r/monarchism • • Mar 04 '25

MOD PSA: Downvoting is still banned on /r/monarchism, and here's why.

0 Upvotes

EDIT: Please read the post before commenting. I and other moderators are getting downvoted for...being against downvoting. People are complaining that not being able to downvote gives views they oppose too much visibility, which is exactly the reason why we don't want downvoting - if something is not against the rules and isn't removed by the moderators, then it's an acceptable post or comment to make on this subreddit, and you should respond to it with arguments if you disagree. People are also claiming that Rule 7 can be used for censorship by serving as a "catch-all" reason for bans. We literally cannot and will not ban people for violating Rule 7 and the rule is meant as an appeal, and as a moral guideline!

EDIT 2: Publicly bragging about downvoting is punishable, no matter whether you actually did cast a downvote or not, because it constitutes uncivil, disruptive behaviour under rules 1 and 2. Rule 7 in itself is irrelevant here. It can also be seen as a call to brigading under rule 3 as it openly and deliberately encourages users to break this subreddit's rules.

In the past few days, I have noticed that downvoting is rampant in some discussions I have participated in or moderate. I would like to remind you that downvoting is banned in accordance with Rule 7 of /r/monarchism. We cannot technically prevent downvoting because the arrow can only be removed on Old Reddit, nor can we (or do we want) to identify and punish users who downvote. The rule is meant as a (strongly-worded) guideline. However, it is just as crucial for the function of this community as the other ones.

We are a subreddit full of people who, apart from sharing an appreciation for some form of monarchy, have wildly different political beliefs. Often, discussions become heated, and this place is meant to accommodate this. This is what Reddit as a whole was supposed to be initially, and many Redditors who aren't monarchists value /r/monarchism for exactly this reason.

The practice of downvoting is highly controversial and does not align with the goal of our forum. Originally, upvotes and downvotes were intended to reward high-quality submissions. You would upvote posts and comments that were well-written, made good arguments, or sounded interesting - even and especially if you disagreed. You would downvote posts and comments that contributed nothing to the discussion, contained fallacies, insults, violated the rules or were made in bad faith - even if you agreed, because such comments, after all, would make your side look bad.

Naturally, as Reddit's userbase widened and the platform became more and more popular, it became harder and harder to enforce this principle. Upvoting and downvoting has become a tool for expressing agreement and disagreement. And as the largest subreddits and finally Reddit's leadership itself embraced an one-sided, openly political stance, the function turned the majority of the platform into one massive echo chamber. Downvoting allows for a false consensus to be portrayed for actually controversial issues, for dissenting viewpoints to be suppressed, and eventually, for what can only be described as "soft deplatforming".

This is not what /r/monarchism is, was, or ever will be supposed to be. Why would we want a system like on most front-page subreddits if the very purpose of this subreddit is controversial debate rather than enforcing a singular consensus?

Subreddits that disapproved of this development added the above principle to their rules or sought to restrict downvoting - /r/monarchism is not the only one.

If you think that a post cannot, under any circumstances, deserve an upvote, then fine, don't upvote it! There are others who might find it more interesting or who might agree with the author. You might also look at the rules and check if the content violates any of them.

Downvoting, on the other hand, has no purpose other than limiting the visibility of a post or comment - not only to people who might agree with it, but also to others who might have arguments against it and to the moderation team which regularly patrols posts. With Reddit's algorithms being one huge black box, accumulating too many downvotes can have far-reaching consequences for an account even beyond a single subreddit. This does not have anything to do with the civil, gentlemanly discourse that you (hopefully) want to see here. Do you want to be downvoted because you post an unpopular opinion? No? Then don't downvote others for the same thing. Just don't do it!

  • If you like a particular post or comment, or if you think that it contributes to this subreddit, you should upvote it - and if you disagree, continue the discussion by answering.

  • If you can gain nothing from a post or comment but also have no arguments against it, just ignore and don't upvote or downvote it.

  • If you think that a post or comment was made in bad faith, is uncivil or otherwise violates the rules, report it and moderators will take action.

Be fair. If you don't like something, disagree with it or ignore it. If something violates the rules, report it. We might not respond within 30 seconds, but somebody who is here to stir up trouble will be certainly banned.


r/monarchism • • Mar 10 '19

Misc. Anarchists can be such douchebags

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/monarchism • • Mar 09 '24

Question are lgbt people accepted here?

