r/mathteachers • u/ninety_percentsure • Jan 10 '24
3rd grade assignment
My 3rd grade daughter was assigned this problem. I can’t for the life of me figure out any missing number except the middle cell. Is this a bad question or am I misunderstanding something?
10
u/DeliveratorMatt Jan 10 '24
This is wild. It’s doable… with Algebra 1 systems of equations method. Otherwise it’s a ton of guess and test.
2
u/ninety_percentsure Jan 10 '24
Yes I agree. I asked the teacher if a number was omitted by mistake. She hasn’t yet responded
5
u/Earl_N_Meyer Jan 10 '24
It is not solvable with a system of equations. I dumped it into a matrix and it was not invertible. I then tried guess and check and you find that there is not a unique solution.
→ More replies (1)4
Jan 11 '24
Thank you. There are many, many solutions even if you just stick to natural numbers. The center square has one solution, but the four corners can be anything as long as you start with a pair that works for that row or column.
→ More replies (12)2
u/Yagloe Jan 11 '24
Guess-and-test is exactly the point of a problem like this in third grade: practice mutidigit add and subtract repeatedly to solve one problem instead of 20 or so rote calculations presented in rows and columns.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/pixelboy1459 Jan 10 '24
You can find the difference of any grey box and its white boxes. 700 - 103 = 597.
Then you need to find out what balance would work out.
2
u/ninety_percentsure Jan 10 '24
Yes but it seems like so much guess and check and abstract thinking for that age group. Whew!
3
u/beckybones257 Jan 11 '24
As a fifth grade teacher, I totally agree. This seems logic based rather than math based.
→ More replies (1)2
u/Mission_Plantain_289 Jan 10 '24
The top left box is 197 and everything else falls into place. I’m not sure if it’s reasonable for 3rd grade math but maybe a process was taught in class that would have made this easier for a 3rd grader to do. Reaching out to the teacher may be worth a shot?
2
u/BaXeD22 Jan 12 '24
This is an awful question. Finding a set of values which work in the grid isn't necessarily hard, since you can fill in literally any value in any one of the corners and work out the rest of the grid. But the question wording "Find the missing numbers" implies that there's a single set of numbers which completes the grid.
If it said something to make it clear that there's not exactly one solution, maybe it would be better? But I'm assuming the goal here is to test whether or not a student can recognize when they can use addition/subtraction to find a missing value, and so this problem is underspecified
1
16
u/BizzEB Jan 10 '24 edited Jan 11 '24
There are many solutions*. Guess something reasonable for one of the four corners squares and solve for the rest.
*204 possible solutions if constrained to non-negative integers, infinitely many when using integers or reals
→ More replies (12)6
u/stillflat9 Jan 11 '24
I teach third. I haven’t seen a problem set like this, but I will say we really stress the importance of asking yourself, “Is my answer reasonable?” There isn’t one correct answer here. It seems to require big picture thinking and flexibility which builds fluency.
4
u/ORteach Jan 13 '24
As a middle school teacher I can’t thank you enough for emphasizing the reasonable question. This is a main emphasis of mine as well (but still you wouldn’t believe some of the answers I get…).
13
u/AnachronisticCog Jan 10 '24
This looks difficult for 3rd grade. You can work the middle one with them easily but for the four corners, my first instinct is to set up a system of 4 linear equations. I don’t think that would be something 3rd graders are taught but if it is, I can show you how to do it.
4
u/RanchoCuca Jan 11 '24 edited Jan 11 '24
Yeah, I think educators need to be very careful, intentional, and explicit about the reason for a given task. As many folks have found, the problem is pretty easily answerable just by using guess-and-check. At the third grade level, that may be an appropriate task, asking them to consider what a reasonable guess might be, and then allowing them to practice their basic arithmetic (with the rudiments of algebraic thinking) as they flesh out the boxes. It can also serve as a demonstration that some math tasks have multiple solutions.
On the other hand, there are times when guess-and-check is fine, but there are times when being methodical is necessary. Solving (or at least approaching) this problem methodically using equations is above the level of most third graders, but they should be exposed to grade-appropriate problems where they don't/can't use guessing.
This makes me think of the "reading wars" in literacy. For many decades, there was a lot of emphasis on "whole language" approaches to reading where students were encouraged to use context clues like syntax or stem recognition to essentially make reasonable guesses when they ran across words they didn't know. This strategy was often emphasizes at the relative expense of methodical phonics instruction. While there is some merit to using context to infer meaning in certain situations, students who develop an overreliance on that imprecise strategy without developing fluency in phonetic decoding end up hampering themselves and often struggle to become fully fluent readers.
We want math students who both have holistic number sense and methodical problem-solving ability, so they don't just rely on guessing, but nor do they blindly use equations they don't really understand (and can't spot when obvious calculation errors arise because they're just "plugging and chugging")
→ More replies (2)6
u/Petporgsforsale Jan 11 '24
I teach high schoolers. I’m going to give this to them tomorrow and see how it goes.
4
3
u/MatthewAkselAnderson Jan 11 '24
Let us know how it goes!
→ More replies (1)3
u/Petporgsforsale Jan 12 '24
About a fifth of the kids got it. They almost all tried it. After about 10 minutes they started moving on to other things. The first kid that finished, did it in about 5 minutes and the last one in about 15 minutes.
