r/janeausten • • Sep 07 '25

Justice for Harriet

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/janeausten • • Jun 02 '25

Emma is in love with Harriet.

0 Upvotes

Emma is in love with Harriet.

I've been through this book a hundred times, and I'm finally pretty confident I can back this up with massive amounts of notes, so please, come at me! I want this theory fully tested. The following are just a distillation of numerous possible ways of backing up this idea.

Harriet is the only person who fits Emma's idea of "the beloved" - a combination of charming and superior as described in chapter 10. Other people are charming or superior, but never both.

Later, when Emma realizes that her version of love includes "the person who you think about first," it's Harriet who Emma considers first after Knightley's proposal.

Emma is described, at 20 years old, as never having been attracted to any man.

Emma's, and the narrator's reaction to Knightley's proposal is odd. We get very into the weeds about truth and concealment of motivations.

Seldom, very seldom, does complete truth belong to any human disclosure; seldom can it happen that something is not a little disguised, or a little mistaken; but where, as in this case, though the conduct is mistaken, the feelings are not, it may not be very material.—Mr. Knightley could not impute to Emma a more relenting heart than she possessed, or a heart more disposed to accept of his.

Emma never says she loves George Knightley. She never inwardly gushes about her feelings for him the way she does Harriet. Physically, she admires him at the Crown for being objectively more fit than the other old men, but it's Harriet's soft blue eyes that cause Emma to lose track of time.

Emma never really worries about Jane and Knightley because Jane isn't, in Emma's eyes, swoony enough.

Harriet is. In Emma's eyes, Harriet is THE SWOONIEST. But Emma, even though she conceptualizes Harriet as the perfect wife, the perfect, most obvious, most desirable partner for literally anyone with eyes to see it, and spends almost the whole book looking for a way to keep Harriet forever, what Emma truly wants is to win.

If Harriet marries Knightley, which obviously (to Emma) Knightley must want to do, she suddenly realizes she'll lose Harriet, be second to Harriet in the hierarchy, and alone forever. That's the bucket of cold water that instantly clarifies all of Emma's competing desires, and exposes her truest, final form - HBIC. She's lost Harriet, but her love for Harriet is second, will always be second, to her truest love, the most charming, the most superior, the first thought of, Emma herself.


r/janeausten • • Feb 04 '24

Austen Adjacent I Love Jane Austen, but . . .

1 Upvotes

In her books, it seems like someone is always getting caught in the rain and then getting sick. I know they didn’t know what we know about germs and viruses today, but you don’t get sick from being caught in the rain. She couldn’t have known too many people that caught a cold from being cold and wet.


r/janeausten • • Nov 06 '23

opinion: Marianne is not ridiculously dramatic and she should NEVER have married Colonel Brandon

8 Upvotes

Hi! To preface this, I want to make it clear that, although I am planning to, I have not yet read the book of Sense and Sensibility, and this critique is based purely on the 1995 BBC adaptation. I'd love to know if what I'm saying doesn't apply to the book, so please, don't hesitate to call me out if I say something that is wrong.

To get on to my point, I don't think Marianne is really that dramatic. Yes, she's emotional, but her father just died, she seems to be a naturally emotional person, and she's 16. She's a normal teenage girl, not an awful, ridiculous person. She's just a normal teenager with raging hormones who's also grieving for the loss of her father.

And why is it okay for her to marry someone who is 19 years older than her? Colonel Brandon is not sweet or decent; he's a creep. He's in love with a 16 year old who, relative to his age, should be a child to him, not a prospective marriage partner! It's NEVER in ANY circumstances okay for a 16 year old to be married to a 35 year old. That is child marriage. What makes it worse is that he has almost no actual conversations with her and is just in love with her for her beauty and musicality. It's so creepy! And the scenes where she is sick are just gross to me. Leave her alone, Colonel Brandon! You're being so creepy!

I apologize if this makes no sense or is innaccurate; I am writing at a time where I am very tired and my brain isn't working.


r/janeausten • • Mar 13 '26

Discussion - General Why is everyone allowed to walk alone in all Austen novels?

5 Upvotes

I admit I’m not a historian or an expert in 19th century British culture. But as a mother of a girl and older sister to 2, I cannot imagine allowing Marianne, Elizabeth, or others walking alone for the hours they are prone, even given the obvious differences. While today we worry about safety, wouldn’t that be the most likely way to not only keep them unsafe, but to lose their ability to be married at all?

