r/monsteroftheweek • • Aug 15 '24

Custom Move/Homebrew I have a setting that is terrible or worse. What do you think?

0 Upvotes

Full disclosure- I’m a big fan of A Song of Ice and Fire, Game of Thrones Lore. Love the lore.

Was thinking about a modern day Westeros, 21st century Westeros. Setting a modern day MotW game in it and using some lore from books and other lore in the game.

Is this an absolute trash idea??


r/monsteroftheweek • • Apr 07 '25

Basic Moves Monster summons?

0 Upvotes

I am a first time player with a newer DM. I need some ideas of what to summon without it becoming "big magic". My conversation with my DM wasn't really helpful.

Me: hey I want to use this at some point. What can I summon without it becoming big magic? DM: the world is your oyster. Me: so I could summon a megalodon? DM: That would be big magic. You're going to need time to draw sigils for a portal. Me: but what makes it big magic? It has no magical ability, is confined to water, and I'm not guaranteed to have control over it. DM: Size and complexity are going to make things big magic.

The DM didn't have energy to talk more about it, so please, is there a list somewhere? Are there premade stat blocks? I would like to bring a list of things for the DM to check off, so I can at least pinpoint if the ability is getting nerfed.


r/monsteroftheweek • • Apr 29 '23

Hunter Playbook for the Mario and Luigi Bros

0 Upvotes

As the title says, if you wanted to play like the Mario and Luigi bros from the RPG series with bros attacks and everything, what playbook best suits that, or should I come up with something custom?

Edit: I should say that I am doing this from the perspective of the Keeper, just curious in using this as a creative exercise. But I am thinking about the Mario and Luigi Bowser’s inside story.


r/monsteroftheweek • • Sep 01 '23

Basic Moves If a person wanted to "Use Magic" as a combat action and they had reason for it, would they just go by the Spell Slinger sheet to decide the effects(if it works in the first place that is?

0 Upvotes

I am just curious abut the game and I want to understand the system better. Also is being a divine with a high weird stat good enough of a reason to say "I make a lightning missile from the spell slinger handbook thing" and it to make sense. I do not want to try making a OP character with two playbooks, I just want to know how that would work or if that is even possible.


r/monsteroftheweek • • Jan 20 '23

Art AI generated Monster and NPC handouts

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

I've been trying out some AI generated art for my game, which is set in the States in the 70s. The players are a set of roving biker gang / hunters. I'm blown away by the quality of images you can produce. The first picture are the monsters, a witch and her undead biker minions. The second set are the player characters and NPCs. I've done a set for the locations they can visit too. It takes some time to get it right but I pleased with the results. I recommend it to any GMs running a planned session.


r/monsteroftheweek • • Jan 12 '20

General Discussion help

1 Upvotes

I need help with coming up with a reason for my players too not alert the town of the monster


r/monsteroftheweek • • Jan 27 '24

Monster How's this special Move to make a boss monster nastier?

1 Upvotes

How's this for a special move to make a boss monster a bit harder to handle?

Supernaturally fast and agile: if he’s not restrained or slowed, when you try to attack him, you must act under pressure. If you miss, the attack fails (you had no opportunity to attack, or he dodged or evaded the attack). On a 7-9, you can go ahead with your attack (kick some ass or use magic) but the effect is weakened - you’ll do half damage, or the magic’s effect is weakened. On a hit, go ahead with your attack as normal.


r/monsteroftheweek • • Feb 27 '23

Hunter Help me decide my character for our next campaign?

1 Upvotes

Maybe I’m overthinking it, but I’m all for synergy when making my character in regards to everyone else in the group, to fit well for the narrative.

So far we have: A searcher A wronged A crooked

I just want to choose a character that will fit well with my group-any suggestions? Idk why but im just stumped on who to choose.


r/monsteroftheweek • • Sep 10 '19

General Discussion Why is Monstrous so broken, and how can I fix it?

