r/ideasfortheadmins • • Jun 03 '12

A new rule stating that default subreddits must stay neutral?

44 Upvotes

Since the default reddits are chosen by the number of subscribers, I say we add a new rule that make it so default subreddits must be neutral and not focused on one interest.

Message thanks to Timmyaberoth:

DEAR ADMINS

There shouldn't be defaults on a website that is supposed to be neutral, whether its r/politics or r/gaming or whatever. Saying "we make it default because its popular" is a bad idea and subreddits that have oped out like r/bestof are proof that, when they oped out their content got so much better. Admins its really not about the r/atheism vs r/atheism haters. You added a front page so people could customise and not have to go to r/all but the problem wasn't that, the problem is the defaults have an ever growning advantage of what gets popular. 6 months ago f7u12 had 100k more subs than r/atheism now r/atheism is double the size of f7u12 its not about content they got that because they are default.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Dec 18 '11

Shut Down /r/ShitRedditSays

62 Upvotes

/r/ShitRedditSays is an organization of redditors who browse reddit and post/share comments they find offensive. They're basically tattling on people who make jokes of questionable taste. They're harassing the community by being unwanted pseudo-vigilantes.

In their sidebar they state that they're not a downvote brigade, but that is a blatant lie and if you click on any of the links it becomes apparent.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Jun 01 '18

You’re going to hate this one : Allow a subreddit setting of only allowing those who have commented to vote on the post.

0 Upvotes

Maybe on comments too.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Aug 18 '25 This

Other I propose limiting the moderator's powers, especially regarding banning.

0 Upvotes

I suggest that moderators be limited in their ability to ban, especially permanently, in a way that permanent bans from the subreddit would have to be approved by Reddit administrators, Reddit would also have a better overview of the work of moderators, especially whether they are abusing their position. It is possible to notice that the abuse of moderators' powers is increasing at least that's what it looks like from users commenting, because when mods don't like a post or it doesn't align with their beliefs, they simply ban the user. I urge Reddit to find a way to start controlling malicious moderators.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Jul 03 '15

Uh, yeah, it'd be great if we could get a list of blacked-out subreddits on the sidebar of the front page. That'd be great.

1 Upvotes

r/ideasfortheadmins • • Oct 08 '15

There should be a Trophy for when your submission/content gets featured in an article on Upvoted.com

0 Upvotes

Imgur does it with their Facebook page feature.

I don't think this is anything other than motivational and in a way remuneration to having had interesting content. Also, new trophies! It's due time!

(also, I want trophies...)


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Jan 23 '10

The downvote button does not work as intended. It only encourages groupthink and so counteracts interesting discussion. Why not replace it with a "report" button?

1 Upvotes

Having everyone in a discussion seemingly agree with you is certainly nice, but does not breed intelligent discussion.

The reddiquette notes:

  • Please don't downvote opinions just because you disagree with them. The down arrow is for comments that add nothing to the discussion.

This is indeed the way the downvote button should be used. However, in such a large and anonymous community as reddit, it seems naive to think people will actually use it for this purpose only. Abuse of the downvote button is very explicit in some discussion, as a visit to /r/atheism would show regarding sincere comments from religious redditors. Shouldn't their voices be heard regardless of their opinion? More importantly, its effects are at work in every discussion on reddit, where it amplifies groupthink and reduces discussion without this being explicitly noticeable.

I believe that removing the downvote button would be a very easy imlpementable and very effective measure to reduce the groupthink bias and encourage interesting discussion. The current "report" button could be used, with options as for example "spam" and "hateful", which would notify a moderator when clicked x times, who can then decide whether or not to delete the comment. However, reporting should not influence a comment's score.

Reddit is an awesome community and I greatly enjoy the discussions here. I sincerely believe that removing the downvote button would make it even better.


edit: Karmanaut pointed out that this could lead to abuse of the report button. However, under the system I have in mind (the report button keeping its current place, not the downarrow's place), people would have no incentive to click the report button without reason, as it doesn't do anything when the post is not spam/hateful/etc. Let's say 20 clicks on "report" would signal a moderator. The mod takes a look at the post, and when not spam/hateful lets it be. Thus someone needlessly clicking "report" gains nothing. In addition, by repeatedly clicking "report" buttons without good reason he could be signaled to mods himself, and for example given a warning or a temporary ban.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Nov 21 '13

Give moderators a supply of gold to hand out.