I genuinely want to be educated on this.

Edit: I’m in a major metropolitan area in the US where I walk alone by myself all the time and will let my very young daughter when ready (she doesn’t understand traffic!). I’m just surprised when I understand the consequences of any meeting, regardless of whether it was consensual or not.

Second edit to 19th century! Engineer here. 😅

Final edit: my main question should have been:

Given the etiquette with letters, how did walking alone for hours align?


r/janeausten • • Nov 06 '24

Adaptations Leading men in Austen adaptations are not at the correct levels of attractiveness.

0 Upvotes

I would say that this is less of a problem in the older adaptations. It seems to be more prevalent in adaptations from the 1990s and later.

In Pride and Prejudice, Darcy and Wickham are, in their own separate ways, stunningly handsome men. Elizabeth is considered a beauty, but less of one than Jane, who apparently is closer to the ideal of the time. In the 1995 adaptation, though, Jennifer Ehle -- who is stunning -- is Elizabeth, and the actors playing Darcy and Wickham are a good deal less conventionally attractive. The 2005 adaptation does basically the same thing by having the modelesque Keira Knightley as Elizabeth and the unconventionally attractive Matthew Macfadyen as Darcy. Rupert Friend, as many people have noted, looks something like a discount Orlando Bloom, but, at least in this film, without the charisma.

Sense and Sensibility adaptations are also weird in this way. Emma Thompson and Kate Winslet fit the Western, Hollywood standards of attractiveness for women -- slim, blue-eyed, blonde (dyed, of course, but relatively few adults have naturally golden-blonde hair), etc. Hugh Grant was considered good-looking in the 1990s, but I think an argument could be made that standards for men are never as high as those for women. However, Edward isn't supposed to be handsome, anyway, so this is still a flaw in the casting. Greg Wise does look better than most of the men in the film, but I think that says more about the average looks of the other male actors than it does about his appearance. Wise, with his very narrow jaw and wide forehead, lacks the classical handsomeness that Willoughby should have. The 2008 S&S follows these casting tropes almost to a T, with the gorgeous Hattie Morahan and Charity Wakefield as Elinor and Marianne, a too-attractive Dan Stevens as Edward, and an unconventional-looking Dominic Cooper as Willoughby.

Am I wrong?


r/janeausten • • Jun 03 '25

Discussion - General Which aspects of Jane Austen’s books do you think can be viewed through a queer lens?

6 Upvotes

This question was inspired by another post about Emma potentially having romantic feelings for Harriet. Regardless of your opinion about that particular theory, are there any other aspects of Austen’s books that you think could be viewed through a queer lens, such as relationships between certain characters or simply certain themes? Obviously, it’s unlikely that Jane Austen intended for any of her books to be read under this lens, but death of the author and all that. Also, queer people deserve to see themselves in the media they consume, especially when that media is held up as emblematic of a shared history.


r/janeausten • • Jan 27 '25

Unpopular opinion: Charlotte Lucas

11 Upvotes

I love the discussion around Charlotte Lucas and her decision to marry Mr Collins, but while I empathise with her to a degree, I also think she makes the wrong decision for the wrong reasons.

She's in a tough situation and her viewpoint of marriage as solely mercenary is shared with other characters across Austen's novels, even within Pride and Prejudice, but I think within the novel she is shown as being incorrect, and I...actually agree.

Marriage was obviously to some extent a mercenary pursuit, with money and status as key concerns in selecting or accepting a partner. However, part of marriage is the vows. Although I'm not personally religious, it is still significant that at this time, you must swear to love your spouse before God when marrying. This is, I think, a pretty big point: most people making marriage vows at least liked or were open to liking their new spouse! It's one thing to swear a vow with good intentions that you later fail to uphold: it's another to falsely swear, and that's what Charlotte will be doing. Even without the religious element, marriage is more than a job. Working a job you hate is definitely not the same thing as being completely stuck in an unhappy relationship.

Charlotte finds Mr Collins personally "irksome" and stupid, she doesn't particularly like the idea of marriage at all, and she also believes that Mr Collins doesn't really like her, that she's just a rebound after being rejected once already. She thinks she'll be happy because she'll have a house and security--but we see from Mrs Bennet, Mrs Dashwood, Mrs Price and Mrs Smith that these circumstances are by no means guaranteed to last, especially if your husband dies or you have more children than you can support. For Mr Collins, he also doesn't actually, currently have most of the assests she's marrying him for: and there's no guarantee those assets would be in good shape when he does get them. It's better to actually like or at least respect your husband before you marry.

