r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 01 '13

SAG's plant lighting guide linked together

155 Upvotes

last update: 30 May 2025- added more /r/BudScience posts

  • my lab setup - I post pics like this because there’s a lot of bro-science and misinformation about horticulture lighting on the internet. I back my claims with hands-on experience and peer-reviewed research. In this setup, I’m safety testing cheap "quantum boards" to UL 1598 standards, something you unfortunately won’t see anyone else doing.

I'm not a commercial cannabis grower, but have considerable experience with cannabis and wide range of other plants. I'm a former union industrial electrician (IBEW local 46, Seattle) and have worked with lighting systems from a few watts DIY setups, to black/gray market grow operations with many thousands of watts, to megawatt lighting installations at Boeing factories.

I insta-block trolls and move on.


TL;DR:

90% of what you need to know as a hobby grower is right here:

  • Get a "quantum board"Ā® or array style grow light using Samsung LM301 style LEDs, with the LM301H EVO being the latest and greatest, and slightly better than the other LM301 LEDs.

  • Examples of good LED drivers are Mean Well, Sosen, and Inventronics. An ultra cheap light typically has an ultra cheap LED driver, some which I have tested to be very dangerous electrically.

  • Flower at 40 watts per square foot to maximize your yields per grow area/volume for LM301 LEDs. Don't go much below 30 watts per square foot. Not enough light means weak plants with loose buds. Train your plants!

  • For PPFD to lux conversion, use 72 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec for most white LED grow lights without red LEDs added. Generally veg cannabis at around 35-40 klx, flower around 70 klx (higher with CO2 enhancement). You can go lower with a linear reduction in yield and potentially quality.

  • I recommend a $20 lux meter with a remote sensor head for PPFD/lux measurements. Have the sensor head pointing straight up and not necessarily at the light source when taking a measurement. Phones can way off unless the have the proper external cosine correction.



Links to my posts and cheat sheet


Latest good cannabis papers to know:



Links to open access papers



Most popular and latest articles

More articles below.



What to buy as a hobbyist

TL;DR: get a grow light using Samsung LM301 style LEDs with the LM301H EVO being the latest and greatest. Use >40 watts per square foot to maximize your yields per grow area and volume. Keep it above 30 watts per square foot. /thread

Need to quickly know what type of light to get as a hobbyist? I would recommend a quantum board type light with Samsung LM301 LEDs and Mean Well LED drivers. You'll pay a little more upfront but you'll save on electricity down the road and have lower heat while also having an LED driver that is going to last for many years. Note- "quantum board" is a trademarked name by HLG although the term is widely used in the hobby community and there are many places selling these types of lights.

A cheap "600w" LED grow light you might find on Amazon or eBay is not drawing anything close to 600 watts, nor is it 600 watt equivalent to anything particularly HPS (high pressure sodium) lighting. It's a deceptive marketing practice and they will not perform as advertised. I've seen 50 true watt lights advertised as "600w". Same with the "1000w" and other lights. Also, you can't make a claim like "a 600w light is really a 100 true watt light" because the real power draw numbers are all over the place because there are no standards and many people don't understand true power draw. Their cheap LEDs are also going to be significantly less electrically efficient compared to quality grow lights, and they will put out around 40-50% less light per amount of energy usage on top of cheap LEDs tending to not last as long as high end LEDs. Do not buy these types of lights. More on this below.

COB lights are another option but only buy Bridgelux or Cree grow lights, again with a Mean Well LED driver. If you like to DIY then building a COB grow light is the way to go particularly with a mechanically robust Mean Well LED driver. As a strong warning, I refer to AC driverless COBs as "suicide lights" for DIY. More on the dangers of AC driverless COBs below and why you should never use them particularly for DIY. No, no...no!


If you know the stuff above including the above lux meter article then you honestly don't need to go further unless you want to understand theory along with reading some of my rantings. At the end of the day most people just want to know what light to get but if you're serious about plant growing then you also want the light meter.

But, if you want to see me rant.....



Don't get scammed and a note on cheaper Chinese grow lights using generic or EpiLED LEDs

Let me start by saying I simply loath what I feel are scammers making faulty claims about their lights and make an example of one. In my honest opinion, the worst I've seen are lights by LEDtonic.

When you are selling a low end grow light for twice the price per watt as other low end Chinese grow lights and claiming, or so much as alluding to, that they can provide good growth at 12 watts per square foot with low end LEDs, is making a non-sense claim and you will end up with weak and lanky plants. It's stuff like this and people getting taken advantage of that makes me live up to my user name.

A 50 watt LED grow light is not a "600W" light and that is a bad claim. No one else is claiming 50 watts is a 600 watt equivalent light except for people trying to be deceptive or acting in bad faith. This is true today and was true over 10 years ago when I first started publicly calling these types of people out in publications like Maximum Grow Magazine. Don't do business with deceptive people no matter how many pretty charts they have. A quality light like by HLG or Atreum will put out over two times the light per price as will many cheaper Chinese quantum boards that use high quality Samsung LEDs (good luck with a warranty from lights bought off of AliExpress, though). The quality of the LEDs makes all the difference as does the LED driver (Mean Well LED drivers are world class).

Most cheap Chinese grow lights that claim to be equivalent to a 600 watt light actually put out more light than that LEDtonic light, despite their claim, because most that make that claim are above 100 watts of LEDs rather than 50 watts using the same types of low end LEDs.

This is why I call LEDtonic in particular the worst deal in grow lights. Don't do business with people who play these sort of games. Mars Hydro and the like also have a history of playing the "600W" and "1000W" game. Good people don't do this.

Currently, for low end Chinese grow lights, you want about 50 watts per square foot for robust flowering of cannabis. For high end LEDs (Samsung, Cree, Osram etc) this is about 30 watts per square foot. Anyone telling you differently is likely trying to sell you something. I like closer to 40-50 watts of high end LEDs per square foot if I want to drive a plant hard.

Also, there is no "magic" lighting spectrum for growing plants and even different cultivars of the same plant type can react differently to light. Sweet basil, purple basil, and lettuce leaf basil can all react differently to light, for example. But generally speaking light quantity (the amount of light) is more important than light quality (the specific spectrum).

This is not to say that lighting spectrum plays no role in plants but many of the benefits have to do with light sensitive protein manipulation (photomorphogenesis) rather than photosynthesis, with results such as making red variety of lettuce even more red or trying to boost trichomes in cannabis. There are research companies that do light profile plants by wavelength and most of this information is proprietary.

Down below is a sample of grow light makers that have integrity by selling quality lights using high end LEDs and LED drivers. Never buy a grow light that is advertised at less than 2.0 μmol/joule which will be explained. Buying a $50 UFO style LED grow light for a space bucket grow is an exception.


A quick note on spectrum and green light

TL;DR what you were likely taught about green light and plants was wrong and here's why.

Here is a spectral reflectivity profile of a high nitrogen marijuana leaf (Jack Herer). About 90% of the green light is being absorbed (it's on an 18% reflective gray card used in photography) although many plants may be closer to 80% absorption. Plants can use green light and at higher lighting levels green is more photosynthetically efficient than red (pdf file). All the latest research and my own experiments back this claim back the claim that plants use green light.

This is because the top layer of chloroplasts that contains chlorophyll becomes saturated while green light can penetrate deeper in to leaf tissue (sieve effect) and reflected around until absorbed by another chloroplast containing chlorophyll (detour effect) or by an accessory pigment. This efficiency can be measure through chlorophyll fluorescence or a gas exchange chamber.

Green light used alone tends to cause a lot of elongation (stretching) due to triggering the shade avoidance response. High pressure sodium lights have a lot of green/yellow/amber light which is why they do so well and are still the standard in large scale horticulture lighting. Catch 22- green/yellow/amber LEDs all have a relatively low electrical efficiency compared to blue/red.

More information that postulates why plants are green can be found here. (pdf)

Ours eyes have a combined sensitivity curve where the peak of our sensitivity is also were the peak reflectivity is going to be for a green plant. (The individual sensitivity of our 3 color sensitive cone cells in our eyes is this).

So, it's true plants do reflect more green light than red or blue, but the way we perceive light is naturally much higher biased for green light (555 nm sensitivity peak which is the same as a green plant's reflectivity peak). This fact means that less electrically efficient green LEDs can still be used in red/green/blue LEDs and we wouldn't perceive the difference. Most green LEDs are about 525 nm or so, which is outside the peak reflectivity of a green plant, but because of the electrical inefficiency of green LEDs relative to red and blue LEDs, white LEDs that have a large green component would be typically used instead (the vast majority of white LEDs are actually a blue LEDs with a phosphor). One problem with red/green/blue LEDs used alone for general illumination is color shadowing and very low CRI (color rendering index) which is why white LEDs are used instead.

It should be noted that the maximum absorption for chlorophyll in leaves in vivo (in a living plant) is 675-680 nm (chlorophyll A) and not 660 nm as often cited (chlorophyll B is about 645 nm). This can be seen in this spectrometer shot of a chlorotic (yellow) leaf as a dip in the 675-680 nm range from small amounts of chlorophyll A left over. The blue absorption seen are carotenoids which have perhaps a 30-70% efficiency at transferring the absorbed light energy to a photosynthetic reaction center through chlorophyll A. Chlorophyll B is an accessory pigment and higher land plants do not contain chlorophyll C-F. Depending on the plant, there may be 3-7 chlorophyll A molecules for every chlorophyll B molecule but mostly around a 3:1 ratio.

Fun fact! Older plants leaves are not as photosynthetically efficient as newer plant leaves. This has been known about for well over 50 years now.


Be careful of improper use of pigment charts

LED grow light manufacturers/resellers often use the incorrect chlorophyll dissolved in a solvent charts or algae charts to back their claims that specific wavelengths are needed for photosynthesis. The correct chart is found here in chart C (pdf file from LiCor- the scientific standard in plant light meters and photosynthesis measurement test gear). This is the McCree(1972) curve based on an average of 22 different plants which shows 550nm green is more efficient than 450nm blue (blue gets absorbed by some other pigments in addition to chlorophyll) and is the chart used in plant photobiology. The McCree curve is only valid at about 15-150 umol/m2/sec of monochromatic light and is most certainly not the be-all and end all-in in lighting spectrum charts. But, it's a good starting point and much more honest.

If you find a chart with a deep dip in the green area then it's for some sort of algae or bacteria, not green terrestrial plants. If you find a chart with a bunch of chlorophyll and other pigment peaks then it's only valid as an extract in vitro (in the test tube or cuvette) and not in vivo (the living leaf itself). The pigment peaks can differ depending on the solvent used and the charts do not tell how much there is of a particular pigment so take them with a grain of salt. They are only valid for the particular set up used.

Most biology text books get the above paragraphs wrong by not giving clear context to these charts or by omitting the McCree curve chart altogether.



Current better LED grow lights on the market

TL;DR: Samsung LM301 LEDs with a Mean Well driver. The Samsung LM301H EVO is the latest and greatest. There's not much difference with the Samsung LM301H and the LM301B except binning and the H has some anti-corrosion protection. The LM301D is designed to be over-driven so lights only need half the LEDs. The D version is not as efficient as the other version.

Don't buy a grow light that is rated for under 2.5 or so μmol/joule! Space Buckets should be the only exception to this. The seller should state this number somewhere on their web page. If they don't then you are likely buying a low quality light, however, just because this number is listed does not necessarily make the LED grow light a higher quality light. Name brand LEDs and LED drivers with a solid industry wide reputation makes a quality light first and foremost.

The gold standard for a pro grow light is the μmol/joule rating (μmol/J for brevity, Joule is a unit of energy equal to one watt of power for one second). This means how much light does this light give off per energy by the grow light consumed. Joules is not the same as watts and this is one way I can tell if someone really understands theory.

I typically write "μmol" as "umol" or "uMol" when just typing away.

What a "uMol" is will be explained later (but it is a micro mole, one millionth of a mole or 6.02x1017 photons in this case). One can also take the PPF (photosynthetic photon flux) of the light fixture in umol/sec of light output and divide by total watts input to the light to derive the umol/joule rating. Don't get hung up if you don't understand this! My article on core concepts of plant lighting does get in to detail.

So, the higher umol/joule rating the better, but still costs and specific spectra to perhaps be considered (e.g. are they adding 735 nm LEDs to bump up the umol/joule number? Is that good or bad? I honestly don't know). You get what you pay for but the ROI (return on investment) for pro uses definitely is in favor for the top end lights particularly at higher energy costs. This was academically demonstrated in 2014 in a paper below where the HydroGrowLED Sol 9 came in last place at 0.9 umol/joule which should be expected when very cheap LEDs are being used. Funny enough, wild claims were being made by HydroGrowLED, like setting world records and getting over two grams per watt (using 2009 LEDs!), and this is the first time there was academic peer review showing she obviously making bad claims like people on many cannabis forums were stating repeatedly.

Never buy an LED grow light unless the light manufacturer is willing to give this uMol/joule number. I can not emphasize this enough. Very low end LED lights like the UFO LED and other cheap lights are currently right around 1.4-1.7 uMol/joule which is why they and similar lights should only be used for hobby purposes. Most also don't have reflectors or lenses to optimize LED lighting.

The quality LED grow light manufacturer will also be able to name the LED brand used. If not then don't buy for commercial/professional purposes. EpiLED and Epistar are not high quality name brand LEDs and that's a big red flag. In some cases Bridgelux LED chips may be bought to make LEDs. Bridgelux is of high quality on their LED COBs, like the Vero 18 and the Vero 29, but the LED chips can also be used in some lower quality products.

For commercial use with an electrical inspector in US/Canada, you'll want grow lights that are UL, ETL, CSA listed/marked or marks from other Nationally Recognized Testing Lab. Even for hobby use I strongly advise getting lights that have been safety tested by one of these labs. I do not trust the CE mark and it is not recognized in the US.

Current ASABE recommendation is at least 2.4 umol/joule but all modern pro lights are higher. The majority of other cheap LED grow lights I've found online would not meet this basic criteria.




All of the below was written around 2012-2015 and kept here for historic reasons. Some parts may be out of date



Original essays: (this was the original 2012 lighting guide)


Beginning of LED and LED grow light series (some parts out of date)

FAQ: the reason that LEDs are not more efficient and lose efficiency as more current is put through them has to do with Auger recombination otherwise known as the Auger effect or "droop". As of October 2019, top end blue LEDs can hit over 70% efficiency.


Four LED application notes every engineer should know


Additions


The aluminum foil debate

No, aluminum foil will not burn your plant. No, it won't burn. Once again, it won't burn. I couldn't even get tomato to burn outdoors with a crinkled Mylar reflector. Foil is a little over 90%-95% reflective as measured by my spectrometer with a diffused light source (it can be tricky to measure aluminum foil and most people are likely doing it wrong). Crinkled foil doesn't change this, it just diffuses the light more. It's not flammable (pdf). Use the shinny side of heavy duty 2mil foil. Triple folding it makes good stand alone reflectors. There are better reflectors than foil in some applications. Flat white paint with barium sulfate added can be in the high 90's (pdf file).


Some older pics

A sampling of white LEDs that I have tested with my spectrometer When I say you can use 70 lux = 1uMol/m2/sec with white LEDs and be within 10% I can back that claim up. These are all older LEDs and I have tested quite a few more.

full color chlorophyll fluorescent imaging leaf All the light/color you see here is through fluorescence from a 405nm laser

full color chlorophyll fluorescent imaging leaf saturated

same leaf under normal light

fluorescent imaging of plant with pH burn

green window with far red fluorescence

blue light scanning a cannabis leaf

inner light blue scan

photo diode used in lower cost PAR meters

SLT light sticks prototypes You can also see a green one lit up. I use violet, blue, green and red

blue light stress of cannabis This is 1000uMol/m2/sec of 450nm light for seven days

my electronics work area That's $8000-9000 worth of gear there and there is more

various corn techniques

spec plot of pink LED

spec plot of RGB LED These are at the same current levels.

RGB color shadowing

LED power supply noise

what light burn actually looks like

adding far red light to white light in a pepper plant

white versus minus blue light on a pepper plant

LST of Super Sweet 100 non-determinate tomato under HPS This strain is not normally grown indoors due to the size it can get.

leaf thickness scanner

tiny grow stations

effect of blue on sweet pea


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Aug 04 '21

Testing the most dangerous light (bloom plus grow BP1000) so far and why I'm such a cynic against shills

142 Upvotes

Testing the most dangerous light so far and some strong criticism

part of SAG's Lighting Guide

This is the light tested:

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B082Y1PMWF?psc=1&ref=ppx_yo2_dt_b_product_details

As a disclaimer, as always, I bought this light myself so there is no conflict of interest.

edit- spelling and just a bit of wordwmithing



The electrical safety test

Click the link on the light above and look at the one star ratings. What do you see? A bunch of people getting electrical shocks and the light overheating. When I first examined the light the first thing I noticed was some plastic insulators like this that immediately raised a red flag.

https://imgur.com/a/ZBKR8E3

Upon really close inspection I noticed that there was a thermal pad between the heat sink and the MCPCB (metal core printed circuit board and where all the parts are mounted). A thermal pad provides electrical insulation.

https://imgur.com/a/Azrfxdc

Hmmm....what's going on here? To confirm my suspicion I tested for continuity between the MCPCB and the heat sink and found them to be electrically isolated. So we have an energized circuit board that is not grounded although most people who don't know how to properly test lights would not notice, with a very thin plastic film over the energized components that does not provide adequate ingress protection, creating a situation that will get people killed although the light does appear grounded.

It's bullshit like this that is going to get people killed, and why I have an issue with people who have no idea what they are doing performing light "tests". How many of these YouTubers, who look like they know what they are doing by waving a light meter under a light, do you think would actually catch this fatal flaw in this light? None of them would because as far as I know none of them are properly trained or understand electrical safety.

You want to see a YouTuber who gets electrical safety? Check out the fellow electrician Big Clive.

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCtM5z2gkrGRuWd0JQMx76qA

I didn't even need to do a light meter test because what's the point if I'd never recommend the light in the first place. I did, though, and about eight inches away from the center is the 1000 umol/m2/sec point.



Thermal imaging pics

Here's some thermal shots of the light tested:

https://imgur.com/a/nkfLHb2 (2 thermal pics)

It's important to note that on the backside of the light, in the pic with my thermal imaging camera, the light appears to be fairly cool with a hot spot on the label. What's going on? The heat sink has a very low emissivity while that label has a very high emissivity that gives a true temperature reading. This is the problem with using cheap non-contact thermometers.

The light measures 70 degrees F above ambient and my rule is that a grow light should never run above 145 degrees F. This is a partial failure and why people are getting burns off the light beyond electrical shocks. I say partial failure because a small fan could keep the temperature down. Heat kills LEDs faster.



Spectroradiometer pics

https://imgur.com/a/FUrXAn8 (2 spectrometer pics)

The first pic is my spectroradiometer in "scope" mode which gives me a raw output. The second pic is what's called a "second order derivative" which is used in analytical chemistry and really allows me to get in close and analyze the phosphors used. Every major downward dip is a different phosphor so these modern white LEDs have a lot more going on that what is shown in the data sheets. I use the same technique to analyze pigments and some proteins in plant leaves.

I'm not aware of anyone on the internet outside academia that gets into actually analyzing the phosphors in LEDs, let alone analyzing pigments and proteins.



What's under the hood

https://imgur.com/a/fBEVeHA (4 under the hood pics)

The line and neutral are going through power resistors, which is then rectified, smoothed out with a capacitor, and this higher voltage DC is then fed to the LEDs though linear current regulators in parallel. If you want to make something cheap and dangerous then this is the way to do it. The capacitor is going to be a major fail point particularly at higher temperatures.



MY RANT (and why I'm such a cynic)

The layman gets so impressed with people waving a light meter under a light, maybe doing a grid test, but none of them are doing a safety test to see if the light is going to kill people. I could probably train a monkey to wave a light meter under a light. That's hyperbole of course, but I could train someone in an hour or two to do most any test that you see on YouTube because waving around a light meter is trivial. Right?

Additionally, when I first get a light I'm not making non-sense shills posts on /r/spacebuckets about "herp-a-derp I got this free light, anyone else have this one? I'm going to put a plant under it and keep making a bunch more posts of this free light. Because it's free advertisement for this person who gave me a free light, and I'm too corrupt to get it. I'm even going to do shout outs to the person who gave it to me for free because fuck it, I got a free light and everyone has a price, mine just happens to be low". It's hard to be unbiased when receiving free stuff, and non-sense to compare lights when the lighting levels are not known, right?

This shilling problem was so bad on /r/microgrowery, at one point around 2016 with the mods receiving free lights, posts were being removed and people banned for promoting other lights. There are good reasons I'm proudly banned from /r/microgrowery for calling out non-sense. /r/microgrowery was quite literally founded on corruption, and the original mod was given the boot when publicly called out. When I started making waves about direct sidebar links to pirated grow books, a practice that Reddit admins would not allow today, the current head mod (Codine) threatened to sabotage my lighting guide with misinformation, which is why I made my own subreddit to protect the integrity of my lighting guide (PMs are forever archived!). This all sounds pretty corrupt, right?

The mods of /r/hydroponics were allowing stickied posts by MarsHydro, and MarsHydro was deleting posts on their own subreddit about people getting electrical shocks off their lights which others have confirmed to me about the electrical shock issue. It's very fair to ask, what's in it for the mods? MarsHydro also plays the non-sense "600w" game which is highly misleading. That sounds pretty corrupt, right?

In 2007 I was active with GreenPineLane, the first forum dedicated solely to LED grow lights. The head mod received a free 100 true watt light that had LEDs that were 15% efficient. The person who gave him the light claimed it would perform as well as a 400 watt HPS that would be around 30% efficient. The mod claimed this seemed right after trying to grow a single tomato plant. But I did some severe call outs because we all know that this would be utter non-sense and therefore corrupt, right?

The first grow light on the market was the LGM5 by Solaroasis that used 5 mm low power LEDs and cost well over $30 per watt. source. The person was claiming this 6-9 watt low power light could compete with HPS. When put to the test it could barely grow a tomato seedling without sever elongation. Complete and utter bullshit, right?

Eric Biksa, a public figure so there is no Reddit TOS violation, was writing in Maximum Grow magazine in early 2008 that LED lights were 10-20 times better than HPS while also claiming to be a world class hydro expert at age 24 despite no training. In summer 2008 in response to his non-sense, I wrote a 3000 word essay calling him and the whole LED grow light industry out for being founded on fraud at the time which can be seen here (a huge mistake was saying little light energy was converted to mass when I really meant that photosynthesis itself was very inefficient). The editor loved the essay because she wanted balance in the claims, the publisher hated it because he did not want to upset the LED grow light manufactures who bought advertisement space, so instead of an article it was published as a letter to the editor (it only meant I would not be paid $500 for the essay which was not the point). That would have been pretty corrupt of the publisher, right?

LEDGirl of HydroGrowLED fame was claiming in 2009 that she could get 2 grams per watt and in 2015 that she could get 4 times the yield per watt over HPS. I called her out in real life and believe me, LEDGirl is just as much as an unstable nutcase IRL as she is online. Four times the yield per watt over HPS is a corrupt non-sense claim even by today's standards, right?

I've seen MIGRO straight up grab energized circuit boards without a ground and handle it carelessly. That's either suicidal or a person who is utterly clueless on safety (people in the comments were trying to warn him). He'll also tell people to remove the covers from LED light bulbs which is very dangerous. He's first and foremost a salesman and acting grossly irresponsible, right? (I have many critiques of MIGRO, including having a weak grasp on actual theory, such as making up his own units like PPFD/W(???) and not understanding efficacy vs efficiency as well as being a bit naive on science in general, but I believe he basically operates in good faith for a salesman- he's also good at waving light meters around).

LEDTonic sells a cheap generic light that is twice the price per watt than any other light, and says 12 watts of cheap LEDs per square foot is adequate. source. This is one of the worst deals I've ever seen in all of LED grow lighting. Don't do business with people, who in my opinion, are scammers. Once a scammer always a scammer, right?

MostlySafe is such bullshit that he claims he created the whole concept of space buckets and used to sell homemade shoddy quality $600 space buckets! archived. He literally doxxed me when I called him out. That's pretty fucking cowardly, right?

If you're publicly shilling a free light then you are fair game for criticism, and I will publicly call you out on it, because you made it public. I've been calling people out for ten years on Reddit, have been doxxed three times for it so far, I've literally lawyered up when legal threats were made by MostlySafe against me and three other people including the head mod on /r/spacebuckets, and I'm not going to change. Nobody is going to control my or anybody else's hobby, right?

