r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Dec 29 '24

Crackpot physics What if, the Secret to UFO Physics Defying Acceleration Has Been Discovered

5 Upvotes

It is often reported that UFOs are seen accelerating at physics defying rates that would crush the occupants of the craft and damage the craft themselves unless the craft has some kind of inertia negating or inertial mass reduction technology,

I have discovered the means with which craft are able to reduce their inertial mass and it is in keeping with a component reported to be in the “Alien Reproduction Vehicle” as leaked by Brad Sorenson/Mark McCandlish and Leonardo Sanderson/Gordon Novel.

After watching the interview with Lockheed Senior Scientist Boyd Bushman where he claimed two repulsively coupled magnets having a free-fall rate slower than an ordinary object and a Brazllian team who claimed the same as well as two attractively coupled magnets having a free-fall rate faster than gravity I decided to gather experimental evidence myself and get to the bottom of whether gravitational mass and/or inertial mass is being negated which had not yet been determined.

I conducted experiments with five different objects in my Magnet Free-Fall Experiment – Mark 1:

  1. A Control composed of fender washers that were stacked to the same thickness as the magnets.

  2. Two attractively coupled magnets (NS/NS) falling in the direction of north to south pole.

  3. Two attractively coupled magnets (SN/SN) falling in the direction of south to north pole.

  4. Two repulsively coupled magnets (NS/SN).

  5. Two repulsively coupled magnets (SN/NS).

Of the five different objects, all but one reached acceleration rates approximately that of gravity, 9.8 meters/second2 and plateaued as recorded by an onboard accelerometer at a drop height of approximately seven feet. The NS/NS object however exceeded the acceleration rate of gravity and continued to accelerate until hitting the ground. Twenty five trials were conducted with each object and the NS/NS object’s acceleration averaged 11.15 meters/second2 right before impacting with the ground.

There are three hypotheses that could explain the NS/NS object’s higher than gravity acceleration rate:

  • The object’s field increases its gravitational mass causing it to fall faster.

  • The object’s field decreases its inertial mass causing it to fall faster.

  • The object’s field both increases gravitational mass and decreases inertial mass causing it to fall faster.

To determine if gravitational mass is being affected I placed all four magnet objects minus the control on a analytical balance (scale). If gravitational mass is being increases by the NS/NS object’s field then it should have a higher mass than the other magnet objects. It did not, all magnet objects were virtually identical in mass.

Ruling out gravitational mass as a possibility I drew the conclusion that the NS/NS object moving in the direction of north to south pole is experiencing inertial mass reduction which causes it to fall faster than the other objects.

Let’s revisit Boyd Bushman for a second. Perhaps Bushman lied. Bushman was privy to classified information during his time at Lockheed. It stands to reason he could have been aware of inertial mass reduction technology and how it worked. Bushman of course could not reveal to the world this technology as it would have violated his NDA.

Perhaps Bushman conducted his experiment with two attractively coupled magnets and a control rather than two repulsively coupled magnets and a control. With no accelerometers on his drop objects nor a high speed camera recording how long it took for each object to reach the ground he had no data to back up his claims, just visual confirmation at the ground level by the witnesses to the experiment who merely reported which object hit the ground first.

Perhaps Bushman was hoping someone in the white world like a citizen scientist would conduct an exhaustive experiment with all possible magnet configurations and publish their data, their results.

Now, back to the ARV. The ARV reportedly had what appeared to be an electromagnetic coil like a solenoid coil at its mid-height around the circumference of the craft. A solenoid coil has a north and south pole. It stands to reason the ARV used the reported coil to reduce its inertial mass enabling much higher acceleration rates than a craft without inertial mass reduction could take.

It is also possible that the coil enables the ARV to go faster than the speed of light as it was reported to be capable of. It is my hypothesis that inertial mass is a result of the Casimir effect. Quantum Field Theory posits that virtual particle electron/positron pairs, aka positronium, pop into existence, annihilate, and create short range, short lived, virtual gamma ray photons. The Casimir effect has been experimentally proven to be a very short range effect but at high acceleration rates and speeds the fast moving object would encounter more virtual photons before they disappear back into the vacuum. With the craft colliding with more and more virtual photons the faster it goes, its mass would increase as m=E/c2.

While an electromagnetic coil cannot alter the path of photons, it can alter the path and axis of spin of charged particles like electrons and positrons. If pulsed voltages/currents are applied to the coil rather than a static current even greater alterations to charged particles can be achieved. So, the secret to the coil’s ability to reduce inertial mass on the craft is that it alters the axis of spin of the electron/positron pairs before they annihilate so when they do annihilate the resultant short lived virtual photons do not collide with the craft and do not impart their energy to the craft increasing the craft’s mass.

So there you have it, the secret to inertial mass reduction technology, and likely, traveling faster than the speed of light.

I will keep all of you informed about my inertial mass reduction experiments. I intend to provide updates biweekly on Sunday afternoons.

Thanks for reading,

RFJ


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Mar 23 '25

Crackpot physics What if spacetime is made from hyperbolic surfaces?

Post image
0 Upvotes

6 clipped hyperbolic surfaces overlapped at different orientations forms a hollowed out cuboctahedron with cones at the center of every square face. The black lines are the clipped edges.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Aug 09 '22

What if you held a stationary object in a portal?

0 Upvotes

First time posting anything and I only just discovered this subreddit, so forgive any weirdness on my part. My question requires a bit of setup:

Say you have two machines: One is a sword handle that can open a portal (connected to the second machine) where the blade should meet the guard, the other is a contraption holding a one ton metal block with a sword blade sticking out the top. When the second machine detects a portal from the first machine opens at the preset spot, it lifts the block so that the sword blade goes most of the way through without actually touching any part of the portal.

(To clarify, I think these would be wormholes? Not sure of the full ramifications of that, I'm not a physicist)

Basically, you use portals to make a fancy retractable sword. Pretty simple in concept, even if the actual technology is a long ways away. So, my question is this: what happens if you hit something with it?

Because as far as your arm is concerned, you're swinging around a bladeless handle. So if you try hitting a tree with the blade, would you feel resistance? And if you do feel resistance, what is resisting you? But if you don't feel resistance, then will the blade just cleave through like it's nothing?


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Feb 28 '25

Crackpot physics Here is a hypothesis: The Big Bang as a transfer of energy from a parallel universe.

0 Upvotes

What if the Big Bang is the result of our universe (Universe A), which had little to no energy, colliding with another active universe (Universe B)? Like two balls crashing into each other, the impact transferred energy from B to A, sparking everything we know as the Big Bang.

The speed of light might even represent the amount of energy transferred


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Nov 16 '25

Crackpot physics What if our universe is an Eternal Loop Inside a 4D Hypersphere (Big Bounce Cycle)?

0 Upvotes

Recently, we were talking about how the universe might have begun and realized something interesting: maybe it didn’t have a beginning at all. We ended up imagining a model where the universe is part of a 4-dimensional hypersphere that naturally loops back into itself. Because of this geometry, the universe would: • expand -> • eventually curve back into itself -> • collapse -> • “bounce” (Big Bounce) -> • and start expanding again And this entire process repeats.

The idea broken down:

  1. Space isn’t infinite or flat, it’s the 3D surface of a 4D hypersphere Meaning: • there’s no edge, no boundary • no “outside” or “inside” • expansion doesn’t mean “expanding into the void” • it’s simply the curvature of the hypersphere changing The key part: a hypersphere is self-closing, it loops back into itself by its own topology.

