That's probably title gore, but it's the honest truth.

The new Mod Mail doesn't seem to fit the current aesthetic design of reddit and makes the whole thing feel kaddy-whompius and like you're viewing a different site entirely than viewing your mod mail for reddit.

The current mod mail feels like you're still part of the reddit website and as such the new mod mail has a very disingenuous ornamental eye candy feel.

If you want us to use this as a full time moderation mail, make it so it actually fits the aesthetics of reddit and doesn't feel like an external site or app when we visit our mail. It's too jarring otherwise.

I like the idea of modmail beta but unless we can start theming it is it useless to me.

Currently I am used to this old dark theming

The new Modmail Beta theme is unusable to me.

So are there plans to allow some theming with the modmail? I don't want to have to hack it myself with greasemonkey and it really should be a key feature. I don't know how well it works on mobile but I feel that is important for some people too.

Cheers,

Just noticed today that there are Help, Terms, Formatting Help and Reply links across the bottom, overlaid by the toolkit status bar. I think most of us use RES toolkit since reddit has a paucity of mod tools.

Opted in already on /r/AsianFeminism. Thanks!

This idiot:

https://mod.reddit.com/mail/all/ffd9

is claiming that they made a comment after they were banned.

But that cannot be the case, as that is the comment which triggered the ban.

According to timestamps, they are correct.

It appears they were banned one hour before they made the fatal comment.

I know it's not there. Just wanted to lend my voice to the call for it in future development. Keep up the great work.

https://imgur.com/lMBlB8z

Mobile, galaxy s5 on chrome app. Tried starting a mod discussion and got this error when I tried to send. I did have 2 users tagged in the post, one a mod and one not a mod (to provide a link to their profile for other mods to use. I used the old /u/ linking system.

It would be very useful for there to be a link to the ban message and any subsequent conversation in the sidebar for a banned user.

Anything I should know off the hop or do I just post here when I come across something?

I keep seeing the green, shield Icon, I have cleared my cookies multiple times, logged out both from modmail and from reddit, Rebooted my notebook several times. Still see the Icon showing you have "new mod mail" It did work for a few hoursafter i cleared the cookies but stopped working.

My "Mark all as read" Button is not working, nada, nothing happens.

I only see about 6-7 mesdsages in the modmal queue, if Iclick one to address it I have to click on the all modmail back button rather than going to the next one in the thread. No threaded modmail.

A lot of mods used the remove tag to mark the submission as being dealt with by turning it red, this function is not available anymore. :(

All in all it seems like you tried too hard. What ever happened to the KISS principle.

It's all way too convoluted for my liking.

Hey,

As the title states, I think it would be a useful feature for us mods to be able to write a message that is sent to the creator of a message to the mods telling them that their mail has been archived and can no longer be viewed, and have that message sent every time a thread is archived (rather than manually typing it)

What do you guys think?

This comment of post has been overwritten. Now that you're here, this is a great documentary: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQRAfJyEsko

Don't know if this is an RES issue or a Reddit issue but switching accounts isn't working. I'll switch accounts and see new modmail lit up green but click it and it goes to the wrong modmail (the account I was previously logged into). I can logout within modmail and login to the correct account, but then when I switch back to Reddit I am logged out of Reddit. Note: the green notification part is working correctly, just not where I wind up when I click it.

Not sure if that's clear, it's kindof a complex interaction but it goes the same way every time. I can never seamlessly check modmail on both accounts and then get back to Reddit. It always requires logging out/in to multiple things.

Chrome/OS X, same thing on two machines.

I use f.lux to shift the blue out of my monitor at night. The new modmail makes it quite difficult to tell which messages are read and which are not when looking through the list while this is active.

This is a very active time for me in the moderation space. Is there any way we can get this more adjustable or a more durable coloration change?

I understand keeping it simple is a goal, but threading is a very basic and very important feature. I don't see any reason not to have it in v1