r/kpoprants • • Mar 31 '25 Helpful Confused Love

Idol Behavior/Public Image The way K-pop fans are handling this N-word controversy is disgusting.

2.7k Upvotes

The videos are out. Some of the biggest names in K-pop have been caught saying the N-word, some even engaging in blackface. And instead of outrage, instead of accountability, what’s happening? Jokes. Silence. Excuses. Fans are treating this like some minor scandal to brush off rather than a blatant display of anti-Blackness. 

Let’s be real: K-pop has been profiting off Black culture for years. The music, the aesthetics, the slang—none of it belongs to them, yet they wear it like a costume when it’s convenient. But when it’s time to address the harm? Suddenly, it’s “just music,” “just a joke,” or “Western artists do it too.” That argument is garbage. Black people didn’t hand out a free pass to anyone. The fact that some celebrities in the West get away with it doesn’t justify a single thing. Saying “Well, Western artists do worse” is a pathetic deflection. It was never acceptable. 

And let’s talk about these so-called fans. The same people who cry about their “idols” being disrespected are now either defending them or staying quiet because they don’t want to “ruin the vibe.” News flash: your silence speaks volumes. It tells Black people that we’re only valued when it’s time to consume our culture—but when we demand respect, suddenly, we’re asking for too much. 

The worst part? Some of you are treating this like a competition. “Well, only one member of my group said it, but your faves said it three times.” Do you hear yourselves? It’s not about who said it more—it’s about the fact that they said it at all. But instead of accountability, it’s damage control. Instead of reflection, it’s “Well, let’s not be too harsh.” No. Be harsh. Be uncomfortable. Because racism isn’t comfortable for the people who live through it every day. 

Slapping a half-assed “sorry” on it isn’t enough. Making jokes about it isn’t just ignorance—it’s racism in itself. And if you still choose to defend these artists, at least be honest with yourself: you don’t actually care about Black people. You just care about your “idols” looking good. 

Stop picking and choosing when Black culture is valuable to you. If you can’t stand with us when it matters, then don’t consume what’s ours. 


r/kpoprants • • Nov 01 '25 Helpful

BLACKPINK/BLINKS At some point we gotta be really honest about jennie

2.3k Upvotes

Banger solo album, incredible high value production and crazy success. I personally loves seoul city wayy too much. Despite all this we all gotta be honest about the blackpink concerts at one point. its insane everytime i see concert clips and she is deadass just flailing her arms around and not even pretending to lipsync. Personally not a blink but idk how anybody pays to see that mess. it seems so incredibly disrespectful to the people who are spending money to see her do this garbage. atleast the others pretend they are into this and give their 70% (excluding lisa i didnt like her album at all but every stage she delivers 100%). I dont understand how the concert goers are ok with her acting like this on stage because its not like bp has a lot of members where one person slacking doesnt affect the whole concert that much but bp only has 4 members so for her to be acting like this puts her in such a horrible light. i dont think anybody would take her artistry seriously after this run. and rightfully so.

edit: this is not a hatred post so u guys can go call her names elsewhere. i am simply curious as to why the fans defend or justify paying money to see someone not really into this. i just want answers from blinks who defend this and dont ever call her out. im gonna assume its the effects of yg marking “quality over quantity” theme for so long that fans are just happy to see the artists instead of expecting the artists to perform well


r/kpoprants • • Mar 08 '25

GIRL GROUPS Extremely disappointed in newjeans

2.2k Upvotes

I am just devastated. At a loss of words. I've supported this group so much. Their music meant so much to me. It got me through some really stressful times. I was a HUGE fan. Loved everything about them. Intended to always support them. They dominated my spotify and yt wrapped for 2022 and 2023,I bought every album,watched every performance,even bought a phoning subscription and I usually avoid subscriptions like the plague.

I didn't think the ignoring incident was genuine mistreatment but I never doubted it happened. I never thought they'd pull a stunt like this. Causing so much hate and harassment to their juniors for literal shits and giggles? While claiming they "don't want their juniors to go through what they have" and being the faces of anti-bullying??

And name dropping lesserafim??? I thought hanni was literally friends with yunjin. And they did that in an attempt to do what? What they did to illit?

I hope they get their shit together. Stop this weird,sick pr manipulation or whatever it is,I don't know what to call it and just get to the court at last.

I was a HUGE ult and I feel extremely devastated. Like really sad. I LOVED this group and everything about them. They were my all time favorite 4th gen gg. I hope you guys understand that with the amount of support I've given to newjeans,my disappointment is understandable


r/kpoprants • • Feb 21 '25

Trigger/Content Warning 2NE1 members are disappointing me right now

1.9k Upvotes

Dara exposed herself on a YouTube show with Minzy about lying to a 14-year-old boy that she was 16 when she was actually 19 so that she could date him. Instead of holding Dara accountable, Minzy laughed at Dara's comments and found it cute.

Now, Park Bom is being too obsessive with Lee Minho (the actor). Bom keeps posting pictures of Lee Minho on her Instagram accounts and keeps calling him her "husband". Lee Minho's agency had to clarify the Park Bom situation by saying he has no connection to Park Bom's Instagram posts.


r/kpoprants • • Dec 11 '24

SOLO ARTIST/SONG Rose music is outdated and empty.

1.8k Upvotes

Rosé’s new music feels like it’s missing something crucial. It leans heavily on a style that feels dated, like it’s trying to revive the early 2010s, but without adding anything fresh or innovative. The biggest issue is how repetitive and empty it all sounds, especially in the choruses. Instead of building momentum or emotion, they just loop the same phrases over and over, making the songs feel static rather than dynamic.

The music arrangements don’t fare much better. They’re predictable and sparse in a way that doesn’t add depth. Is just uninspired.

Rosé has such a unique voice and the ability to bring real emotion into her music, so it’s frustrating to hear it set against tracks that don’t give her much to work with.

I don't get how apt is even popular is literally the most used sound in pop with such simple lyrics, and don't forget about how the word baby is in the same place all the songs that use that sound put it.


r/kpoprants • • Dec 19 '21

Kpop & Social Issues Snowdrop is propaganda and you are falling for it

1.8k Upvotes

I don't think many blinks (yes I will be calling out blinks as most fan accounts are supporting this drama from what I've seen, if you aren't this isn't about you) and jisoo solo stans understand what's happening. I am not Korean but I used to be a huge history nerd and watched alot of historical adaption of events and wars in multiple countries.

I had heard of the events snowdrops is romantizing and it is wrong. You are essentially watching propaganda, you are being taught a false history for a agenda for a country you are not even a part of. Jisoo is at fault for staying in the drama after the script leaked and multiple people spoke out about what the drama could do damage wise.

The so called softie, loveable "characters" you are watching and cheering on where real people. They murdered, tortured, traumatized thousands by inflicting pain onto their initial victims and their descendants/families. The so called spies were innocent people who had their lives ruined. This is not okay and you should feel ashamed of yourself for even defending the directors, producers, writers, etc.

So many Korean accounts have spoken out about this being blatant history revision and propaganda and blinks won't listen. They don't give a damn, and the ones who do are beaten down and pushed to the sides by others.

It's not a joke it's serious and the sponsors are pulling out, people are disgusted, their trauma is being made into a freaking tv show and a famous idol is in it. I wouldn't be surpised if Jisoo was picked to help further their agenda, it's too suspicious they picked a girl whose fans are known for being ride or dies.

Edit 1: I am only saying what korean accounts on reddit, insta and Twitter have said for months so if it comes off offensive that's how they personally feel.


r/kpoprants • • Apr 30 '25

GIRL GROUPS Katseye fans have a severe identity crisis and at some point they'll have to come into terms with the fact that the group is kpop-adjacent

1.7k Upvotes

I dont know how much longer they'll be repeating "katseye is not kpop" for while the group follows every kpop formula and their fans are mostly kpop fans who are active in kpop spaces. They film studio choom, relay dances, korean music shows, hide their hairstyles ahead of their comebacks. What sets them apart from other kpop groups at this point? the race of the members?

Kpop is an industry, not a music genre, and they debuted in a company under this industry. So it's safe to admit they're k-pop adjecent

Edit. It's interesting to see how people on this sub overwhelmingly agree with this notion, but in the kpopthoughts sub people reacted like I was crazy for posting the exact same post


r/kpoprants • • Jul 07 '24

FANDOM Kpop idols are not babies, they are grown men

1.7k Upvotes

I used to be one of the fans that loved the “aww look at the baby 🥺” content of grown-up Jungkook (BTS) up until last year where I realized that it was so cringe and weird. Yes, he is the youngest of the group, but he is not a child. Why are we “uwu baby kookie” to an almost 27 year old man?

Same thing with other groups. Some 20+ year old idol slightly trips and everyone’s like “omg poor baby 🥺” like HES FINE AND HES NOT A TODDLERRR. Post Malone is around the same age as a lot of these kpop idols and when he recently fell on stage, there WAS NOT a single person going “aww poor little baby Postie 🥺”. Like just because they are Korean does not mean you can baby them.