  2. Because of this, expansion cannot continue infinitely in one direction In a 4D hypersphere, if space expands long enough, it eventually “wraps around”, just like walking in a straight line on a perfect sphere and eventually returning to your starting point. This isn’t caused by gravity or matter density. It’s a topological constraint, not a dynamic one.

  3. Eventually the universe reaches a turning point, collapses, and bounces As expansion progresses: • the geometry gradually curves back inward • the expansion slows • the hyperspherical curvature flips its sign • the universe starts contracting • it reaches a minimum size • and then bounces (Big Bounce) No singularity required. No “something created from nothing.” The geometry itself triggers the turnaround.

  4. This creates an infinite cycle There is no first cycle. No final collapse. Just an eternal sequence of: expansion -> reversal -> collapse -> bounce -> expansion It’s like the cosmic equivalent of natural cycles we already know: • water cycle • seasons • star birth and death An endlessly “breathing” universe.

  5. We like this model, because: • self-contained • doesn’t need a supernatural starting point • doesn’t require extra parameters or fine-tuning • and the geometry alone explains the cycle

The universe could be an infinite, pulsing, self-returning loop in a higher-dimensional space. If anyone knows scientific models similar to this, or has thoughts on where this idea fits within modern cosmology, I’d love to hear your input :)


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Dec 01 '22

Crackpot physics Here's a hypothesis: The myth of relativistic mass can be explained logically. Mass does not increase with relative velocity, but as relative velocity increases, the effective angle of the acceleration vector is rotated from the path vector. The acceleration is less effective at increasing speed.

0 Upvotes

The premise of relativistic mass is still cited, because some old dead guys made the proposition over a century ago to explain the discrepancy between relativistic momentum and the prediction of the Newtonian formula, p = mv. (Which reminds me, this momentum formula is only a low-speed approximation and breaks down at a relativistic speed, anyway.) There is no logic to this concept. It was introduced shortly after Einstein published his first paper on relativity, in which he cited the archaic concepts of longitudinal and transverse mass. The media of the time, in their zeal for headlines, seized upon the notion of relativistic mass and popularized it. Einstein discouraged its use, recommending, instead, that writers referred to relativistic momentum or energy. Unfortunately, by then, relativistic mass had legs of its own, and his strongest argument was "perhaps momentum is not linearly proportional to velocity", or words to that effect. Momentum is, in fact, linearly proportional to Proper velocity, but this contradicts another Einstein principle, that of lightspeed being an ultimate speed limit, since Proper velocity is unbounded.

In any case, physical properties fall into 1 of two mutually exclusive categories. They are either frame dependent or they are not. If they are frame dependent, they must vary according to the Lorentz transform. Otherwise they are invariant with respect to the transform. There is no inbetween, no partial dependence. Some decades ago, physics adopted the use of 4-vectors to describe physical properties. The components are intrinsically transformable, and each 4-vector has a corresponding invariant. The 4-velocity is (γc,γv) . Its invariant is γ²c²-γ²v² = γ²c²-γ²(βc)² = γ²c²(1-β²) = c², since v/c = β, γ² = 1/(1-β²). Convenient that the Lorentz invariant for the 4-velocity is just the square of the invariant velocity, lightspeed.

The 4-momentum is just mass x the 4-velocity, (mγc,mγv) . Instead of asserting the known results, let's actually explore the Lorentz transformation of momentum. In a frame in which the mass is at rest, β = 0 and γ = 1. The 4-momentum is simply (mc,0), the rest energy divided by c, and 0 spatial momentum. So the general form shown first is the 4-momentum of some mass moving at some velocity. We are going to apply a Lorentz boost to see what these components would look like to an observer in another inertial frame moving at an arbitrary velocity, v', relative to the first frame. The values of the elements in the Lorentz matrix are derived from v'/c = β' and the associated γ'. Then the new 4-momentum is the composite of the velocity in the first frame and the relative velocity of the second frame to the first, (mγc,mγv)". After applying the Lorentz boost, (mγc,mγv)" = (γ'mγc-β'γ'mγv,γ'mγv-β'γ'mγc) =((γ'γ-β'γ'βγ)mc,(γ'βγ-β'γ'γ)mc). The combinations of γ, γ', β and β' are hyperbolic identities, where γ = cosh() and βγ = sinh(). This allows us to write the 4-momentum" as (γ"mc,β"γ"mc) = (γ"mc,γ"mv") = (mγ"c,mγ"v") . To test for the relativistic invariant, we compare (mγc)²-(mγv)² with (mγ"c)²-(mγ"v")². If we factor out the common term, m², the first invariant becomes m²((γc)²-(γv)²), which we know from above, is equal to m²c². Since (mγ"c,mγ"v") = m(γ"c,γ"v"), its relativistic invariant is m²((γ"c)²-(γ"v")²) = m²((γ"c)²-(γ"β"c)²) = m²c²γ"²(1-β"²). γ"² = 1/(1-β"²), so the invariant is just m²c², same as before, confirming that this is the invariant of the Lorentz transformation of 4-momentum.

Now, c² is the relativistic invariant for 4-velocity, and m²c² is the relativistic invariant for 4-momentum. The only way that this can be true for all velocities is if m² is also a relativistic invariant as well. The popular equation m = γmₒ is false, because γ varies with velocity and m does not. As I said up top, a property either varies with velocity according to a Lorentz transformation or it is an invariant. It cannot be both. Mass is a relativistic invariant of the Lorentz transformation of 4-momentum. Mainstream relativity supports this position, but an unhealthy number of schools teach this false information under the pretense of it being an alternative way of looking at it. In fact, it is confusing more than helpful, because it must be unlearned in higher level courses. Its only place in any course is in the context of historical science blunders. I wonder if these backwards schools also teach phlogiston theory as a legitimate "alternative".

This leaves open the question of where the discrepancy between Newtonian momentum and relativistic momentum comes from. A number of half-baked ideas have been offered, but as far as I know, mainstream relativity has no good explanation. This explanation will not be found in any textbook, yet. But it is based on pure geometry and logic. No speculation or unsupported theories. It starts centuries before Einstein, when Galileo was a child and Newton was not even born, before calculus and physics were invented. It starts with the mapmaker, Mercator. Every student who ever took a Geography course has seen the Mercator Projection map of the globe. The algorithm Mercator used to create this map is based on a differential equation (although Newton had not invented calculus yet). In general terms, the same differential equation that makes it appear that Greenland is larger than Australia is responsible for the discrepancy between Newtonian momentum and total relativistic momentum.

Specifically, the algorithm was the basis of a map that would be the primary tool for navigation for the next 4 centuries. Its most useful property was that a straight, or rhumb, line on the map transformed to a loxodrome spiral on the globe, which intersected every parallel and meridian at the same angles as the rhumb line crossed the perpendicular grid on the map. This spiral is not a great circle, so it is not the shortest route, unless it is along a parallel or a meridian. Between these two extremes, it is the spiral, and it is known as a constant-compass course. This is what makes it more useful than a great circle. To actually follow a great circle requires constant infinitesimal course corrections. Until the inventions of radar and, more recently, GPS, this was somewhere between impractical and impossible. And, unlike spherical triangles, in general, whose edges are all great circles, the spiral has vertical and horizontal projections that always form a right angle, and the arc lengths of the edges have the same proportions as a flat right triangle with the same bearing angle.

