So this past weekend, I had the fortune to be the Keeper of my first Mystery.
I adapted (instead of just purely trying to convert) an old Call of Cthulhu scenario, "The Haunting" (last seen in the 6e rulebook... it's a classic scenario going back to CoC 1e, I think).
It ended up being two Hunters -- a Mundane and a Meddling Kid. (And the player did the MK trope perfectly, channeling her inner Velma... jinkies. Even got to do the broken eyeglasses to give a -1 Ongoing for anything related to sight.)
I liked how I did the bad guy with his powers (though Magic Points are not a thing), but there wasn't much he could do physically. I'm sure the more times I run the game, I'll get the hang of it.
Here's where I had problems though:
- Countdown Clock -- I had no ideas on how to create one that would work this this mystery. I kind of left it aside since the Bad Guy didn't have a real time-sensitive agenda.
- Supporting Cast -- Again, there wasn't much that I could glean from that. Yes, there was research to be done at the library and newspaper archives, and I could have had a couple of minor Bystanders for those elements. Same with the affected family, though they weren't even considered by the Hunters.
So, what would I do different?
- Bad Guy -- Nothing. I liked how I built him out. Even used one of his special powers which worked out rather well. Though I know what I'll be doing to improve it. (Basically a Domination effect.)
- Set an actual "Bad Guy Agenda" with a goal apart from just protecting his house. The original scenario didn't really give him much of a plan or anything. This will help with the Countdown Clock as well.
- Change up Investigate a Mystery, so it's not so cut and dry.
There was so much that the Hunters didn't investigate in the scenario, but... I think I can redo this now that I have a better understanding.
I have two or three other scenarios from other games I can adapt. Mostly they're from Beyond the Supernatural, but the basic threads should work out well.