r/mtgfinance • • 6h ago

Weekend Wrap Up! What was real and what was a trap?

25 Upvotes

What happened over the weekend and what do you think about it? Was it just hype? What if it's a real change? What do you think will happen going forward? Also feel free to use this space to discuss anything MTG Finance related.


r/mtgfinance • • 1h ago

Star Trek Collectors Box experience - Collation Issues?

Post image
35 Upvotes

8/12 packs the same bulk rare Branching Timeline in the foil rare/mythic slot. Ruined the entire experience of opening the box after a few packs. The remainder seemed to be collated normally. I contacted customer service and they sent a form letter thanking me for my feedback. Because of course they did.

Anybody else experience something similar?


r/mtgfinance • • 9h ago

Discussion Great Whale for Nauctis

Thumbnail
gallery
74 Upvotes

[[Great Whale]] is currently a card that ranges in price from roughly $16-29 depending on condition. It is, of course, a Reserved List card, and it has a very functional line of text (pay 7 to cast it, untap seven lands in etb). As with many Reserved List cards that are any sort of usable, they pretty easily spike when new releases put a spotlight on them.

All of this to get to the fact the recently leaked commanders for the Sultai Nauctis Precon reference a new batch called Sea Monster. It includes all the typical Sea Creature types (Kraken, Leviathan, Octopus, and Serpent) as well as Whale, likely to be able to include the Nauctis God Whales in the fun. This also means that Great Whale suddenly comes into the spotlight as an interesting pick up not just for the precon, but for the set as a whole since its very possible that Sea Monster is a batching used in Nauctis in general.

Furthermore, while this mainly applies to Great Whale as a notable spotlight, any other viable Whale suddenly gets some notice put on it since they are now joining the Sea Creature club and a precon dedicated to such a strategy is releasing.


r/mtgfinance • • 14h ago

Discussion MagicCon Atlanta attendee financial discussion

87 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I've done a series of posts about selling as cons, but I am by no means a large enough vendor to sell at magic con. I went to have fun with friends but still also kept my nose out for deals, freebies, and other financial incentives that are available at the con. I'll list out individual deals/gets/specs and then a more narrative back half of the post.

Deal 1: The most obvious "get" for this con was the festival in a box. They are edging up to $500 already and we're going for $250 plus tax at the con. To make an attempt at limiting people hoarding these they limited them to one per badge, as tracked by hole punching the badge. The official store line was super long, 5+ hours long most days. My partner and I waited one hour in line around the middle of the day to grab two and we barely got them before today's sell out at 1:30 or so. They put out 5000 each day and it sold out each day. They also had other product at MSRP.

Deal 2: Dragon shield con exclusive products. The con exclusive sleeves from last year go for roughly $100, these will likely be the same in a year. They cost $25 each, are in seemingly endless supply during the con so you're not a dick for buying a shit load. They are a very easy get at every con. The 5 mox playmat was $80 and is going for $300+ on eBay. It'll be at every Magiccon this next year but will only be at magiccon. You have to be in line very early to get the playmat.

Deal 3: Free promos and pins. Every time you took a photo with the Star Trek transporter and command deck you got a Borg queen promo that is currently $20ish. I took several photos on my own, with friends, and with my partner. I have about 30 of the promo Borg queen. Last year you could get unlimited spiderman intro decks that had a couple of $20 cards each.

For pins they have several free pins that are con exclusive and last years have all appreciated over the last year for last year's con. We also got several free playmates and such.

Deal 4: Bulk bins. You won't find crazy stuff but it's not uncommon to find $3-$5 cards for a buck. I got 65 $1 dark rituals.

Deal 5: Mystery box ticketed play. I did several ticketed play events with mystery box and current card prices are crazy. While I signed up for several events in advance they also had on demand drafts of it going. From a single on demand two headed giant draft my partner and I entered we got over $300 in $5+ singles after we rare drafted it. We then used the tickets from that event to get 3 hobbit box toppers and a hobbit collector booster. Do not sleep on ticketed play for future events with mystery booster 3, the new cards add a lot of value even compared to the strong mystery booster 2.