→ More replies (1)2
u/Serious-Service-4629 Jan 12 '24
How did it go
3
u/Petporgsforsale Jan 12 '24
I gave it to one of my classes. They just about all 9th and 10th graders. A few didn’t start or gave up early. Some chose to help a peer instead of try to figure it out themselves. About 4 or 5 completed it correctly and all got different answers. It took about 5 minutes for the first person to get it and maybe almost 15 minutes for the last person. They all kind of moved on at that point.
→ More replies (2)3
u/PacificGlacier Jan 11 '24 edited Jan 11 '24
Second grade teacher here. Isn’t it easier to plug in one in a corner and then everything else balances out
Edit: got out a pencil and no it doesn’t work
→ More replies (1)2
u/AnachronisticCog Jan 11 '24 edited Jan 11 '24
I teach college classes so I will admit I don’t know entirely what is grade-appropriate. I started working on it with a matrix and there is at least one free variable. I did just get out of a surgery today so I was interrupted by needing to take all my meds so I haven’t finished it yet.
→ More replies (3)
12
6
u/Pikachu-nazi Jan 11 '24
Former math teacher here. Start by putting a "0" in the top left corner, then start solving from them on.
Should look like this.
344+456+000= 800 103+200+297=600 253+144+203=600
Or start by putting a "1" on top left corner and go from there...you get the idea.
I would never use anything like this for my 3rd graders.
→ More replies (4)1
u/ZealousidealTurn2211 Jan 12 '24
This sounds like the time I asked my calculus based physics TA for help on a problem and he replied with "Oh this variable is going to be extremely small so just ignore it entirely."
This kind of shit is why children struggle. Not because they can't understand, but because they're given problems reliant on nonsensical shortcuts that no one explains to them.
5
u/DorkSideOfCryo Jan 11 '24
I just remember working with a lot of crayons in third grade
3
1
u/iesharael Jan 14 '24
Third grade was when I finally learned how to read a book instead of just basic instructions… I feel like this question must be for at least a 6th grader??? Maybe if it was only 2 digits instead of 3 and it was the corner boxes filled? I’m a college graduate and took every math class my buisness college had to offer and I’ve no clue who to solve this beyond the middle is 0
4
u/NebulaPanda7695 Jan 10 '24
This would have made more sense if there was a corner box between the two bottom right grays. Without it then it really is just a bunch of guess work until it all firs
→ More replies (2)
4
u/Earl_N_Meyer Jan 10 '24
I think if you just shove a number between 0 and 344 in for the top left you can then solve the top right, the bottom left and the bottom right. I think there are many solutions.
2
u/pogidaga Jan 11 '24
If you limit yourself to non-negative integers, the smallest number that can go in the upper left is 141. I suspect every number between 141 and 344 will work in the upper left. Solving for the other corners is simple arithmetic.
2
4
u/chillpenguin99 Jan 11 '24
At first I was like "what's the problem, it's simple algebra. You just set up an equation and solve for the missing variable. Do that a few times". Then I was like "oh wait because of the grid structure you need to set up a system of equations. Ok I see why it is hard.". And THEN I was like "oh wait this is an assignment for 3rd graders..."
1
u/Bhappy-2022 Jan 11 '24 edited Jan 11 '24
This is disappointing…. I would switch schooling districts completely!
Let children be kids and allow them to enjoy their childhood. This is hopefully fake. But instead of assuming I’ll give you my 2 cents just in-case.
The state I live in but I am in the (USA). My daughter is currently enrolled in 3rd grade as well and she is only doing times, division, and fractions.
2
u/ninety_percentsure Jan 13 '24
It is not fake. My kid’s elementary school had an e-learning day this week because of weather, and this was one of the problems sent home with my 3rd grader.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/OriginalLetrow Jan 12 '24
It looks like some bullshit they pulled off a state assessment. Confusing as hell.
1
1
u/Randomguyintheus Jan 12 '24
Not meant as a sarcastic question… do you know algebra? This is a system of equations.
Like the top row is x + 456 + y = 800.
There are six equations total.
1
u/ninety_percentsure Jan 13 '24
It’s a system with infinite solutions though. Did you try to work it out?
→ More replies (1)
3
u/user41510 Jan 11 '24
Good morning class! It's raining today so we're not going outside for recess. Do this until the bell rings at 3pm.
2
1
Jan 10 '24
Yeah this is reasonable. Probably some guess and check. Honestly it would look a lot less intimidating if it were just equations, but the area model looking thing allows for more answers.
1
2
u/crazy_teacher345 Jan 11 '24
That does seem tricky and certainly a challenge for 3rd graders. However, I would think 4th graders could give it a shot, especially paying attention to place value and making tens.
2
u/SlurpilyFun Jan 11 '24
I teach third grade, I’ll give this to my class tomorrow. I’m willing to bet only 1, maybe 2, will be able to solve it. There’s 19 kids in the class.
→ More replies (1)
2
Jan 11 '24
I don’t think any of the 3rd graders at our title 1 school could do this. MAYBE a couple of the top students 🤷♀️
2
u/MatthewAkselAnderson Jan 11 '24 edited Jan 12 '24
TL;DR? My answers are a = 400, b = 597, c = -253, d = 0, and e = 456.
Here's how I did it as a system of equations.
First, check it's even possible with a system of equations. We have five unknown numbers and five equations. So, let's get started!
