r/minecraftsuggestions • • Jan 31 '26

[Magic] Curse of planned obsolesce

0 Upvotes

Some villager traders can sell diamond tools for only 20 emeralds. This is pretty cheap for such a strong and durable tool. This would never happen in real life, as it reduces repeat customers

Diamond tools from villagers should have curse of planned obsolesce, a curse which halves the durability of the tool. so that the villager can get repeat customers more easily. This would be very realistic.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Jul 12 '26 Regret

[Community Question] command rework discussion!!!

Post image
0 Upvotes

(premise)Currently commands are very hard to understand, and in bedrock are extremely limited because mojang doesnt want bedrock players to acces the technical side of the game and its "illegal blocks, mobs, and items" .

I think all that all players have full acces to commands and the technical side, of the game, and that commands should be far easier to run:

(idea) Commands would now be formatted with only regularly spaced words and parentheses and would multiple alternative words for each meaning, EG; /locate mushroom island (unfound) or /locate mushroom biome (true) or /locate mooshroom island (unexplored).

Commands in bedrock would also now allow you to give enchantments any value you want, allow you to give mobs whatever item you want, and allow you to fill spawners with whatever you want, and all of them would work in command blocks even if it softlocks you( this would be a world option, and there would also now be a turn off command blocks option in settings.

(discussion) so that was my idea please leave your ideas (or changes to mine) for reworking commands in the comments below.

Edits based on feedback:

The old command format would still work to preserve old builds

there would be two spaces between arguments

my source for the mojang purposely duming down bedrock commands is that the dev build of the game has all of the java commands and the debug stick and menu


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Jan 24 '23

[AI Behavior] Gold armour trims should make piglins passive

0 Upvotes

It makes sense and gives armour trims a small use rather than just being cosmetic.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Feb 23 '26

[Combat] Curved arrows

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

This is a special arrow type whose trajectory is curved. Not to be confused with homing arrows.

How to use:

When you starting pulling the bow the direction you are facing and the trajectory of the arrow if you had shot it is recorded, while pulling the bow you can turn left or right upto 45 degrees and shoot the arrow, this arrow curves such that it lands exactly at the recorded position.

Basically start shooting like you normally would and then just rotate a bit just before shooting to curve the shot.

I hope i explained it well

In survival it's not as useful but it's unique ability is still more useful than some tipped arrows. In multiplayer it adds a whole new dynamic , it creates the ability to curve shots with precision but to get that precision would be hard and require skill. It increases the skill ceiling of bow combat a lot.

I chose 45 degrees cause something like 90 degree would make the trajectory a semicircle which would be too op imo.

Also btw I said only left or right as if you allowed up and down you could use them as gravity defying arrows which would be broken.

Refinement and feedback is appreciated.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Mar 02 '25

[General] Make the nether roof accesible and add biomes on top of it

6 Upvotes

My idea for the nether roof would be make it contrast to the actual nether itself; instead of being warm, its cold.

There would be layers of snow on top of it with different shaped hills, and would basically resemble a large cold desert. Occasionally you would find structures that resemble those from the overworld, but with no loot inside. My idea for this is it would sort of creep the player out, making you feel that something isn't right.

In addition, water placed on the top of the roof would freeze instantly, and lava would turn into cobblestone.

They could perhaps add unique blocks on the roof; Ice Bricks which could be used for decoration.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Jan 09 '26

[Gameplay] Minecraft must change it's difficulty system ASAP.

6 Upvotes

Observation

Something i've noticed in the past few updates is the addition of several features to aid people in their Survival, such as crafting recipes for new items, easy to obtain mounts like the Happy Ghast and the Nautilus, etc.

While i'm not opposed to giving casual players a more practical gameplay for them to enjoy, i genuinely miss the survival aspect Minecraft once had, there's no resource scarcity, even if you play the game casually you can upgrade far too quickly, and once you get to diamond stuff mobs stop being a problem even in the Hard difficulty. This has definitively divided the community, as there is a large conflict of interest in both sides, souring the Minecraft space.