I have never accepted a free light, I'm not trying to sell anything, never done affiliate links, don't make any money off my guide, back my claims with links to hundreds of sources, back my claims with calibrated lab gear if I don't have another source, and I'm guessing I'm doing something right with over 5,000 subscribers. When I first wrote my lighting guide I was telling people not to use LED grow lights for commercial purposes because back then LEDs could not compete with HPS, which I received a lot of criticism for, and it would have been corrupt to say otherwise. Right...?



Affiliate links

You'll see people promoting lights with affiliate links. Most of the time they have never tested those lights and it's all bullshit if that's the case. They are less interested in the truth, and are more interested in a sale. Not all of them, but most of them. I understand some affiliate links keeps some websites going. But if people are writing lighting guides full of affiliate links then how can they truly be unbiased? Enough said.



N=1 and how not to do a test

N=1 means the plant count (population number) used in a test. It's complete non-sense to only use a single plant because you are not going to catch false positives and false negatives known as type 1 and type 2 errors.

Here is a YouTube video that uses an N=1 test that has over 800,000 views by Albo Pepper:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sfihE4IuFuU

It's such non-sense that the plant under the CFL light was allowed to dry out. How is this even remotely a legitimate test? What does this say about the person performing the test? You'll see stuff like this all the time on YouTube. IS THIS THE BEST GROW LIGHT OF <insert year here>!!!! Non-sense. What does best grow light even mean?

Even in academia, I was once volunteering at a plant growth lab to get some hands on lab experience. I open up a $300,000 plant growth chamber, picked up a tray of arabidopsis thaliana (a model plant used in botany), and they were all dried out. Photosynthesis shuts down before wilting happens. How can this be a legitimate test with such sloppy procedures? Non-sense.

Bruce Bugbee discusses this problem and how hard it can be to do a legitimate test. I've never seen a legitimate test done in the hobby community. The conditions must be identical, and Bugbee himself articulates this and how hard large scale cannabis testing can be. Almost always seedlings are used in tests because clones, being genetically identical, can hide type one and two errors if they have specific mutations. Seedlings provide a little bit of genetic variability so your test does not get stuck in some type one or type two error.

How many plants do you need for a test? N=7 would be the absolute minimum for p<0.05 at power = 0.8 for a SN = 1.6. This is what I was taught at the plant growth lab I volunteered at. Most tests are done with dozens of plants if not hundreds of plants, though. This applies for lighting tests, root tests, or any other type of grow chamber plant test. Arabidopsis thaliana is a tiny long day plant with an eight week life cycle, which is one reason why it's used as a model plant beyond having many variants available with specific genes knocked out. It's also why seedlings are sometimes used in studies, and you can get N>100 in even small containers that will fit in a space bucket.

N>100 microgreen radish seedlings in two gallon space buckets under a table at 2000K, 3000K, and 5000K. 215 uMol/m2/sec, DLI 17 mol/m2/day.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P-value

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_of_a_test

http://www.3rs-reduction.co.uk/html/6__power_and_sample_size.html



In conclusion

The light above sucks, YouTubers mostly suck, LEDTonic sucks, the doxxer MostlySafe sucks, shills promoting free stuff suck, affiliate link people suck if they have not at least used the lights, corrupt people in general suck, Star Wars episode eight power sucks, auto-tune music sucks, the US army (infantry) sucked, jumping out of a C-130 with a partial parachute malfunction sucked, covid sucks, white supremacists suck, legalizing pot in WA state but not allowing small private recreational grows sucks, the other people who have doxxed me suck, the deer who keep jumping in front of my car suck, the IMF sucks, Star Wars episode eight power sucks again, Jesus cult door knockers suck, that time I did four hits of LSD by myself sucked, that time pepper spray went off in my pocket sucked, the time I had a gout attack and then stubbed my gout swollen toe sucked, and Star Wars episodes one and nine also sucked (but not as bad as episode eight, it's a scientific fact that episode five was the best).


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Jul 20 '21

SAG's lighting guide cheat sheet

92 Upvotes

SAG's Plant Lighting Guide linked together

last update: 17 JAN 2022 (changed lux numbers per latest research)



Using a lux meter for plants

  • Using a lux meter as a plant light meter article -You only use a lux meter with white LED grow lights. You should use a proper $20 and up stand alone lux meter preferably with a remote sensor head. Your phone is likely not an accurate lux meter due to cosine errors in real life conditions. This is a hardware issue that can not be corrected for in software, and the white translucent plastic over a proper light meter's sensor is the cosine correction.

  • You should not use a lux meter with red/blue dominate "blurple" grow lights. The theory why is in the above article and some below. Only the more expensive $500 range "full spectrum" quantum light meters should be used with blurple LED grow lights to get accurate readings. Less expensive quantum light meters can work well with white LED grow lights, HPS, and sunlight but not necessarily with blurple LED grow lights.



Rough lux lighting levels for cannabis

White light CRI 80, 70 lux = 1 µmol/m2/sec:

  • 5,000 lux_____ unrooted cuttings (many people go higher)

  • 15,000 lux____ lower end seedlings (microgreens)

  • 30,000 lux____ lower end vegetative growth (cannabis seedlings)

  • 40,000 lux____ lower end flowering, rapid veg (tomato, pepper)

  • 75,000 lux____ safer maximum beginner level

  • 100,000 lux___cannabis starts light saturation


  • Keep in mind that with higher lighting levels that things go bad much faster and the fertilizers and all other growing parameters need to be dialed in. The 100klx number is based on the latest 2021 university level research on cannabis and linear growth rates.

  • I've grown various seedlings just fine at 35klx and many people on /r/spacebuckets are running their plants at >75klk or equivalent. You really want to stay above 40klx for flowering and many professionals are going to be closer to 75-90klx. I tend to grow plants at higher lighting levels myself.

  • If your seedlings or veg plants are "stretching" too much then you need more total light or a higher color temperature light.

  • I've seen research papers where cannabis is being rooted at 15,000 lux.



lux to PPFD conversions

The below will get you within 10% for white light.

  • 55 lux = 1 µmol/m2/sec sunlight CRI 100

  • 63 lux = 1 µmol/m2/sec white light CRI 90

  • 70 lux = 1 µmol/m2/sec white light CRI 80

  • 80 lux = 1 µmol/m2/sec HPS CRI 40

Higher CRI lights have a higher concentration of deeper red light (around 660 nm) which does not read as well with a lux meter. CRI has a bigger impact on lux to umol/m2/sec conversion values than CCT (color temp).

I've tested dozens of LEDs with my spectroradiometer (Stellarnet Greenwave) to get these numbers to always be within 10%. These are true measurements and not based off any specific lux meter which may be different. The claims are also backed by peer reviewed literature that uses 67 lux = 1 µmol/m2/sec as a generalization for all white LEDs and not taking CRI into account. (source).

Specific conversion values and spectrum shots for a dozen different Bridgelux LEDs can be found here.



DLI (daily lighting integral) calculations

  • DLI is the amount of light that the plant receives in a 24 hour period. The unit of measurement is mol/m2/day or "moles per square meter per day".

  • (PPFD/100) * 8.6 --this will give the DLI for a 24 hour photoperiod.

  • Multiply the result with the percentage of light on time per day. ((PPFD/100) * 8.6) * (% hours on per 24 hours)

  • Example: 200 µmol/m2/sec on 18 hours per day. (200/100=2) (2 * 8.6=17.2) (17.2 * 0.75=12.9 mol/m2/day)

  • Example: 1200 µmol/m2/sec on 12 hours per day. (1200/100=12) (12 * 8.6=103.2) (103.2 * 0.50=51.6 mol/m2/day)

This usually only counts the top light, and intracanopy or side lighting can greatly increase these numbers.



The basic definitions

  • PAR = "photosynthetic active radiation" or light from 400-700 nm by standard definition. PAR is what we measure and not a unit of measurement e.g. "300 PAR" makes no sense because the person could be talking about PAR watts. Around 4.6 µmol/m2/sec is one PAR watt/m2 for white light CRI 80. (source table 2) -great source

  • PPFD = "photosynthetic photon flux density" in units of µmol/m2/sec or "micromoles per square meter per second" also written as µmol m-2 s-1. This is the light intensity at the point of measurement. Lux is a close white light equivalent.

  • PPF = "photosynthetic photon flux" in µmol/sec or "micromoles per second" also written as µmol s-1. The is the total light given off by a light source. Lumens is a close white light equivalent.

  • PPE = "photosynthetic photon efficacy" in µmol/joule or "micromoles per joule" also written as µmol/J. This is how many photons of light are generated per joule (watt * second) of energy input. PPF/Watts will give the PPE. Lumens per watt is a close white light equivalent.

  • CCT = "correlated color temperature" is basically the red-blue ratio of a white light source and correlates to (i.e. appears to us as) the color temperature of a black body radiation source in degrees kelvin. Higher CCT, having more blue light, will keep plants more compact at a given lighting level. 3000K and 3500K are pretty common for all around use. Roughly speaking, 2700K is 10% blue, 4200K is 20% blue, and 6500K is 30% blue. (source, fig 1)

  • CRI = "color rendering index" is how well the reflected light of different colors look. For our purposes, the thing to know is that CRI 90 and above light will have deeper reds that will read lower with a lux meter, although the true PPFD levels may be the same. The deeper reds is why CRI 80 and 90 have different lux to PPFD conversion values. Roughly speaking, a CRI 100 light has a luminous efficacy of 250 LPW (lumens per watt) at 100% efficiency, CRI 95 is 280 LPW, CRI 90 is 300 LPW, and CRI 80 is 320 LPW. In the real world, these numbers can vary by up to 10% or so. (source 1, fig 2) (source 2, table 1)

  • Photomorphogenesis /"photo-morpho-genesis"/ or "light, change, life". These are light sensitive protein (phytochromes, phototropins, cryptochromes, UVR8) reactions that can be wavelength specific. For example, blue light up to about 470 nm has a powerful photomorphogenesis effect by keeping plants more compact, while 500 nm cyan light may do the opposite. (source for phototropins) (source for cryptochromes)



The McCree curve

  • Picture of the McCree curve for photosynthesis rates

  • Link to the McCree curve paper (fig 14)

  • The McCree Curve Demystified -good article on the McCree curve by a Ph.D senior research scientist

  • The McCree curve is a quantum efficiency lighting curve used in botany and should be used only as an initial foundation for understanding photosynthesis rates by wavelength. It is far more accurate than charts for chlorophyll dissolved in a solvent or charts for green algae, and it is common for these charts to get mixed up.

  • It was developed in the early 1970's by Keith McCree, a Ph.D physicist that was a professor of Soil and Crop Sciences at Texas A&M University. He tested 22 different crop plant types for photosynthesis rates with a PPFD of 18-150 µmol/m2/sec, in monochromatic light at 25 nm intervals from 350 nm to 750 nm, and using the single leaf model. The McCree curve is only valid for these conditions. Monitoring CO2 uptake was used to measure photosynthesis rates.

  • The McCree curve illustrates that all of 400-700 nm is useful for photosynthesis including green light, and not just red and blue light.

  • The McCree curve should not be used for very high lighting levels.

  • The McCree curve does not take in to account the whole plant model, or multi-wavelength lights including mixing in far red to try to increase photosynthesis efficiency (Emerson enhancement effect).

  • The work of McCree demonstrated that both sides of a leaf can be used efficiently for photosynthesis. Dicotyledons may reflect more green light on the abaxial (underside) of a leaf, while monocotyledons will have the same green reflectance on both sides of a leaf.

  • YPF (YPFD) or "yield photon flux (density)" is PPFD that has been weighed to the McCree curve. It is fortunately rarely used in botany but you do sometimes see it. There are special PAR sensors that give measurements in YPFD instead of PPFD, as well as spectroradiometers that can do this.



What different colors of light do to plants

  • BLUE. Blue light decreases acid growth which is different than growth through photosynthesis. Excess acid growth, or "stretching", in seedlings/veg is all about greater cell expansion in the stem that we get from lower lighting levels or not enough blue light. We typically only want as much blue in a light source to help prevent any excess stem elongation. Blue photons have much more energy needed for photosynthesis, and this extra energy is wasted as heat that the plant has to dissipate. The associated blue light sensitive proteins are the phototropins and cryptochromes.

  • GREEN. In healthy cannabis, 80-90% of green light is being absorbed and available for photosynthesis. Green is the opposite of blue in photomorphogenesis responses in that green causes stretching also called the shade avoidance responses. Pretty much anything blue does, green does the opposite. Green can help make leaves larger and increase the LAI (leaf area index) for greater light capture.

  • article on green light and plants

  • RED. Red can help keep a plant more compact but not nearly to the degree of blue. Red should be thought of as a lower energy photosynthesis driver and red LEDs can have a PPE that's greater than theoretically possible with white LEDs (blue LEDs with a phosphor). There are red LEDs on the market that are >4.0 µmol/joule. The associated red/far red light sensitive proteins are the phytochromes.

  • FAR RED. Far red causes greater stretching like green light and contributes to the shade avoidance responses. It "may" help put short day plants "to sleep" faster. Far red may in some plants may be able to drive photosynthesis efficiently though the Emerson enhancement effect. About 50% of far red light is reflected off plant leaves, and also transmits easily though leaves. For photomorphogenesis responses, red and far red are opposites like blue and green are opposites.

  • UV. Ultraviolet is a wild card and I can make no rhyme or reason of it working with a variety of plants. It tends to cause dwarfing when used as an only light source (UVA). For cannabis, the idea is to try to increase trichome and THC levels by adding UV, but some researchers including Bruce Bugbee are saying this does not happen. source. The only identified UV protein is the UVR8 protein, which is only UVB sensitive, not UVA sensitive (285 nm peak sensitivity).

  • Anecdotally, certain selective photomorphogenesis experiments I've done with UVA compared to blue, leads me to believe that there may be at least one unknown UVA light sensitive protein either as a primary receptor, or my SWAG (scientific wild-ass guess) is a UVA light sensitive protein that can express itself differently in different plant parts, affecting the protein phototropin/cryptochrome signal transduction pathways locally. For example the hypocotyl (the stem before the first set of true leaves) can react much differently than the epicotyl (the stem after the first set of true leaves) in some plants like pole beans in my 470 nm vs 405 nm experiments.



Energy and efficacy of photons

Knowing this helps us make LED efficiency calculations and understand why red LEDs are used in grow lights. It's easy to get "efficacy" (how well something works) and "efficiency" (ratio of useful work) confused.

  • 1240/wavelength of light in nm = energy of a photon in eV (electron volts).

  • 10.37/eV of photon = µmol/joule or the maximum possible PPE (photosynthetic photon efficacy).

  • max possible PPE * LED efficiency = the PPE for the specific LED.

  • Example: 660 nm photon. (1240/660=1.88eV) (10.37/1.88=5.52 µmol/joule). At 100% efficiency, a red 660 nm LED would have a PPE of 5.52 µmol/joule.

  • Example: 450 nm photon. (1240/450=2.76eV) (10.37/2.76=3.76 µmol/joule). At 100% efficiency, a blue 450 nm LED would have a PPE of 3.76 µmol/joule.

  • Question: what is the electrical efficiency of a 660 nm LED with a PPE of 2.8 µmol/joule? (1240/660=1.88eV) (10.37/1.88=5.52 µmol/joule) (2.8 µmol/joule/5.52 µmol/joule=50.7% efficient)

  • Question: what is the electrical efficiency of a 450 nm LED with a PPE of 2.8 µmol/joule? (1240/450=2.76eV) (10.37/2.76=3.76 µmol/joule) (2.8 µmol/joule/3.76 µmol/joule=74% efficient)

  • The above means that we can theoretically get about 47% more light for the energy input with 660 nm LEDs versus 450 nm LEDs. It explains why red LEDs are breaking the 4 µmol/joule barrier, and white LEDs based on blue LEDs with a phosphor never will.

  • Green LEDs are electrically inefficient and is a physics/semiconductor issue. Our eyes are most sensitive to green light so we don't notice.



Luminous efficiency and lux meters

  • Luminous efficiency chart -these are correction factors

  • Luminous efficiency is not the same as luminous efficacy (lumens per watt).

  • Luminous efficiency is a percentage correction factor for wavelengths of light relative to 555 nm that takes in to account the spectral sensitivity of the human eye. 555 nm is what our eyes are most sensitive to and has a luminous efficiency of 1.0002 (it had to be corrected once which is why it's not 1.0000- that's good science).

  • LEDs have a binning tolerance, and a 660 nm LED could actually be 650 nm or 670 nm. A 650 nm LED has a luminous efficiency of 0.107, while a 670 nm LED has a luminous efficiency of 0.032. That means with a lux meter the 650 nm LEDs with give a lux reading three times higher than 670 nm LED although the PPFD may be the same. This is why we don't use lux meters with color LEDs for absolute measurements, and why knowing about luminous efficiency is important.

  • A cheap $10 spectroscope can help you identify that actual dominate wavelength of an LED so you can determine the needed correction factor.

  • A lux meter with cosine correction can be used accurately with any visible lighting spectrum for relative measurements. The cheap $20 lux meters I examined where using silicon diodes with an appropriate short pass filter. Here is the transmission characteristics of the filter for a Dr.meter LX1010B lux meter.. This, combined with the response curve of a generic silicon photodiode, gets fairly close to a true lux curve response that a spectroradiometer can give that takes into account the luminous efficiency by wavelength.



Watts equivalent for common CFL/LED light bulbs

This is equivalent to an incandescent light bulb.

  • 40 watts equivalent is about 450 lumens

  • 60 watts equivalent is about 800 lumens

  • 75 watts equivalent is about 1200 lumens

  • 100 watts equivalent is about 1600 lumens

  • greater than 100 watts equivalent is not necessarily very well defined

  • Spot and flood lights may be a little different if the manufacturer is using equivalent to halogen lighting.

  • The watts equivalent does not ever change although the true wattage does as LEDs become more efficient. This is to help lower the confusion among consumers about what size light bulb they should get as LEDs become more electrically efficient.

  • Be wary of any "watts equivalent" to HPS light. A lot of low end LED sellers will use "600w" or "1000w" as a deceptive marketing practice, and you need to go off actual wattage.



Spectrometer shot of a green leaf

  • GREEN LEAF -This is showing 83% green absorption. High nitrogen cannabis can be closer to 90% green absorption.

  • Pigments listed below the line are absorption points, above the line are reflectance peaks.

  • You'll notice that chlorophyll B has very little effect on the red side, and using 630 nm LEDs to try to target it makes no sense.

  • Carotenoids (specifically xanthophylls) are dominating the blue side. Carotenoids are an accessory pigment that are 30-70% efficient at transferring absorbed energy to chlorophyll. Only through chlorophyll A can photosynthesis take place.

  • Carotenoids help prevent damage to leaves from too much blue light known as the xanthophyll cycle.

  • Measuring the 531 nm to 570 nm carotenoid reflectance ratio is one way to determine photosynthesis efficiency and known as the Photochemical Reflectance Index.

  • As far as known, chlorophyll to chlorophyll energy transfer is 100% efficient through Fƶrster (fluorescent) resonance energy transfer and coherent resonance energy transfer (source page 5)



Emerson (enhancement) effect

  • The Emerson effect is about driving photosynthesis with part of the light PAR (400-680 nm in this case), and part of the light far red (700 nm-740 nm or so), combined can result in photosynthesis rates higher than normal.

  • Robert Emerson used his work with red and far red light to deduce that there must be two photosystems, called photosystem I (PSI) and photosystem II (PSII), named in the order of discovery but for photosynthesis, the process starts with the PSII first.

  • Monochromatic light has a sharp drop off in photosynthesis at 680 nm or so (red drop effect), but this does not happen if far red light is added with about 720 nm being most efficient in driving additional photosynthesis. (source 1 fig 1) (source 2 Bugbee)

  • Far red light can drive the PSI independently of the PSII, and PAR is more efficient with the PSII while not as well excited with the PSI. Basically how the Emerson effect works is freeing up electrons between the PSI and PSII by driving them more efficiently in parallel, and photosynthesis becomes more efficient as a result.

  • You can see this jamming of electrons in this chlorophyll fluorescence shot with proteins associated with the PSII and much less fluorescence associated with the PSI (the single 750 nm hump). Higher fluorescence means lower photosynthesis efficiency. (that shot was just turning on the lights)

  • I think most far red driver boards are gimmicks because they are likely not putting out enough far red light to make a noticeable difference.



Lighting tips

  • You generally want the light meter or the sensor head pointing up and down, not at the light source, to get a cosine correct reading. This is a huge mistake I see people make and the white piece of plastic over the sensor gives the proper cosine correction, not tilting the sensor towards the light which will give false readings. This is also why I recommend meters with remote sensor heads for ease of taking a reading and scanning around.

  • Your phone is a poor light meter if it has no cosine correction (highly likely does not), and I can set up conditions where my Samsung A51 (and Samsung S7) are ten times off a true reading and where they read the same as true. This is a hardware limitation that can not be corrected with in software. Phones are basically worthless for color LEDs due to the luminous efficiency issue. Based on hands-on experience, I automatically discount all lux measurements done with phones.

  • The harder you push your plants the easier it is to mess things up. If you are having health issues with your plant the first thing to do is to lessen the lighting levels on the plant to slow things down.

  • I generally run all plants 24/0 that can handle that lighting schedule in veging. Many long day and day neutral plants can not handle a 24/0 schedule in flowering due to blossom drop. At high levels at 24/0 this can cause photosynthesis rates to lower a bit per amount of light due to some damage being done to certain proteins in the photosystem, and the time needed for these repairs to take place (hours).

  • Light quantity (how much light) is generally more important than light quality (the lighting spectrum).

  • It can be a bit naive to use PPF to try to calculate actual PPFD numbers. If you do then be sure that you over estimate by perhaps 30-50%.

  • I have more success with cuttings at 18/6 rather than 24/0. As a wild guess, it could be because auxins are being produced at their maximum levels in darkness, and auxins help with rooting.

  • You can calibrate any light meter for PPFD as long as the meter has cosine correction. Most light meters are highly linear i.e. a light meter based on a light dependent resistor would likely not be linear, but the silicon diodes found in most lux meters are linear to within 1% over 7-10 orders of magnitude.

  • It takes about 30-60 seconds for a dark adapted leaf to fully "turn on" for photosynthesis. This can be seen in these chlorophyll fluorescence over time pic off my spectrometer. In many scientific papers the researchers may wait 60-90 minutes for a leaf to become fully light adapted.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Sep 17 '19

Evaluation of Tiny Grow Lights

85 Upvotes

Evaluation of tiny grow lights

This is part of SAG's Plant Lighting Guide


This is a look at some tiny grow lights mainly from Amazon. If I gave the light a fail for electrical safety then the full test is not being published since I do not recommend buying the light. Some of the shots from my spectrometer may be a bit different from others since I'm showing raw images from ā€œscopeā€ mode.

The conversion factor is how you change the lux reading to PPFD in umol/m2/sec which is the unit of light intensity used in botany. This is so people can spend $20 lux on a light meter rather than hundreds on a quality quantum PAR meter. Some of the lights are using white and red LEDs so the standard conversion factor I tell people to use of 70 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec does not work.

More on how lux meters can be used for some plant lighting can be found in my guide here.

https://www.reddit.com/r/HandsOnComplexity/comments/17nxpy/using_a_lux_meter_as_a_plant_light_meter/

For this guide you really do not need to know all the core concepts which can be found here.

https://www.reddit.com/r/HandsOnComplexity/comments/bhmb22/core_concepts_in_horticulture_lighting_theory/


What is watts equivalent with white LED light bulbs?

It's common to see LED light bulbs sold as a watt equivalent rather than the true or actual wattage. The ā€œequivalentā€ is the equivalent light given off by an incandescent light bulb in lumens in this case. The following is fairly close to what the lumens rating is for different wattage equivalent light bulbs and also applies to CFL light bulbs. This is not a linear scale!

  • 40 watts equivalent is about 450 lumens

  • 60 watts equivalent is about 800 lumens

  • 75 watts equivalent is about 1200 lumens

  • 100 watts equivalent is about 1600 lumens

  • greater than 100 watts equivalent is not very well defined

For a space bucket we want 3000-5000 lumens for a five gallon bucket for cannabis in flowering. At the time of this writing a 100 watt equivalent bulb draws about 15 actual watts so we would want about 40-45 actual watts of LED light bulbs. LED light bulbs are not nearly as efficient as high end COBs or quantum boards.