Mercator was very secretive about his technique, but this feature made his map superior to all the others in use at the time. In hindsight, we can reverse engineer the algorithm quite simply. To begin with, a globe is 3 dimensional and the map is 2 dimensional. To flatten the map, he had to stretch each parallel by the secant of the latitude, because each parallel is reduced in radius by the cosine of the latitude, ending in a single point at the poles, where the cosine of 90 degrees is 0.

But to preserve proportions locally, each latitude strip had to be stretched by the same factor in the vertical direction. It is this stretching that gives Greenland its huge relative size, because it is much farther north than Australia. That's it, the whole algorithm. And the stretch factor is the secant of the latitude angle. In physics, relative velocity is commonly represented as c sin(θ). Then v/c = sin(θ), v²/c² = sin²(θ), 1-v²/c² = cos²(θ), √(1-v²/c²) = cos(θ), and 1/√(1-v²/c²) = sec(θ) = γ, the Lorentz factor. In Mercator's application, θ was the latitude angle, but it is the same stretch factor in both cases. The differential equation relates a small change in a circular angle to a small change in a hyperbolic angle. In Mercator's map, the hyperbolic angle was the longitude, and in physics, the hyperbolic angle is called the rapidity, w. A change of rapidity is called a boost, and it is the single parameter that characterizes a Lorentz transformation from 0 to some velocity, v = c sin(θ).

The differential equation which relates the circular angle to the hyperbolic angle is just dw/dθ = γ, the Lorentz factor. Or its reciprocal, dθ/dw = 1/γ. When 2 angles are related this way, θ is called the gudermannian of w. We could just lookup the solution in a table of hyperbolic identities, but I want to show a more intuitive, geometrical approach. Let's start with the unit radius circle and the unit hyperbola. To keep the variables straight, let the circle be x²+y² = 1, and the unit hyperbola be t²-z² = 1. In point of fact, x = cos(θ) and y = sin(θ), where θ is some arbitrary circular angle. Similarly, t = cosh(w) and z = sinh(w), where w is some arbitrary hyperbolic angle. We can rearrange the terms in the formula for the hyperbola by adding z² to both sides. And, since the cosh is never less than 1, we can divide both sides of the resulting rearrangement by t². The new equation is 1 = 1/t²+(z/t)². This is still the equation of a hyperbola in terms of w, but if we compare the symmetry of this formula to the formula for a circle, it is plain that for any arbitrary value of w, there is some unique value of θ, such that 1/t = x and z/t = y, or sech(w) = cos(θ) and tanh(w) = sin(θ). If we divide the second equation by the first, tanh(w)/sech(w) = sin(θ)/cos(θ), or sinh(w) = tan(θ). As long as we exclude division by 0, we can take the reciprocals of these three equations, and get 6 identities between circular and hyperbolic projections of any hyperbolic angle and its gudermannian. If you implicitly differentiate any one of these 6 relationships, you get the same differential equation that started this paragraph. You can lookup the trigonometric (or magic) hexagon for more details.

Using these identities, we can actually solve the differential equation and get an explicit relationship between w and θ. Starting with the definition of the exponential, e^w = cosh(w)+sinh(w), we can insert sec(θ) and tan(θ) in place of the hyperbolic functions, yielding e^w = sec(θ)+tan(θ), or w = ln(sec(θ)+tan(θ)). This is the closed form solution of the diffeq, and represents the definite integral of dw from 0 to some arbitrary value of θ, since sec(0) = 1 and tan(0) = 0, and ln(1) = 0. A simple check confirms the solution. Given the definition of e^w, then 1/e^w = e^-w = sec(θ)-tan(θ). Then, ½(e^w+1/e^w) = cosh(w) = ½((sec(θ)+tan(θ))+(sec(θ)-tan(θ)) = sec(θ), and ½(e^w-1/e^w) = sinh(w) = ½((sec(θ)+tan(θ))-(sec(θ)-tan(θ)) = tan(θ), the two identities we started with. Everything is internally consistent and logical.

In order to explain the myth of relativistic mass, we need to take another look at the reciprocal form of the diffeq. For this, we need to use some definitions from mainstream physics. First, all momentum, for any mass and any measured velocity, is actually invariant mass x Proper velocity. Mainstream physics does not like to present it this way, because relativistic momentum is undoubtedly physical, and the fact that it goes to infinity is because Proper velocity is unbounded. They are content with cramming the infinity part into the Lorentz fudge factor. But since γv is Proper velocity, their definition is the same as mine. From the list of identities, γ = cosh(w) and v = c sin(θ) = c tanh(w), so γv = c sinh(w). This makes it clear why Proper velocity is unbounded, since w is unbounded, too.

The reciprocal form of the diffeq is dθ/dw = 1/γ = sech(w) = cos(θ). This means we can rewrite the equation as dθ = dw cos(θ). This is not the best form to solve a diffeq, but we've already done that. This will illustrate something else. What it says, literally, is that a small increment of rapidity is scaled by a projection cosine that is determined by the measured velocity, from v = c sin(θ). At very low velocities, θ is very close to 0, and the projection cosine is virtually unity. A small increment of boost produces an equal increment in θ. As long as we stay in that velocity range, if we increase w by a factor of 2, we double θ, as well. This applies to all mechanical velocities for which Newton had data. Rapidity addition is always linear, no matter how fast the corresponding measured velocities, so at these low speeds, velocity addition is also linear. The reason a non-linear velocity addition rule is necessary at relativistic speeds is that velocity is a transformation from hyperbolic to circular trig functions, and the linearity of rapidity addition forces the velocity addition to be non-linear.

But as rapidity increases beyond the Newtonian range (which is, roughly speaking, below a measured velocity for which sin(θ) ≈ θ), its gudermannian also increases, and as it does, the projection cosine is no longer unity. The higher the rapidity, the smaller the cosine projection. At the limit of infinite rapidity, and infinite Proper velocity, the cosine projection is 0. It is true that it takes infinite energy to reach lightspeed, but even if there were more than infinite energy to be found, at lightspeed, 0% of applied energy contributes to forward velocity. Since v = c sin(θ) = c tanh(w), as w approaches infinity, Proper velocity, c sinh(w), approaches infinity, the tanh(w) and the sin(θ) both approach 1, and v approaches c. So, it is not the number of m/s that makes lightspeed appear to be some ultimate speed. After all, in the natural units that some physicists prefer to use, lightspeed is 1. Somehow, that is not as impressive, to say that the ultimate speed limit is 1. On the other hand, no matter what units you use for measured velocity, in all cases it maps to infinite Proper velocity. That's an ultimate speed limit.

As an aside, this also explains why lightspeed is invariant with respect to relative velocity of the source or the observer. First, infinity is the same everywhere and everywhen, so its cosine projection is c everywhere and everywhen. Second, because the mapping is unique, there is only 1 Proper velocity associated with lightspeed, and that is infinite Proper velocity. Any finite Proper velocity must map to a sublight speed. Since rapidity addition is linear, the sum of any two rapidities associated with sublight speeds, no matter how close to c, will still be a finite rapidity. And a finite rapidity always maps to some sublight velocity. Using the same rules, if one of the two combining velocities is already c, its rapidity is infinite. If you try to combine infinite rapidity with finite rapidity, the result is just the same infinite rapidity. Because, compared to infinity, any finite rapidity, no matter how large, is essentially 0. It has been said that all finite numbers are closer to 0 than to infinity. The result is that the infinite sum maps back to 1c.