Frankly, it's also unfair to Mr Collins. He's a bore and not very bright, and it's unlikely he's actually fallen in love in the space of 2 days, but he seems more honest. He thinks Charlotte likes him and he actually likes her (mostly for listening to him, which blech, but it's something). Someone like the elder Miss Steele, Mary Bennet or maybe even a Miss Bates could have been happy with him and would have made him happy in turn! Charlotte accepting his proposal, knowing she doesn't and can't love him (yet making him think she does), is preventing him from finding love in marriage and I think that's an incredibly cruel consequence for being a bit stupid and boring.

Charlotte is "disgracing herself and sunk in (Elizabeth's) esteem" not because Lizzie is a romantic soul, but because Charlotte is going to be going against her own natural inclination against men and marriage, and lying before God and everyone for potential financial gain. She is making a terrible decision that shows poor morals with her eyes wide open, and is still insisting it's going to work out because hey, she'll have a house (for as long as her husband is alive).


r/janeausten • • Feb 26 '25

Mr Knightley is insufferable

4 Upvotes

Not meaning to hate on anyone's fave, but I just CANNOT with him. I have been doing a big Austen reread since January, and I thought: this is the time I finally get through Emma! It shan't defeat me this time! It can't be that bad. I rediscovered Mansfield Park and re-evaluated Sense and Sensibility, surely it won't be bad?

Spoiler alert: it's that bad. Emma herself is dreadful, but she is so cleverly written you can see through her at all times; and you know she will rethink this. But Mr Knightley... I am on chapter XVIII, in the middle of his big rant about Frank Churchill, and I just boggle. Such a preachy, self-important man! And he gets his way in the text! He WILL marry Emma!

Don't even get me started on his /continually/ reminding her he knew her so well as a child... It's so creepy. Yes, I know, that was a common age gap, yes, I know, Marianne Dashwood and Colonel Brandon have a similar age gap... But he met her when she was an adult by the standard of the time, and he always treated her with respect. Knightley'S one note with Emma is: you are silly, as I know very well, because I have known you since you were a child. Ew.

Please tell me it gets better, because atm I am sorely tempted to kick this book and move on to my beloved Northanger Abbey and Persuasion.

(Note: my tone is jokey throughout. But character saying 'Frank Churchill lives a life of idleness' while he himself basically does nothing but go harass his sister in law every day had me 'oh well then, You'd know' :p)

ETA: I am aware that, as the owner of a large estate which is described as encompassing much of Highbury, Mr Knightley HAS to be doing something. It just doesn't show as much in the text as it does in other JA books about other people in similar positions. What I see is, he is along a lot just telling Emma off. The 'harass' is very tongue in cheek. I truly appreciate all the thoughtful takes on this, but if you are just hurt I don't like your fave, that's totally ok: just don't take this so sideways.


r/janeausten • • Aug 05 '23

Keira Knightley>Jennifer Ehle

15 Upvotes

I do love Jennifer Ehle and I actually prefer the '95 version as a whole, but Knightley brought so much life to Elziabeth that it was remarkable. I genuinely think she should of won the Oscar.


r/janeausten • • Nov 26 '21

Does anyone else think the movie Clueless is a ripoff of Emma?

0 Upvotes

I was reading Emma and happened to indulge a take-me-back-high-school re-watch of the movie Clueless during the same timeframe, and I swear they have the same basic plot and a parallel of characters. Random observation, I know, but I’m curious whether anyone else might think the same thing?


r/janeausten • • Mar 27 '26

Discussion - Pride and Prejudice Is Jane Bennet a... Mary Sue?

0 Upvotes

She's borderline too good to be true. Everyone loves her. Even Darcy can't find anything negative to say about her, apart from her having embarrassing relatives. And being too serene, apparently.

She's not a failure as a character; Austen is too good a writer for that. And I understand that she is a foil for Elizabeth as Bingley is for Darcy. But...damn... she is so passive. And so lacking in the interests and talents that constitute an important part of personality. She doesn't sing, play, draw or read. She expresses no opinions except benevolent generalities.