I know some kpop idols act cute and seem like they like it, but I guarantee that most of that is fan service and that most of them don’t like it. Like imagine these idols going to your college. Or imagine you baby-ing your college classmates or male coworkers like you do kpop idols - you wouldn’t because it’s wierd! And it would be even weirder if you saw your classmates or coworkers acting and doing aegyo in real life.

Edit: You can find a person endearing or cute without it being infantilization. This post is talking about infantilism specifically


r/kpoprants • • Mar 20 '26 Hooray Bravo

BTS/ARMY Im disappointed, but not surprised about ARIRANG

1.6k Upvotes

I've been a bts fan ( I wouldn't call myself a full fledged ARMY since I've always mainly cared about the songs) since 2015.

As many other people I fell in love with the style of videos, songs and variety that Kpop brings. So how can the group that has skyrocketed the Kpop genre in recent years, do a whole "We love Korea and want to represnt it to the world", then release a album called ARIRANG of all things AND THEN make the comeback song in FULL ENGLISH???

I was expecting korean heritage, history,traditions, maybe even small cultural elements that only knowledgeable people would get.

But after being gone for 4 years, you comeback with a mediocre, cashgrab that is entirely focused and centered towards white teens??

yea, im done

EDIT: Since I've started getting death threats over a rant on a rant sub about an opinion for a music album made by multimillionaires, Ive decided to repeat what I mean in a hopefully more "waffle/pancake"-proof way :

Part of what originally drew me to K-pop and BTS specifically was the distinct identity in their music, visuals, and storytelling.

Because of that, I was genuinely interested when this comeback was framed around themes of Korean identity and heritage, especially with a title like ARIRANG.

In the lead-up to the release, the marketing strongly leaned into that concept. The album title itself references a traditional Korean folk song, and the teasers and visual materials reference such motifs.

There were also mentions in promotional content about cultural pride and representing Korean identity on a global stage, which reinforced the idea that this would be a concept-driven comeback centered around heritage.

Going into it, I expected the title track to reflect that concept more directly — whether through language, musical elements, or references to culture and history.

Instead, the title track feels largely disconnected from that framing. It comes across as a more generic pop direction that doesn’t really tie into the concept that was presented beforehand.

That disconnect is what I find disappointing. It’s not about disliking English songs or wanting a specific style, but about the gap between the way the comeback was introduced and what the main track actually delivered.

Also, be glad idc enough to be affected by death threats or insults. I can't believe people would stoop so low, be better.


r/kpoprants • • Feb 23 '25

BOY GROUPS The wannabe gangster stuff is ALWAYS cringe

1.6k Upvotes

I'm talking mainly about SKZ here, but I'm sure it applies to lots of other groups. I don't follow a lot of groups lol.

It's getting to the point where I no longer consider myself a fan of this group. There was a couple of things I kind of side-eyed, like Chan's cornrows, or the "pull out the shivs" line in 3RACHA, even the entire song Chk Chk Boom, but I think I'm officially drawing the line after the latest comeback.

Tell me with a straight face why I saw a TikTok of Chan and Hyunjin throwing up gang signs? Like, do they think it makes them look cool or badass or something? Do they not understand that shit like that has killed musicians in America?

And the c-walking? I keep seeing people argue that it's become more of a mainstream dance and lost a lot of it's association with gangs, but then why did Serena Williams get shredded by the press for doing it at the Olympics?

I don't know. I know that K-pop reaches a wide international audience, most of which aren't as familiar with the massive problem we have with gang violence in America, so this will probably fall on deaf ears. Thanks for coming to my TED Talk.


r/kpoprants • • Apr 04 '25

Idol Behavior/Public Image The difference between apologies sent to korean fans vs international fans is laughable

1.5k Upvotes

I was just thinking about the difference between how kpop idols or companies apologise to korean fans vs international fans.

a group would get into a “scandal” cause of dating, not knowing a groups choreography, breathing next to an opposite gender group or not texting on bubble for a week and they give long apologies (some even handwritten or a video apology) and it’s like “I couldn’t sleep at night by how much my heart hurts knowing I disappointed you I promised to make only good memories but I couldn’t do that” or some dramatic thing like that

meanwhile you got apologies for international fans which most of them come from the company rather than the idol itself and they’re like “it was not meant to be offensive but sorry about that, ok bye”


r/kpoprants • • Aug 28 '21

Removed Lucas' scandal made me realise that most fans are only feminists when it's convenient to them.

1.5k Upvotes

I'm sick and tired of going on twitter and on tik tok and seeing Lucas' fans fighting to prove his innocence, spreading lies and misinformation about his case.

Don't get me wrong. I agree that we all should look at the facts and wait for the issue to unfold before making judgment that could potentially destroy a person's life because there are many people who would love to bring an idol down but in Lucas' case there's no salvation anymore.

Five girls have come out and one of them even said that there's even more girls. The first girl who came forward did not lie -as his fans claim- but she came out and revealed even more about him (including that he demanded sex when she was on her period).

Lucas himself admitted his guilt in his apology letter by saying that he is sorry of his past actions and he will reflect. If he wasn't guilty what kind of past actions could he be referring to? Come on.

Even SM issued an apology letter for their lack of good management. You think a company would see a person defame the way they work and they wouldn't immediately pull out a lawsuit against them?

I'm sorry but in this case, I don't think anyone is trying to sabotage Lucas' comeback or whatever his fans say. Everything shows that the scandal is very real and there might be even darker stuff we're not aware of.

Fans claim to be feminists and always on the victims' side but those five girls that have come out have been slandered, called liars and have been laughed at by the fans. They only claim feminism when it's easy and convenient to them.


r/kpoprants • • Jun 17 '24

FANDOM Korean fans being rude to foreigners

1.5k Upvotes

I want to start off by saying I know this isn't that big of a deal, but it really bothered me. I won the raffle to see RIIZING Premiere in person (which was awesome). While I was waiting in line, I was the only nonasian fan, which isn't a suprise. But while I was in line, there was a group of Korean girls who kept giving me dirty looks. At first, I thought it was my outfit, but looking around, there were other girls who were showing more skin, and I literally wore my outfit to class with no issues, so I was confused. Then, one of the girls began loudly complaining about how they let foreigners win the raffle and how it should just be for Korean fans, and foreigners shouldn't be allowed. Her friends laughed and began agreeing and making a couple of other comments about foreigners being annoying, all while glaring at me.

This bothered me for a lot of reasons. While I am not Korean, I can speak and understand it just fine and am a college student in South Korea. The fact that they either assumed I couldn't understand them or didn't care if I did was hurtful. If you are going to talk shit at least do where the person can't hear you. Also, one of RIIZE's members, Shotaro, is a foreigner, and Anton grew up in the US, and RIIZE has a large international fanbase. If you don't like seeing foreign fans, don't stan a group with a large international fanbase or with foreign members.


r/kpoprants • • Sep 12 '21

BTS/ARMY Breathing? BTS did it first. :/

1.4k Upvotes

I’m so fucking TIRED of army pretending literally everything in kpop is something BTS did first, and any group who ever does anything is doing it because of BTS. The dumbest, most benign shit gets called btsprint.

In the past two weeks I’ve seen

  • Spelling a fandom name with arms/bodies

  • Having a deep talk with your member and friend

  • Entire genres of music

  • The english language

  • Generic clothing options (headbands, berets, etc)

  • rap cyphers

All used as an insult to groups pretending they’re copying bts.

It’s exhausting, it’s childish. It’s dumb as hell. Stop it. Hell, even things BTS didn’t do first and we have proof of other groups doing before BTS? “Well that had no impact. BTS had the impact so they get the credit uwu”

Grow up, I’m begging.

EDIT: To the throwaway account that just told me to kill myself, I hope everything is ok at home and your mental stability improves soon.

EDIT EDIT: Two for two on the “kill yourself” dms, are we gunna make it to three before the end of the night? Lessgo


r/kpoprants • • Feb 06 '25

Trigger/Content Warning 2NE1's Dara tells Minzy that she dated a 14yo when she was 19

1.4k Upvotes

On another subreddit I follow, someone posted a clip from a video on the DaraTV channel 8 months ago from when she toured Minzy in the Philippines (in the full video, its around 18 mins in). In it, Dara tells Minzy that a "cute guy" approached her and asked for her number at a mall arcade. She finds out that he's 14, and because she was 19, she lied to him and said she was 16 because it was the only chance she had so they could go on dates?? Minzy just reacts like it's a cute and wholesome thing.

Am I out of the loop or did no one ever make a big fuss about this? The video makes it out to be a ~ hehe young crushes ~ thing and even Dara tells the story as if it was a cute story about her first dating experience before she became an idol. She doesn't really go into more details but the fact that she actively lied about her age just so they could date is so questionable. People are arguing in that sub that maybe she just saw it as platonic dates or that they never even did anything bad so it's not grooming, regardless that's still creepy. How did she or her team even clear that story in this day and age?

