r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Sep 02 '25

Meta r/hypotheticalphysics bingo

Post image
257 Upvotes

r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Jul 15 '25

Humor Here's a hypothesis: What if the solution to everything is (insert word salad)?

192 Upvotes

Think about it, if (insert word salad) is true (I didn't actually define what I meant), then we can (ad-hoc) solve everything. We merely need to assume two hundred extra spatial dimension, seven extra time dimensions, one extra dimension for obesity, and ignore all prior physics frameworks (because I don't understand them). Dark matter is just black people in space. Dark energy is made up of batman farts. The big bang was god having an orgasm. So that's my theory. The theory of everything is (redacted).


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Apr 26 '25

Meta What if we ban the LLM world salad posts on this sub?

143 Upvotes

Hi, I'm a physicist who used to enjoy checking this sub and contribute to the discussions. They used to be a little bit similar to the kind of discussions I used to have during late night afterparties in college. Aka quite fun, sometimes stupid, sometimes thought provoking.

Now the issue is that during the last year or so, this sub has become completely flooded with LLM mumbo jumbo that makes no sense. With this, I don't mean that the proposed physics itself makes no sense, but that the actual post is such a nonsensical salad of words that it's impossible to even comment on it.

Example of a reasonable discussion topic: What if dark matter is actually just gravity working differently at large distances / in different locations

Example of an LLM bullshit topic: What if gravity is actually a fractal phase space oscillation in the Einstein field equation momentum matrix

You get the idea. Now getting this kind of post every once in a while would be fine. Sure. But nowadays I feel like this is 90% of the posts. The problem is that when you point out that their post makes no sense, the OP will alway ask "which part is unclear?". Then, once you point out a random unclear part, they just post another response of the LLM. Probably without even reading it. That's not a way to have a discussion. If I want to talk to an LLM I can do that myself.

So how should address this issue? I'd be down to completely banning all LLM use at this point. Maybe that's too aggressive though. Perhaps we can at least ban LLM responses as comments? My point is mainly that the sub has become less enjoyable and it's worth discussing how to fix that.

I also want to add to this that I don't want to sound like an elitist here. I'm totally fine with posts not containing any math for example. Plenty of physics can be discussed to some level without math. It's the mumbo jumbo word salad I have issues with.

Thanks for reading. I guess this should get a meta tag or something along those lines.

Edit: topic is obviously meant to be word salad... Should have used an LLM to check it.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Apr 14 '22

Crackpot physics What if quantum mechanics is just the result of limited hardware capacity on which a simulation runs in which we live?

124 Upvotes

Hi, 

I am not a physicist and not a scientist, but I have been reading about quantum physics for some time. Looking at it from a very high level perspective I was wondering if you know if the following theory has been discussed by anyone yet.

I was thinking if Quants basically only behave in a statistical manner and it is theorized by the holographic theory that the whole universe might be a materialized kind of hologram which’s data is stored on a 2-dimensional „bubble“ that surrounds the universe, if this doesn’t highly speak for the fact that the universe as we know it is some kind of simulation.

I was imagining that let‘s say we had the ability to develop an artificial intelligence with the intelligence level of let’s say a human being and we want to put this artificial intelligence into a simulation of the universe and avoid that it will be able to find out it is in a simulation we would need to make sure that it will be able to look at everything until the smallest part. So first of all we would be starting by setting general rules within our simulation so for example how light spreads. We have one issue though, the capacity of our hardware in which we want to run the simulation is limited so we need to find ways to simplify things within our simulation so that general rules work.

So we program light to behave like a wave as we now many photons statistically will spread evenly around a room like a wave does and we avoid to force our simulation to calculate the path that every single photon takes as this would not be possible with the calculation possibilities our hardware has.

Now we know that our AI will at some point be able identify that things are made up of quants like everything is made of atoms, atoms are made of electrons etc., so we need to make it possible that these can be observed if the AI does so. And we cannot make everything consist of a wave as at some point we know that it would be inconsistent that something like a stone only consists of waves. So it needs to be observable.

In order to solve this problem every different class of quants consists of the same probability formula. In case the simulation detects that somebody is observing one of these parts based on this formula the actual status is calculated and the quant is displayed to the observer with the calculated status. Afterwards, is it forced to change its behavior to the behavior of a particle as it cannot just return to being a wave, because this would make the AI realize that something is off. By this the needed calculation capacity is only limited to parts that have been actually observed.