This convention of equivalent watts is not going away any time soon and is useful since we can choose light bulbs based on how much light they give off rather by how many watts they actually use.

Some low cost Chinese grow lights use "equivalent" to HPS lighting. It's all a lie.


A quick note on modifying normal LED light bulbs

long rant on modding light bulb

A popular hack is to remove the protective case of an LED light bulb directly exposing the LEDs. This hack actually does work well but by doing this you have removed all ingress protection and have now exposed potentially dangerously high voltage levels that are not isolated from ground. This is normally an instant safety fail.

In a 120 volt AC system, the voltage is going through a circuit called a full wave bridge rectifier/capacitor which will boost the voltage up to about 170 volts DC (the capacitor is holding the peak voltage). This does not necessarily mean that this voltage will be present since the actual voltage will be determined by the voltage drop of the LED string(s) which can still be fairly high. It still presents a very real electrical shock hazard that can in certain cases be fatal. If an LED burns out in an open condition then the voltage will float up to 170 volts.

The above paragraph becomes even more important in 230 volt AC countries where the voltage can float up to 325 volts DC or so.

To learn more about electrical safety and in particular dielectric breakdown of skin please refer to my electrical safety guide.

https://www.reddit.com/r/HandsOnComplexity/comments/crqe8m/line_voltage_cobs_and_electrical_safety/

Unmodified LED light bulbs can be made much more efficient if a reflector is used. Get a wider reflector like this. LED flood lights can also be used that do not need a reflector (note- the "equivalent watts" is often different for flood lights).

I found 100 watt equivalent with a reflector will work with veging cannabis when optimized using a five gallon bucket aeroponic system.

https://imgur.com/a/fs9ohSL

Foil wraps can be very efficient with nanogrows and tiny lights.

https://imgur.com/a/Rx2JmvJ


A type of light not to get

Do not buy this style of light

I want to make something very clear about most Amazon products that are of very poor quality yet have very high reviews- it's mostly bullshit and shady merchants can buy ratings/reviews.

These types of lights are very dangerous. The two I bought had exposed higher voltages and a heat sink that was not completely isolated. The LEDs were also rather inefficient.

I have no idea what the wattage is equivalent to. The ā€œ100 wattā€ light drew about 20 actual watts.

Many of these lights are going to be dual spectrum red/blue LEDs only which do have a history of poor performance. One I bought was dual spectrum, the other was not.

Since I strongly recommend against this type of light I will not post my measurement results.

I am writing about this type of light here

This is a 20 watt LED light, not a 100 watt light. There is exposed non-isolated high voltage DC so if you grab the LEDs and came in to contact with ground potential you could get a fatal shock. I did take the LEDs to ground potential through a jumper and all the sparks and arcs did confirm that the LEDs are at a high voltage and not isolated from ground. This was tested before with a Fluke 287 but I really wanted to see the sparks so I also used a jumper straight to ground. For this reason alone I would not buy this light.

In one of my tests I will reverse polarity the hot and neutral wires and then test the heat sink to see if it is energized. Yes, I was getting leakage to the point that I could get the LEDs to light up dimly even with the light switch turned off. In the test the neutral was being switched on and off and the issue is that the light will appear to be off but can still be a safety concern. This is another reason I would never buy this light.

These LEDs are also less efficient than a normal UFO LED or a normal white LED light bulb watt for watt when I did lighting level measurements with an Apogee sq-520 quantum light sensor in a five gallon space bucket. It may work for earlier veg growth but it's not going to cut it for robust flowering.

Mine was a tri-band 450, 630, 660 nm which is less than ideal for flowering. Being tri-band at these wavelengths will suppress acid growth so even at lower lighting levels there still won't be as much excessive "stretch". This is different than good growth from photosynthesis.


COB grow lights

Amazon has plenty of low cost line voltage grow lights hitting the market. The cheapest ones I tested were ungrounded and very dangerous. A write up can be found here.

https://www.reddit.com/r/HandsOnComplexity/comments/a8hqm3/safety_notes_on_low_cost_led_cob_grow_lights/

There are COB work lights that one can buy from Walmart which should be safe to use.

Here is a spectrum shot of a line voltage "blurple" COB.


GE 32 watt grow bulb

The balanced spectrum version was tested.

light bulb spectrum

Lux to umol/m2/sec conversion factor is 61. CCT is 5250K.

PPFD measurements:

  • 100 umol/m2/sec 30 inches (seedlings)

  • 300 umol/m2/sec 22 inches (basil, lettuce)

  • 500 umol/m2/sec 17 inches (cannabis, tomato, peppers)

  • 1000 umol/m2/sec 13 inches (cannabis)

The GE bulb draws 32 actual watts and has a PPF of 50 umol/sec. The PPE is 1.6 umol/joule.

Is it safe? It is electrically safe but as a warning do not put this light on a bed or the like since in some cases it can be a fire hazard. Here is a pic of a hole it burned through my cover after about 30 seconds.

This is a white light bulb with 665 nm red LEDs although the light may appear to just be white.

While fine for most forms of smaller growing, its higher power output and narrow beam angle would make this unsuitable for five gallon space buckets unless you can keep them far enough away.

With a heavy heat sink that only gets a bit warm, it's important to only hang this light vertically and not use this light horizontally like one might do for supplemental lighting.

One of the few small grow bulbs that is UL listed for safety.

Use for one square foot of higher performance growing and two square feet for lower performance growing like lettuce.


GE 9 watt grow bulb

The light bulb that was tested

light bulb spectrum

Lux to umol/m2/sec conversion factor is 54. CCT is 4000K.

PPFD measurements:

  • 100 umol/m2/sec 8 inches

  • 300 umol/m2/sec 4 inches

This bulb draws 9 actual watts and has a PPF of 16 umol/sec. The PPE is 1.8 umol/joule.

Is it safe? Yes! This is the safest bulb I have ever tested and only gets mildly warm. It is one of the few LED grow bulbs that is UL listed for safety.

This is a white light bulb with 665 nm red LEDs although the light may appear to just be white.

At a PPE of 1.8 umol/joule this light is as efficient as a modern HPS watt for watt. But its small size makes this light usefulness very limited and is rather expensive.

A major issue with this light is its wide beam angle so the light must be very close to the plant.


SANSI 15 watt grow bulb

The light bulb that was tested

light bulb spectrum

Lux to umol/m2/sec conversion factor is 65. CCT is 6000K.

PPFD measurements:

  • 100 umol/m2/sec 20 inches (seedlings)

  • 300 umol/m2/sec 12 inches (lettuce, basil)

  • 500 umol/m2/sec 9 inches (cannabis, tomato, peppers)

  • 1000 umol/m2/sec 7 inches (cannabis)

Is it safe? Yes but the light does have fairly poor ingress protection compared to the GE bulbs and does run much hotter. Do not let any water get around this light. The light is not UL/ETL listed.

The light draws about 15 actual watts.

This is a white light with an enhanced 640 nm red phosphor. Although I can not do CRI measurements, it is going to have a high CRI and particularly a high R9 red value. Having a high R9 value, this is actually a very pleasant light to look at for such a high color temperature.

Its more narrow beam angle limits its usefulness in five gallon space buckets.


150 watt UFO with Cree COB

note- I will be doing more tests on this light next week when I have my hands back on it

This is the light that was tested

spectrum of this light

PPFD measurements:

will be done

This light draws about 55 actual watts.

Is it safe? Sure, why not. It was grounded. This light is not UL/ETL listed.

I kind of doubt that this light uses a real top end Cree COB and is more likely a marketing gimmick.

This is really just a generic UFO light sold by many vendors under different labels.

Inside a five gallon space bucket this light will read about 1200 umol/m2/sec of light.


Review of a $15 60 watt garage light

Light tested: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07W53Y4DL/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_asin_title_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

archived

TL;DR fine for a garage, get a UFO or small quantum board light instead for growing. Will not fit in a five gallon bucket!

Price at the time bought: $15

Electrically safe: yes but not ETL/UL listed

True power: 47 watts

Power Factor 0.61

Color temperature: 5600K (measured)

PPFD over a five gallon bucket: 580 umol/m2/sec

spectrometer shot of LEDs

oscilloscope shot of power supplies

light opened up

close up pic of power supplies

All plastic construction with metal core printed circuit boards (MCPCB) for the LEDs and as the heat sink. No further heat sinking. Translucent covers blocked one third of the light output. No obvious shock hazard. Some Amazon reviews were showing the socket separating from the rest of the light fixture.

The oscilloscope measurements were showing a highly chaotic waveform of the power supply noise with the fixture enclosed at about 57 KHz. Upon opening the fixture I found two internally clocked switching power supplies which is a configuration I've never seen before. Two MCPCBs of the arms and half of the MCPCB in the center were being fed from separate power supplies. The slightly different switching power supply frequencies that were entrained explains why they were operating so chaotically. No flickering noticed.

When placed on top of a five gallon bucket lined with aluminum foil I read a PPFD of 580 umol/m2/sec at the bottom of the bucket using an Apogee SQ-520 full spectrum quantum light sensor. This is very poor and a 55 watt true UFO would read about 1200 umol/m2/sec. With the covers removed I read about 830 umol/m2/sec (you can expose yourself to a shock hazard doing this).

The light is rated for up to 265 volts so this is not rated for a three phase 277/480 lighting circuit. The power factor of 0.61 is awful and the apparent power (reactive power plus true power) was about 75 watts with the true power of 47 watts (residential customers only pay for true power).

The light got warm to the touch with about a 45 degree F rise in temperature above ambient. The light did not get hot enough to warranty a full thermal review.

CONCLUSION: pass on this and get a real grow light. Even a cheap UFO will far outperform this light. With the translucent covers on this light is about half as efficient as a cheap UFO grow light and far less efficient than a quantum board with Samsung LEDs. For growing this light is a waste of power, waste of time, and waste of money.


Pair of 120 watt equivalent flood lights

This is a simple and easy, no hassle solution to getting the lighting done in a five gallon bucket. I got the two PAR38 flood lights for $10 at Walmart. They are "Great Value" brand, rated for damp locations, and have an ETL Mark (they have been extensively tested for safety).

They are "120 watt equivalent" that have a clear(ish) cover, not a white translucent cover. Equivalent watts actually means something unlike low end cheap grow lights but flood lights are measured differently than regular light bulbs. I recommend using 120 watt equivalent flood lights.

the type of light

Place the lights on the lid and trace the lights with a sharpy. Then cut out the hole with a razor blade so the lights will not fall through the holes (duh).

cut the holes

What it looks like with the lights on. The lights only get a bit warm. You always want the lights at least six inches away or more from the plants. Measured with an Apogee SQ-520 full spectrum quantum sensor in a five gallon bucket lined with aluminum foil (shiny side out), at six inches I got about 1200 uMol/m2/sec (about as intense of light as you want to go) directly under a light and about 800 uMol/m2/sec (good level for budding) in the rest on the bucket area at six inches under the lights. Towards the bottom of the bucket it was around 800 uMol/m2/sec fairly even.

A single light in the middle got about 750 uMol/m2/sec in the middle of the bottom of a bucket and about 450 uMol/m2/sec off to the sides. This may be a bit much for veg growth. This was with aluminum foil. White paint or just an unpainted white bucket will have significantly lower measurements.

You'll have to come up with a way to seal the light leaks if needed. The lights only get a little warm so duct tape may work. You can use some epoxy to keep the lights in place.

lights on


Characteristics:

actual wattage: 15.5 watts per light

claimed color temperature: 3000K

measured color temperature: 3491K and 3546K

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 74 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

flood light spectrum

1931 CIE chromaticity diagram


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 28 '20

A strong warning about removing the domes from LED light bulbs by an actual electrician

78 Upvotes

A strong warning about removing the domes from LED light bulbs by an actual electrician.

edit- here is how to use some low cost LED lights safely in a space bucket

https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceBuckets/comments/gn4iut/a_low_cost_no_hassle_lighting_setup_for_a_five/

This is in response to a really good and highly upvoted /r/hydroponics thread that had highly upvoted bad advice in the comments section. I'm not going to link to the thread because it's no my intention to cause embarrassment.

Longer discussion

This will be archived in my lighting guide

Full write up on electrical safety can be found here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceBuckets/comments/crqdsj/line_voltage_cobs_and_a_discussion_on_electrical/

Testing some smaller lights:

https://www.reddit.com/r/HandsOnComplexity/comments/d5nu5p/evaluation_of_tiny_grow_lights/

It's also in response to profoundly stupid people like Shane (MIGRO) for promoting stuff like this.


Not. Isolated. From. Ground.

Removing the plastic translucent dome from an LED light bulb is a way to get more light on your plants. This is just factual. What you are also doing is exposing potential lethal voltages that are not isolated from ground.

With an isolated power supply, like any of the Mean Well LED drivers, I can take the wires meant for the LEDs and take them right to ground potential with no problems, no damage, and no current flow (it is the current that kills). This is a safety test I do with most everything I analyze if I'm actually digging in to a light fixture. Non-isolated means that the current would flow.

At 120 volts AC input you can have up to 170 volts DC exposed by removing the dome (because of the full wave bridge rectifier and capacitor), which does depend on the voltage drop of the LEDs, and in every case where I have simulated ground faults with the domes removed I get sparks flying off the LED light bulb and the LED driver smoking. This is partially because cheaper capacitive power supplies are being used much more often. From the wiki:

"The second is that due to the absence of electrical isolation between input and output, anything connected to the power supply must be reliably insulated so that it is not possible for a person to come into electrical contact with it."

If you are in a country that has 230 volt line voltage there is a possibility of up to 325 volts DC being exposed (230 * 1.41 because the capacitor can be charged up to the peak voltage rather than the RMS voltage). Once dielectric breakdown of the skin occurs it's not one hundred kiloOhms resistance or whatever you measured with a multimeter- it's much, much lower which allows much more current to flow. BAMN!

I want to emphasize that people saying that you can not get a severe shock because your hand has a very high electrical resistance typically do not understand the subject matter because all the matters is the resistance when a higher voltage is being applied. It is not the same and dielectric breakdown in non-linear. Your skin is a dieletric (insulator) that is easy to breakdown.


Bulbs used to be safer

When I was first experimenting with LED light bulbs for growing around 2010 many were about $20-25 for a 450 lumen light bulb that used externally clocked isolated switching power supplies (I could tell they were externally clocked from the low phase noise measurements). They were using less LEDs so the exposed voltage was around perhaps 30-35 volts that were usually isolated from ground.

Right around 2012-2013ish or so I started finding more and more capacitive and linear power supplies and another big difference was that the switching power supplies were not being isolated even with a UL label. But they didn't and still do not need to be isolated because the plastic dome is your ingress safety protection and are perfectly safe if unmodified.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IP_Code

By removing this built in safety feature you are allowing higher voltages to be exposed in an environment that has a lot of highly conductive liquids around (i.e. hydro solution) that may be on a conductive surface like a damp concrete floor or a grounded metal rack system (which ideally should be grounded).

If you were to touch the exposed LEDs with one hand and your other hand came in to contact with ground potential, or if you were standing on a damp concrete floor, for example, you can get a lethal amount of current flowing through your body. The "can't let go" current is only about 10-20 mA (as low as 1/100th of an amp). If you start getting up to 50 mA through the heart then you are in deadly current level ranges. Your heart rhythm can be so easily thrown off with current flow and heart tissue can be damaged from burning. You can also get permanent nerve damage from electrical shocks.

In many LED light bulbs that I've opened they'll be two prongs sticking out and that is a great way to get snagged up on an energized light bulb.

I'm just warning everyone, as an actual industrial electrician, some of you people are giving some really, really dangerous advice and most everyone here does not understand electricity or how dangerous it can be. No sane professional is going to crap on their own reputation by telling others to do something inherently unsafe. Why take advice from an amateur pertaining to electricity and electrical safety issues? That doesn't make sense...

But...but...but...I use GFCI/RCD. Good, you should protect yourself like this but that's not an excuse to be unsafe or to encourage other to be unsafe. Are they using GFCI/RCD, too? The reality is likely not. Use GFCI/RCD protection with hydro setups in particular, people!

But...but...but...I've never heard of anyone getting shocked off a modified light bulb. Well hmmmm, perhaps that person is not around anymore. But would you leave a small piece of bare wire sticking out of an energized receptacle? Removing the dome is basically the same thing from an electrical standpoint.

But...but...but...I saw it on YouTube. Well...YouTube has a lot of idiots. I've seen people grab energized circuit boards on and people were having to point out in the comments that he was going to get himself killed while also encouraging people to remove the cover. I'm specifically talking about how foolishly unsafe MIGRO can be. Fuck Shane for being the clueless dumb ass that he is because he's going to get people killed if he has not already (why anyone would take him seriously is beyond me- he does not not know theory to the point that he makes up his own units like PPFD/W, and doesn't even know the difference between efficacy and efficiency).


Reflectors

If you want more light on your plant then use a proper reflector. You can make your own aluminum foil reflector (for the last time, aluminum foil will not burn your plants). The problem with DIY aluminum foil reflectors is that in many instances (I've seen this so many times...) you'll have a reverse polarity of the hot and neutral wires and in many cases with a light socket there may be some metal exposed where the light screws in to the light socket. If there is a reverse polarity then that exposed metal is going to be energized. If the aluminum foil reflector comes in contact then the whole reflector is going to be energized at line voltage. I just want to throw this out there and it's why I've never done a DIY guide on making your own aluminum foil reflectors for LED light bulbs.

I've designed aluminum foil reflectors, optimized them (they can actually lower the bulb temperature if designed properly by acting as a heat sink), saw the very obvious safety flaw, then moved on with another project.

There are also many instances of Amazon grow bulbs I have bought and tested that also had exposed energized parts (see above link on small light testing). In addition, some of these cheap line voltage COBs I've bought on Amazon and tested had the ground wire simply clipped off even though the light had a metal housing and was advertised for outdoor use. Holy shit....

Every UFO light I have tested was safe with isolated power supplies. I think they are garbage using crappy LEDs and a noisy (RFI or radio frequency interference) LED driver(s) but at least they are safe garbage. Most all high end quantum boards appear safe with isolated Mean Well LED drivers.

Use lights like this below as an example that broadcast all their light in one direction and still have ingress protection. (this is a really good light that I now use as a lab bench light). There are lights by Sansi I've tested that were safe and directional although not as efficient as that name brand GE light.

https://www.amazon.com/GE-Lighting-93101232-Balanced-Spectrum/dp/B07NNT3G7J/ref=sr_1_4?keywords=ge+grow+light&qid=1582885031&sr=8-4


Who are you listening to on safety?

I write a lot about electrical safety on Reddit, particularly on the /r/spacebuckets subreddit where there are a lot of beginners, and due to my past professional on the job experience I've seen (of know) a number of people have been injured by electricity including life altering injuries (I know someone who has such chronic nerve pain from a severe electrical shock that he was put on ketamine at one point to keep him from killing himself from the never ending pain he was in and ten years later is still taking pain killers most every day and wearing a brace- that's a no bullshit story).

I've established my reputation as to knowing what I'm talking about with electricity and lighting (go through my post history or read my lighting guide) and people need to start questioning who they are receiving advice from pertaining anything to do with modifying electrical devices where that device now becomes inherently dangerous or anything to do with electrical safety because it's not some game. I utterly condemn people encouraging others to do things that are obviously unsafe, particularly when most people do not understand the dangers like most all beginners, and so should you.

There are a lot of good electricians and engineers on Reddit. Listen to them. Just be careful of the software engineer saying he's an "engineer" that does not understand Ohm's/Watt's Law and says the he's going to do a write up on electrical safety (I shut that shit down fast). That guy didn't even understand how LEDs worked like that there is a voltage drop across the LED and an I-V curve.

I also really condemn some of these YouTubers suggesting that people do unsafe stuff like removing that cover from LED light bulbs or showing electrically unsafe practices or being clueless about their unsafe recommendations like promoting ungrounded line voltage COB lights. Just because you see a person waving a light meter under a light in a video does not mean that person knows what they are talking about.

Finally, cheap and safe rarely do together. Cheap means that corners are being cut and the last thing you ever want to do is listen to someone emphasize how cheap a light is if they are not qualified to test the light for electrical safety. Blow. These. People. Off.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 01 '13

Using a lux meter as a plant light meter

65 Upvotes

"Lumens are for humans"...unless you understand lighting theory

Part of SAG's Lighting Guide

last update: 20 JAN 2022 -added tl;dr, edited cannabis lighting level numbers



TL;DR

  • A lux meter must have cosine correction to make accurate measurements in most IRL measurements. Your phone likely does not have cosine correction and the white plastic over the sensor with a proper lux meter is the cosine correction. A phone app can not reliably correct for this error. Is your phone model reading going to read the same as another person's model? I can get 50-90% errors with any app I use including Photone in IRL conditions and not just a simple bench test.

  • You want a lux meter with a remote sensor head so you can make proper measurements with the lux sensor itself facing straight up rather than necessarily at the light source to get a true cosine correct lighting level measurement. You need to be able to scan around accurately no matter the sensor orientation. These are also important reasons why we do not rely on a phone as a light meter for what we do in any horticulture lighting.

  • You only use a lux meter with white light sources, not blurple lights, for absolute measurements. Use 70 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec to get within 10% for most white LED grow lights, use 55 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec for direct sunlight. A proper lux meter can be used with any visible light source for relative readings including blurple lights.

  • Minimum indoor light: Cannabis veg >30,000 lux. Cannabis flowering >40,000 lux. Use more light if there is unwanted stretching in veg, pump up the volume in flowering. Cannabis starts light saturation starting around 100,000 lux under ideal conditions.

  • Look up "LX-1010B" as an example mass produced generic lux meter to buy. It should cost about $20-25 shipped in the US and uses a cosine corrected silicon photo diode with a spectral correction filter.

  • Below is theory, explanations and rantings. The above is all most people need to know for cannabis lighting.

  • pic of 50% error with the Photone app --why you should not trust phone apps



Bit of ranting

Only use a lux meter with white light sources, not "bluple" red/blue dominate grow lights unless you know the lux to PPFD in umol/m2/sec conversion factor. I absolutely do not recommend using lux meters for professional or academic use as a PAR (photosynthetic active radiation) meter unless verified with a calibrated full spectrum quantum light meter. A hobbyist who does not want to spend >$500 on a full spectrum quantum light meter should be using lux meters. Lumens and lux are not the same thing; lumens should be thought of as total light output (for example, a 100 watt incandescent light bulb puts out about 1600 lumens of light), and lux the light intensity at a point in space.

Your phone is an unreliable general purpose lux meter because it may or more likely may not have cosine correction (what the round white piece of plastic does in actual lux meters). It does not matter what app is used because this is a hardware limitation. I automatically discount claims based on a phone's light intensity readings for this reason alone. It is very, very important that any phone, sensor, or meter used for a general purpose light readings has cosine correction (more on this below but it gets in to measurement angles and the angular response between the light meter and the light source).

There are too many variables in asking how far away should my light be from a plant such as power output, light fixture geometry (e.g. COB vs quantum light board, how the COBs are laid out in the light fixture), light/LED beam angle, plant type, and how many hours per day the light is on, etc. Spend $20 and use a light meter instead of guessing.



Rough lux lighting levels for cannabis

This is close to the lux readings that we want with a lux light meter as measured at the top of the plant canopy level for cannabis with white light CRI 80:

  • 5 klx -unrooting cuttings (you don't want too much light)

  • 15 klx -lower end for seedlings (more light and/or higher CCT if stretching)

  • 30 klx -lower end for veging (robust growth, keeps stretching down)

  • 40 klx -lower end for flowering (you don't want loose buds)

  • 100 klx -cannabis yields are linear to around this point under ideal conditions

note- cannabis seedlings can typically handle >40 klx and if your plant is doing fine then you should use more light rather than less



quick lux to PPFD in umol/m2/sec conversions

  • 55 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec sunlight

  • 63 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec white light CRI 90

  • 70 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec white light CRI 80

  • 80 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec HPS

These general numbers will get you within 10% of a true white lighting level reading for most white light sources. Many, many dozens of different LEDs were tested starting from 2011. These numbers are not valid for white lights with a CCT (correlated color temperature) of below 2700K or above 6500K (the K stands for degrees Kelvin, not the number one thousand).

As a guess I would use 60 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec for a white light with some red LEDs. Your results may vary due to the specific red to white LED ratio and the specific wavelength of the LEDs due to binning tolerances. A 660 nm LED may really be a 650 nm or 670 nm LED and this can read about three times off with a lux meter 670 nm has a relative sensitivity of 0.032, while 650 nm is 0.107, with an ideal lux meter. That's the problem particularly with the red heavy "blurple" lights and using lux meters.

