Who Made the Better "Virpil Alpha / WarBRD Gimbal" ?
The site is called "REDDIT" with a focus on text. I have the link for the video if you would prefer to watch it, but I also have the script for those who prefer to read.
Please Enjoy.
----Script----
We are on the precipice of a totally new ecosystem.
10 years ago, we basically had the Thrustmaster Warthog and the T1600m, with a scattering of others like Saitech and Logitech. VKB came out strong and started to make high quality products. Virpil released the MT50 set shortly after, offering left and right grips. VKB and Virpil continued to push hard to outdo each other with Delta Kosmosima and Alpha. More companies have popped up, offering more and more impressive solutions and innovation. We consumers, always win and this is an important thing to remember throughout the review.
FliCon had announced years ago that they were working on their own joystick, and released a concept photo of the EVO Mark 1, the full name of the product. I contacted them at that time asking for info.
I also asked if they would allow me a opportunity for review and I have had them for just over one.
The channel is known for no bullshit so, we should address the big elephants in the room, right away.
Parts of the sim community, on Reddit and other forums expressed their concerns that the EVO system is basically a clone of the WarBRD Gimbal and the Alpha grip. Internally and Externally, Aesthetically and Mechanically, obviously inspired. Some said, why do we need a new thing that that is just a copy of the other thing. Some expressed their frustrations that it seemed like a low thing to do, but you must admit it does make good business sense to do this.
Imitation is said to be the most sincere form of flattery, but, Iām going to leave it up to you to decide as today I am only interested in the product.
I have no direct association with any of the companies being discussed. I am not really interested in the corporate politics, mortality or the legality of this specific situation. Im not a lawyer, Its up to the lawyers to decide what actions need to be taken if any, and as for myself, I am consumer.
My only question is Who Makes the better WarBrd Alpha Combo?
Flicon or Virpil? and yes, you bet your ass I will be putting these directly head to head throughout the entire video. Are you ok with copy paste, or would you have preferred more innovation. Something less familiar for the market? Comment in the Comments.
We begin with an overall impression.
I am happy to say that there are many more positives than negatives with this release. If this is not your first time watching my reviews, you may know I review harder the higher the price point, and we are close to the upper limits with the EVO mark 1. Overall the Flicon EVO mark 1 is a very very refined and very well constructed controller set. Very good for a first release. Actually one of the best first launches I have seen with only a couple growing pains that can be addressed without disruption. I had no issues quickly setting up and using them.
Who is Flicon? The company is headquartered in Lithuania, ironically the same country Virpil is currently produced and headquartered. The prices for both at the time of this review are similar within margin of error. Flicon lists 200 euro for the gimbal and 200 for the grip, there is a bundle option as well. Virpil often offers special promotions, so at the time of the video, the Alpha grip is actually cheaper at 165 euro. To remain competitive, I would expect FC Tech to also offer promotions like this in the future.
All parts arrive in their own high quality packaging that is a pleasure to unbox. You really get the impression that you are unboxing something special. Externally, the gimbal is large and solid. From top to bottom, the dust cap is a nice feature for when things are apart and not in use. Below the cap is a fine set of teeth machined into the mounting point. This, when combined with the same pattern in the grip base, results in a very good system that will not twist around. You do not need to apply a huge level of tightening torque to achieve a positive and solid lock. Virpil has a similar system but with a slightly different implementation including three threaded screws. Both perform well and allow you to freely clock the grip angle in fine increments through a full 360 degrees. The Gimbal connects to the grip electronically using the same port as the Warthog, which is also the same as Virpil. The gimbal connects physically to the grip using the same thread, meaning your extensions, Z extensions and grips are all also physically compatible. Electronically, within the software you are able to configure the EVO gimbal to use not only the EVO Grips left and right, but Virpil Alpha, Alpha Prime and even Thrustmaster.
