r/mtgfinance • • Dec 18 '23

The reserve list is the key to mtg long term health.

0 Upvotes

This is going to be super unpopular, but Im going to say it. In order for mtg to survive in the long run, Wizards is going to need to expand the reserve list and add new cards to it

Ive been with the game for...awhile. Before chronicles. I saw what happened the first time they printed cards into oblivion, and I saw what happened when the voices of the mtg community howled against the reserve list won out.

The biggest lie by the anti-reserve list voices is that free printing of old staples would cause some kind of mtg renaissance. Holders would gladly see their thousand dollar collections cut in half if it meant more people played. The promise of that happening just isnt true, nor could it ever be true.

When legends, AQ, dark and AN were reprinted en masse, coinciding also with a massive reprinting in 4th ed in 1995, the last thing that happened was some kind of Renaissance that spurred people to buy more. The game almost died.

LGSes saw the value of their inventory crash, players like myself, bought up a bunch of chronicles and...we got bored. Things like guardian beast, aladdin, the elder dragons were no longer a mysterious awesome card. They were just toys...like any other toy you move on from. The allure was gone. The mystery was gone. And in a busy world, that means the trend will be for nobody to give af.

I made a prediction on mtgsalv yrs ago when it was a thing:

If and when wizards decided to capitulate to reprints, it would basically mean that the long term trend of ALL modern cards would be down. Everything non reserve list would be a sinking ship. Things would get a 2nd reprint, a 3rd reprint, a 4th reprint. That has now all happened.

Since chronicles, wizards learned one thing too. How to monetize the secondary market.
If a card is worth $100, reprint it and put it in a set. Thats the carrot on the stick to buy new product. What they learned since chronicles was to not overdo it. But this value capture is really at the expense of players.

You see the carrot on the stick 100 dollar card which motivated you to buy the product is just going to be the 80 dollar carrot on the stick to get you to buy a 3rd version or a 4th.

Now wizards is reprinting things and selling direct. They've gone overboard with numerous reprints of everything. Heres the thing. Thats what the mtg community wanted.

Id rather see my collection of _____ go down if it meant cheaper cards and more ppl playing. You got your wish, mtg community, anti reserve list folk. MTG is cheaper than ever. And if its not cheap enough, I assure you wizards and hasbro would love to print more.

So where are the rush of new players that were supposed to join? You know where they are? probably playing a moba somewhere. Nobody gives a shit about mtg. It a game for old ass people.

With wizards foraging from the secondary market with no end in sight, the stakeholders have no reason or incentive to prop the game up or promote it. LGSs feel burned because their inventory has tanked, so they have no reason to buy more, and players who thought they got a deal cause they bought from amazon direct laughed all the way to the bank until the amazon dump happened again...and again.

This vocal part of the mtg community that claimed they would gladly take the hit to their collection if it meant cheaper mtg for all and the health of the game has done so much damage with that false dichotomy. They professed to speak for "players", when in reality, they didnt even speak for their own self interests.

Yes its great that the 200 dollar tarmogoyf you got for 140 is exciting. Until that goyf turns into a 100 dollar card, an 80, a 60, a 40, a 20.... Then it turns out, you dont really guve a crap. You'd rather go fishing. not like goyf is worth much anyway.... Thats human psychology. From Jealousy to Apathy.

Mtg has always been a two sided coin. A CCG. Both are needed for the game. Speculators drive up prices. But they give all MTG holders--players and collectors a stake in mtg. With reprints the trend of all cards is long term down.

Cards that have no hope of ever going up in value means "whats the point of buying?" To play? yeah and then what? If I know Im going to lose money I'll just go play something cheaper then.


r/mtgfinance • • Jan 20 '21

PSA: New batch of counterfeits coming out of Ebay

0 Upvotes

In the past month I've received 3 different cards from 2 different sellers in the Southern NY State area that have been fake. All 3 have come packaged in the same overdone way: each card is double-sleeved, in a new top-loader, in a team bag that has a holographic "security seal". Once you get them out of all that, they're very obviously fake and fail all the standard authenticity tests you'd expect (green dot, light test, rosette, etc.) as well as looking discolored and "waxy".