0 Upvotes

i recently saw a couple comments on this sub where someone said you can’t be a monarchist if you’re gay,trans etc because it’s ‘’’against god’’’ and it made me sad/feel excluded. i never necessarily thought being a monarchist meant you were a full on conservative, because most of my views are progressive, monarchism is mainly my only ‘conservative’ view point, even the current labour party in the uk also support the monarchy.


r/monarchism • • Apr 05 '25

Pro Monarchy activism May their reign last 10,000 years

7 Upvotes

I wouldn’t want it any other way. God bless the house of saud 🇸🇦


r/monarchism • • Jan 11 '22

Discussion What the hell is your guys' obsession with Austria-Hungary? it sucked

2 Upvotes

For all of its existence, it was a joke of an empire, completely strife with ethnic conflict and corruption.

For starters, multi-ethnic states don't work very well. Especially when there is no clear majority. Its non-Austrian subjects resented the country, which is what led to the first world war.

It was an aggressive barking dog especially, it attacked Serbia for no reason, failed its military campaign against a country ten times smaller than it, and screwed up the natural order in Europe.

Their military was pathetic and dogshit, the equivalent of Italy in WW2.

Without THEM we could likely still have a monarchy in Germany, Italy, and Russia.


r/monarchism • • Feb 05 '26

Kind of Monarchist Chart Repost of my monarchical chart, now with explanations about the chosen monarchs (as requested by the moderators).

Post image
2 Upvotes

Why I chose the monarchs shown:

Frederick II the Great (Prussia)

He was chosen because he embodies the ideal of the enlightened, militaristic monarch who transforms a kingdom into an empire through Prussian discipline and strategic genius. Under his reign, Prussia expanded its territory through daring wars such as those in Silesia and the Seven Years' War, where he defeated superior coalitions thanks to his personal leadership on the battlefield. His centralized absolutism, combined with administrative reforms and an emphasis on militarism, makes him a perfect model for me: a king who unites Germanic nationalism with effective authoritarianism, rejecting scattered feudalism in favor of a strong, unified state. Furthermore, his agnosticism and religious tolerance (influenced by rationalism) resonate with the Nordic paganism I prefer, moving away from traditional Christian dogmatism.

Louis XIV (France)

The "Sun King" represents the pinnacle of monarchical absolutism, where the king is the state itself ("L'État, c'est moi"). He was selected for his ability to centralize power, crushing the feudal nobility through Versailles as a center of control and propaganda, and expanding France through military conquests in Europe. His reign saw the heyday of mercantilism and state corporatism, with ministers such as Colbert organizing the economy into guilds controlled by the king, aligning with your secondary ideologies of authoritarianism and corporatism. He rejected any form of democracy or decentralization, imposing a unified French nationalism. Although a devout Catholic, his focus on earthly power and rejection of papal interference (Gallicanism) makes him compatible with an anti-traditional monarchism, more focused on empire than faith, fitting into my synthesis.

Mehmed II (Ottoman Empire)

"The Conqueror" stands out for his relentless imperial expansion and his vision of a multi-ethnic but centralized state under an absolute sultan. He was chosen because of his conquest of Constantinople in 1453, which not only ended the Byzantine Empire but also transformed the Ottoman Empire into a Eurasian superpower, combining militarism with innovation (such as the use of massive cannons). He fits into my chart because of his authoritarianism: he reorganized the empire with a system of devşirme (recruitment of elites) and a centralized government, similar to corporatism, where the sultan is the supreme arbiter. His blend of Islam with pragmatic tolerance toward other ethnicities and religions adds a cosmopolitan touch, reflecting my inclusion of the Ottoman flag. As an anti-feudal (he eliminated independent beys), and with a focus on conquest, he complements the rejection of communism and democracy, prioritizing empire over equality.

Julian the Apostate (Eastern Roman Empire)

Julian was included for his defense of pagan Hellenism and his attempt to restore ancient Roman traditions against the Christian tide. His selection highlights my preference for Norse/Germanic paganism: Julian promoted a polytheistic Neoplatonism, reforming the state to revive pagan cults and limit ecclesiastical power. Militarily, he was a successful conqueror against the Persians and Germans, embodying authoritarianism and militarism with a loyal army and centralized administrative reforms. He rejected nascent feudalism and any form of egalitarianism (criticizing Christianity for this), aligning himself with my anti-communism and anti-democracy. His brief but intense reign symbolizes a reactionary and culturally restorative monarchism, merging Roman nationalism with a philosophical absolutism that fits my eclectic pagan-imperial vision.

