"Bloody Sunday" was an event that occurred on Jan 22 1905 in Tsarist Russia during the reign of Nicholas II. It is widely cited as a clear example of the brutality of the Tsarist regime, a catalyst for the Tsar's overthrow, and the spread of Communism in Russia. It is an event especially cited as propaganda against Nicholas II himself. However, there is more to this event than the popular narrative.
Firstly, we must realise that how the event is often taught is heavily shaped by Soviet propaganda. The event as most of you will be aware of it goes roughly like this:
A large, peaceful crowd of working class families, (highest estimates are around 50,000 people), led by the Russian Orthodox Priest Father Georgy Gapon, marched towards Russia's winter Palace. They carried a petition for better working conditions, civil liberties and reforms, as well as religious icons and portraits of the Tsar.
Russian troops fired upon the crowd, to prevent them reaching the palace. Soviet propaganda claimed that thousands had been killed, in reality, historical records indicate around 200.
The first piece of propaganda often taught is that thousands were killed, as I have already said, historical records indicate it was closer to 200. Still very much a tragedy, but no where near the exaggerated figures.
Beyond this, there is also much more information that came to light after the Soviet archives were opened in the 1990s for historians to examine.
Firstly is the origin of the protest. It is often presented as a peaceful march led by a Priest. Certainly most the workers were genuine peaceful protests. However, this was not an entirely innocent event.
The Priest leading the march, Father Georgy Gapon, was a double agent. He was working for the Tsarist secret Police, the Okhrana, and his role was to form workers unions that were loyal to the Tsar, and bring workers towards supporting minor reforms rather than revolutionary Socialism. However, Fr. Gapon held strong Socialist sympathies, and this march at the Winter Palace had not been approved by the secret Police, and included demands that came from his Socialist contacts.
After the massacre, Gapon is recorded as having said "There is no God any longer, there is no Tsar" and called for an armed uprising against the government. This is very far from the often quoted image of a peaceful Priest leading a march for workers rights. Gapon later fled to Western Europe, and formally joined the Socialist Revolutionary Party. He grew disillusioned with them, returned to Russia and reopened negotiations with the Okhrana, and was eventually killed by revolutionaries.
The archives also revealed that revolutionary groups had infiltrated the march. These included Bolsheviks, Mensheviks, and Socialist revolutionaries. Gapon himself recruited a small group of Socialist revolutionaries as personal bodyguards. The majority of the protesters were unarmed workers, however, archival police and military reports, as well as Gapon's own writings, indicate that groups of these revolutionary radicals did fire at soldiers and policemen. Two policemen were killed and several officers wounded during the clashes.
Military intelligence and the Okhrana also knew that these groups had infiltrated the movement by this point. The troops present at the march had been briefed by commanders beforehand that the march had been infiltrated and that the radicals planned to commit acts of violence, terrorism or agitation. This explains why the soldiers and junior officers were so trigger happy, as many expected the march to turn into a armed uprising.
Further to this, Soviet propaganda often portrayed Nicholas II as himself ordering the massacre, giving him the name "bloody Nicholas". This is untrue, and while this point is more well known today, I still see people mistakenly believing that Nicholas was present. So it is worth pointing out.
I am of the opinion that, when this is all put together, the whole event looks very different from the common narrative often presented. The massacre that followed was still a tragedy, and it was absolutely disproportionate violence on the side of the government, but the extra context does explain their actions beyond the usual "super duper evil monarchy" that is often used to explain the events, and it well worth remembering that even if most the protesters were innocent workers, the march itself had been hijacked by revolutionary forces. It also shows how heavily the narrative around it has been warped by generations of Soviet propaganda that sought to present Nicholas as some bloody tyrant.
Curious to hear your thoughts on this.