1 Upvotes

I think the large majority of the moves from the other playbooks have a decent balance of mechanical to roleplay benefits... But the Monstrous moves "Immortal", "incorporeal", and to a degree "flight" are incredibly broken. Incorporeal is the one I have the most trouble dealing with because it has no consequences or cooldowns, so my one player keeps using it to circumvent all obstacles. We had a hallway cave in because they weren't careful... And he just walked past the debris. He stays incorporeal all the time so that nothing can hurt him.

I've already done a few house rules, but I still think these abilities are really OP. Any suggestions for additional house rules or some way to add a cooldown to the ability?


r/monsteroftheweek • • Apr 13 '23

Basic Moves Who can make Magic move?

1 Upvotes

The magic move has no requirement so technically a person with 0 weird can cast spells?

Shouldn't this just be limited to spell caster type?


r/monsteroftheweek • • Jul 15 '24

General Discussion What do you think of this concept?

5 Upvotes

It's a bit like the Boys but adjusted to suit Monster of the Week's genre.

Basically, this is a universe where there are a whole bunch of superheroes and villains, but they're all controlled by an evil corporation in order to make money like Vought. And the player characters are a bunch of people trying to uproot the corrupt system and the sociopathic heroes that make up an elite group that protects the company core like the Seven.

But unlike the Boys, some of the Hunters will be lower ranking heroes or even villains. That's what the more magical or monstrous playbooks will be. Some of them will even be botched attempts at making new heroes like the Monstrous. And some of them will be even be villains who aren't actually evil but get cast as such to make the elite heroes look good. That gives an opportunity to play as a generic Saturday Morning Cartoon villain or something of that nature.

Each monster is a corrupt superhero, or an experiment escaped from the company laboratory. There would also be a big theme of rebellion going on, mixed with pulp action, interpersonal drama, and some body horror.

What sets this apart from the Boys is that instead of hyperfocusing on a small group of really powerful supes, the players will be fighting a different hero each session, gradually working their way up into they face off against the elite ones.

Sound like a good idea?


r/monsteroftheweek • • Feb 26 '26

Basic Moves Considering eliminating Use Magic

7 Upvotes

Use Magic is so broad and so powerful. I'm considering eliminating it as a move. I'm thinking the individual effects would work well as individual Weird Moves.

I've only run a single 1-shot, and 1 player didn't see a useful option to take (Snoop in a combat situation) and the player argued that having seen Weird stuff their character (who had lived a pretty regular life until then) would try to Use Magic to do something.

I allowed the Spooktacular to Use Magic because it felt more true to the fiction, but it also feels unfair that 1 character gets access to a powerful tool kit because of the way they flavored their character.

in the inspiration TV shows, Magic is a plot device. it works when it needs to and doesn't work when it needs to, based on extremely flimsy pretexts. which is fine in that context but feels unfun / unfair to players.

thoughts? experiences?


r/monsteroftheweek • • Jan 26 '23

Basic Moves What does “mark 2 of the basic moves as advanced” mean???

3 Upvotes

A player asked me what this meant on the Advanced Improvements section of The Professional playbook… and I just can’t even begin to guess. Help.


r/monsteroftheweek • • Jan 28 '22

Custom Move/Homebrew Spell Backfire/miscast table?

0 Upvotes

Hey all, currently DMing my first Monster of the Week game and having a blast. Lately, I've been thinking of ways to make magic more interesting for my caster characters and was wondering if anyone had come up with an expanded magical backlash table (almost like a wild magic table from D&D 5e). I could always just make one myself (and still might) but thought it prudent to see if anyone had beaten me to it. Thanks!


