r/asianfeminism • • Nov 21 '15

History Why They Aren't Completely Wrong When They Say East Asian Girls Try to Look White - A Reflection on East Asian Beauty Standards

174 Upvotes

Introduction

To preface this discussion, I will begin by saying that this analysis will primarily be focused on East Asian beauty standards, and how they have evolved from the ancient to the modern, post-Cold War time period. I know that there are quite a number of people who browse this sub that are Southeast Asian or South Asian in ethnicity/background, so if anybody is interested in posting about the progression of beauty standards pre- and post-Western European contact for these groups, I would be very interested to hear about it.

Modern Beauty Standards-- Straddling Two Worlds

The current East AA woman faces a unique dilemma when it comes to the concept of beauty. Just as the East AA woman is expected to come to terms with two cultures that she faces when growing up, she also faces two very different beauty standards: Western-Anglo and East Asian beauty standards.

The current expectations for the ideal Western woman is as follows:

  • White ethnicity, preferably Anglo-Saxon

  • Blonde hair

  • Light-colored eyes (blue, green, etc.)

  • Small, ski-slope nose

  • Tall

  • Slender, hour-glass figure

  • Long legs

  • Ample bust size

  • Tan, sun-kissed skin

From the East AA woman’s perspective, this is an impossible ideal to achieve, simply because of the fact that many East AA woman do not fit the primary requirement to be considered as the embodiment of hegemonic femininity in Western society--she is not white.

On the other hand, when the East AA woman seeks to find connection to a more attainable beauty standard, she usually seeks out to embody the East Asian beauty standard. However, the East Asian beauty standard still represents an impossibility in attainment, as its standards are as follows:

  • Pale, white skin

  • Large eyes with double eyelids

  • Tall, straight nose with high nose bridge

  • V-line chin

  • Tall

  • Slim with long legs

Double eyelids, within the context of East Asian countries, are especially seen as the mark of someone who possesses extraordinary beauty, being a staple attribute that almost every modern Japanese, Korean, and Chinese celebrity possesses, whether it be attained by birth or by surgery. The upholding of this particular trait has reached a fervor within the past decade, with an ever-increasing amount of surgery being conducted on East AA women in Japan, South Korea, China, and other East Asian countries.

This increase in skin-whitening procedures and Asian blepharoplasty (double eyelid surgery) has unsurprisingly caught the attention of Western media, and has been lambasted consistently as East Asian women hating on their ethnic features and “wanting to become white”. Many opponents of this proposition, most being East AA women, counter back by saying that these beauty standards were formed independently by East Asian cultures, claiming that pale skin has historically been considered beautiful, as a marker of a person from nobility, while double eyelids are possessed by 50% of East AA women and the kind of double eyelid that is desired is a slight fold atop the eyeline instead of the deep folds found in Caucasian women. While both arguments skim upon some truthful elements relating to this phenomenon, the real answer is actually at the intersection of both of these somewhat poorly thought out explanations, and will require an examination of ancient East Asian beauty standards, the role of beauty and its evolution within changing socio-political landscapes, and the development of its current incarnation in the modern era.

Ancient East Asian Beauty Standards (AKA Pre-Modern, Western Colonization Times)

Contrary to the way Western media would have the average viewer believe, East Asian beauty ideals are not as set in stone and rigid as they may seem, and have actually been in flux from time period to time period, as well as differing from country to country (China vs. Japan vs. South Korea). Cultural exchange was quite extensive among East Asian countries for thousands of years, and while each kingdom and time period had its own unique bias towards certain attributes, the primary attributes that were considered beautiful were as follows:

  • Pale skin (the symbol of nobility and wealth) with touches of pink (showing the harmony between white and red)

  • Thick, shiny and long black hair

  • Finely shaped black eyebrows

  • Slender, smooth limbs (think hands, feet, arms, etc.)

These traits were described extensively in poetry and historical accounts of various figures of nobility, with sophisticated phrasing used to describe the beauty of the imperial consorts that had existed at the time as exemplification of extraordinary beauty. Phrases such as pale, white skin being described as “transparent crystal” and “warm jade”, and delicate hands being described as “tender bamboo shoots” were a few of the many ways to describe the exceptionally beautiful East Asian woman.

Despite the similarities found among East Asian countries throughout time, each time period/kingdom had distinct biases towards certain traits, some in opposition with each other over time when East Asian beauty standards are looked at broadly over time and location.

The Joseon Dynasty of Korea (1392-1897), where a rare beauty (절대가인; jeol-dae-ga-in; 絶代佳人) (절세미인; jeol-se mi-in; 絶世美人) was expected to possess the 30 elements of beauty, with three elements fitting into each of the 10 core attributes of exceptional beauty:

  1. skin, teeth, and hands should be white (삼백; sam-baek; “3 whites”; 三白) 2. pupil, brow, and eye lashes should be black (삼흑; sam-heuk; “3 blacks”; 三黑) 3. lips, cheeks, and finger nails should be pinkish (삼홍; sam-hong; “3 reds”; 三紅) 4. neck, head, and limbs should be long (삼장; sam-jang; “3 longs”; 三長) 5. teeth, ears, and feet should be small (삼단; sam-dan; “3 shorts”; 三短) 6. chest, forehead, and the middle of forehead (眉間) should be wide (삼광; sam-kwang; “3 wides“; 三侊) 7. mouth, waist, and ankle should be narrow (삼협; sam-hyeop; “3 narrows”; 三狹) 8. hips, thighs, and breasts should be firm/full/thick (삼태; sam-tae; “3 fulls”; 三汰) 9. finger, neck, and nose should be thin (삼세; sam-se; “3 thins”; 三細) 10. nipple, nose, and head should be small (삼소; sam-so; “3 smalls”; 三小)

Meanwhile, in Japan, during the Edo period (1600-1868) when the Tokugawa shogunate was in power, blackened teeth was considered the epitome of beauty, and long legs in China were never lauded as particularly attractive until the modern era. Breasts in China were never traditionally emphasized, as they were seen as unimportant to the distinguishment of a beautiful woman, and was actually seen as immoral to consider given that “sexiness” was considered to not be exemplified by a pure and virtuous beauty that was likened to the goddesses of ancient Chinese folklore.

The ideal figure was also in constant flux as well throughout history. This is especially seen in the difference in beauty ideals between the Han Dynasty in China (206 BC to 220 AD) and the Tang Dynasty of China (618-907 AD). Yang Guifei of the Tang Dynasty and Zhao Feiyan of the Han Dynasty, two of the Four Great Beauties of Ancient China, were imperial consorts that were known for their exceptional beauty and served as embodiments of the physical ideals of their respective time periods.

Yang Guifei of the Tang Dynasty had wide, round hips, and a plump, full waist. These physical characteristics were deemed desirable due to the country’s cosmopolitan status within the context of the world at the time, and the idea that a woman who had these attributes were not only healthy and able to produce many offspring as deemed necessary by Chinese agrarian beliefs, but also seen as affluent and able to afford excess. Coupled with her overall fitness, she was considered the cosmopolitan beauty of her time with graceful looks, mannerisms and her acclaimed expertise in the vigorous whirling dances of the nomads. On the other hand, Zhao Feiyan of the Han Dynasty possessed a slender figure, with her waist described “as delicate as a sheaf of white silk,” and a slim figure being considered the embodiment of a delicate, pure and virtuous beauty.

These historical records not only show that East Asian societies do not hold a rigid, monolithic standard of beauty, but that the concept of what was considered to be beautiful has varied from kingdom to kingdom and time period to time period, with some beauty ideals that are held in complete opposition to each other.

