r/mutualism • u/[deleted] • Mar 02 '22
r/mutualism • u/ExternalGreen6826 • Oct 01 '25
Marxism
Are any Màrxìšt’s in the broad Màrxìšt canon (Council communism to Autonomism to Neo Marxism to Leninism/ Marxism Leninism) etc useful for Mutualists? Even as just a context for certain debates, ideas or critiques?
r/mutualism • u/Pyropeace • Sep 23 '22
Preventing the pitfalls of ancap in a market socialist anarchist society?
My inquiries about mutualism seem to imply that, basically, mutualism is ancap with worker cooperatives. This is intriguing to me, but I worry that without some sort of regulating body and social safety net, this system would simply be a rehash of anarcho-capitalism. So, aside from an unrealistically massive culture and value change (which could theoretically be applied to any system to make it utopian), what can be done to prevent worker cooperatives in an anarchist society from making their own rules and committing the same abuses of power that typical corporations do?
r/mutualism • u/agora3 • Feb 13 '18
Stuff You hate about Communism and stuff you hate About Capitalism.
Capitalism: Usury. Outsourcing of work. exploitation of Foreign and Local workers. Consumerism. commodity Fetishism. coercion.
Communism: Lack of Individuality. exploitation of Workers. Leveling "Mediocrity with Excellence". State Control (statist commies only). Feminism. Abolishment of Currency (as if This would ever work"). Coercion
r/mutualism • u/[deleted] • Dec 30 '24
What is the difference between yalls free-market anarchy and our anarchy? (I'm an AnCap)
I get yall don't really like capitalism, and I'm sure you are not a big fan of us, but what is the difference between a mutualist vision of free markets, and an AnCaps? I know that yall think property is theft, but what exactly do you not like about it? And are there any other real distinction? I would like to ask what yall think of us AnCap but I'll think I'll find out based of the votes...
r/mutualism • u/Hot_Organization157 • Mar 18 '26
What's the problem mutualists see with using some form of a government (creating a transitional government, or taking over one that exists) to create anarchy?
r/mutualism • u/cuddly_boi6 • Mar 02 '22
owning business.
In mutualism will I own the place of work if I buy it or is it communal and how much freedom do I have in terms as the owner is it the same? I'm new to this.
r/mutualism • u/Tim541 • Nov 24 '20
Who will the owner of a company in Mutualist society?
So, suppose I establish a company, which makes cars. I invested my own money into jt. Spent a lot of time, lot of years into developing the R&D, the prototypes, and the strategy to enter the market. Now, my company is running good. I'm getting more demand than ever before. So I decide to hire a few more people to work for me. So do I have to share my profit equally with them in Mutualist society ?
That I am.
I am paying them well.
They're happy.
Content.
I still am making 100x than them. If still I have to share my profit with them as according to the roles. Will it be fair in Mutualist society ? Do I have to share profit along their salary as well ?
r/mutualism • u/zburgz666 • Aug 31 '16
[x-post] Should anarchists be preparing for Mars colonization?
r/mutualism • u/anti-consumeproudhon • May 26 '18
Mutualism as social democracy.
Would mutualism be considerd "Democratic socialism" , personally not a fan of welfare but then again social democracy holds posistions of both market and communal economics, generally speaking i cant stand sanders supporters or any other electoral politicians or politicians in general or democracy beyond the individual's own free will. What do you guys think?
r/mutualism • u/[deleted] • Jul 19 '16
Why does /r/Libertarian link /r/mutualism in their sidebar as belonging to their ideology? topkek
They post this sub right on their sidebar right by the "anarcho"-capitalist sub.
r/mutualism • u/HogeyeBill • Nov 30 '17
An Anarchist may or may not be a Socialist
"A Socialist may or may not be an Anarchist, and an Anarchist may or may not be a Socialist. Relaxing scientific exactness, it may be said, briefly and broadly, that Socialism is a battle with usury and that Anarchism is a battle with authority. The two armies — Socialism and Anarchism — are neither coextensive nor exclusive; but they overlap." - Benjamin Tucker, “Armies that Overlap” http://fair-use.org/benjamin-tucker/instead-of-a-book/armies-that-overlap#e120p10
r/mutualism • u/subsidiarity • Nov 23 '21
CMV: mutualists are the grillers of the anarchist community
'Grillers' are the people that 'just want to grill'. They don't involve themselves in matters of society and politics. Grillers bbq in their back yard and let politics and society do what it will. They are often equated to political moderates but I see a distinction. A moderate could have a strong conviction for moderation and so would not be a griller. A Nazi could have a very weak conviction for Naziism and would be a griller.
Mutualists, like grillers, have very weak convictions about how institutions will work. When asked about how property and dispute resolution will work they respond, 'However the community decides (I just want to grill)'.
CMV
Cheers
r/mutualism • u/LemonadeSauce3 • Mar 26 '21
New meme sub /r/fullmutualism
repost cuz i said wrong sub last time
r/mutualism • u/Afraid_Joke2603 • Aug 29 '24
How is (my) left rothabardianism different from mutualism?
Hi!
I am a left-rothbardian, that is I'm anarchist supporting what ancaps call capitalism is and what you may call comercialism. I think of myself as close to mutualism and I want your opinion if you agree.
I think that without state intervention society would be more egalitarian and monopolies would stop existing, I also believe that in such free market society worker cooperatives and mutual aid unions would be more popular, as well as more people would be self employed artistans and small entrepreneurs.