Just a heads-up that if you recall seeing one of these security seals recently you may want to go back and inspect your cards. Unfortunately, Ebay seems to be removing negative feedback from these sellers for some reason so it may not be super easy to avoid in the first place.


r/mtgfinance • • Mar 31 '26

It's not "Scalpers." It's not "Targeted Buyouts." It's not "Artificial Demand." The game is exploding and most people aren't adjusting to the new normal.

0 Upvotes

I see a lot of old-fashioned thinking on this subreddit on a regular basis, since most of the audience for the niche MTGFinance subreddit tend to be deeply enfranchised players. This group will hype up [[Frenzied Baloth]] or [[Hexing Squelcher]] as the meta-breaker that will finally make Naya Zoo good in Modern again, but it's not 2012.

Similarly, a lot of the ways people talk about MTGFinance here are outdated and outmoded. There has definitely been some "scalper" activity in the game before and now, but in 2026, I believe people are fundamentally underestimating the raw demand this game is experiencing from all angles.

Consider this:

  • LOTR, WH40K, Final Fantasy, and to a lesser extent Marvel, TMNT, and ATLA have brought a high number of new players to this game. Because a lot of these are nostalgia plays, these new players tend to be age 30+.

  • Working adults with full-time jobs and full-time incomes are the DOMINANT demographic of the game.

  • "Lifers" - or deeply enfranchised players who started in the 90's and early 2000's have never been more invested, and are in their prime earning years.

I see people talking about "Judge Foil Sol Ring just got bought out" - no it didn't. A buyout is one person buying all of the copies of something. EVERY old school staple judge foil is up the same amount - Deranged Hermit, Argothian Enchantress, Enlightened Tutor.... they're all up.

"Masterpiece Mox Opal is being artificially inflated!" It's not artificial, literally every masterpiece is exploding.

This is especially annoying when it comes to Secret Lairs. Yes, there are resellers. I don't think it's near as bad as Pokemon or other contemporary examples. I don't think SL buyouts are a complex network of sinister scammers who are buying and reselling on the black market - the total number of any given SL's singles available for purchase have been normal for years. The market isn't flooding with secondhand. When a SL sells out in 1 day, this is ACTUAL DEMAND.

If you see something that isn't exploding when you think it should, wait a week - it will go up. There are millions of new players and hundreds of them are dropping half their paycheck blinging out a new deck this week. A lot of you (and me) are ONE OF THEM.

Time to adjust to the new normal!

Edit: They hated IAMAfortunecookieAMA, for he spoke the truth


r/mtgfinance • • Feb 16 '25

Discussion What happened to Rudy?

3 Upvotes

Pre-2020 Rudy, while sensational, actually gave solid life advice and was genuinely entertaining. But ever since 2020, he's become yet another get rich quick guru, and he's replaced the humor with the same ragebait that every other get rich quick guru uses (always some variation of have fun staying poor, stay mad, keep crying, etc). Not to mention the whole "game pieces" thing he's been doing, i.e; taking aim at people who see TCGs as games. What happened? Why did he change his content from something genuinely unique to just another Andrew Tate clone?


r/mtgfinance • • Mar 20 '23

Discussion The Reserved List contributes to MTG’s collector mythos and helps Wizards keep the game alive

0 Upvotes

While many players would like access to less expensive versions of old cards and many collectors conversely want their old cards to retain value as collectible assets, Wizards has a strong motive for keeping the Reserved List intact: It is an integral part of the game’s “as-CCG” mythos.

Having something incredibly valuable to which to aspire as a collector—no matter how unrealistic that aspiration might be for ordinary people—builds the image that MTG as a whole is a collectible product.

