r/ideasforcmv • • Mar 09 '15

We need a complete overhaul of the current mod team.

5 Upvotes

These people are clearly unfit to moderate a sub dedicated to having a wide variety and clashing viewpoints.

1)/u/iamaN00bie is a given. He's heavily entwined in subs such as SRD and other SJW satellite subs that disallow ANY dissenting opinion.

He's also likely been associated with doxxing and other criminal activities, harassment and hate crimes are the main ones, but others as well.

2/u/cwenham and grunt08 are HIGHLY suspicious.

cwenham has been removing a bunch of submissions that he doesn't agree with, his account activity is suspect to say the least, and likely is running a few alts in some other meta subs.

Jesus Christ, are the other mods just sitting around with their thumbs up their asses? Do a little history check on these people before you blindly fucking mod them.


r/ideasforcmv • • Aug 05 '25

I think your credibility as moderators would be helped if you provided clearer justification for banning transgender people

1 Upvotes

The reason I am not using the appeal process for this is because I am not asking for an appeal. My post can stay removed.

The process for removal is very suspicious though:

  1. At first the post was allowed to stay up.

  2. After an hour or so, it was "removed by reddit's filters." I have never seen this happening to a thread that was active. The filters are usually applied at the time of posting.

  3. While the thread was filtered, two of my comments were removed for telling someone they were incorrect, including a user with fabricated quotations.

  4. After 9 hours, the thread was locked, citing rule B.

  5. The appeal process states that we cannot accuse you of bias because it violates Rule D, the same rule banning transgender discussion. This suggests to me that you have probably been accused of transphobia in the past, and your rule is to stifle discussion. This is consistent with the operating status of many subreddits since January 2025.

Feel free to remove this post, as its removal is evidence of your guilt.

EDIT: I searched through a few of the mods' opinions about feminism and trans people, and as I suspected, you are vocally pro-feminism at a time when feminism is loudest about hating trans women.


r/ideasforcmv • • Feb 05 '15

I think we should disable the downvote function on comments made by the OP only.

0 Upvotes

When someone starts a CMV post and as OP makes comments inside the post, most other people participating in that post views the OP as their adversary - the person they need to argue against. And these other people have a tenancy to over-zealously downvote the OP's comments.

It can be discouraging and frustrating to be an OP and see all your comments downvoted. I am certain that a random person making the very same comments wouldn't be downvoted to the degree that the OP is, because the OP is everyone's main target and other participants aren't. Everyone see's the Op's name highlighted in bold blue. Everyone knows they're there to change the OP's view, and when OP makes a comment that participants don't feel counters their own points well enough, they downvote the OP.

Again, it can be discouraging and frustrating to be an OP and see all your comments downvoted. It creates hostility and tension. It causes the OP to become more hostile and rude to other users, because the OP feels defensive, because his or her ideas are being downvoted far more harshly than anyone is used to. We're all used to downvotes, but not at the severity in which you receive them when you're the OP of a CMV thread.

I think the OP's comments throughout a CMV thread should be ineligible for downvotes. And maybe even upvotes - why not? If that's what the coding requires, I say we go for it. No votes at all for comments made by the OP.


r/ideasforcmv • • May 06 '22

Controversial topics should just be completely disallowed

0 Upvotes

Recently had my account banned for responding to a posters with an otherwise valid argument on a controversial topic. My comment wasn’t even controversial but I simply said that logically if you believe this then you also believe this (something any sane adult would not believe) and they reported me. And this is what most of these controversial post amount to: Traps.

The commenters/OPs goal isn’t to have a discussion or have a view change its to lure people into breaking the rules of Reddit and reporting them. This isn’t exclusive to this sub but since its a largely discussion based it has a major impact.

Reddit has already made its own conclusion on a lot of controversial issues and forced its user base to abide by that conclusion with banning as a consequence. The mods here are also pretty heavy handed. So when a user post a controversial topic (ex. Anything to do with transpeople) anyone trying to change the view enters at a severe disadvantage because a large portion of arguments are off limits. It’s also way too easy for the commenter or OP to steer the discussion to a place where someone says the “wrong”thing. On top of that most of the topics are repetitive and nothing new is ever added to the discussion and everyone just loses their mind

For me these topics are always the most interesting because it can spark good discussion but is often used maliciously.