As the consumer, the more things you can keep using with a new ecosystem the better. The wider shape and physical size of the gimbal body seems to be more of an aesthetic choice as there is nothing internally that required this extra space. This is unlikely to be a concern, but if space is a major concern for you, these are 2cm wider. This is where the VKB Gunfighter dominates with its super small footprint. If size is a consideration, please take note when choosing. Mounting Left and Right during testing resulted in no clearance issues for me. I tested Desk mounts, Desk Rail mount, and even mounted to the MTS motion system. The slightly larger EVO had enough clearance when middle mounted. The connection to the gimbal is USB type A with a nice wire. The wire terminates at a metal plug making it easy to remove and store. Accidentally cutting or rolling over the wire can be fixed easily without the need for tools, you just need to order a new wire. The plug on this wire looks the same as the one Virpil used in the past, with 5 Pins. The wire is pinned unique to this company and any other wires you may have from other gear will not be compatible
Internally We see a familiar and iconic dual cam design. If I was going to copy any design, it would be this one. In my experience, I have always loved its simplicity and it always delivers a balanced, buttery smooth performance. Historically, this configuration fails to provide very high torque or very high resistance with reliability. Extremely strong springs are needed for those who wish to fly this way, and with a quick search you will find several posts from Redlir and Smashley who reported spring failure issues. Frustrating if it happens, but very simple to remedy by replacing the broken part.
I personally like a lighter feeling of resistance, so I really enjoy the design when playing Space Games. Flicon has added more tuning choice by adding two alternate pin holes to mount the springs from. This becomes another way to tune the preload that is not available on Virpil WARBrd. There is a high precision, non contact sensor on each axis mounted on a daughter board which are each mounted securely. The the wires are tucked safely out of the way of moving parts and there is no Hot Glue anywhere inside. All of the wires are terminated in locking tab plugs allowing for easy quick change of serviceable parts.
The cams and gimbal ride on a pair of sealed bearings per axis, within a billet aluminum frame. The cams are machined to create the curved profile, and then, for some odd reason they were powder coated black, not just the sides but over the machined surface. Probably to improve durability and longevity. I will detail later during the video as to why this impacts negatively on the user experience and suggestions on how Flicon can address this in the future. The gimbal is all implemented to a high standard and I also appreciated the unique choice to dye the PCBs in Purple. The product is designed to be taken apart for tuning and basic maintenance, might as well make things pretty to look at.
We can discuss the software which lets you configure, calibrate and check function. I downloaded the current beta version at time of the review which had no version number. Windows defender warned that the file was lacking the security tags. Very easy to bypass the warning by acknowledging the risk to complete the install. A very nice looking interface with a black and red theme. For a first go simple is ok, but its basic. From a drop down, you many choose left or right. By clicking on individual parts of the pictures, you highlight the individual part and are then given more options. Click the gimbal base for example and you now have X and Y as options. Click the Twist Base and you now have options for the Z axis. Its simple, and fine, but somehow splitting everything up this way, also makes configuration time consuming. There is no simple way to āCalibrate Allā where you click one button, and move the system through all of its ranges at once, return to rest at neutral and click save. I do think I understand why it was done this way, and that has to do with each individual axis also having a slider for Deadzone and one for Averaging. Within each of these individual axis pages there is a default deadzone of 5% and a 50% on the Averaging Slider. All of these must be manually adjusted to minimum by the user, for each individual axis. When you have done this for X you save, then you must repeat this process for Y and save, then Z, and save, then select the brake lever, repeat and save, select X mini stick and save, select Y mini stick and save, select the Secondary trigger and save, and then you would need to repeat this again for the second stick, if you have one.
Software evolves and its easy to update so I am sure things will get streamlined in future releases. As I said, mine shipped with each axis was set to 5% deadzone by default. t seems crazy to put such a total effort over two years into making a super precise sensor and then adding a big fat deadzone by default. A deadzone is a physical or electronic section within the gimbals range of reporting, that is usually at the neutral mid point. The dead zone, as the name implies is a section of the range which is dead and reports Null change. If you have a Deadzone set of 5%, any joystick will report no deviation from center until you have deflected either 5% positive or 5% negative in that axis. This means the middle 5% of the total range, does nothing. 5% default out of the box is 5% too much on a joystick of this price point. Being able to adjust Deadzone for a specific reason is a nice feature for unusual setups with very light springs, cams with zero center point bump, or to achieve some other special behavior. I might need to add 1 or 2% deadzone to control a cheap imprecise controller that likes to drift around. I might need to add 1 or 2% deadzone to control sticks with very short travel, such as a analog thumbstick on a gamepad. 5% deadzone by default makes precise aiming or precise flight very and frustrating for no reason.