We're given that the sums of the rows are 800, 600, and 600; and that the sums of the columns are 700, 800, and 500.
Let the unknown variables be labelled thusly:
b | 456 | c
————————
103 | a | 297
————————
d | 144 | e
And let's get solving.
Solve for a**.**
103 + a - 297 = 800
a + 400 = 800
a = 400.
Create four equations for b, c, d, and e.
b + 456 + c = 800
b + c = 344
c = 344 - b ①
d + 144 + e = 600
d + e = 456
d = 456 - e ②
b + 103 + d = 700
b + d = 597
b = 597 - d ③
c + 297 + e = 500
c + e = 203
c = 203 - e ④
Substitute ② into ③
b = 597 - d
b = 597 - (456 - e) ⑤
Substitute ⑤ into ①
c = 344 - b
c = 344 - 597 - (456 - e)
c = 344 - 597 - 456 + e
c = -709 + e ⑥
Substitute ⑥ into ④
c = 203 - e = -709 + e
c + e = 203 = -709 + 2e
c + e + 709 = 912 = 2e
(c + e + 709) / 2 = 912 / 2 = e
>> Check by substituting in eq. ④
e = 912 / 2 = 456 ⑦
Substitute ⑦ into ④
c = 203 - e
c = 203 - 465
c = -253
Substitute ⑦ into ③
b = 597 - (456 - e)
b = 597 - (456 -456)
b = 597
Substitute ⑦ into ②
d = 456 - e
d = 456 - 456
d = 0
a = 400, b = 597, c = -253, d = 0, and e = 456.
And finally, check!
b + 456 + c = 800
597 + 456 + -253 = 800 ✓
d + 144 + e = 600
0 + 144 + 456 + 600 ✓
b + 103 + d = 700
597 + 103 + 0 + 700 ✓
c + 297 + e = 500
-253 + 297 + 456 = 500 ✓
Edit: I fixed some formatting with my italicizing and boldening of text.
1
u/MatthewAkselAnderson Jan 11 '24
Oh, no! I spot at least one undue assumption in my calculations. It didn't make my answers wrong or incorrect, but perhaps I was not practicing "good hygiene"? Can you spot it?
1
u/BaXeD22 Jan 12 '24
There's not an "undue assumption", but your arithmetic for "substitute 5 into 1" is wrong and it should just reduce down to equation 4 (the equation you already have with c and e as variables). There's obviously infinitely many solutions, so any solution that only results in a single answer will have an issue somewhere in the solution
Specifically, equation 5 is:
b = 597 - (456 - e)
b = 141 + e
Then substitute back into equation 1:
c = 344 - b
c = 344 - (141 + e)
c = 203 - e
This is already known to be true.
There's one "free variable" here, aka you can just choose a value for any of b, c, d, e and arrive at a solution for the other variables based on the chosen value, which is why you still end up with a set of values that meet the equation.
But there's not one correct answer here, which is why this is a bad question, since it's wording implies it can be solved with a unique solution ("Fill in the missing numbers implies there's a known number missing in each cell")
→ More replies (3)
2
u/WildMartin429 Jan 11 '24
Is this Sudoku? Seriously though seems a little complex for third grade like maybe fourth grade.
2
2
u/Chance_Split_7723 Jan 11 '24
At this moment, I'm failing the new third grade math. Think I'll just go doodle with my 300+ colors of crayons now...
2
u/alesemann Jan 11 '24
This is the kind of assignment that taught me to loathe math w every fiber of my being. There would be no teaching… just: give it a try! Sure. And here’s a cement wall to bang your head on if this gets boring.
2
2
u/Adventurous_Movie797 Jan 11 '24
This hurts my brain. So many possibilities after figuring out the middle column
2
u/Massive_Potato_8600 Jan 11 '24
This is so unnecessarily complicated especially for a nine year old😭 i couldnt imagine doing at my age now
2
2
2
u/No-Appearance1145 Jan 11 '24
My sister used to have to estimate multiplication. Like round it down or up to the nearest tenth and then add whatever the remaining numbers were in the equation. I don't get it.
2
u/JasonMckin Jan 13 '24
The answer is a lot more obvious to folks who can think with a linear algebra mindset. The middle row and column are basically irrelevant to the problem so it’s really a 2x2 box problem with the corners. But anyone with that linear algebra mindset would immediately see that you don’t actually have 4 equations and 4 unknowns. One of the equations will always fall out. The only way for the solution to be unique is if one of the corners had not been blank since there are only 3 independent equations. Based on the fact that the problem has a variable equation as the answer, it is clearly inappropriate at the 3rd grade level. 3rd graders should still be building intuition around how mathematical techniques relate a problem space to a singular solution space. It’s a principle that even applies to adults with non-mathematical training. My biggest failures with training adults is when I could not clearly associate a process or methodology to a specific problem space- solution space pairing.
2
u/ighatemilksomuch Jan 14 '24
wtf are they making these teachers teach these kids now a days 😭😭. i was only in elem/middle school in the 2000’s and they just taught like normally¿
3
u/Bright_Broccoli1844 Jan 10 '24
Not suitable for a third graders, and not suitable for adult me. It gave me a headache.
→ More replies (3)
1
u/MatthewAkselAnderson Jan 11 '24
I first thought to do it algebraically, the way any high school student should be able to do it. But for third grade? That's a bit accelerated, imo.