CRI or color rendering index is more important than the CCT in conversion values because higher CRI lighting has a greater amount of deeper red light (light in the 650-660 nm area) that is not as sensitive to a lux meter. More on this below.

With non-white light sources like the "blurple" or red/blue dominate grow lights, if you know the lux to PPFD conversion value of the blurple light being used then the lux meter will work as an accurate PAR meter for that specific light.

For Bridgelux phosphors use these conversion values for a higher accuracy:

https://www.reddit.com/r/HandsOnComplexity/comments/gr1rcf/bridgelux_phosphor_guide/



Some tips about lighting levels

I've done closer to 35,000 lux with cannabis seedlings with great success and the above is a general guide. But the harder you push your plant, the easier and faster problems can develop. I personally use continuous, 24 hour lighting for the non-flowering stages. There's a lot of debate on this 24 hour argument versus an 18/6 etc lighting schedule with good points on both sides.

The answer to "should I run my plants 24 hours per day?" entirely depends on what you are trying to get the plants to do and factors such as lighting levels (really high lighting levels causes damage to certain proteins involved with photosynthesis over time and it takes a certain amount of time for these proteins to be repaired in darkness or at very low lighting levels).

In many cases you will have more success with rooting cuttings by using less light per day such as 18 hours per day.

If your plant is distressed from nutrient deficiencies and the likeuse less light until it recovers.

Higher lighting levels will result in lowers yields per watt but can generate higher yields per area/volume. Under lighting and intracanopy lighting can also be used for higher yields in addition to top lighting. You absolutely will get better yields by properly using side and intracanopy lighting rather than just using top lighting alone. You can get to a very high DLI (daily light integral or how much light the plant receives in 24 hours), well beyond normal, by lighting up the lowers leaves that may not normally be lit up.

It is mainly the blue light that keeps a plant compact. Green can reverse blue light effects. Red can also keep a plant more compact that is reversed by far red light. Lights that have a lower CRI tend to have more green light even at the same color temperature but this is not always the case.

When using a light meter, it is typically best to use it with the sensor/meter pointing straight up rather than directly at the light source. That little white semi-sphere or flat piece of plastic you see with the light meter compensates for this (the cosine correction mentioned above). You can get very inaccurate off axis readings if your light meter is pointed at the light source. Let the little piece of white plastic do its job at cosine correction.

If you ever read about "light quantity" then lighting levels are being discussed. If you read about "light quality" then the lighting spectrum is being discussed.



Notes on lux meters, quantum light meters and spectrometers

Lux meters try to get this spectral response curve (the black curve) and typically use an inexpensive silicon photodiode with a particular filter that rolls off the red end. The photodiode naturally has a blue roll off and this, with economy of scale, allows pretty accurate meters to be made cheaply compared to quantum light meters. That filter is just a cheap greenish piece of plastic with this spectral response.

The high end quantum light meters uses a silicon diode with a very expensive spectral response flattening curve made for silicon diodes and an expensive thin film optical band pass filter to only read 400-700 nm light evenly. That's why there is a big price jump in meters prices like in the Apogee Sq-520. These meters also use a digital smoothing filter so the readings aren't bouncing all over the place. If you're serious about lighting you'll get a full spectrum quantum light meter.

One of the lower end meters I have, the cheaper Hydrofarm quantum light meter has a multi-channel spectral sensors. It's 4 channel, 100 KHz I2C data protocol that transmits 3 times per second so readings bounce around. This meter also shuts off every two minutes, was made of really cheap plastic, the battery life was low, and the battery had to be replaced with USB power supply/volt regulator because it was about to rupture. Mine will read green 525 nm LEDs 50% too low. Do not buy this meter.

Another meter I have, one of the Light Scouts, uses a special type of photodiode that coincidentally has a natural response curve that pretty close to the flat PAR curve we want. This means that the expensive filters do not have to be used and why you find quantum light meters that are under $500. But they do not work with 660 nm LEDs reliably (they have a sharp 650 nm cutoff) so they should never be used for pro/academic purposes. I used it for HPS and it was within 1% true.

A new type of meters/sensors out are the Apogee 340-1040 nm Extended Photon Flux Density (ePFD) and 380-750 nm Extended Photosynthetically Active Radiation (ePAR) series of meters/sensors that still reads flat across PAR. A significant advantage with these newer types of meters is the potential to use fairly cheap filters with them and turn the in to red/far red light meters or to maybe measure chlorophyll fluorescence and give us an idea of photosynthesis efficiency. The ePFD 340-1040 nm has the potential to be used with a with variety of filters (some types can get quite expensive) that could perhaps be used to measure in vivo leaf moisture content, for example.

A quantum light meter is called "quantum" because their measurement is in the amount a photons hitting a specific point in space per second and a photon is a quanta of light. A lux meter is called "lux" since they measure luminous flux.

Although we measure the PPFD in umol/m2/sec (micro moles of photons per square meter per second), we do not actually measure all the light in a square meter. It is equivalence to a square meter measurement. Same with a lumen/lux measurement- we are not necessarily making a true measurement in a square meter area but an equivalent measurement (one lumen is one lux per square meter). Any measurement made is only valid for that particular space being measured.

For red/blue "blurple" lighting and for professional or academic use for all lighting, I recommend either the Apogee MQ-500 full spectrum quantum light meter or the Apogee SQ-520 full spectrum quantum light sensor. I use the SQ-520 since I may spend a lot of time with a light meter/sensor and don't want to look at a tiny display. The only other light meter I can recommend that I also have some (but not much) hands on experience with are the LiCor light meters but they are very expensive. There are also

For pro/academic use or advanced hobby use, get the MQ-500 if you are doing more field use, get the SQ-520 if you are doing more lab use and don't need to be portable. The SQ-520 comes with a 15 feet long USB cable which I thought was ridiculous at first until I started using it. You can use the SQ-520 with a Windows tablet computer (get 4 GB of RAM, not 2 GB of RAM with a Windows tablet). It also works with Mac but not Android.

According to Bruce Bugbee, founder of Apogee Instruments and the Director of the Crop Physiology Laboratory at Utah State University, your light meter should never have more than a 5% error over 400-700 nm for academic purposes. A lux meter should keep you within 10% error for most white light sources as per my testing as long as a rough conversion value is known. $20 well spent and you'll learn a lot about lighting.

I do not really recommend handheld spectrometers for advanced horticulture light work since they are not very versatile (relatively speaking compared to a spectrometer with a fiber optic input) and most of the cheaper ones have a reduced resolution of only 15 nm or so. That's not going to work for many botanical measurements particularly for red edge and chlorophyll fluorescence work. You also want a spectrometer with an integration time of at least a few minutes.

If you are going to drop a bunch of money then get a USB spectrometer with a fiber optic probe for about twice the price as handheld including NIST traceable calibration and a few probe heads (cosine and a narrow 2-3 degree lens). You should PM me before buying a spectrometer if thinking on going cheap so that I can further articulate why you should spend more money than you realize on this level of lab gear. Two popular spectrometer makers are Stellarnet and Ocean Optics

As a strong warning on light meters, I have seen a person selling a homemade quantum light meter that has an amateurish 3D printed case (just no). For $650 I consider this a complete rip off in my opinion and the $550 professional Apogee MQ-500 is a better deal. I have some of the LCD displays used in the NukeHeads meter (I believe the cheap SSD1306 0.96 inch version) and they are not good for reading in full sunlight in my experience.

Unlike the NukeHeads meter above, the MQ-500 can also be factory recalibrated, has a data logging feature, and a four year warranty. The Apogee SQ-520 is about $350 (that can also be used as a programmed stand alone data logger) and is the same sensor as the MQ-500 and the NukeHeads meter. Don't pay more for less and never buy Ardruino based homemade lab gear. I will DIY my own lab gear but never buy other's complete DIY lab gear.

Quantum light meters and lux meters are basically worthless for far red lights and far red LEDs. For those you need a spectrometer, a far red sensitive spectral sensor, or something like an Apogee SQ-620 which is PAR and far red sensitive. Red/far red spectral sensors for microcontrollers start at about $25.

https://www.sparkfun.com/products/14351

18 channel spectrometers useful for botany work start at $50.

https://www.tindie.com/products/onehorse/compact-as7265x-spectrometer/

https://www.sparkfun.com/products/15050



A bit more theory

You don't actually need to know this stuff for making simple measurements.

Here's the conversion charts for using a lux meter as a quantum light meter. This is the lux to PPFD (photosynthetic photon flux density) conversion.

PI curve explained Cannabis is a lot higher than the specific curves shown.

Compensation point explained. The compensation point for annuals may be perhaps 20 umol/m2/sec (1400 lux) depending on the plant. BTW, what makes a "house plant" a "house plant" is they often have a very low compensation point and are perennials that tend not to elongate too much in lower lighting levels. This is a generalization.

The umol/m2/sec measurement of light is from 400 nm to 700 nm which is PAR (photosynthetically active radiation and take some of those charts with a grain of salt). It is the unit of light intensity in horticulture lighting. It is always a "PPFD of 300 umol/m2/sec", for example, and never "300 PPFD" or "300 PAR". I can always tell if I'm dealing with a hobbyist who likely does not understand the subject matter if they are misusing terms. More on core concepts in horticulture lighting theory can be found here.

The conversion factor for blurple grow lights can be all over the place. For example, as measured with my own spectrometer, instead of 70 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec, a red 647nm LED was at a 10.3 conversion factor, and a red 620nm LED at 44. A blue 462nm LED measured in at 12.8.

To put it another way, with a lux meter a 460 nm LED can read about 50% higher than a 450 nm LED although they may put out the same light when measured by a quantum light meter. A 630 nm LED may read three times higher than a 660 nm LED with a lux meter but the same with a more appropriate quantum light meter. What do you actually have in your "blurple" red/blue dominate grow light? This is why a lux meter should never be used to try to get a lighting measurement from other than a white light source.

This is the lux conversion table by wavelength of light.

Here's a few examples of light as measured in power by spectrum and how our eyes and a lux meter would perceive it. Here's a 2700K CFL as a true spectrum and how a lux meter reads it. Notice how much the red/green (the middle and right spike) ratio changes. This is because our eyes and lux meters are much more green sensitive. This is a solar spectrum on a cloudy day and how our eyes/lux meter perceives it.

For white LEDs with a CRI of 90 use 65 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec. This is because a CRI 90 white light have deeper reds which will not read as high on a lux meter although they may output the same amount of light as read on a quantum light meter. Protip- your food will look much better with CRI 90 lighting particularly red meats. If you are a chef you would want to use CRI 90 white lighting and not CRI 80 lighting which will have a R9 rating of 0. CRI affects lux readings more than the CCT because of the additional deep red light than CRI 90 lights will have. I also use high CRI lighting at my lab bench. The link below talks about R9.

https://www.waveformlighting.com/tech/what-is-cri-r9-and-why-is-it-important

When comparing two different light sources in a grow comparison, they must be done at the same lighting intensity. Why? First, photosynthesis isn't somewhat linear except between about 50 to around 300 or so umol/m2/sec, strongly depending on the plant. This is due to processes like photorespiration and non-photochemical quenching. Second, many plant proteins are expressed at different lighting intensities which can and will affect plant growth and development. Third, chloroplasts can move to the side walls at higher intensities of blue light lowering plant photosynthesis efficiency. This is called cytoplasmic streaming and is done as a form of photoprotection. An example can be seen here in this sped up 4 second video.

Do not use a cheap analog lux meter. I've tested one type and it was way off (the analog ones had impedance matching problems with the analog scale so were giving bad readings in brighter light). These cheap 3 in 1 light meters, pH meters, and moisture meters are worthless.

BTW, for photography and video, you should always use lights that have a CRI of 90 or higher to get your reds and yellows to show true. It's actually much more complicated than that and you start running in to the TM-30-15 standard and newer standards just started to being used and being worked out.



So, what is white?

This is a deceptively tricky question and it depends who you ask and what industry they are in.

To me it's simple- a white light is any light that has a chromaticity coordinate on the Plankian locus of the CIE 1931 color space within a certain color temperature range with a Duv of +/- 0.006 (or so...ish). See...simple! /s.

Some people might define white as the CIE Standard Illuminant D65 and declare that the white point. But there are other standard illuminants for white. But really if the white light is the only light source and our eyes can use its chromatic adaptation to make the light appear white then it's a white light source.

Try going to a paint store and ask for white paint and they might give you 30 or so choices for white. Your white teeth would look horrible if they where a bright "equal energy white" which is a white that has a flat spectral power distribution. White can mean different things to different people.

The pro video industry are coming up with very detailed standards just for their industry on what is white and how it relates to reflected light.

A camera can use an 18% gray card to get white for the shooting situation instead of the less reliable auto white balance. I often just use a white piece of paper to set my white balance.

Different people may use different color spaces so even defining color may not be very clear cut. Is it red, green blue for the primary colors or is it really red, yellow, blue? What about the heathens that use subtractive CMYK (cyan, magenta, yellow, and black) color model?

So, different people might have different definitions of what's white. But the lower the CRI, the higher the y chromaticity coordinate which means more green light, and lux meters are more sensitive to green light, and that's why CRI plays an important role in a lux to PPFD conversion value more so than color temperature which is more of a red to blue light ratio. This is top of the deeper reds at higher CRI that lux meters are not as sensitive to.

Red, green, blue LEDs together can make a white light source but the CRI (color rendering index) is going to be so low that everything is going to look horrible. In this case it is because the red/green/blue LEDs have strong spectral spikes with large gaps in the visible spectrum so the colors of objects may not look correct. That's why we use typically blue LEDs with broad phosphors instead that do not have these large gaps. Yellow and orange in particular may not render correctly with red/green/blue LEDs. Plants generally do not care, though, but some plants can be hypersensitive.



CRI and the best tip you'll get on LED light bulbs

It's about the color temperature AND the CRI in deciding what bulb to get.

As an aside, get CRI 90 or above LED bulbs, also called high CRI LED light bulbs or high CRI lightning, in your kitchen and your dining room. I'd honestly put them in any living space and pick whatever color temperature that makes you happy (e.g. warmer in living spaces, cooler in work spaces). Any restaurant should only be using high CRI LED lighting particularly if they serve a lot of red meat (wow, people do not understand this. Bridgelux makes white LEDs just for food and has ultra high CRI COBs that have come out). Same with any fashion display/photography or other type of display/photography where colors are important. (and for god's sake, use an off camera light source(s) for display and food photography. don't crap on your own products by using bad lighting)

Even at an electronics or other work station high CRI lighting will make a very noticeable difference if anything red is involved. Make sure that the LED light bulb is not going to interfere with your electronics, though, from that dirty (radio frequency interference prone) LED power supply. Some bulbs up close will interfere with my RF spectrum analyzer and oscilloscopes.

If you have orchids around or growing plants for display purposes that have red/pink/purple in them (e.g. orchids, tomato, African violet), then you want to use high CRI lighting so your plants look extra popping. Don't put all that work in to your plant just to make it look dull.

Most people would likely not need to get higher than CRI 90 for general living but who knows what future trends will be. But, the higher the CRI, the lower the luminous efficacy (lumens per watt) will be so the are electricity usage costs to consider particularly in a commercial environment.

CRI 80 lighting has very dull, lifeless reds and lame off colors that makes me want to vomit in rage (and not in the good way, the bad way). CRI 97 and above makes colors really pop and what you want for higher end photography although you may still may need to gel the light even with color temperature control.

Keep the lower CRI 80 lighting in the garage and the shed or for outdoor lighting or install them at your ex's place. There are very high efficacy CRI 65-70 white LEDs that you might find in a warehouse and street lighting which is a big improvement over HPS with a color temperature of 2100K and a CRI in the mid 20's.

You'll also find CRI 70 white LEDs in some grow lights. It makes a lot of sense when added with 660 nm red LEDs because the CRI 70 light will naturally be much lower in the deeper reds and it's more energy efficient to add the red LEDs rather than generate the extra red light through a phophor (remember, green LEDs are inefficient compared to red/blue LEDs).

Red/green/blue only novelty LED light bulbs will have a CRI of around 45 and are horrible as a white light source. This is why a white LED is often added to help bring the CRI up a bit.

Now, take this knowledge and tell every bar and restaurant owner to buy a pack of high or very high CRI LED lights bulbs just to try out and see the difference. My work here is done.



PPFD, DLI, PPE, PPF, and PAR

Read up on core concepts in horticulture lighting

  • PPFD or photosynthetic photon flux density is lighting intensity at a point in space in umol/m2/sec also written umol m-2 sec-1. Use the conversions above (e.g. 70 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec for CRI 80). umol is often written as μmol.

  • DLI or daily light integral is the amount of light per day in mol/m2/day or mol m-2 day-1. DLI uses "mol" for moles and not "umol" for micro moles! For every 100 umol/m2/sec multiply that by 8.6 and then multiply that by the ratio of the on time of the light in hours per day (e.g. 18 hours per day and you multiply that by 0.75 since 18/24 = 0.75). A PPFD of 300 umol/m2/sec on for 18 hours per day will give a DLI of 19.35 mol/m2/day, as an example.

  • PPE or photosynthetic photon efficacy is the amount of light generated per joule of energy written umol/joule or umol joule-1. Since a joule is one watt per second it can also be written umol/watt/sec or umol watt-1 sec-1. In Dec 2019 high end Samsung quantum boards will have a PPE of 2.5-2.7 umol/joule. Low end cheap Chinese grow lights will be around a PPE of 1.3 umol/joule. Osram has red LEDs that are 4.0 umol/joule and above.

  • PPF or photosynthetic photon flux is the total amount of light given off by a light source and written umol/sec. To get the PPF multiply the PPE by the true wattage of the light source. A "100 watt equivalent" 1600 lumen white light bulb gives off about 20 umol/sec of light +/- 10% depending on specific CRI and CCT. ANSI/ASABE S640 along with the DLC does or will define PPF as umol/sec and not being the same as PPFD.

  • PAR or photosynthetically active radiation is light from 400 nm to 700 nm. It is a description of what we measure, not a unit of measurement. There is no "300 PAR", as an example, just like there is no "300 water" or "300 power".



A quick DLI cheat

  • Want a DLI of 17 mol/m2/day for lettuce 18 hours per day? 17,000 lux gets your pretty close. Need a DLI of 30 mol/m2/day for peppers for 18 hours per day? 30,000 lux gets you pretty close.



Sources



Secret bonus material

If you are a botanist or one in training or interested in the subject then you should know about Norman Borlaug, the man who saved a billion lives. This guy would go in to countries and in many cases double that county's grain output in a matter of years. Mind = blown.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norman_Borlaug

http://www.agbioworld.org/biotech-info/topics/borlaug/special.html

https://reason.com/2009/09/13/norman-borlaug-the-man-who-sav/

https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=norman+borlaug


r/HandsOnComplexity • • May 31 '21

Green leaves and green light: what's really going on

62 Upvotes

part of SAG's Plant Lighting Guide

last update: 4 mar 2023 --added green light canopy section and safe light discussion

TL;DR - This is challenging the claim "plants can't use green light", "plants are green because they reflect all green light", or some close iteration that is so often found in biology. My counterclaim is the McCree curve is used in botany, and every paper on photosynthesis studies by wavelength when the test was actually done demonstrates most plants use green light efficiently, particularly compared to blue light and at higher lighting levels.

There are many links to open access papers supporting my claims below. quick link to the McCree (1972) paper

Please point out any mistakes or needed clarifications! I often go back and do edits for mistakes or to add more.



The claim and my problem with it

There is a lot of confusion about how green plants absorb light in biology, and the notion that "plants can't use green light" or "plants are green because they reflect all green light". It comes from biology books that are likely showing you a chart for pigments in a solvent or photosynthetic bacteria/algae, not how higher green land plants actually respond to light. Even with botany books sometimes the wrong charts are used ("Botany for Dummies", written by a PhD botanist, gets it bizarrely wrong by showing pigments that are not even in plants!).

The issue I have with the claim, coming from a horticulture lighting perspective, is that it has been used by many low end predatory LED grow light sellers, such as making outrages claims about the photosynthetic performance of red/blue only LED grow lights compared to some other grow light like HPS (high pressure sodium), by hitting some "magical wavelengths" based off misused science. I've seen a lot of people get taken advantage off (particularity early-mid 2010's) as well as a lot of disappointment.

There were claims about red/blue LED grow lights being better than HPS, by as high as ten to twenty times better growth per watt in the late 2000's, that was overpriced junk (my first LED grow lights were thousands of 5mm low power LEDs that were hand soldered). Even magazine writers were parroting the claim because of a lack of basic due diligence and not testing the lights.

These non-sense claims are where the "600w" and "1000w" "equivalent" Amazon/eBay scammy LED grow lights get their name and their reputation, and it continues to this day with shysters claiming 50 watts of low end LEDs as "600w". Don't ever do business with these type of people, because if they BS you once they'll BS you again. Don't believe their square footage claims needed for growing cannabis.

So from my niche perspective, I have seen the claim collectively cause a lot of financial harm to people, and consumers may not be making good choices by thinking the spectral output of a lower wattage red/blue LED grow light is somehow going to make up for the low lighting levels; It absolutely will not. This is particularly important as indoor growing becomes more popular. It also hurts the "good guys" in the LED grow light business because the shysters give the industry as a whole a bad name. Their hyperbolic claims are a failure every time because science.



The counterclaim and what's really going on

TL;DR- most green light is absorbed and is used for photosynthesis

Every scientific paper on plant lighting by wavelength for photosynthesis backs the claim that plants use green light, and you will never find a paper where the test was actually done say anything differently. But why this is can be very counterintuitive at first, and having so many YouTube videos and even more respectable forums (such as on researchgate.net) show so much misinformation just causes more confusion. I've seen faulty appeal to authority style arguments from even biologist PhD's who are not understanding the science.

...

"plants are green because they reflect all green light or "plants can't use green light"- reflectance, absorption, and transmittance

You are likely going off the pigments dissolved in a solvent chart if you believe this, and that's a relative absorption chart in vitro (e.g cuvette), not the McCree curve that is an absolute chart of how plant leaves respond to light by wavelength for photosynthesis in vivo (living leaf). There is a pretty big difference here. Also, at no point is chlorophyll in a solvent truly at zero percent absorption of green light in higher resolution charts.

Unlike chlorophyll in a solvent, in a green plant leaf we have relatively dense chloroplasts, containing thylakoid membranes stacked as disks (grana), that holds the chlorophyll in a 3D structure called a quantasome (basic photosynthesis unit with around 230 chlorophyll, perhaps 50 carotenoid molecules, and the PSI/PSII). There is a much higher density level of chlorophyll in a leaf than chlorophyll in a solvent extract.

So in vitro, with just relatively loose pigments suspended in a solvents, there is going to be a different measurement and spectral characteristics than in a green leaf in vivo, that is in a dense solid lattice that changes optical characteristics such as broadening the adsorption bands. (BTW, ionized gases do the same broadening under higher pressure/density, and a white xenon strobe tube may be at 10's of atmospheres of pressure (3-4 more typical) giving a broad white and very high CRI light instead of narrow spectral bands (current density also plays a role here)).

You may also be going off an algae chart (first done in the late 1800's!) or some bacteria, which will show a significant dip in the green area, rather than a green terrestrial plant leaf. Hoover (1937) was the first to demonstrate green light photosynthesis in plants (he used wheat that was likely a little bit chlorotic based off the specific shape of his curve).

For absorption, here is an example of a "medium darker green" leaf showing 83% absorption (17% reflectance with how it's set up but that does not matter) from my spectroradiometer, and more typical of what's really going on. Here is a spectral reflectivity profile of a high nitrogen marijuana leaf (Jack Herer). About 90% of the green light is being absorbed although in the cannabis pic. Refer to the McCree paper above to see many more examples (I have my charts flipped because it's easier for me to work with).



The experiment on green leaf absorption with your phone

Don't take my word for it, test it yourself with your three channel spectrometer that's in your phone.

With a color balance adjusted camera (or in post processing), you can take a piece of printer paper and declare that an 88% reflective white reference standard (you want common "88 brightness" paper but can get up to 97 which is based off a 457 nm measurement). Make sure that the paper is "true white', and not "cream white" or "blue white". You can also preferably take an 18% gray card used in photography/video that may have a white side that is typically 90% reflective.