Frederick II Hohenstaufen, "Stupor Mundi" (Holy Roman Empire / Kingdom of Sicily)

He was chosen because he represents the absolutist, cosmopolitan, intellectual, and warrior monarch par excellence, a precursor of enlightened absolutism with a pagan and anti-clerical touch that fits perfectly into my synthesis. Nicknamed "Stupor Mundi" for his legendary erudition, Frederick embodies the philosopher-king who rules the state with an iron fist, centralizing power in Sicily and defying the papacy (he was excommunicated several times and declared "antichrist" by Gregory IX).

His absolutism is seen in the creation of an advanced bureaucratic state in the Kingdom of Sicily: a centralized legal code (Constitutions of Melfi, 1231), a professional mercenary army, direct taxation, and secular administration that marginalized the feudal nobility and clergy—explicitly rejecting the dispersed feudalism he criticized. Militarily, he crossed the Mediterranean and conquered Jerusalem through diplomacy (Sixth Crusade, 1228-1229) without spilling Christian blood, showing imperial pragmatism over religious fanaticism.


r/monarchism • • Jan 26 '23

Tier List My tier list for the kings and queens of the UK

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/monarchism • • Jan 06 '24

Discussion I’m worried with the amount of people who are against or at least uncomfortable with LGBTQ+ topics.

0 Upvotes

Ive been on this sub for a long time and I honestly feel very uncomfortable with some of the opinions here when it comes to some monarchists opinions on homosexuality and other lgbt topics.

I’ve seen some that are more subtle, such as trying to fit the narrative that some historically homosexual monarchs were NOT homosexual because there’s no “exact” proof or written statement that directly prove it.

But some I’ve seen are more blatantly hateful messages, and it’s honestly upsetting to see. Such as some claiming that homosexuals or “queers” are sodomites and sub-human and are not meant to be treated as humans and more like “sinners or disgusting animals”. Others I’ve seen are spreading equally hateful messages and with similar ties to their religion, which I feel is a stain on the name of Christ who would’ve never advocated for homosexuals to be killed.

I personally find monarchism to have nothing to do with hate. And it’s very upsetting that some monarchists act this way and promote their hateful ideology on this subreddit.

But I also don’t see how monarchism has anything to do with hate and it’s upsetting that some are claiming to be the voices of “true” monarchist values, when all their doing is spreading hate and actual bigotry.

A monarchs job is not to dictate how individuals feel about others of the same gender or how they should live their lives. A monarchs job is not to spread hate and cause further division among a nation.

A monarchs job is to provide the nation with unity and stability, displaying a unifying symbol that all can look up to, no matter what race, gender, sexuality, ext.

I’m a simi-continue monarchist myself and a homosexual male. I am happy the way I am and who I am with.

I hope others will understand why hateful messages hidden under the banner of “true monarchist values” is damaging to everyone else and why it’s so upsetting and concerning to see it more rampant.


r/monarchism • • Jul 29 '26

Photo The Shah of Iran and members of his staff spotted attending the beautiful funeral ceremony of Senator Lindsey Graham, who was a great friend and supporter of the Iranian people.

Thumbnail
gallery
52 Upvotes

r/monarchism • • Jul 31 '24

Discussion Beware of the dangers of Monarcho-Social Democracy. Refining the monarchist movement to its original essence (returning to tradition, one could say)

14 Upvotes

In summary:

  • Monarcho-social democracy, which is unfortunately gaining more and more traction among monarchs, is a perversion of the original purpose of kings as being a spontaneously emerged leadership role within a tribe due to a person and/or family's excellence in ensuring their tribe's security and flourishing. Monarcho-social democracy it is in fact Republicanism in monarchical clothing, as all that is unique with monarcho-social democracy is the creation of a State machinery which will inevitably try to wrestle control from the king (see the remaining monarchies of the West, such as Sweden where the king has become a mere puppet for a Social Democratic State machinery). It is crucial for monarchists to never forget that the purpose of a king is to assume a leadership role for the preservation of the integrity, property and tradition of a specific tribe/community.

  • A way to learn how to think in this original monarchical sense is to acquaintance oneself with the political theory regarding decentralization and natural law: such theory enables you to think more creatively as to ensure that you know how to think with regards to creating social structures which are able to the most efficiently preserve family, property and tradition. It is important to remember that monarchy is a means to an end; not every monarch is worth defending just because they are a monarch.

    • For an unambiguous (maybe there are real life instances, but I feel that some Redditor would point me some minute abuses which would obscure the point; even if it is fictional, it demonstrates the point) example of these concepts in action, I would recommend viewing the Théoden and the people of Rohan in their struggle against foreign subjugation. It, much like intended by the monarchist Tolkein, perfectly captures the aesthetic of what a real king should be: a law-abiding leader, not a despotic ruler.

