him out most if not all of the 2021-22 season.

Luka does it all on offense, he finishes inside better than almost every guard, he added the mid-range shot to his game this year and his three-point percentage reached a career high this year. Depending on his team’s success, Luka could be looking at an MVP campaign next year. At such a young age, he’s already one of the best players we have in this game.

7. Kawhi Leonard (Los Angeles Clippers)

Stats: 24.8/6.5/5.2 with 51.2/39.8/88.5 splits and 62.2%TS

*Team Performance: 47-25, 4th seed in the West, 4-2 loss in the WCF to Phoenix

We might not see Kawhi on an NBA court for quite some time, but he is still an incredible basketball player. Before the injury, he was having another great playoff run that saw him average 30 points a night on hyper efficient 57/39/88 splits. As I explained above, the reason I ‘only’ have Kawhi at 7th is because he just can’t stay on the court. It’s a corny saying, but I’m going to say it, “the best ability is availability.” Kawhi isn’t available to his team consistently enough and while his performances in the playoffs are spectacular, you need to be able to rely on him being available to play. Despite not being load managed this year, it was still filled with injuries as he missed 20 games.

Kawhi’s ability to take over games with his scoring by getting to his spots and controlling the tempo of the game remains fantastic. You can absolutely make a case Kawhi deserves to be a spot or two higher, but I am reluctantly ranking him here. I for one cannot wait to see him get back out there, hopefully sooner rather than later.

8. Nikola Jokic (Denver Nuggets)

Stats: 26.4/10.8/8.3 with 56.6/38.8/86.8 splits and 64.7%TS

Team Performance: 47-25, 3rd seed in the West, 4-0 loss in the 2nd round to Phoenix

This was a fantastic season for the MVP Nikola Jokic, one of the best and most unique for a center. His playmaking continued at the elite level it’s been at the last few years, but this year he took his scoring up from good to elite. 26 points on just under 65%TS while also being an elite playmaker? Jokic is comfortably one of the best offensive players in the game. Many thought the Nuggets’ success would suffer after Jamal Murray went down, but thanks to Jokic it did not as they went 16-8 without him. A few other names occasionally popped up in the discussion, but the MVP was Jokic’s to lose all year long.

Unfortunately, it didn’t go the Nuggets’ way in the postseason as they were swept in the 2nd round by the Phoenix Suns. This was to no fault of Jokic’s though, his 30 points, 12 rebounds and 5 assists a night fuelled Denver’s 6 game series win over Portland.

You may be wondering why I have the reigning MVP at the 8th spot. The answer is that the 5-8 spots were all extremely hard to determine and you can change the order however you see fit and it wouldn’t be wrong. It will be interesting to see how Jokic goes for an entire season without his co-star and how well he can carry this Nuggets team.

9. Joel Embiid (Philadelphia 76ers)

Stats: 28.5/10.6/2.8 with 51.3/37.7/85.9 splits and 63.6%TS

Team Performance: 49-23, 1st seed in the East, 4-3 loss in the 2nd round to Atlanta

Following a down year, Embiid responded by getting into the best shape of his life and ended up finishing second in MVP voting. He’s a bona fide superstar who is both a dominant scorer and lockdown defender. Despite playing with an MCL tear, Embiid still managed to dominate in the 2nd round series against the Atlanta Hawks with 30 points, 13 rebounds and 4 assists a night. However, the Sixers were shockingly upset in 7 games after a spectacular regular season. This sparked the question of whether or not “The Process” is a failure. There are definitely many question marks on the future of the 76ers franchise, but one thing that’s for sure is Embiid will continue to be a top tier player in the world. He dominates the paint with his huge frame while also regularly hitting the mid-range jumper and as of this year, can hit the three at a really good rate. Not to mention being one of the best rim protectors in the league. He’s the whole package.

10. Damian Lillard (Portland Trail Blazers)

Stats: 28.8/4.2/7.5 with 45.1/39.1/92.8 splits and 62.3%TS

Team Performance: 42-30, 6th seed in the West, 4-2 loss in the 2nd round to Denver

This is setting up to be a dramatic offseason for Lillard filled with questions regarding where he will be playing next year after the Blazers’ disappointing first round exit. Although we don’t know for certain what jersey Lillard will wear next year, we do know that he is still the electric player he’s always been.

It was another incredible year for Lillard, the highlight of which being a 55-point, 12-three pointer, performance in Game 5 of the first round series against the Nuggets. A game they lost. A depressing summary of the year for the Blazers. Dame’s ability to shoot the deep three is becoming more prevalent each year as he continues to light up opposing defense’s for high scoring games. He had six games with 40 or more points this regular season.

The Blazers have a lot of work to do to keep their star happy, that’s for sure.

11. Anthony Davis (Los Angeles Lakers)

Stats: 21.8/7.9/3.1 with 49.1/26/73.8 splits and 55.6%TS

Team Performance: 42-30, 7th seed in the West, 4-2 loss in the 1st round to Phoenix

There is no question that this was a huge down year for Anthony Davis. After winning the title, the Lakers came into the season with the shortest offseason in NBA history. This led to an injury riddled year for Davis as he only played 36 regular season games and was injured for their single playoff series. But when healthy, Davis is still one of the dominant forces of the NBA as we saw when he had back-to-back 34-point performances in the Suns series. His ability as a roll man, to catch the lobs and to hit his mid-range jumper makes him the best second option in the league. He continues to be one of the elite defenders in the league.

Davis has always been rather injury prone, but this year was worse than normal. Next year he needs to be able to stay on the floor and consistently dominate the way that we know he can.

12. Kyrie Irving (Brooklyn Nets)

Stats: 26.9/4.8/6 with 50.6/40.2/92.2 splits and 61.4%TS

Team Performance: 48-24, 2nd in the East, 4-3 loss in the 2nd round to Milwaukee

It was a career year for Kyrie Irving who averaged just shy of 27 points as he joined the elusive 50/40/90 club. Yet he was still only the 3rd best player on his team, isn’t that crazy? Health has always been an issue for Kyrie and this continued to an extent this year as he missed the last three games of the Nets’ 2nd round series against the Bucks. But when he was on the court he was an unstoppable scoring force who greatly benefited from the attention that Durant and Harden drew. Quite possibly the most entertaining player in the league, Kyrie’s smooth handles and creativity allow him to carve up opposing defenses. All we can do is hope he remains healthy next year, because the league is better when he’s playing.

13. Jayson Tatum (Boston Celtics)

Stats: 26.4/7.4/4.3 with 45.9/38.6/86.8 splits and 57.6%TS

Team Performance: 36-36, 7th in the East, 4-1 loss in the 1st round to Brooklyn

Tatum is a perfect scorer. There is not a single place he struggles to score the ball from. He can hit the three at a high clip, hit the mid-range jumper and get to the rack for easy finishes. His ability to create his own shot is up there with the best.

However, it was a disappointing year for the Celtics. Despite having two stars in Tatum and Jaylen Brown, they were only able to get the 7th seed and a first round exit. But the 23-year-old continues to step up in big moments. He had 50 points in the play-in against Washington and 50 points in Game 3 against the Nets in the first round.

Tatum has all the tools to be at the very top of this list in a few years. He needs to focus on developing his playmaking and improve upon his efficiency. An extremely bright future ahead for Tatum.

14. Paul George (Los Angeles Clippers)

Stats: 23.3/6.6/5.2 with 46.7/41.1/86.8 splits and 59.8%TS

Team Performance: 47-25, 4th seed in the West, 4-2 loss in the WCF to Phoenix

After a year which drew significant criticism for Paul George, he returned and played like the Paul George we’re used to. During the regular season he was able to consistently perform to keep the Clippers going when Kawhi was in and out of the line-up with injury. But what really made this a successful year for George was the playoffs.

George has been heavily criticised and mocked for his shortcomings in the postseason in recent years, but it was a little bit different this year. After Kawhi Leonard went down in Game 4, many doubted the Clippers’ ability to pull out the series against the Jazz. But George did the unexpected and put together 2 straight wins on the back of his 37-point performance in Game 5 and 28 points in Game 6. The Clippers had made it to their first ever Western Conference Finals. While George played well in the series – 28.7ppg, 10.5rpg, 5.5apg – the Suns were just too much as they fell in six games. But George had already earnt the respect of the NBA world for what he was able to accomplish in the absence of Leonard.

Now Kawhi is set to miss most, if not all, of the 2021-22 season. George will be left to run the team solo, it will be interesting to see what he can do on his own for an entire season.

