r/ideasforcmv • • May 11 '22

Remove the downvote button to discourage downvoting

39 Upvotes

I think the worst part of Reddit is the community of people who are addicted to down voting and that’s particularly apparent in this community due to the nature of it. It’s somewhat discouraging to even attempt to have a discussion to change my view when every comment i make is going to be downvoted to oblivion not for the content of the comment but simply because people are maliciously downvoting.

I think a way to at least discourage this is to remove the downvote button. I’ve seen this done on other subs where they upload custom icons for upvotes and downvotes leaving the downvote option blank. It can still be selected but it’s just not visible


r/ideasforcmv • • Apr 13 '14

Maybe people in CMV should be required to express a seed of doubt in their view

26 Upvotes

There's a ton of people who use CMV as a soapbox or are otherwise interested in writing a manifesto. The redpiller guy in an active thread right now might be the most recent example, but you see it every day. Often the OP will post a wall of text that reads like a term paper, and ends with "so, I challenge you-- change my view" or something that doesn't illustrate good faith.

There also wouldn't be nearly as many threads on duplicate topics if people were really looking to change their mind, rather than argue and debate with others. If I really wanted to change my view on abortion, I would search for "abortion" and educate myself with some of the dozens of existing threads on the topic.

I don't know what the solution is, but I just feel like soapboxing has gotten out of hand. Maybe we should require people to express their motive for coming to CMV in the first place. Why do you want to change your view? What sort of evidence would change your view?


r/ideasforcmv • • Jun 07 '14

In CMV: To see if a view was successfully changed, a symbol should appear next to the title of the post showing the status of the posters opinion.

24 Upvotes

Sorry if this is a repost. Let me know if so


r/ideasforcmv • • Apr 14 '14

If OP never responds to a single argument, they should be suspended from the forum for a week.

21 Upvotes

It drives me absolutely crazy. I don't know how many times I've seen someone make a post, and 15 to 20 people write out thorough well thought out points, and OP never writes a single response to a single one. It's the most irritating thing ever, and it suggests to me that OP wasn't actually interested in having a conversation, but rather putting out a controversial opinion to watch what people do with it. I think that if someone makes a CMV thread, and if after 24 hours of making it they haven't written a single response to a single person in that thread, than they should receive a message that they have been banned from posting in the forum for a week or something like that.


r/ideasforcmv • • Aug 02 '20

Mod neutrality appreciation

20 Upvotes

I’m really impressed with how unbiased the mods of cmv are. From what I’ve seen, they only enforce the rules when they think they are broken, not for personal power or the views of the posts. There are posts on this sub from all angles of life, and civility is kept to a tolerable level thanks to mod action.

It’s all to often that I see mods on big sub-Reddit’s abuse their power and/or use rules subjectively to promote their own political or ideological beliefs. And cmv is a big sub-Reddit: a couple dozen mods vs over a million subscribers.

So whatever you guys are doing to stay neutral and focused on the spirit of this sub-Reddit, I hope you can keep it up! And thank you.


r/ideasforcmv • • Apr 11 '20

Please can we stop the endless repeats of the "Gender dysphoria / Transgender is a mental illness / not real" post?

20 Upvotes

Sometimes these sorts of posts can be insightful. Maybe sometimes the OP even learns something from them. But what the OP never seems to do is press the search bar and see the nearly exactly-the-same worded CMV posted, sometimes in the same week. It's so tiring seeing transphobia getting upvoted to the page again and again when it's the same conversation, again and again.

Here's a small sample of the search results:

CMV: Transgendered individuals have serious and legitimate mental problems and they deserve clinical help to reverse their dysmorphia. (the latest one)

CMV: Gender Dysphoria is a cureable mental illness, we've stopped looking for the cure because society is now forced into accepting transgenders. (1 month ago)

CMV: Transgender people would not exist/be a thing, if societal gender norms/roles didn't exist. (1 month ago)

CMV: Gender dysphoria IS a mental illness and it’s nothing to be ashamed of, but we need to stop pretending like it isn’t (1 month ago)

CMV: Gender dysphoria (transgender) is a mental illness (4 months ago)

CMV: Gender Dysphoria is a mental disorder (5 months ago)

CMV: Transgender people are wrong, and the support is hurting them (6 months ago)

CMV: Aggressive acceptance of gender identity issues can cause more harm than good. (7 months ago)

CMV: Gender dysphoria is a mental illness (8 months ago - exact same as ...)

CMV: Gender dysphoria is a mental illness (9 months ago - and then ...)