Windows to the Soul - The Myth of the Universal Beauty of Large Eyes in East Asia

Contrary to the “scientific” studies that Western media has churned out stating that large eyes throughout the world are considered universally beautiful, including East Asia, the historical accounts of the traditionally beautiful East Asian woman have rarely mentioned the importance of double eyelids versus monolids in judging beauty, and some have even held narrow, small eyes in favor of large eyes in some points of history.

Below are some excerpts from Cho Kyo’s “The Search for the Beautiful Woman: A Cultural History of Japanese and Chinese Beauty (Asia/Pacific/Perspectives)”:

...Occasional Contemplations (Jianqing ouji) by the Qing period dramatist Li Yu (1610-1680) contains a section touching on the criteria of female beauty. “Favored Appearances,” the first chapter of volume 6 titled, “Voice and Appearance,” contains a section called “Eyebrows and Eyes,” where the author exclusively discusses how to evaluate eyes and eyebrows. According to this source, the beauty of eyes is determined by three elements: the size, movements, and the relative proportion of the black and white parts. Regarding size, it says that women with slim eyes are of tender nature, whereas those with large eyes are hussies…”

Similar aesthetics exist in Japan. Customs, Manners, and Fashions of the Capital (Miyako fuzoku kewai den) by the cosmetics researcher Sayama Hanashichimaru, published in 1813, states the criteria for beautiful eyes: “Because the eyes are at the center of the face and the first in bringing out the facial features, they should have dignified strength. Yet, eyes that are too large are unsightly. Some people narrow their eyes, forcefully attempting to make them smaller, but the eyelids and outer corners of the eyes become wrinkled producing a squint. This worsens the looks of the eyes.” The expression dignified strength refers to the gaze, and does not mean large eyes. As is clear from the statement that eyes that are too large are unsightly, in the Edo period (1600-1867) large eyes were deemed rather unattractive.

[...]

Later in China, however, detailed references began to be made regarding eye shapes. Particularly interesting is The Grotto of Immortals (Youxian ku), a tale of the strange by Zhang Wencheng (also Zhang Zhuo, 660?-741?) of the Tang period (618-907) about an encounter with two immortal women dwelling in a cavern. It offers a criterion different from today’s emphasis on big, bright eyes as charming and pretty:

Her heart is vacant, hard to fathom,

Her eyes are narrow, they strongly engage my heart,

Turning herself around she’s already in my arms,

Yet to be seen whether she has an amorous voice.

The second line here, “Her eyes are narrow, they strongly engage my heart,” merits particular attention. Opinion may be divided as to whether “eyes are narrow” means that the woman has narrow eyes, or refers to narrowed eyes in a moment when passion is difficult to resist. Either way, the interesting fact remains that narrow-looking eyes were favored. From the viewpoint of eroticism, half-closed eyes may in fact be more attractive in a bedroom than glaring eyes.

However, “eyes are narrow” in The Grotto of Immortals probably indicates narrow eyes as a physical feature rather than a facial expression of the moment. This is because, in China, narrow eyes were long considered beautiful. We can glimpse this, for example, when looking at a figurine from the Han period (figure 1.2). The same aesthetics appears also in a Daoist source discussing bed-chamber skills. Jeweled Chamber Secrets (Yufang mijue), ascribed to the Six Dynasties period (222-589), characterizes the ideal woman:

Ideally, a woman should be young, firm-breasted, well filled out, fine-haired, small-eyed with clear distinction between the white and black parts of the eyes; her facial and bodily skin finely textured and smooth, her voice and way of speaking pleasant to the ear; not large-boned, but rather well founded from the neck down so that no angularity shows.

Here the author clearly defines “small eyes” as ideal. This statement is also quoted in The Essence of Medical Prescriptions (Ishinbo, compiled by Tanba no Yasuyori, 984), the earliest extant Japanese medical text and a compendium covering all areas of health, including the art of love. A similar view is found here and there in other writings on the art of the chamber as well.

Of course, Daoist philosophy is richly present in Jeweled Chamber Secrets, and sex is discussed as one approach to health. However, because it states that health improves through intercourse with a beautiful woman, it is evident that a small-eyed woman was considered beautiful.

[...]

Over the last one hundred years, various aesthetic premises of Western cultures have become familiar in East Asia. There are no tremendous differences in contemporary East Asian views of feminine beauty from those of the West. Before modern times this was not the case, however. Large eyes, for example, are regarded as beautiful today and are made abnormally large in such things as visual fiction targeted at girls and young females (shojo manga). The situation was totally different just one century or so ago. Li Yu of Qing era China said, in his Occasional Contemplations, that women with “large, wild eyes” are tough and unyielding, and that those with “thin, long eyes” are gentle-hearted. Not only did he not evaluate large eyes positively, but he considered them a shortcoming.

So, too, in Edo Japan. The author of Customs, Manners, and Fashions of the Capital considered that women “should, when going out or attending a formal occasion, keep their eyes at eight-tenths level, looking down rather than straight ahead.” Her further introduces a concrete method for achieving this eye level: “Eyes at eight-tenths level” means you should, when standing, look about two yards away from your feet; and, when seated, just beyond one yard away from your knees. If you follow this rule, your eyes will be downcast by themselves, looking narrow.” ...

In regards to double eyelids, it seemed that while they were complimented on some beauties who possessed them at the time, that they were not held in such high esteem as they were today, and were not seen as necessary for a woman to be considered beautiful:

What is most surprising is “eyelids charmingly overlapping.” No mention whatever of double eyelids is seen in Chinese literature before the late Qing. It is unclear whether double eyelids were ever thought beautiful in China before the introduction of Western culture. Takebe Ayatari’s Japanese Outlaws of the Marsh indicates that in Japan the aesthetic sense favoring double eyelids already existed prior to that.

Finding double eyelids attractive was not a matter of fiction removed from reality, but of everyday life. Customs, Manners, and Fashions of the Capital records an eye makeup method in “Part I, Face.” It does not at all say that double eyelids are attractive, but cosmetic illustrations include such eyes. There may not have been today’s adoration of double eyelids then. But it was probably known that double eyelids gave brighter looks to the eyes than single eyelids.

Beauties with monolids were held in high esteem just as much as double eyelids were in the past, as is seen in a painting done by Shin Yunbok, also known as “Hyewon” (1758-?) entitled Portrait of a Beauty, as well as kisaeng Il-seon, the Beauty of Gang-reung.

The judgment of “beautiful eyes” has never been properly described and measured physically in historical records, as it had only been judged based on the impression or feelings that was invoked in a person upon observing the admired person:

Historically, the criteria for “beautiful eyes” have not been immutable. In fact, objective standards for determining eye beauty long remained unclear. In the East in ancient times, the size and shape of the eyes were not particularly important in evaluating female beauty. The expression lucent irises plainly indicates that. The term, meaning clear eyes free from clouding, conveys the impression the eyes give to a viewer, but does not describe the external appearance. Naturally, the impression of the eyes is not unrelated to their appearance. But the impression the viewer receives is the more important of the two aspects. The Japanese expression cool-looking eyes (suzushigena me) must have been created from a similar idea. The English expression bright eyes too, while suggestive of wide-open shapes, is more impressionistic than objective. It is no less ambiguous than lucent irises and cool-looking eyes. In other words, the beauty of eyes is not determined by whether they are large or double lidded, but rather by the impression they convey.