I spoke about this also with the Turtle Beach Flight Stick Review. Transitioning through the midpoint can not be seamless with deadzone. Imagine you are aiming at a moving target and it changes direction. When you enter the deadzone, your craft completely stops tracking. Your aim is instantly broken and you need to reset and start again, giving your enemy a huge advantage anytime they decide to change direction.
For the first 5 minutes of my fresh out of the box experience, I was confused and really worried for Flicon because I couldn't land, fly or aim with precision. Things improved when I saw where the settings were. The lowest I was able to reduce the deadzone to was 1%. This needs to be able to go all the way to zero deadzone and that needs to become the default when the product is shipped to you. Being used to Virpil, VKB and Thrustmaster, with zero deadzone resulted in that bit of frustration throughout the review period. I have confidence that the EVO sensor is precise enough to operate without a deadzone and this is something that can be instantly patched out with software. Its likely that thig may already be addressed unless you are one of the very early adopters.
So in summary, this gimbal in general has a great design, is built very well, the current software deadzone makes it behave with less fidelity than expected at this price point and it did not achieve the same experience as its competition. When we can set the deadzone to none, this issue should go away. Moving on with more observations.
A gimbals resistance will come from cams and springs. Sometimes a thick dust boot introduces its own resistance forces. VKB completely redesigned the Gunfighter to have the softest boot on the market. Honestly, its as if there is no boot attached and it adds nothing extra, which is ideal. Virpil also provides a near minimal resistance on WarBrd D and the Flicon also scored major points with their boot design.
In 2024, the consumer expects extras at this price point such as drag clutches on each main axis. Within the Flicon gimbal, drag clutches are tucked inside the mechanism on the X and Y axis, near the sensor. These are adjusted from below, through two special holes on both the Desk Plate and the Mount Plate Adapter. Feeding the included Allen wrench through either of these holes allows you to quickly add or subtract drag friction. The process is perfect and easy as the allen wrench lines up every time. It is therefore possible to control all unwanted oscillation, or stick slap back, upon grip release. When fully relaxed, the church adds zero effect. When fully engaged, they will practically lock the stick in place. You can use this feature to achieve a Z throttle. Removing the springs from the left Y axis, and applying friction instead, you can achieve a hybrid HOTAS dual stick, that many seem to enjoy. You can also achieve a workable helicopter deadstick like other gimbals, with an appropriate feeling if these are set quite tight near their reasonable limit. The drag pads and drag cylinder here are smaller than those found on the WarBrd D and CM3. Going all the way back to highschool physics, you might remember that a larger lever is more effective. A larger diameter circles is a larger lever and also have more surface area that can apply more friction. Bigger Clutch, result in more friction potential spread out over the larger area. The point of comparison is, the competition, with its much larger clutch is able to provide more friction to offset more torque, or provide equal resistance with less mechanical strain because its spread out over a larger surface area. The small size clutch will probably last forever unless you play many hours each day, or have the clutch engaged at a high level all the time. When friction is and wear is concerned, bigger is usually better. The clutch being used here is more than up to the required task for most users. It is a part that can be easily replaced in a couple of minutes with simple tools.
I will summarize the Gimbal before I move on. The Gimbal is built well and very precise even at this price point. It has the potential to achieve a perfectly smooth operation and great tuning options. Once the dead zone concerns can be addressed, I believe it will go toe to toe with many on the market. You have the expected cam options from āspace and aviationā included and choice between light medium or strong springs, plus those extra holes in the cams for extra tuning. Add to that Friction clutches to settle out some oscillation and you are left with a complete set of tuning options.
I just said that the gimbal has āthe potentialā to achieve a perfectly smooth operation, and earlier in the intro I mentioned there was a powder coating added to the cams after machining. I spent hours testing an assortment of grips on their table mounts trying to figure this next issue out, because it made no sense and I had never experienced it. A more gritty feeling than normal when moving the grip about its range. Not extra resistance, but feeling as if there was a very very fine sand somewhere inside. I changed through all of the included cams to isolate a one off error. The issue could be replicated. Flicon was a bit gritty, VKB Gunfighter was not, Virpil WarBrd D was not. I thought about it, took it apart, cleaned it, adjusted it, tried a light oil, tried a light grease. I compared the cams from Flicon and Virpil under magnification, and only then it all made sense. The gritty feeling and slightly bumpy texture was the power coating, interacting with the cam bearing and because there are two cams, this feeling would be amplified into the grip and into your hand. It became more apparent with larger springs and for the purposes of the review, its important to remember that what is being tested here, are basically very early release products which are likely bordering on prototype.