Proposal

Because of that, and because Mojang is updating a lot of older features recently, i suggest an update to the difficulty system aswell, since it's easily one of the most barebones aspects of the game since the beginning, with some people even arguing that the Hard mode is the easiest one for having better loot and barely any other change.

With this difficulty update, each mode will completely revamp the way players interact with the Minecraft world itself.

Easy Mode - Aimed towards younger children and people just getting started. In this mode, mobs like the Creeper and Ghast do not destroy the environment, fire does not spread, Gravel won't be affected by gravity, Lava spreads slowly in the Nether, Player isn't killed by the End Void, TnT won't destroy ore blocks, success rates have a higher chance to succeed (Crops grows faster, Chickens have better chance to spawn from eggs), and it could be the perfect opportunity to bring back the crafting recipe of the Enchanted Golden Apple, among other things. The world is far more forgiving to the player, perhaps even hostage to them, while not being boring like the Peaceful mode.

Normal Mode - Aimed towards casual players, it's simply the default version of Minecraft as it is and will be.

Hard Mode - Aimed towards seasoned players who wish for a more exciting and unpredictable gameplay that challanges them. In this version, some guidelines of the development book could be broken in regards to the gameplay, since one of them, "Bad things happen... But it's technically the player's fault" would be actively true for the entire gameplay, as it's the player's fault for choosing the difficulty, and it's clear that they do not intend to play a casual sandbox experience.

This could allow for current and future mobs to grief or build the world as long as they are in the Hard Difficuly, like the Warden being able to destroy block piles to catch the player, or allow Zombies with pickaxes to dig through caves to catch the player offguard, Skeletons could be able spot players through windows and break the glass by shooting at it, Hoglins are no longer repelled by blue mushrooms, Pillagers could steal some itens from chests, forcing players to better protect them, Phantoms could spawn and attack you if the Elytra is used for far too long, among others. In summary, in the hard difficulty, the world wouldn't be at the player's control, instead, the player would have to adapt to it.

Besides that, items like Saddles, Tags and Dried Ghasts wouldn't be craftable, just like in the older versions, with Dried Ghasts being impossible to get even from Piglins, being exclusive to the Soulsand Valley, and there could have increased resource scarcity, removing the crafting of more items and forcing them to be chest-exclusive (though with a slighly higher chance of being generated). Lastly, this could also allow for the addition of new mobs and features that are outside of the player's control unless in lower difficulties.

Conclusion

With these changes, i believe a lot more people would be pleased with the game and the new updates, otherwise we can only expect clashing interests and players getting more frustrated with each new update. The Easy Mode would be an introduction to the game for the new and young playerbase, the Normal Mode would cater to people who want a more casual experience with a few challanges and the Hard Mode would be perfect for people seeking challange, a true survival experience, with the player having to adapt to the world, instead of shaping it.

I believe that this is a way to fix several things in one go, it will improve the difficulty system and give it a reason to even exist, it will please a wider playerbase with contradictory interests and will give the developers a more creative freedom when designing new features to the game, as they can adjust them to fit different modes.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Jun 25 '25

[Sounds] The Tears and Lava Chicken music disc should have a more unique way of getting them

0 Upvotes

Music discs like those shouldn’t be as easy to get as they currently are. The tears music disc you just get by doing what every player always does, shoot the fireball back. The lava chicken one is simply killing a chicken jockey. Theres nothing special about it.

The tears music disc should be obtained by shooting a fireball at ANOTHER ghast rather than the same one

The lava chicken music disc would be trickier to get, as you have to kill the baby zombie in lava, making sure the disc doesn’t burn


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Oct 02 '24

[Subreddit Request] I suggest that everyone stop suggesting features for an update we don’t even have access to yet

19 Upvotes

Please stop talking about the garden.