0 Upvotes

Currently, we only have sticks (bans, removals) to change behavior. Give us a carrot to use. It would be nice if we could give gold to someone who posts a good question in /r/askreddit or to someone who comes up with an awesome question in /r/iama. To prevent people from making subreddits just to get gold, make the amount be based on how many subscribers the subreddit has. Also, moderators could not give the gold to themselves (to prevent conflict of interest).


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Jul 24 '25 Diamonds are Forever

Post & Comment Idea: Ban Political Discrimination by Subreddit Moderators

61 Upvotes

Many high-traffic subreddits, especially those related to news, politics, or country-based topics, are being controlled by moderator teams that enforce ideological conformity while silencing dissenting viewpoints. These mod teams often use vague rules like "low-effort content" or "off-topic" as a cover to ban users based solely on their political views.

This is not just frustrating. It's unethical and damaging to Reddit's ecosystem. When a single group can claim a general-interest topic like r/Denmark, r/WorldNews, or r/Politics, (i'm not calling out these subreddits specifically I don't use them) and and use it to push a specific ideology while silencing others, it creates:

  • Echo chambers falsely presenting consensus

  • Censorship under the guise of moderation

  • Distrust in Reddit's neutrality as a platform

  • Barriers to civil discourse and exploration of ideas

Reddit has already banned discrimination based on race, gender, etc. It's time to take the next step and prohibit discrimination based on political affiliation or viewpoint—at least in topic-neutral or general-subject subreddits.

Proposal:
Add a sitewide rule that says:

“Moderators may not ban or remove users based solely on their political affiliation or viewpoint, unless the content explicitly violates other Reddit sitewide rules (e.g., harassment, incitement, hate).”

This rule would not force moderators to allow hate speech or trolling. It would simply prevent them from banning people just because they disagree.

Reddit has grown into a major hub of public discourse. With that power comes responsibility. Please don’t let Reddit become a patchwork of ideologically-captured communities. Let’s make space for disagreement, civilly, respectfully, and transparently.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • May 25 '13

When a user is banned other mods must vote on it.

0 Upvotes

When a user gets one ban have their comments hidden on the subreddit and if a user gets a few more ban votes have them completely removed from the subreddit.

Make the first ban more like a warning.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Jul 31 '11

An "on/off" toggle for the spam filter... and a "reset" button.

0 Upvotes

Built into the "community settings" please. Allow us to bypass Reddit's spam filter in its entirety, or wipe the training the spam filter has accumulated so that it can be trained anew.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Jan 17 '10

Allow downvoting on deleted comments

0 Upvotes

If we still know what the comment says, then deleting a comment shouldn't be an easy way for someone to avoid negative karma. I'd also like to punish people for deleting as their easy way out.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Sep 19 '26

User Settings Filter out replies from people with post history off

0 Upvotes

Just like how I can disallow chat requests in the settings, allow me to disallow replies from private accounts.

I turned off most of my post history and unlinked social links because I'm tired of the antagonistic replies about absolutely nothing!

They can see everything about me and I can't see anything about them. Horrible and worsening user experience.

edit:: I don't care if people do or don't make their accounts public/private, I just want a way as a user to filter out those who are private, even a little icon indicating private or public next to their username could work.

edit2:: also am not saying everyone with their account history off is bad, but every irrational, aggressive, antagonistic account that I encounter on here has theirs turned off 100% of the time. I would like to not receive replies from those people even if that means blocking normal people too.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Mar 18 '17

Can we get a reddit without nazis, hosted at reddit.com where /r/nazi is banned? I think this makes sense in light of things nazis have done.

3 Upvotes

r/ideasfortheadmins • • Mar 02 '26

Subreddit My idea is: Rating for moderators

1 Upvotes

Hello,

I really like Reddit, but I feel there's a lack of control and transparency regarding the administrators/moderators of each subreddit.

There are political subreddits that claim to be completely open, but if you post something that displeases the moderators, they ban users without justification.

Furthermore, in art subreddits, there's prejudice and judgment where there shouldn't be.

So I thought of something that isn't punitive, but rather an incentive for moderators: a kind of badge where the community approves a moderator, like a thermometer, which should be updated periodically (every 15/30 days). This would make it very clear and transparent what users think about moderation. And at a certain level (many negative votes), they should be explicitly and publicly warned about poor service.