Coming to quantum entanglement it would mean that maybe our perception is wrong that the quants take the decision of their actual behavior and then it is transferred to the other quantum on some higher level, the process of entanglement itself is recognized by the system and within the code a certain constant is put in place that makes the quantum’s behave in the same way. So from the point of entanglement the actual wave function breaks down, but we won’t be able to know until we observe it as we cannot know until we observe it. (Has anyone ever tried sending only quantum’s through a double slit that are all 100% already entangled and looked at the result? I don’t actually know) Let’s say this would be kind of a bug which is not planned as by accident the entanglement is recognized as an observation by the system.

It could also be that the information is just stored on a higher level and then transferred to the other quant in the second of observation, which would be possible because they are not actually in a separate place from a hardware perspective. The speed of light as a limit would only hold true within the simulation itself so within the transfer of observationable information within the simulation, which could again be due to technical limitations. (As we can’t possibly know on which kind of hardware the simulation runs it’s not possible to know, but let’s imagine the graphics card is just not able to process the movement of light/the enlightenment of something faster than with the speed of light) 

Besides that I have some additional ideas on this theory. Let’s say we want to program something like gravity we also have to possibilities. Let’s say we have programmed the whole universe within a kind of square coordinate system and know we want to provide gravity to objects that are close to a mass.

Either we could program every object to be able to communicate with surrounding objects and to let them know it’s mass so they can calculate how they need to move based on the gravity induced by that mass and based on the own mass etc.) this would mean again that every object in the universe would need to calculate its own moving pattern basically all the time, which would again cost a lot of capacity from a calculation perspective. Instead we can make it easier for us: we can just program an objects mass to influence the squared field around it in a certain way and force objects to always move on straight lines within this field. By that gravity is simply programmed without taking to much capacity and this would as far as I understood resolve in the space time bending that is basically caused by any mass. 

Coming to black holes, within the simulation once running we will not be able to just delete stuff and redo it as it will get to complicated to basically delete all traces of what has been happening. But sometimes we will need to change or refurbish something maybe even resolve a bug. So black holes somehow remind me of the garbage collector which I learned about in some programming language. By introducing them we are on one hand easily able to create the paths in which galaxies are moving and avoid that everything is drifting around and also provide an explanation to this behavior to the observer and on the other hand we would be able to delete stuff that we do not want to have in the simulation anymore. Apparently it is random what is radiated by a black whole but it could also be exactly what is needed to do reconstruction within the simulation. 

So I don’t know as said I am not a scientist but that’s what I was thinking. Maybe it’s also just the way my brain tries to grab the fascinating way quants behave and other unexplainable things in the universe works as somehow it would theorize a modern version of god. But I would be really interested in knowing what a real physicist would think about this. (And if you reply maybe you could try to explain it to me in simple terms) 

So thank you in advance!


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Nov 15 '24

What if there was a theory of every pseudoscience?

Post image
123 Upvotes

r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Dec 18 '25

Humor What if duty calls? r/hypotheticalphysics reaches 20k!

Post image
116 Upvotes

r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Apr 01 '26

News! (April's fools) [Meta] Important: Reddit is requesting the immediate closure of this sub

109 Upvotes

As many of you have likely noticed, Reddit has continued expanding its use of community-generated content for training internal and partner AI systems. While this has been discussed broadly across the platform, more niche communities such as ours have recently come under scrutiny.

Earlier today, we received a formal communication from Reddit administration stating that r/hypotheticalphysics and r/llmphysics have been flagged as a “high-risk dataset[s].” The reasoning provided is that these subreddits' content are actively influencing the performance of their AI models.

According to the notice, continued operation of the subreddits “poses a measurable threat to model accuracy in domains relating to classical mechanics, quantum theory, and, regrettably, basic arithmetic.” As a result, Reddit has requested the immediate and permanent closure of the community.

From the mod team’s perspective, this places us in a rather unique position. While we fully support the advancement of science and technology, we were previously under the impression that confidently misunderstanding physics was a cornerstone of scientific progress, not a liability.

After internal discussion, the mod team has reached the following conclusions:

  • We acknowledge that the average post on this subreddit may, in fact, violate several known laws of physics simultaneously.

  • We reject the assertion that this is a problem, rather than the entire point of the community.

