r/ifttt • u/EldonMcGuinness • 9d ago
IFTTT is giving legacy users a monthly credit allowance that lets them keep on keepin' on.
From what I've seen, and what has been confirmed by u/ryan-ifttt in this thread, Legacy Pro+ users are being bumped up to a monthly credit limit that reflects what they would normally use, with a little extra room for growth. This seems to be IFTTT's way of keeping the new system fair while honoring its commitments to existing customers.
Honestly, while this isn't a perfect outcome for everyone, I think it goes a long way toward preserving the spirit of what IFTTT was trying to accomplish while also honoring the commitments it made to its longtime subscribers. Is it fair that different customers will have different monthly credit allowances? Not necessarily. However, when you consider the alternative of legacy customers abandoning the service because their existing automations are no longer viable, I think this is probably one of the best decisions IFTTT could have made.
Objectively, this isn't entirely new territory for IFTTT. Think back to the original pay-what-you-want promotion. Nobody seemed particularly concerned that different subscribers were paying different amounts for the same service. People paid what they thought the service was worth or what they could afford. When that promotion ended, was it fair that new subscribers had to pay more for essentially the same service that existing subscribers were receiving at a much lower price? Some of us, myself included, managed to get Pro+ for just $1.99/month. Was that necessarily fair to new customers? Probably not. But honoring those earlier commitments was the right thing to do, and I think the same principle applies here.
Now, I'm starting to see people complain that this will result in Pro+ subscribers having different monthly credit allowances, even though they're all on the same plan. I'm not entirely sure I understand the objection. If everyone can continue using the service the way they always have, then where exactly is the loss? The goal here isn't necessarily to give every legacy subscriber the exact same number of credits. It's to make sure the transition doesn't take away functionality they've already been using and paying for.
Someone who historically used 500,000 credits per month doesn't necessarily need the same allowance as someone who regularly used 5 million. As long as both can continue running their existing automations, with some reasonable room to grow, neither is losing what they previously had. Is everyone getting an identical allowance? No. But is everyone being treated unfairly simply because their allowances differ? I don't think so.
Fairness doesn't always mean everyone gets the exact same thing. Sometimes it means making sure nobody loses what they already had.
I'm going to say something that some people probably aren't going to like: I actually think this is a great offer from IFTTT.
Is it perfect? Absolutely not.
One thing that is still unknown is how much "room for growth" users are actually getting; I would love to see clarification on this.
Additionally, does it resolve the concerns I've raised about the new credit system? No, and I still stand by those concerns. The credit costs for individual services, triggers, actions, and queries still need some serious reconsideration, particularly if IFTTT genuinely wants its Free and lower-tier plans to provide meaningful access to all the features it is now promoting. New users should have enough credits to actually experiment with different integrations, learn how the system works, troubleshoot their Applets, and explore AI functionality without burning through their entire allowance after a handful of executions. And existing subscribers who don't have sufficient historical usage to qualify for an adjustment may still find themselves facing some pretty restrictive limits.
But I also believe in giving credit where credit is due. IFTTT appears to be listening to its longtime customers and making an effort to ensure that the automations they built under the previous system can continue operating without forcing them into substantially more expensive subscriptions.
That's a meaningful concession, and I think it deserves recognition.
I've been pretty vocal about the problems with this transition, and I'm certainly not going to stop advocating for more reasonable credit costs and allowances across all subscription tiers. But when a company responds to criticism with a reasonable compromise, I think it's just as important to acknowledge that as it is to point out where they're getting things wrong.
This doesn't fix everything, but it's a substantial step in the right direction.