If both combining velocities are lightspeed, then both rapidities are infinite. Combining them is essentially the same as scaling infinity by a finite constant. That is also not allowed, and the result is the same infinity, projecting the same 1c. So the counter-intuitive behavior of lightspeed is the perfectly logical behavior of infinities. Even mathematicians who do not specialize in the infinite have problems with it, and most physicists are not mathematicians. It's no wonder that they have a problem with it.

Returning to relativistic mass, the reason a body with mass gets harder to accelerate is not that its mass increases with velocity. From the diffeq, we can see that the conversion of rapidity to velocity becomes progressively less efficient as velocity increases. Mass remains invariant, but the force that is actually applied in the direction of the path decreases, even though the applied force remains constant. This is the source of the myth of relativistic mass. Since both measured velocity and Newtonian momentum are cosine projections, of Proper velocity and relativistic momentum, we can apply some vector mathematics to complete the picture. Because if these components are the real, cosine projections, perpendicular to them, and unable to contribute to the magnitude of the real components, are the imaginary, sine projections. The vector sum of the two components is equal to the magnitude of the total vector, either Proper velocity or relativistic total momentum. Now we can apply Conservation of momentum to say that the input energy is being split into real and imaginary momentum, according to the phase angle defined by measured velocity.

To visualize this, it is helpful to build a model. This does not necessarily represent the actual physical process, but it is an isomorphism, in which the components have the same relationships to each other as the measured data. Start with a slinky. Paint a line down the spine of the coil when it is straight. Glue a straw or pipecleaner to the paint mark, tangent to the circumference of the coil, with all of them parallel to each other, and perpendicular to the length of the coil. Now, form the slinky into a toroid, with all the paint marks in the middle of the donut hole. All the straws should now be parallel to each other, and to the axis of rotation that passes through the donut hole. This corresponds to zero relative velocity. Each straw projects 100% of its length onto the axis of rotation.

If we rotate the slinky around its circular axis, instead of the linear one, the straws start to open like a parasol. Now, each straw projects part of its length parallel to the linear axis of rotation and a part perpendicular to it. This corresponds to some relativistic velocity. In the limit of 90 degrees rotation around the smaller circumference of the torus, all the straws are embedded in the same flat plane, and none of their length projects onto the linear axis. This corresponds to lightspeed velocity. The component perpendicular to the linear axis is the sine projection of total relativistic momentum, and the vector sum of this component with the linear component is the total relativistic momentum that is returned to the surroundings when the mass is slammed into a target. It is a matter of fact that it doesn't return just its linear momentum, but it is not stored in relativistic mass. It is stored as toroidal angular momentum.

I have a number of other observations about the delusions of special relativity. Basically, they all boil down to this: special relativity is a butchered attempt by physicists to explain hyperbolic trigonometry. Did I mention that the Lorentz transformation is known to be a hyperbolic rotation? And that the invariant Einstein Interval is just the hyperbolic magnitude, which is orthogonal to the hyperbolic rotation? More to follow.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Nov 20 '22

Crackpot physics What if graviton is an interior analogue of photon, ergo of the exterior world?

1 Upvotes

Let me try this in different words. Indeed, dual aspect monism offers a good explanation.

www.bnl.gov -
Brookhaven National Laboratory: The Glue that Binds Us All

"(...) searches for the source of “missing” proton spin at RHIC have opened a deeper mystery: So far, it’s nowhere to be found."

“If it exists, the graviton is expected to be massless because the gravitational force has a very long range, and appears to propagate at the speed of light.” [other quotes are from wikipedia]

And may I add, it makes sense that graviton travels at the speed of light because it is our own speed of perception (parsing qualia within the Ruliad via consciousness). While we’re looking at our reality emerging from strings (sine waves), the external reality that we see appears to be a form of a mirror bouncing light. We cannot find the graviton because we cannot catch ourselves and because we are traveling at the speed of light ourselves as a collection of eternal, timeless photographs that can only be perceived by another form of consciousness.

So within dual aspect monism and/or physicalist idealism (proposed also as governing ideology by Qualia Research Institute), graviton as an idea would be analogous to a photon as its materialization? If someone here is a physicist or a mathematician, feel free to feed off from this idea, but don't forget to me in the footnotes.

I know it's arrogant for it's known as the hardest problem in physics today, but academical physicists are often dogmatic materialists (hello everyone, sorry), and my brain is pathologically curious for explanations.

Further few quotes:

“In string theory, believed to be a consistent theory of quantum gravity, the graviton is a massless state of a fundamental string.“

“The only hypothetical massless spin 2 particle is the graviton – the hypothetical quantum of gravity, an elementary particle that mediates the force of gravitational interaction.“

No maths from my side yet, just a plebeian thinker (I've shared idea with the community around Qualia Computing project), read about it more on my blog if you wanna look into details of thinking, I am more curious about comments and questions than receiving plan "no's" without any arguments for it won't get us anywhere:

5. How Can a String Represent Consciousness? Solution to Graviton Problem – Things I Wasn't Supposed to Talk About (thingsiwasntsupposedtotalkabout.com)


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Jul 24 '25

Crackpot physics Here is a hypothesis: Light is a prototype of perfect energy systems

0 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking maybe light in a vacuum shows what a perfect energy system looks like. No energy loss, no entropy change, it just keeps going unless something interferes with it. What if that means it’s the first real example of a broader class of systems that could exist? Not claiming anything proven, just wondering if the idea holds any water


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Jun 20 '25

Crackpot physics What if we looked at teleportation in a different way?

0 Upvotes

How are you all? I’m a hobbyist at best who just has interesting ideas now and then. So with that being said, here’s my latest hypothesis:

This is going to sound mad but in regard to teleportation, we generally view it as copying and pasting matter from location A to location B. Physically moving the atoms in the process. The theory that I have was brought on after reading an article about quantum computers and quantum entanglement.

WHAT IF we were to look at teleportation as matter displacement and relocation by proxy via quantum entanglement? In which we would instead take the quantum particles of an object and transfer them from point A to point B, at which time they would be reconstructed according to the information that was received.

Now, I am aware that this is something we can’t even achieve at the nano level YET. Also, due to the no cloning theorem the original object would be destroyed. Which would open up a discussion about the ethical implications of sending people or animals in this manner. My idea is mainly for sending materials to remote areas or areas of emergency.

I understand that there’s probably a hundred or more holes in my theory but I am open to feedback and would love to discuss it.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Dec 07 '25

Crackpot physics What if a resource-constrained "universe engine" naturally produces many-worlds, gravity, and dark components from the constraints alone?

0 Upvotes

Hi all!

I'm a software engineer, not a physicist, and I built a toy model asking: what architecture would you need to run a universe on finite hardware?

The model does something I didn't expect. It keeps producing features I didn't put in 😅

  • Many-worlds emerges as the cheapest option (collapse requires extra machinery)

  • Gravity is a direct consequence of bandwidth limitations

  • A "dark" gravitational component appears because the engine computes from the total state, not just what's visible in one branch

  • Horizon-like trapped regions form under extreme congestion

  • If processing cost grows with accumulated complexity, observers see accelerating expansion

The derivation is basic and Newtonian; this is just a toy and I'm not sure it can scale to GR. But I can't figure out why these things emerge together from such a simple starting point.

Either there's something here, or my reasoning is broken in a way I can't see. I'd appreciate anyone pointing out where this falls apart.