1
1
u/ellsmirip25 Jan 11 '24
You could apparently simply use 0 in one of the top row entries and a 1 in one of the bottom row entries, right?
1
u/StrawberryReady5620 Jan 11 '24
I got it 🤷🏻♀️ I'm not rly naturally good at math either but always enjoyed logic puzzles and algebra was fun to me. I definitely have a higher education than a third grader but feel like this isn't super above grade level. it's a guess and check kinda thing
1
1
u/trophycloset33 Jan 11 '24
It’s a problem set for practicing substitution. A problem solving method common for entry level algebra.
Assign each empty box as a variable (x, y, z, a, b)
List out the equations both vertically and horizontally (x+456+y=800 and etc)
Pick one variable to start with and start substituting
You will end up with multiple solutions in solution matrices where a solution is only valid if the solution for the other variables also comes from that same matrix. I do not know if they want all solutions or just a viable solution
1
u/PerspectiveOk493 Jan 11 '24
Starting in top left corner and going from L to R, then 2nd Row, L to R, then 3rd row
244+456+100=800 103+200+297=600 353+144+103=600
No idea if it's the proper way, but it works out fine
1
u/PirateLife23 Jan 11 '24
This is something they can do. It’s working on the “is it reasonable” aspect of the standards. We all know how to get the middle number. Boom. Done.
Now move to the column on the right. 500-297 gives us 203. Well it is reasonable to assume each box would have about 100 in it.
Let’s do a row now. Bottom row. I take 600-144 and I’m left with 456. So I’ll leave that bottom right box 100. Bottom left box becomes 356.
This automatically makes top left box 241 (700-356-103) and makes the top right box 103 (remember one box in that column needed 103, and we made the other 100).
Yes there are other ways to solve. But this is analyzing, evaluating, and considering reasonableness.
Students that just randomly “guess and check” are not using the “is it reasonable” thought process.
1
u/AdministrativeYam611 Jan 11 '24
While this might be above 3rd grade level, my honors math class is 3rd grade did advanced critical thinking content like this, or more rigorous, all the time.
1
u/Chance_Split_7723 Jan 11 '24
And geez, third graders are up to adding and subtracting these amounts? Yikes
1
u/Kingblack425 Jan 11 '24
I could see how this would be a challenge for a 3rd grader but it shouldn’t be one they couldn’t overcome. Like they should be able to do this in one class period after going over an example with the teacher. I like how this has some pre algebra vibes to it.
1
u/Yagloe Jan 11 '24
While some kind of sophisticated strategy might lead to a more or less efficient solution to the problem, that's not really the point in a third grade context. The idea is to give students an opportunity to do lots of addition and subtraction practice in a single problem solving situation, rather than assigning a worksubtraction rote multidigit additions and subtractions or something. The students come up with their own practice problems as they guess-and-check their way to a solution. Whether students will approach this kind of practice with persistance or give up after trying a couple of values depends on the impression they have of what math and problem solving are about. That impression is usually based on communication with their parents and teachers.
1
u/KingColbyIII Jan 11 '24
A note that there may be more than one solution would go along way for that. Trying to throw it in a matrix and seeing that there isn’t A correct answer threw me off.
1
Jan 11 '24
Why did you all guess; or involve equations? Im so curious because to me this is simply addition and subtraction. It gives you the middle 600 line answer already so you know there’s only one possible answer in that center line and that same number corresponds with the 800s because you already have your first box out of the two for that top line. It sounds complicated typing it out but it really gives you the answers from the totals, and which rows share boxes. Then work up to the totals on a calculator. I used mental math and a calculator, no fancy or advanced method and it took me 3-4 minutes max.
1
1
u/sophiajeannine Jan 11 '24
this can be different depending where you plug in the numbers. here's how i did it. from left to right in the blank boxes: 144, 200, 200, 453, 3. you start with your middle value and plug it in to one of the first two boxes (i did the second) since we already know we can add 456 + 144 + 200 to get to 800. then solve the vertical problems.
1
u/Spectre322 Jan 11 '24
Looking at this, I definitely understand both sides. Looking at this and reading the instructions i jumped to looking for THE solution, not ANY solution. As soon as i understood the criteria, it became easy enough for 3rd grade me, but that wasn't given here. No udea if the child has context.
1
1
u/Concrete_Grapes Jan 11 '24
The logic of how i did it.
Center is obvious subtraction.
There are two 600's as answers, so in my brain, they're going to be the same--but, it's NOT a 600 on the back (700 down), and it's 500 on the front--so, i need to make the bottom left, 297+100. Then solve for the front box, like i did for the center.
Now the top right can be solved. It's 144. Then i can solve the final back corner. 200.
To me this feels like a logic puzzle, not a math problem (i know, same same), you just have to use the tool of the 600/700 battle in the bottom left to solve, and it rotates to a solution for all of it.
1
u/EMachine03 Jan 11 '24
I solved it…
Using linear algebra…
1
u/Reasonable_Sector526 Jan 12 '24
haha yeah, that's the same approach that I'd use to solve it. Glad I wasn't the only one. but I'm guessing that's not what they're looking for. lol
1
u/asleepatwork Jan 11 '24
4 simultaneous equations 4 unknowns Solvable, but a bit advanced for 3rd grade
1
u/Alponly Jan 11 '24
It’s teaching kids self confidence. There are lots of solutions. For example, plug a zero into the upper right square as a test. The rest of the problem is then just addition and subtraction.