This issue, just like the the dead zone can be easily addressed by redesigning the process that the cams are made. If it were my choice, I would Mill them out of 304 or 316 Stainless to a precise polish. I might coat the raw polished cam lightly with oil, and completely forget the powder coating step. The new cam would need to be made out of slightly thicker stock to account for the lack of the extra coating. Most importantly, where the roller and cam meet, there would only be polished metal rolling on machined cam. No texture or extra feeling of grit and with the hardness of 304 or 316, the cam would last forever. Buy the Best Once and Only Cry Once, I believe is the saying.
We expect the smoothest experience from our controllers and we expect them to last. A pretty big rookie mistake that would have been picked up if Flicon payed more attention when copying the competition. A footnote to this is that I did try to apply a Virpil Cam to the Flicon Evo, but the size of the mounting hole, plus the Virpil cam being made out of much thicker stock made this impossible.
Lets speak about the Grip.
The Flicon EVO Grip mark 1 is available in both Left and Right hand options. Perfect for controlling your fleet of space ships. The cloning is carried over here too. The side profile shares a distinctive Xenomorph silhouette with another popular grip on the market. It is molded out of a great feeling polymer with a solid build. Not made heavy for nothing and where the grip meets the twist its well reinforced to prevent flex. The Z axis can be locked with the small allen by twisting the internal screw.
When compared to the original Alpha grip, the overall feeling is similar and will accommodate many hand sizes with two included interchangeable wrist wrests. Pilots with very small hands should actually look to VKB Kosmosima Grip as an alternative. Individual ergonomics do change with hand sizes and It very evident that Flicon did a lot of testing, because the layout is consistently great. I have smaller hands, so I did have trouble reaching the pinky switch, but its impossible to make a grip that is perfect for everyone.
The Bindings are unique with some interesting options. There is a reaction lag of over 1 second in the software between when you push the binding and when it changes on the screen. I tested in the windows GUI, āUSB Controllerā and got a real time indication which was a relief.
The bindings are as follows
1 and 2 is the main two stage trigger, its currently really bad. Not good at all, but more on that later.
3 4 5 are three user definable bindings that are part of the secondary flippy trigger. Flip up is 3, flip down activates binding 4 and when the trigger is pulled to contact the main trigger, 5 becomes active. Pulling even more will bottom out on the main trigger which will also activate 1 and 2, with 5. Hopefully that makes sense. 3,4 and 5 each have a set of user defined ranges allowing you to set exactly when each become active, which I really like. This second flippy trigger is also set to report an analog axis in conjunction with 3.4,5. Starting at 0 to 100 as you pull. Because there is a mechanical catch with the flip, you will have no choice but to go from 0 directly to 15%. You may then pull smoothly from 15 to 85% and the last 85 to 100% is a pull through the primary trigger. This is cool, for games that you can manually force set a binding such as DCS or MS Flight. In a game such as Star Citizen, with no way to disable this axis, binding this trigger becomes somewhat of nightmare. You click, the software waits for an input to bind. This trigger often confuses the binding system because your trigger pull starts reporting multiple inputs. Through trial and error, this can be overcome.
6 is push down click on the mini joystick
7 is the red push button
8 is the black push button
9 is click down on the mouse wheel
10 is deep click down on the mouse wheel
11 is the pinky momentary
12 is momentary click mouse roll wheel up
13 is momentary click mouse roll wheel down
14 is a momentary binding associated with the brake lever.
The brake lever also has an analog axis this can be set by the user.
15, 16 17, is the 3 way Finger Rocker on the side. Up Down and Push.
18 is push down on the Thumb Castle and then it gets a bit weird. 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24,25, 26 are 8 cardinal directions of this Thumb Castle. 19, 21, 23, 25 are up down left right like normal. Normally with a hat you can push up and left and you will get both binding for up and left at the same time. But in this case. 20, 22, 24, 26 are the diagonal bindings between up down left right. Pushing on an angle, you get a completely different binding. If the game title can not accommodate this, you are left with no ability to input diagonal. Flicon, please add the ability to toggle this to a standard 4 way with a push in software. For example, when the user pushes up and left, both 19 and 23 would light up. Pushing down as I said is binding 18, but you can also not push down and use any of the 8 directions on this castle switch at the same time. I normally use Up Down Left Right for my translational thruster and I am also able to push down for boost at the same time. I am not able to implement this, because its one other the other when using the thumb castle. Flicon please also add the ability to toggle how 18 behaves, so 18 can be used at the same times as the other bindings from 19 through 26. When the user pushes18 down and 25 Right for example. 18 and 25 should both light up, not one or the other.