This would also generate a healthy ranking among subreddits, showing which ones have the best moderation.

What do you think? It's not a bad idea, is it?

Thank you for your attention.

-----------
[Edit] Update:

It could be something periodic where users go back in time to see if they approve of the moderation as a whole. And the result would be public and have a history. A type of automatic evaluation with moderation.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Oct 18 '12

Allow users to put their contact information & link to their other social media profiles on their userpage if they choose to do so.

4 Upvotes

With all the recent controversy surrounding Jezebel & CreepShots, Gawker & ViolentAcrez, reddit is going through an intense period of turmoil. Moderators and users alike are worried that their online activities could affect them in the real world, and rightly so - reddit is a hot topic on the internet right now. Web tabloids such as Gawker and Jezebel are cashing in on that by doing exposes on reddit users and moderators who were acting less than socially acceptable behind their cloak of anonymity. The moderation community is wondering if volunteering several hours every day to a website they love is worth the risk of winding up on CNN if they ever fuck up.

VA is not the last person who will be doxed. Gawker has set the precedent that if you don't like what someone else is doing or saying on reddit or posting to reddit, you can track down their identity and expose them in front of millions of people, some of whom may want to physically hurt you or your family. Doxing redditors is now news. It's going to happen again, it's only a matter of time.

Why is it news? Why is knowing someone's real name so important? It's because anonymity is built into reddit itself - you can't display your real name and contact information if you wanted to. Anonymity is not just an option - it's the only option, unless you specifically tell someone who you are in a comment, or by doing an AMA, etc. Sure, you can tag people you know in RES or add them to your friends list, but there is no way for people to display their real identity natively in reddit itself.

Why can't we change that? Why can't we allow users the option to shed their cloak of anonymity and stand behind what they do or say online. Why can't we allow redditors to include their contact information in the user profile? Why can't we allow redditors to link to their Twitter profiles, to their Google+ pages, to their YouTube channel?

I'm not ashamed of what I do on reddit. I try to be extremely patient, tolerant and understanding as much as possible. I know that some of the moderation decisions I have made have been extremely controversial, but I stand behind them, and when someone convinces me they are a bad idea, I change them. I've been doxed several times, because I make no effort to hide who I am. My real name is available on my other social media profiles because there is a box to enter that information and display it publicly.

I'm not saying that we need to be like Facebook and insist that everyone use their real name and be accountable for everything they say. Anonymity is a valuable tool and should be protected for anyone that wants to use it. However, I don't want to be getting calls from reporters on my cell phone because someone just "doxed" me in an expose and it's national news. Other social media platforms let you shed your cloak of anonymity - why can't we give that same option to our userbase as well?

Edit: Just a reminder, downvoting comments because you disagree with them does not encourage discussion.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Nov 14 '24

Subreddit Permanent bans from sub reddits should only be applicable after multiple year long bans

11 Upvotes

As the title says, permanent bans should only be applicable if 3 separate year long bans have been received. I say three cause moderators would literally put in the habit of just banning someone after a year has gone by for the permanent bans. I say this cause forever is ducking long ass time to just hate someone, why wasn't this a thing in the first place plexes me.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Feb 16 '12

Delete accounts after 12 months of inactivity (please read)

2 Upvotes

I know this might be seen as controversial, but I think I have some pretty good reasons:

  • If a user has been holding an account for over 12 months and hasn't actually used it, it's likely that they've either gotten bored of reddit or that they have no intention of ever using the account themselves.

  • Deleting unused accounts frees up usernames for new users.

  • Deleting unused accounts (presumably) saves hard disk space somewhere along the line (although the amount of space saved will likely be negligible).

  • Deleting unused accounts means that people can't try and sell "valuable" accounts years later (here is an example). Allegedly, early users of the site registered multiple "valuable" usernames for this purpose.

So...there's my argument for doing this. I would love to hear what other people think about this.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Oct 22 '12

Can we add criteria to subreddits which require an account to be X months/years old to subscribe?

0 Upvotes

Perhaps if the account is younger than X, they have read-only or no access. If account is older than X, they have read/write access? I understand this is a controversial issue, but it would be nice to see some constructive criticism from users on both sides of the fence.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • May 12 '14

Give subreddits the option of having a "Thanks for subscribing message" sent to all new subscribers

0 Upvotes

As soon as you click "subscribe" in a new subreddit, the subreddit will send you a message, consisting of text that the mods have prepared (similar to the submit text, etc.)