1
1
u/Ice-Walker-2626 Jan 11 '24
If you give this problem to 3rd graders, they will never touch math again with a 10ft pole. Self confidence?
1
u/mdencler Jan 11 '24
It's a great question. It's just one that a lot of 3rd graders will not be able to solve independently. It should be treated as such.
1
u/Idonthavetotellyiu Jan 11 '24
I don't see an issue with this, I was taught this in 5th grade and I would actively do this for fun on mobile. It's more of guessing until it fits IMO
1
u/Mountain-Resource656 Jan 11 '24
It seems there are many answers, but here’s mine:
141 | 456 | 203 | 800
103 | 200 | 297 | 600
456 | 144 | 000 | 600
700 | 800 | 500
1
u/TheBalzy Jan 11 '24
So this is why kids can't do math when I get them in HS Chemistry (10th/11th Grade) ...
1
1
Jan 11 '24
Seems really hard for a 3rd grader, other than just guess and check you’d need to set up a systems of equations right?
1
u/Snoo_36434 Jan 11 '24
Kids SHOULD NOT be doing puzzles. They need the basics drilled into them daily. This shouldn't even be extra credit. I agree with another post; this is the kind of stuff that only discourages kids. I hate school. I'm a grandmother/tutor.
1
1
u/wantsrobotlegs Jan 11 '24
This is one of them assignments that would have had me in a fight with the teacher. I never end up doing stuff like this the way they want me to, despite getting the right answers.
1
u/fatherofpugs12 Jan 11 '24
We teach these problems in 8th grade pre algebra/1st half of the course, but we always allow for it to be done by logical processes.
This is just guessing and checking. Not really sure what we are learning here other than teaching them to think? But aren’t there better ways?
1
1
u/kjs122 Jan 11 '24
from top left, first row: 241, 456, 103 = 800 103, 200, 297 = 600 356, 144, 100 = 600 || || || 700 800 500
1
u/dalone2 Jan 11 '24
Assume the top left cell is x, then the top right cell should be 344 - x, the bottom right cell should be x - 141, and the bottom left cell should be 597 - x. By calculating the sum of the left column: x + 103 + 597 - x = 700, we indeed fill the grid correctly.
For a 3rd grade student, it is likely they will not use "x", but try a specific number for the top left cell. They can finish the grid with the same strategy regardless of the value they choose.
It is a little hard, but promotes several good points for the students:
Sometimes you can't solve a puzzle step-by-step, and need to trial and error.
After filling out the grid, you should confirm the correctness.
Sometimes a puzzle can have multiple solutions.
1
u/lunderamia Jan 11 '24
Man all I can think of is plugging everything into a matrix and solving for variables
1
u/KingColbyIII Jan 11 '24
It doesn’t come cleanly out of a matrix. Multiple solutions.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/Bardmedicine Jan 11 '24
There are a few possibilities.
This is a small misprint, and the middle square should have led to another row/column having only one blank. I think this is the most likely.
The teacher is working with them on problem solving strategy and they are supposed to make a guess and then work out the rest of the problem. This is likely 3rd grade appropriate, still. They will see how everyone in the class can get different answers.
They are doing systems of equations. This would be very advanced for third grade, but I teach some very advanced kids who might be working on something like this.
1
1
u/popcornoutofbabycorn Jan 11 '24 edited Mar 02 '25
200, 456, 144
103, 200, 297
397, 144, 59
Solve for middle square (200)
Top row: You know that you can add 456 with 200 and 144 to get 800. There are only 2 variations you can try here.
Solve left column
Solve right column
Check with bottom row
1
u/Inquirous Jan 11 '24
What happened to just “this+that=answer” what was so bad about that format??
1
1
u/Far_Hamster_2410 Jan 11 '24
It only looks complicated once you take away the fact that it's in an odd setting it's simple even for a child ( not saying that as an insult I'm referencing the fact that it is for your kid not insinuating anything about you) these kinda of math problems are all about perspective
1
u/Defiant_Ingenuity_55 Jan 11 '24
There are strategies for solving this and your kid should have those from class. People don’t always understand why these problems are given but always being given a simple equation doesn’t really challenge the brain.
1
u/Defiant_Ingenuity_55 Jan 11 '24
There are strategies for solving this and your kid should have those from class. People don’t always understand why these problems are given but always being given a simple equation doesn’t really challenge the brain.
1
u/Small-Estimate-4641 Jan 11 '24
Don’t know if my answers are correct but I did get answers that line up with the final amounts.
Subtracted 456 from 800 to get 344. Subtracted 144 from 600 to get 456. Subtracted 103 from 700 to get 597. Subtracted 297 from 500 to get 203.
Subtracted 344 from 203 to get the bottom right square of 141. Got 62 from top right square that adds up to 500. Got 282 for top left square to get 800.
The last bottom left square gives 315 for 700.
282+456+62=800 103+200+297=600 315+144+141=600 282+103+315=700 456+200+144=800 62+297+141=500
Honestly though, this requires a bit of critical thinking on the students part to think outside the box, literally. There’s probably more potential answers to this but I wouldn’t know until seeing the final answers.
