I have a few recent stories to share. A bit of background: I've started playing the game since Tenth Edition. In spite of how widespread and popular Magic: the Gathering has grown since I begun playing, I don't play as consistently as I use to. In terms of what I have: three bracket 5 EDH decks, one Canadian Highlander deck, one JundJund deck, and a Type 4 stack. I can pretty much play anything when given the cards. I am of the mindset that players be open and curious, and anything can manifest (no pun intended) when one puts their mind into it.
The most I've played Magic these days is with folks in my company building (I am in tech). We hang out every Wednesday in the evenings to play; for a given month, we devote the last week to playing something different, and the other weeks playing Commander. Our Magic group has a decent amount of people, but not everyone is available to commit on that day of the week. Most of the games I've played are in bracket 2-3, which I personally don't find interesting and still play (I borrow if I don't have a deck to play, and prefer that approach than building my own). Reflecting on the meetups in October, I feel that the combination of factors, a) games being almost always the same and b) inability for folks to commit, has affected my experience attending those meetups. When we got to Halloween week, and there is the option for folks to play a new and different format, the group decided on Commander instead. If folks wanted to play something different, a time is dedicated for that, and we've had previous instances where the group played something different (Cube and Dandan). We somehow decided on Commander, something that we play on every other week of the month. I cannot help but feel highly disappointed; if I wanted to play something different, I would have to wait on the last Wednesday of the following month. It feels unfair, and I am not getting the gaming experience that I want.
I tried looking elsewhere. There is an LGS located close to my home and I learned one of my good friends started playing there consistently again (he couldn't due to work hours). I am thinking it is a good opportunity to see some old friends and play more Magic. A lot of folks show up for the Commander events that pop up twice a week (Wednesdays and Fridays), and there are enough to start a game of competitive EDH (which I like). Last Friday night, I played at least four games of competitive EDH, which was fun. Some of the games were different, though the rest of the pod got a true buttkicking from Raph & Mikey (not that I took any issue because those decks are always fascinating to me). The store closes in an hour and thirty. I proposed our group play a different format, which was the Type 4 format. What happened to our pod, after I explained the rules and set everything up for the group game, transpired in this order:
One player dipped after being too Magic-ed out (which I can understand), but another showed up (that person left shortly).
Another player in our pod requested advice from the third on converting their Urza Lord High Artificer deck into a turbo variant. I was pretty much sitting and watching those two tinker.
We couldn't get a game going until after the two finished tinkering and a fourth player showed up, and we played another Commander game at bracket 4-5.
I don't think words can describe how frustrated I was, that it feels impossible to get Magic players to play something different without really pulling some teeth. I've started playing Commander when the first wave of WOTC Commander products were released. I've played all sorts of games in the ten+ years I've spent for that particular format and met all kinds of people. I get that playing something that one is familiar with is welcoming and well-received. However, I feel that a more complete experience of playing Magic involves finding different things to play and not solely one that they, their friends and their friend's friends knows. And I felt Type 4 was perfect for players that are interested in Commander and casual-friendly games. However, if everyone is playing the same Magic format each week, chances are that there is no one else available to play for anything else.
I don't know if I have any advice. I am thinking the only solution for my situation is establishing a reliable, permanent playgroup. That will take a lot of work on my end (it is harder if it is for something players are less familiar with, and it has to be in-person) and doesn't address the problem I am seeing with a lot of Magic players these days (I am sorry, but that is what I am seeing). For folks that may suggest I return to the playgroup at my work building, there is a bit of a problem. I don't feel like offering my time on the belief that things would be different next time; I have another event scheduled on the same day and time (Silent Book Club), and playing Magic on that final Wednesday of this month means foregoing that other event. And if I cannot play on that Wednesday, I'll have to wait till December (and who knows if I'll commit). As much as I enjoy Magic, I find and enjoy other things. Perhaps as I look for other opportunities, I am placing more value in my time and presence.
If you made it this far, thank you for listening. Here are links to my Type 4 Stack and JundJund deck. You can find my other decks that I listed on my Moxfield account if you're interested. If you are interested in these formats, I highly recommend reading about and sharing them with Magic players you know.
Related Links:
https://mtg.fandom.com/wiki/Type_4
https://www.hipstersofthecoast.com/2025/03/jundjund-a-dandan-variant-for-midrange-players/
https://canadianhighlander.ca/about/