Pitfall: Most singles were at best market, but mostly overpriced especially on the lower end outside of bulk bins. Several vendors claimed merch was "con exclusive" when it wasn't and it just had at best a Magiccon ATL stamp.

Thoughts: There is a lot of financial upside for attendees, I'm sure far more than my partner and I found. I wouldn't make the financial aspect the main point of attendance but we were able to defray the cost of event entry and badge cost while still largely just having a fun time. We're going to have a lot of fun drafting mystery commander with friends back home. Overall the con was a ton of fun and I'll be doing Detroit this year. I would also do Vegas but it's the same weekend as Anime New York which I can't justify skipping.

Edit: A lot of people seem to think I spent all day worrying about money/buying stuff. These were just my observations. A lot of my profit is coming from commander mystery box play. My worst value draft deck was worth over $100 and I had several draft piles over $200. Prize tix on top meant hobbit box toppers and collector boosters for free essentially. I don't consider taking profit from money pulls that I don't want to be work, they covered the cost of the events and I left with a ton of cool stuff still. I was still able to win most games even when rare drafting new cards I didn't need for my pull.

I personally wouldn't burn a huge chunk of con time going after a FiAB. About one hour of wait was my partner and I's "worth it" number. We will be drafting ours with friends.

I did spend 2 hours waiting to get the 5 mox mat, which covered my badge and then some. That is the only thing I did that deviated from what I would do for fun. Was worth it to me.

While the average attendee won't "make money" it's easy enough to do ticketed play essentially for free if you're decent at magic and to cover your badge cost via promos or a bit of line waiting for one more desirable item. This makes attending easy if you can minimize travel costs. I.e. Circus Circus in Vegas is close to the hall and $50 a night. Round trip flights with allegiant are $170 with a carry on bag for me. Vegas in particular will be very cheap to attend this year.


r/mtgfinance • • 1h ago

Cracking packs to chase the signed headliners? Check how much it will cost you.

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Wanna chase the signed headliners but have no money? Maybe see how much hypothetical money you would lose before you open a signed Captain Picard?

We just added Star Trek to our Booster Simulator (https://www.arcane-assets.com).

It’s a free tool that replicates the fun of opening MTG packs online. You’ll see not only your pulls, but also stats like EV (current and historical), percentiles, and basic price data.

No real money involved. Just the thrill of pack opening.

In addition to the Booster Simulator, we have two big features on the site:

  • Collection tracking: you can create an account and keep track of all the cards you open. You can explore your Collection, see how far along you got on each set and the cards you are missing. This feature is completely optional: you can keep simulating boosters as always without the need of an account.

  • Booster Explorer: this is a complementary tool that allow users to browse the slot composition and card pool of Play and Collector Boosters, to understand what cards can show up in each slot and at which frequency.

We hope the community enjoy it, please share any feedback you have, good or bad!


r/mtgfinance • • 22h ago

Someone spent over $4000 on APAC lands at CK, 20% of their inventory sold in one go

Post image
88 Upvotes

r/mtgfinance • • 19h ago

Question The Nauctis Secret Lair Bundle was a really good deal and I totally missed it (on Amazon)....

52 Upvotes

So the pre-order was up on Amazon for about a day and sold out. Somehow the words "Secret Lair" and "Bundle" turned me off (???), and I didn't do the math. So here's the fomo for anyone in my shoes:

Secret Lair Bundle: $89.99 (it was in fact $89.99 for pre-order on Amazon)

2 Collector Boosters: Value $53.98 (@ $26.99 each, they'll certainly be more at launch)

6 Booster Packs: Value $32.96 (@ $5.49 each)

This is already $86.92 of value

Still to calculate: 20 full art lands, 2 mythic Secret Lair cards - so free basically. And a spin down counter...

(As someone new to MTG pre-orders) Is there any chance it will be available again for $89.99?


r/mtgfinance • • 1m ago

PSA 10 MBA Gold Diamond Serialized Chocobo sells for $1.4 million

1 Upvotes

A PSA 10 MBA Gold Diamond Serialized Chocobo sold for $1,400,000 USD according to Collectr on Instagram today.