The reality for most people is that the MTG products we interact with are not especially rare or valuable. If Wizards were to do away with the Reserved List, it would obliterate a huge part of the game’s mythos. The myth is, with all the products being steadily released in huge volumes and all the versions of cards in these releases diluting their value at this scale, that MTG is really a CCG anymore.


r/mtgfinance • • Feb 29 '24

Discussion What is the future for MTG?

0 Upvotes

Hasbro is so short sighted that they are actively killing the game. They don’t realize that what sustains a game is not hype but the community and people actually playing the game.

With their terrible policies and pricing against LGS, lack of support for paper magic and standard they are killing the very places that sustain the game. A game that ceases to be played will be a dead game. With their reprinting of everything, nobody really cares to crack boxes anymore. There is nothing exciting to open when everything looks special and is worthless at the same time.

Distributors are not sitting on boxes like they did in the past but instead rejecting returns from stores. They are pushing set after set that is rushed and we are already well past the amount of product fatigue the playerbase can bear.

The only way they are able to generate sales is by bigger and bigger hype through powercreep and things like serialized cards. This isn’t sustainable. People are selling their collections cause they are just done trying to keep up with the game while watching their collections be printed to 0.

They are eroding their margins with paying for external IPs when they had the capability to invest in their own more and create something more engaging that a plot spit out by chatGPT

MTG is a big enough entity now that I don’t see it dying completely in the near future but what does the future look like? I am leaning towards a long period (5-15years) of depression with low interest until either a revival and resurgence or slow decline to irrelevance.


r/mtgfinance • • Aug 27 '22

Wake up babe, the first ever DMU collector booster box opening video just dropped, and dude got hosed hard

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/mtgfinance • • May 27 '17

[Shit Post] So I warned you guys of a Yidris buyout a couple days before it happened and I was repeatedly downvoted.

36 Upvotes

And right now I'm selling copies of Yidris for $9-10 with an average purchase price of $3.75. So suck it.


r/mtgfinance • • Jun 02 '19

I own over 400 Urza’s baubles and will continue to buy more every week until they reach their fair value at $10 each

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/mtgfinance • • Nov 14 '23

Question Can anyone even tell what these cards say? The text is too small for me to read! I wanted to see if there are any staples or decent value cards in here that I should be selling ahead of time/asap!? Thanks in advance!

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/mtgfinance • • Jan 30 '22

Discussion So, assuming Seb McKinnon gets cancelled, what does that mean for cards with his art?

0 Upvotes

So, apparently there is a new storm about Seb McKinnon. Although personally it never ceases to amaze me how fast people in Magic jump on the ‘cancel’bandwagon, fact of the matter is that is probably what is going to happen. This being a finance group, how do we think this will result cards with his art on it, it at all?


r/mtgfinance • • Jun 01 '22

Discussion Double feature is secret goldmine currently.

0 Upvotes

Even commons where the normal and double feature print is 10 cents are 4$+ in foil market average.

Get a foil mythic and even if it's a 2 dollar mythic its 30 dollars in foil. I've opened several boxes and I havent seen a always make your money back product like this since mh2 release. It's insane. Each box was.purchased at 170, each box was 3-400 in cards over a dollar. I dont understand why or how but the product is bananas because someone somewhere is actually buying these singles.


r/mtgfinance • • Dec 14 '20

Thanks to this sub I made 4.57$

0 Upvotes

Hey guys long time lurker here ( March 2020, OGs represent ) and lately really getting my life together and more into the financial side of things. I thought why not combine my love of spending money on a children's card game with my love of MAKING BANK?

I wasn't about to get bamboozled by this "Alpha Investiments" guy on youtube, I'm smart enough to see through the lies and games, so I came here for advice. Turns out it was the right move as I was about to invest 45$ in a playset of standard cards before release, but you guys told me to wait for prices to drop! I couldn't believe what I was reading, it went against everything my gut was screaming: Buy buy buy, this card will triple in price for sure, you're smarter than everyone else, you got this!

But I waited until release and sure enough, against all logic and convention, the price of this card WENT DOWN!!! I quickly scooped up my playset, saving me a fat 4.57$, which is basically like if I had made 4.57$ ( economics is one of my passions ).