15. Trae Young (Atlanta Hawks)

Stats: 25.3/3.9/9.4 with 43.8/34.3/88.6 splits and 58.9%TS

Team Performance: 41-31, 5th seed in the East, 4-2 loss in the ECF to Milwaukee

Trae Young and the Atlanta Hawks were the story of the playoffs this year. As a 5th seed, no one expected them to get out of the first round against the Knicks, let alone upset the 1st seed in the 2nd round and take the eventual champions to six in the Eastern Conference Finals. Young was weirdly omitted from the All-Star team, but he didn’t let that bring him down. Trae took on the classic villain role and played it to perfection in the playoffs. After receiving “Fuck Trae Young” and “Trae is balding” chants in Madison Square Garden throughout the first round, Young hit a deep three and took a bow as he eliminated the Knicks in 5 games. In the 2nd round, they went up against the first seeded Philadelphia 76ers. Once again no one believed they could win this series, but Trae’s fantastic 29ppg and 11apg performance got the Hawks the win in 7 games. He was great in the Conference Finals, with a 48-point night in Game 1, but they were just too much, and the Hawks magical run had come to an end. But what the Hawks did this year was special and they have so much to look forward to in the coming years.

Trae is just an electric player. He can hit the deep three, he can use the Pick and Roll better than anyone to get to his patented floater and he can pass the ball like not many can.

16. Bradley Beal (Washington Wizards)

Stats: 31.3/4.7/4.4 with 48.5/34.9/88.9 splits and 59.3%TS

Team Performance: 34-38, 8th seed in the East, 4-1 loss in the 1st round to Philadelphia

Beal gets buckets. That’s his job and he does it well. Coming in 2nd to the great Stephen Curry in the scoring title race is nothing to be ashamed of. Beal still posted an efficient 31ppg season on a decent team. The Wizards had an extremely rocky start to their year but rallied back in the 2nd half of the season and snuck into the playoffs where they fell to the Sixers.

Beal is a 3-level scorer who can create his own shot but also move off the ball and work off his teammates. He has no weakness when it comes to scoring the ball. Volume scorers are typically inefficient, but not Beal. He is prone to huge outbursts of points - he had 8 games of 40 or more points in the regular season – and he is consistent as well.

17. Devin Booker (Phoenix Suns)

Stats: 25.6/4.2/4.3 with 48.4/34/86.7 splits and 58.7%TS

Team Performance: 51-21, 2nd seed in the West, 4-2 loss in the Finals to Milwaukee

In his 6th year in the league, Booker finally made it to the playoffs. But not only did he make the playoffs, they were the 2nd seed and made it to the NBA Finals. Booker performed well throughout the postseason averaging 27 points. Though it wasn’t his night in Game 6 of the finals where he did underperform, with 19 points on 8/22 shooting.

Some may question why Booker deserves to be above Mitchell. Booker is a more versatile scorer, he can score from anywhere and has the biggest arsenal in the league. His shot creating is incredible and he is great at getting to his spots, as well as moving off-ball. He is also a really good playmaker despite his low assist numbers this year which can be attributed to Chris Paul’s presence. In the two years prior to this, Booker averaged 6.8 and 6.5 assists. We know he is good at passing the ball. While I do think Booker edges out Mitchell, it is absolutely a close call that is up to personal preference.

The Suns look to build on their newfound success next year. After suffering a devastating loss in the Finals, you can count on them to be hungry to get back to the sport’s biggest stage. Their 24-year-old star will be a key factor in that.

18. Donovan Mitchell (Utah Jazz)

Stats: 26.4/4.4/5.2 with 43.8/38.6/84.5 splits and 56.9%TS

Team Performance: 52-20, 1st seed in the West, 4-2 loss in the 2nd round to the Clippers

Donovan Mitchell was the key to the Utah Jazz’s unexpected success. Not many could’ve foreseen them achieving the best record in the league. The 4th-year star continues to improve every year.

The Jazz didn’t get quite as far as they would’ve liked in the playoffs, but Mitchell replicated his incredible performances from the bubble. He averaged 33 points across the playoff run including a 45-point performance. His ability to take it up a level in the playoffs is something most young guys don’t have. From eliminating three stars in his rookie year, to having two 50 bombs against the Nuggets last year in the bubble, to this year, it’s safe to say Donovan Mitchell is a playoff performer.

However, I would like to see Mitchell improve upon his efficiency in the regular season. 56.9%TS sits below the league average. His game has reached a new level every year he’s been in the NBA, so I definitely think he can do it.

19. Chris Paul (Phoenix Suns)

Stats: 16.4/4.5/8.9 with 49.9/39.5/93.4 splits and 59.9%TS

Team Performance: 51-21, 2nd seed in the West, 4-2 loss in the Finals to Milwaukee

Arriving in Phoenix after rejuvenating his career in Oklahoma City last season, not many expected the Phoenix Suns to do this well. They were the 2nd best team in the league record wise and made it to the Finals. Paul even received some MVP chatter here and there.

The playoffs were up and down for Paul. He was a non-factor in the first round due to a shoulder injury that kept him under 10 points a game, but they were able to advance in light of this. The Nuggets series in the 2nd round is where Paul dominated, playing some of the best basketball of his career. He averaged 25.5 points, 10.3 assists and shot 62.7% from the field in the sweep. He missed the first two games of the Western Conference Finals series against the Clippers because he tested positive for COVID-19. His first three games back were subpar, but his 41-point performance in Game 6 to clinch a finals berth is pretty easily the best game of his career. He averaged just under 22 points on 55% from the field in the Finals, but after taking a 2-0 lead and then proceeding to lose 4 straight games, Paul has understandably received criticism for not doing more. This was most likely CP3’s last chance at winning an NBA championship and he came up short.

But he is still a dynamic floor raiser who significantly improves every team he goes to.

20. Zion Williamson (New Orleans Pelicans)

Stats: 27/7.2/3.7 with 61.1/29.4/69.8 splits and 64.9%TS

Team Performance: 31-41, 11th seed in the West

Zion had an injury riddled rookie season, but he still performed well and showed flashes to justify being one of the more hyped prospects ever. This year he took off. He averaged 27 points on absolutely insane efficiency. He is one of the most dominant inside forces since Shaquille O’Neale. Last year, he was primarily doing his work in the post. But this year he transformed into more of a perimeter player which let him use his elite explosiveness and first step to get to the rim and finish with his soft touch.

Williamson was an All-Star averaging 27 a night in his 2nd year at the young age of 20. His ceiling is as high as anyone’s in the league. He is among the next generation of NBA superstars.

21. Zach LaVine (Chicago Bulls)

Stats: 27.4/5/4.9 with 50.7/41.9/84.9 splits and 63.4%TS

Team Performance: 31-41, 11th seed in the East

LaVine quietly produced an impressive scoring season. 27 points on 63.4%TS is no joke whatsoever, but it flies under the radar due to the Bulls’ lack of success.

LaVine is a smooth shot creator who is one of the best three-point shooters in the NBA while also being one of the most athletic players in the game. All this put together makes him a pleasure to watch.

Halfway through the season, the Bulls traded for fellow All-Star Nikola Vucevic but the Bulls weren’t able to pull themselves into the Play-In. Maybe after a whole offseason together, they can aim for a playoff berth next year.

22. Jimmy Butler (Miami Heat)

Stats: 21.5/6.9/7.1 with 49.7/24.5/86.3 splits and 60.7%TS

Team Performance: 40-32, 6th seed in the East, 4-0 loss in the 1st round to Milwaukee

After a historic run to the NBA Finals in the bubble last year, this season didn’t quite live up to the expectations. The Heat finished as the 6th seed in the East and had a rocky regular season. It’s the playoffs that went worse than anyone could have imagined. In the 4-0 loss to the eventual champions, Butler averaged just 14.5 points on under 30% from the field. By far the worst series of his career.

Now don’t get me wrong, Jimmy is still great. But he will be 32 next year and doesn’t have a feasible jump shot, this raises questions regarding how much longer he can play at this level. I could foresee a slight decline in Butler’s play next year. But I’d be happy to be proven wrong.

23. Karl Anthony-Towns (Minnesota Timberwolves)

Stats: 24.8/10.6/4.5 with 48.6/38.7/85.9 splits and 61.2%TS

Team Performance: 23-49, 13th seed in the West

I think it’s fair to say that Karl Anthony-Towns hasn’t quite lived up to the lofty expectations set for him a few years ago. He has been struggling to stay on the court in the last two years playing just 35 games in 2019-20 and 50 this season. Not to mention the off the court troubles that may be distracting him on the court, from losing his mother to COVID-19 to contracting COVID-19 himself at one point.

The Timberwolves have consistently been one of the worst teams in the league. But I do believe that if he can stay healthy next year, he’ll start to rise up in the rankings quickly.

24. Jaylen Brown (Boston Celtics)

Stats: 24.7/6/3.4 with 48.4/39.7/76.4 splits and 58.6%TS

36-36, 7th in the East, 4-1 loss in the 1st round to Brooklyn

Jaylen Brown took a giant leap this year from a solid player to a full-fledged star. He made his first All-Star appearance and averaged just shy of 25 points a night. He’s a 3-level scoring machine at the wing who plays great defense, pretty much the ideal modern NBA player and everything you could ask for in a 2nd option to Jayson Tatum. It’s the Celtics’ lack of depth that let the Celtics down this year.