I doubt mods would actually do this but I think that any controversial topic Reddit has come to a conclusion on or restricted should just be automatically disallowed because they are implicitly bad faith arguments whether OP means them to be or not


r/ideasforcmv • • Jan 30 '23

A new format so people don't always have to fight a 1v50?

1 Upvotes

Although a lot of good ideas come out through discussion on this sub, it is just way, WAY too demoralizing, stressful, and demanding to be the one who has to defend the view.

The biggest problems:

  • As I said, you're fighting a 1v50 here. It's you against basically the entire internet. Any responses of "I agree" or supporting your view are actually removed by mods, leading to OP inevitably feeling more isolated.

  • I realize an attempt was made to try and make these discussions less intense and more "conversational" with the description saying "enter with a mindset for discussion, not debate", but seriously, can we please stop kidding ourselves? CMV is 100% a debate sub, NOT a "discussion" sub, not even close. Nobody treats it like a discussion, and the sub itself has evolved in a way that normalizes this clear set of circumstances.

  • Every single reply by OP will be downvoted. Seriously. Even if your reply is reasonable, it is ALWAYS, ALWAYS, ALWAYS downvoted, which is, AGAIN, a clear sign that CMV is obviously not a "discussion" sub in the slightest, because why would anyone feel the need to downvote a simple reply in a discussion?

  • Especially after many dozens of replies have been submitted, people feel far more comfortable dunking on OP, really pushing the limits of what would be considered "rude and hostile". Because, why not? 98% of the people there are on your side, so clearly that must mean OP is so unbelievably wrong that it's okay to dunk on them a bit. It has happened with every single CMV I have submitted, that 10+ hours after I submit my post, I get later replies more along the lines of "wow you sure are an asshole / idiot for thinking this", not always phrased in that way, but honestly, sometimes, yeah. I DO get that. And sure, I can report it and you can remove it, but the damage is already done by that point. I've already been called an asshole and an idiot.

The biggest problem is that we allowed CMV to become an intense debate sub and we force OP to take on the full brunt of one side of a view. IMO we should create a more reasonable space where someone SUGGESTS a topic, and a MODERATOR posts the view (which is written by an anonymous person), and then anyone can chime in, for or against, without one person having to take on the full weight of the idea. That would be an infinitely healthier way of discussing things here.

This should be one of the best places on reddit to debate any issue, but it isn't, because of what OP is subjected to, being put on what is not just a "hot seat" but a chair literally made of molten lava, where anyone who sits there long enough WILL be destroyed, no matter how sound their opinion is. CMV has become a rather toxic place because of it, and I no longer have any interest in submitting any discussion topics there because I'm just fucking done dealing with the stress I endure by making a post. It's just not worth the pressure I have to deal with.

Also, this doesn't need to apply to every view. You can let people post like they have been. I just like the idea of adding an option where people can post their reply anonymously and are not themselves beholden to answering each and every criticism of the view.


r/ideasforcmv • • Feb 17 '26

CMV doesn't require OP to discuss in good faith

0 Upvotes

If an OP intentionally does not address everything in a comment and ignore arguments that should change their view, I think that shows they are not discussing in good faith. However, there are no consequences for this despite it going against the core tenant of the sub - substantive, good faith discussion.

There should be a way for commenters to easily know that replying to OP is a waste of time and they are not arguing in good faith, but no one can accuse of them acting in bad faith so people just waste their time.

It seems clear to me that a rule should be added that OP has to reply to every part of a comment, which I think would address this since OP can't ignore arguments by omission/pretending they don't exist.


r/ideasforcmv • • Oct 25 '25

CMV: CMV has gone off the rails, and needs moderator moderation

2 Upvotes

Two supporting pieces of evidence for this:

  1. Despite healthy content and debate, a higher percentage of new posts in CMV are deleted than any other subreddit I have been able to study.

  2. Reasons for removal are unclear. Certainly NOT for actual rules (the view, soapboxing, improper title, lack of OP interaction, etc).

  3. Rules (although valid) have lots of arbitrary issues.

Dunno why, but it seems that about 1/3 of all new posts are removed in short order, despite numerous and rigorous healthy debate, to/from the OP.

