r/mathteachers • u/kilgoretrout_1922 • Feb 05 '24
r/mathteachers • u/Emdubs • Jan 19 '24
Illustrative Mathematics is *Garbage*
I hate it. It’s not kid friendly, it’s not teacher friendly. My department head says it’s “based on research” but I can’t find the research it’s based on.
It might be good for students who are on or above grade level but for my struggling students it’s been a nightmare.
Also, these kids don’t know what an outline is or how it works. Every time they ask a question using A. B. C. as subquestions, the students view it as multiple choice because their whole life that’s what they’ve been taught.
The design of the book is awful. They don’t give the kids enough room to work on problems and everything is too wordy. They don’t use enough visuals. Some of the problems are confusing even for me, the teacher, to do.
In conclusion, please enjoy this absolute sw*stika of a problem.
r/mathteachers • u/Impressive_Returns • Mar 30 '24
Stanford professor is saying Algebra is racist and is having it removed from being taught in California schools. Yet she’s sending her kids to private school where they are learning Algebra. She’s doing to math/Algebra what Lucy Calkins did to reading.
And she got paid nearly $50,000 to tell California public schools Algebra is oppressive and racist.
r/mathteachers • u/[deleted] • Feb 02 '25
Teachers to be required to take U.S. Naturalization test
I wonder if they're going to give us a raise. Probably not.
r/mathteachers • u/ninety_percentsure • Jan 10 '24
3rd grade assignment
My 3rd grade daughter was assigned this problem. I can’t for the life of me figure out any missing number except the middle cell. Is this a bad question or am I misunderstanding something?
r/mathteachers • u/Impressive_Returns • Apr 06 '24
FRACTIONS Guy at Home Depot cutting sheets of plywood doen’t know fractions. Ruined $500 of plywood cutting to wrong length. I asked him if he knows fractions and can read fractions of an inch on a tape measure-No Spent 5 minutes teaching how to read fractions on a tape measure. PERFECT cut
Employee was so thankful. He said HomeDepot had him cutting plywood for customers for months. When customers weren’t happy when the cut size was wrong he would more until the customer was happy. The incorrect cuts would be given away or sold as scrap.
After teaching him fractions he was so happy. Said it was something he was taught in school.
r/mathteachers • u/meched • Jan 13 '24
3rd grade assignment
Keep math alive, show your work!
r/mathteachers • u/Filthy__Casual2000 • Apr 21 '24
Is this student cheating?
TLDR: Habitual cheater in other classes turned in a suspicious test and I’m trying to decide if I have enough evidence to do anything about it.
I’m a first year 7th grade math teacher and was grading some of my honors retests and this stuck out like a sore thumb. This kid has been caught multiple times using AI in his English class so I try to keep an extra eye on him during tests. However, I had a lot of students asking me questions during this test so it was really hard to watch him this time around. I ran his test through multiple AI apps to see what came up. Most of them weren’t able to come up with an answer until I got to Math AI, it solved the first and second problem but it couldn’t do the third one. It also seems extra suspicious that he wrote “find the area” and “find the volume” and got mostly right answers with no work (he also showed no work on the rest of the test and mostly got right answers). I can’t take points off for not showing work because we use the shitty standards based grading and we are given very specific rubrics for tests that we have to use, and unless it mentions work has to be shown, we can’t count that against them and this rubric does not require it.
I’m just not sure if I have enough evidence to bring to admin for an academic dishonesty referral since I didn’t directly see him do it or have his phone out. The last time I sent someone their way for something I didn’t directly see, but I and other students know they did, they said they couldn’t do anything about it because I didn’t witness it.
r/mathteachers • u/llcoolade03 • Jan 17 '24
Is Math Anxiety a real condition?
I'm not asking to be condescending.
I recently had a student who got an IEP due to their math anxiety. When they explained their anxiety, they used very broad brushes to describe what they were experiencing. I don't doubt their feelings but when I compare that to the literature and research, I just wonder why it's specific to math. Why don't we hear about science anxiety or art anxiety or social studies anxiety?
Is it simply because we hold teachers and students more accountable with their math education?
If they have dysgraphia or discalculia then it's quite understandable, but to say that one is anxious because of an upcoming assessment or being worried about one's ability can and should be existent in all fields, not just math.
r/mathteachers • u/hollowfurnace • Feb 14 '24
How do you deal with "when am I ever going to use this in real life" questions?
Was asked this question today literally right after I had showed the class how to apply it in a real life situation.
The audacity.
(For the record, I was teaching Network Diagrams and Critical Path Analysis.)