CMV: Gender dysphoria is a mental illness (3 years ago)

Please mods, can we put a moratorium on this topic and refer people to the plethora of existing threads on the same topic. If an OP comes along and is convinced by none of the arguments in any of the threads, that would be grounds for a novel discussion.


r/ideasforcmv • • Feb 07 '25

Rule D's transgender section is not neutral but explicitly anti-trans and should be removed to preserve the spirit of r/CMV

18 Upvotes

Recently, one of my posts was flagged for removal because of rule D, specifically for using the word trans in my post. It was just an off-hand reference, and one that I could easily avoid by changing the wording on one part, without actually changing the substance or message of my post at all.

However, in reading up on Rule D itself, I couldn't help but read through it, read through as much of the discussion around it as I could, and ultimately, I have come to the conclusion that the trans section (which I'll refer to as Rule D-T) not only should be removed, but must be removed for r/CMV to maintain it's mission.

First, let's look at Rule D-T in detail and break it down:

Transgender Posts: Views regarding anything related to transgender people.

This wasn't really our choice.

If nothing else, please remove this part. It is simply insulting, it was your choice. You may argue that the choice was forced onto you, but ultimately you made the choice the way you did, and so you must own up to it if you want to have any integrity at all.

We don't police topics based on the view presented (outside of the short list in Rule D). We don't see it as our place as mods to decide what views should be changed, and the purpose of CMV is to allow views that we want to see changed a chance to get voiced. Most importantly, we promise that you won't be punished for voicing an unpopular or disliked view - this is a safe space to voice how you feel and have people civilly respond with counterarguments.

However, the Admins see things differently. They were removing transgender related posts and comments with very little consistency or rationale. Some things that seemed openly hateful were left up and some things that were benign were taken down.

So, the story is this. As far as CMV was concerned, everything was on-table, including pro- or anti- trans speech. However, by the nature of being a site on Reddit, the Reddit admins had the authority and power to ban people for going against site-wide rules. The same thing would go for any other hate-speech that Reddit decides to punish site-wide, so no need for a carveout for trans people specifically. So far, so good.

However, the problem you had was that you disagreed with the Reddit admins about what was or was not hate speech regarding trans people.

Personally, I think the argument stops here, because as a neutral party, r/CMV mods should not be stepping in to try to override the Reddit admins. Let them ban as they felt necessary. If you disagree with what they're doing, complain to them directly. If that doesn't work, well that's just it, you accept it and move on. I can't imagine anything more neutral than that.

Of course, you disagreed, so let's keep going and address the reasons you thought the above wasn't acceptable.

So we had three big problems:

  1. We couldn't uphold our promise that you won't be punished for views you post here so long as you follow the rules. If we know there is a good chance the Admins will punish you, then we have to protect you from that.

Why? You say "we have to protect you from that", but make no argument as to why. If you wanted, you could throw up a warning along the lines of, "Hey guys, the Reddit admins are itchy with the ban-button around the whole trans topic, so broach it at your own risk." To me that seems unnecessary, but it would at least still be in the neutral spirit of r/CMV. If someone gets banned unnecessarily, well darn. It's just a social media site, nobody's life or livelihood is at stake here. They can appeal the ban, or make an alt account, or just stop visiting Reddit altogether.

On the other hand, Trans people have skin in the game. Not by choice, but simply by being who they are. If anti-trans hate speech is allowed, or, as is happening here, if trans people are swept under the rug and treated as personas non-grata, that has real-world effects on their livelihoods, and by degrees, their lives. It makes r/CMV an unwelcoming place to them. It excludes their thoughts and ideas. Nobody can relate their experiences as a trans person to someone else's experiences as a gay person, or someone being bullied, or someone who is going through severe depression. They can mention that they too once flirted with suicide, but can never say why they were suicidal.

Again, this problem, as far as it exists, has a very clear answer as to which side you should be falling on to protect. Being a Redditor isn't an identity. Being trans is.

2) We couldn't craft any guidance on what types of transgender posts/comments would be acceptable, as there was no constancy to what was removed.

This is more an extension of the first issue, but there's no mention here of you asking the admins what guidelines they were following. If you could get even a nominal set of rules from them, then you could attempt to enforce them more lightly yourself (though as mentioned above, that seems unnecessary), or at least use them as something to point to when disputing bans, or for others to use when disputing their bans.

3) Any guidance we might have been able to cobble together would have been overwhelmingly pro-transgender. That would be us putting a massive thumb on the scale for the issue, which is pretty counter to the purpose of CMV and our role as mods.

You point out another fine example of a solution here. Some true pro-trans rules would have solved the problem neatly, and while it can be argued it goes against the spirit of neutrality, I would point to the paradox of intolerance as a counterargument.

However, even if you still think that being pro-trans is a thumb on the scales, I would argue that the current policy of blanket-banning the topic is, at minimum, an equally large thumb on the scale on the issue, just in the other direction. The current policy is, at it's heart, a repeat of the don't-ask, don't-tell policy. Trans people can exist on this subreddit, they just can't be so openly. And just like the don't-ask, don't-tell policy, this amounts to little more than thinly-veiled suppression of trans people.