I'm also unclear as to the underlying existential reason for the sub.

I had ASSUMED it was prima facia: CMV exists for the purpose of debate whereby a poster is willing to have his/hear views challenged and possibly changed.

IF that is the actual reason for the sub, I'd submit that many/most of the aforementioned removed threads WERE substantially achieving the intended purpose.

I'm not saying there are NOT good/valid instances where this is needed, but it becomes a challenge to meaningfully contribute to the general goal of the thread if a high percentage of posts are deleted for unclear reasons.

I'd suggest:

  1. mod removal of posts require a reason for said removal

  2. post removal include clear reason. and it should be included in a meta about that post, so those involved in the post can understand why it was removed.


r/ideasforcmv • • Jan 28 '15

Downvoting OP responses: Is There A Way To Lock It?

0 Upvotes

We've all seen it, OP posts an unpopular opinion, and then as they respond to posts, they get downvoted to oblivion.

I don't care about the Karma aspect of it, but the downvoting also hides comments at a certain point (below whatever the threshold is), and makes following the discussion difficult, and in some cases, next to impossible.

I know that you can hide the arrows, but is there a way to actually disable downvotes for the first three hours (the time in which OP is required to actively respond), or is that a Reddit function that subs have no control over?


r/ideasforcmv • • Oct 02 '25

All Trump and Maga posts should be banned or severely limited from CMV.

4 Upvotes

The sheer volume of posts that boil down to "Trump/MAGA is racist" (or less frequently, Trump is not racist) is overwhelming. We get that some of you are basing your entire personality around hating (or more rarely on Reddit, loving) Trump, but people joined this sub for actual debate and conversation. If you genuinely want your views on Trump challenges whatever you are posting has already been done. You should just use the search function and start reading replies. If you don't genuinely want your view challenged, then you don't belong here, and I feel like these are the majority of Trump related posts.

If you look at any trump or Maga related post the rules violations are continuous. Name-calling. Top level comments that don't challenge. Top level comments that do challenge and are met with insults.

Honestly there is a topic fatigue rule for 48 hours, but they are all the same topic and they are done to death. Those of us actually interested in the original intent of this are drowning. Those of us who aren't American are fed up and over it.

So to change my view you would need to show me that CMVs about Trump or Maga actually contribute to meaningful discussion. You would need to show me that most posts and responses are novel and not just a rehash of the same ideas ad nauseum. You would need to show me that most posts aren't just people statinh their views with no willingness to change. Compare Delta numbers? Do Trump posts actually award an average number of deltas? Are they what I'll call technical deltas ("You changed my mind, I said trump hates immigrants, but really he hates brown immigrants. I've seen the light" -- isn't really changing your mind, it's just slightly refining your terms).


r/ideasforcmv • • Sep 16 '24

The moderators on this subreddit are too draconian about deleting posts.

2 Upvotes

The rule that posts are able to be deleted if two moderators agree that the poster's not flexible about having his/her view changed is too draconian.

I have had two posts deleted on important subjects that had dozens of comments to which I had responded. I was involved in active and productive dialogue with some of these commenters and then went to sleep, with the post being deleted.

A two-moderator consensus isn't a reliable one. Many famous academic breakthroughs have first been rejected by dozens of editors (let alone two).

It's very arbitrary deciding whether a poster's open to having his/her view changed. There are no clear guidelines. And when the post gets deleted, there are no examples given of infractions in the comments.


r/ideasforcmv • • Oct 11 '25

Mods who remove comments should have to do so from their actual account, not a generic 'cmvmodteam' account.

1 Upvotes

r/ideasforcmv • • Jul 11 '22

r/changemyview shouldn't have a Karma requirement or anything like that.

1 Upvotes

I have so many questions about certain controversial topics that I don't understand and I just want to talk to someone about them. But, nooooo.... because I don't have enough Karma, I can't talk to anyone about them. I can't post them on r/changemyview or r/unpopularopinion or r/TooAfraidToAsk or anywhere.

I genuinely want have discussions about my unpopular opinions but, I just get shut down because these places don't want to foster real discussion.

