r/mutualism • • Oct 20 '20

Intro to Mutualism and Posting Guidelines

139 Upvotes

What is Mutualism?

The question seems harder than perhaps it should because the answer is simpler than we expect it to be. Mutualism is, in the most general sense, simply anarchism that has left its (consistently anarchistic) options open.

A historical overview of the mutualist tradition can be found in this chapter from the Palgrave Handbook of Anarchism, but the short version is this:

Mutualism was one of the terms Proudhon used to describe anarchist theory and practice, at a time before anarchism had come into use. Proudhon declared himself an anarchist, and mutualism was alternately an anarchist principle and a class of anarchistic social relations—but a lot of the familiar terminology and emphases did not yet exist. Later, after Proudhon’s death, specifically collectivist and then communist forms of anarchist thought emerged. The proponents of anarchist communism embraced the term anarchism and they distinguished their own beliefs (often as “modern anarchism”) from mutualism (which they treated as not-so-modern anarchism, establishing their connection and separation from Proudhon and his work.) Mutualism became a term applied broadly to non-communist forms of anarchism (most of them just as “modern” as anarchist communism) and the label was particularly embraced by anarchist individualists. For some of those who took on the label, non-capitalist markets were indeed an important institution, while others adopted something closer to Proudhon’s social-science, which simply does not preclude some form of market exchange. And when mutualism experienced a resurgence about twenty years ago, both a “free market anti-capitalism” and a “neo-Proudhonian” current emerged. As the mutualist tradition has been gradually recovered and expanded, it has come to increasingly resemble anarchism without adjectives or a form of anarchist synthesis.

For the more traditional of those two modern tendencies, there are two AMAs available on Reddit (2014 and 2017) that might answer some of your questions.

The Center for a Stateless Society is a useful resource for market anarchist thought.

Kevin Carson's most recent works (and links to his Patreon account) are available through his website.

The Libertarian Labyrinth archive hosts resources on the history of mutualism (and anarchism more generally), as well as "neo-Proudhonian" theory.

There are dozens of mutualism-related threads here and in r/Anarchy101 which provide more clarification. And more specific questions are always welcome here at r/mutualism. But try to keep posts specifically relevant to anarchist mutualism.


r/mutualism • • Aug 06 '21

Notes on "What is Property?" (2019)

Thumbnail
libertarian-labyrinth.org
57 Upvotes

r/mutualism • • 7d ago

Proudhon, Slavery, and the American Civil War

Thumbnail
theanarchistlibrary.org
4 Upvotes

r/mutualism • • 8d ago

Ive been reading a lot about mutualism today, and Ive accumulated some questions about it

0 Upvotes

How is my original labour and investment protected? If I put a bunch of previous work into a project and once it’s successful I bring on more people to help, am I just getting a equal share even though Ive put all that previous work into the project? Or am I compensated by the new workers so we all have an equal share?

For example:

If I fund and build a series of escape rooms, then let others operate it while I pursue another project, what rights do I retain? Am I still entitled to profit off of it?

If everyone agrees beforehand that I can return or repurpose the land, would that agreement be upheld?


r/mutualism • • 16d ago

Is Mutualism Really Part of the Left?

17 Upvotes

I don’t know. Every time someone from the traditional economic left (communists, state socialists, etc.) wants a surface understanding of my views on economics, they conclude that I am a right-winger. Conversely, if I search on Google or whatever, it says mutualism is far-left. But if I say I am far-left, everyone is going to think of communism. Am I just bad at explaining my views, or is mutualism in a gray area, wherein the left sees it as too liberal and the right as too revolutionary?


r/mutualism • • 17d ago

A political ideology that advocates for a classless stateless society based on anti capitalist free markets, mutual aid, mutual banking, consent, labor notes, etc

2 Upvotes

My friend gave me this as a mutualism definition for my website is this good?


r/mutualism • • 22d ago

Christian mutualism anyone?