This, more than anything, is my argument for why this rule must be removed. As things stand, r/CMV has not only failed to remain neutral on the trans topic, but has come out as explicitly anti-trans.

Furthermore, we found that posts and comments which referenced transgender issues, even tangentially, often led to a chain of increasingly hostile and rule-breaking messages. The ratio of civil, thoughtful discourse that changed views to rule-violating posts and comments was strikingly low. We received feedback from some users that they did not feel comfortable in the sub due to the frequency of hateful or rules-violating comments.

So what you're saying is, you're happy to ban any topic, as long as 4-chan is sufficiently motivated to be nasty about it? If tomorrow, suddenly thousands of posters started spewing hate speech towards Jewish people, you'd be happy to just sweep that under the rug by banning Jews and Judiasm as a whole as a topic?

While I can understand the struggle here, this is a battle that simply comes with the territory for r/CMV. It's also a reason to be judicious with the ban tool yourself, not a reason to throw up your arms and let the bigots have what they want.

We argued internally about this for nearly a year and finally landed on this: if we can't uphold the CMV mission for a particular topic, then we can't host that topic at all. The Admins decided that we can't do the former, so we resigned to do the latter.

You've discussed this amongst yourselves. I would suggest going to the trans community directly to ask them how they feel about it. I suspect I know what kind of response you will get, and I suspect you have an idea what response you'll get as well, but I think it's important that you hear it directly from them. They know this topic far better than you or I, and they can be quite persuasive.

At the very, very least, if you're going to tell them they can't exist here, tell them that to their face.


r/ideasforcmv • • Sep 12 '24

Rule D needs to be reworked as it is overzealous in making the sub anti-trans as a whole.

18 Upvotes

While I can absolutely understand not wanting to debate about trans people due to topic fatigue, instead it is far overreaching in that you cannot even state that trans people exist, or reference them in any ways even when they are relevant to the topic at hand.

I particularly would like to point out the ridiculousness of the statement in point 3:

3) Any guidance we might have been able to cobble together would have been overwhelmingly pro-transgender. That would be us putting a massive thumb on the scale for the issue, which is pretty counter to the purpose of CMV and our role as mods.

By wanting to avoid the appearance of being pro-transgender in your policy you instead take on an appearance of being overwhelmingly anti-transgender by removing any and all reference to people's existence from the sub no matter how relevant it might be to the discussion.

This policy should only be applied to original posts and not to comments as it removes the ability for people to even attempt to sway people's minds if their argument involves trans people in any way at all.

This does incredible harm and makes the community one that I am no longer proud to be a part of since learning of this. Not being able to even speak about experiences or the facts of the current political climate makes these discussions meaningless as it is impossible to debate properly when large portions of personal experience are against the rules simply for existing.


r/ideasforcmv • • Aug 20 '18

For Rule 2, why isn't overt racism considered a form of rudeness?

18 Upvotes

tl;dr CMV categorically allows generalized racist statements in comments and posts, which arguably violates rule 2: "Don't be rude or hostile to other users." I would argue that most generalized racist statements that are under 3 sentences in length clock as violations of rules 1, 2, 3, and/or 5.

**

So, I'm still chewing on a ban I received just now. To elaborate: I had a thread about cultural boycotts of Israel. I said people should boycott America as well. In the thread, I mention specifically that I myself am Jewish. Someone comments, saying that "1/3 of Supreme Court is Jewish - seems like racist laws are enacted by Jews and it shows why it's so widespread in Israel." My retort was "wow, it's great that you are so transparent in your hatred of Jews." My comment was removed for rudeness. But my question is, why doesn't blatant antisemitism/racism violate rule 2? (Nevermind the fact that 'the Jews are creating racist laws' also violates rules 3 and 5.)

Imagine that the case is a comment saying, "Blacks are ruining this country. Just look at the racist laws enacted by blacks." Someone comments saying, "Hey, look at this racist over here." What is the justification for the first comment being "less rude" than the second?

Here's what I got from CMV mods:

Racism isn't against our rules. We only remove comments that are rude and/or hostile to specific other users. Not to groups and not to specific people that aren't participants in the thread.

OK, but what if I'm a member of the group that someone is being racist against? Is that 'individual' enough?

It was rude in the ways we care about. You broke our rules. The poster you replied to did not. Thus your comment was removed and theirs was not

I feel especially uncomfortable because my original post specifically mentioned that I am Jewish, and my comment was deleted (and I was banned????) because I responded to an antisemitic comment with a claim that it was antisemitic. It's not like I said, "You Jew-hating piece of shit! Get out of my thread!" I just noted that the comment was bunk and moved on. How is it rude to point out that someone is responding to me in bad faith, and responding to me with a hateful allegation against my group? How is it rude enough to warrant a ban? Feels like I am being tone policed for ... being marginalized. Furthermore, there's no robust standard by which rudeness can be measured... it's just up to the mods to decide who's being an ass and who's not. But if the whole point of the subreddit is to change views, why was my comment deleted, and why was I banned for appealing the removal? This seems more like "we don't like you protesting antisemitism" than it seems like "we want a healthy discourse."