Why should CMV thread or others like it have a Karma requirement? Shouldn't we let anyone and everyone post things there? Even if their viewpoints are so controversial, wrong, or bigoted... shouldn't we allow them to discuss them and possibly change their views? Instead of just wallowing in their views never changing them?


r/ideasforcmv • • Jul 23 '22

CMV: Rule E ruins the fun of of CMV and should either be abolished or changed to 10 hours.

1 Upvotes

Rule E is imo one of the strictest rules I’ve seen and maybe even on all of Reddit. Knowing that we have to respond within 3 hours even with the exceptions mentioned seems stricter than it should. What do I want to do if I wanna sleep? Set an alarm for 3 hours just to keep the post up?

The other thing is knowing for my voice to stay heard, I have to respond within 3 hours or else our voice gets suppressed. I think it should be 10 hours at minimum; 8 so people can work and sleep working, and 2 to have that awake time to respond.

It gives off like it’s made for mods to give users a hard time and mods something to do. I am all game for be a hardass against ghosting and cowards, but the strictness of that rule ruins the purpose and fun of it because of what I said above. I have so many good cmv topics to bring up, but I feel like I have to do it on a weekend or else my post will be removed due to this Rule. It has me concerned.

Tl;dr: Rule E is unnecessary and should be changed to at least 10 hours or should be abolished in order for our voices to be more organic while still maintaining your initial purpose of making it in the first place.


r/ideasforcmv • • Nov 20 '24

The 24 hour rules and Fresh Topic Friday are unnecessary and a detriment to the subreddit.

1 Upvotes

This may be the hill I end up dying on. I've mentioned it several times (under various usernames) in the bi-monthly suggestions thread. First time I'm bringing it here.

There is a post at this moment with 50 comments in the first hours with the topic of "CMV: Abortion law exceptions for Rape and Incest make no sense".

Clearly, that is a very common topic (and I suspect it will eventually be deleted as a duplicate post violation). I'm confident there is a post with virtually that same title at least weekly on the subreddit.

Sometimes I'll be inspired to participate in this popular topics. Other times, I'm not in the mood for those topics. Today was one of the those not-in-the-mood days. So you know what I did? I passed by that topic without clicking on it!

Wild, right? It wasn't a topic I was personally interested in, so I skipped it. No need for that post to be deleted. No reason to silence the 50+ people who were interested in that post. Just me, making a personal decision, that I wasn't interested.

Seems to me that that's the solution to complaints about common topics. If it's not of interest to you, skip it! And if people did that, then there'd be no need for Fresh Topic Friday or the 24 hour rule. And the people who are interested in those topics when they're posted still get to enjoy them.

So my suggestion would be to eliminate, in their entirety, both FTF and the 24 hour rule. Then, if/when you get complaints from people about common topics, you could just tell them that they should skip topics that are not of interest to them.

If you want to take it a step further, you could even create a rule: "If a topic does not interest you, skip it." Then, if you get a complaint from someone about frequent topics, you could point to that rule, slap them with a rule violation penalty, and be done with it.

Eventually the chronic complainers will get banned for too many violations of the new rules, and the mods will never have to hear complaints about common topics again.


r/ideasforcmv • • Dec 17 '24

The rules need an overhaul to make it easier to have interesting discussion

1 Upvotes

I appreciate that there have to be rules, but a sub like this simply doesn't do what it says on the tin if a certain amount of discussion isn't allowed because one person isn't meeting the mods' expectations.

The idea that someone needs to 'demonstrate that they're open to changing their mind' is simply silly. Sorry, but it is. That's a feelings-based rule. The rule description even goes into great detail about how 'well nobody made a good argument' isn't an acceptable answer. That's extremely subjective. How can you possible demonstrate that in a clear, objective way? And even if you could, why should you need to? Sometimes, your mind isn't changed, that's OK.

Of course excessive 'soapboxing' should be discouraged but a rule that says 'mods decide if you're acting in good faith or not' makes no sense. As long as your tone is respectful, how is anyone hurt by this? And don't just say 'you're banned' and mute replies, that's juvenile.

You can't have discussion under strict conditions, there needs to be the capacity to respectfully disagree.

Also: change the trans rule. I don't care, change it.


r/ideasforcmv • • Dec 27 '22

CMVs and answers with arguments containing views which violate human rights should be removed, and a rule should be made about this.