It’s not out yet. Please. We as a community can be patient and not suggest anything until we actually have played it


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Feb 14 '23

[Plants & Food] Rename Cherry Blossoms into Sakura trees

4 Upvotes

Cherry Blossom tree or as it known to be in it's home region the Sakura nobody know where they originate but they are flourishing in Japan

also the reason why I suggest this is it just sound better
Cherry Blossom Sapling
Sakura Sapling
Cherry Blossom Logs
Sakura Logs
Cherry Blossom Planks
Sakura Planks

It also will help teach kids name of a Japanese tree


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Aug 08 '24

[Combat] The mace on Java should deal 7 attack damage instead of 6

3 Upvotes

It seems a bit overkill in how weak the mace is without the smash attack. Since most mobs have 20 HP, it takes 4 hits to kill a skeleton with with only 6 attack damage. And that is on top of the way longer cooldown compared to other weapons.

To compare, a diamond sword has a DPS of 11.2, an axe has 9 DPS, but the mace has a DPS of 3.6 damage per second. Now, if the attack damage was raised to 7, it would do 4.2 DPS, which might not seem like much, but it would allow you to take out most mobs in only 3 regular hits or 2 critical hits, instead of 4 regular hits or 3 critical hits. That to me seems way more reasonable.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Oct 14 '12

XP is storable.

0 Upvotes

I hate it when I have tons of XP and I die, thus losing all of it. You should be able to take your XP and put it into Bottles o' Enchanting, to store it.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Sep 05 '26

[Blocks & Items] Sand dupers should be patched

0 Upvotes

Instead you should be able to use either the stonecutter or (even better) a new crushing wheel block like in Create Mod to break down stone into cobble, cobble into gravel, gravel into sand, concrete into powder (although this isn't really realistic but it's quality of life) etc. This makes sense because making stone and deepslate into cobbled versions already is possible with stonecutters so why stop there? Additionally you could crush things like glowstone into dust (either more efficient than breaking it or just so you don't have to mine it) pack ice blocks together (either more efficient than crafting or just replacing crafting it) and turn quartz blocks back into quartz. Or slabs/stairs back into their material. Or diorite into cobble and quartz and so on. There are infinite possibilities and I think this would be better than an end update or another wood type (wood cutter when) But what do you think?


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Mar 22 '25

[Mobs] Allow Zombies to drop iron when killed by environmental damage

4 Upvotes

I really, really hate iron farms. I'm well aware of the origins of the golem in Jewish mythology, and have been since before I started playing Minecraft (and that was in 2009...) so building internment camps to produce them feels very, very icky.

But everything mechanical is balanced around being able to get lots of iron, so if you want to play with that side of things you basically have to build one.

As a workaround, letting zombies drop iron ingots if you killed them with environmental damage would allow general mob grinders - which feel a lot less evil - to produce iron. Not as quickly, but probably enough. Plus it'd make zombies not as annoying to get in them, rotten flesh is not particularly useful!


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Sep 15 '25

[Gameplay] Rework ALL Movement Mechanics To Be 100% Server-Sided.

0 Upvotes

Minecraft's most fatal flaw is that so many mechanics can be easily modified on the client side and can only be checked for by server-side anticheats. Obviously, it's gotten better over the years, as you can't simply change how fast you regenerate with a modded client anymore, but the most exploited mechanic in Minecraft has to be movement. Almost, if not all movement can be messed with from the client and accepted by the server (without anticheat), from walking to running to swimming to even elytra.

This has been devastating for servers, especially Mojang's partnered servers on Bedrock, since Bedrock has less detailed packet data to go off of. Flight has never 100% been patched on a single server, as cheat developers keep finding every exception, every subtle movement, every right packet to send to make the anticheat say "this is vanilla!" How? Because they're able to change movement in the first place

In the same sense that, when regenerating, the client cant tell the server "hey im regenerating right now and this much" or "hey, my hotbar has 64 diamonds in this slot!", the client SHOULDNT be able to tell the server "hey! i just moved from here to here". It's more than just "anti-cheat" it's basic server security that should've existed since the beginning. the server should be the one to determine:

- how fast you walk (and the physics of walking, interpolation and all)

- how fast you run (and the physics of running)

- how your movement changes when moving on soul sand, ice, etc.)