Anyway, all of this is to say that Rule 2 contradicts r/CMV's 'policy' of permitting racist discourse. It's ridiculous to delete comments that point out racism and leave the racism itself standing. Just leave it all, or delete it all. I don't understand why you're tone-policing people who react to racism with contempt. Polite racism is still bad faith discourse.


r/ideasforcmv • • Jul 20 '25

Anti-trans conversation rule is inherently trans erasure

17 Upvotes

I am not the first and I'm not the last to say this. It is transphobic and political essentialism.

I refuse to write an essay that will get largely ignored, especially when other people have done so before me, only to get met by some bs take from a mod who doesn't understand why erasing trans people from the conversation is bad. Or god forbid, how it's actually a good thing for trans people's sanity.


r/ideasforcmv • • Sep 17 '17

Lowercase delta(𝛿) for minor view changes, Uppercase delta(Δ) for view reversals.

16 Upvotes

For example:

Lowercase for "Chocolate is the best ice cream flavor and anyone who likes vanilla is stupid" to "Chocolate is my favorite ice cream flavor, but other people can like vanilla"

Uppercase for "Chocolate is the best ice cream flavor and anyone who likes vanilla is stupid" to "Vanilla is my favorite ice cream flavor"


r/ideasforcmv • • Sep 16 '24

A concrete proposal for improving the Trans rule

14 Upvotes

Introduction

I have been a very long time lurker on the CMV sub, and have always deeply admired what that sub tries to do. Furthermore, it was often very refreshing and downright fascinating to see the discussion in the sub and how they were managed. But I have been deeply saddened each time I am confronted with the results of rule D Transgender Posts implementation. This has gotten to the point where I had to unsubscribe from the subreddit to improve my mental health, regardless of how much I wished to keep reading the fascinating interactions that the sub is filled with.

However, it still stuck with me and I did occasionally venture into the ideasforcmv sub to see if any improvements were on the horizon. Sadly, the discussion here about it was generally unproductive. On the one hand there were concerned users making posts explaining the failings of the rule's implementation but unable to provide concrete alternatives. On the other hand were moderators that seemed frustrated by having to constantly explain their position while not being presented with workable alternatives. The result was a discussion with two sides just talking to a wall that won't move, with no sign of consensus or compromise ever being within sight.

For those reasons I will now attempt to present in detail the situation that lead to the rule and its implementation, the damage and problems that the rule and its implementation is causing to the quality of the subreddit and finally a few concrete steps that could be taken to mitigate these problems.

Important to note here is that I will try to refrain as much as possible from ethical objections to the decision to implement this rule and will mainly be focused on how it negatively influences the goals of the sub. Should there be any interest from the mods to hear the ethical arguments against the rules, then I will gladly provide those, but this post will focus as much as possible on the practical issues. Finally I may add a comment underneath with some notes that pertain to this rule and its implementation, but which did not clearly fit anywhere in this text.

The problems the rule attempts to solve

The original problem that caused the rule to come into effect was an overflow of posts about trans people. These posts were dominating the subreddit, and due to mods not being able to keep up with the sheer number of them, were filled to the brim with bad faith arguments and unproductive arguments. This problem was not always there as initially trans people were not considered as controversial of a topic, but around the time of the Trump election there was a large influx of these posts from transphobic individuals that had no intention of changing their mind. Furthermore, the admins became quite active in curbing the rampant transphobia on the entire platform, which meant that people on CMV using transphobic language were often caught in the Admin's crosshairs. (though of course with the very typical non-existent reddit consistency)

This brings us to the problems as they are presented in the rules document: 1a) Moderators were unable to uphold their promise that users won't be punished for views they post on CMV so long as they follow the rules. Essentially indicating a desire to protect users from the unreliable wrath of the Admins.

1b) The moderators couldn't craft any guidance on what types of transgender posts/comments would be acceptable, as there was no consistency to what was removed.

1c) Any guidance the moderators might have been able to cobble together would have been overwhelmingly pro-transgender, which would be them putting a massive thumb on the scale for the issue, which would kind of defeat the purpose CMV for those posts.

An important thing to note here is that this isn't the whole story as can be seen in the many comments of moderators on this issue. An even more prominent reason seems to be the inability for the current mod team to see and moderate sufficiently to deal with the sudden influx of these posts. Of course this is in no way a criticism of the moderator team's abilities. The subreddit is huge and the moderator team is both limited in number and time. It would frankly be unreasonable to expect them to be able to spend as much time as would be needed to moderate against that storm when each moderator also has a life of their own and is doing this as unpaid work on the side.