So, if I go to /r/askhistorians and click "subscribe" then I would immediately get an orange envelope that says "Thanks for subscribing! Here's all of the important stuff you need to know for participating here!"

This would ensure that users actually are alerted to the important rules of the subreddit before they start participating there.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Jun 12 '16

Remove abusive mods in a "right to work" no explanation capacity

1 Upvotes

I just read in a thread, with this whole default sub censorship fiasco with the shooting in Orlando (condolences to anybody affected), that there was a lawsuit by AOL moderators who said because they were being given direction by the admins that they were an unpaid labor force and I think were therefore trying to get wages for their efforts. As someone fluent in business, I now understand this as the reason why admins are afraid to get involved in moderating issues. However, this would only apply, I imagine, where explicit parameters are given to the moderating staff such as "don't censor people regurgitating what the FBI says because you disagree with it or disagree with it's validity at this point in time." If the admins set up a one-way infrastructure to have abusive mods reported and removed without disclosing to them nor users why they were removed nor establishing guidelines for future mods, I think that would be a defense in a lawsuit like that. If you leave it open ended from the removed moderators' perspective, they would not be able to prove in court that you guys removed them for that specific reason of not following guidelines and you would thus be free from that enormous liability while not letting this site go to shit at the same time.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Nov 18 '12

Create a subreddit for all gilded comments.

0 Upvotes

Any time a comment is gilded, it should be automatically submitted to a bestof-like subreddit.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Mar 16 '25

Post & Comment Downvoting should cost karma

2 Upvotes

The reddiquette says:

Please do not downvote an otherwise acceptable post because you don't personally like it. Think before you downvote and take a moment to ensure you're downvoting someone because they are not contributing to the community dialogue or discussion. If you simply take a moment to stop, think and examine your reasons for downvoting, rather than doing so out of an emotional reaction, you will ensure that your downvotes are given for good reasons.

As well as:

Please do not mass downvote someone else's posts. If it really is the content you have a problem with (as opposed to the person), by all means vote it down when you come upon it. But don't go out of your way to seek out an enemy's posts.

Which makes a lot of sense, as downvoting in those prohibited ways creates echo chambers, prevents meaningful discourse, suppresses minority opinions, discourages people from being open and honest, and so much more. Considering that some subreddits require certain amounts of karma to even participate in them, the mass downvoting of users can also be abused to essentially bully users into being unable to contribute at all. All of which is detrimental to the platform.

Unfortunately, as anyone who has spent any amount of time on reddit will know, this is exactly how most people use downvotes, which is a problem.

It has become clear that rules or guidelines can't prevent users from abusing the downvote system. Most users aren't even aware and assume that the "downvote" button is essentially the same as a "dislike" button. Therefore, the only solution is to change the system itself. One way would be to remove downvotes entirely. This makes sense, because if you read the above rules, one could argue that whenever one would rightfully use a downvote, they might as well use the "report" feature instead. Example: off-topic content is against the rules in pretty much any sub, and can and should be reported as such - so why have the downvote button as alternative in the first place? However, as we've seen with YouTube, taking this feature away is likely to result in backlash, as is usually the case with taking away existing functionality.

This is where my suggestion comes in: I propose to change the downvote system in such a way that downvoting a post or comment will take a point out of your own karma pool. This has several advantages:

  • New accounts with little to no karma can't be used for downvoting

  • Having a cost associated with a downvote will actually have people "think before you downvote", as the reddiquette asks

  • Mass downvoting of users becomes unattractive due to the increasing cost to your own karma

  • There would be a limit to the amount of downvoting any one user can do

  • Implementing (mass) downvote bots will be much harder

  • It would add an addtional meaning to the Karma system, and hence incentivise contributions

There might be even better solutions; but if the system is left as-is, it will continue to erode the platform. The above suggestion has been implemented on other platforms, like the family of StackExchange websites, and seems to work very well there. This suggests that it would be a good first step into addressing the issues around the current system, maybe even a solution.


r/ideasfortheadmins • • Aug 13 '12

Mod ability to put a comment at the top of a discussion

0 Upvotes

Like distinguishing a post as mod, call it "promote" or something like that it puts the selected comment at the top of the discussion with the caveat that said comment no longer collects karma. This allows mods to bring important but buried information or a mod post to the top of a discussion.