I believe in right to natural law, Non agression Principle and natural right to self-ownership, which is why right to own property should be universal and for all, based Neo-Lockean property theory. I'm also pro profit and anti socialist/marxist class struggle, and instead I believe in agorist class theory based on divide of statist society in two classes: one taking advantage of state and one being exploited, so the previous one may get richer and stronger.
Apart from that, I think that gold based currency is best as it will lead to no inflation.
What do you think? I will answer questions if necessary, but I do not want to debate.
r/mutualism • u/Nezaus • Jun 26 '16
Lauren Southern ATTACKED by Anarchist FarLeftist thugs in London!
r/mutualism • u/Unique_Confidence_60 • May 31 '26
What stops people from hoarding money
Under mutualism, what stops a mutual bank from just deciding they're going to give themselves a massive amount of money? What stops a coop from deciding to make a profit instead of just selling at cost? What stops companies from just failing and big ones expanding and potentially developing into capitalism again?
r/mutualism • u/[deleted] • May 27 '17
Is Individualist anarchism a small business friendly, small scale Ancap theory
I keep looking for an ancap ideology that has competition, but in small business only form - lots of small businesses competing in a fast paced thriving economy, no corporations. After looking at all the ancap associated writers, I can't find anything like this. The closest is Konklin's Agorism, but I feel that might end up being something whose members shift to the right or into more right-libertarian territory. So I guess my question is, in economics, does individualist anarchism adhere to something like what I am saying, ancap but smaller scale...
another question, the american individualist anarchists have a lot of market thought and economics, but europeans have had philosophy, egoism, nihilism, illegalism instead. Was there ever a softer version of individualist anarchism in europe, that was market and economics oriented, like Tucker et al?
Another question, am I right in saying that at the present moment, many people labeling themselves as individualist anarchist would be pro-market, pro-money, and pro wage in a small firm only setting? Like if they say they are into this, I can guess they take these positions?
r/mutualism • u/enesra • Feb 24 '18
What is a mutualist definition of the word "capitalism"?
Describe me a human being movement that you describe "capitalist". Let's begin with this. Than I'll ask some more questions. Maybe also define "property" for me.
r/mutualism • u/ExternalGreen6826 • Sep 17 '25
Can anarchists focuses of Hierarchy and Authority be applied to topics like veganism and relationship anarchy
Are philosophies like veganism and relationship “anarchy” inherently anarchist concerns and does anarchist concepts of hierarchy apt to describe human animal relationships and “hierarchical” relationship styles such as monogamy or “hierarchical polyamory”
There are a lot of anarchists who practice both, I’m sympathetic to both as a vegetarian and someone who is interested relationship anarchy
I’ve heard people apply concepts such as property to both human animal relations as well as between people with even hierarchical polyamory being described as a kind of “power relation” with the primary having decision making power over the secondaries
Iim not sure I agree that monogamy is inherently authoritarian but I would love to hear anarchist opinions on both these topics?
r/mutualism • u/ExternalGreen6826 • Jan 31 '26
Any Right Libertarian Thinkers that are Useful?
I just bought a book from Frederic Bastiat on “The Law” from cursory knowledge he had a bit of a spat with Proudhon about interest? And a “past” ancap friend of mine recommended him to me. Other thinkers that interest me for both knowledge and critique are David Huemer, Rothbard, Mises (I know the last teal had reactionary ideas but I still want to know from the source) and Auberon Herbert, Hayek and De Molinari (I think he’s a proto right libertarian)
I have seen left wing market anarchists utilise Hayek, Rothbard and even Mises and I know of “Agorism” by Samuel Konkin III but his class theory confuses me and both ancaps and market anarchists claim him, similiar to spooner, I may ask a separate question/post on what is “left Rothbardianism” to save the time because I’ve never got a satisfactory answer
But either way is it useful to engage with classical liberals/anti state capitalists/ “Voluntaryists,” and Minarchists?
r/mutualism • u/[deleted] • Feb 14 '17
Orange and Black mutualist bicolor flag angers traditional anarchists. Green variant replacement?
talking about colors is a waste of time, but here: No anarchist wants to see their beloved spanish flag slowly morph into an ancap flag, but mutualism contains some market elements maybe, so how do you show it without pissing people off? I may have a solution in: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_colour#Green I see 4 social democrat parties, all the green parties, levellers, medical marijuana, agrarians, nordic agrarians (sweet btw look at norway's) and you have the 'greens' in the russian revolution. In addition to being the Green Parties, a shade of green could easily be a code for a kind of limited low scale coop market Economy, like in economics view only. It might suck in all the moderate environmentalist nonviolent hippies that are at the periphery of the anarchist movement, maybe even some liberals. You just have to distinguish it in shade from the green and black bicolor that you see from the people that have that ideology that would never work (luddites) that are already around.
r/mutualism • u/davavino • 8d ago
Ive been reading a lot about mutualism today, and Ive accumulated some questions about it
How is my original labour and investment protected? If I put a bunch of previous work into a project and once it’s successful I bring on more people to help, am I just getting a equal share even though Ive put all that previous work into the project? Or am I compensated by the new workers so we all have an equal share?
For example:
If I fund and build a series of escape rooms, then let others operate it while I pursue another project, what rights do I retain? Am I still entitled to profit off of it?
If everyone agrees beforehand that I can return or repurpose the land, would that agreement be upheld?