What should I invest this 4.57$ in now? Wal-Mart is having a sale on Fidget Spinners, good long-term hold ( 2-5 weeks )?


r/mtgfinance • • Aug 03 '24

I made almost $40,000 selling my card collection and just finished a video explaining how.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/mtgfinance • • Nov 12 '22

Discussion [Meta] We should require a minimum threshold of comment karma in this subreddit to submit a post

0 Upvotes

Over time this sub has gotten more popular which means more posts and discussion. Unfortunately, many of these posts are low quality. This is especially exemplified now by people posting pictures of their serialized cards and asking "is this worth anything?"

In order to increase the average post quality and decrease the work for our volunteer moderation team, I recommend requiring a minimum comment karma threshold on r/mtgfinance in order to submit a post.

Forcing users to engage with the community in the comment section of posts will broaden the number of ideas and perspectives shared in these posts. Additionally, it will teach users new to this subreddit how this forum operates as they spend time in the posts of regular contributors.

Thanks for coming to my Ted Talk


r/mtgfinance • • Oct 14 '20

Conspiracy Commander Legends eBay Leak was intentionally done by WoTC

35 Upvotes

With the looming ban of Omnath, WoTC needed a distraction so that players would talk about the fancy new cards coming in CMR, rather than complaining about the ban. This is a PR 101 stunt; misdirection to get people talking about something else rather than the Omnath ban, and it seems to have worked.

Remember, CMR was originally supposed to be released on November 6th.

The eBay listing went up at exactly 8:30 AM PST; Right when WoTC starts work. This shows indicators that the auction was intentionally set to go live at that time, and was made in advance.

Additionally, the eBay listing was never taken down and there have been no attempts to suppress the leak by WoTC. They did not contact eBay asking for the auction to be taken down.

Furthermore, leaking non-English cards was brilliant, as it kept the playerbase busy translating and evaluating the cards, so that less discussion on the recent bans would be at the forefront of discussion. Instead, the time of individuals were spent looking at, and translating the cards, and then looking at possible specs to buy.

Lastly, spoiler season was originally slated to happen on the 12th anyways. This was no coincidence. :)


r/mtgfinance • • Jan 18 '26

Even with ~50 rare and mystic spoiled for TMNT already, people still doesn't seems to be interested in TMT

0 Upvotes

We currently have about ~50 cards from TMNT had been spoiled on the main sub, this is about 1/2 of rare and mystic from a large set like FF and about 75% from a small set like SPM.

When you look like the sell number on tcgplayer, the sell number just have a really minor increase and it shows people aren't interested in the set.

Personally i am feeling this set looks like another SPM situation.


r/mtgfinance • • Feb 01 '23

Currently Spiking COMPLEAT EDITION GO BRRRR [MEME]

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/mtgfinance • • Mar 17 '25

LoTR Collectors on the move again

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/mtgfinance • • Dec 28 '24

My prediction: Aetherdrift will be the worst selling set in 2025, wait for discount sales!

3 Upvotes

You can buy some Aetherdrift cards a month after its release when the first discount sales start because of how bad it will sell but here is the logic that will cause this:

  1. Cars in a fantasy game. It's downright offensive in how bad this is. This is literally the meme of parking a BMW next to Gandalf. This will be disliked.

  2. Wizards of the Coast does not believe that Aetherdrift will be successful either. Look at the price that they have set for their boxes, it's almost at the initial level of the Foundations boxes which they obviously priced lower because they want it as a new beginner set. Not the case for Aetherdrift. It's also not because they are suddenly trying to be more affordable, Innistrad Remastered launches three weeks earlier and is far higher priced.

  3. Everyone knows that it looks like a joke, look at the moxman's initial reaction: https://youtu.be/O8MrJKNk2-o?t=31 He tones it down because it's an mtg channel and obviously he can't just downplay a set entirely all day long. Especially given how UB is the future and this is the first quasi "UB" set except it's in in-universe UB *without* the bonus of being a popular external franchise. The sales for this are going to be abysmal. He basically ends it by saying to pick out singles that you like. Yeah that means: No sales.