To deal with all these issues, the current rule and its implementation were implemented. To paraphrase the mods themselves, it is a bad rule but it is the best they could come up with. In the following sections I will present why this rule and implementation is more damaging than it might seem and what might be done to improve upon it.

The rule, its implementation and the problems that the rule creates

The current implementation of the rule is not actually as it would seem from the rules wiki. In the rules wiki it is described as a ban on transgender posts. This is incorrect. The current implementation means that any discussion of trans people, any reference to trans people, and even any mention of trans people or a trans person is banned in both posts and comments. This is being implemented with an automod that has been programmed to remove any potential reference to trans people without any human action needed at any point in the process. One mod aptly described it as a "don't ask don't tell" policy for trans people.

The intended effect of this policy is that there are no visible trans people on the subreddit. In this way the problem has been solved with a lack of visible trans people meaning that there aren't any posts and comments containing transphobia. At least, that seems to be the impression the moderators have of the rule working as intended. From the comments made by moderators about this rule, at least part of the moderators seems to consider this a neutral solution. I strongly disagree that it is and it would appear there is also a part of the moderators that thinks so, but they appear to consider it an unfortunate but necessary part of it.

If we ignore any moral arguments and objections to the rule, then we are left with four main problems that the rule and its implementation creates:

2a) Discussion about trans topics is not possible:

This one if very obvious and the intended consequence of the rule. Topics about trans people can no longer be discussed and people can no longer have their views about trans people changed. Though unfortunate, this has obviously been taken into consideration and was considered a worthwhile sacrifice to improve how well the subreddit can be moderated.

2b) Trans users feel less welcome on the sub and will stop using it.

Having a "don't ask don't tell" policy will obviously make the people that are no longer allowed to mention a major characteristic of themselves feel unwelcome. From the comments on this issue it would seem that moderators are significantly underestimating how severely unwelcome trans people are on the subreddit now. I've seen moderators argue that this is not the case because trans people can have opinions that don't rely on them being trans, but I think that argument completely misses the point of the atmosphere a blanket ban of your identity creates and though well intentioned comes off as tonedeaf to a failing of the implementation of the rule.

2c) Any active trans user still present will be unable to properly participate in the sub.

Elaborating on the argument mentioned before, being trans in modern society influences a significant part of a person's life. It completely changes the people you can interact with, the way strangers treat you and the events and organisations you can participate in. Because of this, the fact someone is trans can have large and sometimes unexpected effects on the arguments they can offer up in a discussion. With the current rule implementation, any trans person still on the sub will be severely neutered in how they can interact with posts and other users.

2d) Any subject that could profit from either the perspective of a trans person or the mention of trans people has the quality of the discussion significantly degraded.

Aside from this ruling influencing trans people, it also significantly influences the quality of discussion that can be had about other subjects. Any discussion involving sexual education, sexuality, gender norms and other topics that are only tangentially related to gender, will be lacking significant parts of their discussion due to the rule's implementation. This won't just affect the contribution of trans users, but of any user who interacts with trans people or is knowledgeable about trans people and wants to share views that could be valuable in a discussion.

To summarize, all 4 of these reasons go directly against the subreddit goal of providing an open platform for civil discussion. Point 2a bans certain discussions from taking place. Point 2b reduces the number of perspectives that will participate in the discussion due to the subreddit creating a hostile environment. Point 2c means that certain users will be more limited than others in which arguments and experiences they are allowed to bring into a discussion. Point 2d shows that the ruling also reduces the value of the subreddit for far more subjects that just subjects directly involving what has been banned.

Potential improvements to the current rule and its implementation

In a perfect world the solution would be having a moderator review every post and comment and manually check whether these abide by the letter and spirit of the subreddit rules. Of course this is not feasible, so let's look at some points that another moderator mentioned a solution needs to take into account:

3a) "The solution must be implementable with our current small moderation team. When we do moderation drives, we usually get about 3-10 applications, and most of them are people who are interested in pushing an agenda or are blatantly unqualified. We don't have a way of getting more moderators. Any solution that requires more moderation work is impossible to implement."

3b) "The solution must make trans folks feel welcome without harming our credibility as a neutral subreddit. If we are seen as taking a side on an issue, our entire mission and reason for existence is null and void."

3c) "If the solution involves lifting the ban, then there must be a way to productively discuss the topic and allow transphobic people who might be questioning their views to air their problematic positions without fear of reprisal from either us or Reddit administration. Otherwise, what is the point of allowing the topic at all?"

3a is a very clear and reasonable requirement that from moderator comments also seems to be the main reason that the rule exists in the form it does right now.