EDIT (02/07/25): Some of y'all need to chill, esp saying things relating this to their company (or certain individuals from said company) or assuming she kept doing this to people after this one story. We have no proof of the latter. I don't consider her actively predatory as she only tells this one story with little detail BUT it is still extremely questionable and should not be normalized regardless. The fact is she knew it was wrong enough by lying about her age to this child after finding out his own age and then she still did not even let him know throughout their interactions before she became a celebrity. She implied that he only likely found out through the media when she became a star already. She had and continued a deceptive interaction with someone 5 years younger at an age when that difference is significant.

Read comments from fellow Filipinos below on (1) legality and (2) cultural context. Again, this should not be normalized. The point of me bringing this up was the fact that this was problematic behavior whether she had platonic intentions or not, and by bringing the story up now 20 years later on a platform she owns for content she and her team work hard on, she is normalizing this further and proving that she/her team are tone-deaf in how they view and have shown it.

Like I said in another comment: if she thought that this was purely platonic, then she should have chosen her words better by just saying that she made a cute friend instead of saying she went on dates AND her team should not have labeled these moments as "untold love stories" and "dating experiences" in literally 3 languages. It's problematic to normalize referring to these things that way.

EDIT (02/12/25): There's more info coming up that Dara has said multiple times over the years that she prefers younger men and that there's no age limit for her. There's a new discussion thread on it here. Dara's team removed that part of the video without any apology and only claims it's so that there's no controversy, instead of Dara herself owning it up to it and saying it's wrong.


r/kpoprants • • Oct 28 '25 Diamonds are Forever

GIRL GROUPS I'm sorry but has Le Sserafim actually had spaghetti before?

1.4k Upvotes

(Edit: please don't take this 100% seriously, see my note at the bottom)

Like look. I know this is a "serve the haters" song and I know they somewhat identify with the spaghetti here. But I stan Le Sserafim and I've had spaghetti, and these two experiences are nothing alike. At this point really the only thing they have in common is Chaewon's concept hair color. In fact I considered actually seeing Le Sserafim the fun thing I did, instead of having leftover spaghetti for like the 4th night in a row.

No hate, all that good stuff, I just think we need to be clear as a kpop community on what spaghetti is.

Of note is how many lines in the song are just totally not getting anything right about spaghetti. It would be like writing "I'm spicy like gazpacho, don't get burned." You go through the lyrics and ALL OF THE LYRICS ARE LIKE THAT

This is a hot spot
Your favorite dish like a hot pot

Spaghetti is nothing like a hot pot. Also why would your favorite dish be "like" a hot pot? Hot pot is already a dish. Just stan hot pots. Great now that's two unrelated foods I'm craving. Dear Le Sserafim songwriters including Yunjin who you'd think grew up on spaghetti: I cannot have both of these cravings in one meal. I can't even have both of them at the same restaurant. Hell I'm not even sure I can have both of them in the same city. There are diners and there are fancy spaghetti places that charge $27 for the same thing the diner does, and neither serve hot pot.

You taste it once and fall in love

It's such a staple food that nobody has any idea the first time they had spaghetti. And nobody's really fallen in love with spaghetti. We fall in love with not starving after we just moved out of our parent's home at 18 or 22 or cough whenever that was and that's where spaghetti comes in.

You don't need to think too much

Correct

Oh, just savor all the flavor dancing on your tongue

Okay this one is borderline. Like I've tried making my fancy spaghetti sauce before -- garlic, basil, mushroom, olive, all that good stuff. Look we all do it once after moving out, eating a bunch of spaghetti, and wanting the spaghetti to taste better but not really being ready to make something besides spaghetti. It comes out SLIGHTLY better than a jar of tomato sauce. But you made it and that makes it special. (True enough.) But it's 45 minutes of effort and not even cheaper. You could make a nice stir fry, and those you can't really buy out of a jar. All this is to say there's not a lot of flavor going on besides "tomato."

Now my name is melting in your mouth

Okay now's where they're starting to sound like somebody pretending to have had spaghetti before, going off one time they watched someone eat spaghetti. Spaghetti just does not melt in your mouth -- that's chocolate, ice cream obviously, maybe certain fancy cuts of meat.

I serve looks like spaghetti

Like Chaewon's hair color sure, but outside of this song you couldn't really say "my girlfriend is really hot, she looks just like spaghetti" and get anywhere with that.

Bad dish in between your teeth

Okay, I admit, some Mandela effect here for all you Mandela effect nerds: I thought this was "stuck between" your teeth. But spaghetti is still kind of thick. It doesn't fit between your teeth.

Several lines about diet, guilty pleasure, calories --

Like yes spaghetti is a carby food but it really is one of the most basic foods you can think of. Guilty pleasure is like. Too much ice cream. Not "I don't know what I'm having dinner for today, I guess spaghetti for the 4th night in a row."

This contributes to my overall sense that they were introduced to spaghetti for the purpose of this concept, looked up some facts about spaghetti, and it nutritionally matched what they would consider a guilty pleasure food, and now the lyrics are here.

Post script

I'm trying to not break rant-character here but I should probably say

  • I like the song and think the lyrics are funny

  • at some level I understand they have all had spaghetti before their attempts to eat it for the MV

  • I <3 songwriter Yunjin and would have straight up deleted this if people got hate vibes from it

  • Just going for a good, hearty, nutritious rant here, no outrage, I think you're supposed to kinda break at how goofy the lyrics sound the more you listen


r/kpoprants • • Nov 04 '21

COMPANY I hope this NFT deal ends up slapping Hybe in the face

1.4k Upvotes

Honestly fuck Hybe if they’re going through with the NFT… those who know about NFTs are pissed, those who don’t know what it is are being informed,and those who don’t care … why? BTS have spoken about sustainability so many times INCLUDING the most recent UN visit… why the hell did Hybe greenlight this idea???

And now they’re going to make BTS the face of it… WHY WOULD YOU SET THEM UP LIKE THAT??

I hope this fails. I hope this fails hard. I hope this set the board of Hybe into a frenzy. Fuck NFTs.

Edit: YG announced an NFT today despite just announcing BP albums would be greener 💀💀💀 Monsta X, Brave Girls already had an NFT before Hybe did and there was little to no backlash. Guys PLEASE do more research on this and don’t just call out one company because you don’t like them. The industry is complacent to this crap.


r/kpoprants • • Jan 04 '21

TW/CW - LOCK ME F*ck Seungri, F*ck G-dragon and F*ck ot5 stans

1.4k Upvotes

For those who are not aware GD posted a pic on his instagram of all 5 members of BB, including Seungri. This is so disgusting and such a f*cking slap in the face not only on his victims but all of the victims of sexual abuse in the world.

Seungri literally trends every few days on twitter with ot5 stans praising him and to yall i just have to say that you are disgusting human beings, you are scum, the lowest of the low in the world.

I came across this community tab on youtube and to say that i was disgusted is to say the least, i think the comments that pissed me off the most were the ones calling for a ot5 reunion, some of the worst are

- This is what through friendship means... through good times and bad times.- He may be a criminal but that doesn't change the fact that he was his friend ffs.- Seungri is a member of bigbang and whatever decision Gd takes true vip's will appreciate it cuz we know he is a responsible and the best leader- Knetz always overreacting. GD know what to do and what he want. I'll support him no matter what. I still wanna OT5 no matter what. Knetz please don't make more artist commit suicide or depressed.- As long as leader GD says that they are ot5 then THEY ARE OT5- For me: BigBang always 5 member...no matter what they say...Bigbang always 5 member...- In 2021 korean netizens should stop criticizing idols or actors for unwanted reason

But the one that takes the cake for me

He can disagree with his actions and still be his friend

Are you dumb? are you fucking stupid?, we can disagree on what our favorite cake flavor is, in what we want to do with our live, whether we want to get married or not.

We can NOT disagree on whether you should be able to run a prostitution ring or not and still be friends.

I said this in another post, i have never believed that somehow the rest of big bang had no idea the bullshit that Seungri was pulling, even if they were not involved directly and didn't do anything i don't believe that they didn't knew, GD has always stricked me as an ashole and i am glad to know that my intuition was right.

If you still support ot5 BB and Seungri you are a disgusting human being, your are trash and you are scum .

One last time

F*CK SEUNGRI

F*CK OT5 STANS

F*CK G-DRAGON

If you disagree with me feel free to argue with the screen because i have no interest in arguing with people that support sex offenders


r/kpoprants • • Jan 04 '26 This

Kpop & Social Issues as a queer fan of xlov, i don’t feel safe in or welcomed into the evol fandom.