Bottom line: People will not be buying the boxes, so you can either wait for a sale after the first month or come up with your own strategy on how you will handle this situation. My suggestion is to just wait for the UB sets. There is no point buying anything else in 2025.


r/mtgfinance • • Oct 24 '25

People are still buying Spider-Man Sealed product

0 Upvotes

I went to my LGS this week on their commander night, it was packed by the way, and saw two different people at the tables busting a box of Spider-Man play boosters. This shop is not giving away the product, they are priced a bit under MSRP, which if I remember right is just over $200, and they were selling at $199 a box.

Contrary to belief most people don't read or post on these forums and constantly complain about everything, this is a tiny segment of who plays and or collects... so just because you hate something doesn't mean everyone else does.


r/mtgfinance • • Mar 27 '25

Article Would you spend $15 on four Food tokens?

8 Upvotes

Alternative question: How about $20 on four foil Food tokens?

The latest Secret Lair Chaos Vault drop is exactly that. Oops All Food Tokens for $15-20. Four tokens, each with admittedly awesome art, and that's it. That's the drop. This is coming off the heels of their big main-line superdrop, where many of the individual picks people wanted sold out in an instant. So as a consolation prize to anyone who wasn't able to get that sweet Tragic Romance drop, you can at least eat your sorrows away with an alternative drop full of Food tokens instead.

So is anyone excited to pick that up? Is the door open for more drops like this? What kind of "supplementary" Secret Lair would actually get you interested -- a pile of Treasure? That Kaldra token we never got in paper? Four Etherium Cells and a Gold token?


r/mtgfinance • • Aug 25 '21

Redefining failure for AFR

0 Upvotes

Comments Reply: I find it funny that all the claims in the comments on this Finance Sub circle around how each commenter feels about D&D and AFR. Market prices show units aren't selling at a retail level, the demand from players just isn't there for sealed or singles.

Comments Reply 2: Is a longer explanation of the design failures so I added it at the bottom.

AFR has seen drastically reduced allocations to most stores. There is one guy on here who claims to have received his full allocation and then some, maybe he has the extra thousand of boxes shorted elsewhere.

What we know is the prices have fallen during allocation period and collector boosters are still available at pre-order pricing or less depending on the seller. New product prices are at multiple year lows for AFR. Multiple stores are unloading boxes at $80-$89 just to move what boxes they received. Here’s one example if you want it https://www.prodigygamestcg.com/products/magic-the-gathering-adventures-in-the-forgotten-realm-draft-booster-box?variant=39404817940551&currency=USD&utm_medium=product_sync&utm_source=google&utm_content=sag_organic&utm_campaign=sag_organic&utm_campaign=gs-2021-03-03&utm_source=google&utm_medium=smart_campaign&gclid=CjwKCAjw1JeJBhB9EiwAV612y-eKQhVigzIDF5TA7wGGDqNKNiY8_QAqoNHqN-nqtYBFP0BJ2CvIyxoCK_EQAvD_BwE.

Singles prices are squashed down towards the lower boundary and there has been some vocal backlash.

So when asked if WOTC learned anything from the failure of AFR, Mark Rosewater responded

“Failure? Who’s causing it a failure? It’s looking to be one of the best-selling sets in the history of the game. I’ll officially call it “not a failure”.”

If we take Maro at his word and assume that Maro is comparing AFR to ALL previous sets including Kamigawa, Shards, Rise, Oath, NYX, Theros, Zen, Innistrad… blocks… then he is technically correct.

Sales are at all time highs across all products and print runs are much higher, but shitting your pants in an Armani suit instead of a Men’s Wearhouse garb doesn’t make it any better.

I would like to point out that simply using the excuse that because sales as a whole are higher now that redefines failure into success is broken logic that will lead us down a fraught path.