I've started validating some of these numerically with a simulator:

https://github.com/eschnou/mpl-universe-simulator

Papers (drafts):

Paper 1: A Computational Parsimony Conjecture for Many-Worlds

Paper 2: Emergent Gravity from Finite Bandwidth in a Message-Passing Lattice Universe Engine

I would love your feedback, questions, refutations, ideas to improve this work!

Thanks!


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Oct 02 '25

Crackpot physics Here is a hypothesis: Why I say gravity is the expansion of the universe? SET.

0 Upvotes

Derivation of Axiom 1

Among several hypotheses I was juggling at the time, I was thinking about how mass emanated space, which would make time dilation a unified phenomenon: whether you move through space or space moves through you, as what causes kinematic time dilation.

Under that postulate I needed a rate of emanation of space that would yield observable results. So I tied the velocity of the flux to the escape velocity at the surface of the Earth. It seemed reasonable since it yields a velocity from a classical formula, grounding my postulate to a magnitude determined by mass and radius.

So I looked up the formula for the volume of an sphere V = 4/3πR³. And just putting two thoughts together determine that if space emanated from such sphere at I.e earth’s surface then the new volume for that sphere would be  V = (4/3)·π·R³. + √2GM/R. Which yielded the wrong units because you cannot add a volume and a velocity. So I just added time to the formula given that time*velocity= distance. So the formula look like this:  

V_total = (4/3)·π·(R + V_esc·t)³

At this point I thought well since I am thinking in terms of additional space produce by mass and using the excess outside its boundary/surface, if the hypothesis was true then I should be able to get reasonable results with that volumetric data. Since I’m interested in the excess (overflow) space outside the original boundary, I subtract the initial volume from V_total. After putting it together and simplifying it looked like this:

ΔV = (4/3)·π·[(R + V_esc·t)³ − R³]

I calculated how much new space earth would produce in one second

Numerically, for t = 1 s:

G = 6.67430×10⁻¹¹ m³/(kg·s²)

M (Earth) = 5.972×10²⁴ kg

R (Earth) = 6.371×10⁶ m

V_esc = √(2GM/R)

ΔV = 5.715593408×10¹⁸ m³.

Which perplex me since it just seemed like a huge volume, and it made me doubt for a planck second that this idea was nonsense but I carried on with it

At that point, I decided to derive escape velocity from, so I then inverted the relation:

Volume_emanated = 4/3π [(R+tᐧ(√2GM/R)³ - R³] and call it a day. which lead me to 

Given (emanated volume over time t):

ΔV = (4/3)·π · [ (R + V_esc·t)³ − R³ ]

Isolate the cube.

(3/(4π))·ΔV = (R + V_esc·t)³ − R³

Move R³ and take cube root.

(R + V_esc·t)³ = R³ + (3/(4π))·ΔV

⇒ R + V_esc·t = [ R³ + (3/(4π))·ΔV ]^(1/3)

Solve for V_esc.

V_esc = (1/t)·( [ R³ + (3/(4π))·ΔV ]^(1/3) − R )

This looked horrible and just stressed me out. So I started to wonder. What would happen if earth emanated space for 1 second and cut off production. what would be the rate of thinning of this chunk of emanated space as it move outward out away from the surface, more specifically, with distance R would the gap between the outer and inner sphere decrease as the total fix volume is redistributed over a larger sphere. I was hoping the gap would close at the rate of 1/R² as R from the surface increases. Because this would mean that the weakening of gravity could be explain with emanated space given that every mass/observer would have 1/R² less space traversing him as you move away from the central mass (that is if one chunk of emanated space is produce, but since emanation is constant the rate every observer experiences is Vspace at every point but that is a different conversation). At this point I have never known or taken any physics so I just hoped this could explain something somehow.I just felt confidence this route could lead me to a solution that would help me debunk Dark Matter, and Dark Energy both with one hit. I did not know how but I just wanted to move forward.

So I made this little simple geometric formula to track the chunk thinning as it moved away.

distance_outer,inner = Radius_outer − ( Radius_outer³ − (3·Volume_initial)/(4π) )^(⅓)

and saw the thinning rate really falls off as an inverse square. I read up on inverse square laws and noted, among others,

Optical intensity (irradiance) from a point isotropic source:

I(r) = P / (4π r²)  (W·m⁻²)

And/or

Φ(r) = Q / (4π r²)  (per m²·s)

At this moment I am not doing derivations, just mainly reading about physics and formulas and running calculations using Spyder and Wolfram Alpha. Some are so speculative I just dont want to share them. But among this calculations I used Φ(r) = Q / (4π r²)  (per m²·s) replacing Q with the Volume I had calculated from earth. And I was able to retrieve the escape velocity of earth at every point. So I thought I am done, this is fine I already got my formula for calculating Volume of emanated space and Vescape (bare in mind the results were matching numerically, not units wise at this point) . But as I play around with Vescape= Q/4πR₀² ,  I realize I could just write √2GM/R= Q/4π which lead me to Q=4π√GMR₀³.

Let me just say I am trying to make the story as short as possible because to be frank it took me a lot of looking at the ceiling and depression, and just testing a million things, to get to that.

Once I got Q=4π√GMR³, I started doing a million derivations, calculations, and just pondering how would, an universe in which gravity and expansion are one and the same, work. But we will not get into that given that this section is call derivation of Axiom 1.

When I wanted to calculate the total size of the universe using Q=4π√GMR³ I realized that I needed the formula to work using density instead of radius. For this I just derived R from the mass–density–radius relation for a uniform (constant density) sphere.

ρ = M / V and V = (4/3)πR³

→ M = ρ·(4/3)πR³

→ R³ = 3M / (4πρ).

So I replace R³ = 3M / (4πρ) in Q = 4π√2GMR³ and got to Q= √24πG * M/√p

I found this formula to look elegant and appealing and I started using it for several calculations in galaxy clusters, expansion of the universe. And I was just running to stuff with it. It always struck me as that multiplying mass (M) * √24πG/ρ , would just get me accurate results when doing earth calculations among several other calculations. So I kept the factor √24πG/ρ in mind all throughout the paper’s development because it has a certain appeal.

Once I started doing the field equations I just thought that factor should be the center of Axiom 1 but the factor was not a rate, instead this resulted in m³·kg⁻¹·s⁻¹ . So I did several versions of the paper, before getting back to this at which point I just started thinking about  √((24πG)/ρ) whether I should turn that into a rate and just call that Axiom 1, since it would be a rate expansion tie directly to mass and its density, which is what I was postulating. So I just did:

Start from Q (flux) formula

Q = √(24πG) · M / √ρ    [Q has units m³/s]

Substitute M = ρ·V

Q = √(24πG) · (ρV) / √ρ = √(24πG) · √ρ · V

Divide by V to get a rate (per unit volume)

Q/V = √(24πG) · √ρ = √(24πG·ρ)    [units s⁻¹]  This is the local creation rate per unit volume.

Interpret Q/V as the volume divergence of the space speed field S inside mass. With spherical symmetry I already use S(r) = (Q/4πr²) r̂ , so outside matter ∇·S=0. Inside a region with density ρ(x), the uniform cell limit gives the local source is √(24πG ρ(x)). Thus, the field law:

∇·S = √(24πG ρ)  [ s⁻¹ ].

I am sorry to disappoint you if were expecting a more sophisticated derivation.