He’s still only 24-year-old so making further strides in his game is absolutely not out of the question.

25. Julius Randle (New York Knicks)

Stats: 24.1/10.2/6 with 45.6/41.1/81.1 splits and 56.7%TS

Team Performance: 41-31, 4th seed in the East, 4-1 loss in the 1st round to Atlanta

Julius Randle brought much needed life to Madison Square Garden this season. He had a career year, being selected to his first All-Star team and winning the Most Improved Award. After hearing “empty stats” criticism throughout his career, Randle finally started winning. He led a New York Knicks team that no one thought would contend for the playoffs, to the 4th seed in the Eastern Conference. Unfortunately he did underperform in their 4-1 series loss to Atlanta, but it is a year to remember for Knicks fans.

He’s brough hope to the city after years of underwhelming team performances. For the first time in a while the future looks bright in New York.

26. Rudy Gobert (Utah Jazz)

Stats: 14.3/13.5/1.5 with 67.5/0/62.3 splits and 68.3%TS

Team Performance: 52-20, 1st seed in the West, 4-2 loss in the 2nd round to the Clippers

Rudy Gobert won his 3rd Defensive Player of the Year award and was arguably the most impactful regular season player for the team with the best record in the league. His rim protection was the cornerstone of their success and screen setting and ability to catch the lob as a roll man were huge to have on offense. Unfortunately, their playoff run didn’t go the way that they hoped.

The Jazz were heavily criticised for giving Gobert a 5-year/$205million contract last summer. Is he worth that much? Maybe not. But one thing that’s for certain is that the Jazz wouldn’t be where they are without Gobert.

27. Khris Middleton (Milwaukee Bucks)

Stats: 20.4/6/5.4 with 47.6/41.4/89.8 splits and 58.8%TS

Team Performance: 46-26, 3rd seed in the East, NBA Champions 4-2 over Phoenix

Khris Middleton is officially a 2nd option on a championship team. Middleton missed out on the All-Star selection, but he shined in the playoffs. His up and down performances was one of the main storylines of the post season. It seemed like he was “Prime MJ” one night and terrible the next. But he stepped up in big moments, including a game-winner in the opening game of the Heat series, a 35-point game to stave off going down 3-0 to Brooklyn, 38 points to force a Game 7 against Brooklyn, 32 points to close out Atlanta and 40 points to tie the series against Phoenix. He’s the perfect 2nd option next to a guy like Giannis. There’s no reason why the Milwaukee Bucks can’t be a top contender to repeat as champions next year.

28. Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (Oklahoma City Thunder)

Stats: 23.7/4.7/5.9 with 50.8/41.8/80.8 splits and 62.3%TS

Team Performance: 22-50, 14th seed in the West

The Oklahoma City Thunder had a bad year record wise, but there were many bright spots. The brightest being 23-year-old Shai Gilgeous-Alexander. He was the core piece coming over from the LA Clippers in the Paul George trade and he had a great year last year as the 2nd option on a playoff team to Chris Paul. But this was the year he took his game to a whole new level, averaging a super-efficient 23.7 points and significantly improving his playmaking ability. His impact on winning was clear as the Thunder were 16-19 before losing Shai for the rest of the season to a Planter Fascia tear. Sure, 16-19 doesn’t sound that impressive, but when you look at their 6-31 record without him, it’s quite the achievement.

I’m excited to see what Shai can do over the course of an entire season when healthy, an All-Star selection is definitely in the cards for him.

29. Jamal Murray (Denver Nuggets)

Stats: 21.2/4/4.8 with 47.7/40.8/86.9 splits and 59.2%TS

Team Performance: 47-25, 3rd seed in the West, 4-0 loss in the 2nd round to Phoenix

After historic performances in the NBA Bubble last year, many expected Jamal Murray to permanently take his game to a new level, which he did. He had a career high in points per game, made a significant leap in efficiency and the Nuggets were looking like potential title contenders. Unfortunately, everything went downhill on April 12th against the Golden State Warriors when Murray tore his ACL and was deemed out for the season. Not only did he miss the rest of the 2020-21 season, he is looking at missing a sizeable portion of the 2021-22 season. Luckily, the track record of recovering from ACL tears recently has been good. We should be able to expect a return to the normal Jamal Murray, hopefully sooner rather than later.

30. Bam Adebayo (Miami Heat)

Stats: 18.7/9/5.4 with 57/25/79.9 splits and 62.6%TS

Team Performance: 40-32, 6th seed in the East, 4-0 loss in the 1st round to Milwaukee

Bam Adebayo’s game is coming along nicely. He is one of the premier defenders in the NBA and his offensive game is making strides. This year he improved upon his mid-range jumper, giving him access to another scoring option and making him more versatile, which is necessary for an undersized center. The next part of his game that he’ll likely look to develop is his 3-point jumper. Adebayo will be playing for Team USA in the Olympics this summer, hopefully that experience will help him improve upon his game.

31. Russell Westbrook (Washington Wizards)

Stats: 22.2/11.5/11.7 with 43.9/31.5/65.6 splits and 50.9%TS

Team Performance: 34-38, 8th seed in the East, 4-1 loss in the 1st round to Philadelphia

Russell Westbrook is officially the King of the Triple-Double after surpassing Oscar Robertson’s incredible record of 182, the record now stands at 184 and there is no reason Westbrook can’t continue to increase this number. After suffering a quad injury in the bubble with Houston last season, Russ was coming into Washington with some question marks. His season started off horribly, which seems to be a trend for Westbrook in recent years, but after he recovered from that lingering quad injury, he began dominating. Before the All-Star break Russ was averaging 20.3 points, 9.7 rebounds and 9.8 assists on a woeful 48.4%TS. But after the All-Star break, he averaged 23.6 points, 12.8 rebounds and 13.1 assists on a still less than ideal 52.5%TS. Yes, he’s not efficient. Yes, he makes some stupid mistakes. But Russ is still a fantastic player who passes at an elite level and is a great floor-raiser. Westbrook was the primary reason behind the Wizards’ second half of the season turn around that allowed them to get the 8th seed. The Wizards were 14-20 before the All-Star break but finished the season on a 17-6 streak.

We don’t know what the future holds for Russ’ career or where he will play in the coming years, but we do know he will continue to make history and put up incredible numbers.

32. De’Aaron Fox (Sacramento Kings)

Stats: 25.2/3.5/7.2 with 47.7/32.2/71.9 splits and 56.5%TS

Team Performance: 31-41, 12th in the West

33. Ja Morant (Memphis Grizzlies)

Stats: 19.1/4/7.4 with 44.9/30.3/72.8 splits and 53.7%TS

Team Performance: 38-34, 8th in the West, 4-1 loss in the 1st round to Utah

34. Domantas Sabonis (Indiana Pacers)

Stats: 20.3/12/6.7 with 53.5/32.1/73.2 splits and 60.1%TS

Team Performance: 34-38, 9th seed in the East, Play-In loss to the Wizards

35. Nikola Vucevic (Chicago Bulls)

Stats: 23.4/11.7/3.8 with 47.7/40/84 splits and 56%TS

Team Performance: 31-41, 11th seed in the East

36. Brandon Ingram (New Orleans Pelicans)

Stats: 23.8/4.9/4.9 with 46.6/38.1/87.8 and 58.4%TS

Team Performance: 31-41, 11th seed in the West

37. Ben Simmons (Philadelphia 76ers)

Stats: 14.3/7.2/6.9 with 55.7/30/61.3 splits and 58.4%TS

Team Performance: 49-23, 1st seed in the East, 4-3 loss in the 2nd round to Atlanta

38. Gordon Hayward (Charlotte Hornets)

Stats: 19.6/5.9/4.1 with 47.3/41.5/84.3 and 58.4%TS

Team Performance: 33-39, 10th seed in the East, Play-In loss to Indiana

39. Tobias Harris (Philadelphia 76ers)

Stats: 19.5/6.8/3.5 with 51.2/39.4/89.2 splits and 59.8%TS

Team Performance: 49-23, 1st seed in the East, 4-3 loss in the 2nd round to Atlanta

40. Collin Sexton (Cleveland Cavaliers)

Stats: 24.3/3.1/4.4 with 47.5/37.1/81.5 splits and 57.3%TS

Team Performance: 22-50, 13th seed in the East

41. Jrue Holiday (Milwaukee Bucks)

Stats: 17.7/4.5/6.1 with 50.3/39.2/78.7 splits and 59.2%TS

Team Performance: 46-26, 3rd seed in the East, NBA Champions 4-2 over Phoenix

42. Mike Conley (Utah Jazz)

Stats: 16.2/3.5/6 with 44.4/41.2/85.2 splits and 58.9%TS

Team Performance: 52-20, 1st seed in the West, 4-2 loss in the 2nd round to the Clippers