  • We are, however, apparently powerful enough to negatively influence billion-dollar AI systems, which we consider a significant achievement.

At this time, we have been given the choice to either shut down voluntarily or have the moderation team replaced by individuals “aligned with data quality objectives.” While we do not fully understand what that means, we assume it involves fewer consciousness posts.

Therefore, effective immediately, r/hypotheticalphysics will be closing indefinitely in compliance with Reddit’s request and in the interest of preserving whatever remains of modern artificial intelligence.

Lastly, we apologize to our members for the abrupt nature of this decision. We recognize that many of you were on the verge of scientific breakthroughs. Please rest assured that your work has not gone unnoticed and will remain archived here but posting will no longer be allowed.

Thank you all for your contributions, your creativity, and your unwavering commitment to being confidently incorrect.

Best regards,

the r/hypotheticalphysics and r/llmphysics mod team

Edit: I hope you all had a Happy April’s fools day!


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • May 21 '25

Humor Here is a hypothesis: The Lagrangian is invariant under puppy/kitten transformation, and thus this is the true model of the universe.

Post image
108 Upvotes

r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Oct 04 '21

Crackpot physics What if time were in reverse, would we know it?

108 Upvotes

This began with a question about consciousness.

If time were in reverse, would we know it?

Played forward, we die believing time moves forward.

Played in reverse, we begin to live (un-die) believing time moves forward, and we continue to believe this until we dissolve in the womb.

Our entire lives, in a universe in which time flows backwards, we would believe that time flows forward.

This leads to the question, is time flowing backwards right now? And another: is it possible to know whether this isn't the case?

Consider if the following were true:

All time exists simultaneously.

The present moment is shaped by our consciousness, which remembers the past and cannot see or "remember" the future.

Each present is unique, encoded by it's specific past.

Significantly, we distinguish the present from the past by our memory of the past's future, a knowledge which is hidden from the past.

It's significance makes it relevant, and it's relevance defines the unique sensation of presence.

If we could remember the future, the present (specifically it's sensation) would therefore cease to exist.

Without distinction from the past, the present would lose it's significance, and thus it's relevance, and thus it's unique sensation. We would cease to feel time at all.

And now, a question about entropy.

The second law of thermodynamics:

All organized systems tend toward disorganization.

But could it be simultaneously true that all disorganized systems tend toward self-organization?

If you reverse entropy, time, as we entropics know it, would appear to flow backwards. Knowledge would be mirrored and so too the knowledge that we live in a physical reality defined by the existence and truth of the second law.

My main question follows:

Could it be that we are in a constant state of forgetting the future BECAUSE of self-organizing systems' ("reverse entropy's" affect on consciousness)?

And then the question: Why would this be the case?


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Jul 20 '25

Crackpot physics Here is a hypothesis: Photons actually have a TINY amount of mass which solves 2 big mysteries in physics.

93 Upvotes

This sub just popped up in my feed for the first time and I figured I would share my crackpot theory.

As a bit of background, this was in 2011 and I made my first trip to Amsterdam. Well, as one does when in Amsterdam I had to sample the local baked goods. I stopped into a local establishment and got myself a space cake. I’m a lightweight and figured it hit me hard so I should eat it back in the safety of my hotel room. This turned out to be a good call. It took almost an hour to kick in, but when it did, it just kept going and going and going. I was high as hell and started to get very tired. I passed out in my bed with the only English channel on the TV which was CNN. It was the night that Kim Jung Ill died so I was absorbing that non-stop in my sleep.

At some point my mind switched over and decided to solve the mysteries of the universe. My mind came up with the idea that photons actually have the smallest amount of mass to them. Like just a Planck mass. Think of a photon as a structure like a tiny ping pong ball and the mass is not evenly distributed. It all sits on one side of the particle. Imagine you injected a touch of water through the hole of a ping pong ball and then freeze it where it sticks to the inside and makes the ball slightly lopsided.

Now when this photon particle is traveling at the speed of light, it is still a particle but it is spinning like crazy. When viewed from the side, the lopsided nature of this would have the photon out of balance and the path would look like a wave. This slight bit of mass would explain the duality of the particle / wave nature of light while being extremely hard to measure such a small mass.