  • A litmus test whether you truly have internalized these ideas is to check whether you can see borders like these and feel a sense of awe and fascination. If your gut reflex is: "Guh, we need to make these borders more logical 🤓🤓🤓", you are thinking like a Jacobin.

  • If you disagree with this understanding of kingship as one of being a leader, as opposed to a ruler with a State machinery, then I urge you to bring me to your thought leaders. Whatever causes this misunderstanding must end: I don't ever want to see another monarchist argue for a One World Government.

The problem: increased awareness of monarchism, which is unfortunately diverted by superficially appealing social democracy

A concerning trend I have seen among monarchists is what I call monarcho-social democracy or social democracy with monarchist characteristics. It is basically social democracy with monarchist aesthetics.

This is a problem because such a philosophy is a mere perversion of the true essence of monarchism: family, property and tradition.

As Lavader wisely puts in his video Everything You Were Taught About Medieval Monarchy Is Wrong, the original monarchs were simply representatives of specific tribes who spontaneously arose to the top as leaders within a tribe, as opposed to rulers. This ressembles the idea which natural law advocates like Murray Rothbard and Hans-Hermann Hoppe advocate for with their accent on closely-knit and sovereign communities.

Tragically, and painfully so, people who point out such glaring flaws in the anti-monarchist narrative are oftentimes the very same people who advocate for left-wing economic policies and politics in a thinly veiled monarcho-socialist, be it intentionally or not. Whether they realize it or not, this kind of monarcho-social democracy is merely a form of Republicanism in monarchist clothing.

If you subsidize single-parent households, you will get more singe-payer households; if you subsidize immigration, you will get more immigration; if you have monopolies on law and order, you will, as in any other industry, get increasing prices and decreasing quality. If you don't even dare to budge your local State's borders, then you are a very predictable controlled opposition.

Reminder that monarchism is not blind crown worship, but creation of social structures conducive to the preservation of kin, property and tradition

Too many monarchists fall for the trap of thinking that monarchism is dogmatic bootlicking of everyone who wears a crown.

As described above, monarchism is far from that, but primarily concerns itself with creating social structures with which to preserve one's kinship, property and traditions. Kings were originally just individuals within the tribe or kin who excelled in being leaders - not ones who expropriated from their fellow kin.

To this end, it is beneficial for monarchists to learn to at least embrace a decentralized way of thinking about political matters which puts preservation of kin, property and tradition in focus, as to not fall into the trap of blindly worshiping authority, which is counter productive to this end. The focus should always be on these things, never slip and make it into worship about State power, which is unfortunately too easy to do. The correct mindset is that one thinks of one's tribe and wants their sovereignty AS A PEOPLE (not in the State sense) to be secured.

Political structures should be formed around the purpose of preserving these things, and should consequently be attentively scrutinized with regards to their attainment of these ends.

To be able to do that, it is important to have a sound theoretical framework.

A real monarchist:

While it is indeed fictional (I nonetheless think that The Lord of the Rings excellently conveys the monarchical aesthetic, strong recommendation if you truly want to get into the mindset), I nonetheless think that king Théoden of the people of Rohan are a perfect unambiguous example of the approach I am elucidating here. Kings are supposed to be excellent leaders, not despotic tyrants; they gain the respect from their subjects by excelling in enabling them to protect their kin, property and traditions, not by whimsically unilaterally imposing their wills upon them. Kings are supposed to be leaders, not rulers. Once a king establishes a State apparatus (which will by the way inevitably start to try to wrestle control from the king), then the perversion of the leadership role starts and the tribe is on course to be subjugated by a despotic master.

The dream which a refined monarchism is conducive towards

I dream of a future where a wide variety of communities and peoples peacefully coexist in an international economic order in which the justice of natural law is respected and enforced. I dream of a Europe of 1000 Liechtensteins.

Are you with me?


r/monarchism • • Apr 22 '24

Question Why do people praise Hakkon VII for appointing a Labour PM but criticize Victor Emmanuel III for appointing Mussolini?