I only use paper or cloth color reference cards to insure near perfect diffused cosine response, not plastic smooth ones which may have a bit of specular reflection (ie glare). The smooth plastic ones are fine in most situations but not in spectrometer. If working with a waxy leaf it's often best to remove the wax layer with very fine steel wool to prevent specular reflections.

Now take a picture of the leaf on the paper. Try to use a more diffuse light source but most any white light source can be used with the color balance adjusted. You want to make sure that you have even lighting on the subject and the white standard.

In your camera's histogram (quick how-to), get the camera's exposure so that the white paper is as high as it goes on the graph without clipping/saturating. We want as much usable dynamic range as possible.

When you have the picture, open it up in GIMP/Photoshop, and we are going to examine a section of white paper right next to the leaf. Adjust the levels to 100% (255 for red/green/blue). Now examine the color of the leaf, taking into account that the levels had to be raised a bit, and you'll see that most of the green light is being absorbed by the leaf and can roughly measure it.

An easily falsifiable experiment is a credible experiment, and the experiment is easy enough to perform to be a good school lesson (if you measure ratios then you can get a good idea of chlorophyll content). I'm sure that there is an app that can easily automatically measure the green levels in leaves.



The McCree curve and its limitations

  • The McCree Curve Demystified -this article discusses the McCree curve from a horticulture lighting scientist's perspective. The "relative action" takes in to account the energy of the photon which is why the blue side takes such a hard dip. Blue photons have more energy than red/green photons, but it's one photon per photochemical reaction as per the Stark-Einstein law, also known as the second law of photochemistry (there are exceptions to the second law).

McCree was a physicist who in the early 1970's tested 22 different types of plants for their photosynthesis response rates by lighting level, and by specific monochromatic lighting spectrum. He took what are called leaf disks, about one inch in diameter leaf cutouts in this case, but 20mm x 20mm was being illumined, in to a machine that was able to measure how much carbon dioxide the illuminated leaf disc was uptaking. That's an accurate way to measure photosynthesis rates. BTW, the light sensor was not any sort of full spectrum quantum light sensor like we'd use today, but rather a thermopile pyranometer painted black that measured the heat generated with the illumined area, with a separate thermocouple as a temperature reference. Pyranometers are still used in agriculture.

The light wavelength was measured in 25 nm intervals, from 350 nm to 725 nm, achieved using a high power arc lamp and water cooled filters. This light gave the leaf discs an illumination level at five test points from 18-150 uMol/m2/sec. This mean was taken for all 22 plants, and the mean totality is how McCree curve was created. So, the McCree curve is a good starting point for learning about photosynthesis rates by wavelength, but the results are limited to lighting conditions that most people will never use because most people don't grow plants with monochromatic light at relatively low levels.

The McCree curve also only looks at the single leaf model of plant growth, not the whole plant model. For example, the McCree curve does not take into account that green (and far red) light can make leaves larger which increases the LAI (leaf area index) capturing more light, but can also cause excess stem elongation from a type of growth called acid growth.

McCree also tested the underside (abaxial) of leaves, and found that they were also performing photosynthesis. In many cases the underside of a leaf will have a lower chlorophyll density, and may reflect more green light than the topside (adaxial) of a leaf, which may lower green light photosynthesis. Monocotyledons (e.g grain crops) tend to have the same photosynthesis rates on both sides of a leaf.

He also found that adding white light to monochromatic light can lower absolute (but not relative) photosynthesis rates at lower lighting levels, saying he found no Emerson effect, but I believe he may have misunderstood what the Emerson effect is. The Emerson effect has to do with light that can drive the photosystem one and two separately, basically freeing up electrons between the PSII and the PSI to increase photosynthesis efficiency. This was discover in 1957 by Robert Emerson, and demonstrated that there were two separate photosystems in plants.

It's my guess that the above white light lowering photosynthesis, may be why the below paper is named the way it is.



Terashima et al has entered the chat

TL;DR- green beat red at about 300 uMol/m2/sec

When I see people mentioning this is only for higher white light conditions mentioned in the title, then I can tell they have not read the paper.

What's going on above? Well first, we are looking at net photosynthesis rates in the above paper and that is what really counts, not absolute absorption. Also, the absorbed green light can also transmit deeper through leaf material more effectively and potentially used for photosynthesis more efficiently.

This is because the top layers of chloroplasts that contains chlorophyll becomes saturated, as per PI curves, while green light can penetrate deeper into leaf tissue (sieve effect) and reflected around until absorbed by a chlorophyll molecule (scattering) or by an accessory pigment.

This efficiency can be measure through the amount of chlorophyll fluorescence or a gas exchange chamber.

Terashima et al were using chlorophyll florescence techniques to measure net photosynthesis rates. Everything you need to know about chlorophyll fluorescence to measure photosynthesis rates can be found here.

What the team found was the green light started outperforming red light at about 300 uMol/m2/sec as measure with a pulse amplitude modulated fluorometer.

You can see this going on in this pic below of light penetration for red, green, and blue light. Red and blue light gets quickly absorb by the chlorophyll near the leaf surface, but green is able to drive photosynthesis deeper.

So what really high intensity light source has a lot of green light that plants evolved to? The sun and at a full sunlight PPFD (photosynthetic photon flux density) of around 2000 uMol/m2/sec would be considered very, very intense light compared to what the average indoor grower would use. With thin leaves (e.g. apple) I can measure perhaps 150 uMol/m2/sec of sunlight through an upper leaf that will illuminate a lower leaf with nearly all green light which is a very efficient lighting level for photosynthesis.

Ironically, it could be the case that plants evolved to be green because of the high green light component in sunlight makes green leaves more efficient, by absorbing most of the green light, and using the absorbed green light more efficiently throughout the leaf.



It's more than just photosynthesis- photomorphogenesis

Photomorphogenesis has to do with light sensitive proteins, and unlike photosynthesis, can be very wavelength dependent in a plant's response. The phytochromes are predominately red and far red with Pr peaking around 660 nm, the blue sensitive proteins are the crytochromes and phototropins have what's known as the "three finger blue action response" with peaks at roughly 430, 450, and 470 nm depending on the specific protein. 470 nm light can be very different than 490 nm light when it comes to light sensitive proteins and how plants respond to light. source 1 source 2

Green light used alone tends to elicit a lot of elongation (stretching) due to triggering the shade avoidance response causing more acid growth which is different than growth though photosynthesis. This is the opposite of blue light. High pressure sodium lights have a lot of green/yellow/amber light which is why they do so well and are still the most widely used in large scale horticulture even at the time of this writing.

The above means that we can get larger leaves with green (and far red) light due to the reversibility of blue light sensitive proteins. Larger leaves means a greater leaf area index which means more potential for photosynthesis from greater light capture.

Green light can also cause the stomata (gaseous exchange pores) of plants to close a bit more than normal, which is the opposite of blue light. Basically to plants, blue light is the opposite of green light, and red light is the opposite to far red light for light sensitive protein reactions (not completely accurate but fairly close).



You eyes can deceive you, don't trust them -Obi-Wan Kenobi, Jedi master

With plants there's also perceptual differences and our eyes have a combined sensitivity curve where the peak of our sensitivity is also were the peak reflectivity is going to be for a green plant. (The individual sensitivity of our 3 color sensitive cone cells in our eyes is this.).

So, it's true plants do reflect more green light than red or blue, but the way we perceive light is naturally much higher biased for green light with a 555 nm sensitivity peak, which is the same as a green plant's reflectivity peak. This allows use to notice very tiny variations of green which can be use to more precisely diagnose a plant if a gatherer. Coincidence? It's also why in cameras there's a ratio of one red, one blue, and two green pixels.

It should be noted that the maximum absorption wavelength for chlorophyll in leaves in vivo is 675-680 nm (chlorophyll A), and not 660 nm as often cited (chlorophyll B is about 645 nm). This can be seen in this spectrometer shot of a chlorotic (yellow) leaf as a dip in the 675-680 nm range from small amounts of chlorophyll A left over. The blue absorption seen are carotenoids which have perhaps a 30-70% efficiency at transferring the absorbed light energy to a photosynthetic reaction center through chlorophyll A. Chlorophyll B is an accessory pigment and higher land plants do not contain chlorophyll C, D, or F (there is no E type). Depending on the plant, there may be 2.5ish-7 or so chlorophyll A molecules for every chlorophyll B molecule but mostly around a 3:1 ratio.

The 30-70% efficiency claim (depending on type and the paper) about carotenoids is why I've always thought it odd that any grow light seller would brag about targeting carotenoids. Carotenoids are there to help the plant with intense lighting and shunting some of the higher energy blue photons absorbed away from chlorophyll through non-photochemical quenching. From a thermodynamics perspective this makes perfect sense for plants to have evolved carotenoids, and we can measure their activity to high light through the photochemical reflectance index by taking ratiometric measurements with a spectrometer.


And that is what's really going on with green light and green plants, and how you perceive them.



Why not use green LEDs?

Green LEDs are electrically inefficient compared to red and blue LEDs, and this problem is known as the "green gap" (google image link) in physics/engineering. The most efficient green LEDs that I known of are actually blue LEDs with a green phosphor.

The above is why white LEDs, blue LEDs with phosphors, are used instead that have a strong green light component. I've done pure green grows, but was using green COBs in a small space, and just to prove a point.

But the above, with our enhanced green light sensitivity, is why we can use green LEDs in red, green, blue lighting strips, for example, and we won't notice the inefficiency in the green LEDs.



green light penetrates deep into the plant canopy?

Many research papers or online sources will say stuff like an advantage of green light is that it can penetrate deep in the plant canopy and drive photosynthesis in lower leaves. The reality is that green light usually doesn't penetrate through cannabis leaves, but green light can penetrate deeper into individual leaves and drive more photosynthesis in that specific leaf.

Outdoors in many plants there will be much more green and far red light in the lower canopy because leaves from nearby plants reflect higher amounts of green and particularly far red light from sunlight. This is likely where the myth comes from and is true for certain growing conditions.

A thin leaf like an apple tree leaf will have about 100-150 uMol/m2/sec of green light penetration through the leaf under full sunlight (2000 uMol/m2/sec) but we're not going to get this with a higher nitrogen and thicker cannabis leaf to any significant degree.

So yes, green light can penetrate deeper into a plant canopy, but that's not really going to happen in a typical cannabis grow chamber like a grow tent to any significant degree. We may use green light for multiple reasons but it has nothing to do with canopy penetration in nearly all indoor grow setups.



green light as a safe light <----not necessarily as safe as thought

We might use green as a safe light (a light for inspecting cannabis photoperiod plants in darkness) due to our eyes being more sensitive to green light and the lower sensitivity of the cryptochrome proteins involved with photoperiodism to green light.

The point that Bugbee makes about cryptochrome (light sensitive protein that plays a role in photoperiodism) is that green light has the potential to trigger more of the cryptochrome proteins deeper in the leaf since green light can penetrate deeper in leaf tissue. But, a point he may not be stressing enough is that cryptochrome also has much lower sensitivity to green light so it could be a combination of the two which allows low levels of green light to be used for short periods in the dark period of photoperiod cannabis plants.



Links to open access papers on green light and plants


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Apr 26 '19

Core Concepts in Horticulture Lighting Theory

62 Upvotes

Core Concepts Horticulture Lighting Theory and Quantum Light Meters

June 2022 edit: changed a few numbers to reflect current technology

part of SAG's Plant Lighting Guide

You need to understand this stuff before understanding more advanced horticulture lighting concepts.



Definitions to know

Avagadro constant- This is a number more popular in chemistry and is expressed as the SI unit as the mole and written as "mol" or "Mol" here. It's simply a really big number of 6.02 * 1023 sometimes written 6.02E23. You should be comfortable working with this number and would have been heavily emphasized during high school chemistry (just like PV=nRT).

"µmol" or "micro mole" is commonly used in horticulture lighting and is 6.02 * 1017 or 6.02E17. This is still a relatively huge number but below it will be made more relatable.

PAR- "photosynthetically active radiation". This is light that has a wavelength from 400 nm to 700 nm. That's it. PAR is not a unit of light but rather a wavelength range of light. Certain types of bacteria can readily use wavelengths of light longer than 700 nm and small amounts of photosynthesis in plants also occurs outside the range of 400 nm to 700 nm. In an ideal quantum light meter, there is no bias and all wavelengths of PAR are counted equally.

PAR is only measured as 400 nm to 700 nm light. Far red or near infrared light that has a wavelength loner than 700 nm would not be included. In botany far red is from 700 - 800 nm and is not counted as PAR nor is <400 nm UV. ePAR by Apogee covers 400-750 nm.

Saying that the lighting levels are "300 PAR", for example, is like saying we have "300 water". Is that 300 glasses of water? 300 liters? 300 acre-feet? PAR in horticulture can be measured as PAR watts per square meter, PPF, PPFD, PPE or DLI. Don't assume the unit used until it is defined as such- this has caused some confusion when I have dealt with people in the past or have read certain research papers.

BAR- "biologically active radiation". This is light that has a biological affect on plants (photosynthesis and light sensitive proteins) with a wavelength from 280-800 nm. You'll rarely see BAR used but still it's important to know since in this definition far red light is included as well as UV light that may also affect plant growth and response. The numbers 280 nm covers the UVR8 protein and 800 nm covers far red photosynthesis in some photosynthetic organisms other than plants like certain bacteria.

PPFD- "photosynthetic photon flux density". This is the intensity or the amount of the light at the point that the measurement was made. This unit of light alone tells nothing about the wavelength(s) of light, only the amount of PAR when measuring PAR in this unit.

PPFD is given in the SI units of umol/m2/sec, often written µmol m-2 s-1 or something similar, and is pronounced "micro moles per square meter per second". I typically say just "micromoles" IRL as long as everyone knows. You can sometimes see it written as µE or "micro Einsteins" particularly in papers written in the 1980's.

Roughly 2000 umol/m2/sec of light is equivalent to full daylight and most plants can not take more than 500-1000 uMol/m2/sec of light without a photosynthesis efficiency hit but this really depends on the plant- don't assume all are the same and even different cultivars of the same plant type can have different lighting needs.

We measure PPFD with a type of light meter called a ā€œquantum light meterā€. ā€œQuantumā€ in this case is not some gimmick marketing term but rather to emphasize that the meter is measuring the actual number of photons, the quanta or individual particle of the electromagnetic field, being radiated to a space such as the top of a plant canopy.

For human light intensity we use lux and lux meters instead since the unit of lux has a strong green bias just like our eyes do. We do not perceive blue and red light as intensely or as well as green light and for human eye measurements we want a sensor/meter to match that.

Because a lux meter does have a strong bias for green light and does not measure different wavelengths of light equally, measuring red and blue light low, we should not use a lux meter with color LED lights.

*For clarification it would not be 500 PPFD as an example, it's a PPFD of 500 umol/m2/sec.

PPF- "photosynthetic photon flux". This is how much light a fixture is giving off in umol/sec. PPE times the wattage of the light equals PPF.

There is some confusion about this term. It can be very well argued that this is the same as PPFD above but is being defined by ASABE and will most certainly be accepted as an industry standard to define how much light is being given radiated by a lighting fixture, or by a lighting source such as an LED, as measured in umol/sec or "micromoles per second". ANSI and the ISO will be defining PPF as total light output in umol/sec.

uMol/second is analogous to the lumens measurement for total light output of white light sources, or the radiant power of any light source.

Joule- A unit of energy equal to one watt per second. Since a watt is volt times amperage you'll sometimes see this as VA for volt-ampere. If I have a 1000 watt light running for one second then 1000 joules of energy is consumed (note- many cheaper LED grow lights are exaggerating their wattage draw and you want to go off "true" or "actual" wattage) . If this 1000 watt light runs for one hour then 3600 seconds * 1000 watts = 3,600,00 joules or 3.6 megajoules is consumed. So 3.6 megajoules is a kilowatt-hour (kWh) which is the unit of energy on your electrical bill. I pay about $.09 per kWh for my electricity which equals one penny for 400,000 joules of electricity.

Don't get joules which is energy mixed up with watts which is power.

umol/joule or PPE- "micromoles per joule" or "photosynthetic photon efficacy". This is a critical measurement of lighting sources that tells us how much light is being radiated per amount of energy consumed by the light source. It is literally a metric of how many photons are being produced per joule of energy input. A HPS light puts out right around 1.8 uMol/joule, top end grow lights put out about 2.4 umol/joule, and I will demonstrate below how a blue LED pumped white light source may never have above 3.76 umol/joule (for a 450 nm LED).

Low end LED grow lights are going to be from about 0.9-1.3 uMol/joule. You may save money on the front end but you are going to get hit with much higher energy usage costs long term.

Don't ever buy a grow light for professional use unless you know the uMol/joule number. This should not be the sole decision in making a purchase since other features like lighting geometry are important.

electronvolt- for our purposes the electronvolt, or eV, is how much energy an individual photon has although it is also be used to measure mass of electrons, protons, and the like due to mass-energy equivalence. Even though a photon has no mass it still has energy in the form of momentum.

PAR photons have an energy range of 1.77 eV for a 700 nm photon to 3.10 eV for a 400 nm photon.

One eV equals 1.602 * 10-19 joules of energy.

The amount of light given off by an LED is determined solely by current levels. But blue photons have a higher eV than red photons so with LEDs, blue LEDs need a higher voltage than red LEDs. If I have a constant current LED driver rated for 30 volts max, I can use about ten blue LEDs in series but about 14 red LEDs in series because blue LEDs have a higher voltage drop.

(Although Plank's Constant would suggest that light energy can only come in discrete units or discrete wavelengths, Lorentz boosting would suggest that it can come in any wavelength).

Tl;DR- most people should take eV as an arbitrary unit of energy defined by photon wavelength. Although it is critical to know of eV at least to understand below. I have a 40,000 character limit here and this topic can go on.

DLI- "daily light integral". This is the amount of light a plant receives per day measured in mol/m2/d or "moles per square meter per day". DLI does not take in to account that as the intensity of the light increases in PPFD that the photosynthetic efficiency of the plant decreases.

It is very easy to spoof this number. 2400 umol/m2/sec for one hour will have the same DLI number as 100 umol/m2/sec running 24 hours per day. Obviously the plants are going to behave differently when the 2400 umol/m2/sec plants are in darkness 23 hours per day with most of that light be wasted regardless due to such mechanisms as non-photochemical quenching, and the other plants are bathed in continuous low levels of light driven at a fairly efficient PPFD.

An easy way to quickly calculate the DLI is to take 100 umol/m2/sec * 24 hours = DLI of 8.6. 24 hour lighting at 200 umol/m2/sec is a DLI of 17 mol/m2/day. If I have 400 umol/m2/sec of light for 16 hours per day then the DLI is 4 * 8.6 constant * (16/24) of a day = round up to DLI of 23 mol/m2/day.

Take a PPFD measurement in uMol/m2/sec.

Divide that result by 100.

Multiply that result by 8.6.

That will get you the DLI in Mol/m2/day assuming 24 hours of light per day. "Moles of photons per square meter per day". (I incorrectly said "micro moles" in my previous reply when talking about DLI which could cause confusion. DLI is about moles of photons per day, PPFD is about micromoles of photons per second)

DLI = (PPFD/100)*8.6

You can take the PPFD and go through all the math at 86400 seconds per day (this is where the 8.6 comes from rounded down from 8.64), convert micro moles to moles (a factor of one million), and get the same number. My way is so much easier, though.


Cosine corrected- This means that the light meter either has a sensor that follows Lambert's cosine law or has a white diffuser in front of the sensor to correct for any cosine errors. The lack of cosine correction is why the light sensor in you phone is a very poor replacement for a dedicated light meter. When a cosine corrected light meter/sensor is pointed 60 degrees from a point light source then there should be half the reading as when the sensor is pointed directly at the light source.

Using a light meter that is not cosine corrected, such as your phone, can cause some pretty significant measurement errors.

McCree curve- This is a chart averaged of 22 different types of plants used in botany that shows the amount of photosynthesis that occurs by wavelength. The McCree curve is only valid at 50 uMol/m2/sec of monochromatic light with the single leaf model but a useful starting point. The McCree curve is different than absorption curves of pigments isolated from a plant leaf and gives much more realistic information as to how plants respond to photosynthesis by wavelength.

There are other curves somewhat similar to the McCree curve (1972) rarely seen such as the Inada curve (1976) and the Hoover curve (1937).

The McCree curve uses interpolation and if more data points were taken then you'd find that the slope on the right side of the curve around 690-700 nm is much steeper.

To emphasize, the McCree curve should only be used as a starting point and should not be taken as an end all, be all in how plants will perform by wavelength. Lighting is much more complicated than that.

Correlated color temperature- abbreviated "CCT" this measurement in degrees kelvins give us the red/blue light ratio of a white light source with 5500K-5700K being considered a neutral or "daylight" light source since the color temperature of daylight on a non-cloudy day is about 5700K. For a natural black body radiation source, it is the spectrum power distribution of an object heated to 5700K or to any other temperature.

For an artificial lighting source such as LED lighting, CCT is how white light is perceived. Cool white will have a higher blue light ratio and be at a higher CCT such as 6500K. Warm white will have a higher red light ratio and have a lower CCT such as 2700K. Higher color temperatures are common for vegetative growth since the higher blue light ration will help keep plants more compact.

With color temperature we can perceive red hot and blue hot but not green hot since our eyes will adapt to make green hot appear to be just white hot. This is why there are no green stars even though a star like out sun has a near green peak.

More on color temperature can be found here.

CRI- color rendition index. CRI is a measurement of how well a light replicates reflected colors compared to sunlight and has little if anything to do with horticulture lighting but we will still run in to this number with white LEDs and other white light sources. What's important for us is to understand that the higher the CRI number the greater and deeper the red light we will have (it does not have to be this way in theory but is this way in practice). Our eyes have less red light sensitivity compared to other colors, so a really high CRI light will have less lumens per watt although there may be the same amount of light being produced as umol/sec and as perceived by the plant.

The maximum theoretical efficacy of white light sources is about 320 lumens per watt for a CRI of 80, 300 lumens per watt for a CRI of 90, and 280 lumens per watt for a CRI of 100 depending on the phototropic cutoff points (2). These numbers are fairly close only. A white LED that is 100% efficient that draws one watt of power (one joule per second) will output about 320 lumens of light at CRI 80. An LED with a CRI of 80 that outputs 200 lumens per watt will have an efficiency of 200/320= 63%. But an LED with a CRI of 100 that output 200 lumens per watt will have an efficiency of 200/280= 71%.

As an aside, if you want to make your food look better then use high CRI light bulbs in your kitchen and dinning room that are also lower color temperature. CRI 80 light bulbs have a very low R9 value. The newer CRI 90 and above LED bulbs also really help with skin tones and won't make you look so pasty.

Because a higher CRI is going to make things looks better, if you have plants growing for display purposes, like for growing and displaying your orchids particularly red flowers, then you should be using higher CRI lights that are CRI 90 and above.

Fluorescent lighting- Light using a higher energy photon (higher eV), such as a blue, violet, or UV photons, to generate other spectra of light such as green, yellow, orange, and red through down-conversion using a phosphor. Most all white LED lights on the market today are using blue LEDs as a pump source exciting phosphor(s) to give us white light at various correlated color temperatures and CRI numbers. By definition all white light in common use is fluorescent lighting even if they are white LEDs.



The energy of a photon, efficacy, and efficiency

Photon energy calculator

[1240] / [wavelength in nm] = energy of photon in eV

[10.37] / [energy of photon in eV] = umol of photons per joule

If you can get through this section then you will have a lot of insight in to lighting and some of my online rants/raves will make more sense.

Knowing the energy of a photon in eV is important for determining such stuff as how much light can a grow light put out at 100% efficiency or by making measurements such as how much energy is being lost with white LEDs using blue LEDs to generate the light. Understanding it is pretty fundamental to horticulture lighting theory.

A fast and easy way to calculate the energy of a photon is to take 1240 (1.240E3) and divide by the wavelength of the photon in nanometers. A red 660 nm photon is 1240/660=1.88 eV. A blue photon is 1240/450=2.76 eV. It's that simple!

A UV photon generated with mercury vapor, such as found in non-LED fluorescent lighting such as compact fluorescent lights or T5 grow lights, has a wavelength of 254 nm for an energy of 1240/254=4.88 eV. A far red photon of 735 nm has an energy of 1240/735=1.69 eV.