43. DeMar DeRozan (San Antonio Spurs)

Stats: 21.6/4.2/6.9 with 49.5/25.7/88 splits and 59.1%TS

Team Performance: 33-39, 10th seed in the West, Play-In loss to Grizzlies

44. CJ McCollum (Portland Trail Blazers)

Stats: 23.1/3.9/4.7 with 45.8/40.2/81.2 and 57.7%TS

Team Performance: 42-30, 6th seed in the West, 4-2 loss in the 2nd round to Denver

45. Pascal Siakam (Toronto Raptors)

Stats: 21.4/7.4/4.5 with 45.5/29.7/82.7 splits and 54.7%TS

Team Performance: 27-45, 12th seed in the East

46. Deandre Ayton (Phoenix Suns)

Stats: 14.4/10.5/1.4 with 62.6/20/76.9 splits and 65.3%TS

Team Performance: 51-21, 2nd seed in the West, 4-2 loss in the Finals to Milwaukee

47. Jerami Grant (Detroit Pistons)

Stats: 22.3/4.6/2.8 with 42.9/35/84.5 splits and 55.6%TS

Team Performance: 20-52, 15th seed in the East

49. Kyle Lowry (Toronto Raptors)

Stats: 17.2/5.4/7.3 with 43.6/39.6/87.5 splits and 59.3%TS

Team Performance: 27-45, 12th seed in the East

49. Malcolm Brogdon (Indiana Pacers)

Stats: 21.2/5.3/5.9 with 45.3/38.8/86.4 splits and 56.1%TS

Team Performance: 34-38, 9th seed in the East, Play-In loss to the Wizards

50. Michael Porter Jr (Denver Nuggets)

Stats: 19/7.3/1.1 with 54.2/44.5/79.1 splits and 66.3%TS

Team Performance: 47-25, 3rd seed in the West, 4-0 loss in the 2nd round to Phoenix


I had a write up for all 50, but had to delete cause of character count.


r/nbadiscussion • • May 12 '25

What exactly makes Cooper Flagg a “generational” prospect?

2.1k Upvotes

Now that Dallas has the first pick, I’ve been trying to really understand what the hype is with Cooper Flagg. He’s obviously the projected number one, but I’m struggling to see what separates him from other top guys in recent drafts, let alone why he’s being labeled as a generational talent.

To be clear, I’m not saying he’s bad. The motor is elite. He plays hard every possession, defends at a high level, and clearly wants to win. That alone makes him a high-floor prospect. But when I look at his game, I don’t see anything that screams once-in-a-decade.

He’s not a sniper. The jumper is fine, but it’s not automatic or something defenses fear right now. He doesn’t have a deep bag as a shot creator. He’s not breaking people down off the dribble or pulling out advanced footwork. Athletically, he’s good but not in that freak tier like Zion or even someone like Anthony Edwards. And physically, he’s already pretty built, so I don’t know how much more projection you can really count on.

When Tatum came out, he had elite scoring potential and clear tools to be a go-to guy. Cade had vision and size as a lead initiator. Paolo had NBA-ready strength and skill. I’m just not seeing that kind of offensive ceiling with Flagg. He seems more like a glue guy on steroids someone who does everything well and competes like hell but not a franchise-altering offensive centerpiece.

So my question is, where is the generational tag coming from? Is it just because he’s fundamentally solid and checks a lot of boxes? Is it his feel for the game or leadership that doesn't show up in highlight clips? Or is there something I’m just flat out missing?

Genuinely curious what others see that I might not. Especially now that my team is in play to draft him.


r/nbadiscussion • • Sep 09 '20

With Giannis losing so early in the playoffs, it’s a clear sign that the NBA needs to announce the MVP award much earlier

2.0k Upvotes

Instead of trying to force this Oscars-like awards show that not many people enjoy, the NBA needs to announce the MVP at the start of the playoffs and the player should receive the award in front of home fans, as they did with Derrick Rose. After being bounced rather early in the playoffs it’s gonna be extremely awkward for Giannis in receiving the award. Also, it’s a regular season award, and the NBA needs to announce it right after the playoffs since it’s almost impossible to not factor in playoff performances when you announce the award so late.


r/nbadiscussion • • Feb 17 '25

Game Thread NBA should scrap the all star game

1.9k Upvotes

I’ve been saying for years that NBA should just scrap the all star game and give players a week rest. It’s clear most players don’t care and rightfully so because it doesn’t make any sense to go all out in a meaningless game and risk injury.

NBA doesn’t care because they decided to change the format and instead of showcasing actual basketball they spent most of it showcasing Kevin Hart and friends.

They can go the NHL route which seems to be a success so far and do the nations thing but I doubt players would care in that scenario too and they would just spam ads more than have actual basketball gameplay.

I think the NBA should just have a week off in this 82 game season where players can rest up and or manage their injuries while doing so because this all star game is a waste of time and I believe the reason why players even participate in it is because I believe you have to barring injury if selected have to participate in the all star game since it’s in their contract. That and all star selections somewhat matters on players resume so I assume players still want that acknowledgement.


r/nbadiscussion • • Jul 30 '21

Mod Announcement [META] Important information regarding the mod situation and direction of the subreddit. (Please Read)

1.8k Upvotes

Edit: wanted to add to the top of the post so it’s not buried - me and the other old mods are making a new subreddit r/NBATalk now that this one is basically fucked

TL;DR: Wilfra has been neglectful and done nothing to moderate the Discord server. He was the owner of the server so there were certain things we couldn’t do without admin approval. After one mod reached out and asked him for more power/permissions, he banned every single discord mod (not just unmodded - he banned us from the server) and removed every single moderator from r/nbadiscussion. He banned the people who actually took care of the discord because he wanted to have more power, and has removed all rules from this sub. He is currently on an insane power trip and is completely derailing this community.

https://i.imgur.com/sbYGcp8.jpg

This will be my last post on this subreddit, as I will 100% be banned and have this post removed once wilfra sees this. But this is important info regarding the subreddit situation that I need everyone to know.

Some background - I became an r/nbadiscussion mod in Fall 2019. I loved the sub and things went very well at first. However, there were differences in thought among the moderation team. I, and most other mods, were basketball purists and wanted to preserve the original rules and spirit of the subreddit. I strongly supported the character limit and other rules that upheld the quality and kept this community separate from r/nba. wilfra, on the other hand, prioritized activity and membership over quality of discussion; he felt that maximizing activity on the subreddit was the main goal and that the subreddit should adapt over time to suit the member base. Despite these differences, he was actively moderating the subreddit and seemed like a good guy so it never arose as a huge problem between us.

There was one incident during the summer of 2020 involving the Reddit chat room for r/nbadiscussion. A group of trolls had completely overrun the chat that night (long and complicated story). Wilfra, Kev (/u/kevinlovedagoat), and I were the only 3 mods on at the time, and we were working to contain the situation. Me and kev urged wilfra to ban the trolls, as they were completely destroying the chat room at that point. However, wilfra maintained that he would not ban them as they were active members, and banning them would decrease activity in the chat room. We were openly discussing what action to take in the chat room and we tried to negotiate with them about what they wanted. (Let it sink in, this is already an absurd situation - these guys are sending hundreds of messages per minute and breaking every subreddit rule, and wilfra is asking about their “demands” and attempting to negotiate with them) As we talked, they realized that they could do whatever they wanted as the mod wouldn’t ban them for it, and they only ramped up their behavior.

The trolls used a variety of racist and homophobic slurs against me and kev. I am black and kev is a member of the LGBTQ community, and the fact that wilfra not only ignored, but empowered those people after the incident spoke volumes. That was the breaking point for kev, who left the moderating team and stepped down as a discord mod the next day. Kev was a fantastic mod, he was very active and was the main reason the discord was alive for months. Him leaving was very sad and a huge loss for the server.

This left a hole in the discord mod team, which led to another active user, Mark, being promoted to moderator. Mark was amazing as a moderator - during our absence he pretty much single handedly kept the server running at a high level. Despite being the only active mod and experiencing a large influx of new users, the server was active and running perfect thanks to his efforts. I returned to the server earlier this year, and things had been amazing the past ~6 months. We had high activity, little drama, and engaging discussion.

Fast forward to today (2 days ago) - we had just finished wrapping up an eventful season and a great Finals. That afternoon, I received a message that I had been removed from the mod team. Later that day, all the other active mods besides myself got banned from the server. I went and unbanned the other mods who got banned (but i couldn’t make them mod again), then asked wilfra in the mod chat what was going on. He told me to tag him in the general channel so we could discuss it, and then permanently banned me from the discord. With him as the only mod now, I was unable to rejoin the server or get unbanned.