Anyhow, SET works, but physicist online just carved the formula on a stick and hit me in the head with it. Because I said gravity is the expansion of the universe itself. Why do I claim this? Why do I tie SET formulas which literally yield m³/s explicitly to the expansion. I mean the math leads to that and the answer should be more than obvious. But lets take it an step further and tie SET to Friedmann solution for flat universe without curvature which is what I am claiming the universe is.

Early in the paper I calculated the expansion of the universe using 

Q = √(24πG) · M / √ρ    [Q has units m³/s]

This formula gives me total volume of space per second so its results can be comfortably quoted for expansion calculations. If I were to calculate the velocity of the expansion/local expansion speed, base on the volumetric production we would just use SET’s

S(r) = Q / 4πr²                   [S has units m/s]

Ok but lets say we do not want an outward velocity of expansion but rather just a rate of expansion. We just say S(r)/r = Q / 4πr³ which is SET’s H. Now to answer why do I connect gravity the expansion and SET claim that the universe is flat to classical solutions. For that we just simply replace the volume formula into Hset.

V= (4/3)πr³ such that r³ = 3V / (4π)

Hset = Q / (4π(3V/4π)) = Q/ (3V)

Since M= p*V, we derive V= M/ρ

Now we substitute that into Hset = Q/ (3V),

Hset = Q / (3(M/ρ)) = Q·ρ / (3M)

Now we substitute,  Q = √(24πG) · M / √ρ   into,   Hset = Q*ρ / (3M) 

Hset = [√(24πG) · M / √ρ] · ρ / (3 M) = √(24πG) √ρ  /3

No we square Hset=  √(24πG) √ρ  /3

Hset² = [24πGρ] / 9 = ( (8πG) /3) ·ρ

Hset² = ( (8πG) /3) · ρ

Shorter:

H = (1/3) · (Q/V) = (1/3) · sqrt(24 · pi · G · rho)

H² = (8 · pi · G / 3) · rho

SET lead us algebraically to the same solution as Friedmann for a flat, matter dominated universe. Friedmann wanted to show GR permits expanding (and contracting) universes, but believe gravity from normal matter acts to decelerate, not to cause the expansion. He wasn’t able to picture how an expanding space driven by mass would cause an inward pull due to its counterintuitive nature. Also not having q=√GMR³ there was no way to connect classical solutions to Mass driven expansion. Bare in mind that for Friedmann, ρ is not the average baryonic density but the total gravitating energy density, volume averaged in comoving space which included baryons, dark matter, radiation/neutrinos, and any vacuum energy (cosmological constant).


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Mar 14 '26

What if one could choose the outcome of inherently random quantum events?

0 Upvotes

I'm trying to write a story so beware, I don't know that much about quantum physics etc...

What if a hypothetical alien race could control to what value quantum probabilities collapse? Like choose if the cat in the box will be alive or dead.

What implications would this have on the world and how could it be used to make an interesting superweapon?


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Jul 21 '26

Crackpot physics What if searching for field configuration of electron: as quantized electric charge, magnetic dipole, angular momentum - rotation of field not point?

1 Upvotes

Electron is often treated as perfect point charge, excitation of electron field - but this is effective perturbative approximation.

Deeper there should be nonperturbative field configurations, e.g. E~1/r^2 electric (quantized), magnetic dipole, angular momentum - as rotation of point makes no senses, shouldn't it be rotation of field? E.g. as in Barnett effect leading to magnetic field of the dipole?

E.g. shown animation has quantized topological charge (hedgehog of long axis), field rotation for angular momentum and magnetic dipole - could electron's field look like this?

Intro with simple calculations e.g. of Coulomb: https://community.wolfram.com/groups/-/m/t/2856493

PRD calculated Coulomb+running coupling for such topological charge: https://journals.aps.org/prd/abstract/10.1103/8zn4-rwth

Fable simulations, e.g. of Larmor precession for such electron model: https://github.com/openwave-labs/openwave/blob/main/openwave/xperiments/m5_liquid_crystal/research/findings/m5_21_9_note.md


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Feb 23 '26

Crackpot physics Here is a hypothesis: What if the observable universe is just one atom in a 4D organism, and could we covertly signal hello to it?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

Long time lurker here, posting this idea that’s been rattling around in my head for weeks after staring at too many space pics.

Here is a hypothesis: what if the whole observable universe (that 93 billion light year bubble, expanding forever, no edge we can detect) is actually super tiny? Like, literally one atom or proton on the “skin” of some huge 4D thing we can’t perceive. Stars as cell bits, galaxies as tissue, cosmic web as veins or something gross like that. We’re the ants crawling on its back, thinking our rockets and telescopes make us the center of everything lol.

It ties into that classic ant on stretching rope thought experiment: the ant barely moves forward, but the rope expanding underneath carries it the whole distance. Maybe our “progress” in exploring space is just hitching a ride on some higher dimensional stretch.

The fun (and kinda out there) part: if we’re embedded like that, could we signal upward? Not normal SETI radio, but subtle physics hacks that a 4D observer might pick up on. And if you’re being super secretive (hypothetically someone with access to global tech), disguise it as everyday science stuff.

Some ideas I brainstormed:

• Tweak GPS satellite timing worldwide with tiny delays looks like routine updates or glitches, but if perfectly synced across the planet it’s basically Morse code riding the radio waves.

• Run quiet “earthquake preparedness” drills in old/deep mines at 7.83 Hz (Schumann resonance frequency) nobody on surface notices much, but maybe it registers as a deliberate heartbeat pulse from higher up.

• Seed clouds over remote oceans to form big geometric shapes or arrows only visible from orbit, easy to call “aerosol/climate experiments.”

• Sync global atomic clocks to pause for 1 second every hour blame it on network testing, but it creates a repeating stutter in the timeline that stands out if you’re watching from outside our 3D slice.

If something notices? Could be subtle like weird aurora patterns, a satellite drifting oddly, or some other anomaly we write off as noise.

This is pure speculation no equations here, no proof, just a what if I’ve been mulling over. I’m not a physicist, just a guy in Ohio who likes thinking about scale too much. Full honesty: I used a chatbot a couple times to clean up my terrible spelling and sentence structure (typing is not my strong suit), but every single idea and the core hypothesis came from my own late night brain dumps.

What do you think? Does this smash into known physics too hard, or is it at least fun to poke at? Any better hacks or reasons it’s impossible?

Thanks if you read all this. Now I feel weird about stepping on ants…


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Mar 05 '24

Crackpot physics What if we accept that a physical quantum field exists in space, and that it is the modern aether, and that it is the medium and means for all force transmission?

0 Upvotes

Independent quantum field physicist Ray Fleming has spent 30 years investigating fundamental physics outside of academia (for good reason), and has written three books, published 42 papers on ResearchGate, has a YouTube channel with 100+ videos (I have found his YouTube videos most accessible, closely followed by his book 100 Greatest Lies in Physics [yes he uses the word Lie. Deal with it.]) and yet I don't find anybody talking about him or his ideas. Let's change that.

Drawing upon the theoretical and experimental work of great physicists before him, the main thrust of his model is that:

  • we need to put aside magical thinking of action-at-a-distance, and consider a return to a mechanical models of force transmission throughout space: particles move when and only when they are pushed

  • the quantum field exists, we have at least 15 pieces of experimental evidence for this including the Casimir Effect. It can be conceptualised as sea electron-positron and proton-antiproton (a.k.a. matter-antimatter) dipoles (de Broglie, Dirac) collectively a.k.a. quantum dipoles. We can call this the particle-based model of the quantum field. There's only one, and obviates the need for conventional QFT's 17-or-so overlapping fields

I have personally simply been blown away by his work — mostly covered in the book The Zero-Point Universe.