3b I think is significantly weaker as it seem to assume that making trans people feel so unwelcome that they stop interacting with the subreddit is a neutral position. However, it does touch upon the fact that the moderators do not consider banning transphobia to be a solution as it would be more actively taking a side, rather than more passively removing one side from the equation.

3c synergises beautifully with the first to create a very difficult problem. This point also highlights way more rationally and clearly why the moderators consider banning transphobia to be against the spirit of the subreddit. Unlike the previous point which tries to convey the same message but instead comes of as trying to take a moral high ground over any critics of the rule as it is.

So taking these things into consideration, I would propose the following improvements which can be combined, but also implemented separately.

Solution 1 (easy and realistic):

Having moderated a very controversial subreddit, I have noticed a kind of shock therapy effect on a reddit community when strict rules are implemented and very strictly enforced. The effect is that if the rules are relaxed somewhat afterwards, most problematic users have left and won't return unless something draws their attention back to the community.

Additionally, most of the problems created by the current rule and implementation are not actually cause by the rule itself, but by the automod and the implementation of the rule on comments as well as posts.

For these two reasons I believe it might be beneficial to remove the automoderation of trans related comments to see if the problematic behavior has calmed down since the point it started and if the "shock therapy" has worked. After all, the behavior started suddenly so it is not unreasonable to consider the possibility of it dying down again. Just by implementing this change it would satisfy requirements 3b, while solving problems 1b, 1c, 2b, 2c and 2d. If the shock therapy worked and the behavior has died down, then it would also satisfy point 3a and thus solve problem 1a.

This solution is not a replacement of the current rule and would require almost no adjustments. The downside is that this would still make posts about trans people banned, but it would do so with far less collateral damage than it is doing now.

Solution 2 (harder follow-up to 1 and risky):

This would be an ideal scenario where the previous solution works exactly as intended. If the moderators want to take a large risk, they could at that point consider very slowly removing the rule and seeing if CMV posts about transgender topics work again like they used to before the problematic times.

This solution would however be high risk as it could undo any gains made by the previous solution if it goes wrong.

Solution 3 (more difficult to implement but complete):

The final solution I will propose is to designate a single day each week, or a few days each month, where trans related topics are allowed alongside other topics. This could even be done without a regular interval, but just on certain days when the moderators have time and feel like it to reduce brigading and have mainly regular users participate.

This could be combined with solution one to solve all problems I presented, or it could be done with the current system which would partially solve most of the problem.

( Not really a solution, but a bandaid (trivial to implement but only solves one issue partially): Have automod send mod mails rather than place mod comments when removing a comment for breaking the "don't say trans" rule. This doesn't actually solve anything, but it very slightly improves how hostile the sub feels for trans users by not having constant mod comments reminding them that they are not welcome. )

Conclusion

First I would like to sincerely apologise for the length of this post and the fact that it is ANOTHER post about the don't say trans rule. However, I believe what I included might help non moderators and myself get a more complete picture of the situation, the problems and what needs to be addressed.

To summarise, I have presented the problem that the current rule seeks to solve and the ways in which it either fails to do so or conflicts directly with the stated subreddit goals. I have presented 3 solutions that I believe could be an improvement over the current status quo with limited extra effort on the moderation team's part.

I would like to invite other users as well to share their thoughts about how to improve the current ruling if the solutions I presented here do not work. I strongly believe that the current rule implementation conflicts sufficiently with the stated goals of the subreddit that it should be considered unacceptable as the status quo. Comments and question are of course very welcome and I will gladly elaborate on any of the points I have made in this text.


r/ideasforcmv • • Nov 10 '23

CMV should allow free discourse on controversial topics, like debates on Transgenderism

14 Upvotes

Title explains it all. Why isn’t free discourse allowed (obviously not tolerating hate speech/recommending violence & being respectful etc.)

But why is this topic SPECIFICALLY banned on CMV? Isn’t this meant to be a medium for open & honest dialogue, not an artificial echo chamber of one side because the other side has been banned into silence?


r/ideasforcmv • • Sep 14 '20

CMV: All CMV posts should need to formally state, within the post, why they want their mind changed.

14 Upvotes

Hi folks.

I'm quite new to this sub, but I've noticed a fair number of strongly worded posts that could reasonably be called "soapboxing"; folks coming on the CMV to have their views validated, rather than challenged. I understand that this is antithetical to the purpose CMV, so I'm proposing the folowing view:

"All CMV posts should need to formally state, within the post, why they want their mind changed."

I'm thinking this could serve a few purposes:

  • Encourage folks to consider whether their post is appropriate for the sub;

  • Allow folks to better understand the motive behind a given view, which may make for higher quality posts and comments;

  • Make moderation easier to manage.