The Introduction of Asian Blepharoplasty (Double Eyelid Surgery)

The first documented Asian blepharoplasty occurred as early as the 19th century, and there has been subsequent documentation of this kind of surgery being performed throughout Japan, Korea, and China since then for medical and cosmetic reasons. However, the first wave of widespread blepharoplasty being performed was initiated during the 1950s in war-torn Korea during the Korean War by late American plastic surgeon, Dr. David Ralph Millard. Millard was critically acclaimed as a titan in his field, praised as the “messiah of children all over the world who were born with facial clefts” and was involved in the Korean War reconstructing the disfigured faces of wounded soldiers.

An excerpt from Wilson Quarterly’s “Eyes Wide Cut: The American Origins of Korea’s Plastic Surgery Craze” by Laura Kurek:

In 1954, Millard was stationed in South Korea as the U.S. Marine Corps’ chief plastic surgeon. He considered it an opportunity to leave a legacy similar to Gillies, who by then was a celebrated innovator in the field. Postwar South Korea offered no shortage of patients for Millard, who deemed the country “a plastic surgeon’s paradise.”

[...]

The historical context of Millard’s visit to Korea perhaps best elucidates the Western connotations that the double-eyelid surgery carries. The Korean War had just exposed the entire country to the Western world via the U.S. military’s presence. After the fighting stopped, Koreans sought to emulate the people they now associated with influence, money, and power. “More critical than the surgery itself,” writes John DiMoia in Reconstructing Bodies, “was the postwar context in which it took place, with medical relief frequently mobilized as evidence of benevolent intentions, conveniently ignoring the power differences embedded within the U.S.-ROK [Republic of Korea] relationship.”

An excerpt from The Korea Herald’s “Uncovering History of Double Eyelid Surgery” by Claire Lee:

According to Kim, Millard was stationed in Korea during the war as part of an American public relations campaign to show “American’s benevolent face to the Koreans.” On top of developing and performing double eyelid surgery ― which was the alteration of “Oriental” features to “Occidental” ― he was also committed to serving those who were severely injured on the battlefield and in need of surgical reconstruction.

During the war, Korean eyes without the crease ― referred to as the superior palpebral fold in American medical texts ― were dubbed “slanted,” and were seen as a mark of inscrutability and deviance. In her text, Kim argued that it was significant that Millard, who is one of the pioneers of Asian double eyelid surgery, was a military surgeon whose experience of Asian bodies was firmly rooted in Cold War ideologies and discourses.

“Surgically altering the ‘slanted’ eyes became a mark of a ‘good’ and trustworthy Asian, one whose modification of the face provided a comforting illustration of the pliable Asian, and served as evidence of the U.S. as the model and Asia as the mimic,” Kim wrote.

War brides and prostitutes were among the most common types of patients that Millard would receive for a blepharoplasty procedure. This was encouraged by American nationalists after the War Brides Acts in 1945 allowed American GIs to bring back East Asian wives after the war:

In such a political climate, Korean military brides were considered both cultural and racial threats to the U.S., which influenced many Korean women, especially those who wished to marry American soldiers, to alter their eyes in the 1950s.

“It is felt that this deorientalizing problem may well come home to the American plastic surgeon, for there have been well over 10,000 Japanese war brides as well as many post-war marriages with Korean girls,” wrote the American surgeon Millard in 1955.

According to Yuh Ji-yeon’s 2002 study on Korean military brides, the women who were brought to American families at the time were strictly pressured to nurture their children as future Americans and provide their husbands with an American lifestyle: “Their fear was that, unless properly Americanized, the women would ‘foreignize’ their husbands and children.”

David Palumbo-Liu’s book, “Asian American: Historical Crossings of a Racial Frontier” talks about how cosmetic surgery reduced such American anxieties by demonstrating the “shaping power of the U.S.” and the “malleability of Asia.”

By altering their eyes, the Korean brides became less threatening racially, while their “passive, compliant” nature would make them easily assimilate, according to the studies.

[...]

“While it is primarily beauty that motivates (today’s women’s) desire to alter their eyes, this beauty is built on a legacy of a history of Western science and race that privileged the white body as the normal, beautiful body,” Kim wrote in her study.

[...]

Cultural critic Moonwon Lee tells the Korea Herald that while people don’t personally believe they’re trying to look white by getting their eyelids done or other plastic surgeries, they’re still moving away from Korean-ness. The big eyes, small faces, and perky noses that are hallmarks of beauty in Korea aren’t natural to most Koreans, he says.

The Role of Beauty in a Socio-political Context

The following are excerpts from The Search for the Beautiful Woman: A Cultural History of Japanese and Chinese Beauty regarding socio-political influence and dominance, and its impact on the perception of beauty.

Have universal standards for determining beauty emerged with the global reach of consumer culture and of the media? As products of multinational enterprises transcend national boundaries to spread worldwide, people of different races and nations have come to use the same cosmetics, and people of different skin colors and facial and bodily features have come to don similar fashions.

As a result, the fact that different cultures have different standards of beauty was forgotten before we realized it. In earlier epochs, different cultures shared no common conception of beauty. In ancient times, each culture held a different image of beautiful women. This was naturally so when cultures were widely different, say, between Western Europe and East Asia, but images were not identical even between closely connected cultures.

Historical accounts of foreigners from the European and East Asian perspective indicated that not only were the aesthetics of facial features noted to be different from their respective viewpoints, but were also thought of as ugly. A typical European viewpoint of East Asian looks is as follows:

The Portuguese Dominican friar Gaspar da Cruz (1520-1570), who visited China in the mid-sixteenth century, portrayed Chinese people, in his South China in the Sixteenth Century, as having “small eyes, low noses, large faces.” Matteo Ricci (1552-1610, the Italian Jesuit priest who lived in China starting in 1582, wrote, “Men’s beards are thin and meager and at times they have none at all. Their hair is rough and straight… The narrow, elliptical eyes are noticeably black. The nose is small and flat.” While neither missionary directly says Chinese are ugly, discomfort lurks between the lines.

Similarly, East Asians also viewed the Europeans as foreign and ugly, and compared their appearance to monkeys from the mountains. It was very interesting to see that the attributes that many people today hold in such high esteem were looked down upon historically in East Asian societies:

...[Yan Shigu (581-645) of the Tang period] characterizes the Dutch as having “deep set eyes and a long nose, with the hair, eyebrows, and beard equally red.” Seemingly an objective depiction of physical characteristics, the passages uses the words deep set eyes and long noses with a clearly derogatory nuance. The term red hair (hongmao) as a disparaging alias for Westerners began to be used around. Likewise, “red hair, jasper eyes” (hongmao biyan) was a negative expression. As in Tang China (618-684, 705-907), red hair (or gold hair) and blue eyes were directly connected to the image of wild animals. Such a view finally reversed itself in modern times

This passage is an interesting observation of how people view others of a different ethnicity and how they differ from one gender to another:

When looking at people of a different race or ethnicity, whether the observation is of the same gender can affect aesthetic judgments. There are many examples in which, in the eyes of male observers, foreigners of the same gender look ugly, yet women look beautiful. Siebold and Thunberg mentioned above, as well as the German physician and naturalist Engelberg Kaempfer (1651-1716), write in their travelogues that Japanese women are quite lovely. Likewise, even if Western women looked attractive to a Qing government official, he may not necessarily have similarly assessed Western men.