11 Upvotes

I’ve started looking into Christianity again after being atheist for a bit and Lutheranism caught my eye and I might become Lutheran but I’m also a based mutualist. Anyone had an experience like tjis or just me idk if I want to be a Christian again but idk y’all’s thoughts?


r/mutualism • • 23d ago

Question about firms

5 Upvotes

From what I understand, a big difference between mutualists and LWMAs is that LWMAs are more tolerant of the existence of firms, whereas mutualists would argue that firms shouldn't exist.

However if we look at Ronald Coase's Transaction Cost Theory, the cost of using the open market is higher. Firms have lower internal organization costs than market transaction costs, which is the reason firms exist, Coase argues.

My question is, would mutualists argue that the higher transaction costs of using open markets be a feature of specifically capitalist market dynamics?

Or alternatively, am I wrong in that mutualists don't believe firms should exist?


r/mutualism • • 23d ago

So many people think we do labor notes and it’s annoying

3 Upvotes

It comes from Marx making a tasteless critic and now it has stuck with us for a while


r/mutualism • • Oct 17 '26

Is William Henry Van Ornum worth the read?

11 Upvotes

I know this isn't a market anarchist subreddit, but I think I found some of his work on Libertarian Labyrinth so I assumed people here might be familiar.

I haven't heard of William Henry Van Ornum organically in the wild. But he wrote two or three books (Co-operation and Why Government At All ) from a market anarchist perspective. I skimmed parts of them maybe six months ago and remember sort of liking them. They're big-ish so I'm wondering if he has anything to offer that I wouldn't get from Tucker (I remember him mentioning Tucker a lot which I why I'm assuming he was a Tuckerite).


r/mutualism • • Oct 16 '26

Paul-Émile De Puydt: A Selection

Thumbnail patreon.com
8 Upvotes

r/mutualism • • Oct 14 '26

How have egoists interpreted mutualism?

9 Upvotes

I know that historically, especially in the American tradition, many mutualists have incorporated egoism into their ideas. But, looking through some of the work of Proudhon especially, he seems to appeal to "fixed ideas" like justice and liberty quite a lot. Is that more of using terminology that is useful, or was that intended to have a specifically moral dimension? I'm much more interested in a more "Proudhon-ian" construction of mutualism for context, although I acknowledge that people like Benjamin Tucker are an example of what I'm asking.


r/mutualism • • Oct 09 '26

My friends thing about mutualism

Thumbnail
tiktok.com
5 Upvotes

r/mutualism • • Oct 01 '26

Are there any mutualists that join anarchist group stupid question I know

6 Upvotes

Mutualism has a gradual form of revolution and are many mutualists in any anarchist groups with other types of anarchists?idk man stupid question I know


r/mutualism • • Sep 28 '26

I want to recommend Gary Chartier as someone to potentially read

10 Upvotes

One of the biggest frustrations I have with some anarchist writers is their lack of specifics when it comes to their theories of justice. It doesn’t need to be (and shouldn’t be) prescriptive, but there should be specific methods and ideas for how to conduct justice anarchically.

The same goes for planning economies and/or doing markets anarchically. It can’t simply be written off as “communities will figure it out,” because that can result in virtually anything and doesn’t necessarily equate to anarchism. Specific methods and ideas that people can adopt, experiment with, and build upon are paramount to actually creating and learning how to do anything. I'm sure there are many anarchists that have written specifics, but I'm still fairly new in my readings. I'm not sure that I'm an anarchist but I am a fan of many anarchist ideas.

Overall this is why I want to recommend Gary Chartier. He's a market anarchist, and has, in my opinion, one of the best and most comprehensive theories of anarchist arbitration. I could also make actions post about it, though it would be extremely long.

Even if you disagree with him completely, you won't find yourself having to fill in any blanks yourself about how his theory would work in practice, regardless of what you think about his ideas.


r/mutualism • • Sep 27 '26

Who’s Useful for mutualism?

8 Upvotes

So I was wondering outside of Proudhon works,
Who else’s would be useful To help develop mutualism?


r/mutualism • • Sep 26 '26

How exactly do you understand alegality vs necessary structures/institution arrangements around questions of allocation and access/control over resources?

4 Upvotes

Ok, so that title sounds quite of confusingly worded.

What I'm trying to get at is, what amounts to a "legal order" and how should we understand what makes certain institutional arrangements "governmentalist" and others not?