Other heroines do things, say things, think things. Catherine plays cricket and loves horror stories. Emma is jealous of Jane Fairfax. Lizzie expresses her opinions very decidedly for so young a person. Even Fanny knows a wrong 'un when she sees one. Jane can't even see her own mother's foolishness and mercenary attitudes. If Jane was as plain as Mary, Mrs Bennet wouldn't give two hoots about her. Just as well she's not the heroine, I guess.


r/janeausten • • Mar 09 '26

Fan Works Elizabeth Bennet according to the 2005 film adaptation of Pride & Prejudice ⚘️🌹

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

r/janeausten • • Mar 24 '25

I've seen every Jane Austen adaptation - these are the nine worth watching

Thumbnail
inews.co.uk
0 Upvotes

r/janeausten • • Feb 15 '26

Discussion - Emma Haven't seen/read all of Jane Austen but I don't like Emma

0 Upvotes

I adore Pride and Prejudice, I watch the 1995 miniseries and listen to the Rosamund Oike audio book at least once a year. I love Persuasion, the movie wirh Ciaran Hinds and the incredible book. Sense and Sensibility ranks lower (again the 1990s version of the movie) purely because I listened to the book after watching the movie and was sad I liked the movie better.

Then we get to Emma. I've watched the movie once and while it's a good movie (Ewan MacGregor version, I think 1999?) I can't stand Emma Woodhouse! She's uppity, snobby, and self-centered, and thinks so highly of herself that she thinks Harriet should get a better marriage simply because Emma is her friend and Emma has deemed her acceptable, no matter that the only claim to high society Harriet has is that she is the illegitimate daughter of an unknown high society person. That makes her friend material but not wife material to high society, any well to do man marrying her would take a serious hit to his standing and reputation.

I got halfway through the book before I stopped because I wanted to throttle the entire Woodhouse family. I have an aunt like Mr. Woodhouse and his eldest daughter and these hypochondriacs are truly among the most annoying people on the planet, I can only take so much.

And I will never forgive the directors of the movie for giving Ewan MacGregor a historically accurate haircut that made him look like a cocker spaniel. There were other historically accurate haircuts that would not have made him look so ridiculous.

Overall - this book has more annoying characters than the other three put together and I could not finish it because of that. I will attempt to anyway simply so I can decide if the second half of the book redeems it in any way.​


r/janeausten • • Nov 09 '24

Why do you like Catherine Morland?

1 Upvotes

I've read Northanger Abbey once and could barely get through it. I disliked Catherine; she takes her friend's mother's death as her private entertainment to indulge in fantasies about how her host is a murderer. I lost all sympathy and liking for her at that point and it didn't return by the end of the novel.

I'd love to have my mind changed, though: what are Catherine's good features, that I should pay attention too during my re-read?

If there's a particular audiobook narrator that makes her compelling, I'd like to hear that, too.


r/janeausten • • Apr 21 '26

Discussion - General Criticism towards Jane Austen

6 Upvotes

Maybe this is wrong sub for that, but what is your criticism towards Austen’s works?

And I don’t mean something like „I didn’t like the ending of X” but more about her writing style.


r/janeausten • • Oct 24 '25

Discussion - Sense and Sensibility Thoughts on Elinor and Marianne

0 Upvotes

Just finished my second read of S&S after quite a few years. During this read, I was surprised by how much I disliked Elinor. Don't get me wrong, she's kind and strives to be moral and respectful towards others. While this is noble, it is also one of her greatest flaws. Oftentimes, she exerts herself too much and worries more than she needs to about the opinions of others.

The most frustrating was when she tried to push her sister into being more like her. I acknowledge that Marianne can sometimes act the fool, but there were only a couple of times that she caused any actual embarrassment for Elinor, like when she broke down in front of Edward's whole family. Otherwise, I really admired how Marianne wore her heart on her sleeve and refused to be ashamed of her own feelings. Her behavior didn't seem that impertinent to me, especially in that it didn't directly negatively affect others.

What really got me was when Elinor told Marianne to "Exert" herself when they were alone and Marianne was breaking down. Like... why?! Not one else is there! Just because you don't like to hide your feelings doesn't mean it's everyone's responsibility to do the same. I feel like they could have had a much more open and supportive relationship if Elinor didn't so often shame Marianne for expressing emotion, as a principle.

My real issue with the book is the framing. Elinor could have been treated as a flawed but well-meaning character who learns to embrace more facets of herself or guide her behavior through a newfound lens, like many JA heroines do. But she stays the same the whole book and is never truly challenged or self-reflects in a meaningful way. Meanwhile, Marianne's punishment for being dramatic is that she almost fucking dies! She does get a happy ending, but not before the narrative punishes her harshly for her choices.