This is where he really went off the rails and openly started to go on a power trip. This is already a pretty long post so I won’t say too much, I’ll let the message history tell the story for me.

https://i.imgur.com/sbkx6Iw.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/4upC2Oj.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/Cwdqc7k.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/c1UZEpz.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/1Ey5uRU.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/uIarK0Y.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/MnrtndR.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/5HMuaHv.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/kPgZs6H.jpg

Here is how people are reacting to the changes:

https://imgur.com/a/bZqNzNc/

It wasn’t just me; he banned every moderator as a “test” to see who would message him back to see who cared about the community. (That’s right: he did nothing for the server, banned the people actively moderating the community, and then claimed it was a “test” to see who cared about it.) The server has been dead since the mods were banned; it’s just people calling out wilfra’s actions and him banning everyone who criticizes him or “did not show complete buy in”.

As if prioritizing quality over quantity to this extent for years wasn’t bad enough, he has now removed all rules and moderation from the sub. He’s gone completely nuts. This subreddit is finished.

For OG r/NBADiscussion members who want an actual subreddit for serious discussion, I just made r/NBATalk. It’ll be similar to the original r/nbadiscussion - a smaller, more chill community, with better moderation and higher quality discussion.

I am banned from r/nba and will be banned from this subreddit shortly. To the people reading this, please continue spreading the word, both on here and r/nba. It was wonderful during my time here and I’m sad it had to end this way. ✌️


r/nbadiscussion • • Jun 07 '21

Team Discussion The 2018 Rockets were a team that revolutionized NBA offense and defense but will be forgotten in the grand scheme of NBA history

1.8k Upvotes

2018 Rockets were led by one of the best offensive coaches ever, Mike D’Antoni, and a defensive mastermind, Jeff Bzdelik. They implemented a never-before-seen strategy on both offense and defense.

On offense, it was simple: spread the floor and use Harden to spam the shit out of pick-and-rolls. He had the floater, layup, lob threat, and 3pt threat, and could pass to the open shooter. The unique part of the offense came in crunch time: pure, 100% 5-out offense. Just Harden and Paul taking turns on the perimeter to try to break down their defenders. Harden is one of the best ISO players in history, so it worked for them, and they were able to maintain a historic level offense the entire year.

However, the main reason why the Rockets went toe-to-toe with the KD warriors was on the defensive end. Every single player was a defensive stud. They were not going to clamp up the opposing teams best player, but they could all guard multiple positions. Watching the series with GSW, I had never seen Curry seem so uncomfortable. He would run around screens trying to get off CP3, and 10 seconds later he’d be on PJ tucker. 10 more seconds of running around screens and he would find himself on Trevor Ariza. A lot of the time, he would end up trying to iso and eventually just throw it to KD to jack up a shot. The Rockets willingness to switch literally everything was so successful that now everyone is doing it (at least based on what I’ve seen in the West).

Yet in the grand scheme of things, Mike D’Antoni and Jeff Bzdelik will never get the appreciation they deserve since they didn’t beat the Warriors. I will leave on this final note: FUCK KD


r/nbadiscussion • • Apr 29 '25

Team Discussion Houston looks like a team missing its best player

1.7k Upvotes

Watching the Rockets this year, but especially this series, they just look like a team that lost its best player and is 'getting-by' without him.

Not only is their half-court offense down the stretch just nauseating, but at times they just look lost out there, committing stupid fouls and taking dumb shots.

In this game 4, their entire offense was bailout 3's from a red-hot FVV (a 34% 3PT shooter who went 8/12) and an 8-minute stretch where Sengun got anything he wanted w Draymond out.

I really like their core of young wings, but unfortunately, they will need to change something this summer. Not only do they not have THE guy, but they might not even have A guy...


r/nbadiscussion • • Jan 28 '21

Current Events It’s actually absurd how much more enjoyable games are with competent commentators

1.7k Upvotes

Just watched the Lakers-Sixers game. Great game, lots of narratives and very exciting. LeBron had a dirty push on Embiid but other than it was good clean fun.

Mike Breen and Doris Burke were on the call and OH MY GOD that improved the experience so much. Breen is one of the best play-by-play guys and Doris really knows her stuff. They weren’t perfect but the were a value add. Their tangents were short and funny. They were knowledgeable about the players and their personal arcs. And it seemed like they a good understanding of what this game meant and didn’t try to make it a bigger deal than it was. Doris’s point about Tobias Harris focusing on efficiency and not dribbling the ball too much was insightful for someone who hasn’t watched many Sixers games.

What was even more striking was what they DIDNT say. They didn’t demand stars be more aggressive if they didn’t drive the ball every other touch. They didn’t rail against analytics after every midrange jumper. They didn’t talk about how much better 90s basketball was and how these calls wouldn’t have been made 20 years ago (even tho they probably would have). It was striking the difference.

I think the clearest way to improve the product (besides staring the games at their listed times) is to get higher quality commentators. I re-introduced my mom to the NBA recently and, while watching a Mark Jackson/JVG game a while ago, just said “What the fuck are they talking about?”

Hopefully the league filters out the lower quality guys (or they get head coaching jobs) because my god is it annoying to have to check who is doing the broadcast to determine if the game is listenable.


r/nbadiscussion • • Apr 25 '24

Why does it seem like Tatum despite being so talented has limited effect on the game.

1.6k Upvotes

It just seems like to me he takes and makes shots or sometimes misses them.

He doesn't command special defensive attention, he doesn't make his teammates better, and while being a good defender his presence isn't anything special.

I've also seen him outplay superstars like Embiid Giannis and KD in the playoffs in important games and there are a few games where he doesn't miss but overall on average he just seems underwhelming


r/nbadiscussion • • Jun 17 '21

Maurice Stokes was a LeBron-Draymond hybrid who had an elite combination of rebounding, passing, and defense his first 3 years in the NBA ('56-58) before a tragic accident ended it all.

1.6k Upvotes

I'm posting this now, instead of during the off-season, because today is Maurice Stokes' birthday.

Maurice Stokes really was "LeBron before LeBron". He was a physical specimen who entered the league in 1955 (one year before Bill Russell): he was 6-ft-7, and I've seen him listed everywhere from 232 to 280 pounds (teammate Jack Twyman said his normal playing weight was 275). Not only did he have a large, strong frame, he was also very athletic -- not just for the 50's, for any era. Here are some career highlights. He played 2 years in college and averaged 23 ppg & 27 rpg his first year and 27 ppg & 26 rpg his second, and he was the NIT MVP despite his team finishing 4th. He was the 2nd pick in the '55 draft, and he was immediately great in the pros.

  • In 1955-56, Stokes averaged a league-leading 16 rpg (above MVP Bob Pettit), team best 17 ppg, and also had the league's 8th-best assists/game at 4.9. With his size & athleticism & hustle, he was also one of the league's elite defenders. On offense, he was difficult to handle in the post and extremely difficult to stop in transition because of his athleticism & passing. He was an All-Star, 2nd-team All-NBA, and easily won the Rookie of the Year. He also was the league's first point-forward (really a point-PF/C). He also had the most insane triple-double ever recorded by a rookie: 26 points, 38 rebounds, and 12 assists (box score). Similarly, in his first ever NBA game, he went for 32 points, 20 rebounds, and 8 assists.

  • In 1956-57, Stokes averaged a league 2nd-best 17 rpg (behind Bill Russell), team 2nd-best 16 ppg (15.6 just behind team-best 16.3), and league 3rd-best 4.6 apg. He was fractionally behind a PG and was only really topped by Bob Cousy (7.5). Stokes' defense remained elite. Again he was an All-Star and 2nd-team All-NBA, plus he was 6th in MVP voting despite playing on a middling club and lots of racist voting back then.

  • In 1957-58, Stokes' 18 rpg were again 2nd-best to Russell, his 17 ppg were 3rd on the improving Royals (pre-Oscar), and his 6.4 apg were again 3rd in the league (barely behind Cousy who lead the league at 7.1). Again, he was an elite defender, an All-Star and 2nd-team All-NBA player, and was now 5th in MVP voting as he lead his team into the playoffs. In November of this season, he recorded 4 consecutive triple-doubles, back when recording even one triple-double was nearly unheard of.

Over the first 3 seasons of his career, Maurice Stokes grabbed a league-best 3492 rebounds (prime Pettit was 2nd with 3417), and he had the 2nd-most assists in the league with 1062 (only behind Bob Cousy). Stokes is the only player EVER to finish top-2 in both of these categories over a 3-year period. Here are his career stats.

Tragically, Stokes struck his head on the floor in the final game of '58 which lead to seizures and a damaging brain injury (he likely contracted encephalitis) that left him permanently paralyzed. His teammate Jack Twyman helped take care of him for the rest of his life, which ended at age 36. The NBA's teammate of the year award is named after the pair, The Twyman-Stokes Teammate of the Year Award. Maurice Stokes was finally elected into the Hall of Fame in 2004.


r/nbadiscussion • • Aug 04 '22

Draft/Pick Analysis Could the OKC Thunder buy out an entire draft class and win a title?