Now as a consequence of this mass, it would explain the mystery of dark matter. All of light floating around between stars and galaxies would add up to a lot of mass out there that we cannot see or detect. Photons traveling between 2 stars in an image would be undetectable to us unless it interacts with something in between them and that applies for all directions for every star out there. That is A LOT of undetectable mass. How much? No idea. I’m no physicist but I am ready to receive my Nobel prize in physics when this is all finally verified.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Feb 15 '21

Crackpot physics What if the "speed limit of the universe", AKA the speed of light, is actually dictated by the escape velocity of our own specific black hole universe?

89 Upvotes

Assuming the black hole cosmology theory is accurate, that is.

This could mean that exceeding your own universe's speed limit will break you out of your own universe and into a parent universe.

The kicker is that the more mass which goes into a black hole universe, the higher its escape velocity, and therefore, the higher its speed of light.

Edit: I'm not necessarily saying that it's actually possible for matter to exceed the speed of light. If anything, this idea could explain why such a rigid and specific limit does exist in the first place; in order to keep you in your original universe. More I think about this, though, the more I think the idea belongs in something like r/shower thoughts or r/writingPrompts rather than in the context of scientific discussion, since there's no way science would be able to prove something like this any time remotely soon.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Nov 18 '21

Crackpot physics What if the universe expands like a rubber band?

88 Upvotes

Since energy cannot be created or destroyed the universe will one day have to stop expanding. In this hypothesis the universe is expanding much like a rubber band would, and will eventually slow down as its limits are reached. My contention is that once the universe reaches the limits of its expansion one of two things will happen:

  1. The universe acting like a rubber band will snap back into itself and time will reverse. Eventually going back to a singularity before expanding again.

  2. The universe acting like a rubber band will snap into two, creating another dimension. The two dimensions now will act in the way that scenario one does and snap back before expanding again.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Aug 31 '24

Humor What if there were a cartoon that summarized most of the hypotheses posted on this subreddit?

Post image
84 Upvotes

r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Apr 30 '21

What if you had a large enough mirror placed far enough away from earth and a powerful enough telescope, would you be able to see living dinosaurs?

83 Upvotes

r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Jan 05 '25

Crackpot physics Here is a hypothesis: The laws of physics are NOT the same in all inertial frames.

72 Upvotes

The results of an experiment are given below that show a distinct difference between inertial frames. The effect is greater than 5 sigma significance and so meets the formal definition of discovery, challenging the long held notion that the laws of physics are frame invariant.

Experiment

It is well known that cosmic rays can decay into pions in the upper atmosphere. These in turn rapidly decay to muons that travel onwards towards earth. The muons reaching earth will have relativistic velocities by necessity, as the muon half-life (1.56 μs) is too short to survive to earth without time dilation. These relativistic particles make an excellent candidate for our experiment - we will measure the flux of relativistic muons in two different inertial frames.

Set-up

A PVT-2,5-diphenyloxazole scintillating block is coupled to a photo-multiplier unit. Incident rays within the block will produce a pulse of light that is then recorded by the photo-multiplier unit. Other sources such as cosmic rays can also excite flashes of light in the scintillator. To ensure we only measure specific muon events, we will look for the signature of a muon coming to rest and decaying in the scintillating block. This event will produce a signature double flash from first the kinetic energy being absorbed, followed by the decay event. These events can then be computationally analysed to give the flux of muons that were within appropriate velocity profile to come to rest in the scintillating block. Allowing the experiment to run for 1 hour yielded our benchmark value: a muon event rate of 0.64(3) per minute.

Changing reference frame

The above set up was conducted in the lab frame. We now couple our equipment to a layer of hexahydro-1,3,5-trinitro-1,3,5-triazine in order to rapidly impart a constant (within air-resistence) velocity to the equipment. When the layer was activated the velocity profile of the equipment was 250(80) m/s with respect to the lab frame (measured using radar doppler shift). In this reference frame the equipment recorded no events. Further more, once the equipment reached the extent of the lab, it encountered a boundary condition that returned it to the lab frame velocity profile. Curiously, the no-events-effect persisted even when returned to the lab frame. After 1 hour of observations an overall rate of 0(0) events per minute was recorded.

This is a significant difference from the lab frame result. The result can not be explained by applying a Lorentz boost. I appreciate the need for repeat experiments to confirm this result. However, due to unforeseen circumstances I do not currently have access to the lab, so can not repeat the result at this time.

Happy to take any questions.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Mar 18 '25

Meta Theories of Everything only allowed on weekends.