I hope there is some additional supporting responses to come that allow WOTC to learn from the multitude of errors in releasing AFR as is.

Comments reply 2: It appears that many of the commenters have not played with the AFR cards much. Two glaring design mistakes overshadow this set. Both the mechanics for dice rolling and dungeons are non interactive Solitaire effects that are a side game inside of the larger game. Maro's favorite card is Shahrazad and these effects both add elements of side game delays. Additionally, both effects require additional equipment, dungeon cards and multiple different dice to roll for different effects ( d4, d6, d8, d10, d12, d20) that most players do not bring with them which leads to issues in game. These types of non interactive, complicated, game stalling effects have been regarding as a bad game play experience for many years which is why cards like Divine Intervention, Shahrazad and Worldfire are banned in formats like Commander. If you haven't played with the cards much, you probably haven't seen this play out. Give it time and allow this play style to percolate, it's damaging to the health of the game.


r/mtgfinance • • Jul 17 '21

MTG Market and the deflation of 4th Tier card games and currency scams

0 Upvotes

REPLY TO COMMENTS: If you are going to lose money because you purchased Flesh & Blood cards believing they were an investment as Rudy claims on a daily basis. Then you should pursue Rudy to pay for your losses. Rudy is the authorized representative of Flesh & Blood in the USA and the primary distributor of their signature line of products. The Flesh & Blood company itself is domiciled in New Zealand because NZ has very weak laws regarding overseas financial fraud. There is no recourse against the company when this "investment" falls to close to zero. I bear you no ill-will and I'm sorry you made bad choices that resulted in you tieing up your money in the Flesh & Blood fake currency scam. The fallout from this will affect the primary CCG markets, MTG, Pokemon, and Yugioh.

If anyone has noticed, the MTG market has softened. There are fewer sales and rapidly declining prices in many standard sets coupled with declining sales volume of the Adventures in the Forgotten Realms D&D set. A primary driver of the current downtick in prices comes from "investors" seeking to curtail purchases of new sealed products and sell cards from the primary CCG games (MTG, Pokemon, and Yugioh) to raise cash as a result of experiencing losses in the Flesh & Blood market. This will be a multi phase downturn over a prolonged period of time as people come to terms with their loses. This is likely to hit reserve lists specs of non playable cards and other specs the hardest and there is significant demand based price support for staples and reserve list playables.

I made a much hated posted a few weeks ago that money leaving the fake currency scam of Flesh & Blood would cause selling in the primary CCG markets of Pokemon, Yugioh, and MTG. Remember, the Flesh & Blood company has been claiming there was a healthy "secondary market" for Flesh & Bloods cards long before any were printed and they continue to advertise this on their website to this day.

It is important to put out into the public arena that the unwinding of the Flesh & Blood fake currency scam will cause several down legs in the primary CCG markets as "investors" will sell high quality assets to cover losses in Flesh & Blood "investments".

"Investors" have considered Flesh & Blood a currency. "Investors" have taken Rudy's advice to keep "money invested" in Flesh and Blood "like Crypto". This is a deliberate attempt to mislead people into thinking Flesh & Blood is a currency.

The problem comes when the market is no longer appreciating rapidly, the liquidity dries up and there is little to no ability to convert "Flesh & Blood" investments to cash as there is no demand for the product outside of being a currency. This means that "investors" that have overspent or need to raise money will sell assets they can move such as high quality MTG, Pokemon, and Yugioh cards.

As the Flesh & Blood prices deflate the "investors" that believed they were "putting their money to work" by having a large % of their net worth in Flesh & Blood "investments" seek to raise cash so they can pay for things in the real world with real currency it puts additional downward pressure on prices. Most of the "investors" in Flesh & Blood will struggle to accept the declining prices and reality that, without a player base, the price of the Flesh & Blood "investments" would correct down a negligible number.

Flesh & Blood is very similar to the Mississippi Company, it will take a prolonged period of time for people to psychologically and economically come to terms with losses on these "investments". There will be waves of downward pressure on pricing on the primary CCG's.