Knowing how much energy a photon has allows us to make theoretical calculations as to the efficacy of the photon. For this we take 10.37, and divide by the photon energy in eV, to get how many photons can be generated per energy input in joules or the photon efficacy. For a red 660 nm photon with an energy of 1.88 eV we get 10.37/1.88= 5.52 uMol/joule or 5.52 micro moles of photons per joule input. If we have a 660 nm red LED that is 100% electrically efficient then for every joule that the LED consumes 5.52 uMol of photons will be produced. A red 660 nm LED that is 50% efficient will output 2.76 uMol/joule.

If we have a 450 nm blue LED what is the maximum amount of photons that can be produced per joule of energy input? 1240/450=2.76 eV per photon. 10.37/2.76= 3.76 umol/joule. If that 450 nm blue LED is being used as the phosphor pump for a white LED then at 100% efficiency 3.76 umol/joule of photons is being generated. There is no way that a 450 nm LED can ever produce more than 3.76 umol/joule so we just established a theoretical maximum for white LEDs/white light that use 450 nm LEDs. So if I have a white LED and it produces 2.4 umol/joule of light then I know that the electrical efficiency of that white LED is 2.4 / 3.76= 64% efficient.

As mentioned, currently 2.4 umol/joule is about as good as it gets for white LEDs at full power (June 2022 edit- 3.1 umol/joule is about current). But what if it was a 660 nm red LED that generates 2.4 umol/joule. How efficient would that red LED be? 1240/660= 1.88 eV per photon. 10.37/1.88= 5.52 eV/joule. 2.4 / 5.52= 43%. In this example a red 660nm LED that is 43% efficient produces as much light as a 450 nm LED that is 64% efficient because the red photons have less energy than the blue photons and as a result more can be produced per energy input. And that, in a nutshell, is a compelling reason to use red LEDs (I'm going to get much more in to this in another article on light absorption by a leaf with my spectrometer).

What is the average energy needed to drive photosynthesis? I know that the photosystem II requires photons with 680 nm wavelengths or shorter. The photosystem I requires 700 nm or shorter. Averaging the two gives us (680+700)/2= 690. Figuring out the energy is 1240/690=1.80 eV. The correct answer is 1.80 eV of energy needed to drive photosynthesis averaged and any higher energy amount absorbed is wasted as heat.

I have a "blurple" COB LED (blue LEDs pumping a red phosphor). It's phosphor pump source is 450 nm. It's main red fluorescence peak is 630 nm. How much energy do I waste generating these red photons with a blue light source? 1240/450=2.76 eV for the blue photon. 1240/630=1.97 eV for the red photon. 2.76-1.97=0.79 eV of energy is wasted for every red photon produced not taking in to account the quantum efficiency of the phosphor. The energy is wasted in the phosphor as heat and is sometimes known as Stokes heating. This is one reason why these "blurple" LEDs are inefficient compared to using just red and blue LEDs.

Photons from mercury vapor found in traditional fluorescent lights, such as compact fluorescent lights, has a predominate wavelength of 254 nm. 1240/254= 4.88 eV per photon. 10.37/4.88= 2.13 umol/joule. At 100% efficiency a T5 fluorescent grow light is at 2.13 umol/joule and it's no where near 100% efficient which is why these styles of grow lights are becoming obsolete.



What exactly is a quantum light meter?

Sometimes called a "quantum PAR meter" or just "PAR meter", an ideal quantum light meter measures light from 400-700 nm that has a flat response so it measures light equally across the PAR wavelength band of 400 to 700 nm. 450 nm photons will give the same reading as 660 nm photons, as an example, which is deceptively tricky to do. You can buy very close to ideal light meters. The LiCOR meters are the high end standard (in the US) but Apogee has meters and sensors that are essentially as good at about half the price (Apogee uses freshly calibrated LiCor sensors as NIST traceable standards when calibrating their own quantum sensors). I personally use the Apogee SQ-520 USB sensor when a spectroradiometer is overkill.

What makes a good quantum light meter is the whole flat response of the sensor issue. Silicon photodiodes do not have anything close to a flat response so a "flattening" filter must be used. These are not cheap!. On top of that, a 400-700 nm band pass filter is used which is surprisingly cheap. I tested that $15 filter with my spectrometer and it really does block light well at 700nm while staying fairly flat as long as the light is on axis (thin film filters can have different characteristics for off axis light so filter placement in relation to the silicon diode becomes very important.)

On top of careful calibration of high quality meters/sensors, on top of higher prices due to economies of scale, on top of R&D, rather expensive components are being used. I'm sure Apogee is doing well for themselves but you're not going to get super rich making tools even at about $350 for a sensor (I'm happy to pay this relatively low price for a full spectrum, high build quality sensor that will last for years).

You get what you pay for which leads to....

The cheapest quantum light meter is not worth the money

One of the shittiest meters I've ever bought, and I'm talking all types of meters, is the $135 Hydrofarm Quantum PAR meter. The meter is cheaply made, turns off every two minutes, has a poor battery life, I had to remove my battery because it was about to rupture, but worse than all of that is that it does not use a higher quality sensor but a cheaper four channel spectral sensor (It's I2c at 100 KHz and a few readings per second).

Spectral sensors have their place. Hydrofarm can use this same sensor and meter to make a lux meter with a firmware change. Spectral sensors do provide some color information unlike single sensor quantum light meters. But they are going to have gaps in their coverage unlike a diffraction grating spectrometer (my Stellarnet Greenwave has about 1000 channels with no gaps for comparison). For example, 520 nm LEDs are going to read about 50% too low with the Hydrofarm meter due to spectral gaps although it did read 620 and 660 nm LEDs well enough.

The Hydrofarm sensor was also not consistent at variable lighting levels so ten times as much light does not mean ten times the reading on the meter.

The $270 solar/electric quantum light meter from Specmeters did fair better. It did self-destruct after about three years of heavy use but was dead on accurate with HPS lighting and sunlight. The issue here is that it used not a silicon diode but another type of photodiode known as a GaAsP diode (gallium arsenide phosphide) which is also found in some lower cost Apogee quantum light meters. They are used since they will not read far red light which eliminates a filter and do not necessarily need a flattening filter. But, the better Apogee quantum light meters use a blue correction filter to flatten the GaAsP sensors response a bit, unlike the Specmeter meter, and none of these lower cost quantum meters are considered "full spectrum". This means in practice that they are not going to read 660 nm LEDs properly that are common in LED grow lights. Your measurements with such lights are going to potentially be way off.

Save your money and buy the Apogee SQ-520, the MQ-500 or similar full spectrum light sensor/meter. I've seen someone selling homemade quantum light meters using Apogee sensors that I would never buy particularly at a little over $500, about the price of a MQ-500. If it has a 3D printed case or advertised as handmade then do not buy it- get something straight from the manufacturer with guaranteed calibration, a display that will work in bright light, a long warranty, and isn't based off an Arduino (I love Arduino, though).

Keep in mind that quantum meters, full spectrum or not, will not work with far red LEDs.

But what about lux meters?

I've had plenty of people tell me that lux meters are worthless for plant use. My retort is shut the fuck up context is important. The vast majority of hobbyists are not going to spend many hundreds of dollars on a quantum light meter, for example, but will spend $20 on a lux meter.

It is perfectly legit to use a lux meter with a white light source, and white light source only, within constraints and I've covered this before on my article using a lux meter as a plant light meter. But what I did not cover in that beginners article is the affects of different CRI numbers on different correlated color temperatures.

CRI does really have nothing to do with botany but it does have something to do with conversion values of lux to umol/m2/sec. Basically the higher the CRI the lower the conversion value. I did link to some CRI numbers in the lux meter article, as well as emphasizing that you should not use lux meters with color LEDs. In the paper below, Maximum Spectral Luminous Efficacy of White Light, it does give more realistic efficacy ratings for white light at different CRI numbers and the theory of why the conversion numbers are different. The paper below, An easy estimate of the PFDD for a plant illuminated with white LEDs: 1000 lx = 15 μmol/s/m2 gives a broader estimate of 67 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec (I use 70 as a conversion value for a light with a CRI of 80, low 60's for a CRI of 90 and 55 for a CRI of 100 like sunlight).

It's really using your phone as a lux meter which isn't going to fly. Due to lack of cosine correction, off axis I've had measurements that were ten times off. Different phones can have different sensors with different characteristics. Putting a case on your phone could partially block the sensor compounding the errors. I can't even guarantee that all apps are going to give the same results.



What is a spectrometer?

A spectrometer is a device that allows us to make lighting measurements by wavelength. If all you need is to see what wavelengths of light are present then for about $10 you can buy a spectroscope (I used one of these before I had a spectrometer). If you need a spectrometer that can read lighting power measurements such as lux, watts/m2 or uMol/m2/sec then you need a spectroradiometer. A freshly calibrated spectroradiometer is more accurate than a quantum light meter/sensor and can read wavelengths outside of 400-700 nm PAR or adjusted in software just to read PAR like a quantum light meter. Lab spectrometers can also read ratios of any light inside their wavelength range (mine will read from 350-1100 nm. Enhanced UV spectrometers can read down to 200 nm. If you are working with DNA or doing a lot of flame/plasma analysis work then you want an enhanced UV spectrometer).

A spectrometer is just as fundamental of a research tool to lighting as an oscilloscope is to electronics. They allow us to measure absolute or relative lighting intensity, reflection, absorption, and transmission by wavelength. Almost any type of lighting measurement can be made with a modern spectrometer with sufficient resolution such as color temperature and CRI number; it's simply a software issue.

There are affordable DIY spectrometer kits that you can buy for about $50 with open source software. I strongly doubt that these are being used as spectroradiometers due to calibration issues. I have not played around with these kits but seems like a really good way to get started in spectrometry.

There are micro spectrometers based on diffraction gratings (a diffraction grating breaks up light in to its individual wavelength components like a prism like the DIY spectrometer above. Most all spectrometers use diffraction gratings) for around $400 when they are on the market designed to be used with Arduinos and the like. These are the types of sensors found in $1500 range handheld spectrometers and tend to have a lower resolution and lower sensitivity compared to the lab style spectrometers as well as not having a fiber optic input.

Spectral sensors (sensors with two to dozens of photodiodes that each have their own narrow band pass filter) can be used as micro spectrometers although they will have gaps in their coverage. I have used the AS7262 six channel visible light sensor which is a really nice sensor for white LEDs, the AS7263 NIR spectral sensor which can work as a red/far red light meter, and the 18 channel AS7265X set. A huge advantage of these sensors is that they come pre-calibrated (to a point).

You already have a three channel spectrometer

The camera in you phone is a three channel spectrometer. To accurately use at such, you want to get a gray card used in photography. Take a picture of the gray card with your subject on it like this. Since the gray card is going to have an 18% reflectance (or very close to it) for the red, green, and blue channels in your camera, we can open up Photoshop/Gimp etc and adjust the red, green, blue color levels to all be equal and all adjusted to 18% or 46,46,46 which normalizes the lighting (evens out or compensates for various types of lighting). We can then analyze the colors in the test subject. We can use this information to analyze and estimate the chlorophyll levels in leaves using this technique, for instance. We will be discussing this further in a future article.



How much light does a "100 watt" light bulb put out?

The light bulbs in your home are rated in wattage equivalent to an incandescent bulb and don't actually use 100 watts. A "100 watt" light bulb is around 1600 lumens and a "60 watt" bulb is around 800 lumens. If we know that the white light coming from the bulb with a CRI of 80 has a theoretical maximum efficacy of 320 lumens per watt**(2)** and our light is rated for 110 lumens per watt then the bulb is 34% efficient. If the light bulb is using 450 nm blue LEDs as a phosphor pump source, and the maximum theoretical efficacy of a 450 nm photon is 3.76 umol/joule, then we know that the light is putting out 1.28 umol/joule of light. The light will be drawing 14.5 watts (1600 lumens light output / 110 lumens per watt) giving a total PPF of 18.8 umol/sec of light. If that 18.8 umol/sec of light is spread evenly over a square meter of plant canopy then the average light intensity in the square meter will have a PPFD of 18.8 umol/m2/sec.

An economic metric one might use is umol/sec per dollar or PPF/dollar. If that "100 watt equivalent" 18.8 umol/sec light bulb is costs $2.50 then 18.8/2.5= 7.52 umol/sec per dollar is the cost of the light. As a comparison, a 1000 HPS consumes 1000 watts and outputs 1800 uMol/sec of light. That 1000 HPS lighting setup costs $200. 1800/200= 9 umol/sec per dollar. The HPS provides 25% more light per dollar than the LED light bulb.



Revisiting uMol/m2/sec

I hate pronouncing ten syllables for a lighting measurement. But this measurement makes so much sense in horticulture lighting that I'm willing to swallow my rage until it's a little tiny pit in my stomach right next to my poor liver (hang in there little guy!). Let's say that I want to have an idea of how many photons are hitting one square millimeter of leaf tissue. I have 166 umol/m2/sec of light hitting my leaf. A micromole is 6.02E17. 166 umol is 1.00E20 so we conveniently have 1.00E20 photons per square meter per second. A millimeter is 1/1000th a meter so a square millimeter is one millionth of a square meter which is 1.00E6. 1.00E20 minus 1.00E6 is 1.00E14 or 100 trillion photons per square millimeter per second.

I know that a chlorophyll molecule is going to be right around 1 nanometer in diameter or one billionth of a meter or 1.00E-9. There are 1.00E18 square nanometers in a square meter. At 166 umol/m2/sec we have 1.00E20 photons per second minus 1.00E18 or 100 photons per square nanometers per second. That would also be 100 million photons per square micron.

Calculating how many photons are hitting a given arbitrary area becomes pretty easy after a little practice with this unit of measurement.

But we can also measure how much CO2 is being consumed by a plant in umol/sec of CO2 molecules at a given umol/m2/sec light value. Or how much sugar is produced. Or how much water is being transpired. Particularly on the chemical side it just makes things more convenient.



Conclusion

I am going to make this article clearer as needed. Next article is going to be talking about absorption properties in leaves, likely some stuff of chlorophyll fluorescence and how you can measure it without breaking the bank, and further articulations on some of the stuff above. I also want to show how to design a quantum light sensor step by step.

Spend $20 and get yourself a cosine corrected light meter! Even a lux meter is far better than no meter.



Sources

(1) Measuring Daily Light Integral in a Greenhouse-- Torres, Lopez

(2) Maximum Spectral Luminous Efficacy of White Light-- Murphy 2013

(3) Light Meter for Measuring Photosynthetically Active Radiation-- Kutschera, Lamb 2018

(4) Accuracy of quantum sensors measuring yield photon flux and photosynthetic photon flux-- Barnes et al 1993

(5) Sources of errors in measurements of PAR-- Ross, Sulev 1999

(6) Accurate PAR Measurement: Comparison of Eight Quantum Sensor Models

(7) Effects of radiation quality, intensity, and duration on photosynthesis and growth

(8) An easy estimate of the PPFD for a plant illuminated with white LEDs: 1000 lx = 15 μmol/s/m2-- Sharakshane ā€Ž2018

(9) Design of Photosynthetically Active Radiation Sensor-- Dilip et al 2018

(10) Construction and Testing of an Inexpensive PAR Sensor-- Fielder, Comeau 2000



quick chart

[1240] / [wavelength in nm] = energy of photon in eV

[10.37] / [energy of photon in eV] = umol of photons per joule

735nm    6.14uMol/J    1.69eV     far red 
660nm    5.51uMol/J    1.88eV     deep red
630nm    5.27uMol/J    1.97eV     red
570nm    4.77uMol/J    2.18eV     yellow
550nm    4.60uMol/J    2.25eV     greenish-yellow
525nm    4.39uMol/J    2.36eV     green
470nm    3.92uMol/J    2.64eV     blue
450nm    3.76uMol/J    2.76eV     royal blue
375nm    3.13uMol/J    3.31eV     ultraviolet A
254nm    2.12uMol/J    4.88eV     ultraviolet C

r/HandsOnComplexity • • Jan 15 '22

SAG's open access cannabis links

60 Upvotes

SAG's Open Access Cannabis Links

last update: 11 NOV 2022 (added 100 papers in part 2)



  • Most links are for THC cannabis but some are for hemp or CBD and found primarily using Google Scholar. At the very bottom is a recently added section which will likely be every few months.

  • Please report dead links! You sometimes have to look around a bit to find the actual PDF download in the page linked to.



Highlights



Cannabis spectral and lighting

--THESIS


--ULTRAVIOLET


--SPECTRUM AND LIGHTING LEVELS







Commercial Cultivation

--THESIS


--ENERGY


--BUSINESS



--ENVIRONMENT AND SAFETY




--CULTIVATION





Root zone




Propagation and genetics








Biochemistry






Recently added

39 papers added 20may22





r/HandsOnComplexity • • Mar 14 '21

links to scientific papers

60 Upvotes

Open Access Scientific Literature (more than just plant lighting)

part of SAG's Plant Lighting Guide

last update: 19 july 2024- added far red 2024 page



Links by subject and video series


Non-lighting open access papers



Quick links to some favorite papers/videos


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Nov 24 '13

LED and LED grow lights part 5: Working with 100 watt LED modules

55 Upvotes

Working with LEDs and LED grow lights part 5: using low cost 100 watt LEDs. This is part of the Lighting Guide.


edit 19jun2017- be careful with getting open case line voltage power supplies as they can be very dangerous. Here is an example of an open case power supply in a kit that you should not buy unless you have previous experience working with line voltage. With this particular kit you will need a 12 volt power supply with the fan.

edit 2019- there are plenty of Mean Well LED drivers out now and you should be using name brand COBs like from Bridgelux or Cree

http://archive.is/x04ai


The nice thing about 100 watt LEDs is that they give you the best bang for your buck initially. At the time of this writing 100 watt white LEDs are in the $8 range (I've seen under $5 in bid, just now paid $6.08 in bid) and 100 watt color LEDs are in the $20 range. Now, these are no name Chinese LEDS bought off Ebay but 30 watt Cree modules can be bought for $15 that gives in the 130 lumens per watt range. These are great for micro grows or for Space Bucket grows.

I have 100 watt warm white, cool white, red, green and blue LEDs as well as a 50 watt red/green/blue LED.

POWER SUPPLY

A compelling reason to use 100 watt LEDs rather than say 40 or 60 watt LEDs is to under drive the 100 watt LED to make them more efficient. They're actually 100 emitters bonded to the same module, 10 in series and 10 strings in parallel. A 50 watt will be 10 in series, 5 strings in parallel. 100 watt generic white LEDs are advertised as having 8-9000 lumens (edit- these numbers thrown around may be a bit optimistic) but if you drive them at 50% rated current levels they can be around 30% more electrically efficient. This only apples to these generic EBay white LEDs and your results may be a little different but you will get higher efficiency- I believe the reason why is that it has to do with the quantum efficiency of the phosphor versus LED die temperature and Auger recombination. Regardless, the thermal load alone in a compelling reason to use lower current levels with 100 watt LEDs. Don't buy a 50 watt no name Ebay white LEDs and a 50 watt power supply. Spend a few extra bucks and buy a 100 watt LED with a 50 watt power supply for greater efficiency and longer life.

It's likely most don't want to get in to a DIY project beyond some soldering. For you, just go on eBay and pick up the power supply. Never over drive your LEDs, always under drive no name LEDs (theme here) and do not exceed the current rating of name brand LEDs like Cree, Osram, Nichia, Philips and the like. I drive no name LEDs at 50-70% their current rating max. And watch the voltage rating. A person with a 60(?) watt red LED had a power supply for a 50 watt white LED. Well, that ballast is designed for 30-36 volts found with the white LED module but the red LED ran at 18-22 volts. This caused the ballast to flicker. The solution was to put a 20 watt 10-12 volt red LED in series and of the appropriate amperage rating and the problem was solved.

So, remember to get a power supply that matches the LED voltage but get one at a reduced current. PM me if you're not sure. Some 10 watt white LEDs run at 10-12 volts, some are the 30-36 volt type, for example. Know what you're getting.

BTW, technically, the power supply is a ballast. Just using a resistor? It would be called a "ballast resistor". I have no idea why LED power supplies are not called a ballast and I use the terms interchangeably.

THE DIY POWER SUPPLY

I build modules and use them alone or together. Here's some so you can get an idea to build your own. All are powered off old used laptop power supplies that I was able to shake down friends for and 150 watt DC-DC converters that are $6 on Ebay (I replace the capacitors at higher power levels and use a fan at about 50 watts and above, a $1.30 buck converter is also shown for a 12 volt output as is the $1 12 volt cooling fan).

The idea is to use a free laptop computer power supply and then use an efficient 150 watt switching power supply to 30-35 volts and then regulate the current. The actual voltage is set to maximum electrical efficiency for the specific LED. One can also use a ATX PC power supply and run the input to the 150 modules at 12 volts but it will need air cooling at higher power levels.

SAMPLE HIGH POWER MODULES

100 watt red at 60 watts. Being used to supplement a 150 HPS, 647nm, ā€œbrickā€ heat sink, dual fans, op amp/mosfet linear constant current, thermal cut out switch. I'll be talking more about this module in part 6.

100 watt green at 50 watts up close This is a cheap and easy constant voltage with a thermal cut out switch. A one ohm, 10 watt resistor you can get at Radio Shack is used in series with the LED. It's technically called a ā€œballast resistorā€ when used in this way as stated. As opinion, 50% the current rating is the highest you should go if running constant voltage unless you have some sort of thermal cutout switch or a very well designed heat sink.

50 watt red/green/blue This is PWM (Pulse Width Modulation dimming) controlled by an Arduino, a very simple microcontroller system to work with because of its huge user base and easy to use software libraries. Notice the 4 extra red LEDs to make up for the lower voltage drop of red LEDs. Each red, green, blue LED string has its own LM317 and PWM transistor. Electronically, this is very easy stuff to make once you get over that initial hump and learn soldering skills. There are also better/more efficient ways to dim an LED; with rapid testing/prototyping/not caring sometimes ease is the priority.

100 watt cool white at up to 70 watts Constant voltage with one ohm resistor, thermal cut out switch. Larger fan and heat sink allows two 100 watt LEDs to be mounted here.

Two 100 watt at 18 watts each plus additional This is for a Space Bucket. This will be its own post. All LM317 constant current.

100 watt robotic light with sonar This is a focused light that acts in place of a light mover using 2 servos and a sonar unit to determine optimal light intensity. Uses pulsed light which allows for a tiny heat sink. This particular light is to manipulate blue light sensitive proteins rather than a general purpose grow light and is a rough prototype. Humidity and temperature sensor also included. Those fans sticking out are to provide additional canopy air circulation.

note to self- add pics

HEAT SINK

The heat sink is one area where the price can quickly go up. As a minimum you want a 1/8 inch thick, 2 inch wide, 12 inch long piece of aluminum with fins attached to make a relatively low cost heat sink for these very how power LEDs. Figure 50-60 watts per foot with some airflow and this is a conservative figure. Why not cheaper steel? Give it a try but aluminum is superior at conducting heat away from the 100 watt LED. Home Depot had all the aluminum and 4/40 screws etc I used.

The middle heat sink is ideal for 100 watt class LEDs. It did not overheat at 50 watts with no fan but I use one regardless.

Air cooled heat sinks for high power CPUs would also work. Many are designed for +80 watts.

Use thermal grease to get a good thermal bond between the bare heat sink and the LED. Do not forget this step. I've seen chap/lip stick used as thermal grease in a CPU over clocking test. It worked just as well as low end silicon heat grease. If you are going to max these LEDs out, I'd use a a better paste like Arctic Silver 5 otherwise you can get by on low end heat grease. A little goes a long ways. The smother the surface, the less grease you need to use. Using too much grease is also bad so spread it very thin and twist the LED around a bit on the heat sink to get out any tiny air bubbles and to let extra grease squeeze out the edges of the LEDs to be wiped up.

Use flat black spray paint that is also a primer, single layer, to dump the heat off the heat sink faster. I found that Krylon flat black to work quite well. The idea is to raise the aluminum's emissivity since being a shinny metal is quite low. It's not as critical is there's air flow cooling.

DAZZLE AND HIGH POWER SAFETY

Sunglasses are your friend. If your wear glasses then get a pair that'll slip over them. Working with 100 watt LEDs feels like I need a welding mask. As with HID lighting (HPS, metal halide, etc), there is a very intense photon flux density in a rather small area/volume unlike linear lighting like T5 or other fluorescent tubes. This will cause severe temporary dazzle so work with these very high power level LEDs when them facing away from you and/or wear proper eye protection.