Overall, when viewing the significance that beauty plays in gender relations, one must recognize that beauty and aesthetic judgment is a reflection of an understanding of power hierarchies:

Judging comparative beauty of two human groups invariably involves a perception of hierarchy, or power relations, between them. Aesthetic judgment about racial and ethnic groups involves power relations between cultures. Stated simply, a people whose civilization is regarded as highly developed is likely to be viewed as physically appealing, whereas an ethnic group deemed “backward” is considered ugly. So long as the “backward” culture remains unaware of its backwardness, members do not think of themselves as ugly. But once hierarchical consciousness is established, the aesthetic of physical features rapidly changes.

This is the reason that, today, Westerners are considered beautiful. It is not just Westerners themselves who think this; people in developing countries also do. Such aesthetic sense perfectly corresponds with ideologies pertaining to “the West” and “the East,” and “advanced” and “backward” countries.

Beauty in the Role of Interracial Relations

Within the context of East Asian societies and East Asian diaspora in Western countries, a Westernized appearance has been indoctrinated throughout the past few decades to a new generation of young people of East Asian descent. Contrary to what many East Asians may try to convince themselves to believe, light-colored hair dye, colored contact lens, eyelid tapes and double eyelid plastic surgery are not beauty trends that developed independently and in a vacuum. It is far from it at all, considering that, prior to the development of these products, the spread of Western white supremacy has been ongoing for over a century in these countries.

In the context of interracial relations, this is prevalent in the cases of both East Asian men and women. The upholding of the Western white man and woman as the epitome of high status and beauty has radically shifted the understanding of what it means to be a beautiful and desirable person in society in today’s global context. While the modern beauty standards in East Asia and Western societies may seem completely different from each other, in actuality, they are actually much more closely related to each other than one can imagine. This is the reason why a Chinese person stuck in the middle of nowhere in China could consider white people to be beautiful even if they have never actually seen a white person in person. From the very moment they are born, even if they have never had any contact with white people, the concept that a person who possesses more Anglo features is beautiful has already been indoctrinated into the mind.

This also explains the reason why many people consider “mixed babies” and “hapas” to be “beautiful” and “adorable”, especially when they are mixed with white parents. The upholding of features that are possessed by Western white people can be seen throughout East Asia, from featuring celebrities who are of mixed white-East Asian parenthood to the recent trend of the “Haafu” look that is ongoing in Japan at the moment. Hapas of half-white and half-East Asian heritage are viewed as superior and a step above full East Asians, similar to the way that light-skinned black slaves in America were offered positions in the house instead of the field like their darker-skinned counterparts. Combine this with the Confucian mindset that a parent’s status is a reflection of the child’s success in life, and that it is the parent’s duty to sacrifice in order to provide the best possible outcome for the child’s future, and this explains the reason why there has been an increase in intermarriage between whites and East Asians over the years. The appearance of a child that possesses the physical traits that are upheld in society contributes greatly to the way they will be received in society, and this is especially the case for women, whose value has historically been linked to their physical appearance and who also understand how important this attribute will play in their and their future daughters’ prospects in gaining a favorable position in society. The mindset that by marrying white is to provide a better future for future children with regards to status and desired appearance lies as one of the core reasons for the high prevalence of interracial marriage between whites and East Asians for both genders.

Personal Thoughts

The East Asian monolid is a unique trait that East Asians possess by a large percentage. No other trait is as much ours as the East Asian monolid, and to reject this physical attribute in the context of modern Western-influenced beauty standards is a rejection of our ancestors’ ideals of beauty and its important place in history, its evolutionary benefits (protects eyes against sandstorms and insulates from extreme temperatures), and most importantly, ourselves. And while I do not deny the fact that East Asians with large eyes and double eyelids can be beautiful, it leaves something to be considered when we reject almost half of an entire population as unattractive simply because they don’t possess one tiny attribute that has historically been ignored until the 20th century. So even if it's still considered an "ugly" trait by many, I'll be sitting right here rooting for my monolid sisters Ahn Sohee, Gain, Kim Yuna, and Park Ji Hye.

TL;DR: Large eyes and double eyelids have never historically been considered to be universally beautiful in East Asian societies until extensive contact was made with Western Europeans in the 20th century. The current beauty standards found in East Asia are an offshoot of the imperialistic tendencies of the West during the Cold War era. This still affects us today in the way we perceive our own beauty and how we view interracial relationships, particularly with white people.

Sources:

The Search for the Beautiful Woman: A Cultural History of Japanese and Chinese Beauty (Asia/Pacific/Perspectives) by Cho Kyo

Traditional Korean Beauty (First post, translation of Korean article about Traditional Korean Beauty Standards)

Evolution of Beauty Standards

Ancient Chinese Beauty -- Blessings and Curses

Uncovering History of Double Eyelid Surgery

Eyes Wide Cut: The American Origins of Korea's Plastic Surgery Craze


r/asianfeminism • • Feb 14 '17

Media asian female who is a rebel? Give 'em a streak of color

Post image
85 Upvotes

r/asianfeminism • • Feb 27 '17

Discussion There's something really fucking creepy going on and I need to know what the fuck it's all about.

75 Upvotes

I just unsubbed from like 3 other Asian-oriented subs because there is some godawful policing going on there and the mods are having a hard time dealing with it.

I'm talking about the weird fucking obsession with Asian women by redpillers disguising themselves as social progressives by hiding behind the Asian label.

The Hapa Problem

The second an Asian woman talks about her experience, she gets attacked from all sides about how she's probably awful, racist, and self-misogynist. This is especially true if she talks about Asian men and, for some fucking reason, hapas.

All the discussion I've read, even when it wasn't actually about half-Asian/half-white people, went basically like this:

hapa hapa hapa hapa hapa hapa hapa hapa hapa hapa hapa hapa hapa hapa hapa hapa

I'm really fucking tired of reading that word. I'd never even heard of it until I came over to reddit and was harassed for having a white partner.

When I called it out, you know what happened? Immediately it was all about how Asian men are sidelined, how they're nice, how they're like, totally feminist, how I and other Asian women never give Asian men a chance, everything is hapa hapa hapa hapa hapa hapa--

And then we get policed on how awful we are for mistreating them, how they're valid, how they don't deserve this, how I'm actually oppressing myself and everyone else... for making my own choices in life while being Asian and female. No, that's somehow an oppression against the world. I'm not saying that the White-Man/Asian-Woman pairing isn't a more common trend when it comes to interracial marriage than other pairings, but come on. You wouldn't attack a woman for choosing to be a housewife, regardless of whatever vacuum or trend or self-oppression it might be, would you? And why does it have to be about the babies we'll be pushing out?

None of this sounds like feminism, or anti-racism, or social justice. This sounds a hell of a lot like misogyny and tone policing.

These People Are All Dressed Up Nice Guys, With A Healthy Dose of Racism.

The words that they use sound pretty, with social justice buzzwords like POC, Men of Color, standards of beauty, institutionalised racism, cultural vacuum, and internalised beliefs. But in the end, most of the so-called discussions can be boiled down to "Why don't Asian women date a nice Asian guy like me? They're all dating those balding white asshole men and it's causing me to suffer! Because it's the hapas the hapas the hapas the hapas the hapas the hapas" -- it's a broken record. Supposedly there are a lot of hapas who also claim that this is the ultimate oppression, even thinking it completely sound to PM me and ask me, on behalf of all hapas everywhere, to abort my hapa sons. Because, obviously, it's only decent when I'm going to be racist against myself like this. Who the hell says this and thinks, yes, this sounds like feminism! Let me just reduce a woman to her uterus and her baby making abilities and add that she has a duty to make them all pureblooded!!