27 is push in on the top cap hat switch, 28, 30 32 34 are Up Down Left Right. 29, 31, 33, 35 are the diagonals and this hat works the same as the thumb castle switch. An 8 Way with push.
With the Grip attached to the Gimbal we have the following axes.
X / Y and Z Twist. After the Averaging and Deadzone are set to minimum, they react well. Averaging is a smoothing filter that should not be used unless you have a specific need. It numbs and dumbs down input, introducing lag and making it hard to not overshoot while aiming or precise flight. We had spoken about the axis on the secondary trigger We had spoken about the axis on the the brake lever. There are two axis, X and Y on the mini stick. It moves very nicely and will not bind to a side when pushed to an extreme. I was unable to remove the averaging filter applied to it by default. This makes it difficult to be precise with, so Flicon, can you please investigate the ability to set the Averaging and Deadzone on these axis to zero. The buttons were comparable to Standard Alpha Grip with most having a positive tactile click. Good overall here and Im sure there will be the regular back and forth on the forums about who has the better buttons, but nothing is out of the ordinary.
The primary trigger on the other hand, is, in my opinion, really bad, to the point where I contacted them a couple weeks ago to express my concerns. First was that rounding off the end of an already short trigger is simply crazy. Those who are familiar with shooting generally use the end of a trigger to achieve more precision. The end is a better lever and you can become very precise more quickly, here. Even if you have never shot a weapon, this is still normally the natural place that many contact, without knowing it.
There are 63 unique joysticks in my collection. All of them, without a single exception have the same shape. No matter if they are replicas of real grips, or crazy futuristic grips to drive mechs or fly space ships. I continue to be totally dumbfounded because earlier I said it was clear that lots of research and testing must have been done to get the grip design polished. So what the hell happened with the trigger, Did this slip by the approval committee? Who decided to disregard two hundred and sixty seven years of trigger design? 63 with the same shape in my studio. One that is different, and I wouldn't mind, if it was easier to use or somehow better, but its not.
We tend to use the meaty section of the furthest part of the index finger, or the meaty section of the next furthest part of the index in certain situations who need even more precision. We tend to use the lower part of the trigger, staying clear of the upper part that is closest to the grip case. The round shape⦠makes it impossible to enjoy. You must deal with fighting a finger that slips out and off where you normally contact, or mess about with the upper part of the trigger, which feels even worse due to the odd radius and how the trigger is pinned. A short rounded trigger for nothing, and it hobbled my precision. I am constantly frustrating when trying to use this grip. Along with this was also the subject of the trigger pull and tuning. When pulling the trigger, the first stage click requires significant force and is quite inconsistent. This seems to be due to extra friction where the trigger meets the grip case, which can be relaxed by loosening the screw that holds the grip together, but then I get a slight wiggle. The second stage click of the main trigger occurs where it should, when the trigger bottoms out, but on mine, there is no tactile click on the right grip, and there is on the left. This can be addressed with better quality control or a slight revision to the assembly process. I will say, as we come close to the end of the review, that all of the negative points addressed are things that are either solved in software or better QC or redesigning parts such as cams and triggers. Its clear that lots of work, care and consideration was invested to bring this to market. I said that for a first release, this is a solid product and it only needs a bit more care to address a couple details to allow it to stand on equal ground to the product it was inspired by. Its perhaps risky to be an early adopter of Mark 1 and as a person who appreciates a good effort, it gives me no pleasure say this as part of my review.
Im being to hard on the product its because I know by addressing the last 5% that the product will be end up being great. I invite you to express your comments and findings within the Comments section of the video. I rely heavily on your feedback to improve the content and delivery. Flicon also relies heavily on our feedback to improve their product, which we all want as consumers. Competition is good for us, so thank you Flicon for releasing the EVO. One of the best first product launches I have ever seen, and the potential to be close to perfect. Thanks for spending your time with me.