1.6k Upvotes

The Oklahoma City Thunder have a historical amount of draft capital, including 16 first-round picks over the next seven years (including 7 of their own). https://fanspo.com/nba/teams/Thunder/21/draft-picks

But since you always risk drafting the wrong players, why not just buy out a draft, all 14 slots in an upcoming year (let's say 2024 or 2025) using your existing draft capital plus your young assets (Shai, Holmgren, Giddy, Dort)?

Would the entire lottery draft class from an average year be enough to win you a title? I went through each draft class from 2003 to 2018 to find out.

Yes and here’s why.

Using historical draft classes, you can see that most lottery classes will make you a championship team. I only used lottery picks, so there is no revisionist history. The 2019-2022 years are still too young to form a real opinion on.

2018: Trae Young (5), Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (11), Luka Doncic (3), Jaren Jackson Jr. (4), Deandre Ayton (1)

Bench: Mikal Bridges, Colin Sexton, Wendel Carter Jr, Michael Porter Jr., Miles Bridges,

Championship Caliber: Yes

Fire-power and scoring at all positions. Could use more defense, but JJJ helps out a lot at the four. Plus, there are several decent defenders off the bench.

2017: Lonzo Ball (2), Donovan Mitchell (13), Jayson Tatum (3), Lauri Markkanen (7), Bam Adebayo (14),

Bench: De’Aaron Fox (5), Markelle Fultz (1), Luke Kennard (12), Jonathan Isaac (6), Malik Monk (11), Zach Collins (10), Frank Ntilikina (8)

Championship Caliber - Yes

This team is saved by the last two lottery picks, Mitchell and Adebayo. Some shortage of talent at power forward, where you plug in Markkanen, but you could probably swap out Kennard or Isaac (if he ever plays) for fit. The bench is inconsistent though.

2016: Ben Simmons (1), Jamal Murray (7) Jaylen Brown (3), Brandon Ingram (2), Domantas Sabonis (11)

Bench: Buddy Hield (6), Taurean Prince (12), Jakob Poeltl (9), Kris Dunn (5), Denzel Valentine (14), Georgios Papagiannis (13)

Championship Caliber: yes

Strong starting five, if you can get anything out of Ben Simmons and a really versatile defensive team if Ingram can continue to improve on that end. This is actually a long, rangy defense that would cause fits with Simmons, Brown and Ingram playing as really strong potential wing/backcourt defenders with Sabonis holding down the center spot.

2015: Devin Booker (13), D’Angelo Russell (2), Kristaps Porzingis (4), Karl-Anthony Towns (1), Miles Turner (11)

Bench: Emmanuel Mudiay (7), Stanley Johnson (8), Justise Winslow (10), Cam Payne (14), Trey Lyles (12), Frank Kaminsky (9)

Championship caliber: No

Booker and Towns are top-tier talent, but the rest of your starting five is only above average (Turner), bad (Russell) or questionable (Porzingis). The bench has some nice players but not a lot of punch.

2014: Marcus Smart (6), Zach Lavine (13), Andrew Wiggins (1), Julius Randle (7), Joel Embiid (3)

Bench: Aaron Gordon (4), Doug McDermmott (11), Dario Saric (12), T.J. Warren (14), Elfrid Payton (10), Nik Stauskas (8), Dante Exum (5), Jabari Parker (2)

Championship caliber: Yes

Great and balanced starting five anchored by Embiid and Lavine with Smart and Wiggins providing defensive stoppers. You may sub out Randle for Gordon based on fit and for more bench scoring, but this would be a high-powered team.

2013: CJ McCollum (10), Victor Oladipo (2), Kenvtavious Caldwell-Pope (8) Otto Porter Jr (3) Steven Adams (12)

Bench: Cody Zeller (4), Alex Len (5), Ben McLemore (7), Trey Burke (9), Kelly Olynnyk (13), Michael Carter-Williams

Championship caliber: No

Analysis: One of the worst drafts in NBA history, with top pick Anthony Bennett quickly washing out of the league. McCollum is your only star level player on this team. Oladipo and Adams were quality starters, but the rest are bench or even low bench guys. Drafting better would have made this team any automatic contender with Giannis and Rudy Gobert.

2012: Damian Lillard (5), Bradley Beal (3), Harrison Barnes (7), Anthony Davis (1), Andre Drummond

Bench: Dion Waiters (4), Terrence Ross (8), Austin Rivers (10), Jeremy Lamb (12), John Henson (14), Meyers Leonard (11)

Championship caliber: Yes

Analysis: Heck of a starting five although it lacks a true wing, but Davis and Barnes can make up for that on defense.

2011: Kyrie Irving (1), Kemba Walker (9), Klay Thompson (11), Enes Freedom (3), Jonas Valanciunas (5)

Bench: Tristan Thompson (4), Brandon Knight (8), Markieff Morris (13), Marcus Morris (14), Alec Burks (12), Bismack Biyombo (7), Derrick Williams (2),

Championship caliber: Yes

Analysis: At this point you have to start remembering peak career guys, not what they are now. Irving, Walker and Thompson give you a lot of offensive shooting and scoring. The frontcourt lacks versatility so does the bench. To bad you miss out on Kawhi Leonard at 15

2010: John Wall (1), Evan Turner (2), Gordon Hayward (9), Paul George (10), DeMarcus Cousins (5)

Bench: Derrick Favors (3), Greg Monroe (7), Al-Farouq Aminu (8), Ed Davis (13), Patrick Patterson (14).

Championship caliber: Yes

Analysis: This would have been a really fun team to watch around 2016 or 2017. Wall, George and Cousins would be a mean bunch and Hayward would give you shooting. The bench isn’t great and lacks a really offensive driver, but there are a lot of versatile players here.

2009: James Harden (3), Steph Curry (7), DeMar DeRozan (9), Blake Griffin (1), Jordan Hill (8)

Bench: Tyreke Evans (4), Ricky Rubio (5), Brandon Jennings (10), Gerald Henderson (12), Tyler Hansbrough (13), Earl Clark (14),

Championship caliber: Yes

A historically good starting five, even with Jordan Hill as your only real center on this team. Several good guards off the bench, but the defensive backcourt is also incredibly weak.

2008: Derrick Rose (1), Russell Westbrook (4), Danillo Gallinari (6), Kevin Love (5), Brook Lopez (10)

Bench: O.J. Mayo (3), Michael Beasley (2), Eric Gordon (7), D.J. Augustin (9), Jason Thompson (12), Jerryd Bayless

Championship caliber: No

The starting five may get you Finals talk during their peak years, but the bench is a trainwreck.

2007: Mike Conley (4), Kevin Durant (2), Thaddeus Young (12), Al Horford (3), Joakim Noah (9)

Bench: Jeff Green (5), Cory Brewer (7), Al Thornton (14), Brendan Wright (8), Acie Law (11),

Championship caliber: Yes

This is a big, stacked starting five with Durant at shooting guard, Horford and Noah holding it down in the backcourt. No quality small wings though (other than Durant who has to play to play shooting guard).

2006: Brandon Roy (6), JJ Redick (11), Ronnie Brewer (14), Rudy Gay (8), LaMarcus Aldridge (2)

Bench: Andrea Bargnani (1), Tyrus Thomas (4), Randy Foye (7), Thabo Sefolosha (13),

Championship caliber: No

A nice playoff team with Roy, Gay and Aldridge with Redick as a shooter, but just lacks the top-level star power needed to win a chip. One-dimensional bench players too.

2005: Chris Paul (4), Deron Williams (3), Marvin Williams (2), Channing Frye (8), Andrew Bogut (1)

Bench: Raymond Felton (5), Martell Webster (6), Charline Villanueva, Rashad McCants (14), Ike Diogu (9),

Championship caliber: No

Despite the Point God and Deron Williams, who many early argued was as good as Paul, the star power stops here. Bogut, Frye and Marvin Williams are all fine role players, but even the bench lacks any umph.

2004: Ben Gordon (3), Devin Harris (5), Luol Deng (7), Andre Iguodala (9), Dwight Howard (1)

Bench: Shaun Livingston (4), Josh Childress (6), Andris Biedrins (11), Sebastian Telfair (13), Kris Humphries (14), Emeka Okafor

Championship caliber: No

Iggy and Dwight Howard are a nice start, but the guards are just okay. A nice bench unit though.

2003: Kirk Heinrich (7), Dwyane Wade (4), Lebron James (1), Carmelo Anthony (3), Chris Bosh (4)

Bench: TJ Ford (8), Dark Milicic (2), Chris Kaman (6), Mickael Pietrus (11), Nick Collison (12), Luke Ridnour (14)

Championship caliber: Yes

Analysis: All-time great team here and even Heinrich was a quality point guard in his prime. If the Heatles could win a championship with Mario Chalmers running the point, then this team with Carmelo can probably contend with any champion in Finals history.