And I can't possibly be the only one. It wasn't even my thread, it was /u/RagingFuckalot's thread which was immediately taken over by people who got frothy in the mouth for calling out the trend.

Of course, in the real world, I doubt this is very common. I've never come across this before except in reddit. And supposedly we should just focus on the fee-fees of Asian men and these non-Asian-male-derived hapa spawn, as we are frequently implored to do, and understand their plights on not being dated by us, and maybe we should just be racist from now on in order to fight racism. All the while having our experiences and thoughts and opinions repeatedly squashed down and attacked.

Is This The Real Life? Is This Just Fantasy?

Now, I've assumed so far that we're all actual feminists here, hence the lack of the disclaimers like #NotAllMen. But, like, take a look at the OKCupid race article. 1% more Asian men than Asian women in 2009 felt that interracial marriage was a bad idea, but 98% of Asian women and 97% of Asian men said no, it wasn't bad. 5% more Asian men than women "strongly preferred to date a person of their own background." (82% and 76% respectively said no, they didn't.) Overall, Asian people, both men and women, are not racist as fuck. But where did these extreme minorities of racism go? Funny, isn't it? Isn't it odd how the narratives change for these guys on reddit? Isn't it odd that no one's going to talk about how black women are singlehandedly ignored and discriminated against in the dating arena, more than Asian men ever have, even from their black brothers? No? Yeah, I thought so.

Now, granted, that article was from 2009. Here's the fun article damning them even more as they look at trends going to 2014. Asian women are attracted to Asian men more than any other group. Not only that, but adding Asian + white to your race card actually increases your attractiveness rating, so no, that can't be it, either. (And no, I won't go into the standard of beauty here because that would be derailing and I assume that we all know about it anyway, but if you want to talk about it, go ahead.)

What do we actually see?

Yes, Asian men do receive lower ratings from non-Asian women, but not from Asian women, who are just like the other three groups in that they prefer their own race. And black men suffer just as hard as Asian men do. And Asian men are just as complicit in racial bias (especially against black women) as everyone else. And that though Asian women on these averages seem to prefer white men and Asian men, they preferred Asian men more in the most recent one, 2014. And also, keep in mind that women in general have to be pickier and more judgemental in OKC than men are because men and women play completely different games to each other in online dating.

So no, this trend of angry (at least partially Asian) men raging against the hapas and the women that supposedly create them is not justified. This tiny group given a brigading voice on reddit is not justified. Especially because they're not even going to address the myriad of other problems within the social justice scene regarding all POC, not just their own problems. Aren't you going to talk about your black and latino friends or are you just going to tell them to STFU? (God, that whole user reads like a parody but there you have it.)

I'm really fucking tired of it. But, well, I want to discuss it first with everyone to see what their thoughts were before we all move on with our lives.

TL;DR: An Asian fuckboy does not lose his fuckboy label when he's Asian. There is an extraordinary push about how Asian men are the only ones that suffer, or that these hapas suffer. This attacking is pretty much only about how Asian men don't get any dates. And the main method of approaching it is by blaming Asian women and their supposedly hapa babies. Isn't that gross and creepy as fuck? Can we talk about this in a more in depth light?


r/asianfeminism • • Apr 27 '17

Discussion Woke Asian guy's Twitter Thread

Thumbnail
twitter.com
53 Upvotes

r/asianfeminism • • Feb 03 '17

Disgusting Dating Site Teaches Creepy White Guys How to Land an Asian Woman

Thumbnail
nextshark.com
50 Upvotes

r/asianfeminism • • Jul 05 '17

Media The Asian stars of 'Hawaii Five-0' quit the show after CBS refused to pay them as much as their white costars

Thumbnail
google.com
49 Upvotes

r/asianfeminism • • Jan 30 '16

Relationships We Asian women should call it out when other Asian women trash Asian men

48 Upvotes

"It would be nice to see Asian women call out other Asian women when one of them says something blatantly racist about their fellow Asian men. Unfortunately, I rarely see this happening. Hopefully things are changing.....

It's a shitty situation and it pains me whenever i hear a fellow asian woman tell me they "don't date asian guys" because of some assinine joy luck club reason. There's so much fuckery.

All I know is that in teacher's college, many of the young white teacher candidates could be overheard planning to go over to teach English in Japan/Korea/Taiwan, where "getting pussy" was like "shooting fish in a barrel." I heard this statement numerous times. Every time it made me want to puke. Ever since I have eyed guys who go overseas to Asia to "teach English" with a certain amount (okay, a massive amount) of suspicion.

Ultimately, their issues are our issues. The objectification and hypersexualization of Asian women occurs as the other side of the coin of the demonization of Asian men.


r/asianfeminism • • Mar 14 '18

Personal Experience A Letter to Asian Girls

Thumbnail
etcetera.org.au
46 Upvotes

r/asianfeminism • • Dec 30 '15

Relationships Something for Asian feminism to address: Being seen as the easy (back-up) option for (white) rejects

46 Upvotes

We are the option for white men who are rejected by other women, who are misogynist, who are racist, who are unattractive, etc. Asia itself has become a destination for losers looking to score. We are seen as the easy option, the ones who will worship them. While those uppity white feminazis rejected him, Asian women will be good, submissive, easy women who best of all love white men. Woohoo!

Asians have their unique issues. They don't always fit into mainstream liberal narratives (not that other minorities really do either, but you get the gist.) There is nothing for us there. They themselves prop up people like Maxine Kingston who are damaging.


r/asianfeminism • • Jan 28 '16

Personal Experience My Experiences with White People and Their Reactions to My Preference for "Asianness"

45 Upvotes

Listed below are a few of the more memorable experiences that I have had when I had expressed an interest in anything "Asian":

  1. My white childhood friend of over 10+ years had been exposed to Asian entertainment due to my constant pushing of it onto her, and had grown up to eventually be attracted to Asian men. Oddly enough, she was also a big fan of Amy Tan's Joy Luck Club. When I had stated my preference for Asian guys, she quizzically asked me, "emcee, you don't have to listen to your parents. Wouldn't you rather fall in love instead of marrying a rich Asian doctor that your parents picked for you?" When I asked her why it was okay for her to like Asian guys and why it wasn't okay for me to prefer Asian guys, she laughed it off by saying, "Because interracial relationships are progressive and show the world that we're all becoming more equal." She then proceeded to tell me that she's pretty sure that Asian guys would probably prefer blonde hair and blue eyes (which she had) instead of just black hair and brown eyes because it was unique and pretty.

  2. One of my white college friends and her roommate knew a white guy friend that had developed a crush on me, and for several weeks, had tried to get me to spend more time with him and be with him. When the white guy had finally plucked the courage to ask me out and I had calmly turned him down, these two white girls (both of whom had been watching from afar) came up to me and asked me why did I not like him, considering that they thought he was good for me. It was odd, because later on, they told me that they didn't find that same white guy to be attractive either. When I had told them that I did not find him attractive, and that I had actually found an Asian guy that I had liked in my class and that I preferred Asian men, these girls immediately began to criticize Asian men, asking "Why are you attracted to Asian guys?" and "Don't you think that not liking white guys is kind of racist?" Later on in the night, behind their dorm room, I had heard them talking about how they didn't find Asian men attractive and they couldn't understand why I liked them over the guy that they had picked for me.

