Edit: Many commenters pretend like live singing will resolve all expectations and standards placed upon them. Please refer to the last paragraph again.
And I think we should talk about it. aespa, like many groups, has their upsides and downsides. Their vocals and visuals are great, regardless of if you personally like their music, it charts insanely well, and their personalities are cute enough to go viral in Korea at times. Their downside is they’re not the strongest dancers of 4th Gen or strong performers. Most groups have downsides. But for some reason aespa being shy of perfection is an extremely large issue compared to most other groups.
I’m not saying other groups don’t get hate, but it’s nearly 50/50 on if they get a positive or negative post about them. Even positive posts or news like about their visuals get snide “But they had plastic surgery” comments… as if a vast majority of idols haven’t gotten plastic surgery. Breaking news: There’s more idols that have gotten procedures than not. (Including your biases unless he’s Astro Eunwoo who was blessed in a way many are not.)
Their negative ratio is probably closer to 80% in recent days. It’s been a hate train. Which, part of it isn’t even their fault. Sure, aespa underperformed and even fans aren’t happy but MAMA has a misleading award category with best dance performance actually being best dance song charting, take it up to them. We all know Itzy are better dancers and it’s a shame they didn’t get recognized but aespa won due to digitals because the way MAMA structured the award. It is not their fault for winning a dance award when they fit the criteria. It’s doubly awkward to witness fans bicker because aespa and Itzy are friends.
I oftentimes see that “aespa should be better than other groups and it’s okay they’re held to a higher standard because they’re from a big three/four company”. Okay, fair. They’ve got better vocals overall than other 4th Gen groups (with only two female vocalists better than Ningning), even Karina who would be characterized as a sub-vocal if they had official positions can compete with many lead vocals technique wise. And for most groups it would end there because they have a specialty (Itzy has dance, TXT are well-rounded, and SKZ are self-producing) but with aespa, it’s “But their stage performance and dancing in comparison to X is so terrible.”
I wonder how much of that is people forgetting that they’re comparing aespa to groups older than them.
Here’s the debut stages of Itzy, Blackpink, and Red Velvet. Now take aespa
Yes, the other groups are better performers and Itzy shows better dancing in their debut. But are their debuts 10x times better? Probably not. But I think we can all agree that every single of these groups have improved immensely in the years they’ve been active and are great now. aespa just started their second year a month ago and their closest peer Itzy is almost in their third year. Blackpink is in their fifth year, and Red Velvet in their seventh year. Itzy and Blackpink started off good and just got better. Though, I’d venture to say Red Velvet had a rougher start like aespa but they’ve since proven themselves.
Another thing that confuses me is for some reason it’s okay when other groups lipsync but when aespa does it, they become the face of the issue with countless posts about it. And when they do live vocals to prove their prowess, people still dog on them about lipsyncing and won’t even allow them to market their vocals because: “aespa isn’t as good as their seniors. SNSD and Red Velvet are better singers.”
Let’s play their first encores: Red Velvet Okay, that’s not fair, they were bawling. So here’s their another from that era. Here’s a Dumb Dumb encore
SNSD. And here’s a Gee encore.
Now take aespa’s two encores, the first one and the second one.
Yes, SNSD and Red Velvet have better singers in Taeyeon, Wendy, and debatably Seulgi now but in terms of when they first started? I’d say aespa matches up pretty well, if not better overall due to their smaller member size. People look at other groups in a golden haze seeing their (legendary) skills as the way they are now, not as they started. I say this as a fan of all three. RV was awkward af until they hit their stride, SNSD only got better with time. Debut Tiffany for sure is not the same vocalist as she is now. And even still, aespa has some of the best vocals of 4th gen.
All these groups mentioned are great, but to pretend like they were perfect at the start is a disservice to the effort they put in to improve. aespa isn’t perfect. But they’ve improved at dance, you can especially see it with Ningning and Giselle for Savage compared to their debut. They’ve begun to start being a little more expressive on stage and show individuality in dance moves (which is on purpose btw) but people say it just makes them look out of sync lol.
I’m not saying you shouldn’t criticize aespa, especially if it’s constructive and provides solutions, but I’d say reevaluate the standards you put on them and remember they just started their careers not too long ago. The groups they get compared to were lacking in some way too but improved throughout the years. And some of them still have weaknesses but have strengths to make up for them. Which is something aespa isn’t allowed for some reason. Other groups lack in singing, rapping, or dancing but I don’t see them get nearly the same hate even if their popularity is more. (Which I don’t wish on them)
It’s just frustrating to witness everything aespa has improved at has had the goalpost be moved and their improvements or efforts ignored. I wonder what it would take for people to genuinely be happy? And I’ve come to the conclusion, aespa simply cannot reach the impossible, ever increasing standards put upon them right now. The only thing people have given an inch is on complaining about is their music because it either grew on them or they couldn’t deny the power it had on Korean charts.
For the negative comments for aespa to reduce they’d need: Visuals that trend, vocals on par with SNSD or RV while they live sing every performance, rap nearly as good as G-Idle Soyeon, and dance that competes with top 4th Gen groups. How many groups have all that? And of those few, if any, how many of them are groups with less than 7 members? Most groups have more leeway because they can assign a member to one or two of these requirements and spread the load across less impressive members and most groups still lack one or more of those requirements. aespa is 4. They do good, but good isn’t enough for people when other groups get to be “okay” without being bashed to hell and back.
TLDR: aespa isn’t perfect but they receive so much more heat for it compared to other groups. Even by big four standards.