1.3k Upvotes

i’ve been in love with xlov ever since their debut. their concept is incredible, i’m a massive fan of their music and performances, and they genuinely seem like such lovely people. watching them rise to this level of success in less than a year has been amazing, and their genderless concept brings a truly refreshing element to kpop that i didn’t even realise i’d been missing.

that being said, there has been one glaring issue for me as a queer person trying to fully immerse myself in the fandom: xlov seems to be the first exposure many evols have had to concepts that originated in the queer community, and instead of educating themselves on the history and context behind those concepts, they often choose to lecture and shout down actual queer people who try to educate them.

for example, words like “mother,” “diva,” “queen,” “princess,” etc. are feminine terms that were co-opted and repurposed as slang within the queer community, particularly by black trans women. when used this way, these terms have no inherent connection to someone’s gender identity or sexuality. a cishet man can be a diva, can be mothering, can be a queen, or a princess—none of those words dictate anything about their sexuality or gender identity.

shortly after xlov’s debut, queer fans began using these kinds of terms to refer to the members, and the members were very receptive to it. however, as the fanbase grew, it became clear that a portion of evols were missing the essential context behind this language and began interpreting it as a direct statement about the members’ gender or sexuality. people started using she/her pronouns for the members and lecturing anyone who didn’t, arguing that the members’ receptiveness to feminine nicknames meant they were all genderqueer or trans. needless to say, that is not the case, and it’s extremely careless to spread rumors or misinformation about someone’s gender identity.

whenever queer evols tried to explain this in a gentle manner to those spreading this misinformation, we were scolded, harassed, and even sometimes called bigots. over time, i realised i no longer felt safe or welcomed in the fandom, which genuinely broke my heart. this discourse has only intensified as the months have gone on, with the most recent development being fans directly asking the members their preferred pronouns at fansigns. to be clear, there is absolutely nothing wrong with asking someone their preferred pronouns in general—the issue is the intent behind it. these questions aren’t being asked out of genuine care or respect for the members, but rather to use their answers as “gotchas” in online arguments.

even when the members themselves have tried to clear the air by saying they’re okay with any pronouns and don’t see the issue as a big deal, there are still evols who insist on using only she/her pronouns and aggressively scold anyone who doesn’t. there are still many fans going around stating as fact that all the members of xlov are gay or trans, neither of which has ever been said by the members themselves. and again, there would be nothing wrong if they were, but no one gets to define someone else’s gender identity or sexuality except the individual themselves. if someone has not stated that information themselves, you have no right to jump to conclusions or assumptions about it no matter how “obvious” it may seem.

in short, too many evols refuse to educate themselves, refuse to listen to actual queer people, and refuse to listen to the members when they state their own preferences. as a result many queer fans have been left feeling unsafe in a community that the members themselves have stated they want everyone to feel safe in. it’s all just so disheartening.

and for the record, you’re completely free to disagree with me here. but this is my lived experience as a queer evol, and these are valid frustrations to have. thanks for reading my little rant, i just really needed to get this off my chest.

ETA: just an additional warning that if you cannot define the very clear distinction between pronouns and sexuality/gender identity/queerness, this may not be a conversation you are informed enough to participate in. i’m not even saying that to be rude—i’m saying it because i genuinely feel bad for the sheer amount of people in these comments who are making complete and total asses of themselves all while literally proving my point.


r/kpoprants • • Jan 08 '26 Hooray Mindblown Bravo

BLACKPINK/BLINKS My Frustrations with Jennie's Public Image

1.3k Upvotes

TW/CW: discussion of r-cism/r-cial sl-rs (referenced), cultural appropriation, misogyny/harassment (briefly mentioned and criticized), exploitation/ab-se themes in media (The Idol), se— misconduct allegations (referenced), strong language (lyrics from Jennie’s songs).

Buckle up buttercup because this is going to be a long one.

I’ve been thinking about this a lot, and Jennie has taken up an embarrassing amount of real estate in my brain. I’ve given my friends podcast-length rants about BLACKPINK and Jennie specifically, not because I set out to hate them, but because their rise, their fandom, and the way Jennie is positioned within all of it is genuinely fascinating and, honestly, frustrating.

For the sake of focus, I’m not really gonna touch on BLACKPINK because people have already sung their throats dry about their music and starvation tactics. I’m just going to focus on Jennie specifically and, more importantly, the things that are within her control. 

For context: I wanted to like Jennie. Around Pink Venom’s release, I was pretty neutral-to-positive on her. When dating rumors started circulating, I was literally in her Instagram comments defending her, because regardless of how you feel about her as a person, shaming a woman for dating is weird and gross.

I also fully acknowledge the massive hate train she faced around 2018–2020. I’ve watched the videos breaking it down. A lot of that backlash was absolutely rooted in misogyny and misplaced frustration, not just from Blinks but from the wider K-pop community. I consider myself a feminist, and I’m very aware that sexist narratives still seep into even the most “progressive” corners of the internet. None of us are immune to that.

So yes, I went into this wanting to give her the benefit of the doubt.

Even with all that grace, though, I still can’t get past how she presents herself publicly.

I’ll be blunt but fair: based on what I've seen, her group-stage performances are a hard watch.

I didn’t just rely on edited compilations, I actually went back and watched full performances to see if context changed things. It didn’t. In multiple stages, she noticeably disengages: stopping choreography early, missing large sections, walking around instead of dancing, or visibly checking out mid-song. Some days were worse than others, but I believe any day with that level of neglect for performance is kind of unacceptable.

This isn’t about one off night or a mistake here and there. It’s the pattern that’s frustrating.

I understand that idols are human. Burnout is real. Touring is exhausting. I get all of that. But when you’re standing next to other members who are still locking in, even when the choreography is repetitive, it becomes harder to excuse. Lisa, for example, has her own controversies, but one thing you can say about her is that she consistently gives full effort on stage, even with songs she’s clearly performed hundreds of times.

Another common defense is that BLACKPINK had so little new music that of course they were tired of performing the same songs. I understand why that would be draining, but repetitive work is something most people deal with. The difference is that most of us don’t get paid millions of dollars or have the flexibility Jennie does.

I’ve worked long retail shifts folding and refolding the same piles, listening to the same painfully short playlist on loop, and still had to show up with at least baseline effort. That doesn’t make me special, it just makes me… employed. I say this to point out how unconvincing the “poor her” framing feels when that’s a part of life, especially adulthood. Jennie is not unique in this frustration, but it is her job and responsibility to “suck it up” to put it bluntly.

If performing truly wasn’t something she wanted to do anymore, transitioning fully into fashion or influencer work, and not renewing her contract, would have been a valid choice. But continuing as a performer while repeatedly disengaging on stage is where I personally lose sympathy.

I’d have more empathy if BLACKPINK were clearly overworked. Groups like aespa, for example, promote almost nonstop, which makes weaker performances easier to contextualize. BLACKPINK, famously, does not. Given their schedules, it’s hard for me to believe there was zero time to practice or reset between fashion events and appearances.

Another major issue for me is Jennie’s repeated involvement in cultural appropriation and racial insensitivity.

I’m not just talking about isolated moments or vague accusations. There are documented audition tapes where Jennie, Lisa, and Rosé used a racial slur. These videos resurfaced this year (2025), which means the harm isn’t theoretical or “in the past” for the people affected, it’s current.

I already know the responses her fans will bring up: “It was years ago.” “Other idols have done worse.” “What about BTS?” “What about Stray Kids?”

That’s all deflection. I’m not talking about them right now. I’m talking about Jennie.

Yes, it happened years ago, but time passing doesn’t automatically equal growth. Growth requires acknowledgment, reflection, and some form of accountability. None of that happened. The videos resurfaced, caused real hurt, and were met with silence.

That silence matters, especially when BLACKPINK, and Jennie in particular, benefit heavily from Black and Brown aesthetics. When an artist profits from a culture but refuses to address harm done to that same community, it sends a clear message about what (and who) they value.

I could also get into BLACKPINK’s long history of borrowing from Black culture aesthetically while remaining disengaged when it comes to respect or accountability. And while some concepts are company-driven, there are also interviews and moments, especially involving Desi culture, that don’t come down to stylists or creative directors. There are plenty of clips showing that behavior for anyone who wants to look.

Now let’s talk about The Idol, because this is where my frustration with Jennie really solidified.

If you somehow missed it, The Idol was the HBO show released in 2023, created by The Weeknd and Sam Levinson. It starred Lily-Rose Depp as a pop star in crisis and The Weeknd as a cult-like figure who ab-ses and manipulates her. The show became infamous almost immediately for: its content, its messaging, and the messy behind the scenes.

The series repeatedly framed se—- abuse in a way that felt exploitative. It leaned into shock value, blurred consent in uncomfortable ways, and ultimately twisted its narrative so that the “victim” was positioned as the true manipulator, while the on-screen ab-ser was reframed as sympathetic. On top of that, there were deeply questionable elements involving n-dity, v–lence, and tasteless jokes that many viewers felt crossed lines.

Then there were the production controversies. The original version of the show had a female director and a reportedly very different tone. It was supposedly more focused on Joselyn’s (Lily Rose's) internal world and agency. That version was scrapped after The Weeknd allegedly felt the show leaned too much into a “female perspective.” The director was removed, Sam Levinson was brought in, and the entire project shifted into what we eventually saw on screen.

All of that context matters when talking about Jennie’s involvement.

Jennie was not part of the original iteration of The Idol. She joined after the creative overhaul. In interviews, she spoke positively about Sam Levinson, said she connected with the script, and expressed enthusiasm about being part of the project. That makes it hard to argue that she was unaware of the tone or themes she was stepping into.

She’s a grown woman with immense power, money, and career security. This wasn’t a situation where she had no choice or needed the role to survive in the industry. She chose to be there, and she chose to publicly praise the people responsible for the show’s direction.