  3. The same white guy from #2 once had a conversation with me about how we see ourselves after we had graduated from college. I had told him that I potentially wanted to move into an Asian enclave so I was close to the people, food, language, and thought that it could be a really good place to raise children in. He then asked me, "Why would you want to close yourself off with the same kinds of people every single day? Wouldn't you want to be exposed to more diversity in your life? I don't think it's good to have enclaves considering you're all just closing yourself off and not learning how to interact with other people."

  4. I had a white friend who I had met via a mutual international student friend. When we were poring through her copies of fashion and beauty magazines, I had pointed out that none of the beauty looks offered were doable on my face considering that I had a different eye shape compared to the girls featured in the magazine, and lamented why the magazine couldn't be more inclusive to girls of other races. She got upset and snapped, "Why does everything have to be about racism with everybody?"


Whether it be products, living situations, dating choices, or media, I have noticed that whenever I express an interest in anything "Asian", there is almost always an immediate reaction against them and an attempt at either dismissing my opinions or outright bashing my choices. Unsurprisingly, this is perpetuated by white people, given that the culture and society that we live in was created for them and their interests. It seems that when you break the consensus of what's preferable, there is an immediate backlash at making sure that they "keep you in line" and have you uphold the status quo of what is preferable and what isn't in society.

Have any of you ever experienced backlash from white people when you have expressed a preference for "Asianness"? Very interested in hearing your experiences.


r/asianfeminism • • Dec 22 '16

Activism Asian Male Issues...and Asian Feminists. How Can We Help?

42 Upvotes

This is something I have been wanting to talk about again for a long time: how Asian feminists (AFs) can relate to Asian male (AM) issues.

No, I’m not here to talk about toxic behaviors displayed by certain AMs who fell into harmful, misogynistic, white supremacist ideologies. A lot of us have stories galore about our interactions with them, including myself, but sorry trolls, I’m not feeding you today.

I’m talking about the Asian men who believe in building our Asian community--or perhaps haven’t found community yet. These are the men who recognize the problem of white supremacy and want to combat it in their own lives and our community. Toxic individuals have poisoned the well and burnt many bridges, leaving many of us hesitant, exhausted, or even afraid to talk about AM issues without harassment. I’ve certainly felt this way myself. Despite this, Asian feminists should not be intimidated into remaining silent on a topic that directly affects our own well-being and the future of our community. The deep-seated insecurities in these individuals must be prevented from forming in our sons and younger brothers, who wreck the community under the guise of AM issues when in reality they’re white supremacist puppets. Asian men’s image in Western countries directly impacts the safety and well-being of Asian women all around the world. Disrespect for Asian men leads to disrespect for Asian women, as many truly believe that if the men are weak, the women must be even weaker. As wrong as that is, this is what we’re up against.

I know I’m repeating the word “community” ad nauseam, but at this point we do not have the luxury of being viewed as individuals, as whites do. In America, all of us are ch*nks. I hope this will change, but probably not in any of our lifetimes. In the end, we are each responsible for our own choices and cannot place the blame on either AFs or AMs as groups for the struggles we experience at the hands of racism. AMs hold up half the sky; they are part of our community too. Their issues are our issues.

The most harmful lies are those mixed with truth. Asian-on-Asian atrocities throughout history, economic struggles, and patriarchal cultural norms to the present day have given rise to a host of stereotypes about Asian men. Asian women were/are abused, sold, trafficked, and abandoned as children. Western civilization has fed many of us a version of history that neglects to mention or downplays driving forces such as Britain encouraging the opium trade, just to mention one off-hand example. Moreover, it preys on the insecurities we all face growing up as “other” in Western countries by telling us the issues we escaped from in the old countries are still what define us in a new land. Know history, but don’t repeat it.

One of the first steps is to validate the other side’s feelings and experiences, a very basic skill in communication. Just because you have never personally experienced or witnessed a phenomenon, or the fact that you may have seen/experienced the complete opposite yourself, does not mean someone else's experience is necessarily false. Letting others share their experiences, expressing sympathy and support, and asking about ways to help goes a long way towards building trust and collaboration. Some of what you hear may make you uncomfortable, and that’s ok. It may be an opportunity for self-reflection, it may be an opportunity to acknowledge where the person speaking may be at in his individual journey to awareness (none of us have arrived). However, the minute someone attempts to guilt/blame you by applying blanket generalizations to you as an individual, or to force you to act as some sort of ambassador/spokesperson for your gender, the conversation does need to end (or shouldn’t start at all).

Ask an Asian man how you can help, and depending on his life experiences, the answer will inevitably vary. Generally speaking, sharing articles, images, studies, and history is useful in building our community’s knowledge base. Social media is a powerful tool to share Asian media or images of Asian male role models for all of us to look up to. (Twitter taught us to never underestimate a rabid crowd of teenage female fans. #1D) It's ironic that some of the most vocal fans of, say, kpop or anime, are non-Asian and dominate the social media discourse for those fanbases. Their cultural insensitivity and sometimes downright racism as well as some's attempts to profit off our cultures has been discussed before. It's time to own our media and make sure it is appropriately shared & credited.

Sexuality and body image are frequent topics that concern Asian men. Bodyshaming and reinforcement of Western beauty norms must be combated. I have heard more than one Asian woman say “Asian men look so feminine” citing facial features or lean frames. While I’m not anti-plastic surgery, the goal should not be to conform to Western standards of beauty. Muscle dysmorphic disorder (also known as bigorexia) is receiving more attention in the medical community and is related to OCD. Fitness for health, self-defense and positive self-image are worthy goals, but that doesn’t look the same for every body type. Problems arise when AMs risk their health to achieve a rigidly-defined ideal. I personally am vocal about what I am attracted to because it is different for everyone, and AMs need to know that more than one body type is sexually attractive.

AFs can help with AMs’ social skills, believe it or not. I’m biased because I’m fairly outgoing and talkative, but guess what---I was that quiet Asian girl once upon a time, and it took a welcoming social setting before I found my voice. (Sidenote: Plenty of white people can beat me 5 times over running their mouths. White people seem to be socialized more than Asian Americans to speak up with much less self-awareness or regard for their audience. AAs are further restricted by the “loud rude Asian tourists” stereotypes.) In my personal experience, group conversations can drown out Asian men, particularly very mixed groups. If you are more of a conversationalist like me, giving a guy a chance to engage more by casually throwing out, “Oh, speaking of X, didn’t Y___ go/do/see Z? Tell us about it.” Obviously not everyone wants to be put on the spot like that but the stereotypes that Asian men are silent or socially awkward may be nurture over nature IMO. Some people are indeed naturally more quiet and that’s fine, but many more have a lack of opportunities to develop.

I also work in a very female-centric field (men are a minority) and have AM coworkers who get shafted---others may have completely different experiences in a different occupation, so please bear with my perspective. In my line of work experienced AM mentors are not as easy to find as experienced AF mentors. I mentor less-experienced Asian coworkers/students/new grads who demonstrate maturity, responsibility, and work ethic, regardless of gender. Many hiring managers in my field are white women who are inherently biased against POC/MOC. Obviously one must demonstrate worth, but I believe in helping a brother out with a letter of rec or more if I can. Moral of the story: While Asian men should speak to Asian men, where AMs cannot go or are automatically treated differently, is where AFs need to go pick up the torch and speak out.