So, like, every (so far existing) society generally has some sort of institutional structure/rules around access to scarce or common resources right?

It is socially necessary to have some for of regulation of the usage of the commons and scarce resources in order for a social order to utilize them. This doesn't necessairly require mediation through formal state institutions (Elinor Ostrom wasn't a mutualist or anything, but has written quite a lot on the topic of self-governing commons institutions in fascinating ways), though in many societies it has an can.

These institutional arrangements are binding, even when not enforced by the state, as they have to be in order to effectively regulate access.

That, to me, sounds legalistic, at least in the sort of libertarian/mutualist understanding of the word. Even the more ostromite self-governing commons relations have binding rules to ensure that the commons is preserved long term and so are arguably governmentalist.

So, what I'm trying to better understand here is, what makes a "legal order" governmentalist per se? My guess is the binding nature of these institutions (even the non-state Ostromite institutions).

So what would an alegal institutional arrangement for commons access or scarce resource allocation look like if not binding? If the "binding" part is not the distinguishing factor that makes certain arrangements governmentalist as opposed to others, what is?


r/mutualism • • Sep 19 '26

William Batchelder Greene pays a visit to P.-J. Proudhon

Thumbnail
libertarian-labyrinth.org
15 Upvotes

r/mutualism • • Sep 16 '26

Proudhon's Explanation of Interest pre-Capitalism

4 Upvotes

From my notes reading the third study of Justice:

In ancient times, the loan at interest was universally condemned. Although, interest was required to induce Capitalists to lend which was highly beneficial for economies. Proudhon argues that in the past, "in the conditions of inorganic and individualistic economy in which the old society lived", interest was needed, but not anymore. "… the Church plays with misfortune: she prohibits lending at interest when the world needs it most and when there is no possibility of free lending; she authorizes it when we can do without it"

I believe he makes a similar point in his debate with Bastiat.

"I repeat then, – and, on my honor, I think I speak clearly, – yes, Lending at Interest was once legitimate, when the democratic centralization of credit and circulation was impossible; it is so no longer, now that this centralization has become a necessity of the age, consequently a duty of society and a right of the citizen. That is why I raise my voice against Usury; I say that Society Owes Me Credit and Discount without Interest: Interest I call ROBBERY."

Does Proudhon expand anywhere on what exactly the "inorganic" and "individualistic" economy looked like, and how that was inimicable to zero-interest credit?

My best guess is that in the feudal economies, the circulating media were commodity money and not banknotes. The political institutions were perhaps not developed--"centralized"--enough to supply banknotes for circulation. Therefore, to obtain money, interest was necessary to induce lending of silver or gold.

Although, I don't see why a mutual banking association would be impossible to set up in and of itself (except that all businesses required permission from the State).


r/mutualism • • Sep 11 '26

What is the relationship between Fourier and Proudhon? Can understanding Fourier help us understand Proudhon's work?

14 Upvotes

I wonder if Fourier is analogous to Hegel in the position he has with respect to Proudhon (i.e. the same sort of relationship Marx has with Hegel). Similarly, I wonder if Proudhon's organizational proposals or aims are informed by that of Fourier's.


r/mutualism • • Sep 09 '26

Help me understand Kevin Carson's idea of the "Partner State"?

11 Upvotes

The conception of the Partner State shows up multiple times in Carson's work, such as *The Desktop Regulatory State* where he quotes Michael Bauwens:

"First of all, these communities are not democracies. Why is that so? Because democracy, the market and hierarchies are all modes of allocation of scarce resources. In hierarchy, our superiors decide; in the market, prices decide; in a democracy, “we” decide.

But where resources are abundant, as they are with knowledge, code and design— which can be copied and shared at a marginal cost—they are truly unnecessary. These types of communities are truly poly-archies and the type of power that is held in them is meritocratic, distributed and ad hoc. Everyone can contribute without permission, but those with recognised expertise who are accepted by the community—the socalled “maintainers” and the “editors”—decide which software or design patches are acceptable.

