r/javascript • • Sep 04 '16

Boycott Nodevember

And if you already have filed for a refund, please say so here. Intolerance shouldn't be tolerated, especially one that is founded on fabricated lies, and ridiculously sensitive standards of judgement.

474 Upvotes

182 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/falafel_eater Sep 05 '16

And in response I can simply point you to the guy posting an article about how outrageous it is for the American military to have sensitivity training about Islam. Why? It proves my point that people here are motivated not by genuine concern for anyone's well-being, but by participating in the fight against social justice.

All it proves is that this particular guy exists. Statistics do not work with N = 1. That is cherry-picking, and your conclusions are not supported by your evidence.

Nowhere did I claim that everyone in this thread is sincere. You, however, are claiming that this entire community is insincere.
You presented the following reasoning in support:

People in this thread are making things up to make this seem worse than it is, there's even a guy who used "cuck" and "mangina" and he got compassionate replies about not being too hard on himself. Political motivation of these posters coudn't be more evident. It's not about justice for Crockford.

The sentiment is obvious: this community is against social justice, and the most useful tool they have to fight it is misrepresenting the entire movement .

The presence of a single person that used this terms is meaningless. The fact SJW appears 22 times (in many cases, 3-4 times in a single comment, sometimes in quotes) in a thread with ~150 comments is saying very little.
The fact there appear to be maybe 8 Anti-SJW people in this thread says very little about a community with 90,000 subscribers (plus others with no reddit accounts).

I am leaving this conversation with that. I hope you consider my words seriously; they are not intended as an attack against you, but as a rejection of flawed (and unfair) methodologies.

1

u/FunctionPlastic Sep 05 '16

I don't know whether you truly don't understand how communities work, or whether you're pretending not to. Either way this is a huge strawman.

Not all posts in a community express explicit sentiment. Despite what the alt-right believes, saying "cuck" 100x times is not a sentence through which you can communicate anything constructive. I'm not accusing this community of being only about right-wing politics, that's absurd, I'm accusing it of holding a general sentiment, and pretending not to hold it.

The same goes for /g/. The nominal topic for that board is technology. 90% of posts are about technology. However, there are posts which make fun of feminists, social justice activists, try to entice rage in the community against certain topics, etc. Statistically, these are in minority, but their success and acceptance is what shows the general sentiment in the community.

If you have daily threads where people express outrage about something stupid a feminist did 5 years ago: do you think people who aren't hostile to social justice would feel welcome in that community? In a thread explicitly about technology, if someone posts something like "women are dumb and can't program as good as men" -- and the rest of the community just accepts it and doesn't challenge it -- would you think that's not indicative of a problem? (Not saying this happens on /r/javascript, it obviously doesn't, but much worse things to happen on 4chan, I'm talking about sentiments and tendencies here.)

All it proves is that this particular guy exists. Statistics do not work with N = 1. That is cherry-picking, and your conclusions are not supported by your evidence.

So for you to consider my experience, that I share with many others both inside and outside the mentioned communities, it would take a thorough statistical analysis of all actual beliefs and behaviors people in these communities exhibit -- despite that being practically impossible? Sorry m8, when someone asks rigorous mathematical proof for perspectives they don't agree with, and continues accepting those which don't bother them, it's not proper skepticism, but denial.

And did you apply the same rigorous standards to all the numerous posters accusing SJWs of something in general? After all, these are just singled-out examples of bad behavior, not a trait of their community! You didn't. You replied to me, practically the only person with a dissenting opinion in this entire thread. Who's at like 10 downvotes.

The irony is that your behavior proves my general point: communities defend their culture and shared beliefs. In this community's case, the shared belief is that social justice is bad.