1
1
1
1
u/Aboko_Official Jan 11 '24
I wish there was more of this in school honestly. Its not about the answer, its about the journey.
1
1
u/GovTheDon Jan 11 '24
Shoot man idk if my 5th graders could figure this out, seems tricky enough for me
1
1
u/liebemachtfrei Jan 11 '24
This was the test for my 3rd grade gifted and talented class.
I was no longer gifted and talented.
1
u/Automatic_Moment_320 Jan 12 '24
At least five of my second graders can solve this I bet… I’m going to print and see how they do!
1
u/BrodysMama0521 Jan 12 '24
It’s just subtraction mama, so take the difference in some of those columns and unfortunately it’s a really shitty version of sudoku
1
1
1
u/Mad_Madam_Meag Jan 12 '24
I got all the columns and the top two rows, but the bottom row is wrong and it's driving me insane.
1
1
u/Intrepid-Antelope Jan 12 '24
Context is everything! My hope is that this comes from a packet with a title along the lines of:
"Not all math problems have just one correct answer"
How cool would it be to learn in third grade that some math problems can have *lots* of correct answers? Especially if the teacher goes on to point out that there are still a lot more wrong answers than right answers — just throwing random numbers in the grid won't work. But it's entirely possible that each student in the class could come up with their own correct answer.
FWIW, here's the answer I came up with:
241 456 103 800
103 200 297 600
356 144 100 600
700 800 500
I love the fact that there are so many other examples of correct answers in this thread, and I look forward to showing this problem to my (middle school and high school aged) boys.
1
u/Old_Landscape_6860 Jan 12 '24
There are infinite solutions so basically once you figure out the center number and then you throw in any numbers and work your way out.
1
u/Blue_Monkey_Funk Jan 12 '24
Yes, this is too much for a 3rd grader. The problem can be solved with some guess and check, but no 3rd grader (except those that enjoy number problems) will focus on this.
1
u/wasteoffire Jan 12 '24
I mean it's basically sudoku, but this seems more like 5th grade level. I used to T.A. for 3rd grade and they could barely add numbers up to 100, and I never once saw any of them applying logic to solve things
1
u/xFoxMcCloud2x Jan 12 '24
It’s 200. The inverse of addition is subtraction so subtracting the numbers in the white boxes from the number in the gray box should give you the missing numbers. 103-600= 497 and 497-297= 200 or you could add 103 and 297 and subtract the difference from 600 to get 200. Maybe you’re meant to find the center first since you have all the numbers to confirm that answer first.
→ More replies (2)
1
u/DJRThree Jan 12 '24
I think the question is bad in that it doesn't lay an age-appropriate path to solving the problem. I think someone goofed and filled in the wrong cell.
1
u/snowphysics Jan 12 '24
I'm a Math/Physics double major and I remember consistently crying over math in 3rd grade bc I'd get problems like this that didn't specify there were multiple solutions and I'd think I was too stupid for school.
L problem to assign to 3rd graders
1
u/freckle_thief Jan 12 '24
I did the middle easily, then put 100 to the left of 600 just to see if it would work, and then figured out the rest of the numbers from there and they worked
1
u/pinknpurplecows Jan 12 '24
It took a few minutes but I solved it. The first row is 225 + 456 + 116 = 800 the second row is 103 + 200 + 297 = 600 the third row is 369 + 144 + 87 to equal 600.
1
u/Any_Age_4424 Jan 12 '24
I got the following:
344 456 0 800 103 200 297 600 253 144 203 600 700 800 500
It was at this point, my brain hurt because there was more than one solution.
1
1
1
1
1
u/poodlini Jan 12 '24
plugged it into AI: Here's the result,
A | B | C | D
--------------------------------
1 356 | 456 | 343 | 800
2 103 | 153 | 297 | 600
3 197 | 144 | 259 | 600
4 700 | 800 | 500 | 2000
ETA: yeah some of those numbers don't add up correctly. Particularly Row 1. Guess AI isn't that smart afterall
1
u/tube_radio Jan 12 '24
The real answer is a generalized solution.
My vars: a=top left, b=top right, c=bottom left, d=bottom right
You start with the vars on one side and the middle values moved over so constants are on another side:
a+b=800-456 = 344
c+d=600-144 = 456
a+c=700-103 = 597
b+d=500-297 = 203
Then you simplify for each:
a=344-b
c=456-d
a=597-c
b=203-d
Then you can mix up to get the diagonal relationships a&d and b&c
a=344-b , b=203-d
b=203-d, c=456-d
From here, there are fixed relationships for any given variable to all others. Take C, for example. I use C because it's the first letter in "constant". So I'll solve for C.
You get a full generalized answer that covers all answers, with C being anything:
c=c
a=597-c
b=c-253
d=456-c
Example:
if c=0
a=597
b=-253
c=0
d=456
→ More replies (1)
1
u/CheesecakeTruffle Jan 12 '24
We learned how to carry numbers in 3rd grade. We'd have been totally bombed out of this.
1
u/someaccount246 Jan 12 '24 edited Jan 12 '24
I just tried this and got it in two minutes by grouping to hundreds. Here was my thought process:
A) center box. Looking at center row - 103 + 297 = 400 so the middle box has to be 200 (600-400). Then confirmed the middle column works.