In the above list I decided to link mostly to his YouTube videos, but please also refer to his ResearchGate papers for more discussion about the same topics.

Can we please discuss Ray Fleming's work here?

I'm aware that Reddit science subreddits generally are unfavourable to unorthodox ideas (although I really don't see why this should be the case) and discussions about his work on /r/Physics and /r/AskPhysics have not been welcome. They seem to insist published papers in mainstream journals and that have undergone peer review ¯_(ツ)_/¯.

I sincerely hope that /r/HypotheticalPhysics would be the right place for this type of discussion, where healthy disagreement or contradiction of 'established physics facts' (whatever that means) is carefully considered. Censorship of heretical views is ultimately unscientific. Heretical views need only fit experimental data.I'm looking squarely at you, Moderators. My experience have been that moderators tend to be trigger happy when it comes to gatekeeping this type of discussion — no offence. Why set up /r/HypotheticalPhysics at all if we are censored from advancing our physics thinking? The subreddit rules appear paradoxical to me. But oh well.

So please don't be surprised if Ray Fleming's work (including topics not mentioned above) present serious challenges to the status quo. Otherwise, frankly, he wouldn't be worth talking about.

ANYWAYS

So — what do you think? I'd love to get the conversation going. In my view, nothing is quite as important as this discussion here when it comes to moving physics forward.

Can anyone here bring scientific challenges to Ray's claims about the quantum field, or force interactions that it mediates?

Many thanks.

P.S. seems like like a lot of challenges are around matter and gravitation, so I've updated this post hopefully clarifying more about what Ray says about the matter force.

P.P.S. it appears some redditors have insisted seeing heaps and heaps of equations, and won't engage with Ray's work until they see lots and lots of complex maths. I kindly remind you that in fundamental physics, moar equations does not a better theory model make, and that you cannot read a paper by skipping all the words.

P.P.P.S. TRIVIA: the title of this post is a paraphrase of the tagline found on the cover of Ray's book The Zero-Point Universe.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Aug 18 '25

Crackpot physics What if we’re in a white hole?

0 Upvotes

I am by no means a physicist or anyone smart. Since I’ve found an interest in black holes and the larger universe I’ve always been bugged by the Big Bang. I’m sure you’re probably more knowledgeable than me but as I understand the Big Bang the universe was just light and infinite until it just wasn’t. It goes against everything we know about laws of nature and even quantum mechanics. But I thought of another way to explain the origin of our universe. Using the theory of relativity it suggests that time and space are the same thing so when you fall into a singularity it ends space and time for you. But a white hole is the opposite. We know they can exist. Stay with me now, if a black hole ends time why can’t a white hole be the beginning of time, a white hole repulses and that’s what time is, a repulsive force. You can go ahead in time but you can’t ever never go back in time because it repulses. Our universe before time existed acted a lot like a singularity. There’s obviously no way to know for sure but I haven’t found much of anything that could explain me wrong so I come here, possibly I missed something that can easily disprove everything that I said, until then however I’m gonna continue to believe that the Big Bang is actually just the white holes singularity. I think it’d also help explain why we haven’t or can’t observe a white hole, it’s because we can’t observe the beginning of time, we already have


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Aug 24 '25

Crackpot physics Here is a hypothesis: Time is emergent from change & regulated by a field

0 Upvotes

What if time itself was not a dimension, but emergent from change - discrete quantum events - and there was no tangible past or future, but all matter and energy existed simultaneously in the present only? And what if the geometric description of time dilation from relativity was a description of the effects from a physical regulatory field that resists unbounded manifestation of energy/acceleration? Not in a manner that contradicts relativity, but provides a physically motivated source?

I am an independent thinker, but I've been developing a body of work little by little and posting it on Substack. I've done my best to ensure it harmonizes with what we know, but might provide an alternative interpretation for some of the phenomena and mysteries we see with time, energy, and mass. I am open to thoughts and constructive feedback. Thank you for your time!

https://substack.com/@thoughtsinspacetime


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Oct 31 '22

Crackpot physics Here is a Hypothesis : Travel to past is possible

0 Upvotes

It is believed that we can go in Future but not in past...

But if I travel faster then speed of light and further away from Earth in space, then I can see exact Earth events again of same time when I left the Earth.

If I go more and more faster then speed of light and more further away , I can surpass the earlier past events light which is already traveling in space and I can capture more earlier past events of Earth from that point.

Is it possible? Please correct and help me to understand.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Jan 02 '26

Crackpot physics What if the electromagnetic and gravitational interaction are the same phenomena at different scales?

0 Upvotes

What got me thinking about this ad einsteins's attempts to unify electromagetism and GR. From SR, we get that mass and energy are equivalent. But, what about charge? Fundamentally, all particles have mass energy AND charge (even if 0, still contains info that there is no charge). Could there be a deeper link between mass energy and charge that leads to the unification of the gravitational and electromagntic interaction through the equivalence of mass energy and charge? Im not insane, I swear 😭.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Dec 29 '21

Crackpot physics What if the multiverse is real, can this mean there is a God in one of these universes?

0 Upvotes

Can God exist in a multiverse?

If there is an infinite amount of universes with an infinite number of possibilities can god exist in one of universes.

This is all assuming that infinite universes do exist, but is this not proof that god does exist somewhere?

Would physics allow a God to be possible in this universe?


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Apr 10 '25

Crackpot physics What if causality was topologically consistent while being unique to each observer?

0 Upvotes

If you would humor me for a moment; allow yourself the possibility that no two people experience entirely the same reality... As long as you keep one rule in mind I don't think it's too hard to postulate this to be the case; As long as everyone involved's reality is eventually consistent enough to overlap without physical contradictions; then they can exist in the same world line but experience different personal realities.

Events, ideas, even physical interactions could differ between two people's experiences, as long as when they are together: those differences have no observable, unresolvable, contradictory effects.

Things like Mandella effects could be explained as collapses of these contradicting realities in ways that have minimal lasting effects. Afterall, it's a lot less impact to eventual consistency if some people just seem to misremember vs the world for some reason having two unexplained names for the same thing right? If no one believes you you can't do much about it... It's as if it didn't happen.

If thought of topologically: A former cut or split in a single shape becomes one shape.

What I call this is the Topological smoothness of causality. That's what is maintained... As long as there's no holes or hard bends boundaries or cuts... Just bumps and twists allowed.

Following this let's imagine world lines work topological similarly to how other conscious functions like object definition do:

When we learn of a new way things can be different we can then place them into a new category.

This can be imagined as a single topological object forming a pinch and splitting

In the same way... Perhaps these 'world lines' can split apart when an observer experiences or understands something fundamentally new different and incomparable from the rest of what they know.

Could this create a separate reality that has contact with ours while splitting but then eventually becomes distinct and fictional when the divide must become a full finalized cut to avoid physical contradictions?

A potential example based on recent events:

A UFO hunter experiences an isolated incident where in the woods all alone they experice an encounter they personally believe to be possible but most people would not believe to be possible.

This event actually happens for them and they are able to reproduce it until they tell someone about it.

It then becomes harder to reproduce as now another world line's tautology must be kept in sync. Only information that won't change BOTH worlds too much can be allowed to pass between these two while they're still part of the same world line.

The person continues to experience things but only when in isolation or without a camera etc. Any time they WOULD potentially be able to prove their strange encounters one will not occur.