Elinor reminds me a lot of Fanny from Mansfield Park. The key difference is that Fanny was raised in an emotionally abusive environment where she was constantly reminded of her own inferiority. Elinor had a loving and mostly self-possessed mother, and she grew up in a house of equals. Fanny's moral absolutism and obsession with pleasing others feels way more earned than Elinor's.


r/janeausten • • Feb 12 '25

Mr Darcy - So Misunderstood!

8 Upvotes

I'm rewatching the 2005 P&P after having just rereading the novel and I was in the middle of the public ball scene when it struck me: Mr Darcy is utterly misunderstood!

Hear me out!

The most common sentiment about Darcy's prickly demeanor, particularly at the public ball, is that he's proud and snobby. I've even seen it being very trendy to claim he was autistic. But if we look at him in a wider context, I find his mood easily explained.

He is mentoring his friend Bingley, possibly for many weeks by now. Bingley is relatively new money and very good natured. He probably attracts a LOT of eager female attention wherever he goes. Darcy sees this.

Being much wealthier and titled (*ETA, he is NOT titled), Darcy is very familiar with how marriage arrangements work. He'll have to broker an advantageous marriage for his little sister and he gets the financial considerations. He would have been very familiar with poor younger sons meeting wealthy women and titled women with no money making a marriage for financial safety. And it wasn't so long before that he had to deal with Whickam's marriage for money scheme with Georgiana and almost ruining his very young sister's virtues while breaking her sweetly gullible heart.

I believe he is so prickly at the ball because he assumes any woman giving him attention isn't interested in him at all. He has Caroline Bingley hitting on him constantly. And she has mean girl snobby manners which annoy him.

He feels on guard, worried about girls on the make. And one of them might turn out to be mean like Caroline! And so he holds himself aloof, making dour or even mean comments only when spoken to, refusing to dance, and unable to be authentic enough to hold a conversation with anyone. He can't relax and enjoy the moment because he has all of this swirling around in his head.

And, well, yeah, that's pretty much it. He's wary, worried, cautious, and a little resentful or still smarting from dealing with grifters and graspers.

Does this track for anyone else?


r/janeausten • • Apr 03 '26

Discussion - Emma Should i continue Emma by Jane Austen?

0 Upvotes

I have read the first 200 pages or so and I wouldnt say its boring but it is becoming sort of tedious to read and it isn't what i would call entertaining. Alot of the book feels extremely slow and hard to follow aswell that i sometimes feel like im forcing myself to read it. Does it get better or am i better off dropping it and reading another book?


r/janeausten • • Jul 24 '24

Pride and Prejudice 1995 - Hot Takes

8 Upvotes

I might be shot down for this but I thought Jennifer Ehle did too much with her eyes. Too much acting. I mean all of the actors were too old (the 2005 version got that right) but I don't know, I was annoyed by Jennifer Ehle's constant "performing." I did love the actress portraying Charlotte, I liked how serious and clear-eyed she was about her goals. In the 2005 version I think her "Don't you dare judge me, Lizzie" was powerful but not the way Austen wrote such a practical, sensible character. Lastly - I'm definitely getting downvoted for this but I didn't think the wet shirt scene was necessary. It seemed too "anything to keep the ladies happy" for my taste. Thoughts?


r/janeausten • • Nov 06 '23

"Sorry, Jane Austen, but Mr. Darcy is the Worst", review of book "The Darcy Myth"

3 Upvotes

r/janeausten • • Nov 23 '24

Childless by choice couples

14 Upvotes

Which of Austen's couples do you think would be childless by choice in a modern adaptation? I ask because I see Elizabeth and Darcy as that couple. I can see them being very supportive of friends' children and very happy to return home to each other and their dogs.


r/janeausten • • Mar 06 '25

Discussion - Emma Just started Emma and quick question

10 Upvotes

Hi, I’ve never read anything by Jane Austen before. I usually read queer YA fiction, and read Emmett by Lev AC Rosen a few weeks ago which is said to be a queer retelling of Emma, so I wanted to try to read Emma. I’m only 5 pages in but a little confused. Based on what I know about this book it seems set in England, but they keep referring to distance in terms of miles. I thought miles was an American unit of measure. Wouldn’t someone in England refer to distance in terms of kilometers? Sorry I’m sure the question is naive