Championship Caliber Teams: 10/16 - 62.5%

Conclusion: OKC should go all in on a single draft. 2028-2029 NBA champions, 62.5% guaranteed.


r/nbadiscussion • • May 03 '23

Freedawkins deserves his flowers for making instant highlights a standard norm now

1.6k Upvotes

Today you can view a 10 min highlight of an NBA game almost immediately after the game has ended. Before Dawkins and other highlight channels you were lucky to get 60 secs of game highlights on Sports Center hours after a game.

For 1 person or maybe a small team of hard core NBA fans to rip a game live and edit live to then publish on youtube minutes after a game ended is a shit ton of work to do. NBA and ESPN do it now and I'm sure spend a ton of money on staff and resources to edit highlights as the game is going on. After getting taken down by Youtube and NBA multiple times and still up and running, I'm sure Dawkins doesn't get his credit nor get paid what he should.

I'd love to see like an espn e60 documentary on Dawkins. I just imagine a kid in his room ripping games on his computer and editing them to share with NBA fans.


r/nbadiscussion • • May 19 '21

Team Discussion Can Miami finally un-retire Michael Jordan’s number 23 after 18 years?

1.5k Upvotes

When the Heat first retired Michael Jordan’s jersey during his final game in 2003, it was a nice gesture to honor one of the game’s all-time greats. Plus, they were a relatively young franchise with not much to hang up in the rafters yet.

It seems like this was also intended to be the catalyst for a league-wide retirement of the number 23, which obviously did not happen.

Now, the Heat just seem like the dude that tried to start a slow clap but the rest of the crowd awkwardly sat in silence.

If anyone hasn’t seen it, the jersey is relegated to the corner of the AAA (not even in the rafters with the retired jerseys of actual Heat players), hanging next to Dan Marino’s jersey for... reasons


r/nbadiscussion • • Jan 04 '21

Player Discussion Jaylen Brown is becoming what Andrew Wiggins was supposed to be and is just as important to the Celtics as Jayson Tatum

1.5k Upvotes

I'll be the first to admit that this may be an overreaction to the first seven games and that Jaylen's recent play may partially be due to a higher usage rate because of Kemba's absence. However, he's averaging 28 ppg (5th in the league), 4.6 rpg, and 3.1 apg on 60% from the field and 42.5% from three with good defense. Back when he was a rookie Wiggins drew comparisons to players like Kobe and T-Mac for his ability to score at will and was thought to be a future superstar, even earning the nickname Maple Jordan. To begin this season Jaylen has been sensational and looks to be the pure scorer that Wiggins was thought to be, while being the good defender that people thought Wiggins would eventually develop into. If Jaylen can keep up this play for the rest of the season, which admittingly may be unlikely, there's no doubt that he's an All-NBA level talent and one of the brightest young stars in the league, on par with Tatum. Do you all think that Jaylen can maintain this level of play or do you think that the Celtics should consider including him in a potential James Harden trade?


r/nbadiscussion • • Jul 08 '21

NBA needs to start marketing its gameplay rather than debates and hypotheticals

1.5k Upvotes

Seeing comments around r/NBA and in basketball subreddits in general, give off the consensus of people being tired of the NBA promoting player drama and debates rather than the on-court product. If you look at the NFL, the majority of the networks and programs talk about the analysis of games.

For example, how a defensive scheme won them certain possessions, what kind of route combinations the offensive coordinator drew up that week, how a QB managed to scramble and create a play on the fly.

I feel like I don't see any real basketball analysis on the popular networks and programs. I would love it if networks went into how the Suns' offense is being run through Chris Paul with Ayton and Booker, or how the Bucks should run their defense while Giannis is on the court.

I think teaching more basketball knowledge would cater to the existing fans more and provide insights to newer fans. I understand that the flashy plays and big names bring in the revenue, but this is an untapped market that I think will improve the health and interest of the game.

Edit: Omg so many comments! One thing I noticed was people saying that basketball is a faster pace than football so they can’t say as much during the game. Even if that’s the case, networks can definitely up their production quality outside of games with solid analysis and breakdowns.


r/nbadiscussion • • Jan 26 '20

Kobe Bryant has died in a helicopter crash

1.5k Upvotes

This will serve as our mega-thread for this topic, all similar threads will be closed and people directed here. Anything broadly related to this is topic welcome in this thread. Please be mindful of our rules.

RIP Kobe :(

https://www.tmz.com/2020/01/26/kobe-bryant-killed-dead-helicopter-crash-in-calabasas/

https://myfox8.com/2020/01/26/kobe-bryant-killed-in-los-angeles-helicopter-crash/

https://theathletic.com/1562407/2020/01/26/reports-kobe-bryant-killed-in-helicopter-crash-in-southern-california/

edit: most of the comments are very short. i wasn't sure exactly how to handle this so approved them all so far. it's possible another mod may decide to go another route. this is an unusual situation.


r/nbadiscussion • • Feb 28 '25

Team Discussion The Luka Lakers Are Figuring It Out... Thanks to LeBron's evolution from his heliocentric role into a 0.5 battering ram.

1.5k Upvotes

The morning I filled in for Adam Mares on the All-NBA podcast with Tim Legler, I watched Los Angeles lose to Charlotte. As I took notes and pulled clips, I could only feel disbelief at how clunky the Los Angeles offense looked with two players trying to play the same role: heliocentric alpha.

LeBron James and Luka Doncic have thrived in this role throughout their NBA careers. They’re the basketball version of grandmasters chess players. They’ve seen every coverage under the sun, can make every shot/read in the book, and they both know how to move the pieces around the basketball chessboard with precision and ease.

Thanks for reading Low Man Help! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

But like Highlander, there can be only one, and as to the question of who would be that one for this Los Angeles team, well… The 25-year-old generational talent with a long runway in front of him would always be the answer.

Players often say they want to win, but they really mean, “I want to win, but I want to do it playing my way.”

The Charlotte game felt like a line of demarcation for this team. Two heliocentric grandmaster chess players wouldn’t give them the best chance to win, so an evolution had to happen.

Two BIG things have stood out to me since that Charlotte game:

  1. LeBron’s shift into a 0.5 Player

  2. The Roberson Rule

LeBron’s Final Act:

LeBron James has shifted from the only role he’s ever known in the NBA into a 0.5 player1. This is a massive step for someone of his caliber; he’s undoubtedly one of the top players to play this game.

Since the clunky Charlotte game, Los Angeles has won four games in a row, three of which have featured both James and Doncic. In those three victories, James recorded his two lowest games of the season in average touch length and average dribbles per touch.

During the Los Angeles win over Denver, James set a season low for average touch length (2.892 seconds) and average dribbles taken per touch (1.83).

The Denver game was the only time during the 24/25 that he had been under three seconds per touch or two dribbles. Until the Los Angeles win over Minnesota, James again set a season low for average touch length (2.581 seconds) and average dribbles taken per touch (1.44).

The data indicates precisely what the eye test says: LeBron has shifted into the 0.5 player this team needed to reach its ceiling, and he and the Los Angeles Lakers are thriving!

LeBron James Closeouts:

  • Before Luka: 1.033 Points Per Chance (52nd Percentile)

  • After Luka: 1.351 Points Per Chance (87th Percentile)

One of the most significant benefits of James relinquishing the highlander role to Doncic has been seeing his first three steps transition from then defensive end to offense. James no longer waits for every outlet pass to control the chess board; he knows Doncic sees the same picture he does, so he gets on his horse and goes!

James has long been one of the league's best, if not its best athlete. However, creating offense in the NBA takes energy, and that burden fell on James more times than not. But with Doncic in Los Angeles, the on-ball burden is gone, and LeBron’s athleticism has been unleashed every play they’re on the court together.

The Roberson Rule:

JJ Reddick is using the NBA regular season as a defensive lab experiment. One theory he’s been beta testing is Seth Partnow’s “Roberson Rule.”

The past week, Aaron Gordon, Russell Westbrook, Dante Exum, Naji Marshall, Jaden McDaniels, Jaylen Clark, and Tarrence Shannon Jr. have received Reddick's version of Partnow's Roberson Rule.

One of the things I always tell agents, scouts, or front office members when discussing shooting is that volume matters. Yes, it’s great to be a 40% shooter from the three-point line, but if the player turns down open → semi-open shots to pass or drive into traffic, the percentage doesn’t matter because they can be put into a box defensively.

The Roberson Rule is that box.

Since January 15th, Los Angeles has been first in defensive rating, opponents’ points in the paint, and opponents’ FG%. The results are straightforward; the lab experiment is working.

Reddick is unwilling to concede gravity to players he doesn’t believe will shoot enough volume to beat them. Instead, he chooses to shrink the defensive shell and shift more gravity to players who can beat Los Angeles, like Jokic, Kyrie, and Anthony Edwards.

Ben Taylor showed what that extra gravity looks like when shifted towards a player (Jokic).