Why do I want this view changed? Well, clearly this would constitute a rather large cultural shift to a sub; it's not something I would want to suggest lightly (especially as I'm new to the community). If I've misunderstood community standards, I want to be aware of how so I can be a better member of CMV.

Thanks folks. :)


r/ideasforcmv • • Apr 22 '14

if the thesis that OP presents to CMV is shown to be factually incorrect, Deltas should be awarded by the mods.

14 Upvotes

I am not suggesting that mods rule over every post to CMV.

I am suggesting that I have seen OPs stating positions and when proven factually wrong, the OP disappears.

This is part of my anti "soap-boxing" campaign...

The "there was no plane that crashed into the pentagon on 9/11" post is just one from today that I can think of.

And perhaps a list of commonly "de-bunked" CMVs should be added to the side bar or bot banned????


r/ideasforcmv • • Apr 10 '14

A flair for threads, similar to those on /r/ELI5 and /r/tipofmytongue, that indicate a CMV that has been "successful."

13 Upvotes

Like the "Explained" flair on ELI5 that lets you know an sufficient explanation has been given, a flair that shows a view has been changed.


r/ideasforcmv • • Sep 25 '24

Is it the official stance of the Mod team that Drag Queens are a Trans topic?

12 Upvotes

I saw a post just now regarding Drag Queens, but removed for rule D.

I'm not sure if I missed something in the content, but broadly Drag Queens are their own thing, not really anything to do with Transsexuality, it's it's own performance form separate from Gender topics even though some try and conflate them.

Do the mods consider drag queens to be trans?

Is the culture of drag queen part of transsexuality as far as CMV is concerned?

Not really an "idea" more a clarifying question for that rule I guess.


r/ideasforcmv • • May 23 '24

OPs who delete their threads when they realize how wrong their view is should probably be penalized

12 Upvotes

It seems like every CMV I have recently participated in has been removed by the OP. A bunch of people, myself included, type up detailed replies—and the OP just quietly wipes their entire thread. Sometimes the OP defends their view across a few replies and then, when it's become obvious that their view is unsustainable, deletes the thread. It's not a big deal, but it seems to defeat the purpose of the sub, on top of being mildly annoying and somewhat discouraging.

It feels like posting on a debate sub rather than one about people practicing open-mindedness—not so much "change my view" as "this is what I believe, fight me!"

Everyone has the right to the privacy of their posts, but doesn't quietly removing threads go against the spirit of CMV—and, if so, shouldn't it be penalized on CMV? A ban (perhaps temporary) seems like an appropriate penalty for someone who posts a CMV, reads the replies, realizes their view was wrong all along—and just deletes the thread.

Has this been discussed before? Is there a reason there is no rule against this?


r/ideasforcmv • • Jun 16 '21

I think that Submission Rule B should be relaxed.

12 Upvotes

In my opinion, the part of Submission rule B which requires posters to demonstrate that they are open to changing their view is unnecessarily harsh and restrictive.

The reason is simple: it results in deletion of interesting and informative discussions that I'd rather see preserved for posterity.

I would love to provide multiple examples of this happening, but the fact that the threads are deleted makes it complicated. I'll have to speak from memory.

A day or two ago, there was a CMV about the backlash against alleged teaching of Critical Race Theory in schools. As you can guess, it was deleted for rule B. I managed to read most of it before it happened.

The problem was that the responses (especially top-level comments) were bad. Ridiculously, awfully bad. There were factually incorrect statements (immediately called out by others). There was blatant misrepresentation (for example, a famed civil rights activist and attorney was presented as a proponent of segregation using out-of-context quotes - again, called out). There was gish galloping (posting a dozen vague quotes without links). There were comments where it was obvious that authors did not even read the articles they submitted in support of their views (for example, an opinion piece with a title that suggested anti-CRT nature, but the text itself was not). And of course, there were plainly very, very not smart people, who struggled even with the basic concepts like "theory" or "race".

The poster was in an impossible position. They had either to say that they were convinced by obvious frauds, or face deletion. I am very sad that the entire discussion is gone now.

In light of this, I suggest to relax the enforcement of Sub Rule B, or to rephrase it, or, at the very least, change the penalty from deletion to locking.

Thank you for your attention.


r/ideasforcmv • • Mar 12 '21

On the surge of gender and sexuality related posts.

12 Upvotes

The subreddit has recently seen a surge of posts regarding gender and sexuality, many of which have been removed under rule B or rule E violations. Similarly, these posts usually attract commenters who advance transphobic concepts and/or use techniques such as sealioning to waste time.

I propose that CMV lay down some ground rules for this category of topic to avoid giving a platform to such views:

- Posters should be required to explain why their view has been not been changed by the N other posts (or a FAQ) on the exact same topic. (yes, I know the reasoning that some people learn by engaging with others in dialog, at some point commenters hit burnout and/or overload and stop responding as constructively as they might otherwise to fewer, higher quality, posts.)

