r/mtgfinance • u/Eastern-Parfait6852 • Dec 18 '23
The reserve list is the key to mtg long term health.
This is going to be super unpopular, but Im going to say it. In order for mtg to survive in the long run, Wizards is going to need to expand the reserve list and add new cards to it
Ive been with the game for...awhile. Before chronicles. I saw what happened the first time they printed cards into oblivion, and I saw what happened when the voices of the mtg community howled against the reserve list won out.
The biggest lie by the anti-reserve list voices is that free printing of old staples would cause some kind of mtg renaissance. Holders would gladly see their thousand dollar collections cut in half if it meant more people played. The promise of that happening just isnt true, nor could it ever be true.
When legends, AQ, dark and AN were reprinted en masse, coinciding also with a massive reprinting in 4th ed in 1995, the last thing that happened was some kind of Renaissance that spurred people to buy more. The game almost died.
LGSes saw the value of their inventory crash, players like myself, bought up a bunch of chronicles and...we got bored. Things like guardian beast, aladdin, the elder dragons were no longer a mysterious awesome card. They were just toys...like any other toy you move on from. The allure was gone. The mystery was gone. And in a busy world, that means the trend will be for nobody to give af.
I made a prediction on mtgsalv yrs ago when it was a thing:
If and when wizards decided to capitulate to reprints, it would basically mean that the long term trend of ALL modern cards would be down. Everything non reserve list would be a sinking ship. Things would get a 2nd reprint, a 3rd reprint, a 4th reprint. That has now all happened.
Since chronicles, wizards learned one thing too. How to monetize the secondary market.
If a card is worth $100, reprint it and put it in a set. Thats the carrot on the stick to buy new product. What they learned since chronicles was to not overdo it. But this value capture is really at the expense of players.
You see the carrot on the stick 100 dollar card which motivated you to buy the product is just going to be the 80 dollar carrot on the stick to get you to buy a 3rd version or a 4th.
Now wizards is reprinting things and selling direct. They've gone overboard with numerous reprints of everything. Heres the thing. Thats what the mtg community wanted.
Id rather see my collection of _____ go down if it meant cheaper cards and more ppl playing. You got your wish, mtg community, anti reserve list folk. MTG is cheaper than ever. And if its not cheap enough, I assure you wizards and hasbro would love to print more.
So where are the rush of new players that were supposed to join? You know where they are? probably playing a moba somewhere. Nobody gives a shit about mtg. It a game for old ass people.
With wizards foraging from the secondary market with no end in sight, the stakeholders have no reason or incentive to prop the game up or promote it. LGSs feel burned because their inventory has tanked, so they have no reason to buy more, and players who thought they got a deal cause they bought from amazon direct laughed all the way to the bank until the amazon dump happened again...and again.
This vocal part of the mtg community that claimed they would gladly take the hit to their collection if it meant cheaper mtg for all and the health of the game has done so much damage with that false dichotomy. They professed to speak for "players", when in reality, they didnt even speak for their own self interests.
Yes its great that the 200 dollar tarmogoyf you got for 140 is exciting. Until that goyf turns into a 100 dollar card, an 80, a 60, a 40, a 20.... Then it turns out, you dont really guve a crap. You'd rather go fishing. not like goyf is worth much anyway.... Thats human psychology. From Jealousy to Apathy.
Mtg has always been a two sided coin. A CCG. Both are needed for the game. Speculators drive up prices. But they give all MTG holders--players and collectors a stake in mtg. With reprints the trend of all cards is long term down.
Cards that have no hope of ever going up in value means "whats the point of buying?" To play? yeah and then what? If I know Im going to lose money I'll just go play something cheaper then.