I've been rewatching them all as a big Wes Craven fan so I did head-to-head matchups with all 20 of Wes Craven's movies until I had a final ranking. This is based on those I think are the best with a little bias here and there for guilty pleasures :-)
Spoilers ahead...
**20. The Hills Have Eyes Part II (1985)**
It's nice to see Michael Berryman back, but that's about it. The movie is weird, tonally off-putting, poorly written, and clearly a desperate cash grab from Craven during a slump. It leans on flashbacks to pad the runtime. It's unimaginative and has almost nothing to redeem it. At least Vampire in Brooklyn had some effort behind it.
**19. Vampire in Brooklyn (1995)**
I avoided this one for the longest time because I can't take Eddie Murphy seriously. Then a small online reassessment convinced me to give it a shot as camp. I did. It still wasn't great. Wes and Eddie were clearly at odds. From what I've read, Eddie wanted a true horror film and Wes knew the best bet was a horror comedy. It falls flat because Wes tries to squeeze a comedic tone out of a serious script, and everything comes off off-putting, unfunny, not scary, and kind of weird. Angela Bassett is the highlight, like she is in anything.
**18. Swamp Thing (1982)**
Swamp Thing has a better script and more effort behind it than some movies higher on this list, but the production value and budget have aged terribly. It's a good story, and it was well received back in the early 80s. Visually, though, it hasn't held up. It's hard to watch with a straight face when the suit is clearly falling apart on camera. I feel bad for not loving it more. It's a good movie for its time, just painfully dated.
**17. Music of the Heart (1999)**
Another good movie that just doesn't interest me. Wes wanted to break out of horror and did a good job, but he picked the most run-of-the-mill feel-good story he could find. He played it so safe it left no impression beyond a gold star for effort. It's one of those perfectly fine movies made to be a little feel-good hit and then die in anonymity, which is exactly what it did. Craven succeeded in a lot of ways here. He just played it way too safe and should have picked a more interesting story.
**16. Deadly Friend (1986)**
I only recently watched this one. It has such a reputation that I didn't want to be disappointed, and overall I wasn't! Wes made a fantasy drama and the studio demanded a horror movie late in the game, so it got heavily reshot. All the last-minute gore shows, but there's still stuff worth appreciating here, and I think it deserves a camp-value reassessment in the age of AI. I liked the lead's descent into madness as he gets desperate to save Samantha. There's a little Frankenstein in it too. It's very dated and the studio interference made it a mess, but there's a lot of charm in the ambition, the story, the themes, and the camp.
**15. Deadly Blessing (1981)**
I've always been into religious horror and fascinated by the Amish, so the Hittite community pulled me right in. The movie has a lot of ups and downs. The story is engaging but it's a slog at times, with some standout sequences mixed in. The ending is a hot mess and kind of laughable, but I read the studio forced it. Wes's career was plagued by studio interference. He rarely got to make the movie he set out to make, and it usually shows in the endings. Still, this movie has atmosphere and a vibe to it that gives it a little extra staying power despite so many flaws.
**14. My Soul to Take (2010)**
I know a lot of people will be bewildered this is so high. The script is an absolute mess. Still, this movie fascinates me. It has so many ideas that it would've worked better as a miniseries so Wes could flesh them all out. I love the concept of the harvester of souls. A serial killer everyone believed had multiple personalities really had multiple souls, and when he's killed, those souls reincarnate and he comes back to collect them.
I think it would've been better if Wes dropped the whodunit, made the Ripper a straight-up supernatural killer, and gave the Riverton Seven more room instead of killing them off so fast. But a lot works for me. I love the way it looks. Great shots and atmosphere with the river town setting. The opening kill on the bridge is creepy, and the Ripper looks terrifying there. I also like the relationship between Bug and Alex.
A lot of the dialogue is unrealistic, and the Fang subplot is just weird. Why is she still in school? Why is everyone her minion? How does she have all that power? It's a much older Wes Craven trying to write sharp teenagers, and it doesn't work. But I still find it charming, and I always find something new in it. I don't know why. I wish someone would remake it and retell Wes's core story in a compelling way.
**13. Cursed (2005)**
Another movie that was almost entirely reshot after it was 90% finished, all because of studio interference. It's not the narrative mess some people claim. It's a pretty simple, coherent story, and everything flows naturally into the next thing. The real problems are the CGI and the tone. I wonder if the well-known production trouble colors how people see it, because I don't think it's anywhere near as bad as its reputation. Yes, it's campy and the CGI is rough. It's also fucking fun. So much fun. The entire cast is fantastic. It comes down to whether you can get past the CGI and a downright campy tone. I can. I love this movie but I know it's not perfect. I would kill for the Craven cut, but it bombed, so we'll never see it.