Edit: Since there are people are saying this is a student acting out because he didn't understand the work, no. He did understand the concept of CPA. He just didn't see the point in it. I'd also like to clarify that he had just transferred from another class into mine and was trying to test the waters on how far he could go with his behaviour. His previous teachers have told me he has a problem with authority figures. In fact the other students were quite shocked by his question and tried to tell him I had just given them a variety of real life examples on how CPA could be used in different fields. Considering how he'd be taking over his father's business in future, this topic is actually very relevant for him. However he has since apologised for his behaviour which I count as a plus.
r/mathteachers • u/[deleted] • Jan 30 '24
New math teacher- unit exam went horribly
I was hired to start the Monday after Thanksgiving break to teach fifth grade, math and science at a well regarded public school in my area (my area is not known for good public schools, many folks send their kids to catholic school even if they aren’t catholic just to avoid the failing public schools). I have been really enthusiastic and I really really love the kids and I love this age range.
I have never been a strong student. When I was growing up, I had a lot of childhood trauma that definitely affected my academics, but since then I’ve put myself through college, and also received a masters degree in environmental law recently. I taught for five years prior to obtaining my masters, but it was kinder, first, and second ELA. I absolutely love science, and was excited for this new challenge.
They had a sub for over a month before I was hired (their former teacher decided to retire in October). I had to pound through half a math unit in 3 weeks so they could take the benchmark. Since returning from the winter break I have taught an entire unit and today was the end of unit assessment.
my kids absolutely bombed it. 44% average, including my kids with IEPs (I have 4). This unit was solving for volume and partial product division. I actually felt like I was getting the hang of it myself! And now I feel so rotten, like I’ve let them down. I really love what I’m doing right now- the kids, the school, even the subjects!
How do I overcome this? Should I reteach and retake the assessment? Am I doomed to suck at teaching math? And yes, we do have a master teacher, but she is naturally quite good at math and was teacher of the year for the parish…. I just don’t feel good enough.
r/mathteachers • u/dev81808 • Mar 25 '24
My 6yo loves math. Today she said, "sometimes, I wish I could do math at home."
So like.. of course we need to do math at home now. any suggestions for online material maybe printable for an eager 6-7yo?
US education system if that matters.
r/mathteachers • u/OneTiredSub • Mar 19 '24
My 5th grader is MELTING DOWN at home every time I try to help him.
Update; He came home yesterday and said his teacher confirmed it was 3. I dropped it for now, but he's either lying, misunderstanding, or his teacher is wrong. Lol.
Edit: Thanks for all the reassurances that it's just not my kid that thinks I know nothing. Also, for allowing me to vent the frustration, and for the reminder that he is long overdue for a mental health evaluation. I realize that I have some parenting things that might need to be sorted out, not just math things. Lastly, for helping me realize that his math tantrums may be indicative of other things. I never really thought of it that way since he's mostly happy, respectful, and hard working otherwise. I was just always told he is simply 'highly sensitive'. I never get complaints about him, aside from the rare roughhousing incidents with his friends at school. ******
I taught math for one year in 8th grade. I building sub in an elementary school. I understand that the math curriculum is extremely fast-paced. Too much so for understanding, in my humble outsider opinion. My child was good at math until 5th grade hit. When I try to offer him help, he resists. I don't yell at him. I am not berating him. Nothing. I just say, "You know, I think that you should rethink this problem." Then it hits...
"YOU AREN'T TEACHING ME THE WAY MY TEACHER IS TEACHING ME."
I actually know much of the Common Core ways of doing math due to working in every grade level this year to a superficial degree. I don't know as much as you all do, but I know enough to help my child. So, I try to tell him: "I know that this is how your teacher is teaching you, but it's still not correct. Let me help you the same way your teacher is doing it."
Tantrums. So many tantrums over math! It's frustrating. I messaged his teacher once, and she had to sit down and tell him that there are many ways to do math, and he's lucky to have someone to help him at home. That there are many parents that CAN'T help their kids with math.
I'm not sure if it's just the manner in which things are being taught, but something is really just... I don't know how to explain this other than I am frustrated. He has a C- in math, which I don't think is bad, to be honest. It just means he's having a harder time.
Today it's over the GCF of 27, 54, and 72. He broke it all down into factor trees and said it was 3. I told him that 3 is not the greatest number they have in common, and that it's 9. He started crying and screaming and saying that it's 3 because he broke down the 9 which means he can't use 9 anymore. That's what he says his teacher taught him. That can't be what she taught him, and I am attempting to tell him that he's just confused.
It's so hard to help him at home. He's stressed about math. They don't offer tutoring, and I am not sure why he thinks he only needs to listen to his teacher. Even then, no matter what, he's still doing the teacher's way incorrectly.
Not sure what I need... I have tried Khan Academy, showing him videos, but he is sooooooo resistant to a super frustrating degree. Now he's dealing with his dad who can do math really well, but isn't patient at teaching it. He also doesn't know the Common Core methods and can be a bit harsh. I don't want to keep pushing my son to the point where he is crying because I don't want him to hate math the way I did when I was a child. I want him to realize that he's good at it, but that I also understand the frustrations of being taught at a pace that feels impossible with a million different ways to work one problem.
Maybe I need advice... or to vent...
Edit: I know this sounds crazy, but I am starting to get anxious about checking his homework and telling him he got something incorrect.
r/mathteachers • u/Irreverent_Pi • Mar 15 '24
My kids can not think for themselves. Help!