Chocobo 47/77

Insta link: https://www.instagram.com/p/DfzycdwJJBL/?xtok=MWZmdzN5aHBkamttdQ==

Imgur link for those without instagram: https://i.imgur.com/0nZP1WU.jpeg


r/mtgfinance • • 1d ago

Currently Spiking Captain James T. Kirk spiking heavily

24 Upvotes

Looks like he's slotting into [[The Naked Time]] decks and went from around 3.50$ to a low of 9.36$ and a high of 29.99$

If you can pick him up for less than 5$, I'd do it now


r/mtgfinance • • 1d ago

Discussion Damn Trek is that bad huh? Free pack coming Nov 21 GameStop with a “mystery” promo too.

Post image
130 Upvotes

Bold strategy from Gamescalp if you can’t sell it just give it away. In all seriousness in case you have a GS nearby and want a promo figured I’d let others know kind of curious what those promos are going to be ohh and a free trek pack I guess. Still can’t believe sub 100 play boxes day 1 lol is this the worst received UB set ever did even SPM crash this fast?


r/mtgfinance • • 35m ago

Discussion What am I missing with Hobbit Collector Boxes?

0 Upvotes

Aren't these a steal at 500$ for long term? Or is there something specific about the set that turns you off even at that price?

Asking cuz to me it seems like a no brainer.


r/mtgfinance • • 21h ago

Question TCGPlayer Mass Price not working for new sets and inventory

Post image
3 Upvotes

How is everyone using mass price for new sets and new cards that are not in your inventory yet? I have noticed that it is random and can take a couple of hours or a few days for new sets/cards to be recognized by the mass price.

For example have been running star trek since thursday night and still not available in the mass price. So the prices are stuck at the market at the time I uploaded the CSV and when I run mass price that star trek isn't being updated to reflect current market and my floor isn't set. Typically I would hide my inventory when adding cards and wait the night until the next day, but this obviously isn't ideal with new sets and getting the sales first weekend. (and it's sunday still not available in the mass price)

Also happens when I run other cards that are not in my inventory yet.


r/mtgfinance • • 7h ago

Discussion Star Trek Play Booster Box in launch week: 121 US shops, from US$90 to US$209.70 (chart)

Post image
0 Upvotes

I made a free site that tracks Magic sealed prices across independent shops, and I charted every US shop with a Star Trek Play Booster Box in stock this week.

• 121 US shops have it in stock • Cheapest US$90.00, median US$139.99, dearest US$209.70 • TCGplayer's lowest listing is US$102.00, and only 7 of the 121 shops are at or under it • The biggest group (23 shops) sits between US$120 and US$130

Canada has 90 shops in stock, C$130.99 to C$279.99. The UK has 21, £119.94 to £209.70.

Prices are before shipping, in stock only, each shop in its own currency.

Full list: https://mtgcompare.app/us/p/star-trek-play-booster-box?utm_source=reddit

What shop am I missing? And if a listing looks wrong (wrong product, wrong language), tell me and I'll fix it.


r/mtgfinance • • 8h ago

Zeta set reprint popularity

0 Upvotes

How popular do you expect the zeta set reprint to be? I've seen next to no speculation/hype on this since the announcement, but it could pick up now that the cards are arriving in people's hands.

I think there's a chance it won't be popular at all, and the limited print run was a lot of the appeal for some people. It selling out so quickly will have soured people too.

Genuinely don't know which way it'll go!


r/mtgfinance • • 2d ago

Scalpers looking at hobbit and Star Trek CBBs right now

Post image
659 Upvotes

r/mtgfinance • • 11h ago

Selling everything?

0 Upvotes

I own ALOT of mtg cards. Cards in the $200 range that I personally have pulled as well as cards I have been gifted or bought in bulk over the years. I'd say conservatively I have around 7k in mtg cards. I love the game. But recent negative experiences have lead me to think I should sell off my collections and proxy the cards I wanna play. I know there is a "pride in ownerahip" aspect. But i am losing my desire to purchase new products because of price increases. As well money is very tight. I am looking for advice and honestly some.motivation to reignite the love for the game. Any opinions?


r/mtgfinance • • 12h ago

How to value damaged cards?