**12. The Last House on the Left (1972)**
I love the story and respect its cult classic status. It's an exploitation film that even Roger Ebert loved. But I love it from a distance. It's a little too nihilistic for me. Rape and murder, two young girls going through that much horror, all in such a realistic, almost documentary style. It's hard to watch. Wes almost always had optimistic endings, which is probably a big reason I'm such a fan, so I appreciate that he produced the remake and that it ends a little more triumphantly. It's a great early 70s exploitation film and I can see why it launched his career. It's this high because I know how good it is, not because I love it that much.
**11. The Serpent and the Rainbow (1988)**
A hidden gem. It was well received when it came out but wasn't a big commercial hit. There are a lot of terrifying scenes, and you can see him channeling some of what he pulled off in the first Nightmare. It drags at times in between the big moments, but Bill Pullman is great as the lead and the story is really interesting. I'd love to see it remade with modern effects, more budget, and a little more flair.
**10. The Hills Have Eyes (1977)**
Just an awesome story. Doug is the unlikely hero, half the family dies all at once in a bold, unexpected way, and the survivors have to step up. Doug is so underrated, and the lengths he goes to to save his baby and the rest of his in-laws feel so triumphant. I saw the Craven-produced remake first, which follows the original closely with some added lore. I'll never forget it. I hated Doug, then loved Doug, then was sure Doug was going to die, and was so relieved when he came out on top. The mutants were terrifying, and the camper attack was so horrifying I was scared watching it in broad daylight. I loved it so much I tracked down the original and found basically the same movie, just on a much smaller budget and more visually dated. I love both to this day, and I'd love to see more in this universe.
**9. The People Under the Stairs (1991)**
The title is so ominous that sometimes I wish I could watch a more serious, grounded version. But I still love it for being thrilling, campy, funny, scary, and endearing all at once. Fool is a great lead. It was bold of Wes to write and direct a movie centered on Black characters with this much racial and social commentary, and he pulled it off. So much of it is over the top, but that works because the horrors in that house are larger than life, and Fool has to make it out alive and free everyone held captive along the way. It's rare for a movie with this many elements to work this well. The horror, the humor, the camp, the commentary... somehow it all just works. A few years back I read that Monkeypaw (Jordan Peele's company) was going after a remake. I'd love to see it.
**8. Red Eye (2005)**
To me, Red Eye shows Wes's greatest strength. He's so character-focused and gets the best out of his actors. He was a director for hire here, and he elevates the material through the performances he gets. It's almost entirely isolated to a plane, and the tension keeps building. It never slows down or drags, and he doesn't pad the runtime. It's a great psychological survival thriller, and the third act puts his slasher energy on display with the chase through the airport and the house. Some people knock it for going slasher at the end, but I love it, because Wes was always great at nail-biting, high-octane third acts.
**7. Shocker (1989)**
Another one Wes wrote and directed, and he was clearly trying to outdo Freddy. He doesn't, and like a lot of the movies he wrote himself, he crams in way too many ideas instead of committing to one or two and fleshing them out. Still, Shocker is a downright fun mess. I love Jonathan as the lead and I love the zany camp. My favorite parts are the travel through electricity and TVs and the wild third act. It's such a vibe despite the obvious flaws. If I could tighten it up, I'd cut the ghost girlfriend subplot, spend less time on body hopping, and focus more on using electricity to stop him. Imagine a remake with clearer rules, where Pinker can only travel through electricity and they get creative with cutting power to trap him or going off grid to escape. So many missed opportunities, but I still love this wild mess. I always have a damn good time.
**6. Scream 4 (2011)**
I know, I'm piling all the Scream and Nightmare movies at the top. I just love them. Scream 4 was so refreshing when it came out. Wes was coming off the huge failure of My Soul to Take, and even though 4 has some tonal whiplash like 3, it just feels like Thanksgiving. The family's back together and everybody brought their favorite dish. Wes goes off the wall in the third act, which is the movie's biggest strength. Gale, Dewey, and Sidney all bring their best, and Jill is an awesome reveal. It's like a greatest hits album with a few new tracks we might not love as much, but it all still feels great.