What makes it more frustrating is that her participation wasn’t neutral. The show leaned heavily into aesthetics and imagery that echoed the same cultural appropriation issues she’s been criticized for before, including her wearing cornrows. At this point, it doesn’t feel like a coincidence or a one-off styling choice. It feels like a pattern she’s comfortable participating in.

As for her acting: it wasn’t great. That’s not a moral failing, everyone has to start somewhere, but given how controversial the project already was, her performance didn’t add anything that justified her involvement.

To be clear, I don’t just have an issue with Jennie here. I have problems with nearly everyone involved in The Idol, especially The Weeknd and Sam Levinson. But Jennie stands out because she didn’t need to be part of it. Unlike lesser-known actors or crew members, she had the leverage to say no.

Instead, she aligned herself with a project that many viewers, especially women, found degrading, regressive, and harmful.

That’s why it felt like a deliberate decision that says a lot about what she’s willing to overlook, and who she’s willing to work with, as long as it benefits her image or career. 

This is where everything kind of connects for me.

On their own, any one of Jennie’s controversies could maybe be explained away. Bad judgment, bad timing, bad advice, whatever. But when you zoom out, a pattern starts to form, and that pattern is largely about who she chooses to align herself with.

I’m not someone who believes people are responsible for every action of everyone they’ve ever interacted with. But I do believe that repeated, voluntary associations, especially when you’re powerful and have options, say something about your values or, at the very least, what you’re willing to overlook.

I already talked about Sam Levinson and The Weeknd in the last section, so I won’t rehash that here.

There’s also G-Dragon. Beyond the long-standing conversations about cultural appropriation in his work, there’s also the uncomfortable timeline of their alleged relationship. Even if nothing illegal occurred, the optics of a grown man pursuing someone he’s known since she was a teenager are hard to ignore. Jennie being involved with him doesn’t make her responsible for his behavior (especially with that last aspect), but it does add to a pattern of proximity to men with questionable histories and again, indifference to cultural appropriation.

Her friendship with Grimes also stands out, particularly given Grimes’ public alignment with El-n M-sk during that period. Jennie being photographed with her in front of SpaceX isn’t a scandal on its own, but again, it fits into a broader pattern of comfortably orbiting people with deeply controversial reputations while never acknowledging the harm those people are associated with.

Then there’s her most recent controversy that I saw. Her association with Alexander Wang, who has faced multiple accusations of se— misconduct, including allegations of gr-ping, dr–ging, and inappropriate exposure. Jennie's association with him, after these accusations became widely known, feels especially disappointing. At that point, it’s not about ignorance. Even if it wasn’t a continuous relationship, after that came out, I feel like my first step if I was her would be to set things straight and make it clear that I don’t condone or associate with that man. But, she doesn’t. She never does. And it gets to a point where her silence is a statement in itself.

Taken individually, any of these could be brushed off. Together, they reinforce an image of someone who either doesn’t care about the implications of these relationships or doesn’t see them as important enough to address.

That’s ultimately why this section matters to my overall perception of Jennie. Combined with her history of racial insensitivity, lack of accountability, and inconsistent effort as a performer, these associations don’t feel random. They feel aligned with a larger pattern of disengagement; from criticism, from responsibility, and from the communities she profits from.

Now… her solo album.

This one is personal.

I’ve seen overwhelming praise for this album from K-pop fans. For a lot of people, this was framed as a redemption arc for Jennie. The songs were everywhere—Like Jennie especially felt unavoidable for a while, and tracks like Mantra, Seoul City, Zen, ExtraL (feat. Doechii), and Love Hangover (feat. Dominic Fike) all got a ton of love. I saw people calling it one of the best K-pop albums of the year.

So I listened to it.

And here’s the frustrating part: I actually liked it.

Despite my issues with Jennie, I genuinely enjoyed the sound of the album. I added songs to my Hot Girl playlist, which, for the record, is the highest honor, and ExtraL even ended up in my Spotify Wrapped playlist. Sonically, the album is addictive. Zen feels ethereal and hypnotic, like a spell being cast. ExtraL feels breezy and expensive in the best way, and Doechii is fantastic as always. Mantra works as a confident, fun anthem. Seoul City is whimsical, intimate, and visually stunning.

The problem is that all of that potential feels wasted on lyrics that are, frankly, empty and sloppy.

DISCLAIMER: Feel free to disagree with me, this is just my personal opinion of the album. Obviously, as a work of art, everyone's consumption of it is subjective. Again, this is just MY personal gripes with the album from my VERY unprofessional OPINION.

Once I actually read the lyrics, it completely broke the illusion for me.

The album is filled with misused AAVE, vague flexes that don’t land, and lines that sound like they were stitched (and I do mean stitched) together for aesthetic rather than meaning. It’s frustrating because there is so much talent around this album.

Let’s look at an example from Like Jennie, which is honestly one of the more tolerable tracks lyrically:

“Special edition and your AI couldn't copy”

“I'm leaving clues in the fittin' room and it's hot tea”

I genuinely don’t know what “leaving clues in the fitting room and its hot tea” is supposed to mean. It doesn’t feel clever, it doesn’t land as a metaphor, and it reads like a misuse of slang rather than intentional wordplay. The stylized spelling of “fittin’” also shows up throughout the album, even though Jennie doesn’t speak that way naturally, which adds to the feeling that this is more about adopting an aesthetic than expressing something authentic.

Ironically, for a line bragging that “AI couldn’t copy,” it sounds like something an AI could’ve copied.

The chorus itself is fine. It’s catchy, simple, and repetitive in a way that works for a club song. I’m not asking for deep poetry here. But even club lyrics should at least make some sense.

The second verse, though, is where the song completely loses me. Here’s the translated version from Genius (I’ve marked the Korean lines):

“No matter how much you give me, I can't do circus (Korean)

Make a pose in one go (Korean), mosh pit

They can't deal with me 'cause I'm priceless

My DNA in so many celebrities (Korean)

Get, get outta my way

Before Barbie becomes Chucky (Korean)

Name, shame, blame tryna burst my bubble

Pop it up in a bigger hall (Korean)

Keep shading JENNIE

I need a frame for a work of art (Korean)

I've slayed it, and I graved it

It's a sin to be so good, then yes, I'm guilty (Korean)”

I genuinely don’t know what’s being communicated here.

“No matter how much you give me, I can’t do circus” sounds like a toddler wrote it I’m guessing it’s meant to say, like, no matter how much money you offer me I won’t join your circus, but it’s just worded weird. “Make a pose in one go, mosh pit” I genuinely, honest to god, don’t know what this means. “They can’t deal with me ‘cause I’m priceless” sort of makes sense, but it’s so vague. What does being priceless mean? Why can’t people handle you for that? Are you saying you're rich, irreplaceable, famous? Like what does being priceless mean in this context?

Someone annotated the line suggesting it means people can’t put a price on her or bargain for her, which could work, but even then, it’s awkwardly phrased. Also it’s kind of ironic considering the people she’s associated with and praised, for a check.

“My DNA in so many celebrities” seems like it’s meant to imply influence, but it comes off unintentionally funny.

“Before Barbie becomes Chucky” is just… not it. I understand what she’s probably trying to say, that she can switch from cute to dangerous, but the line feels juvenile and out of place.

“Pop it up in a bigger hall” Like hall of fame maybe? I don’t know.

“I need a frame for a work of art” Like, is she the work of art? What is the work of art?

"I've slayed it, and I graved it" ...I'm not touching that.

Overall, this song benefits from most of its second verse being in Korean. Lyrically it doesn’t make sense, although, some of that might be because of mistranslation or lack of Korean context. I’m not sure, let me know.

Mantra.

Mantra works best if you don’t look too closely at it.

Sonically, it’s catchy and effective as a “pretty girl anthem.” The hook is sticky, the production is polished, and it’s easy to see why people gravitated toward it. But once you actually read the lyrics, the song starts to feel hollow.

The biggest issue is how heavily it relies on AAVE and Black slang as aesthetic rather than authentic language. Phrases like “check you like commas,” “catch no stray,” “swerve off all the creeps,” and “ain’t nobody gon’ dim our good light” feel pulled from a trend board instead of coming from Jennie’s natural voice. They don’t build character or meaning, they’re just there to sound cool.

The chorus sums up the problem.

“This that pretty-girl mantra, this that flaunt ya, just touched down in L.A.​”

“Pretty girls don't do drama 'less we wanna, it'll be depending on the day”

“Pretty girls packed in a Defender, know I'ma defend her, never let her catch no stray”

“This that pretty-girl mantra, she's that stunna, make you wanna swing both ways”

“...this that flaunt ya, just touched down in L.A.” Does not make sense. It’s word salad. The rest of the chorus makes sense, in the way that they make full sentences but the voice of the speaker is inconsistent even in terms of first person vs third person to where I don’t know if Jennie is talking about herself, if she’s framing it as a guide to the “pretty-girl mantra”, or talking about someone else. I don’t know.

It’s catchy, yes. But empty.

