r/millionairemakersmeta • • Dec 21 '19

I urge you to delete your child comments in the drawing threads

64 Upvotes

Hi, I just discovered this community and I love what y'all are doing. I just missed my chance to enter the 49th drawing (ouch) but I think I can still do something useful. I've seen comments with up to 160 child comments on them which means 160 original comments that don't get to enter the drawing. If you have posted a child comment, I urge you to delete it to allow more people to enter. I already missed my chance but I must guide others to a treasure I cannot possess. Merry Christmas y'all!

UPDATE: The mods made another fresh thread for us to participate. Thanks so much guys! But still, don't post child comments.


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Jun 20 '19

MillionaireMakers Extended Rules and FAQs [Drawing Thread Documentation for Summer and Fall 2019]

59 Upvotes

List of FAQs:

  • What is /r/millionairemakers, anyway?

  • What are the rules?

  • How will the winner be picked? What is the process?

  • What preparations should be made before paying the winner?

  • What else can I do to encourage participation?

  • Miscellaneous


What is /r/millionairemakers, anyway?

Three years ago, a Redditor posted an idea in /r/Showerthoughts that speculated the fact, if a million people picked a certain Redditor and all donated just $1, they would have the power to make someone a millionaire.

This subreddit is an embodiment of that showerthought, and the monthly drawings are the attempts to make it happen.

We need your help to keep this running, which amounts to only $1 a month to make someone's day. In the long term, that’s $120 every decade, which is much more affordable than other expenses. How does it work? Below, you will find an explanation on entering, rules to keep in mind, the selection, and other important things to note.


What are the rules?

  • Only ONE top level comment per person (replies and subsequent-level comments aren't included), but feel free to reply to other comments. Making duplicate top level comments may result in exclusion from entering. Go to /u/me to ensure you don't accidentally double comment.

  • If, by any chance, you do double comment, delete any extra duplicates ASAP, ideally before the thread is locked, as any chosen draws found to violate this will not be eligible to win, and will be banned from the subreddit.

  • Your account must be older than 30 days with some amount of activity. Throwaway accounts with very minimal activity will also not be eligible. This is to prevent multiple entries from the same person.


How will the winner be picked? What is the process?

  • After 24 hours following the submission of the thread, the thread will close, and the method of selection will begin.

  • While attempts to make the selection method similar to 2017’s have been performed, it still varies from the original. For an example from a prior drawing, see [Draw #36]. For archival purposes, please click here for the original selection method.

  • Method's TL;DR: Each comment is assigned a number by sorting the comments by old, starting with 1. The list of comments will be publicly released for the community to verify per their own accord. The subreddit then waits for a randomly generated block (a string of numbers) from Bitcoin's blockchain, after a preselected date and time, and calculates the winner using a formula described in the posts mentioned above.

  • Comment IDs are downloaded at 2:00 UTC (though not enforced, this is the ideal hour), three hours following the thread being locked. There will be an official run at the time listed, and the list of comments will be released right before the [Drawing] takes place. If it is shown that there are any technical difficulties, the retrieval of the comments will be delayed following the same procedures.

  • While not necessary, to determine if you are on the list, please go to your comment and save it. The comment ID is what gets recorded and selected, which looks like this: e3yxpj4. To find your comment, download the list, use Ctrl-F, and paste the comment in the search bar. You should find your comment deep inside of the list.

  • The Draw is held at 16:00 UTC the Sunday after the [Drawing Thread], unless stated otherwise. Using the Bitcoin blockchain, the third block yet to be mined will be used to select a winner.

  • The user who created the winning comment will be informed of their luck and will provide any information necessary for their chosen payment methods (mods will help set this up if needed).

  • The generous Reddit community donates to this lucky person, hopefully making some worthy soul a millionaire! A donation table will be stickied to the winner’s post, giving users the freedom in how they donate.

  • The lucky Redditor follows up with a thank you within the next days, revealing to the community exactly how much was raised and thanking their generosity.


What preparations should be made before paying the winner?

  • Take the time you have available now to setup your PayPal, or if you would like to use other services, Square Cash and a Google Pay account. (Note: Some services may not be available depending on where you reside.)

  • While not required, cryptocurrency wallets are also encouraged as another method of payment.

  • To buy any cryptocurrencies, you may use Coinbase for purchases using your bank account.