Much of what I just said could be applied the other way (re: body image, socialization, and career which are also concerns for many Asian women) but that’s a discussion for another time and perhaps another place. I also apologize for focusing on het cis AMs as this is the group I have interacted with the most, but I hope some points are applicable as well. Thanks to those who survived the wall of text--I could go on but I'd like to hear readers' thoughts.


r/asianfeminism • • Nov 09 '16

Politics One small sign of progress: the number of women of color in the Senate quadrupled

Thumbnail
vox.com
42 Upvotes

r/asianfeminism • • Oct 10 '17

Discussion How Reddit harasses Asian women into silence: A tell-all from an /r/asianamerican mod (x-post /r/againstharassment)

Thumbnail reddit.com
39 Upvotes

r/asianfeminism • • Jan 02 '17

Discussion Toxic white male racism/sexism at its finest

Thumbnail np.reddit.com
39 Upvotes

r/asianfeminism • • Aug 01 '16

Discussion Giving a Name to the Perpetrator and the Crime: Why We Should Be More Upfront in Critiquing White Men

38 Upvotes

Something that I’ve noticed when interacting with Asian women online and IRL is the fact that there is a reticence of not only addressing the harrowing presence of white men on our lives, but even when we are critiquing the transgressions that they have inflicted on us, there is a lack of naming them for what they are when we are critiquing them - “white men”. With other groups, like white women and Asian men, I’ve noticed that while there is some hesitance among the users that there is reticence to name them for fear of backlash, it’s still relatively feasible for us to call out the respective group that one is critiquing and attribute whatever criticism or use whatever language we want to address the group. Although I do think that many of us have begun to be able to address it, I can't say that I've seen the same comfort when addressing white men.

It’s not to say that I don’t think we should critique white women for their racism - we should. It’s not to say that I don’t think we should critique Asian men when they begin attacking Asian women by calling us names and saying that non-Asian women are better than us - we should. But the overall trajectory of critiquing should be re-examined when we’re willing to critique every group around us who doesn’t hold institutional power, and yet we shirk when it comes time to critique the group that holds the most institutional power to not only control us but all marginalized groups.

White men, after all, are the ones responsible for creating the one-dimensional, racist, and sexist depictions of us. White men are the ones who unfairly preside over our abortion and rape cases and project it as if it’s our fault for the tragedies that were brought against us. And even on a wider scale, with regards to the policies that they thrust onto the Asian community, also affects us as well. Some of us have family in Western countries and the current political tone in many Western countries begs the question of whether we’ll ever be able to reunite with loved ones in the countries we reside in. Asians trying to create communities for themselves are red-lined and have resources depleted from our communities progressively as the decades have gone by. There’s still relatively lackluster education in our curriculums to really examine the impact of laws meant to disenfranchise marginalized communities, including our very own.

And while it seems fearful given the reactions of how white men as a group react to critique and given how discouraging it is to see white men get let go time and time again for transgressions they have committed, it doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t speak up against them. We should be willing to speak up against them. And when we say that they’ve done something wrong, we shouldn’t just say that this is a horrible event and screw the guy and leave it at that.

Because just like the girl who has experienced rape at the hands of a man who is trying to figure out what to do next, we should come forward and be willing to say the name of the perpetrator and the crimes and transgressions that have been done to us (both figuratively and literally) if not for bringing justice in an unjust world, then at the very least for our own dignity and for the girls that come after us.

And while it's difficult to find articles and mainstream media sources critiquing white men from an Asian woman's perspective, it doesn't have to be that way. It can begin with us - after all, the personal becomes the political. When the experience of one resonates with the experiences of many, it is no longer an individual occurrence - it is a collective grievance that must be addressed by society.

After all, as an old white man from a beloved fiction series himself proclaims:

“Always use the proper name for things. Fear of a name increases fear of the thing itself.”


r/asianfeminism • • Nov 19 '15

Activism Why Minority Male Oppression Is A Feminist Issue

Thumbnail
thefrisky.com
38 Upvotes

r/asianfeminism • • Mar 15 '17

Ghost in the Shell's latest critic: it's own viral marketing #iamwhitewashing

Thumbnail
theverge.com
37 Upvotes

r/asianfeminism • • Aug 20 '18

Crying in H-Mart | The New Yorker

Thumbnail
newyorker.com
36 Upvotes

r/asianfeminism • • Feb 10 '16

News The Attack of Jarred Ha - We Need to Hold White People Accountable for Their Actions

36 Upvotes

http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/crime/cleared-after-stabbing-ex-uw-student-wants-his-life-back/

There was an AMA done with Jarred Ha. You can find it in this link: https://np.reddit.com/r/asianamerican/comments/44yong/hello_i_am_jarred_ha_exuw_student_who_was_charged/

The stakes couldn’t have been higher for the 22-year-old aspiring accountant, who got kicked out of the University of Washington and booted from his apartment within a day of his arrest last year for stabbing a member of the Pi Kappa Alpha fraternity.

Charged with first-degree assault with a deadly weapon and fourth-degree assault for punching a young woman in the face, Ha claimed self-defense — and was found not guilty by a King County jury on Jan. 15.

The same jury also returned a special verdict, rendering a somewhat rare finding that Ha used lawful force to defend himself. That finding means he is eligible to be reimbursed by the state for the roughly $40,000 his family spent on his criminal defense.

Now that his freedom is no longer in peril, Ha wants to clean the taint from his name, resume his studies at the UW and move on with his life.

But Ha and his family are bracing for another legal battle, this time against a civil complaint filed by Graham Harper, a 20-year-old UW student and National Guard reservist who was stabbed by Ha.

Ha's Story

Just after midnight on Jan. 25, 2015, Ha and a group of friends set out on a “21 Run” to a trio of University District bars to celebrate one woman’s 21st birthday. At the last bar, the young woman fell asleep at the table, so the group walked her home to a U District rental house shared by members of the UW women’s rugby club.

He and a male friend waited outside the “rugby house,” where a party was under way, as others helped put the woman to bed.

Ha was then greeted by one of the rugby players who had attended the party but lived in the same five-unit apartment building as Ha and his roommates, about a mile south.

According to Ha, she routinely took up two parking spots at their apartment building, which had become a sore subject among the other tenants. He suggested she needed “to park straighter.”

The woman punched Ha in the head, according to Ha and the defense’s trial brief. She swung again, he blocked the blow, and she ended up on the ground.

As he reached to help her up, he said, he was punched in the head from behind as up to four other women joined the fray.

“I didn’t know who they were, what gender they were. I’m pushing back, punching back, just trying to get out of there,” he said.

At least one of his punches connected, blackening a woman’s eye.

As Ha and his friend walked away, the women yelled taunts and one followed the men a short distance, swatting at Ha’s head.

Graham's Version

Harper’s version differs sharply. He said in an interview that he came out of the rugby house, saw a girl crying and inserted himself between Ha and the women. He said he told Ha to leave, and Ha started walking away, but then came back.

He acknowledges slamming Ha into a car: “I slammed him in the car one time — it’s not like I picked him up and repeatedly bashed his head. He had no more than a black eye.”

Harper said he never saw Ha’s knife. His left leg, chest and groin were cut and one jab punctured his abdomen, causing a small section of intestine to protrude.

Ha, who said he feared he would die from having his head repeatedly slammed into a car, said he showed Harper his knife and told him to back off, then wasn’t sure that he’d actually cut Harper.

The jury also heard that Harper, who was 19 at the time, had a blood alcohol content of 0.13, well above the legal limit of 0.02 for those under 21.

Eyewitness Accounts

Friends Shane Colburn and Elana Helfand, both UW students who were sober and had no connection to anyone involved in the fight, happened upon the scene as Ha tussled with the women. They saw the first woman fall to the ground and watched Ha walk away as “this other girl was punching and slapping him in the head,” said Colburn.