These decisions require expertise, not communal consensus. The tension between inclusive participation and selection for excellence is one that every social system faces, and that peer production has solved in a rather elegant way. The genius of the solution is not that it avoids conflict, but that it designs away unnecessary conflict by allowing for the maximum human freedom compatible with the goal of co-operation. Indeed, peer production is always an “object-oriented” co-operation, and it is the particular object that will drive the particular form chosen for its peer governance mechanisms.

The main allocation mechanism in such projects is a “distribution of tasks”. Unlike in the industrial model, there is no longer a division of labour between jobs and mutual coordination. Because the work environment is designed to be totally open and transparent, every participating individual can see what is needed, and decide accordingly whether to contribute. Remarkably, this new model allows for both global coordination and for small-group dynamics. And it does this without “command and control”!"

It isn't clear to me exactly how this would work in practice. There seem to be some concerning terms used here, such as *meritocratic*. My question is, would such a system really survive a consistent critique of authority?


r/mutualism • • Sep 03 '26

New Proudhon Library: Journalism from "Le Peuple" (1849) (pdf)

Thumbnail libertarian-labyrinth.org
13 Upvotes

r/mutualism • • Sep 03 '26

What is your response to this criticism of market anarchism from an anarcho-communist?

11 Upvotes

I was discussing market anarchism with an anarcho communist, and they told me the following.

They said that in their opinion market anarchism is an oxymoron. Because they said in order to keep monopolies from forming, you would need heavy state regulation, and that it would "be a constant arms race of regulation and corruption and eventually end up with most of the same problems of capitalism."

They also said if a system is using money, then it is using a transferable store of wealth. And that inherently makes it easily concentrated and incentivizes people to concentrate it.

In defense of communist planning as a superior method, they said direct communication, as opposed to markets, gives far more nuance and accuracy than supply and demand market signals.

I also mentioned non-profit markets, and they said there is no monetary system that doesn't end up being for profit. And that in order for non profit markets to work, there would need to be a centralized authority.

I gave my own responses, but I'm curious what other market anarchists say to these objections raised to me. Thank you.


r/mutualism • • Aug 26 '26

The Biggest Theft In History (Andrewism)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
25 Upvotes

r/mutualism • • Aug 25 '26

Occupancy-and-Use vs. Technology

9 Upvotes

A question I am thinking over at the moment is this: Does technological innovation make occupancy-and-use norms increasingly untenable for an equitable society?

As technology develops, it becomes increasingly easier to cultivate and use large swaths of land by less people. "Occupying" or "using" can become more and more indirect. If there is not some sort of counterbalance, then it seems as if it would lead to an increasing suffocation of the commons, meaning a privilege for the land-holders against any newcomers.

Proudhon seems to mention this as a concern for taking occupancy as a basis for property:

"I maintain that the element of time must be considered also; for if the first occupants have occupied every thing, what are the newcomers to do? What will become of them, having an instrument with which to work, but no material to work upon? Must they devour each other?"

A specific issue I am thinking of is the worsening of rent. Obviously, under occupancy-and-use, there is no person accumulating rents from owning land that people occupy and use, but if the swathes of land people can occupy and use enlarges, then the differences in land quality will exacerbate the differences in wealth that can be obtained through labor.

If I recall correctly, the Individualists did not find the collection of rents by owners who occupy or use a piece of land necessarily just, but the Georgist and Communist alternatives were simply too authoritarian to abandon the many boons of a free-market anti-Capitalist economy. I agree that it is pointless to invite governmentalism to fix this issue, but nevertheless, if technology improves and that leads to a concomitant expansion of the confines of occupancy-and-use, this problem might not be as easy to ignore.

Both of these instances there is a certain break of reciprocity, either between landholders and land-not-holders, and/or between landholders and Nature.

I understand that mutualists do not have a single theory of property, but occupancy-and-use is the most prominent. I am currently halfway through Instead of a Book, so maybe my question will be answered once I trudge through the Land and Rent section (if this is the case, please say so), but I wanted to see what the neo-Proudhonians might have to say, as I have not yet engaged with Proudhon's later works on property.

  1. Am I correct in my argument?

  2. Does the Proudhonian approach offer a "fix" to this sort of issue?