- No blatant transphobia. (trans women are NOT men, trans men are NOT women, for example.)

- No arguing in bad faith, (these threads attract trolls who are not contributing to a civil discussion; it's easier for a troll to spam shit than it is for people to constructively engage to disprove the shit.)

- Start actively moderating such threads without waiting for individual users to report individual instances of rule 1, 2, and 5 violations

It's bloody tiresome seeing thread after thread, often multiple active at the same time recently, questioning the validity of your identity as a person. Many of which lead off with something along the lines of "I'm not transphobic, but..." <transphobic viewpoint> and end in 3 hours of nothing followed by Rule E removal or have an OP who is actively defending their viewpoint and get a Rule B removal.


r/ideasforcmv • • Feb 16 '21

OPs deleting threads is becoming a increasing problem

12 Upvotes

In the last couple days I've commented in about 10 threads on CMV. of those, no less than 5 were deleted by the OP. Most often the pattern is "create thread"-> be surprised that in a forum that engenders disagreement, people don't all agree with out -> delete post

To some extent not much can be done. After all, what are you going to do, remove the post? But there is at least one person who's username I've come to recognize who posts semi-regularly, only to delete the post once comments come in.

How do we encourage OPs not to do this? It really makes me (and other's in those threads) hesitant to engage. Why take the time researching and formatting a carefully worded reply if the post is deleted before you finish? I find myself withholding thought and effort before replying, which encourages nitpick-y pithy discussion.


r/ideasforcmv • • Oct 12 '20

CMV in person?

12 Upvotes

Hello all. I was directed here by a r/CMV mod to ask a pseudo-meta question. I'm looking for a place in person where I can have good faith debates similar to Change My View. Over video chat would be fine too, if not preferred.

I know there are a lot of text based websites and platforms for debate, but for all the power of the written word, it's just too arduous for me personally. I'm interested in the live discussion aspects and instantaneous feedback.

I spent some time searching recently and can only find text dialogues or academic debate teams. Does anyone know of a voice based solution? Thanks!


r/ideasforcmv • • Mar 28 '25

Can we ad a tag so we can filter out politcal posts?

11 Upvotes

I'm seriously tired of seeing the 1000th post for "CMV: Trump is bad because xxx reasons" or "CMV: Elon sucks because xxx". I understand that CMV is a place where poltiics are allowed, and I'm by no means suggesting to ban the discussion of political topics. But, can we add a political tag political posts are required to use?


r/ideasforcmv • • Mar 15 '25

Collectable CMV Cards Batch 2

11 Upvotes

disclaimer: Although I am a mod, I am making this post as a user. It is not anything official from the mod team. In fact, this post could get removed by other mods. (though, even if this were an official post it could get removed by other mods, but I digress)

Its been a while since batch 1 was released, but now you can finally get your hands on batch 2!


CMV collectible cards batch 2


Everything in the first post is pretty much true for this one, save the users I chose to make cards of. You may notice that this time around, its all moderators and no normal users.

The reason is, which I am a little embarrassed to admit, is that I have just not been as enmeshed in the community as I was when I made the 1st batch, so there were no non-mod users I was aware of that I wanted to make a card for. Ever since I became a mod, my time on CMV has been focused on working "the queue", which means I pretty much only see content that has been reported. Thus, any well contributing users escape my view. To be clear, this is mostly just a me thing, you'll see that a lot of other mods remain active as normal users in the community while volunteering as a mod.

With that said, if anyone wants a card made of themself, or wishes to nominate someone else from the community who you think deserves a card, please let me know! You can just drop their username in the comments, with any ideas for their card you think I should include (ie: signature move, area of expertise). Whatever info you don't include I will look up by stalking browsing their profile and history in CMV. The one thing I can't look up is past yearly, monthly, and weekly deltaboards, so if you or the nominated user have ever been on one of those you'll have to let me know to get that achievement.


What is the point of this?

Mostly its just a small way to honor members of the community who have contributed a lot. If there is interest, we (I and anyone who wants to help) could try to make rules for a game that you can play with these cards. An idea I've been toying with is making a random deck of "CMV posts" that you flip over 1 at a time, and players try to "win" the post by playing cards with high relevancy. For example, a post card on "Should congress pass x law" would give relevancy to cards with "Law" specialty or "US politics" specialty. If it has the attribute, "Lots of rule violations," cards with the moderator achievement gain relevancy. Another attribute could be, "Random deltas spotted!" where cards with the "Delta giver," award gain (or perhaps give to your opponents) relevancy. Whichever card has the highest relevancy wins that post (and for fair gameplay, you can't use that card again). In the case of a relevancy tie, whichever card has the highest delta count wins the post.