  • To store cryptocurrencies, there are many accessible wallets, and if you win, you will be guided on which ones to download. For Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash, it’s recommended to use the Electrum and Electron Cash wallet for Mac, Linux, and PC.

  • If you want to be reminded to donate, please comment "RemindMe! 3 days Donation for /r/millionairemakers" or click on the link in the TL;DR on the [Drawing Thread].


What else can I do to encourage participation?

  • Spread the word! The more people who participate, the better this gets for everyone! There has been a correlation between this subreddit making it in /r/all and an increase in donations.

  • Try to cross-post to relevant subs, and upvote. There is a correlation between reaching /r/all and the amount of donations for the winner. (Please don't spam other subs though. We're not trying to make any enemies here.)

  • Please try your best to donate a $1, no matter who wins. Every single dollar, cent, anything really counts, so please take the effort to remember and go through with it.


Miscellaneous:

  • Note about legality: This is NOT a lottery. You don't have to pay to enter. No prizes are given away directly by the moderators of this subreddit (the moderators will never even touch your donations; this is done voluntarily).

  • Additionally, according to the IRS, gift taxes are paid by the donor, and any donations under $15,000 is not taxable.

  • If you are under 18, please talk to your parents to get their consent to participate and use their help to setup a PayPal account.

  • If you have any questions, you are welcome to ask them in the comments. The rules regarding comments do not apply to /r/millionairemakersmeta.


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Nov 24 '20

And again someone has games the system and won by using an obvious Alt. What are we going to do about this? It needs to stop

35 Upvotes

We really need to find a way to prevent this from happening. It would take work. Any maybe require a whole other bot to catalog and keep track of legitimate vs Alt accounts. But if we really want to make this a thing again. We need to do better. And we need a way for people to have faith in the system.

My two ideas.

1: we increase the requirements to enter. A higher karma requirement and a requirement to have some sort of activity on subs that aren’t giveaways or karma farming.

My second idea is one I brought up the last time this happened. It’s complicated. But I feel it’s the best solution. We make a bot that will require some sort of “proof of participation” before you will be allowed to enter. If you make a parent level comment on the drawing thread. You must donate to the winner. Or else you will be banned from The next drawing. This option admittedly still slows for alts. But then it would make it that anyone who uses an alt also has to give more.

Second option could also do some sort of way to prevent alts entirely by making the sub a invite only. And to join you have to submit a form. Where you give your reddit user and your PayPal username. That way if you have two accounts with the same PayPal you know you have an alt and one would be banned


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Jun 25 '20

Suggestion: Keep the entry thread open longer than 24 hours

31 Upvotes

Lack of participation is a problem. The longer the entry thread is open then the more people who have a chance to participate. Simple.

Obviously there still needs to be a cut off, but I think we should try 2 days for a while, then test 3 days and we'll see how it effects participation.


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Jan 24 '20

Recurring payments?

30 Upvotes

While I like how MillionaireMakers is very honor-system bound, I'm a forgetful human being, and really don't mind chipping in a $1+ a month to transform a life.

The idea of the drawing being based on submitted comments, is great. Could we add a recurring donations system to really stoke the momentum of the monthly pot? It'd also be a healthy way to provide a layer of privacy between redditor's payment method and the public at large.


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Nov 26 '20

This situation is making me sick

28 Upvotes

Edit: IT WORKED OUT! YAY!

The guy followed the rules, hasn't broken any, and the only "evidence" is pure conspiracy, assumption, and judgmental behavior. We can't expect people, who stand to benefit from /u/umerabrar89 being passed over, to vote fairly when they have a stake in benefitting whether or not he won! This is diluting the spirit of the sub. I think the "poll" needs to be cancelled since his identity has been proven. This is absolutely ridiculous. 🤬


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Dec 21 '19

There’s plenty of traffic at the Christmas party. If you have any questions, or just want to talk about how good the party’s getting (for whatever reason), feel free to discuss it here! It’s posted on my main account, so I should hear it! [Discussion #49]

25 Upvotes

To enter the Drawing Thread - Part 2, click here! THIS IS NOT THE DRAWING THREAD, ANY COMMENTS HERE WON’T COUNT AS YOUR ENTRY!


What's next?

Alright, I had this part written in the event of a three-parter, but comments are slowing down. If you're excited about the Drawing, make sure your preparations are set.