B) left column. Left middle is 103 so let’s make left bottom end with 97 to work with easier numbers. If 197 then top left would be 400. This is too high because top row 400+456 is already over 800. So let’s make bottom left 297. Okay now top left is 300. That works.
C) top row to solve top right 800-300-456= 44
D) need to solve bottom right. Looking at right column I have 44 + 297 and looking at bottom row I have 297 + 144. I want to make my numbers easier by working with hundreds. To make those numbers hundreds I need 3 (for the numbers ending in 97) plus 56 (for the numbers ending in 44) which gives me 59. So with that logic for my right column my 44 becomes 100 and my 297 becomes 300. What’s missing is 100 so the number is 159. Confirm this works for the bottom row.
E) yay math!
I don’t do math in my career. I did used to teach Montessori and would say this type of thinking is similar to how we teach kids to think about numbers. Our advanced kindergarteners were multiplying and dividing 3 and 4 digit numbers because they had a solid understanding of place value, grouping etc. I’d recommend looking into Montessori math for anyone interested - I find it fascinating (the hands-on exponents is what drew me in off the bat - it solidified my understanding in a way I never had growing up).
1
u/Gullible_Flan_3054 Jan 13 '24
Assuming one number in each row/column is going to end in zero makes it much easier op
1
u/CardinalCountryCub Jan 13 '24 edited Jan 13 '24
I'm just seeing this 2 days later, but when I worked as a learning coach for virtual students during Covid year 1, this unit was specifically about 3-digit addition, so in the columns/rows where you have to get 2 numbers, you don't have to start at 1, x-1 but at 100, x-100 where "x" is the grey box minus the provided white box.
Basically, that top right corner could be 100, 101, 102, or 103 and the bottom right would be 103, 102, 101, or 100, respectively. Then, starting top right and moving clockwise, the remaining squares would yield: (100), 103, 353, 244 or (101), 102, 354, 243 or (102), 101, 355, 242 or (103), 100, 356, 241.
The goal of some of these assignments was to examine the process more than the answer, iirc.
1
1
1
u/MCMamaS Jan 13 '24
My fourth grade parents would riot if I sent this home.
This seems to be more of a puzzle than actual instructional practice (similar to KenKen). There is no reason to teach addition (or subtraction) like this (as opposed to area multiplication which represents actual area).
I try to send home puzzles and things to make students think outside of the curriculum.
1
u/Single-Limit1042 Jan 13 '24
This assignment would be better off given as a problem set that builds up from fundamentals if it didnt happen.
3 + 5 = ?
3 + 0 = ?
7 + 100 = ?
100 + 333 = ?
428 + 123 = ?
3 + X = 8; X = ?
10 + X = 15; X = ?
47 + X = 61; X = ?
381 + X = 999; X = ?
X + 101 + Y = 455; X = ?; Y = ? (infinite solutions if negative numbers are allowed or real numbers)
Given the above, solve this grid problem.
1
1
1
1
u/DoubbleD_UnicornChop Jan 14 '24
Interesting style, this looks like good practice for sudoku fanatics.
1
1
u/SpewPewPew Jan 14 '24
| 344 | 456 | 0 | 800|
| 103 | 200 | 297 | 600|
| 253 | 144 | 203 | 600|
| 700 | 800 | 500 |
I got lucky. I was trying for extremes cases to get some range and it happened to be the first.
1
u/Echoris09 Jan 14 '24
I just tried doing it and got it right - I'm no math teacher but I'll try to explain how I did it
The middle one is basically a free cell
Then instead of doing each square I focused on the 1s digits for each square
297 needs to get to 500 so I know either the top or bottom box needs a 3 in the 1s place
Then 144 plus XX3 needs to be 600, the bottom left square needs a 3 in the 1s place as well
Once I got all of the last digits in each square then I could fill in the 10s and 100s
Hope that helped a bit
1
u/Kagonu Jan 14 '24
I'm not sure what way kids are taught how to do this, but knowing that the middle is 200, I subtracted the known numbers from the totals, then to start solving the rest, I subtracted the first row and column remainders (800-456=344 & 700-103=597, 597-344=253). 253+103+[344]=700, and just repeated that throughout and that seemed to work. Feels like overly complicated Sudoku.
1
u/Cautious_Midnight_67 Jan 14 '24
This is literally algebra (systems of equations). So maybe a 7th grade level? Hilarious that this would be given to a 3rd grader - the only skills they have to solve this would be guess and check which is not productive for their learning at all
1
u/Hog_to_BANK Jan 14 '24
Think people think... like a third grader, the middle cell is 200 ... add numbers in the respective column or row and then subtract from either respective answer on the bottom or right side in those gray cells to get the final answer for the center cell.. Hello, it's 200 in both directions. Or can I just review college physics and multi variable calculus? LO. L
1
1
u/spaghettiplants Jan 14 '24
Should’ve been written to say there are multiple correct answers. Seems like a great way to discuss different strategies in a classroom discussion. Hope the teacher does that but also sucks that the instructions left room for confusion.
1
u/Training-Set9964 Jan 14 '24
It is really a simple problem because you can put anything in the top left square and then solve the top row. From there solve the far left column and lastly solve the bottom row. Any number will work for that first missing cell even negative numbers.