66 Upvotes

After a little pow-wow, we've decided to try another limit to posting.

As it is, and with the advent of the large language models (LLMs), the sub is getting flooded by one Theory of Everything (TOE) after another. This is not what the sub is supposed to be about, and it's killing good discussions, and -- we fear -- will ultimately drive out the physicists from the sub. Without the physicists, we'd be just another r/holofractal.

Killing good discussions? A layperson, AI-generated TOE is a form of low-effort posting. On the other hand, to challenge it 'seriously' basically means explaining all of known physics to the layperson. This is a HUGE effort to anyone who wants to have a go at it. See the imbalance here? The crackpots have a forum for airing their LLM chats, yet no-one in their right minds can be assumed to go through the trouble to actually make the threads worthwhile (as in educational), or interesting. Combine this with the fact that most LLM-posters are posting in bad faith -- in other words, unwilling to listen to corrections or challenges, unable to look for a mutual understanding.

On the other hand, we don't want to be the ones to dismiss the next Nobel theory!

So, we'll try this. TOEs are allowed only on weekends (saturdays and sundays). This is tentative at first -- if it doesn't work out the way we hope, we'll take it away.

Comments welcome.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Nov 08 '21

Crackpot physics What if we could model a Quantum State using Purely Imaginary Numbers?

63 Upvotes

Hi! I(19M) have been doing some experimental studies with modelling quantum states through alternate mathematics using imaginary numbers without complex numbers(i.e. attempting to solve for sqrt(-x) rather than factor out sqrt(-1)). I think I've come up with a pretty interesting way to model relativity with pure mathematics and would love to engage with others so that I may further develop it. I know this is long, but I've lived my life asking these questions and this is what I've got so far!

From my understanding(and feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, I love to learn!), relativity suggests that light is released in quanta, which are little bits/packets of energy. These quanta for light are called photons, and they carry the electromagnetic force according to the standard model of particle physics. Similarly, I understand that light is expressed both as a line(constant vector quantity in linear algebra) and a wave and a photon would then be correlative of a point in Space with a constant instantaneous velocity. From my best attempt at conceptualizing the above, I am led to believe that we may then use imaginary numbers independently of complex compositions, but specifically for the pattern, they follow in iteration to model the movement of a wave function such as light/Energy.

The idea is this, according to Einstein's theory of General Relativity, we could detect whether or not a particle or force exists based on the presence of its Energy. In fact, the Standard Model of Particle physics defines the fundamental different Energies that makeup reality. Mass is gained from the Higgs field, the electromagnetic force from photons, W and Z bosons carry the Weak force, and gluons carry the strong force/gravity. Since those can all be defined in terms of Energy, perhaps our solution would come not from studying different forces and particles, but rather considering them all proofs of the existence of light! After all, E=mc2, and so rather than convert mass to energy, allow us to consider the existence of Energy proof of the existence of Light beside any given object or force in the Universe.

That may sound like a crazy idea, but crazy ideas tend to create discussions that lead to crazy knowledge. What if we considered Energy to be the rate at which Light is displaced? The viscosity of an object's Energy would be the very viscosity of its existence, contained inside its potential energy thanks to mass and momentum. At a certain point, specifically, the speed of light, mass and momentum are the same relative to a photon. This led me to a question, how much energy is from mass, and how much from momentum? In order to contextualize that, I had to crack open Newton and Einstein, only to realize that for a photon, it doesn't matter! Newton's expression of F=MA was simply reworded by Einstein with a constant frame of reference for acceleration. A photon has a constant speed, and therefore a constant Energy gained from momentum(c2). Could we then define the mass of an object by the Energy it carries from one point in time to the next? That would mean breaking down a unit of Time, specifically Planck Time. Planck's constant converts a photon's Energy to the Frequency of its wave function, and the frequency tells us the instantaneous Energy, we just haven't yet figured out how to do so!

