r/justrealized • u/[deleted] • Dec 24 '11
I just realized that, thanks to Batman, I don't agree with the lyrics of "Imagine" by John Lennon at all.
It occurred to me at work shortly after reading through Batman: The Killing Joke right before I got off for the Christmas weekend. The concept of imagining no heaven, hell, or religion altogether in order to stop killing one another and to live as one, was not entirely dissimilar to how The Joker explained how there really was nothing that bound a regular human being to remain sane and rational.
The background, I suppose, is that I personally believe that John Lennon, being an activist for peace and a staunch opponent of the Vietnam War, along with being an anti-authority symbol, must have seen something wrong or ineffective with the concepts of religion and the concept of eternal paradise or damnation depending on one's choice throughout life.
Along with the concepts of nationalism ("Imagine there's no countries."), it's not far-fetched to determine that religion was something that people needlessly killed each other for. However, I believe that any rational-thinking human being knows that nothing can ever impede violence completely. Doing away with the concepts of religion or nationalism isn't the answer to complete and universal peace. In fact, I believe that any attempt at abolishing such concepts would lead to chaos and disorder.
The reason being is that many people rely on concepts such as nationalism and religion as a pillar of law and order. Laws that define and shape our society and our moral consciousness are derived from concepts such as nationalism and religion and, in the cases of Islamic Republics, the concepts are linked with one another.
Despite the sense of law and order that nationalism and religion sometimes represent, corruption and injustice still happens. They can vary in both rate and volume depending on the current stability of the times, and people can still very easily end up victimized as a result. The Joker characterized this idea as life's "random injustices."
As stated before, any rational person can come to the conclusion that absolute peace can never be achieved. Neither can absolute innocence and purity. Bad things, "random injustices," will happen regardless of what's in place to stop them or not.
John Lennon, in his song, theorized that, if society were to rid itself of religion and nationalism, then everyone would "live in peace," with nothing "to live or die for." A world suddenly devoid of "greed and hunger."
That will never happen. Of course, it doesn't hurt to try, but we will inevitably fail. And, to me, the concept of having nothing to live and die for is an abhorrently selfish concept. I've always personally believed the most fulfilling way of living is to live for others, unsurprisingly, like Batman, who is portrayed as a protector and defender of the innocent.
In any case, The Joker had attempted to show Commissioner Gordon gruesome images of his injured and naked daughter in an attempt to cause a psychological breakdown. In a particular scene, Gordon is caged and shown naked and on his knees before The Joker and a collection of circus freaks, whom Joker had begun to woo and awe by introducing the now-humiliated and emotionally scarred Gordon as "that most rare and tragic of human mistakes: The average man." The freaks begin to laugh and gasp as The Joker describes his "deformed set of values, the hideously bloated sense of humanity's importance, his club-footed social conscience, and the withered optimism. Worst of all is his frail and useless sense of order and sanity."
While John Lennon was never as sociopathic as The Joker, he may be just as idealistic. Both entities believed that the "unjust" pillars of authority in their respective senses were not contributing to anything worthwhile, and they both believed, to a certain degree, that they had to be done away with.
The Joker then famously rants in a memorable dialogue with Batman about the futility of life itself, commenting on the savage nature of humanity and how many times we've come close to ending the world over "flocks of geese on a computer screen," reducing "everything that anyone has ever worked for was just a monstrous gag," and mocked Batman for continuing to uphold his sense of morals, even in the face of massive redundancies that stood to invalidate it. Even though The Joker knew that Batman, just like he did, suffered from a "random injustice" ("Why else would you run around dressed up as a flying rat?") The Joker asks Batman, "Why aren't you laughing?" He replies, "Because I've heard that joke before, and I didn't find it funny the first time."
Batman, to me, represents the constant, yet never-ending battle with injustice. Just as we, as a society, enact laws and initiates measures in the name of battling injustice, it still happens to innocent people. Sometimes, it even occurs in moments when we meant for it to be in the best interest of others. There's nothing, not a government, nor court, nor religion, nor superhero that can ever put a stop to it, but just because we've been hurt doesn't mean that the authority whom we trusted to protect us, be it our government or religion itself, or whatever it is that you have placed your faith in, is completely ineffective, and that we'll only be able to obtain peace and love without it.
Batman, in the same sense, knows that he cannot forsake the rule of law just because of all the unspeakable and terrible acts done against him and the society in which he sworn to protect. Morally, he must fight injustice by bringing criminals like The Joker to court, even though that would certainly mean that he would inevitably break out and cause havoc once again. He must continue to follow the rule of law, even if it stands to solve nothing and continues to allow the same mad men to break out time and time again, or he'll become the same type of injustice in which he fought all of his life; the same injustice who made him who he is.
TL;DR: The reason why I cannot agree with the lyrics of "Imagine" by John Lennon is because it is too idealistic, and that, through reading "Batman: The Killing Joke," I've come to realize that rallying against authority would not, in reality, rid us of injustice, and that the rule of law in which our society is built upon cannot protect us entirely from injustice, yet it must still be maintained for the good of society.
Screw anarchism.