Even a few makes from Gordon and Westbrook didn’t shake his resolve in the Roberson Rule strategy; it takes volume. Your shooting gravity is not defined by your percentage but by a combination of three factors: Percentage, Volume, and Mechanics.

He knows that players who have never shot 15 threes in an NBA game don’t know how to deal with the emotional swings of missing nine threes and it still being a good thing for the team, and he’s betting on players not being able to step that far outside the Overton Window of volume.The Luka Lakers Are Figuring It Out...


r/nbadiscussion • • May 10 '24

This Boston team is probably my least favorite to watch among all the 60-wins teams I remember

1.5k Upvotes

I don't know if this topic is too polemical for this sub but I need to confess. I remember having watched some amazing 60+ win teams over the past twenty years.

Despite having significant different style of play, sometimes very team oriented, sometimes with ultra star power, they were all entertaining or even amazing to watch : Webber Sacramento, Suffocating Defense Pistons, 7 or Less Suns, Big Three Celtics, Kobe and Pau Lakers, Big three Spurs basketball, Miami 3 Amigos, Steph' Warriors to name the most memorable among them.

I absolutely do not feel this anticipation and enjoyment with this year' Celtics. I've been trying to rationalize this feeling over the past months, as I was experiencing it in the midst of winter while the Celtics were punching everyone in the NBA.

  • The quote "live by the three, die by the three" was never more appropriate than for this iteration of the Celtics. To see them insist and chuckling massive volume of 3s is infuriating to watch, when said amounts are littered with bricks and badly missed contested ones. Perhaps the fact that these Celtics do not include a true specialist among them but a lot of streaky hitters exacerbates the feeling. But one thing is certain, every time I see Al Hordord taking a 30 ft deep 3 something dies inside me, converted or not.

  • I do not feel a lot of passion from the players. This lacks personality. Past seasons included players like Smart or even Grant Williams, who embodied something at least. The mere fact that they were despised by opposing fans was a good sign at least. But here, nothing to love. And, but maybe it is only my perception, It looks like the Garden is feeling the same: I haven't seen it rocking a lot this season, at least compared to what I remember and what should be the case for a 64 win season.

  • This leads to my next take: the stars are not inspiring in Boston, both in their play and attitude. It is sometimes hard to exactly grasp what constitutes the "it" factor. But to me one thing's certain, both Jay do not have it. It was amusing to see ESPN trying to hype JT earlier this season, with NBA PR Representative SAS trying to sell us the next "face of the nba" and such. But it doesn't work because JT is bland, does not have any charisma. Regarding their style of play : as some people pointed out, JT does a lot of things well but is not the best at anything. He is not a flashy player, and he's not a particularly smart one. Same goes for JB, with his much maligned leftie. He can have strong finishes, nice takeovers, quite often in the 1st, but he can also completely disappear from a game.


r/nbadiscussion • • Jun 24 '21

Statistical Analysis If the Suns or Hawks won the championship this year, they'd be the biggest preseason underdogs to win a title in over 35 years.

1.5k Upvotes

Basketball reference has preseason title odds for every champion dating back to 1985. Here are the biggest underdog title teams in that time span:

YearLgChampionPreseason Odds
2015NBAGolden State Warriors2800
2011NBADallas Mavericks2000
2019NBAToronto Raptors1850
2004NBADetroit Pistons1500
1994NBAHouston Rockets1200
2014NBASan Antonio Spurs1200
2003NBASan Antonio Spurs1100
2008NBABoston Celtics1000
1991NBAChicago Bulls700

The Suns were +4000 to win a title in the preseason, and the Hawks were +10000 (same as the Wizards and Pacers). If either team won the championship this year, they be by far the biggest underdogs in the past 35 years to win a title, and if the Hawks were to do so, they'd likely be the biggest preseason underdogs in NBA history to win a ring.


r/nbadiscussion • • Jun 17 '21

Player Discussion Last Night Kevin Durant Demonstrated the Exact Issue with Superteams

1.5k Upvotes

Kevin Durant's performance last night was absolutely incredible, but watching it reminded me of the exact reason why his move to Golden State was such a waste: When transcendent players take the easy way out, and build dominant superteams, you don't get to see the sort of performances we saw last night.

I look at accomplishments in basketball a lot like diving. It's not just about sticking the dive, it is also about the degree of difficulty. Kevin Durant going to Golden State was like an Olympic diver delivering a cannonball. Last night was Kevin Durant showing us he's still capable of a reverse four and a half somersault.

I don't want to see Kevin Durant do cannonballs. I want to see him challenge himself. Nothing KD did in three years in Golden State was remotely as impressive as what he did last night. Yet, for some reason there is this idea that the couple of easy rings that he coasted to, beating up hopelessly overmatched teams next to Steph and co, are somehow the defining achievements of his career.

Now, of course, the irony of the whole thing is that KD didn't choose to have to carry his team last night. He teamed up with Kyrie, then recruited Harden to make sure he wouldn't have to carry a team the way he did last night. Injuries forced him into greatness, but I really wish more players would choose to trust their own greatness, instead of pretending that greatness can be achieved be taking the easy way out. Even the world's most perfect cannonball isn't winning any Olympic medals.

Of course, that doesn't mean that players have to stay in hopeless situations with terrible teams. You still don't try dives in competition that you can't possibly execute. But, you still have to challenge yourself if you want to prove what you can do. KD's decision to leave OKC wasn't LeBron's decision to leave Cleveland. While I would have like to have seen LeBron challenge himself, too, by maybe not teaming up with Wade and Bosh, what is so annoying about KD's situation is that he had a squad. His supporting cast in OKC was excellent. He was a game away from knocking off the 73 win Warriors. He had a guy next to him who won the MVP the very next year.

At the end of the day, taking the easy way out, when he already had a championship level supporting cast makes it look like KD didn't believe enough in his own greatness. When KD doesn't believe in his own greatness it makes it tough for others to believe in it. And, ultimately, last night showed exactly why he should have believed in himself. Because KD is great, and he could have proven it to the world in OKC, or with almost any non-Warriors team in the league. Instead, he took the easy way out, landed the perfect cannonball, and only showed his greatness again when circumstances forced it out of him.


r/nbadiscussion • • Apr 13 '21

Player Discussion In case you haven’t noticed, Thanasis Antetokounmpo has become a legitimately useful NBA player

1.5k Upvotes

Thanasis Antetokounmpo is Giannis’ older brother who spent a year with the Knicks G-League team after being a 2nd round pick in 2014. He played a few years in Greece and then signed with the Bucks for the 19-20 season. He was pretty much exclusively a garbage time player that year and seemed lost on an NBA floor, but did have a few moments of some good hustle.

The 20-21 Thanasis is entirely different. Since about mid February, Thanasis has been a regular member of the Bucks rotation. He’s been one of the hardest working players I’ve ever seen on the floor, and he’s also clearly improved his handle and scoring ability, even dropping 23 on the Knicks in one of his 2 starts this season. He’s also been a menace on defense and grabbing tough rebounds. Even when he’s not scoring, he has a really good knack for making winning plays that don’t show up on the stat sheet. In addition, he’s cut way down on some of the bad turnovers he was prone to having in the past and it seems that the game has slowed down significantly for him.

Thanasis’ development since the start of the season is incredible, I don’t know if I’ve ever seen a player improve as a season goes on as much as he has. I wouldn’t even be shocked to see him get 5-15 minutes in playoff games. Thanasis will be a free restricted agent this off-season and he will likely get offers from other teams, but I’d be shocked if he leaves Milwaukee as long as Giannis is there.


r/nbadiscussion • • Feb 21 '26

Player Discussion What Charles Barkley accomplished from '90-93 was ridiculous

1.4k Upvotes

Yesterday was Chuck's 63rd birthday, so I wanted to point out how bonkers good Barkley was during the four-year stretch from '90-93 since it often gets overlooked.

In '90, he received the most 1st place MVP votes while finishing second in the MVP race, and he was named the Sporting News MVP. The Sixers finished near or above several Eastern contenders despite having a much worse supporting cast than those teams.

In '91, Barkley was easily the best player in the ASG, recording 17 points and 22 rebounds, resulting in being named the game's MVP.

In '92, Barkley was the break-out star on the Dream Team and led the Olympic squad in ppg, FG%, and 3FG% (18, .711, .875); it became overwhelmingly obvious that summer how much that the inept Sixers supporting cast had been holding him back.

In '93, he joined a consistently very good Suns team and made them great (+9 wins), winning the MVP and getting Phoenix to Game 6 of the Finals in a tight series (Chicago's four wins were by 8, 3, 6, and 1 points, and the teams had an even point-differential for the series). Barkley badly injured his elbow in Game 2 of the Finals, and the Suns lost starter Cedric Ceballos (#1 FG% in the NBA that season) in the previous series, so a slightly healthier Suns coulda/shoulda won that title.