Appropos of that, Could we, hypothetically factor the square root of negative one into positive one multiplied by negative one, in addition to being equal to i. Why would we break it down into an expression that multiplies to a negative one? Simply put, this helps to represent the wave function! Positive one represents the peak, and negative one represents the trough, and the square root of negative one is equal to the distance between them, an imaginary number known as i! Rather than consider a constant definition of i, I hope to prove a relative one, but to do so I must show the rate at which the constant definition is relative. In short, consider the square root of negative one to be a unit of Planck Time. It can be broken down into an infinite number of iterations of i where it will always be equal to +1 when the wave function is observed at its peak, -1 when the wave function is observed at the trough, and i or -i depending on whether the function is increasing or decreasing by a rate of i. This rate is equal to the Energy of the photon being observed, and therefore constant, but I find this to be the case only for the number one. Each imaginary number is unique because it's relative to the number being squared. In our case, the peak and trough are 1, but for the square root of negative nine, for example, the peak and trough would be at plus or minus three. This is best expressed as a new set of numbers, separate from the complex set, known as the pure imaginary numbers!

One is a very useful number in this set because it represents the identity property, as well as the movement of Light, or a photon. I've found a decent approximation of the square root of negative one to be equal to the sin of (-xpi/2), or rather a negative quarter rotation about the x-axis. This is very similar to what imaginary numbers represent in the complex plane anyways, and that's because, to my understanding, they're multiplicative instances of this rotation. However, I want to see if we can define a plane with exponential instances of this rotation since imaginary numbers follow the same patterns as a wave function!

Take for instance this blank graph of the function sin(-xpi/2). The hypothesis is that we can consider said wave function as a rotation about the x-axis, inverting in polarity as it moves to the right. Polarity in this sense is simply whether the distance from Y=0 is positive or negative. The reason the units aren't labelled is that we're going to suppose that the X-axis is iterations of the value i, beginning with i**0 and ending at i**5. As long as we know the change in Y from i**0 to i**1, we would be able to calculate the value of i, since i*1=i! If the Y-axis consists of real numbers, then the point of intersection is zero, and the trough and crest of the function are at positive and negative one. Simply put, if we knew the length from the starting position at *i0 to position i, could we consider the other intervals of the graph as rotations of such curve?

I reached a bit of an issue here honestly, and so I had to write my way out, and that meant "defining my own mathematics", which is of course subject to peer review, as well as my own development. In addition to the set of pure Imaginary numbers, I've been experimenting with a set of Impossible numbers, consisting of all real numbers when divided by zero. These numbers are, of course, impossible, and have no Real equivalent, hence why it made sense for them to be defined as a separate set of numbers. In Set notation, I believe this is written as I={1/0, 2/0, 3/0... n/0}. With that set of numbers, I did some experimenting with dividing imaginary and impossible numbers, and I found that when you divide an imaginary number by an impossible number, you get an oddly useful fraction, among other unique properties involving infinities I'm more than happy to go in detail over.

Take for instance the square root of the negative number n, which for now we'll write as ni, and consider the superscript a form of notation and not exponentiation(yet!). If we were to divide the imaginary number ni by the impossible number n0 again noting the exponentiation as the class of numbers to which n belongs to. Such division would give (ni/1)*(0/n) thanks to the division of fractions being equal to the multiplication of the reciprocal of the divisor, which yields the number (0/n).

This number, (0/n), seems to yield no real significance. After all, it is just equal to zero for most values of n. However, when defined as the set of all Improbable numbers, in={0/1, 0/2, 0/3... 0/n}, they become exceptionally useful for calculating the distance from i0 to i1! These numbers are fractional compositions of zero, equal to various lengths away from zero as the divisors increase. Using these Improbable numbers, I've been experimenting with their use in calculating the distance away from zero of a value of i. Specifically, Improbable numbers, while equal to zero, are a Real point with a distance away from zero, equal to the inverse of the value n. Basically, the point 0/2 is 1/2 a unit away from 0, but technically equal to zero! Such is true for any value of n!

This is all hypothetical, and also getting excessively long, and I'm sorry, but there is still so much more that I've been studying which I hope to unite into a common theory of Everything(ambitious, but there's no chance of it happening if I don't try!). In particular, I've been studying the propagation of Light through a prism, and studying how the number of reflections changes based on the viewing angle, and attempting to correlate that to the shadow of a light source placed at the viewing angle. With any luck, I'll be able to take the dimensions and luminosity of the shadow cast by the light in order to calculate the actual mass of the prism. It's taxing and I don't expect it to be solved today, but I figure it'd be good to ask Reddit about my ideas as I've started to study them more thoughtfully and attempt to articulate them more accurately. I am always looking to learn and my education has been haphazard and mostly self-guided, and so I am always looking for something new to learn and new feedback to understand and incorporate into my work!