Also… 

“Mix me with the drama (Drama)”

“Check you like commas (Ah-ah, ah-ah)”

“My clothes are pajamas ('Jamas)”

"Straight from the cold plunge (Ah-ah, ah-ah)”

“Daytime baddie use her mind”

“Quick switch of the fit for the night (Night)”

“Swеrvin' through the lane, we'll bе twenty minutes late”

“'Cause we had to do an In-N-Out drive-by”

I’m sorry. Genuine gibberish. I think it’s supposed to reflect her busy and chaotic life (...as the pretty girl mantra?), but feels more like word salad. 

“In-N-Out drive-by”? Is that her favorite fast food place? I don’t know, it always icks me out when songs name specific brands or businesses. It can be done right but I just don’t think it was done right here. 

“Daytime baddie use her mind” I– I don’t know. “Baddie”, again AAVE used in a seemingly incoherent and insincere way which lacks understanding of the dialect. It’s being used as a catchphrase to give a ‘hip-hop’ vibe rather than an expression using hip-hop style.

The only personality that made me believe that Jennie even so much as looked at these lyrics is “straight from the cold plunge” because a commenter said that she talked about doing cold plunges after long recording sessions in an interview. The lyrics feel disconnected and spliced together to fit a pre-made beat. No storytelling, no coherence, no sense of identity or “mantra” outside of vaguely hip sounding one-off lines. The only reason this song is called Mantra is because it’s in the chorus. The lyrics aren’t discernible from other songs on the album and could be switched out with lyrics from ExtraL or Like Jennie without noticeable change.

Mantra is a fundamentally shallow song. As a fun track, it succeeds, I guess. As an expression of identity or authenticity, it feels manufactured. And I’m aware that that is par for the course in much of k-pop. But the inauthenticity annoys me specifically. I’m not really a huge general k-pop fan because of that reason. The k-artists I do follow have a distinct voice, style, and creative direction because lyricism and authenticity is something I highly value in the artists I follow.

Notice how I didn’t say deep? I’m not trying to put my nose up and say “I only consume fine art” because that’s not it at all. But art, which music very much is, is an intimate form of expression. It’s incredibly human, or should be. I love pop as a genre (which is widely considered 'soulless' and 'shallow). For example, I genuinely enjoy Sabrina Carpenter’s recent albums. I like them because of her wordplay, her cheeky attitude that makes the songs so distinct. Her now very recognizable visual style. The strong sense of identity and creative direction that make her stand out among other pop acts. Even comparing Short n’ Sweet and Man’s Best Friend to each other, they are noticeably different when you look at them. But, I won’t focus on Sabrina since that’s not what this post is about.

Now, these lyrics (Jennie’s Lyrics), if delivered by a different artist (one that actually talks like that), maybe could be excused due to the nature of the songs. Maybe. However, there is one song that I have personal resentment towards.

Zen.

Zen is the most frustrating song on the album because it sounds incredible.

Sonically, it’s hypnotic. It genuinely feels like a spell being cast, ethereal, heavy, atmospheric. It’s the kind of production that makes you want to believe there’s something deeper happening. And that’s exactly why the lyrics hurt so much. Once you read them, any remaining benefit of the doubt about intentional depth in this album disappears.

The writing is a mess of buzzwords, faux-spiritual language, and empty affirmations that never resolve into meaning. It gestures toward enlightenment, power, and self-mastery without ever saying anything concrete.

Verse 1 is aggravating even with the commenter on Genius doing their f—ing hardest to give meaning to this song:

“I tell 'em, "Down, now"”

“On that energy, yes”

“I am what you think about me”

“Cross me, please”

“I'ma keep it Z, Zen”

“Presence, bless”

“Money can't buy sixth sense”

Nonsense, filler. Even with the fan given explanations. One of them is literally just the definition of what ‘Zen’ is, like, this is not lyricism. I get it, you’re not gonna respond to hate and instead you're choosing Zen? I guess, you know what? I don't care anymore. Genuinely. Still doesn’t make “Presence, bless” or “Money can’t buy sixth sense” make any sense at all. What does that mean outside of filling the beat?

The pre-chorus continues to fall apart for me:

“Bad b—, ’kay, so make me better”

“Fire aura, quiets chatter”

“They can’t move my matter”

What does “bad b—, okay, so make me better” even mean? Is she challenging herself? Addressing critics? Talking to another person? “Bad b—” just sounds so out of place in a song like this.

“Fire aura, quiets chatter” sounds spiritual, I guess, but it’s vague to the point of parody. 

And… Fire aura? Fire aura?? Are we in middle school because last time I checked, this woman was almost thirty. Saying fire aura in a song is automatically going to date it for me. Not to mention, it’s like salt in the wound when it is sung in such an ethereal tone.

Even with meaning, the lyrics are janky, cringey and inauthentic. It’s a hollow, cheap African American costume carried by a beautiful production.

That’s what makes Zen so disappointing. The production promises transcendence, but the lyrics deliver nothing. It doesn’t feel meditative or empowered, it feels like someone skimmed a list of buzzwords and turned it into a hook.

If Zen had even slightly stronger writing, it could’ve been a standout. Instead, it exposes my core issue with this album: incredible sound, minimal substance.

The lyrics only make sense if you make them make sense. They feel janky once you notice them and completely cheapen the songs. They rely on AAVE that is completely inauthentic to Jennie as a person, and considering her history with cultural appropriation, that’s the best way I can describe her use of it here.

It is a damn shame that such a talented rapper like Doechii was wasted on an album like this. Like I said, I liked ExtraL, but Jennie, her lyrics, and my immense disappointment with this album tainted any love I had for the thing even as a meaningless song. And I do mean meaningless.

“All of my girls looking good and they got they own money (Do my, do my ladies run this?)”

“Pop your sh-t”

“This for my girls with no sponsor, they got they own fundin' (Do my, do my ladies run this?)”

“Not your sh-t”

“Run through your city, that motorcade (Do my, do my ladies run this?)”

“Soon as I enter, they close the gate (Ladies run this?)”

“Presidential through your residential, b-tch, it's nothing”

“Said, "F— your rules," is the mood, damn right”

“Walk in a room and I set the vibe”

“Get a pic, it'll last you long, whole team, they gassin' on us”

“You sit too far down on 'em charts to even ask me who's in charge”

“Ridin' 'round, foreign cars”

“Top down, starin' at the stars”

“Attitude, so don't start sh-t”

“Big moves, only extra large, yeah”

And finally, Seoul City. Let’s start with what Jennie said about it:

“This song has a double meaning in the title, it’s also a ‘soul’ city for me and we loved how  ‘Seoul’ and ‘soul’ sounded the same way, pronunciation wise, and we wanted to play with that. We were actually in the studio talking about where everyone’s paradise city would be and my turn to say it and I couldn’t think of anywhere else than my home town and it was Seoul city. It’s got that energy that I wanted to capture like how every corner of Seoul feels alive with history and culture and I was inspired by the mix of traditional and modern vibes in the city and how it’s always involving but still rooted in its soul. I think it’s also got that feminine energy. I love how the vocals came out in this song and it’s always a pleasure.”

It’s simple and meaningful to her, even if she can’t verbalize it well here (which makes sense since I’m guessing this is an English interview and English is her second language). That’s something, and not only is it something, it’s related to Jennie. Now, I just wish the song referenced literally anything she mentioned here. 

It’s a love song. And Jennie takes the “Seoul” and “soul” wordplay to its least interesting conclusion. In fact, she didn’t mention anything about the city aside from its name. Also, the mix of traditional and modern vibes? There’s nothing in the song that I could hear or read that “got that energy that [she] wanted to capture”. 

“It’s also got that feminine energy” what does that mean, Jennie? How did the song capture this feminine energy? How is the “vibe” that you describe Seoul having translated into the song, because it's not the lyrics. I’m not given any context from her that tells me she was involved with the producing or lyrical process which she is credited for, by the way.

“Give me hug, need your love, touch my thigh

Tell me what puts you in that mind

Frame it up, draw me in, do me right

Don't you dare leave my sight

I could be, be your prize, pick me up

Flying lights, paradise

In Seoul city (Ooh-ooh)

I see your soul

Seoul city

I see your soul

Yeah, yeah

Hey, ayy, hey

+82, some miracle

Only listen to my general, oh-oh

He says my attitude out of control

Tell me what to do, Mr. General

Oh-oh

Would you make me your boss, pretty please?

Pretty please, let me ease your mind

Look at me, can you breathe? (Ah, ah)

I could give you life

Apple of, of my eye, pick me up

Flying lights, paradise”

“Give me hug” ok, Elmo. Relax.

I don’t even know what to say. It’s nothing. It’s vague at best. If I’m being so incredibly generous, and ignore Jennie’s lack of explanation, the about section on Genius, and the pure lack of examination by commenters. Maybe, probably not because it doesn’t make sense but… maybe the lover in the song is Seoul City itself? I don’t know, I’m tired of trying to find meaning in nothing. That’s how I would’ve approached it, but then again, I don’t think Jennie approached it. You can’t convince me that Jennie wrote anything on this album. The sonics are, again, beautiful, and like she said, the vocals are a delight. Honestly, I’m proud of her and her writer for resisting the urge to put “bad b—” or “aura” in this song so I guess that’s nice. And no AAVE, what a treat. 