Be extra careful with 100 watt blue LEDs. Wickedlasers.com has a good piece on blue light hazard. With the higher energy photons you can damage more than just you eyes- objects up real close will heat up very fast. I like burning stuff as much as the next hacker but just be careful.

additions:

what do you think of these 100w LED outdoor light fixtures sold on eBay

Watch this youtube video on a 10 watt unit tare down to see what I think about the quality. Make damn sure that the lighting fixture frame is actually grounded.

setting up a 100w LED with this 150 watt boost converter

Recent testing found that the Bridgelux VERO 29 81w LEDs where in the 50% greater energy efficient ballpark than these cheap eBay 100 watt LEDs. The VERO 29 can safely be ran above 120 watts if you can keep the LED cool enough. The VERO 29 also needs about 40 volts so you need to use the booster in the pic off eBay

You need a multimeter. First wire up the booster to the laptop power supply. Do not wire it up backwards. Adjust the voltage to a few volts above the typical voltage drop across the LED. You want roughly 35 volts for the white generic 100w COB LEDs and 42 or so for the VERO 29. (24 volts or so for the eBay 100w red ones). BTW, never buy red LEDs where you can't see the individual chips. Don't buy this type of red LED which is a blue LED with a very inefficient red phosphor, get this one where you can see the LED chips.

Assuming you have a multimeter rated for 20 amps or so then put the red plug into the current plug receptacle from the voltage receptacle where it's likely in. Set the multimeter to its highest amperage rating. If you don't understand what you meter is rated for then PM me.

Now hook up the negative side on the LED to the "-" booster power supply terminal and you are going to want to take the red lead of you multimeter and rig it up to the + terminal of the boost converter. The black wire of your multimeter is then used to power up the LED. We are literally putting the multimeter in series between the power supply and the LED.

Once you current is dialed in simple take the multimeter out of the circuit and wire up normally.

I tinker a lot and one may need to keep adjusting the current or not have a meter with a higher current rating. I use a .27 (or .47 ohm), 5 watt resistor in series and then measure the voltage drop across the resistor. I know at .27 volts we have one amp flowing trough the circuit. For 1600mA flowing through the LED you'd want .43 volts to drop across the resistor, for example. This resistor, called a "shunt resistor" in this instance, can be taken out of the circuit after current level is determined.

Radio Shack sells 1 ohm 10 watt resistors if you were to need a quick resistor.

Meters are typically pretty forgiving to electrical abuse.

On the generic white 100w LEDs there is a "+" symbol. The solder lead point nearest is the negative side of the LED.

The constant current adjustment potentiometer should be turned all the way to the left. That may be a 20 turn potentiometer so take a screw and give it 20 turns to the left to make sure you are initially set to a very low current. Turn to the right to raise the current. If you need more current but the boost converter isn't providing it then you need to set the voltage higher.

If you notice any strobing then you are likely overloading your laptop or other power supply and need to turn down the current on the LED.

You might want to have some sunglasses handy or work with the 100w LED facing away from you. You'll understand.

what's the magic LED grow light formula?

I don't know. Try 2 parts red to one part warm white as a flowering light.

I want to build a 800 watt light but have no electronics background and have never grown a plant before

Start:

No. Build a 100 watt unit first. In fact, I prefer 100 watt modules so you can experiment easier and just use different modules together. No, listen to me, you don't understand heat and the thermal requirements. Build a 100 watt unit first as you can always expand later with DIY. Why won't you listen to me? Build a 100 watt unit first.

Goto start


r/HandsOnComplexity • • May 02 '21

Arduino links for the botanist

53 Upvotes

last update: May 2021

main links page

Part of SAG's Plant Lighting Guide

this will be edited as needed



quick notes on sensors

Don't use resistive moisture sensors for soil like shown in many of the papers below. You want to use capacitive moisture sensors instead. Resistive sensors tend to not last long due to damage from electrolysis. If you do use a resistive moisture sensor then power on the sensor through a digital pin as needed, wait perhaps 1 mSec for everything to stabilize, do your A/D measurement, and then power down the sensor again until the next measurement is needed. This will minimize electrolysis damage long term and you will quickly kill a resistive sensor that is left powered on.

Capacitive soil moisture sensors can be left on all the time and do not have the above electrolysis issue assuming they are properly sealed including the all of electronics. They are not affected by soil (fertilizer) salts content unlike resistive sensors. The orientation and placement of a capacitive sensor will make a difference in their output in soil containers so you may have to play around a bit to get the more ideal reading range you want. I've seen this cause issues and you generally want the circuit board side facing inwards with the common generic capacitive v1.2 soil moisture sensor.

I would avoid the DHT11 humidity/temperature sensor shown in many papers below. I prefer the BME280 because I can set a bunch up and actually have them read the same under the same conditions consistently, which can be a problem with very low cost humidity sensors like the DHT11. The BME280 on protoboards are pretty cheap out of China, if in the US then check out eBay for US sellers at a pretty low cost (around $4 and you get an air pressure sensor in addition). The MCP9808 is one of the better lower cost temperature sensors that I also tested.

The Arduino type lux sensors that I've tested are pretty close to cosine correct (this is so, so important and why your phone makes a poor light meter). Assuming you know the lux to µmol m-2 s-1 PPFD conversion value for your light source, then a lux sensor can be used for plant lighting. I discuss this more in my article on using a lux meter as a plant light meter with links to supporting literature. Be sure that you can verify the lux measurement readings with a calibrated full spectrum quantum light meter for higher academic use. The TSL2591 can also be used for ultra high dynamic range two channel spectrophotometry.

Most of the latest spectral sensors like the $16 10-channel AS7341 spectrometer are not cosine correct so may need a secondary optic depending on your application (probably not as a general purpose spectrophotometer). The AS7341 could be made in to a full spectrum quantum light meter saving you >$500, when cosine corrected with a thin piece of white opaque plastic spaced properly, and a great sign of where lower cost spectrometry and light measurement is headed. The AS72652 can be used as a low cost red/far red light sensor also saving you >$500. The TCS3200 color sensor is being used as a SPAD meter replacement in some papers saving >$1,000. The TCS34725 color sensor is cosine correct and can fairly accurately measure color temperature with the AdaFruit library.

For carbon dioxide measurements, you ideally want to use dual channel NDIR type sensors although most of the lower cost ones are single channel. When first working around CO2 sensors, you need to be aware that you are constantly breathing out about 45,000 ppm CO2 and this is going to affect the sensor on the lab bench. It's a good idea to give lower cost NDIR sensors a several day burn-in period before relying on them. The MH-Z14A is an example of a lower cost but fairly accurate CO2 sensor with official library support.

The $7 VL53L0X laser range finder can be used to monitor plant growth or for cheap 3D scanning with a small tube over the sensor reduce the FOV. You may want to do some averaging with the sensor output.



grow related systems



farming and agriculture



measurements and lab gear



misc


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Oct 16 '13

LED and LED Grow lights part 4: building your first LED grow light

53 Upvotes

This is part of the LED series of the Lighting Guide.

edit 2019- this is a bit obsolete now and there are better ways to builb LED drivers if you don't wish to build a linear constant current driver.

So, here's a step by step for a simple 10 watt LED light. After this we'll move up to 100 watt LEDs that are about $8 for white and $20 for color at the time of this writing. In the last 9 months they have mostly dropped half in price. These 10 watt white LEDs can be bought for about $1.40 off EBay. The compelling reason for learning to build you own lights is flexibility and safety. You must know how to use a soldering iron. Here's a video on soldering. Let me know if you need more help with soldering.

Common tools used. The tools on the bottom from left to right are wire strippers, needle nose pliers, clippers (I'm lost without them) and forceps which are nice for surface mount work. The wire is stranded 22 gauge. The solder is 0.032 inch. You can pick up a cheap soldering iron at Radio Shack but the more expensive units are far superior.

My soldering iron is temperature controlled by changing tips. It'll go from 600-800 degrees F and I always have it set to 800 degrees for fast consistency. I'd rather go cheap on a multimeter than a soldering iron if you're going to do a lot of soldering. Speaking of which, a cheap digital multimeter should be another tool you should have. Just plan on $20. I checked a wide variety of cheap digital multimeters and none was off by more than 3% compared to a Fluke 287 with a fresh NIST tracable calibration.

I say the same thing about cheap digital light meters. A group I tested where good enough for white light sources and in the $20 range. I just bought a $13 one to work with an integration sphere for white light sources and for quick general measurements. It'll be calibrated to a NIST traceable spectrometer, though



The simplest way: SAG, just tell me how to do it without all the extra stuff!

Get a 10 watt warm white LED

Get a power supply

Get a heat sink

Boom, baby-you're in business. You still need to solder. With bigger LEDs like the 100 watt ones get power supplies that are rated at about 1/2 to 2/3rds current levels. The thermal load is easier to manage, the LEDs will last longer and they'll be significantly more electrically efficient at lower drive currents.



A few useful links:

Ohm's Law calculator. You need to know Ohm's Law but the resistive circuit analysis is all we need. You'll learn this below. Ignore the time varying and reactive circuits in the wiki link.

how to soldering video Let me know if you need more help with soldering.

1-3 amp buck converters. I love these- they make good PC fan speed controllers.

150 watt dc-dc boost converter. I replace the capacitors. The stock capacitors have a high fail rate when driving higher voltage white LEDs.

LED power supplies on ebay PM me if you need help finding what's best for you.

LM317 in constant current mode.. Take 1.25, divide by the resistor in ohms and that how many amps you get.

I keep a stock of 1.3 ohm, 2 ohm and 2.2 ohm, two watt resistors on hand.



The build We'll do a quick constant voltage so some stuff can be explained and then go in to a more appropriate constant current set up.

1---bend side terminals up and melt some solder on them. Pre-soldering makes soldering the wire much easier. Bending the terminals up a little makes sire they don't contact the heat sink.

2---up close shot of soldered terminal

3---up close shot without solder

4---put a thin layer of heat grease on the back of the LED. Radio shack will have plenty of varieties. [You just need the cheap stuff.] (http://www.radioshack.com/product/index.jsp?productId=15438946) ignore the comment, it lasts long term

5----mount them to the heat sink middle of the heat sink. Use aluminum stock 1/8th inch thick, 1 1/2-2 inches wide and 8-10 inches long. There's a few ways of doing this. Screws and washers, screws that fit the out indentations, screws that fit in the small holes, 5 minute epoxy around the edges (I often do this), thermal epoxy, adhesive thermal pads. If you use 5 minute epoxy, give it 5 hours to cure otherwise you'll end up with a gooey mess.

6---optionally mount the buck converter to the heat sink with a spacer. Those are 4-40 screws that Home Depot should have.

7---shot of heat sink, 1 ohm resistor and buck converter before every thing is solder. Pre-soldering everything makes soldering components together easier. Once done solder everything together. <NOTE TO SELF- put up a schematic here>

8---As mentioned, we'll play with constant voltage first. Apply at least 12 volts to the primary side of the buck converter. You can use an old lap top computer supply, 12 volt "wall wart" or the like.

Spin that little screw on the blue, rectangular potentiometer about 20 complete turns counter clockwise. This will ensure the output voltage is a minimum. Measure the voltage across the one ohm resistor. Turn the screw clockwise until it reads 0.7 volts. This will mean 0.7 amps of current are flowering through the circuit. The LED will be quite bright at this point. Wear sunglasses or put an object in front of the LED to block the light from your eyes.

As a build hint, wait 15 minutes for everything to warm up and reach thermal equilibrium and then redial the voltage is down to .7 amps which is 70% of the current and call it good for a very simple set up. I like the 4 second rule- if you can keep your finger on the heat sink for 4 seconds then you're good to go. I do run some 100 watt LEDs this way but with a thermal cut out switch (another article).



constant current

I'll do LEDs constant voltage but I mostly do constant current. It all has to do with thermal runaway. The hotter the LED gets the lower the voltage drop across the LED. This allows more current to flow. This extra heat from the increased current causes a further voltage drop across the LED that allows even more current to flow. The device may heat up to the point of destroying itself. That's thermal runaway in a nutshell.

This is why we use a constant current source with LEDs- when the LEDs get hotter and the voltage drop decreases, instead of allowing more current to flow, the voltage to the LED is dropped to maintain a consistent current. No thermal runaway.

Now, you can buy constant current power supplies and just be done with it. But, in future projects we'll be modulating the LEDs for experimentation and dynamic spectrum controllable lighting using the Arduino microcontroller or in analog only.

We start with removing the 1 ohm power resistor and solder in a LM317 with a 2 ohm resistor. Since there's a constant 1.25 volts dropped across the resistor, 1.25 volts / 2 ohms = 0.612 amps. Around a 60-65% current levels is about what the experiment board can handle with a single 10 watt LED.

lm317 set up with the 1 ohm resistor removed

lm317 up close

lm2596 removed If you have a 12-15 volt power supply then you can get rid of the lm2596 and just use the LM317.

LED on It can be very intense on the eyes



some LM317 resistor values (amps, resistor value, resistor wattage rating)

1.25 amps    1 ohm        2 watt

1 amp        1.25 ohm     2 watt

0.7 amp      1.79 ohm     2 watt

0.63 amp     2 ohm        2 watt

0.5 amp      2.5 ohm      1 watt

0.31 amp     4 ohm        1 watt

0.25 amp     5 ohm        1 watt

0.125 amp    10 ohm       1/2 watt

Remember, you can use multiple resistors in series and/or parallel to hit the amperage you want.



So, ask for clarifications or things I should add to above. Working with 100 watt LEDs, a bit on side lighting, low cost DIY heat sink design and temperature control will be the next article.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 10 '16

basic plant FAQ V0.1

52 Upvotes

Basic Plant FAQ V0.1 updated 9feb2016

This is a temporary posting and will be deleted upon V1.0 release. THIS IS ONLY A FIRST DRAFT AND IS NOT COMPLETE! It is not yet archived in the lighting guide. Constructive feedback is appreciated.


This is being archived in my plant lighting guide series. I'm most active on /r/spacebuckets and one may feel free to PM me as needed.

CRITICAL THINKING AND RELIABLE SOURCES

There are a lot of claims made about various facets of plant growth such as some sort of super plant growth supplement giving twice the yield as normal, for example. The burden of proof on such claims is always upon the person making the claim. Otherwise we run in to a condition known as appeal to negative proof or an argument from ignorance which is a logical fallacy. ā€œWhat can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidenceā€ (Hitchens, 2003).

Psychologically we tend to be prone to two conditions that one should be aware of when learning about plants or some other subject. This is cognitive inertia, where the first piece of information taken tends to stick with us whether correct or incorrect, and confirmation bias where we tend to interpret results that align with our particular beliefs. Due to the amount of questionable information about cannabis online, it is so important not to fall in to these two psychological traps if you want to truly understand how cannabis as a plant works.

Be careful of appeal to authority. When getting advice or looking up information on a forum, what are the person's qualifications giving out that information. Just because someone has demonstrated that they can grow a plant does not make one an expert on the subject. As analogy, just because one can bake a cake does not make that person a pastry chef. Does this person have a financial interest in giving out certain information? Is the information sourced and sourced properly (this can be very tough for the layman)? Are you getting information from a beginner who does not understand basic botany? This happens all the time which is why there is so much bad information on cannabis.

Here is an entity with a PhD on staff trying to sell some very odd plant enhancement device. Hey, it's been tested by Ohio State University! The results appear to be inconclusive. But we have science! A paper was cited of someone who has a financial interest in this product. I can't comment on the other tests since the methods do not appear to be published. A hydroponics testing/retail company that tested this device appears not to sell it (why?). Testimonials have to be taken with caution.

Understanding the key concepts above will help you learn about a new subject and help you from being taken advantage of by people peddling products that may be nothing but snake oil.

"I don't know" is perfectly legit. If demonstrated to be wrong acknowledge it.


ASKING FOR HELP

The first pieces of information when doing a plant diagnostic request needed is a picture of the plant under white light from the top and from the side. The run off pH should be known (when you water a plant you need to measure the pH of the water/solution that drips through the soil, not the pH level added to the soil), the soil used and the fertilizer used. The specific strain or plant type should also be stated. With cannabis, a sativa dominate AK-47 is much more tolerant than the blue/purple indicas to pH problems as another example.

Never use liquid pH drops for testing since they are only intended for clear liquids. pH paper can be bought cheaply and has no special storage nor calibration requirements. Only use pH test strips that are for a pH of 5.5-8.0, never use the pH 1-14 strips.

One problem leaf does not necessarily mean that there is a problem with the whole plant.


HOW TO WATER A PLANT AND WHAT IS OVER WATERING

Over watering is a continuous condition of low oxygen levels and the root zone

We know that plants can be in water 100% of the time due to hydroponics

Most plants need at least 4ppm dissolved oxygen levels

Root rot is where a fungus sets in the medium and roots from low oxygen conditions

Root rot shows symptoms with loss of turgor pressure (cellular collapse) in the lower leaves and leaf petioles. It is almost always fatal to the plant. The xylem is being destroyed.

White roots means no root rot. You can dig down on the side of the plant to look at root color. Brown roots that are mushy are rotted roots. Some fertilizers can stain roots brown such as General Hydroponics Micro.

Roots will not grow in to dry soil.

The "2 knuckle" rule is a good rule of thumb of when to water your plant. Stick your finger in to the soil to the second knuckle. Does it feel dry? If yes then water you plant.

Most experienced growers do a lift test to tell when a plant needs to be watered. Does the plant container feel light weight? If yes then water.

When you water a plant water it completely rather than just spray water on top.


HOW NUTRIENTS, SUGARS AND OTHER STUFF IS TRANSPORTED IN PLANTS

Roots have the ability to uptake nutrients selectively through transport proteins. They can also alter the pH of its immediate surroundings by releasing organic acids.

There are 2 transport structures in a land plant, the xylem and the phloem.

Xylem- one way, powered by the transpiration process. Nutrients that are nonmobile can only be translocated through the xylem which is why nonmobile deficiencies show up in new growth.

Phloem- two way powered by the pressure flow hypothesis. Can transport sugars, amino acids, some proteins, mobile nutrients. Mobile nutrient deficiencies can show up in old growth because enzymes (proteins) can release them from the leaves in to the phloem to go to new growth areas of the plant.

There is very weak evidence that land plants can uptake sugars and carbohydrates through their roots and have these sugars and carbohydrates translocated to the upper plant.


WHAT IS SPOTTED NECROSIS AND TIP BURN

This is a close up pic of spotted necrosis

Spotted necrosis, often called necrotic spotting, are localized areas typically on leaf tissue that has some sort of nutrient deficiency. This is often simply caused nutrients being locked up in the soil for a pH that is too low in most cases. Spotted necrosis on the bottom leaves and the newer growth can be caused by different nutrient deficiencies.

If you see spotted necrosis on your plant then the first thing you do is check the run off pH of the plant. A pH of mid 6 is were you want to be.

This is a close up pic of tip burn

Spotted necrosis is different than tip burn. Tip burn is typically caused by salt build up in the leaves from over fertilizing. There is then an osmotic imbalance causing or preventing nutrient ions from going to areas where there is less of a salt build up such as the very tip of a leaf. In particular calcium can't get to the leaf tips so cell walls can not be built and the tip dies. Calcium is sometimes added to leaf crops like lettuce to help prevent tip burn at higher fertilizer levels since necrotic tissue doesn't sell well aesthetically and is prone to molding in shipping.


UNDERSTANDING PLANT NUTRIENTS AND DEFICIENCIES/EXCESSES

a diagnostic flow chart will be added

Instead of fertilizing every two weeks, try cutting the fertilizers to one third strength and fertilize every time you water. Unless you really now what you're doing, it's best to under fertilize than to push a plant.

Chlorophyll A and B has 4 nitrogen atoms and 1 magnesium atom. These are the only types of chlorophyll found in land plants.

Hard water means that your water source has a lot of calcium, magnesium and usually iron in it. These are all important plant nutrients so it may not be the case that you would want to use a reverse osmosis filter to get rid of the minerals. There are nutrients specifically designed to work with hard water. Do not use chemical water softeners, use a reverse osmosis filter if needed.

Mobile means mobile in phloem, not soil in this thread

Mobile means deficiencies usually show up in lower leaves first. Non-mobile means new growth affected. This is why a side and top pics are needed.


Macro nutrients <nutrient> <ionic form> <mobile, not mobile> <what it is for> <deficiency> <excess>

Nitrogen NO3- , NH4+ (mobile) amino acids and proteins. Part of chlorophyll. Def- yellowing from the bottom up, red or purple striping on the stems and petioles. Ex- nitrogen clawing with very dark green leaves- must be more than one leaf

---Red stripes on the stem is a sign of a nitrogen deficiency although genetics can play a role.

Phosphorus H2PO4-, HPO42- (mobile) Def- brown splotching (mottling) on leaves with soft edges. Ex- smaller leaves that are wrinkled. Blocks Fe, Mn, Zn uptake. Harder to uptake when cool.

Potassium k+ (mobile) explain the concept of ā€œhidden hungerā€ and low K. Proteins and stomata opening. Def- chlorosis leaf edges Ex- can block Ca, Mg

Magnesium Mg2+ (mobile) Chlorophyll and enzymes Def- general chlorosis from chlorophyll being unable to form.

Calcium Ca2+ (not mobile) mostly cell walls and cell membranes. Helps prevent tip burn.

Sulfur SO42- (not mobile) mostly used for amino acids, chlorophyll production, essential oils Def- new growth is yellow


Micronutrients- used mainly for enzymes. Non-mobile means protein bound

Chlorine Cl- (mobile) ionic balance and osmosis

Zinc Zn2+ (not mobile) helps form chlorophyll, enzymes, Ex- can block Fe

Copper Cu2+ (not mobile) enzymes Ex- can block Fe

Iron Fe2+, Fe3+ (not mobile) Def-green leaf veins with chlorosis in newer leaves. Part of cytochrome proteins.

Molybdenum MoO42- (not mobile) enzymes

Manganese Mn2+ (not mobile) interveinal chlorosis in young leaves

Zinc Zn2- (partial mobile) enzymes Def- mid plant interveinal chlorosis, stunting

Cobalt Cu2+ (not mobile) enzymes Def- interveinal chlorosis

Boron BO3-, B4O7- (partial mobile) carbohydrate transport, nucleic acid synthesis, cell walls. Def- New leaves light green and twisted.


HORMONES

Plant hormones play the dominate role in plant development.

auxin cell expansion. Used in rooting compounds for clones. Used in "weed and feed" to kill dicotyledons (plants that have 2 leaves when germinating like cannabis) while leaving monocotyledons (plants that have a single leaf when germinating like corn and lawn grass) intact. Hormone most involved with plant morphology (plant shape) and tropisms (how a plant reacts to environmental conditions like light or gravity).

cytokinins cell division. Can be bought as Nitrozyme

gibberellins cell expansion. In cannabis commonly used to hermaphrodite a female plant to produce feminized seeds. Can be used to help some seeds to germinate. Can be bought in powder form here

abscisic acid reacts to stress. forms with dry soil to signal stomata to close

ethylene involved in plant ripening. Very simple hydrocarbon in gaseous form (C2H4)

brassinosteroids reacts to plant stress particularly leaf damage. Lowers photosynthesis efficiency in leaves.

florigen hypothesis proteins involved in flowering. The hypothesis states that flowering is triggered in leaves.


TEMPERATURE

roots 68-72 is ideal. Above the lower 80s and fungal problems can start. This is why in hydroponics chillers are often used.

upper plant can be in the lower 90's

soil will be cooler due to natural evaporation cooling <show thermal pic>


CARBON DIOXIDE

400ppm is normal ambient. There is debate if 1000ppm is optimal or if 1500ppm is. Yields reduce at above 2000ppm or so.

The most inefficient and expensive way to generate CO2 is chemical based reactions like vinegar and baking soda. 5 or 20 pound tanks/regulators are used with smaller grow ops, liquid propane or natural gas and usually used in large grow ops.

Most people do not use CO2 enhancement due to needing CO2 enhancement levels in a certain range and the need to deal with humidity.


HUMIDITY

explain vapor pressure deficit and stoma

You can get mold at higher humidity particularly Botrytis. Some strains are mold resistant.


DIFFERENT TYPES OF SOIL

soil acidifiers and soil basifiers

--Peat moss works as a soil acidifier buffer. Use if having problems with too high of a pH.

--Dolomite lime works as a basifier buffer and has calcium and magnesium. One can sprinkle some on top of the soil and wash it in. Use if having a problem with too low of a pH.

Use mineral acids and bases only. Phosphoric acid can cause iron deficiencies (interveinal chlorosis) in certain cases where phosphorus levels are already high which is a compelling reason to use nitric acid instead. Explain why no organic acid.