- knockback

- basically everything that has to do with movement

But since it's been so many years and that so many new mechanics regarding movement have been added, i know this wont be a straightforward process and could take years. Doesn't mean it shouldn't be done though.

You can look at partnered servers right now, many of their pvp minigames and gamemodes fail to reach 300 players, some not even 100.

These servers that pay mojang a percentage of their cosmetics and marketplace content aren't being given proper server security, and are suffering because of it.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Oct 22 '25

[Mobs] The nautilus should only pause the oxygen bar while wearing a turtle shell

0 Upvotes

I like the idea of the nautilus. But the fact that it gives basically unlimited water breathing is broken. It defeats the purpose of the water breathing potions and the already forgotten turtle shell. This would still keep the base effect while giving a use to turtle shell and not being OP.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • May 31 '14

Make it rain less

0 Upvotes

It annoying raining every 5 minutes


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Jun 01 '14

A lot of enchantments that just seem interesting to me

0 Upvotes

Pickaxe: Torch Placing (I-III)

Level I: Consumes 1 durability and 1 torch to place a torch by right-clicking.

Level II: Consumes 2 durability and 2 torches to place a torch up to twice as far away.

Level III: 4 durability, 4 torches, 4x the distance. Same deal otherwise.

Axe: Slicing (I-III)

Level I: 10% chance to drop heads of killed mobs (NOT PLAYERS), +1 damage.

Level II: 20% chance to drop heads of killed mobs AND PLAYERS, +2 damage, hold shift to tree-capitate, using twice the durability cutting the tree down standardly would.

Level III: 30% chance, +3 damage, and no extra durability loss respectively; acts like shears as well.

Hoe: Greenery (I)

Effects: Tilled dirt grows crops twice as fast, hoe acts as shears, +3 damage at cost of rapid hunger loss (unless you have seeds in your inventory!). -50% durability.

Sword: Aquatic (I-V) *NOTE: Can NOT be put on a wooden sword in any way. Can not stack with Sharpness OR Unbreaking.

Level I: +1 damage to Blazes. -10% durability.

Level II: +2 damage to Blazes and Magma Cubes. -20% durability.

Level III: +3 damage to Blazes, Magma Cubes, and Endermen; blocking gives Water Breathing. -30% durability.

Level IV: +4 damage to Blazes, Magma Cubes, Endermen, and Ghasts; blocking gives Water Breathing AND Fire Resistance. -40% durability.

Level V: +5 damage to all above mobs + Ender Dragons; blocking gives Water Breathing, Fire Resistance, AND Resistance II. -50% durability.

Shovel: Erosion (I-III)

Level I: Sneak to mine all gravel/sand above the dug block with twice the durability loss of mining the blocks directly.

Level II: Same thing, but same durability loss as normal digging; also digs whole gravel/dirt veins at one time taking up 2x durability.

Level III: All that for no durability loss, PLUS digs whole clay veins at once.

Fishing Rod: Arcane (I-III)

Level I: Doubled chance of fished gear to be enchanted.

Level II: TRIPLED chance.

Level III: QUADRUPLED CHANCE; bobber +10 damage to squid; 2 durability damage from fishing or killing squid; 1 durability from reeling in other mobs.

Bow: Endric (I-III)

Level I: Shot arrows can hit Endermen, however this ability costs a stack of cobblestone/dirt to use.

Level II: Arrows home in on everything, but each arrow shot this way consumes an ender pearl.

Level III: At the cost of one ender eye, anything killed with a homing arrow from this bow explodes into more homing arrows.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Sep 25 '23

[Mobs] Phantoms should spawn when you fly, not when you don't sleep.

2 Upvotes

Sleeping already takes away part of Minecraft's charm, and with phantoms spawning as a penalty for not sleeping, it's basically a necessity. (Sleeping needs a rework too but that's for another post) Phantoms should spawn when you fly a certain distance with elytra, and should not burn in the day.