0 Upvotes

I don’t get how people can praise Hakkon VII for appointing a communist in office but then criticize VEIII for making Mussolini PM despite widespread support and a political crisis. Communism is more evil than fascism and although Hornstrud’s time as PM would be 18 days, both Nygaardsvold and Gerhardsen would do irreparable damage to the country by nationalizing industries and healthcare which lead to massive stagnation until the late 90s and created a culture that relies on the government for support. VEIII made the only reasonable decision at the time. So why is he hated for that but Hakkon declaring himself king of communists ok? If he appointed a fascist and said he was king of fascists would that be fine?


r/monarchism • • Aug 14 '23

Tier List Tier list for every king of Norway

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/monarchism • • Jul 05 '26

Question What would monarchists think about Communism if the Soviet Union was actually successful (but still a totalitarian regime)?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/monarchism • • Jun 12 '25

Meme Seriously can someone give me an example that isnt tainted by Christian Fundamentalism?

Post image
24 Upvotes

The only example I can think off are the French Nobles who joined the third estate and founded the National Assembly.


r/monarchism • • Sep 25 '24

News 'Monumental step' as Thai king signs same-sex marriage into law

Thumbnail
news.abs-cbn.com
21 Upvotes

Exciting news!


r/monarchism • • Nov 12 '24

Misc. If Donald Trump gets crowned in 2028

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/monarchism • • Aug 11 '20

Meme God communists suck

Post image
312 Upvotes

r/monarchism • • Aug 28 '22

Discussion Polish monarch

3 Upvotes

Who would you support as a new polish dynasty? I excluded germans (catholic Windsors are an exception, because i have a great respect for them, because they converted to catholicism) and polish nobility, because they don't deserve to rule Poland.

453 votes, Aug 31 '22
166 Catholic member of Windsor dynasty
86 Bernadotte dynasty
51 Braganza dynasty
34 House of Orléans-Braganza
26 House of Orléans
90 House of Bourbon, some branch of it

r/monarchism • • Aug 14 '22

Question non-homophobic monarchist community?

0 Upvotes

Hello, I am an asexual and trans monarchist currently part of a monarchist discord server. Sadly I keep seeing people glorifying burning pride flags and protesting our literal existance. As well as being personally opposed to this all obviously I don't think this is a good look for our movement either. I obviously don't want to be around people who want me dead (People saying things like "Than he will find himself without a head when he takes the throne") referring to the Wittelsbach heir. If anyone knows a more tolerant monarchist community please let me know.


r/monarchism • • Apr 06 '21

Photo The best Empire the Middle East ever had.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/monarchism • • Jan 13 '23

Discussion Divine right to rule is outdated

3 Upvotes

Do you agree or disagree? Tell me in the comments and keep all conversations civil.


r/monarchism • • Aug 26 '21

Politics r/monarchism should stand with the other subs demanding that reddit admins need to take a stand against COVID misinformation and disinformation.

1 Upvotes

For one thing, the antimask, antivax, and antilockdown groups are nothing more than peasant populist fantasies of which we ought to stand against. They are against the sovereign power of the state and are actively encouraging actions that harm the subjects a monarch should protect with their powers.

Secondly monarchs have historically been arbiters of moral progress, especially when it comes to vaccines. Catherine the Great of Russia was among the first to be inoculated against smallpox, along with her son Paul. Her actions set an example for the Russian people, and millions would be inoculated because of this. We need to take the moral high ground here, as is our prerogative.


r/monarchism • • Feb 11 '24

Discussion Why parlamentarist monarchy?

0 Upvotes

I saw many liberals in this server and it is so strange because liberalism is the opposite of monarchy. So why you follow monarchy? For the aesthetics?


r/monarchism • • Mar 03 '26

History Iran

0 Upvotes

They’ve had quite a miserable time since leftist mobs overthrew their Shah haven’t they? Perhaps their best alternative, after almost a half century of misery, would be to send an invitation to Reza Pahlavi. I can’t imagine anyone could worry it would be worse.


r/monarchism • • Sep 17 '26

Discussion "He will be a martyr"

Post image
0 Upvotes

I am a socialist. At first I only came to this subreddit out of curiosity and a good laugh, only to be surprised I found like-minded and rational people who only want what's best for their country and landed on the path of monarchy,

not to be subjugated and dominated to by a man/woman whose greatest achievement was winning the lottery of life,

but for a none political figure to that unifies the people and preserves the tradition and culture of a country and most importantly to persevere the rights of and the will of his/her people.

"the power of the crown is the power it deprives others."

I am disappointed by the recent discussion about the prince of Liechtenstein vetoing the rights of his people and commenters championing undemocratic measures.

For people who lament the fall of monarchies and the rise of republics and the threat of turning into a republic, within the very few monarchies left

Why the fuck would you support a monarchy falling in favor of them being a martyr?