First, you need to make sure you have made one (AND ONLY ONE) comment in any of the three [Drawing Thread] posts. This comment also must be a top level comment, as seen here. Have you made more than one comment, and neither of them are replies? Take the time between now and midnight (ET) to delete a comment of your choice. Each account may only leave one comment in any of the three threads, and all winners will have their accounts checked out for any questionable activity.

Second, you need to stay tuned this Sunday at 11 AM ET (16 UTC). The winner will begin to be picked at that time, and a post will be made to acknowledge that.

In case you don't know, all of our winners have been picked by the third block released on the Bitcoin blockchain at that time. This process can be as short as twenty minutes or as long as an hour. You don't need any Bitcoin, all you have to know is a big line of numbers (a hash) comes out, and picks the winner for us!

The text file is released beforehand, with all of the entrants from the three [Drawing Thread] posts summed up in the post and a SHA-256 hash, to make sure none of the data has been tampered with. I will also include an Information folder, so for those who don't code, can find the winner for yourselves.

In other words, it's going to be remarkably hard for this to be rigged and going unnoticed.

Third, make sure you are reminded to donate to the winner! That includes setting a calendar reminder at December 23 at 6 PM ET (23 UTC), or PMing the RemindMe bot about it (links below). This is the biggest Millionaire Makers thread, and we want to give the winner justice!

For closure, this is done every month. If you thought today was hectic, January will not only be the first [Drawing Thread] of 2020, but our 50th Drawing Thread! That means that once January is done, we will have made 50 millionaires! (Our definition of "millionaire" in this subreddit is loose.)

Keep in touch! We have our own Discord moderated by one of the mod team, and if Discord isn't your thing, then set a reminder for January 17 at 6 PM ET! We have RemindMe bots, too (links below).

Finally, thank you all for entering this. Your entries have made this one of the biggest threads in the subreddit's history, and I'm excited to see what the future holds.


Clarification:

I want to let everyone know of a few things.

First, congratulations! Never before as moderator has this happened, you all have made me work harder as soon as I woke up!

Second, I want to clarify on some things. I’ve seen some accounts make replies, but have it as their only comment. If you have made a reply, make sure you make an original top-level comment to enter in the [Drawing Thread].

How do I know my comment is a top-level comment? Well, I have a handy graphic for you: https://imgur.com/Si1VLX4

Third, I am going to make a change. The Drawing Thread will receive a three-hour extension! This means that the posts will be locked at 9 PM ET (2 UTC), to give the people who weren’t able to comment in the original a chance to do so.

As for gathering comments, there is also change in that. They will be done only once at 12 PM ET (5 UTC) (originally 9 PM ET). This is because with so many people, many delete their comments, either due to not qualifying or not wanting to enter. This directly affects how comments are gathered, and with users this size, comment gathering will take a significant amount of time. To retry every time a comment is deleted will delay the [Draw] process, hence this decision. Speaking of which, the [Draw] post will continue to be made at 11 AM ET (16 UTC).

Finally, thank you. The response has been wonderful, and I’m glad this has been well received. If you have any comments, make sure you leave it in this subreddit: /r/millionairemakersmeta. If this is your first time here, I’ve also pasted the information from the original [Drawing Thread].


In Case You Missed It:

  • This is done every month, we will be doing this again starting with January for our 50th Drawing and the first [Drawing Thread] of 2020! If you would like to be reminded, set a calendar reminder for January 17 at 6 PM ET, or click here to be reminded through the RemindMe bot via PM!

  • I (the writer) am currently on winter break and will take the free time I have now to future-proof this subreddit. I will add a Dropbox text file with all of the dates for 2020 in the upcoming hours, and will update the list of past winners in the subreddit sidebar (if you can’t see it, use old.reddit.com).

  • Our last winner, /u/Phantom_Viper, is currently accepting donations! A college student and a hard worker, donations will go towards savings and to future winners. If you would like to contribute, donate here!

  • The /r/millionairemakersmeta discussion thread is now up!


This thread is for the sole purpose of discussion. Any comments here will not count towards your entry at /r/MillionaireMakers.


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Jun 24 '20

MillionaireMakers current drawing and moving forward thoughts and ideas

24 Upvotes

I like most other people are a little bit suspicious of our current pending winner. Under 200 total karma and only 1month old. Add to a suspicious post history of how to evade getting detected when you comKent on one post with multiple accounts this screams of someone cheating the system. And that’s just not ok.

