When I saw the ad for this subreddit in the sidebar, I was really curious. I read the rules and a few posts, and was wondering if there's a better way to use donations than "raffles".
Here are a few problems that you may or may not have already thought of:
The subreddit is divided. There are "Givers", "Receivers", and "Passive participants".
The "Givers" give and participate in the subreddit. They have a small chance of getting anything back, but they are the reason the subreddit exists.
The "Receivers" just receive benefits. The chance that they have given as well is relatively small, but they may become "Givers" afterwards (although the amount they give will be small comparatively).
"Passive Participants" make up the vast majority of the subreddit. These people participate, but they don't give or receive. This is the normal Reddit behavior on a subreddit.
The idea is to make someone a millionaire. How does this benefit the community that accomplishes this goal? The reward is high for the individual "winner", but the community reward is too low.
We like to imagine we know where our donations are going, but we can't really know.
The process may be "fair", but it is not "fun" for most participants.
There is no donation incentive.
There are no ways to raise money besides donations.
There are even more problems that I haven't mentioned, but here is my suggestion to solve some of them:
Gamify the subreddit.
What does this mean? Gamification is the application of game playing to other areas of activity, such as this subreddit. Since the incentive is relatively large amounts of money, the potential for gamifying /r/millionairemakers is huge.
Gamification is actually quite easy, but making it effective is very difficult. The current subreddit form is actually already a "game"; the raffle. The rules are simple: Participate, and you have a chance to win. The chance to win is low, but the cost to play (only a few seconds or minutes of your time) is low as well. The original idea of the subreddit is similar: Low risk, high potential reward.
We can expand on this idea, and make something with more complex rules, higher participation rates, and even higher chances for rewards. On the other hand, we want to avoid becoming a lottery; that is not what I'm suggesting. I suggest keeping the cost to play at $0, but raise the chance to win, while making it "fun".
I've been studying math, computer science, economics, and game theory for a while now, but I don't consider myself an expert at all. If you have a better idea, please feel free to share. Now, here's my idea:
Restrict the amount of money given out, and save some for later. The original idea was that only $1 would be required per user. If a user donates $10, then it should go out to 10 people rather than just 1. This would also allow a "community chest" to build, which publicly keeps track of the amount of money raised, and would help users gain interest in participating. The limit wouldn't have to be $1, but could be $2, $3, etc., but something low enough to start building a community chest.
This would require a database that keeps track of individual donations that should not be tampered with, and it would also require the money to be held by a 3rd party. Donations would also be made public (the amounts only, not necessarily user names) so we can check the balance for ourselves. This brings up other problems, such as adding interest that builds up in the "pot" (because the money would be stored in a bank that would award interest).
2) Provide a way for users to participate which would raise their potential chance to receive rewards. We want people to have an incentive to participate in the subreddit beyond commenting in the occasional raffle.
We could give donors the ability to skip having to participate in the next raffle, 1 skip per $1 or $2, but their name would still be entered. We could give activities to users where, if they complete it, they would have their name entered a second time. For example, add a link to the picture of your favorite chair to have your name entered twice. Or if you comment on this random thread our mod made in another subreddit as well, your name will be entered twice (secret mutually beneficial advertising).
3) Provide the option for people to donate for others, which gives both participants "skips", limited to $10, or something like that. This would get people to interact with each other, and perhaps even spark mutual donations (I will donate 10 if you donate 10, which gives us double the participation). There would have to be a limit, in order to spread the love around.
4) Give someone the chance to re-invest in the community after they win. For example, any money a winner donates will be worth 2 skips instead of 1. Or, any money a winner donates will go towards a community party, which will be held eventually for the community only using money that winners donate, or perhaps towards paying someone to gamify the subreddit better.
5) Organize alternate ways of donating. For example, instead of donating money, someone could donate a piece of art, which someone else could "buy". The money for the art would go towards the subreddit, the art would go to the buyer, and the person who donated the art would get the relevant amount of skips.
6) Give winners the chance to show what they did with the money. If a winner provides "proof", they will get special flair or something. This would be optional of course.
Anyway, I have a ton more ideas. If you guys are interested in hearing more about these suggestions, or have some of your own, feel free to comment and I would be glad to respond.