And… yeah.

What else is there to really say? I can’t chew on what isn’t there.

I want to end this by talking about Jennie’s recent MMA performance, because it honestly crystallized every issue I’ve been circling this entire time.

To get this out of the way: the production was good. The transitions between songs were smooth, the remixes were well chosen, and visually, she didn’t look as weighed down or stiff as she often does in BLACKPINK group performances. On paper, this should have been a strong showing.

But that’s where my praise ends.

The most underwhelming part of the performance was Jennie herself.

She barely sang live. Seoul City opened the set, and she already sounded out of breath and slightly off-key, and this was before she had really moved at all. Shortly after that, she just… stopped singing (outside of shouting a lyric or two in Like Jennie). Which might make sense if she were going all out choreographically, but she wasn’t. Her movement was minimal.

What stood out most was how much the backup dancers carried the entire performance. Their energy filled the stage, but instead of elevating Jennie, it highlighted how little she was giving. There were multiple moments where she either missed choreography or avoided full movements altogether. And again, this wasn’t a case of sacrificing dance for vocals. She wasn’t singing.

Even though she wasn’t visibly disengaged, her energy was still low. She wandered around the stage, and the only reason the performance felt full at all was because of the dancers around her. By the halfway point of an eight-minute set, she already looked spent.

That’s what really lost me.

I’ve seen fans argue that Jennie only slacks in BLACKPINK performances and truly shines in her solo stages. I wanted to believe that. But after watching this, I just don’t agree. This was a solo performance, tailored to her, with strong production support, and the same issues were still there.

At the end of all of this, my issue with Jennie isn’t that she’s evil, untalented, or uniquely bad. It’s that she is consistently underwhelming relative to the power, resources, and platform she has, and yet endlessly protected from criticism by narratives that don’t hold up under scrutiny.

What frustrates me isn’t one bad performance, one messy lyric, or one controversial project. It’s the pattern. Repeated disengagement on stage. Lyrics that sound aesthetic but empty. Heavy reliance on AAVE and Black cultural language that feels adopted, not authentic, paired with a long history of racial insensitivity that has never been addressed. Aligning herself with exploitative people and projects when she very clearly has the power to say no. And finally, a solo era that was framed as artistic freedom and self-expression, but still feels hollow once you look past the production and visuals.

Jennie is surrounded by talent. Incredible producers. Strong collaborators. Visually stunning concepts. Phenomenal dancers. And yet, time and time again, the most compelling parts of her work are the things happening around her, not her writing, not her performances, not her presence.

I don’t think criticism of Jennie should turn into harassment, dogpiling, or misogynistic hate. She absolutely did not deserve the abuse she received earlier in her career. But acknowledging that doesn’t mean we have to pretend she’s delivering something she isn’t. Accountability and criticism aren’t hatred.

At this point, my feelings toward Jennie aren’t rooted in anger. They’re rooted in disappointment. Disappointment in the wasted potential, the lack of growth, and the way style, aesthetics, and silence keep being substituted for substance.

And after everything, this album, these lyrics, these associations, and that MMA performance, I’m no longer confused about why she frustrates me.

EDIT: To address some things from the comments. Sorry, this is long too. Also, ignore any grammar mistakes, I’m not editing it as closely.

If you think my rant is too long, that’s totally fine, you don’t need to read it. I wouldn’t recommend commenting that, though, since that is against the subreddit’s guidelines. The reason I made it so long is because I wanted to make my points clear, fair, and open for argument. Tell me if I got something wrong or misinterpreted something because I don’t HATE Jennie, and there’s a part of me that still wants to give her a chance. Which is exactly why I looked so much into her. Not to mention, her journey is very interesting. Also, I didn’t wanna get anything wrong so I did research on her, which I don’t think is obsession, I think it’s having an informed opinion. (It just so happens that the more I learned, the more I had to say)

I wanted to touch on Jennie’s fandom in this post, which definitely elevates a lot of this frustration from not just me, but many other others who are also annoyed by these aspects of Jennie (which is very visible in the comments). I personally don’t think I would’ve been this compelled to make a post like this if all of these things were already being acknowledged. And no, vicious hate and name calling do not count. they actually piss me off more because now I have to defend someone I don’t even fw like that because I’m a feminist first, and a hater second. So, if you have something disrespectful to say about Jennie, please shut up 🙏 I am not on your side. I haven’t seen too much of that yet but I wanted to clarify just in case. But anyway, I didn’t because I wanted to focus on things that *Jennie* has control over.

Also, I’m realizing that my critique of Jennie’s album is rooted in the fact that I’m not as well versed in music as an art form and as someone who does creative writing as a hobby, I just personally prefer more narrative songs with “coherent” lyrics. So, I changed the disclaimer to reflect that. AND THANK YOU ALL FOR YOUR OPINIONS ON THE ALBUM, IT WAS REALLY INTERESTING TO READ!!

But, I still stand by my main critiques of it being WAY too over-reliant on AAVE and black culture (profiting off of it while consistently disrespecting it) and the disconnect between Jennie and what is supposed to be HER music. I still don’t believe she wrote it, *in my opinion*. And I (personally) prefer music that reflects the artist it’s coming from even if it’s supposed to be “just fun”. Because music is such a beautifully expressive art form. That’s more of a personal gripe, though.

I’d probably make an exception if she was able to *interpret* that art in a way that elevated it, but she (as I discussed) doesn’t really do that. Which leaves me confused on what her role is in her own fame. I am interested to see if she improves, though. She has a lot of potential. Like I said, the songs *sound* incredible. I really wish the other stuff didn’t bother me so much. But, with how well she’s doing alongside the little to no pushback (where it matters) I don’t see her being motivated to change.

The associations section. I don’t think each encounter alone is a nail in the coffin. I don’t think any ONE EXAMPLE I gave in my rant (besides maybe the racial stuff if left unaddressed) is a nail in the coffin. I made it very clear that it’s the accumulation of all of these things big and small. Plus, other stuff that I left out because I, again, wanted to focus on what I believe was in Jennie’s control. Because if you think THIS is long, baby it could’ve been a WHOLE lot longer.

And FINALLY, the “a man wouldn’t receive this much scrutiny” argument. I feel like I already addressed this in my paragraph about deflection but I’ve gotten enough comments that I wanna jump on it again. Personally, if I talked about a man I hated, I would be banned for bullying and harassment. I’m kidding… sort of. Plus, I don’t want to look into these men (derogatory) because I do have genuine hate in my heart for them and I just don’t think I can be fair.

Anyway, thank you all for commenting. I appreciated hearing people’s personal takes on Jennie (both agreeing and disagreeing). This post has genuinely helped me organize my thoughts and the comments have helped reshape my perspective on things. Thank you so much to those who enjoyed my post and those wanting me to write more! I definitely have more to say (on not just Jennie but other things too)!


r/kpoprants • • Nov 30 '21

Trigger/Content Warning Leeteuk(Suju) still having a career, fans and opportunities to interact with young female idols bothers me

1.3k Upvotes

this post will touch on themes of possible preying on minors and grooming, if you’re not comfortable with that please skip the post

i don’t particularly like making accusatory posts for specific idols or just inciting hate towards anyone, but i’ve been deeply bothered lately from how people either gloss over this issue, deeply oppose and act like all of this is a joke, or just don’t know about it at all. this topic is something that should be talked about and in my opinion, men shouldn’t be getting away with things like these. so here i go.

this post is about the leader of Super Junior - Leeteuk - and his relationships with some people around him. i’ll mention a few separate cases.

• Krystal (f(x)) - Krystal and Leeteuk were on some show back in 2011, where LT mentioned that he had asked Krystal to marry him back when they first met. sounds harmless until you realize that she was eleven years old when she joined SM as a trainee. a literal child. LT was 23. he was 12 years older and at that time, had not only debuted, but had already released a few successful songs with Suju. he was a senior, someone who was supposed to be an inspirational figure for her, a ‘sunbae’. he was absolutely in a position of power, not just bc he was 2x older but bc he was her ‘sunbae’. she even said she only agreed to his advances bc she was scared of /intimidated by him.

Krystal then made accusations at Leeteuk, saying “You told all the oppas in the company that you were going to marry me! And you even told one person that we had even kissed!”, leading to Leeteuk’s shocked expression on screen’

he went around talking to ppl about marrying and kissing a child (she was likely anywhere between 11-14). worst part is - this conversation was happening in 2011. when Krystal was STILL a minor. she had just turned 16 years old. Leeteuk was 28.

that’s so unbelievably gross to me and idk how it isn’t a bigger deal.

• Yoona (SNSD) - here’s a clip where she talks about how Leeteuk has been making advances towards her and asking her to marry him since she was THIRTEEN years old. barely a teenager.
and Leeteuk later responds that apparently, when Yoona was a trainee, whenever she felt scared or insecure she’d call him and confide in him :) looking to him to comfort and reassure her that she’d be able to debut. and that 20 year old man interpreted that as a 13yo child liking him. and started marriage proposals. a grown man assumed that a scared trainee confiding in him was a sign that she was in love with him and started making advances towards her. oh and he also announced the fact that she’s also his ideal type.

this genuinely makes me sick lol. if you want to feel worse, look over the comments in that video (hundreds of likes on “omg i miss when idols could joke!” “stop calling Leeteuk a creep can’t you see that Yoona doesn’t hate him” and more).