So here are some ideas of mine addressing two issues on /r/MillionaireMakers. 1: making sure nobody is cheating the system. And 2; making sure people actually donate.

Let’s start with 1. Easiest way I can think of is require every account to fill out an “intro form” on something like google forms. Where you put in your reddit username. And all of your information for where people can send you money if you win.

This purpose is twofold. Saving the mods from contacting and getting the information delaying the process. And allowing a database to check against itself. If you accounts have the same PayPal it’s an alt and that entry won’t be counted.

The second problem is one that I also see having a simple solution. With the database from 1 we now have a list of every account that successfully enters PayPal and etc. now all we ask is that you send in a picture of the screen or email you get after sending money (with necessary personal details blurred of course) then when the next months entry comes around if and that account hasn’t given at least say $1. Then you are barred from entry for that month.

Both of these seem reasonable and well within what a bot or a mod team could do.


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Apr 18 '20

Am I dumb or are the instructions confusing? I know how to enter the drawing but I do not know how to put money in, or, understand howI would find out if I won.

24 Upvotes

r/millionairemakersmeta • • Jan 14 '24

Discussion Thread for /r/MillionaireMakers [Discussion for 2024]

23 Upvotes

Discussion Thread

This thread covers discussion from the threads listed below! In case you didn’t know, [Drawing Thread] posts are held once a month on every 15th. The entry threads are posted at the following times, and are open for 24 hours.

2024 Drawing Threads

January 15 23:00 UTC (changed)

February 15 23:00 UTC (changed)

THE 100TH ENTRY THREAD - March 15 23:00 UTC

April 15 23:00 UTC

May 15 23:00 UTC

June 15 23:00 UTC

July 15 23:00 UTC

August 15 23:00 UTC

September 15 23:00 UTC

October 15 23:00 UTC

November 15 23:00 UTC

December 15 23:00 UTC


This thread is for the sole purpose of discussion. Any comments here will not count towards your entry at /r/MillionaireMakers.


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Dec 14 '20

Finding my way.

21 Upvotes

Hello everyone .I have been a member of millionairemakers for 4 years but was too busy with work and quite honestly to depressed to even care to comment or enter. My 26 year marriage recently ended abruptly one morning. In an instant my world changed. I was shell shocked. I still am. Now I'm couch surfing while in the process of trying to find a divorce attorney. It's not easy with very little income. I would love to be chosen and find a room for rent and gain back some of my pride and privacy. I wish everyone who enters good luck. What a wonderful way for people to help eachother. Thank you Reddit. Thank you to everyone who participates.


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Jun 23 '20

Suggestion: Unpin the Winner's thread when the next drawing happens

21 Upvotes

Hi,

the typical way I participate is like this:

- I comment in the drawing thread

- I set a remind bot to remind me in 3 days

- In 3 days, I see the message and go to donate

- I open and read the pinned winner's thread and I donate... wait a minute.

The Winner's thread is often not opened after three days yet and there is the previous winner's thread pinned in the top. I have almost donated twice to the same winner a few times already (there are usually these edits that remind me that something is wrong - then I check the date of the thread and realize my mistake).

Does it happen just to me? Would it be possible to unpin the previous winner's thread after the new drawing thread is created?


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Aug 20 '19

Reminder: please upvote drawing and winner threads, so they stay on subscribers' front pages, so they don't miss them.

Thumbnail self.millionairemakers
21 Upvotes

r/millionairemakersmeta • • Jan 15 '25

Discussion Thread for /r/MillionaireMakers [Discussion for 2025]

19 Upvotes

Discussion Thread

This thread covers discussion from the threads listed below! In case you didn’t know, [Entry Thread] posts are held once a month on every 15th. The entry threads are posted at the following times, and are open for 24 hours.

2025 Entry Threads

January 15 23:00 UTC

February 15 23:00 UTC

March 15 23:00 UTC

April 15 23:00 UTC

May 15 23:00 UTC

June 15 23:00 UTC

July 15 23:00 UTC

August 15 23:00 UTC

September 15 23:00 UTC

October 15 23:00 UTC

November 15 23:00 UTC

December 15 23:00 UTC


This thread is for the sole purpose of discussion. Any comments here will not count towards your entry at /r/MillionaireMakers.