The real thing to notice here is if we label the corners a(top left) b(top right) c(bottom left) d(bottom right) and we know the center is 200. If I try 200 for cell a then I know b is 144 c is 397 and d is 59. If we want to say start a at 250 just add 50 to d and subtract 50 from b and c and you have a whole new solution.
A is always 141 more than d and c is always 253 more than b, so when a increases or decreases then d will increase and decrease by the same amount. This is the same for b and c and if b and c increase then a and d need to decrease by the same amount that b and c are increasing.
1
u/noisybogfrogs Jan 14 '24
I’m guessing there are three major points to this assignment: 1) there are multiple correct answers, 2) proficiency in understanding the ones/tens/hundreds place, 3) reading a grid. So many folks talking about systems of equations and math that has not yet been taught to 9 year olds. Middle answer is obvious, which leaves the corners. Figure out the ones place looking at both rows and columns. Figure out the tens place for each row and column. Figure out the hundreds place. Since there are so many correct answers, no guess work is really required.
1
u/JesusIsMyZoloft Jan 14 '24
There are infinitely many solutions. If all the numbers are integers, then there are countably infinite solutions. If all the numbers are positive, then the number in the top left corner must be between 141 and 344, giving the solution space a range of 203.
| 141 < x < 344 | 456 | 344 – x | 800 |
| 103 | 200 | 297 | 600 |
| 597 – x | 144 | x – 141 | 600 |
| 700 | 800 | 500 |
1
u/JesusIsMyZoloft Jan 14 '24
Have your daughter pick any number between 141 and 344 (my favorite is 270½), and write that in the upper left corner. Then the puzzle should be solvable.
1
Jan 14 '24
As a math student, I can say that this is a dependent system of equations, so you can always add 1 to the top left and bottom right cells which automatically subtracts 1 from the bottom left and top right cells, making an infinite number of integer solutions.
Unless if you are doing algebraic representation where the corners are something + or - x for all x in reals.
1
u/The_Bardiest_Bard Jan 14 '24
I used to do something like this when I was in TAG - its challenging for sure
1
1
u/Puzzleheaded-Phase70 Jan 10 '24
I like this format! New one for me.
2
Jan 10 '24
You do know this is for third graders right? This looks at minimum junior high levels
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/jneinefr Jan 10 '24
Just pick something for a square. For the bottom right corner, any number from 0 to 203 will work.
Honestly, negatives work too, and bigger numbers, but negative solutions are beyond grade 3.
So just, guess a number. It'll be right!
1
u/THEMommaCee Jan 11 '24
Retired teacher here. I love this! It’s more about thinking and problem solving than it is about getting one right answer. There are many situations in real life where there is more than one way to look at a problem and there are multiple solutions. This kind of problem would lead to a robust class discussion: How did you approach this? Ooh, cool! Who had a different way? Wow, that’s awesome! Did anyone try this?
It’s also important to keep in mind the context. What was the learning objective? (This should be clearly stated before the lesson: Scholars, today we will learn …) What kind of instruction/teaching happened before this worksheet was passed out? Did the teacher demonstrate one like this first or was this a get-your-brainiac-juices-flowing kind of task?
Also, how will this be assessed? Is this a check-off for completion or will some kind of grade be attached? This here would guide my level of concern with this assignment.
2
1
u/Bright_Broccoli1844 Jan 11 '24
It’s more about thinking and problem solving than it is about getting one right answer.
The problem for third grader me is that I am miserable in math class, I don't understand a damn thing, and I stopped paying attention about 10 minutes ago because it's boring too. Also you may call on me, so I can feel extra stupid.
The solution is that I get a massive stomach ache, get sent to the nurse, and go home. My mommy makes me toast and tea. I get into bed, read Charlotte's Web, and recover. My dad comes home from work, we watch Happy Days together, and all is right in the world.
→ More replies (2)
1
u/Abundance_of_Copium Jan 11 '24
Not that difficult. I got it on guess/test the first attempt. Will give to my first grader and see how he does.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/GGG_Eflat Jan 11 '24
This is reasonable. And it is reasonable for 3rd graders, given that it is presented appropriately as a challenging puzzle. It shouldn’t be something that kids should be penalized for not figuring out. My students loved being challenged by puzzles like this.
The student is not expected to use any skills that they should not have already mastered. Adding and subtracting 3 3-digit numbers is appropriate. In addition, students practice number sense and estimation.
What may be hardest for 3rd graders is approaching the problem. If you give the hint to start by estimating to see what numbers might work, it is a whole lot easier to narrow down possible solutions.
The issue is that students often expect to be presented with math problems that have a straightforward solution. This activity may have a student practice multiple addition/subtraction problems as they estimate, guess, and check. But, that would also occur with a worksheet of say 30 problems.
However, if I was the teacher, I would be prepared to scaffold student needs. Perhaps give one of the numbers, or give the numbers that each would round to.
1
1
u/vickism61 Jan 11 '24
Solve for the 2nd column 456+144+x=800, so x=200
Then solve for the 2nd row 103+200(x from above)+297=600
Now you can finish the rest.
1
u/dekrypto Jan 11 '24
props to this 3rd grade teacher for pushing their students
→ More replies (1)1
1
u/carthesoccernerd Jan 11 '24
i did this. the top left and right box is 172. the middle box is 200. the bottom left box is 425 and bottom right is 31
→ More replies (2)
24
u/photorganic Jan 10 '24 edited Feb 11 '25