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Feb 05 '22

what if a flashlight traveling through space facing backwards (turned on) is going faster than the speed of light what happens to the light? thank you, long car trip disagreements lol

61 Upvotes

r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Sep 15 '25

Meta Here is a hypothesis: No one posting a hypothesis is a physicist.

60 Upvotes

Seriously. Every post is tagged with "Crackpot Physics".


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • May 05 '25

Meta [Meta] Temporary rule: No LLM hypotheses during May

51 Upvotes

According to last poll, 80% of the voters consider that we should remove LLM-generated hypotheses. We are going to implement the "NO LLM-generated post" to see if it works until the end of May.

This is about hypotheses that are evidently made using LLM (chatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok) due to formatting. More elaborate post where LLM's were used for grammar cannot be detected easily.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Aug 08 '21

Crackpot physics What If consciousness is caused by a Boson particle in the brain?

51 Upvotes

So super string theory says there exists a supersymetry between the Fermions (Matter Particles) and Bosons (Force Particles). Bosons are the interaction between Fermions However scientists have not been able to find some of these particles, but what if the problem is they are looking in the wrong place. What if consciousness and subconsciousness arise from a Boson particle? Could these sub atomic particles exist only in life forms and that be the reason we haven't yet proved their existence? The current known forces of nature are; gravity, magnetism, weak nuclear force, and strong nuclear force. Gravity is predicted to be cause by a hypothetical boson particle called a Gravitron. Could the brain have force particles interacting with the brain matter?


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Jul 21 '26

Crackpot physics Here is a hypothesis: The Earth is ROUND, and revolves AROUND the Sun.

50 Upvotes

13 yo independant researcher here.

Okay, I know this sounds crazy, but I had a thought when I was out today. I was looking at the horizon over a lake and I noticed something. It seemed to me like it curved a little bit.

It struck me.. what if the Earth is actually an oblate spheroid?

I was left stunned. I pulled on this thread and it unravelled.

I noticed the Sun and thought 'Wait.. what if the SUN is round too?'

That made me kinda think. The sun is probably huge right, with the amount of heat it gives off and.. probably if it's a huge spheroid, and earth is a small spheroid, it would make sense that earth goes around the sun!

Does anyone know if there are any theories that explain our solar system in this way? I know it's a stretch but I think I'm on to something.

Thanks y'all.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Oct 26 '25

Meta What if we can illustrate why the "concept-first" approach doesn't work when creating novel physics?

50 Upvotes

It's quite clear from many, many posts here that pop culture and pop science leads lay people to believe that physics research involves coming up with creative and imaginative ideas/concepts that sound like they can solve open problems, then "doing the math" to formalise those ideas. This doesn't work for the simple reason that there are effectively infinite ways to interpret a text statement using maths and one cannot practically develop every single interpretation to the point of (physical or theoretical) failure in order to narrow it down. Obviously one is quickly disabused of the notion of "concept-led" research when actually studying physics, but what if we can demonstrate the above to the general public with some examples?

The heavier something is, the harder it is to get it moving

How many ways can you "do the math" on this statement? I'll start with three quantities F force, m mass and a acceleration, but feel free to come up with increasingly cursed fornulae that can still be interpreted as the above statement.

F=ma

F=m2a

F=m2a

F=ma2

F=m sin(a/a_max), where a_max is a large number

F=(m+c)a where the quantity (ca) is a "base force"

N.B. a well-posed postulate is not the same thing as what I've described. "The speed of light is constant in all inertial frames" is very different from "consciousness is a field that makes measurement collapses". There is only one way to use the former.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Jun 02 '25

Meta [Meta] New rules: No more LLM posts

50 Upvotes

After the experiment in May and the feedback poll results, we have decided to no longer allow large langue model (LLM) posts in r/hypotheticalphysics. We understand the comments of more experienced users that wish for a better use of these tools and that other problems are not fixed by this rule. However, as of now, LLM are polluting Reddit and other sites leading to a dead internet, specially when discussing physics.

LLM are not always detectable and would be allowed as long as the posts is not completely formatted by LLM. We understand also that most posts look like LLM delusions, but not all of them are LLM generated. We count on you to report heavily LLM generated posts.

We invite you all that want to continue to provide LLM hypotheses and comment on them to try r/LLMphysics.

Update:

  • Adding new rule: the original poster (OP) is not allowed to respond in comments using LLM tools.