They would be able to fly faster than the player, and when they hit, the player would plummet from the sky for a few seconds before regaining control and continuing to fly. upon each hit, there is a small chance that the player's elytra is dropped. If the player lands while being pursued by phantoms, they will stop attacking but will continue to follow the player from above for 5-10 minutes before disappearing into the sky. In night, however, they would continue to attack you when landed. This would balance elytra, and allow players to choose not to sleep without being punished.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Nov 25 '24

[Community Question] What are your thought on an enchantment limit for items. Lets say 3 enchantment on an item max?

6 Upvotes

In my opinion I think it would be a good idea to prototype at the very least. I came up with this too counter the issue of too many enchantments on an item. So what if there was a limit, they you need to be more decisive about what you put on it.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Jan 09 '24

[Magic] Let's remove Sharpness and Protection. Hear me out.

4 Upvotes

Scroll to bottom for summary, but I recommend reading it all

Now, the current enchantment system heavily favors specific enchantments, like Protection, or Sharpness, over their more specialized counterparts. This is pretty strange, considering that Sharpness simply adds more damage, and Protection simply negates more damage. These enchants are essentially just another tier of equipment.

The two aspects I enjoy most about the enchantment system are:

  1. Unique enchantments. This includes fire aspect, thorns, or frost walker. Not saying they're all good, but unique. They are enchantments that add something new, not just add another tier of progression.

  2. Incompatible enchantments. This could be Infinity, or Mending. This makes the user think about what they want. It's not just trying to get everything on their equipment.

Putting these two concepts together is what I believe are good enchantments. My best example is Fortune and Silk Touch. They are both useful, so users have to decide what they want.

Unfortunately, the majority of enchantments don't follow this path. This is why I believe enchantments such as Sharpness and Protection should be removed. Now, you may be asking, "But, wouldn't we be so much weaker?" or "Wouldn't this make the game harder?"

I would like to address the incompatible enchantment system first. Instead of preventing some enchantments from coexisting, there should simply be an enchantment cap. For example, maybe three enchantments per piece of gear. This could be changed through armor tiers, maybe an item that adds more slots, or anything else, but I'll let you guys flesh this idea out.This allows users to consider which enchantments are most important, and allows for different play styles. This will pair well with the next idea.

This is why there should be new enchantments as well. New unique enchantments that aren't a "one size fits all" enchantment. I know I can't design perfectly balanced enchantments, but some examples to flesh out armor could be:

( [] means a stat is scaled with level of enchantment. )

Last Stand - Make armor [10%] stronger when under [10%] durability
Potion Absorption - make potion effects last [20%] longer
Companion - Creepers avoid you if you tame a cat, similar with skeletons and dogs

These are useful enchantments, but with a limited amount, players are encouraged to pick those that suit their situation or play style.

Summary: Instead of sharpness and protection, which is essentially just another tier of armor, there are new unique enchantments. There is also a cap of 3 (changable) enchantments per item to encourage adding enchantments that suit your play style or situation.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Feb 18 '26

[Mobs] Please Mojang, change the baby animals

1 Upvotes

A lot of them are cute but some are hideous. Give the baby zombie villager and villager a chin and bigger nose. Please. Also make the horse’s heads thinner by 2 pixels. lastly, change the bathroom mold horse to look like what it used to be. I thought Mojang was good at listening to feedback:(


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Dec 31 '12

Bluestone as a redstone alternative to make circuits smaller

0 Upvotes

Bluestone that will not join onto redstone, to have 2 wires next to eachother. Crafted with redstone + lapis lazuli

Edit: Maybe purplestone that will connect to both?


r/minecraftsuggestions • • Mar 26 '23

[Mobs] Withers should be untrappable.

0 Upvotes

The Wither is supposed to be one of the largest challenges Minecraft has to offer, and thus should be untrappable to prevent people from cheesing it. Right now, all you need for a beacon is to know how to spawn the wither under the end portal.


r/minecraftsuggestions • • May 23 '23

[General] Mojang should make "Minecraft Classic" for PC and console.

7 Upvotes

would be an security updated legacy console/old java emulator with multiplayer enabled for older console releases. It would include servers, discount realms, and built in tutorial worlds and textures/ost. I know if they made that, I would ditch new Minecraft for it. All your DLC should carry over!