r/monsteroftheweek • • Jun 08 '22

Custom Move/Homebrew Table of mutations for a game i'm preparing

0 Upvotes

Mutations: When a players afflicted with a kind of mutations, they will have -1 ongoing on a stat depending on the mutations and until it's treated or fully grown and a chance to get unstable quicker. 1-New Limb: Growth of a new limb like a prehensive tail, or extra set of fingers, those takes multiples months even years to grow, those afflict Tough giving it a -1 ongoing, through when grown give a natural attack depending on what limb grew. 2-Sense Sensibility: a heighted version of sense like sight, hearing, scent ect. Those are relatively quick to appear and hard to treat taking a full blown surgery leaving you to bed for some weeks. Those afflict Cool giving it a -1 ongoing, through when fully grown roll with Sharp using that better sense gain +1. 3-Renforced Skin: a harden patch of burned looking skin, those grow rather quickly needing quick surgery and skin graff. Those afflict Charm giving it a -1 ongoing, through when fully grown, it offer a +1 to your armour on that specific spot. 4- Berserker Gland: A section of your nerve system begin develloping a incredibly potent rage, those need immediate surgery despite their slow growth. Those afflict Sharp giving it a -1 ongoing while harming you by giving you worsening headaches each , through when fully grown, it offer + 1-harm when using a weapon.

This -1 ongoing are only during it's Growth and stop when fully grown


r/monsteroftheweek • • Apr 18 '19

Story SCP themed campaign update: mystery 1 pending session 4 and a VERY important tip about communication

0 Upvotes

No update on the campaign just a tip this time around.

So my group tries to get together every week. It's been almost a month since our last session. My first tip is for you keepers out there, be patient with your players especially those that are students. They're real fuckin busy what with tests and studying. Literally all of my players are students so it's easy to have a session or two canceled here and there due to assignments and the like.

My second tip is for both keepers and players, but mostly players as the keeper should be the one spearheading the sessions. Players PLEASE COMMUNICATE!!! 3 of the 4 times our group has tried to reschedule we've had one or more players just contribute literally nothing (they just didnt respond to messages) to the effort of trying to reschedule and when we're two hours out they finally message and say "sorry I cant play"

It doesnt matter if you can't answer the question right then and there. A simple "sorry I'm busy right now" or "I'll get back to yall on this later" would do just fine just to let us know that you've acknowledged the message. Because the fact of the matter is, your keeper has written this amazing story and world that they want everyone to have fun living and playing in. Communication is always a 2 way street and without one side the other is totally lost.


r/monsteroftheweek • • Aug 02 '19

Hunter A crazy character idea.

0 Upvotes

So I just got done with a session and I came up with a crazy character idea....a spell slinger who is a year old....and moved around with help of her man nanny. Basically the man nanny has the baby in one of those baby backpacks and he counts as what would take the damage and movement and such. While the baby shoots spells and stuff. Could this work? Better yet should this work??


r/monsteroftheweek • • Dec 04 '20

Monster The Christmas Tree (How will it do?)

0 Upvotes

I’ve done a single keeper session for an actual MotW game a few weeks ago for our group. This is gonna be their second game, hopefully where we all actually understand the the rules to their fullest, and since we’re so close to Christmas, I thought about doing a very good Christmas Tree Monster! It’s cultivation would be dependent these Centaur Reigndeer minions, and it would alter the fates of specific people to lead them into dangerous, incriminating scenarios, but I need stats for everything. I think 3 minions and the monster stats are the big things I need. I don’t know if crowdsourcing is the way to do this but between school and work, I think this would be the best way to go. Thanks you all greatly!


r/monsteroftheweek • • Dec 12 '20

Hunter Need help for a character

0 Upvotes

I'm going to be playing a character that has a Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde situation, effectively playing two characters. One of them is a mundane while the other is a crooked. Any other ideas? (btw I'm a bit new to MotW)

Edit: Should've noted, old enough to know how to play and all that. New enough to not know every class. (but thanks for those that help regardless)


r/monsteroftheweek • • Mar 03 '20

Story Hallow (Campaign Story Introduction)

3 Upvotes

Around October of 2019, I and some of my friends decided to run MotW campaign with me as the Keeper. I plan to tell the story here cause I think its quite a fun and interesting story. In the introduction, I will explain the setting and the player's characters. Now please note that this was our first authentic MotW campaign so I let two of the players switch their characters early on (before level 5) because of 1. I forgot the rule about the character switching, and 2. I didn't want my players to endure the campaign with a character they didn't like. There are also some other rule bends that were used, but that was to make the game more enjoyable and fun.