1 Upvotes

I have recently come across this post, in which OP states that killing civilians in a war is fair.

I believe the vast majority of things are up to discussion and healthy debate, but there are limits on what can and cannot be expressed. Each nation and culture comes with its own set of laws and taboos, but the basic minimum in which pretty much all agree is registered in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.

Basically, an argument or view containing any violations to human rights is immediately harmful to a given discussion, because it expresses ideas contrary to inherent human dignity.

When I saw the post I did not know if I should have reported it, or ignored, because there is no rule letting me know if the sub os intolerant even toward these "seemingly unharmful" posts.

If the sub repudiates this, I suggest making it explicit so users can take care and action, and if there is no rule regarding the issue, I'd like to suggest considering creating one.


r/ideasforcmv • • Sep 16 '15

My posts on CMV are often misunderstood and strawmanned, if I clarify I am attacked, not sure how to improve

1 Upvotes

Making this post from a throwaway (obviously).

I love reading CMV threads and sometimes commenting on other people's posts, but I've tried making my own posts a couple times now and am really frustrated by the results. The problem seems to be that a large number of people assume they know what my position is, because it bears some cosmetic similarity to a more common position, then they attack that other position while ignoring what I actually said. Then when I try to respond clarifying my position so we can get the discussion back on track I am downvoted and people ignore my clarification in favor of attacking the strawman.

I try to be as precise as possible in stating my position in my original post. I put in statements like "What I am saying is X and Y, I'm NOT SAYING Z, Z doesn't follow from X and Y" but then I still get 20 comments saying "Z is obviously not true, here is the well-worn argument why" and it's pretty disheartening, especially because I'm then expected to wade through all these very similar statements replying "No, I didn't say Z" and getting downvoted on each one. Sometimes people accuse me of backtracking for citing my own OP to clarify my position. It really gets annoying because too many people make assumptions I never stated, that don't follow directly from my argument, then act like I'm being dishonest for disagreeing with those assumptions!

Oftentimes this will take a form where I will say something like "X is sometimes Y, so therefore..." and people will respond "So you're saying every X forever is always Y? That's so ridiculous, here's one X that's not Y, view disproven!" then when I say, "I didn't say all" they act like I'm changing my position.

Or I'll make a hypothetical syllogism, "If X is true, then Y follows" and I'll get a bunch of replies saying "X isn't true!" like that disproves my statement. I can't tell if these mistakes are from people not reading my OP carefully or if I'm somehow not being clear enough.

I don't totally blame people for this because I am sometimes posting about the sort of hot-button topics that have a lot of shit associated with them on CMV, like feminism and racism, so it's probably more tempting for people to assume they know what I'm saying, but it's frustrating when the community is misunderstanding me and I can't try to clarify without getting buried (I also don't understand why people compulsively downvote every OP comment in a thread; how is it irrelevant for the OP to state their opinion in light of comments? How is that going to help anyone change their minds?). And like I was saying, the sheer volume of misunderstandings makes it hard to participate in my own threads. When I'm bombarded by 15 top-level posts in an hour all saying basically the same thing (apparently without checking whether their point was already represented) and to top it off, all containing the same fundamental misunderstanding of my position, it makes me want to give up.

TL;DR presenting a nuanced position in CMV is frustrating because the majority of responses are mischaracterizations and strawmen repeating the same errors, and people are hostile to clarifying statements from the OP


r/ideasforcmv • • Jan 18 '15

I just started a new subreddit, /r/HelpMyArgument, which I think CMV'ers would like.

1 Upvotes

The purpose is to take a vague, unsubstantiated, or incoherent idea or "concept", and turn it into a cogent argument. It's at square one at the moment, and I'm hoping some people are interested in either participating or potentially modding at some point down the line.

I'd quite like to post this on the CMV sub itself, but wasn't sure if that would be okay, so I wanted to check here first.


r/ideasforcmv • • Oct 06 '16

Disable downvoting and use the amount of deltas awarded on a single post to rank responses

0 Upvotes

Upvotes should be reserved for the best arguments that were not awarded a delta, and a response that gets the most deltas should take priority regardless of how many upvotes it gets.