“He wasn’t hitting her back, more like blocking her strikes,” said Colburn, 22, who along with Helfand testified at Ha’s trial.

That’s when Harper came out of the house and went “full-on sprinting” after Ha, “yelling something to the effect of, ‘You never hit girls,’ ” Colburn said in an interview. “I remember being concerned this was escalating now — the way he was running was aggressive.”

From his vantage, Colburn said, he saw Harper grab Ha and repeatedly ram Ha into parked cars.

The incident, and Ha’s arrest, were covered by Seattle media. Harper was hailed as a hero and a protector of women.

Jurors heard two versions of the events of that night, from Harper and then from Ha, whose account was corroborated by the witnesses. A Seattle man who sat on the jury said initially he assumed that with Harper’s injuries, Ha “was on a rampage.”

After finding Ha not guilty, it didn’t take long for the jury to reach the special verdict in Ha’s favor, finding he acted in self-defense, the juror said.

Harper, who is studying political science and international security, was shocked by the verdicts, saying he thought the case against Ha “was a slam dunk.”

“I believe there was a lot of legal manipulation. O.J. got off,” Harper said. “I still believe I was right and he was so, so wrong in hitting those girls.”

UW Suspension

While still in jail, Ha was notified that he was suspended from the UW and barred from campus.

Ha said he has attended academic disciplinary hearings and was ordered to take an alcohol-safety class. He has been told by the UW that he can reapply in the fall, but he hopes to get back in before then.

When Vanessa attended the UW, her father, Joe Ha, became alarmed by the frequent safety alerts his daughter received on her cellphone from UW police. He gave her the choice of carrying a Taser, mace or a knife for protection. She chose mace.

When it was Jarred’s turn to attend the UW, their dad gave him the same choice. After his son decided on a knife, Joe Ha purchased a Karambit, a knife with a curved, 2 ¼-inch fixed blade.

“I said, ‘I ruined your life,’ ” recalled Joe Ha, “and he said, ‘No, Dad. You saved my life.’ ”


Stereotyping used to create an enemy out of the defendant and a corrupt judicial system favoring whites - this is one of those cases where whiteness needs to answer for itself and realize that it cannot ruin peoples' lives and put them behind bars because of the latent biases that allow these situations.

And on this note, I will make a counter-argument against mainstream feminism's stance on assault by men. I completely agree that it is egregious for men to hurt women. Yes, physical assault and laying on a hand on a woman with the intent to hurt the victim is despicable.

HOWEVER, when you aim to physically assault the person with the intention of hurting them without their provocation, when you gang up on a victim with four other girls by your side, you should not cry wolf when the victim, whether they be a man or a woman, swipes back at you in an attempt to defend themselves. Being a man or a woman means nothing in this matter. These women committed an assault. Jarred Ha was the victim of an assault committed by all of these white women and the white man that came afterwards. He is also the victim of a racist judicial system which favors whites, especially white women. It was only by a stroke of luck, the right eyewitness accounts, the right evidence laid at the scene, whatever it may be, that prevented him from having his entire life completely destroyed before him. There needs to be recognition that not only should individuals, regardless of their gender, be held accountable for their actions, but that within the context of American society, white people as a whole, including white women, possess way more social power than any other racial group in this country, even if said racial minority is a man.


r/asianfeminism • • Jan 22 '17

Activism Did anyone go to the women's march in their city?

35 Upvotes

Just wondering, since I went to the one in NYC and was blown away at the strength and diversity of the crowds. I honestly didn't know what to expect and from what I was hearing almost expected it to be full of and lead by mostly white women. Instead I saw people from all different walks of life--people with walkers, entire families some with young children, mixed race couples, older folks, LGBT folks, even different generations from the same family marching together. It warmed my heart to see so many Asian faces in the crowd, too. I saw for the first time how many men were willing to stand up against misogyny and denounce rape culture, the taking away of reproductive rights, and male entitlement.

Overall I'm very glad I was convinced at the last minute to go and I have renewed faith that not everything is going to shit over the next 4 years. ✊🏼


r/asianfeminism • • Mar 17 '16

News Japanese woman beaten to death by Australian husband

Thumbnail
mobile.abc.net.au
35 Upvotes

r/asianfeminism • • Dec 28 '15

Discussion We Should Stop the Fetishization of Hapa Babies (Specifically Half-Asian, Half White Babies) in Our Community

35 Upvotes

I think one of the least discussed issues within the AA community that is predominantly perpetuated by AA women is the fetishization of "beautiful" hapa babies. Jenee Desmond-Harris, herself a mixed person, for the Root writes "Mixed Kids Are the Cutest’ Isn’t Cute?" It is taken from the perspective of black/white biracial people, but I think there are some key points that can be extrapolated to us as well. A few excerpts:

You're right to be bothered by the remarks from the Biracial Babies Fan Club. Here's why: These people aren't pulling an arbitrary appreciation for almond-colored skin and curls from the ether. Instead—even if they are not aware of this—they're both reflecting and perpetuating troubling beliefs that are bigger than their individual tastes. Specifically, while "mixed kids are the cutest" is evenhanded on its face, treating both black and white (and all other ethnic groups) as inferior to your daughter, I hear it as anti-black.

As Marcia Dawkins, the author of Clearly Invisible: Racial Passing and the Color of Cultural Identity, told me, "The myth that mixed-race offspring are somehow better than nonmixed offspring is an example of 'hybrid vigor,' an evolutionary theory which states that the progeny of diverse varieties within a species tend to exhibit better physical and psychological characteristics than either one or both of the parents."

And just take a wild guess how this idea has popped up for black people. You got it: In order to demean and oppress African Americans, thought leaders throughout history, including the likes of Thomas Jefferson, have said that black-white mixed offspring are better, more attractive, smarter, etc., than "real" blacks and not as good or attractive or smart as "real" whites, Dawkins explains.

So alleging that mixed kids are the best of anything sounds different when you consider that we've long put a wholesale premium on all that's whiter and brighter.

Against this backdrop of painful beliefs that people of all colors buy into, yes, "Mixed kids are the cutest" should sound "off."

Although Asian women do have our own rightful grievances against white society, this is one of the biggest things that we are guilty of doing that continuously promotes white supremacy. While billboards promoting white women as the de facto symbol of beauty around the world and the promotion of half-Asian people in Asian entertainment industries do play a role in telling us what is beautiful and what is not, it is our responsibility to take that message, parse what it means, and promote a message that is more helpful in promoting good body image for future AA women and men.

We all know what it's like to be living in a society that puts white beauty as higher than people from different ethnicities/races. Do we really want to continue to promote the idea that the only way to be considered beautiful is to be mixed with a white person? Do we really want to promote this message to full Asian children that they're not as attractive or intelligent as half Asian, half white children? We may not say it out loud explicitly, but people can pick up what we mean when we say "mixed babies are the cutest", especially when the majority of the time, those babies are Asian/white mixes. And our children are no exception.

What do you all think of this? Opinions from the hapa woman's perspective are also appreciated!


r/asianfeminism • • May 10 '18

Student presents thesis in underwear after professor questions choice of clothing

Thumbnail
cornellsun.com
34 Upvotes

r/asianfeminism • • Feb 16 '17

How the alt-right’s sexism lures men into white supremacy

Thumbnail
vox.com
34 Upvotes

r/asianfeminism • • May 16 '17

Personal Experience My Family's Slave: Lola's Story

Thumbnail
theatlantic.com
33 Upvotes