The setting is a small town in Wisconsin called Nestedhallow. Founded in the year 1804 by 7 settlers, the town grew to a decent size. It is has a lake north of it and a forest to the south so it is a go-to place for people who enjoy nature. However, what the inhabitants of the town weren't aware of was that the sins of its town founders were about to resurface.
For our players, I'll start with Randy Fantom our Spooky. Our friend who was playing him wanted to really lean into that dark aspect of it so much so that Randy is more of a villain than a hero. His plans, however, coincide with my story and makes for some unique interactions later.

Then we have Jamie Klein. He's a young Expert who came across the Necronomicon and becoming a genius at a young age. So he attends high school at the young age of 13.

Then we have Leonardo the Divine and Principal Snooty the Mundane. These two characters were the ones that were switched early on, however, their existence affected the story further along in the campaign. I will begin the story in my next post


r/monsteroftheweek • • Feb 16 '22

Custom Move/Homebrew I made a supplementary rulebook to add a bit more finesse to combat & character creation. Tell me what you think!

6 Upvotes

I felt like it didn't make much sense that a spooky and a chosen had the same exact HP, and some other minor issues that I'm attempting to tweak with this playbook. I ran it for my friends in their campaign, and they really dig it. Let me know what you think!

https://docs.google.com/document/d/17yeFrSDWruC4wowM-M7cLs6V5acAPrMP9eaE7aXtHIY/edit?usp=sharing


r/monsteroftheweek • • May 06 '19

General Discussion The Monster of the Week TV Tropes Page needs Updating.

Thumbnail
tvtropes.org
1 Upvotes

r/monsteroftheweek • • Sep 07 '22

Custom Move/Homebrew Harm reworks/homebrew/hacks?

0 Upvotes

My first full-length campaign of MotW is approaching the end (last night was session 12, I expect we'll end on session 15 or 16). One pain point I've found is Harm. It's mostly just tracking HP, which is fine but a little bland. First aid is also a little weird, since the Professional and Wronged (but only these two IIRC) have playbook moves that specify that they can perform first aid and the Wronged's move only "counts as normal first aid" if they roll and get 10+. That seems to imply that Hunters can't necessarily perform first aid (or maybe they can but the Wronged's move allows them to do it with improvised supplies or something? Anyway, I found it confusing.)

So I'm interested in reworks, homebrew, and hacks of the Harm system. Personally I can think of a few alternatives from other games, but I don't know that any is a perfect fit with MotW.

  • Urban Shadows 2e: harm boxes arranged in tiers + conditions attached to the tiers (require narrative justification to clear) + scars (avoid death by taking a stat penalty)

  • Fate: stress boxes (harm boxes that clear automatically at the end of the scene) + conditions

  • Fellowship 2e: mark a stat (penalty to use that stat) + explicit healing moves and items

  • Masks: explicit mechanics for marking and clearing stats, emphasizing narrative (only roughly correspond to taking and recovering from damage)


r/monsteroftheweek • • Dec 30 '23

Custom Move/Homebrew Combo Skill for Ordinary Citizen?

0 Upvotes

Trying to come up with a pseudo combo system for an ordinary citizen in a world filled with monsters. There is a Run stat in the game. My character is just on the run, essentially. (ie if move 1 succeeds, you can than do move 2, and move 3 is the "max tier", and you can only do 1->-2->3, you cant do 1->2->2, for example), they are meant to either help with the character's "escape" stat to help success in escaping, or to lower the amount of turns before you can escape. Damage on moves is supposed to be low, with chance to inflict certain status effects, the weapon will be subject to approval. The character possesses no weapons, as they are supposed to be an ordinary person that managed to survive the apocalypse scenario in the game.

Something like Slap -> Throw Rock -> Shove, maybe? I dont know, someone suggested Throw Rock but it doesnt seem a good fit.