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Nov 27 '20

Sidebar Winners List

19 Upvotes

In the sidebar there is a list of winners along with their approximate winnings. Would it be possible to keep this updated, even if the winnings aren't known? The last entry is from 2019.

Thanks mods for all you do.


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Feb 24 '20

I want to be active in this sub but I never receive updates from my feed.

19 Upvotes

The mods should consider creating an app to join/donate with a click of a button.

I can always help with creating an app!!

Feel free to DM me


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Jan 19 '20

Drawing frequency

19 Upvotes

I see a lot of people give two dollars, myself included. What if we drew twice a month? I feel like having more rapid drawing would keep people active, and more winners should bring more attention.


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Jan 14 '22

Discussion Thread for /r/MillionaireMakers [Discussion for Winter and Spring 2022]

18 Upvotes

Discussion Thread

This thread covers discussion from the threads listed below! In case you didn’t know, [Drawing Thread] posts are held once a month on every 3rd Friday. The entry threads are posted at the following times, and are open for 24 hours.

2022 Drawing Threads

January 21 23:00 UTC

February 18 23:00 UTC

March 18 23:00 UTC

April 15 23:00 UTC

May 20 23:00 UTC

June 17 23:00 UTC

July 15 23:00 UTC

August 19 23:00 UTC

September 16 23:00 UTC

October 21 23:00 UTC

November 18 23:00 UTC

December 16 23:00 UTC


This thread is for the sole purpose of discussion. Any comments here will not count towards your entry at /r/MillionaireMakers.


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Jun 26 '20

48 hours to respond is lame

18 Upvotes

I can't believe I won but lose because I'm offline in the middle of the work week. Apologies to the keyboard jockeys frothing at the gills, but I'm not a bot, I just have to work.


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Feb 22 '20

A Remind Me link to donate/winners thread

16 Upvotes

There's a reminder link to the NEXT drawing, which is nice, but what about a reminder to donate to the winner?

I only remembered to give to the winner now a month later.


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Jan 18 '20

On the offchance that I do win, what do I have to do to receive the winnings. I have a paypal account, that's what I use to give the dollar to the winner but how do I receive the winnings if I do win?

16 Upvotes

r/millionairemakersmeta • • Jun 20 '21

Love this place!

15 Upvotes

r/millionairemakersmeta • • Dec 21 '19

Donation amount data over time?

15 Upvotes

I'm curious if winners could submit total amount donated so everyone can see in one place who won, estimated amount won, anything else that would be interesting, maybe break down of how donations were made. It would be cool to see the patterns over time, as the subreddit grows, % of users who donate vs who enter, that kind of stuff. Maybe it's a 60 or 90 day total so they can be reminded to submit totals after that period?


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Aug 17 '19

It’s been a year since I started doing this. Feel free to discuss. [Discussion #45]

15 Upvotes

To enter the Drawing Thread, click here! THIS IS NOT THE DRAWING THREAD!


Major Announcements

New Account:

This will be my last [Drawing Thread] posted on this account, but only because I’m transferring all official posts to a new one:

/u/MakerOfMillionaires

Starting September, he will be responsible for all official /r/MillionaireMakers posts, primarily the [Drawing Thread] and [Drawing] posts. If you’re also using the new version of Reddit, you can follow his account and you will (should) be getting posts from said account directly in your home page!

Additionally, in the event we program a bot, it should be easier to do it through a separate account. Thank you so much!

Looking for Web Developers:

Alright, my license to use redditmm.com is expiring (I want to give a final thank you to the Bitcoin Cash Association for gifting me the domain several months ago), and spending money makes for a really good incentive to put it to proper use.

In other words, I’m looking for web developers willing to volunteer their time. If you have the knowledge, please use our interest form here: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSei_V6_7VxXjLou3yaLzqILtJfHRPLr69YubxcnJ9WiuxPFhQ/viewform?usp=sf_link

I am willing to write the pages and other things I can put in effort from my end. However, I can only do so much. If you do volunteer, know that you will not be paid (I’m already going to spend $13-ish bucks on renewing the domain), but it will really mean a lot for offering your skills and time to us. There’s no deadline, and your consideration means a lot.


This thread is for the sole purpose of discussion. Any comments here will not count towards your entry at /r/MillionaireMakers.


r/millionairemakersmeta • • Apr 27 '21

So 5 hours ago reminderbot messaged me to enter in last months draw?!

Post image
14 Upvotes