**5. Scream 3 (2000)**
Scream 3 has worked its way up my list. I don't see the futuristic voice changer as a silly gimmick anymore. Watching in 2026, it feels relevant and aging well. And sadly, the movie's take on rape culture in Hollywood has aged so well that in hindsight it plays like a direct shot at Harvey Weinstein. It's a tonal detour, to say the least. It really embraces the humor, but the humor works, and it still gets serious when it counts, especially with its themes and anything involving Sidney. The third act isn't exactly earned, but it's still really satisfying. It's the first time it's just Sidney vs. the killer, a fight to the finish with no one saving her, though Dewey gets the final shot and is very useful in this one. Parker Posey is so much fun, and even with the full-on camp, I buy that that's just who Jennifer is. Messy elements, a weak script, major tonal issues, and there's still so much to love and so much rewatchability.
**4. Wes Craven's New Nightmare (1994)**
One of the coolest, cleverest, most inventive scripts ever. I love all the meta stuff. A demon is breaking into the real world through the character of Freddy, and you see it in his torn skin and in the earthquakes. The only way to stop him is for Heather to play Nancy one last time. And it's not just a clever meta story about actors and characters. It also shows how Freddy became an icon and how the actors, especially Heather, are haunted by it and living in its shadow. Heather gives her best performance here.
It's a character-first slow burn, which is my thing, so that's a huge compliment. It takes its time worldbuilding, and once we hit the hospital it ramps up and never lets go. Julie's death. The highway scene and its imagery (some people laugh at the effects, but I think they look amazing for their time and have a haunting quality). John becoming her father again. Freddy rising from the bed as Heather turns around, sees the Elm Street house, and accepts her role as Nancy. ICONIC to me.
I love Freddy's lair, but I wish it had been a little more inventive, like running through rooms that look like sets from the earlier films. Love the Hansel and Gretel setup too. The final effects aren't great, but neither are the final effects in Dream Warriors or the original, so I'm not knocking it for that. And I love that it ends with them reading the script lines that close out the movie. Heather stopped a real demon from entering our world by putting on her pajamas and playing Nancy Thompson one last time. Such a great movie.
**3. Scream 2 (1997)**
Scream 2 knew it was an inferior sequel, and that's exactly what made it a top-tier one. It absolutely nails the commentary on sequels and why they're inferior. The opening is iconic, and the whole cast is as great as the first. Chase scenes and set-piece galore, all contenders for the best of the 90s. Derek is a great character, and Mickey brought a unique manipulative quality to Ghostface. He's in Sidney's ear the whole movie making her doubt Derek, and that leads directly to Derek dying in front of her when she fails to untie him. I love the reverse Friday the 13th reference of making the mother the killer in the sequel, and Laurie Metcalf is top tier as a deranged, desperate, maniacal Ghostface. Gale gets her best arc in the franchise, Dewey becomes more central, and the events of this movie send Sidney into isolation and darkness. She also becomes a true fighter here, and the way her theater role plays into that works great. Scream felt smaller and more intimate, small-town vibes. Scream 2 feels bigger, almost operatic.
**2. A Nightmare on Elm Street (1984)**
The most imaginative slasher ever made up to that point. Wes always had wild ideas, and here they work to absolute perfection. Not only did he give us a terrifying, well-told story about a supernatural killer who kills teenagers in their dreams, he gave us Nancy Thompson, the first final girl of her kind. She's not blindsided by a surprise killer in the third act and stuck in a 15-minute chase until a passerby on a dirt road picks her up or a doctor shows up just in time to shoot the killer. Nancy is aware and proactive, and she fights her demon alone. She systematically figures out how he operates and how to use what she learns to beat him. She begs for help, nobody helps, and she wins anyway, defeating him by no longer being afraid. Nancy, Freddy, and this movie are all GOATED.
**1. Scream (1996)**
There's bias here. Scream was my first horror movie, and it's what made me go back and fall in love with all the classics. It's one of the few horror movies up to that point where every character has something to say. They're not wasting time talking about cute boys. They're talking about what's happening around them, reacting to it, commenting on it, being self-aware and self-referential. Such a smart, timely script. Gale is one of the best characters ever written in a horror franchise. She's a smart antihero who's right about literally everything, saves Sidney, wins in the end, and eventually transforms.
Beyond all the meta fun, people forget there's a really eerie story going on. Sidney is holding back socially, sexually, and emotionally because of her mother's rape and murder. She has to come to terms with her mother being someone she didn't recognize and her boyfriend manipulating her and trying to kill her, and she loses almost all her friends, including the two who betrayed her. It has the greatest opening scene of any slasher and one of the wildest endings. Smart script, great characters, perfectly performed, directed, and executed. 1 and 2 are interchangeable for me. Scream gets the edge for making me a lifelong horror fan.