• Sooyoung (SNSD) - while thinking of this topic, i also roughly remembered something about Sooyoung (i’m an ancient kpop stan…) but if you look it up, there’s not ONE source out there. i looked for hours. but i have good memory so i finally found what show they were guesting on (lol) and found the exact moment this was mentioned. yall are welcome, this is the first time someone has cited a source for this (it’s at around 45-45mins if you want to watch).

so. to sum it up, they had an ‘apology’ segment and Leeteuk decided to apologize to Sooyoung for grabbing and hugging her when he was excited bc of a World Cup match in 2002. he added that this was the reason SM’s female and male trainees aren’t allowed to hang out together anymore. AND that Sooyoung at that time was his first love. she was ELEVEN at that time. he was TWENTY. he even had the nerve to act shocked with “were you that young?”.

the fact that he apologized for the hugging incident shows me that he knew it was wrong for a grown man to get that close to an 11yo. he was perfectly aware it seems. didn’t seem to stop him after tho.

these are just the few cases i can think of, but there could be a lot more that was buried by his fans (who are absolute experts at that; even looking this stuff is nearly impossible if you don’t know where to look). this was just a very common practice in big 2nd gen fandoms.

what Leeteuk did is not okay, these are not just separate incidents. there are clear patterns here and it’s not just a ‘joke’. there’s already a huge power imbalance between trainees and sunbaes, add onto that the fact that these kids weren’t even into their teens when all this began and had to grow up with him in the ‘SM Family’…. idk like i can’t be the only one who gets disturbed to my core by this.

so yeah, i just wanted to share this bc i’ve been made deeply uncomfortable in the past few days as i’ve seen stuff praising Leeteuk and his character, or my favorite - ELFs calling me ‘dramatic’ and ‘a hater’ after briefly mentioning all this in a comment, bc that all of these things were just lighthearted jokes… isn’t he hilarious you guys? you guys?!!?

edit: cleaned up the spelling and grammar mistakes


r/kpoprants • • Jun 30 '26

NCT/NCTZENS mark lee what happened

1.3k Upvotes

genuinely, what the fuck happened. he was doing so well and he left the group in such a good light and he had a bright future. we cheered for him even though it was bittersweet, members supported him, and he goes and wears a confederate flag shirt. he hasnt even started his solo career yet..

how the hell am i gonna listen to his solo music which i love(d?), how the hell am i gonna rewatch the nct videos, how the hell am i gonna enjoy markhyuck fanfiction now 😭


r/kpoprants • • Jun 09 '21

BTS/ARMY It is perfectly reasonable to ask HYBE, a billion-dollar company, to provide at the very least English translations for all BTS content. What isn't reasonable is asking fans to spend years of hard work learning a new language, just to understand BTS.

1.3k Upvotes

Many people in the fandom try to kill the discourse on whether HYBE should at the very least provide English translations for all BTS content, by saying it's an entitled demand by monolinguist English speakers or by equating criticism towards HYBE business practices with criticism towards BTS, or by 'reasoning' that since it was the fans choice to stan a Korean group, they have to adapt and learn BTS's language.

Most people asking for subs are multi-lingual non-native English speakers (including myself). And therefore people who are well aware of how it takes years of hard work to become fluent in another language. Asking people to learn the language of someone else, just to understand what they are saying, is a ludicrous demand. If these standards were applied consistently, we would have to learn a new language for every person we want to communicate with and/or understand, but whose first language differs from ours. In a globalized world, this is an impossible standard.

Don't get me wrong, I don't like the reason that English has become the lingua franca, which includes the after-effects of the massive expansion of the British empire and American (cultural) imperialism. But fact is that English has become the closest we have to a global language today. And we need a global language, to communicate and understand people all over the world, without having to learn 6500 languages, because that is how many languages are spoken today.

Asking a company to provide better service should never be considered 'being entitled'. On the other hand, thinking another person owes you something and you can therefore tell them how they should act and speak, is being entitled. This includes telling BTS to speak English or expecting fans to learn a whole new language, just because a billion-dollar company doesn't want to provide translations to the fans who tirelessly worked for free towards the success of their favorite band, of which that company profited billions.


r/kpoprants • • Jul 13 '21

BTS/ARMY Dear ARMYs who attacked D'angelo Wallace: please shut the hell up.

1.3k Upvotes

Disclaimer: I know the title is harsh, and most of this is directed at Twitter, but I do not care. I gotta complain.

If you don’t know what happened, a YouTuber named D'angelo Wallace made a video criticizing “Permission to Dance” and talking about how he believes it (and their other English songs) are not a good representation of BTS compared to their higher quality Korean music. He also tweeted about this before making the video:

“I wish the audience BTS is aiming for with their English songs wasn't so unflinchingly biased towards English lyrics

Having done a deep dive into one of their Korean-language albums, their music is literally deep and lyrically unique

Then Ed Sheeran gives them English Kids Bop”

So now Twitter is angry. Again. A lot of people took issue with the fact that he said he thought they were “overrated” in his review of Map of the Soul: 7 and now had seemingly changed his tune in order to justify his dislike for their new songs. Well, unlike these people, I actually WATCHED his MOTS:7 video and I have only one thing to say.

Shut up.

I’m seriously convinced everyone complaining about it clicked out after the opening where he said he didn’t like BTS, because he had a lot of praise for them during his MOTS:7 video. He gave a lot of credit to their creativity and lyricism, and he’s said on more than one occasion that he thinks they’re talented. Hell, he gave the album a B- rating, which is equivalent to around 7-8/10. He has not changed his tune in any way except for the positive.

So now we come to the PTD video. To summarize, he criticized the song for its use of autotune/mixing, its lyrics, and the part of the music video involving the masks. Nowhere in the video did he criticize BTS as people, their authenticity, say “you should not like this song,” etc, and yet ARMYs are jumping on him, accusing him of being biased and unfair, a clout chaser, and even calling him the n word in one case. Summing up their arguments would be redundant since they’re all pretty similar, so I’ll just go through some of the best ones I could find. Usernames are redacted for obvious reasons.

“d’angelo wallace literally antis bts but always finds a way to make half an hour long videos about them time after time again…. i beg of him to leave bts alone. all these other kpop groups u could like or wtv but u stuck on bts.. ? grow up 😭”

Hoo boy. Lots to unpack here. First of all, he does not anti BTS. He’s never said anything disrespectful about them, unlike actual antis who call them trash, gay, etc. Second, he’s made TWO videos about them (four if you count videos where he mentions them in passing) and the number of personal attacks in those videos was ZERO. The criticism was purely on the quality of music. Three, he does like other groups. He’s a fan of Blackpink, which he has ALSO criticized.

“actually, talk really is cheap because how do you go from calling a group “extremely overrated” to saying “their music is literally deep and lyrically unique” ? d’angelo wallace you made it VERY clear you don’t like them so why are you suddenly switching up?”

This is one of the people I mentioned earlier, who are mad about him “changing his mind” or whatever. Even though he SAID at the end of his MOTS:7 video that he had changed his mind and saw more in them than he had before. He even added “My Time” to his playlist. Removing all context from the argument makes this look very disingenuous. I get the feeling they didn’t finish the video, otherwise they wouldn’t have made this tweet in the first place.

“D'angelo wallace has been rubbing me the wrong way with the way he talks about kpop and BTS. He said he doesn't care about kpop and doesn't like BTS, so why does he insert himself into conversations about kpop that don't concern him and that he knows nothing about? Clout chaser.”

Once again, he’s only made two videos about BTS in particular and one video about Oli London and the over-glamorization of K-pop stars. Those videos were very well researched. He even states that he delayed his MOTS:7 video for days to research BTS and the album. He knows what he’s talking about. Also, clout chaser? He’s a content creator. His career revolves around covering topical subjects. I don’t know what you’re expecting. The internet isn’t going to sugarcoat things for you, and if you think they should, see off the internet because you are going to have a bad time.

So, yeah. Terrible takes all around. D'angelo is one of the most unbiased creators I know, and I’m seriously disappointed in how defensive some ARMY are being. Not everyone is going to like the song, and getting this angry about it shows you care about their opinions more than some of the supposed “haters” do. If their opinions really were useless, then the only judgement that should matter to you is your own.

Don’t send any hate to these people, I'd prefer you go support D'angelo instead because his videos are awesome. While I’d like to encourage some healthy further discussion in the comments, I’ve said my piece and I don’t wanna think about this bullshit again. I’m going to bed.

TLDR: ARMYs are spreading misinformation and attacks because a YouTuber criticized PTD

Edit: everyone saying he’s calling them anti-mask are twisting his words. He said that if he saw the video with no context as to what it was, he would’ve thought it was an anti mask ad. All of the comments about it just proves my point that people were taking things out of context or not paying attention.

Edit 2: someone reported me to Reddit care for having mental illness. Seriously?