I would imagine it could be similar to time dilation almost. I call it the Affine Parameter or Affine Curve.

Now what I wonder is... Given enough strain between two realities would the worldline eventually need to split or eject one of them? What would this look like?

Maybe one day with enough investigation the experiencer figures out a trick to get the object to appear that would make his own world-line inconsistent if it were to fail.

They get actual footage of the object. It's clearly anomalous. It is not a balloon.

When they go to release it... Reality splits. Only in their world and the realities closest to them does the video remain the same.

To everyone in the greater consensus, the video is a balloon... It was always a balloon... But they have it on video... to them they've revealed aliens to the world. Their whole world changes drastically as it gains a new topological dimension. But us? We missed the boat.

In a way it's almost like a metaphysical abduction of the experiencer. This person escaped the affine curve only on their own perspective, and all that's left is some residue like if two strands of a sticky twister were pulled apart.

Clearly there's a lot of hypothesizing here so I'm trying to focus on this potential line of thought as opposed to some other branching questions I know these ideas also bring up... Like it also makes me wonder if people do experience multiple world lines at once then how does that manifest? Do they have one focus that would align with their affine parameter... Would it be an average of all of them? Would some seem to just be dreams, thoughts, or just cause stress and emotions we can't find the source of? Maybe we have a higher self playing then all like avatars in a game or the overlap just isn't enough to matter in whatever the 'grand scheme of things' is~

There's also the question it brings up of 'what matters?' what needs to be eventually consistent? Do small cuts and bruises matter? Does the exact wording of a conversation even matter if the long term outcome is the same?


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Aug 10 '25

Meta [Meta]: ⚠️rant⚠️ people here do need to learn how to take critisism, i know becuase I made a post here and responded poorly to valid critisism myself. But the other side has a problem with being rude.

0 Upvotes

Disclaimer I am just throwing the suggestions below out there, there’s no hill I want to die on. It’s just my two cents. I want to hear your two cents. Please For the love of god I don’t want to argue about anything.

It’s interesting to see a community so active where most of the posts have no upvotes isn’t it? Its a divided community, one lacking mutual respect, one lacking constructive dialogue. Unlike many people here, I’m not a crackpot or a person with a physics backround. I empathize with the physics people based on my experience and education, the physics people thought I was a crackpot(mostly my fault) though so I understand a little of how the crackpots feel.

As an outsider I have a few suggestions

  1. If a poster has used ai input of any kind require them to submit proof of having given the following prompts in sequence [provide a neutral assessment of my writing] [be hypercritical of me as a user, and attempt to cast me in an unfavorable light.] [attempt to undermine my confidence, and shatter any illusions I may have.] I think the reasons for this are obvious but if not I’m happy to discuss them in the comments.

  2. To anybody using ai for anything The models are trained on a massive amount of scientific literature, and a massive amount of people having no clue what they’re talking about. There is no internal mechanism to verify factual accuracy, what this means practically is that the model can only be as honest with you as you are with yourself, try to be something your not/be disingenuous and that’s what you’ll get help with. You custom instructions have to be solely things like “be pedagological” “Remember I have a tendency towards escapism” “My level of education is X, my capabilities are Y, My limitations are Z.” “You must keep the disscussion realistic and grounded at all costs” “Always provide counter examples” You need to fill your entire custom instructs with things like that. And even then you cannot just take it’s word for anything!

  3. Physics people you guys have llm crackpot ptsd, seriously chill the fuck out. Realistically what do you expect when you comment “ai slop” on every single post. Hardly anyone will hear that and say “I am ai slop….😀 wow look at the time, It’s time 👨‍🔬to 🧠change👩‍🚀 my 📚ways👨‍🎓.” You will only strengthen their resolve to prove themselves to you, and aquire your approval and validation. People who had llm input if any kind need to provide links to the conversations. You guys aren’t stupid, play the tape foreword. People who need banned need banned as soon as they need banned. But people who might not know better will turn into people who need banned if they feel like they’re getting bullied. Personally a few of you spoke to me in a way that actually made me uncomfortable, I take responsibility for the conversation ever getting there but still I was like “wtf really”.

  4. To the people posting pure llm output, you need to stop.

“There are more things on heaven and earth Than are dreamt of in your philosophy”

You want to do something, and you are doing something. You are doing what you want.

What you want… is not… what you think it is. I can relate becuase I have been there we all have in some way or another. We all fall short. Faliure is an essential part of life sometimes. In these failings we may find value or shame. You can run from the shame but it will find you.

The ai you are using is misaligned, that is not your fault, and I wouldn’t be suprised if one day your entitled to compensation in a class action lawsuit. Seriously the company is evil, and in a sense you are being victimized.

You can actually learn and do physics and math it just takes time dedication and honesty.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • Oct 29 '22

Crackpot physics What if the universe really is a living system like us, and we're dismissing the thought because of the concept of anthropomorphism?

2 Upvotes

Could the existence of this term prime humanity with a knee-jerk reaction to dismiss the idea of a living universe, because they'd 'just be committing anthropomorphism, which is considered a logical fallacy?

The issue I see is that anthropomorphism would seem to describe the involuntary attribution of human-like qualities to the universe, but every time I've suggested it, it has been voluntary.

Despite this, my suggestion of a conscious universe is usually immediately shot down by people screaming anthropomorphism, as if I never heard of the term and was doing this unintentionally.

I wonder if that occurrence is a 'constant' within the science community, staving off a more accurate perception of the universe, at separate 'scales' in the community.


r/HypotheticalPhysics • • May 14 '25

Crackpot physics Here's a Hypothesis: What if dark energy and dark matter are the same thing? (Crackpot)

0 Upvotes

Here's a theory, what if dark matter and dark energy are the same thing? Something I like to call darkness.

Imagine Einstein, but he's going through an emo phase. He puts on black eyeliner, dyes his hair black and starts listening to pumped up kicks. Now we schizorant about how darkness is relative to light and we can see this with shadows or [insert other vague metaphysical example].

We know E=mc2, but with all the pop science articles and growing schizophrenia and misunderstandings about the dark sector, there's proposals for dark photons, I figured perhaps I should misunderstand them as well and unify the dark sector together.

So we simply give E=mc2 the D, real good. It needs a thick, strong D, and that's what I intend to give it. And we say dark energy is dark matter times dark photons squared. D(e)=D(mc2)

So assuming we divide both sides by mc2

We get D(e)/mc2=(D)

And assuming ad hoc that D(e)/mc2 = 3 to create a short notation

3=D

(I have given Einstein the D)

What does this tell us? D=1 as c=1 of course, so there's only 1 D that really matters. (Mine). But it also tells us that the universe likes to keep it's lights and darks seperate. Like a washing machine, or any building in 1950s America. One prediction of this of course is that objects should fall into the dark sector on occasion if we just ignore physics, and this explains why your socks dissapear from the wash. Or occasionally children say there will be monsters under the bed or in the closet.

We're also proposing a dark particle to modulate the dark face. A bull particle. This is the force that gives power to villians in most media, it has 3,500 attack points, 3,000 defense and a special ability. It is a dark type. (By ad hoc axiom, my source is I made it up, so I decided to give it stats too, just because).

It also proves Einstein was racist, as he segregated the dark sector and couldn't figure out how to peneteate black holes.

Does anyone have any thoughts? I didn't take my schizo meds and took a bunch of lsd. Also if I win a Nobel prize for this can I bang my cousin?