While the upvote system is shit in all of the subs, it is manageable in all of them except this sub. This sub hurts the most from this.

For posts and responses that are off-topic or troll it's better to report them, not downvote.


r/ideasforcmv • • Oct 16 '14

Why was my CMV about CMVs deleted by a mod and I was told to post here, while another CMV about CMVs was mod approved?

0 Upvotes

So one or two weeks ago, I posted a CMV about CMVs: http://www.reddit.com/r/changemyview/comments/2io4dg/cmv_i_think_its_condescending_and_erroneous_of/

Why was it deleted? Well it was because I was making a CMV about CMVs and to then post it here.

Today, I was just browsing the CMV subreddit and I found this CMV about CMVs: http://www.reddit.com/r/changemyview/comments/2j7gwy/cmv_i_think_many_people_posting_cmvs_dont/

Just wondering: why was my CMV deleted when his isn't? His is even mod approved. That is just bullshit and unfair so I'd like an explanation.


r/ideasforcmv • • Mar 12 '23

Create a pinned meta post (or something similar) with best posting practices on CMV

0 Upvotes

I completely understand CMV’s reasoning for it’s current posting requirements. However there are definitely additional guidelines where if OP were to follow them it would improve the discussion. (Sort of how there’s a lot of information on the wiki about best/ worst reply practices) To encourage those so inclined, CMV should create a pinned meta post where it clearly explains additional guidelines (op should state in their post if willing to follow them) for posting and replying as the OP.

Some examples might be:

  1. Stating the status and the exact changes in their viewpoint clearly in the post.

  2. Category’s for disagreement (the information is contested by experts, it isn’t actually applicable to my claim, this is more important) (this might make it easier to find what OP lacked in your argument)

  3. State the most extreme version of the viewpoint that you also believe (encourage true minor changes in viewpoints)

The mods definitely know what extra guidelines would work better than me. Additionally there might be some best practices.

Anyways I see no downsides, this wouldn’t effect those who have difficulty following directions or are barely able to meet CMV’s current requirements. But for those willing to read CMV’s rules and recommendations in detail and follow some more stringent standards that would lead to a better discussion it would clarify how to do this.


r/ideasforcmv • • Dec 25 '19

CMV needs to vet cringe out of the community more than micro-manage modding

0 Upvotes

I basically never use CMV because of these 2 reasons - It attracts cringy people, and the modding is so pedantic, combined with a vanity inspiring reward system. In a way perhaps it is the central idea 'change my view' that is toxic, I mean like, detracting away from 'lets find the best answer together'. Of course that's implicit, but to people who are cringe / tactless that is lost on them. I dunno. It seems really tribal. Maybe different vetting on the way you can state/ask. Of course the point of the sub is to attract ignorant people and change their view. It just seems to be overtaken by them en mass already.


r/ideasforcmv • • May 30 '19

Add something to the rules about not using metaphors

0 Upvotes

This is inspired by a recent post titled "Trump will never be arrested or see the inside of a courtroom."

Based on the text, we can tell that the "see the inside of a courtroom" is a metaphor, but the OP carries it through the rest of the post and actually makes it a little unclear.."No President has ever seen the inside of a courtroom [while] President or after without exception."

So they're saying that no president will ever go into a courtroom with their eye open ever again? Probably not, but their intention is needlessly unclear. Sticking to literal language has only benefits...e.g. "Trump will never be prosecuted for what he has done while in office"

I don't think this is important enough to be a headline rule, but seems like it would fit under A or maybe C.


r/ideasforcmv • • Jan 09 '15

Is it possible to allow (or is it allowed) to award a delta as a token of appreciation for good debating skills in CMV?

0 Upvotes

Exempli gratia

I agree with /u/BlinkingZeroes there, so I can't say that my view has been changed. The other poster (which I purposefully don't name because blaming people is not the point here) is, I feel, acting in bad faith.

I suppose we could just report users when they are being rude (which the other poster probably is), but I feel it would be even better if instead of (or as an added step to) punishing the offender, it would be nice if something positive could be done for those who try to understand and reason with even the rather rude users.

So my idea is to allow giving deltas for that based on this excerpt:

Please note that a delta is [...] just a token of appreciation towards a user

Then again, maybe it's a better idea to just report violators, I don't know.