0 Upvotes

Just curious for a little guidance. Obviously can use TCGplayer for comps, but damage can range drastically... I'm looking at picking up two damaged expedition fetchlands for about $100 total, one is in good shape except for having a corner that's worn, and the foil is slightly peeling at that corner, the other has overall pretty major edgewear but is fine in a sleeve.

Quick google searches say like 20-30% of NM value, but TCGplayer sales are substantially higher. Just curious if people generally have thoughts on damaged cards, how to properly evaluate, or other advice. Thanks!


r/mtgfinance • • 7h ago

33 of 35 Star Trek cards over $50 dropped after release

Post image
0 Upvotes

Preorder median (Nov 6–9) vs. release weekend (Nov 14–15), Near Mint. H.M.S. Bounty was the only one that went up.


r/mtgfinance • • 12h ago

He-Man Secret Lairs

0 Upvotes

Hey all, I could use some insight from the community on this one. I thought the he-man lairs were pretty hyped and mostly sold out quickly but it looks like prices for some of them are now below even the initial sale price. Do you think it’s lack of interest in the IP? Overprinting? General wallet fatigue?

It’s cool to see them available for a reasonable price but since the price behavior isn’t what I expected it makes me wary of them.


r/mtgfinance • • 1d ago

Discussion Nauctis Commander specs

Post image
83 Upvotes

Anyone have any interesting specs for the Nauctis Commander decks? I'm trying to think of merfolk cards specifically that are less likely to be reprinted.

Sygg, River Guide, and Sygg's Command are unlikely to be reprinted right?

Namor the Sub-mariner won't get a reprint and goes well with go wide merfolk

Deepway Navigator could be helpful for untapping merfolk since the deck sounds like it'll have a lot of tapping effects. Not the greatest.

Merrow Commerce could be great, but could be reprinted and is already pricey.

Deeproot Pilgrimage would also be great, but could be reprinted.

Judge of the Currents is a bit random with life gain, but it's a merfolk tap synergy and is cheap

Adrix and Nev, Twincasters would be great. It sounds like the deck makes merfolk tokens and a merfolk token doubler would fit right in.

Thoughts?


r/mtgfinance • • 23h ago

Spec Is now the time to buy Zeta Set singles?

0 Upvotes

Not traditional speculation as I'm not really looking to resell. I love the zeta set art, and would love to make a themed commander deck using only zeta set basics, and as many zeta set cards as possible.

I've never tried to buy a new secret lair/set like this before, so I'm curious if typically now is the cheapest it'll be (at least until reprints late next year), or if prices will start going down as more sealed stuff is opened. Thoughts?


r/mtgfinance • • 2d ago

Star Trek; CBB $399.99 at Amazon Already

88 Upvotes

Big retailers must already see the writing on the wall with this one. Not sure I can remember a time where they cut the price this quickly.

Amazon.com: Magic: The Gathering | Star Trek Collector Booster Box : Toys & Games


r/mtgfinance • • 2d ago

Hobbit Book Covers @ Bottom?

17 Upvotes

Tried to search for this and really couldn’t find anything definitive so figured I’d ask. Does it look like the Book Covers have hit their bottom (or as close as it’s going to get) or do we think they could slide a little further? Most of the surge foils are, by choice, out of my price range, but The Lord of the Eagles is fairly close to what I would consider reasonable, so that’s my best chance of grabbing at least one cover in Surge.

I was lucky enough to stumble into some decent prices for non-foil versions, but even at that, the more popular ones are still just a hair out of my range. I’d hate to drag my feet too long and see them start to tick up.

I was really looking forward to this set and went in hard, only to be disappointed with my 12 copies of Gigantic Big Bear so I’ve got a little ptsd at the idea of investing any more money into it than what’s necessary.

Thanks in advance for any feedback!


r/mtgfinance • • 22h ago

Question Mystery Booster Commander Edition

0 Upvotes

Is this product going to stay at its double-MSRP price tag online? I want to get a single box to draft with my friends for my birthday, but the price seems insane.

Are there any upcoming ways to get a box closer to $200? If this is the wrong sub to ask, sorry!

Edit: I thought the box was $200 and the promos made it $250! Oops