I teach pre-Algebra (gr. 6-8) and sometime I've noticed increasing over the past several years is that my students can not problem solve their way out of a paper bag. They would sit out that bag forever until someone draws a big arrow that says "this way out" and even then, half would miss it bc they couldn't bother to read...
But seriously, there is zero effort to think through a problem and figure something out . They do fine on basic follow-the-algorithm problems but if steps aren't completely laid out for them, they won't even make an attempt.
Instead of just complaining, though, I'd love ideas on how to build up their mental muscles. How can I incorporate micro-scale logic/ problem solving that they'd actually try so that I can build on that? Anyone else have this issue and/or found a working solution?
r/mathteachers • u/Odd-Finance-1340 • Mar 08 '24
Please someone should help me with this and explain
r/mathteachers • u/[deleted] • Feb 29 '24
A new large problem set to answer the "when will I use this" question
Edit: Website now has instructional videos for each question
Hi everyone,
I created a list of real-world math problems.
https://when-will-i-use-this-math.com/
I think we all agree that there's lots of reasons to learn math other than to apply it directly to a discipline or career. As students often roll their eyes at us when we give this speech, though, I decided to create a bunch of problems for teachers to use that are real-world. I hope they help someone who has that rebellious student like I have had.
I know that there's already lists out there - I hope this list adds some unique problems to a fellow teacher's toolbelt.
r/mathteachers • u/kazkh • Oct 29 '24
Is this math question for 7-8 year olds too ambiguous?
"A coach leaves a terminal every 10 minutes. How many coaches will leave in 60 minutes?"
My child and I thought 6, and he drew a timeline to prove it. The book says 7 because a bus leaves at 0 minutes.
But imagine if the bus left at a minute past when you set your watch... it would be 6.
Are these kinds of questions too ambiguous or are good questions?
r/mathteachers • u/kazkh • Feb 28 '24
Thinking of quitting Kumon math. But what’s the alternative?
My child’s weak in maths, and after doing Kumon math for two years (grade 3-5) he’s still quite weak at it despite doing about 150 sums a day. You have to master the topic before progressing to the next one, so if you’re stuck on a problem you’ll be doing the same sheets for months. It’s also expensive.
I have textbooks that cover a range of math questions each session with only about 20 questions per day. I could see it working for primary school, but not sure about middle and high school.
I was always weak at maths so I don’t know what’s the best approach because I can’t go by own experience.
Any suggestions?
r/mathteachers • u/Background-Major8657 • Jan 04 '25
This picture helped me to switch a few kids from "decimals only" mode
r/mathteachers • u/evermica • Mar 11 '24
Problems with math ed in the US
I'm a college chemistry professor in the US (California). Many science teachers have noticed that our students are struggling more and more with basic math skills (adding fractions, solving a=bx for x, etc.). I expect that math teachers in the upper grades are seeing the same thing. What is going on?
I have a suspicion—particularly that I have been working very closely with a student in HS pre-calculus. California (and I suspect much of the US) has been using a curriculum in which they do a little bit of many subjects each year. I'm noticing that the student I am working closely has a hard time multiplying binomials (FOIL). Even though he is a junior in HS, and has supposedly done this in many previous classes, he has not been expected to master this skill in any previous class. He would just do a little bit each year for the last five years.
Does this ring true? I love that the newer curriculum focuses on higher-level thinking at all ages, and rote memorization with no understanding isn't great, but students really do need to master basic skills at some point. What can be done about it? Are math ed researchers documenting this? Will the curriculum pendulum swing back toward mastering basic skills? Would that be better?
r/mathteachers • u/GollyGee196 • Feb 16 '24
AI sites students are using?
Algebra 1 and Geometry teacher here. Some of my online assignments require students to show their work. So many of them are submitting work that’s clearly generated by AI.
I can give them a 0 if I can backup my suspicions with reasonable proof. This was easier when students use to post the questions on public forum sites (like brainly) and paste other people’s responses. Now they seem to usually use AI.
What (free) sites or apps are most popular? And are there any AI detectors for math submissions? Sites like ZeroGPT seem to be geared for English classes and can’t read Latex or other formula languages.
ETA: I teach at an online high school. I appreciate the suggestions to make all work in-person, but that’s not how our school is modeled. I moreso appreciate the suggestions of the AI sites kids are using, my original question. I don’t know how many people will see my edit, but those who do might have big opinions about having high school online. All I will say is that it’s not for most kids, but it’s great for some.
r/mathteachers • u/Ill_Boysenberry_4909 • Mar 28 '24
How would you approach the removal of calculus?
Our high school has opted to not offer college in the high school/ap calculus next year. The reasoning is because in a school of roughly 800 only 15 kids signed up for it and we "don't have the funding" to make it work. However we do have funding for a coteaching model in our algebra 1 classes with a class size capped at 28. How would you approach this with your admin, superintendent or school board, or am I over- reacting. As a high school math teacher and parent I find it super concerning.