Adding perlite to the soil can help prevent over watering.


SEEDS and CLONES

Stable genetic seeds that are true breeding are P1 seeds. Plants that are P1 produce P1 seeds with the same genetics besides potential mutations. Older strains (Bid Bud, Northern Lights, Skunk#1 etc) and strains with enough inbreeding for the same traits can be considered P1.

Breeding 2 separate types of P1 plants produces an F1 hybrid (ie "Royal Kush" is an afgani kush crossed with a Skunk#1. "Purple Trainwreck" is Trainwreck crossed with Grand Daddy Purple). F1 hybrid seeds have genetics that pretty much expresses themselves the same (ie same flowering time). F1 hybrids are one way to protect genetics because if you seed out an F1 hybrid you'll get F2 hybrid seeds. F2 hybrid seeds will have genetics that can express themselves randomly so F2 hybrid seeds off the same F1 plant can grow differently.

Feminized seeds come from a female cannabis plant that was forced to produce male flowers to self pollinate. Since there is no Y chromosome involved you get a female seed. Forced hermaphrodites generally use giberrellic acid sprays although other chemicals like colloidal silver and colchicine can be used (colchicine can also be used as a plant mutagen.

Clones will always be the same whether taken off a mother donor plant or in a perpetual cloning set up where clones are taken off plants in vegetative growth.


HOW TO DEAL WITH POWDERY MILDEW, FUNGUS GNATS AND SPIDER MITES

Powdery mildew- spray the leaves with baking soda. Use ½ teaspoon in a spray bottle. It works by raising the pH of the leaf surface. Some strains are PM resistant. Basically any bicarbonate can be used for PM control such as potassium bicarbonate. Baking soda (sodium bicarbonate) is the only instance where I'd use sodium on a C3 plant like cannabis, tomatoes etc. Try not to spray the buds but if you do the bicarbonate can be washed off at harvest.

Fungus gnats- put an inch of aquarium gravel on top of the soil to keep the gnats from breeding <show pic>

Spider mites- better you than me. Use neem oil and spray pyrethrins on the underside of the leaves. You have to control the eggs. Mites come from poor plant hygiene.

virtually any emulsified oil will control the TSSM. Also might consider spinosad. i personally combine emulsified oil, pyrethrins and spinosad, cause overkill is its own reward. This is a good tip from HugePrime.


PIGMENTS

photosynthetically active accessory pigments: chlorophyll B, carotenoids

other pigments: anthocyanins


PLANT SUPPLEMENTS AND SNAKE OIL

<puts flame suit on>

No published peer reviewed cited studies on adding carbohydrates to soil being uptaken by a land plant. Ask sellers of carbo additives for a study outside a lab and see what they say! (some studies use root or leaf discs, not plants in a real life condition) If they can't back it up then don't buy it. Anecdotes and testimonials are not scientific. Ask how they get around the casparian strip.

Most plant supplements are worthless on an otherwise healthy plant. Amino acid additives may be broken down for its nitrogen or you can just add nitrogen to your plant.

Many carbo supplements claim to work with bacteria in the soil without actually stating what the optimal bacteria count per cubic centimeter is. Does too high of a bacterial count compete with the roots for resources? Also, when you buy soil it is generally pasteurized first killing bacteria in the soil although it can be reinoculated.

Aquaponics does require nitrifying bacteria as part of the nitrogen cycle.

Mycorrhiza is a fungus that can be an additive that helps in the uptake of some nutrients. You want endo, not ecto, mycorrhiza. This is a good write up since fungi is not my specialty.

Rhizobia is a bacteria that can be added for nitrification with legumes.

Plant roots do release sugars, amino acids and proteins into their rhizosphere.

Plant supplements are a hot topic for debate and a great way to start a flame war.


MY PLANT WON'T GROW. WHY?

Try feeding your plant (hidden hunger from low potassium). Get the temperature up. Improper watering.


LAWS ON CANNABIS AND A CAUTION ON KEEPING FIREARMS AROUND

Discuss the tale of two growers who got caught- one went to prison for having a shotgun, cops let the other one off

Mention that firearms stored in cars and storage units can still be used against you.

Define firearm according to WA state law

US government response to medical marijuana and firearms


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Sep 09 '21

Bruce Bugbee AMA Highlights and Commentary

40 Upvotes

Bruce Bugbee AMA highlights and commentary

part of SAG's Lighting Guide

Bugbee AMA <<<link to the AMA

last update: 13 SEP 2021



Organic vs synthetic fertilizers

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha66mu4/

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha6ate2/

I think "organic" is non-sense and stopped using it in the late 1990's (I'll go ahead and put that flame suit on now!). For me and cannabis, it was/is a consistency issue. I knew a lot of growers (Seattle area) who would use hot organic soils, and in many instances get leaves all curled up due to phosphorus levels being way too high affecting taste and how the pot smokes (I thought this was a huge problem in Amsterdam in the late 1990's). Or the lower leaves may start yellowing much too early. I prefer everything dialed in perfectly from start to finish and expect all leaves to be green when harvested.

But, fertilizers and "organic" are outside my specialty, and I do not engage in debates over it. My mantra has always been, "find what works for you and stick with it". I use General Hydroponics 3 part flora with the same 1:1:1 ratio (NPK of 7/6/11) for everything and every plant. The nitrogen and phosphorus levels are about the same with very high potassium levels (all protein/enzyme synthesis relies on potassium, and plays a role in many other plant processes like photosynthesis and carbohydrate metabolism). I use the same fertilizer ratios for radish seedlings as I do for flowering cannabis, with the same pH for hydro and soil (around 6.5), but at different strengths. I need consistency so my motivations may be different than yours because I enjoy researching plant lighting, not plant fertilizers.

Because I use potassium hydroxide for pH control, my potassium levels are even higher than what's mentioned above.

Even outdoors I avoid organic fertilizers. I have seen nitrifying bacterial inoculations perform very well outdoors, and I'm sure it works well indoors, too.

I would like to say that I'm quite pleasantly amused that Bugbee is not a fan of organic! Take that, hippies. /s

"find what works for you and stick with it"



Veg vs flowering fertilizers

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha64ihk/

I use the same for everything.



Fertilizer strength

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha6du4n/

TL;DR- EC of 1.4

This is in the ballpark of what I run cannabis at.



pH with lime

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha6328a/

Lime is a pH buffer in that it stays in the soil. I personally use potassium hydroxide, and I do tend to run my pH a bit higher than most people.



Container size

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha6f985/

TL;DR- the bigger the better. There is a good meta-study below. It likely has to do with cytokinin levels which is a hormone responsible for cellular division, and higher cytokinin levels in the roots means higher cytokinin levels throughout the plant. Bonsai plants have small leaves due to small root mass. Not all plants can be turned in to a true small bonsai plant, though.

A case for smaller containers may be the sea of green style of growing. But, taller containers that are narrow stills means one can have a larger container size. BTW, legal reasons and plant count is a compelling reason not to do sea of green.



Flushing

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha69aqr/

TL;DR- don't bother in most cases. Below is what he's referring to.

I can honestly say that no one can ever tell if I flushed a plant or not.



Pruning

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha65974/

TL;DR- minimal

This is another amusing response because I tend not to prune, either. I prefer to light up the lower leaves rather than prune. Airflow issues may be a good reason to prune, though. People often over prune and a photon that is absorbed by the soil is a wasted photon.



Mediums

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha6dzmq/

Don't ask too many question in a single post!



Powdery mildew

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha6gamw/

TIL about silicon levels in the soil and PM (powdery mildew). For me, I use strains not prone to PM, and use a half teaspoon of baking soda and a drop of liquid soap in a standard size spray bottle to spray on the leaves for PM. This raises the pH of the leaf surface so PM can't grow. I'm highly allergic to PM and know if it's there before it becomes visible.



Heirloom strains

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha67xj0/

I think a lot of heirloom strains suck. I've grown original strains that were around in Seattle in the 1980's, and the Dutch did wonders in correcting their many flaws in the 1990's. Original Big Bud from the 1980's is very prone to botrytis (gray mold) and "banana hermies", the Dutch version does not have these issues.

These newer strains out are superior to most heirlooms in most every way. An heirloom that I am very fond of is Durban Poison which is a South African pure sativa that is an 8 week plant with very high yields. Durban Poison x Northern Lights #5 is also a favorite and another huge yielder.



Spectrum tuning

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha6c3mi/

Spectrum shapes the plant, but high light increases yield- Bugbee. This is perfectly written.

....

High efficacy (the technical term for efficiency) is more important than spectrum- Bugee. This is horribly written.

NO, just NO! Efficacy is absolutely not the technical term for efficiency, particularly in lighting, and I don't know why he wrote this. There are many instances where efficacy and efficiency will be the same, but I've never seen them the same in lighting. Never.

I would have wrote it as, "in general, light quantity is more important than light quality".

Say I have a 450 nm blue LED that is 2.8 umol/joule and a 660 nm red LED that is 2.8 umol/joule. Those are identical efficacies, right? That is the PPE or "photosynthetic photon efficacy". But that blue LED has an electrical efficiency of 74% and the red LED has an efficiency of 51%. Refer to my cheat sheet under the Energy and efficacy of photons for the math, and why I'm right.

But SAG, he has a PhD and you barely graduated high school with a GPA of 2.3 and never even took high school biology! I don't care, he's wrong here.

Luminous efficacy and luminous efficiency are also no where close to being the same. Not even the same ballpark. I talk about this in my cheat sheet linked to above under "Luminous efficiency and lux meters", and show a luminous efficiency chart. Luminous efficiency is in percentage sensitivity for a certain wavelength of light relative to 555 nm and the spectral response of the human eye, luminous efficacy is lumens per watt. Those are not close to being the same. It mixes things up but I can also have a red 660 nm LED that will have a luminous efficiency of about 6%, could have an electrical efficiency of 60%, and this gets us a photosynthetic photon efficacy of 3.3 uMol/joule that would have a luminous efficacy of about 25 lumens per watt.

  • Luminous efficiency chart from the book, "Introduction to Radiometry and Photometry" and an example of "fair use" under 17 USC part 107.

He's actually been wrong on other stuff like claiming UV photons are "hundreds or thousands of times more powerful" than PAR (source- 4 minute mark on video, How Ultraviolet Radiation Affects Plants with Dr. Bruce Bugbee). Photons of those energy levels would be x-rays or soft gamma rays (depending how they are generated- x-rays are emitted from electrons, gamma rays are from atomic nucleus but can have the same energy levels), and this will quickly kill the plant.

Even if he's talking about a UV beibg thousands of times more powerful for a photomorphogenesis effect, he still has to prove the claim and the claim has not been proven in the literature.

He used to also conflate PPF with PPFD (he explained why in a couple videos, and why he does not anymore). When I see papers conflating PPF and PPFD, I look to see if Bugbee is being referenced.

My points being, just because it's Dr Bruce Bugbee does not mean everything he's saying is correct although it nearly always is. I've corrected my share of PhDs IRL and online, and the title "Dr" does not confer infallibility. But, most PhDs will readily stand corrected if actually demonstrated to be incorrect because that's being a good scientist, and it's easy to make mistakes just typing or talking away in an AMA. I go back and do edits as needed in my lighting guide to fix my mistakes or to add clarifications.

Also, don't confuse some slight criticism and scientific corrections for lack of respect.



My questions- overdriving light, chlorophyll fluorescence, spectral sensors

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha63jmi/

I wanted his opinion on overdriving plants and he did not actually answer. But, saying "We are doing additional studies o this now" is honest which should be respected. "I don't know" is always acceptable in this case and it means the person has credibility because they are not BSing you. Red has has a higher theoretical (and currently practical) maximum efficacy over blue although the efficiency may never reach that of blue. Did I mention don't get efficacy and efficiency confused!

He did say that he also uses chlorophyll fluorescence techniques but preferred other techniques (it allows me to see what individual proteins are up to). His alluding to chlorophyll fluorescence not being able to be used on single leaf and whole canopies models is actually wrong (see the work by David Kramer). NASA also uses chlorophyll fluorescence imaging in some satellites.

He ignored the question about using $5 spectral sensors instead of using silicon diodes with a fairly cheap interference band pass filter and a rather expensive response flattening filter (that one linked to is larger and more expensive than needed), for making a full spectrum PAR meter. As a businessman, I completely understand why he would not answer this question and I would not have answered either if I were in his shoes. There are technical advantages of using the silicon diode instead of the spectral sensor such a faster response time which means a running average can be done to give a smoother response that won't bounce around. The reason the cheap Hydrofarm quantum light meter readings bounce around is because it uses a four channel spectral sensor that uses no averaging. Here's a picture of that spectral sensor. I hooked it up to an oscilloscope and it takes three readings per second (100KHz I2C).

I strongly recommend against cheap quantum light meters like the Hydrofarm meter and Apogee is going to be your best deal for calibrated scientific equipment. Only use full spectrum PAR meters with LED lighting otherwise 660 nm LEDs aren't going to read accurately.

Get something like an Apogee SQ-520 for lab work (this is what I use), get something like an MQ-500 for more field or mobile work.

  • 11 channel spectral sensor I was talking about. This is the future of light meters because spectral sensors can be so versatile. It's literally turning your light meter in to a very low cost spectrometer that can be used for full spectrum PAR, lux, CCT, red/far red ratio, chlorophyll meter etc all in one device.

BTW, "570/531 nm photochemical reflectance index" (PRI) I mentioned is a way to tell if a plant is going in to light saturation by monitoring small changes in xanthophyll. It can be measured with a spectrometer or one can build a PRI camera using a couple of bandpass filters.



IR cameras

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha649b5/

This can mean NDVI cameras or thermal imaging cameras. NDVI can measure chlorophyll levels, thermal imaging can give ideas about transpiration rates. I use thermal imaging myself.

Thermal imaging picture of cannabis leaves:



DLI (daily light integral)

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha65vuf/

That answer is for top light, and a total plant DLI can run higher if using side or intracanopy lighting.

  • DLI = ((PPFD/100) * 8.6) * (% hours light on time per 24 hours)



Far red light

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha66kq3/

Far red triggers the shade avoidance responses which increases acid growth (plant cells get larger). When Bugbee talks about greater light capture he means that leaves can be made larger than normal with far red light. Very high amounts of far red light could cause foxtailing in buds in some cases.

Green light also triggers the shade avoidance responses.

Far red can cause excess stem elongation which is why he mentions he uses it during veging and not flowering. Far red may also increase photosynthesis efficiency through the Emerson effect.



UV light

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha6jc88/

TL;DR- UV to increase THC is an urban legend. To note, the only UV light sensitive protein known is the UVR8 protein which is UVB sensitive, not UVA sensitive. Keep that in mind.

There are studies from the 1980's that may show increase in THC from UV but those strains back then had lower THC levels in the first place compared to modern strains.

This is another answer from Bugbee that amuses me because I've been saying for a long time that the UV light question has not been demonstrated to increase THC. Perhaps there's a study out there I'm missing.



Green light

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha6ia29/

I would be willing to bet that he meant cryptochrome and not phytochrome. I'm happy he mentioned Terashima et al and green photons (I think he got the dates confused because it's 2009 that the green photons work was published, not 2005).

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha63xm5/



Photoperiod

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha67xd9/

TL;RD- shorter photoperiods do not accelerate flowering, longer photoperiods may increase yield



QWERTY or DVORAK

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha64cwk/

IMO, DVORAK is basically like kicking a puppy, and that is wrong. You're not a filthy puppy kicker, are you?



Don't ask way too many questions at once!

https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/paoigz/im_dr_bruce_bugbee_professor_of_crop_physiology/ha635by/

Don't do this and you should post the questions separately in blocks of two or three. A person doing an AMA will typically not spend too much time with a single person, and most of the questions will be ignored.




r/HandsOnComplexity • • Sep 17 '13

LED and LED GROW LIGHTS PART 3: Color and White LEDs

40 Upvotes

LEDs and LED Grow Lights Part 3 lighting guide: color and white LEDs

Why not green LEDs? Come on SAG, your always dropping that green is better than white drives photosynthesis link (front page, lighting guide). Well, I typically use that to make a point that HPS light, which is high in green and yellow/orange, is a very efficient grow light and to refute a lot of claims about green light and photosynthesis found in many biology/botany text books and put out by LED grow lights distributors.

Why not use green LEDs then.....? Their electrically inefficient compared to blue and red LEDs is very low. BAM! That's it. White LEDs, which are just blue LEDs with a phosphor, can put out more green than green LEDs per watt in some cases. It's sometimes known as the ā€œgreen valleyā€ in LED semiconductor physics and here's a good intro Tech Review article on green LEDs.

The only reason why I use green LEDs is for plant and plant lighting R&D. Although I do use high power red/green/blue LEDs, it's typically a blue LED with a green phosphor as shown in the first pic. The yellow looking LEDs are actually warm white 3000K LEDs. I'll sometimes use warm white LEDs with a yellow filter to make a broad band minus blue plant light source. No blue light on the leaves, blue light on the stems of sweet basil is the key to making them four times larger than normal. No blue light what so every with sweet basil and you have a plant that will not grow. Damned if I know why. Some sort of blue light sensitive protein cascade effect. I also tend not to build over 100 watt LED lights. Things scale up and smaller light engines can be built in an hour or two at a very low cost.

So what is the best ratio of colored LED? Don't know. Gotta experiment. Different plants, different results. 1 red :1white is a good place to start to keep it simple. Photosynthesis can be roughly measured using the lighting levels at the leaf and then measuring the chlorophyll florescence on the front and back of the leaf (and knowing the leaf thickness) then you can get charts like this and this using LEDs and cheap lasers as my light source and try to interpret the results.

What I can tell you is that from a photosynthesis stand point there is not much difference between 630 and 660nm, for example. These solvent/chlorophyll charts for chlorophyll you see on Wikipedia don't have much meaning. 680nm. That's peak absorption wavelength of most green leaves. You need a spectrometer and a chlorotic leaf to really see it. On the other hand, why use a wavelength that will quickly become absorbed in the first few layers of chloroplasts (which contain the chlorophyll).

So, what's up with white LEDs? They're simply blue LEDs with a phosphor like found in fluorescent lighting like CFLs, induction lights, T8s and the like. But white LEDs excite the phosphor with blue photosynthetic active radiation (top chart in the link is for dissolved pigments, the second one is for green algae. Green land plants is not shown) rather than not photosynthetically useful ultraviolet radiation. It's called PAR.

Here's why the above is a big deal- white LEDs are basically 100% PAR including the blue light (radiation) that excites the phosphor. Fluorescent lighting must use more energetic photons which also excite the phosphor but here's the big sticking point: the energy difference between mercury vapor ultraviolet photon the photon the phosphor releases as PAR is wasted as heat. The greater the difference in wavelength between the two photons, or the Stokes shift, the more inefficient the lighting source becomes.

Here's an example. Mercury vapor in fluorescent lighting generates an ultraviolet photon of 254nm or an energy of 4.88 electron volts (1240 / photon wavelength = electron volts of energy). We'll call middle PAR 555nm or 2.23 electron volts. We just lost 2.65 electron volts of energy. We're now at 46% maximum theoretical efficiency due to the Stokes shift alone. It just goes down from there when the quantum efficiency of the phosphor which requires a triple phosphor instead of a single phosphor found in most white LEDs.

There are red LEDs that you can buy at the time of this writing that are +40% electrically efficient (electrical energy in, number of photons out), blues that are +50% efficient and whites that put out 140 lumens per watt, up to 200 at reduced power levels. No traditional fluorescent technology, including induction lights, come near these numbers.

Well great, lets put lots of blues in there since it's most efficient. No, a blue 450nm photon has an energy of 2.76 electron volts while a red 650nm photon 1.91 electron volts. It takes less energy to generate a red photon so while blue is more electrically efficient, red is more energy efficient.

Also, there's 2 photo systems a photosynthetic reaction center, PS1 ans PSII. It's part of the very important Z scheme. They require 2 photons to complete, one 680nm and one 700nm or an average of about 1.78 electron volts of energy. That red 650nm photon lost 0.18 electron volts due to heat from this mismatch and the blue LED 0.98. Wasted heat. Plant thermodynamics.

Remember, with LEDs, it's the current level that mainly determines how many photons are generated. With a ā€œ12 voltā€ power supply I can use 3 blue/white LEDs or 5 reds in series. LEDs in series always have the same current levels so there's 2 extra LEDs at the same total power levels. We pay for the price of a blue photon by having to use LEDs with a higher voltage drop. Around 3.4 volts or so. A red LED perhaps 2.2 volts.

Part 4 on choosing LEDs and LED grow lights will be from some posts over the last few months. Then we'll get our hands dirty and build our own LED grow lights.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Jul 08 '21

Theory and tips on white LEDs and grow lights

39 Upvotes

Theory and tips on white LEDs and grow lights

last update: 8 July 2021

I wanted to try writing stuff a bit different so I used bullet points with short and direct statements. There's a bit of theory below but actual white light theory would require its own article due to the 40,000 character limit in a post.



Good paper and the basic definitions

  • From physics to fixtures to food: current and potential LED efficacy -Must read. When I write "above paper" with a page number, this is it. Note that this paper covers a lot of 2020 LED efficiency numbers while also discussing maximum theoretical efficacy in this paper, and it can be easy to confuse the two.

  • PAR -"photosynthetic active radiation" or light from 400-700 nm by standardized definition. PAR is what we measure, and not a unit of measurement. Saying "300 PAR" would be like saying "300 water".

  • PPFD- "photosynthetic photon flux density" or light intensity at the point of measurement. The unit is umol/m2/sec (µmol m-2 s-1) or "micromoles per square meter per second". The close white light analogy is lux.

  • PPF- "photosynthetic photon flux" or the total amount of 400-700 nm photons per second given off by an LED/grow light. The unit is umol/sec (µmol s-1) or "micromoles per second". The close white light analogy is lumens (e.g a 100 watt incandescent bulb (true or equivalent) puts out about 1600 lumens of light).

  • PPE- "photosynthetic photon efficacy" or the amount of photons produced by a light source per amount of energy input. The unit is umol/joule (µmol j-1) or "micromoles per joule". The somewhat close(ish) white light analogy is LPW (lumens per watt). You will sometimes see PPE written as PPF/W.

  • Efficiency is the ratio of useful work (e.g an LED is 50% efficient if half the consumed energy is radiated away as the light). Efficacy, as how I'm using it, is how well something works (e.g that white 50% efficient LED at CRI 80 has a luminous efficacy of around 160 lumens per watt, give or take a bit).



The ultimate efficacy limits of fixtures

"The upper limit of LED fixture efficacy is determined by the LED package efficacy multiplied by four factors inherent to all fixtures: current droop, thermal droop, driver (power supply) inefficiencies, and optical losses" -above paper, page 1

  • To maximize an LED grow light's idealized efficacy, we want the LED current as low as possible (throw more LEDs at the problem as they become cheaper and underdrive them), keep them as cool as possible (a little airflow goes a long ways, maybe 2-10 times so), get the most efficient driver (you want to look up the efficiency by current level curves in the data sheet), and don't use lenses or a glass cover. But, by not using a cover means we lose ingress protection leaving exposed voltages so there are potential safety concerns, and exposing the LEDs directly to the environment can potentially lower their longevity and the grow light's longer term reliability.

  • Current droop -The greater the current though an LED, the less efficient it becomes. This is one reason why medium power LEDs in large series/parallel arrays (e.g quantum boardsĀ® ) have become common at least in the hobby community, and how COBs work by having a large series/parallel array of LEDs in a smaller common package. LED makers typical rate their LED at a "nominal" or "sorting" current that may be significantly lower than what the LED is actually being driven at in real life. The Samsung LM301H has their specs listed for 65 mA, but is rated for 200 mA continuous, for example.

  • Thermal droop -The higher the temperature of the LED, the less efficient it becomes. LED data sheets typically give bin numbers for 25 degrees C (77 F) or 85 C (185 F), and most LEDs are specified to operate at 85-125 C. Higher temperatures also means that the LED degrades more quickly, particularly red LEDs. The difference between 25 C and 85 C is about a 5% efficiency loss for most LEDs. Some 125 C continuous rated red LEDs can take a >20% efficiency hit at 125 C. Higher temperatures will also degrade LEDs faster, and cheap light bulbs are going to run their cheap LEDs very hot. Don't buy the cheapest light bulbs if you want them to last- you get what you pay for.

  • Driver (power supply) inefficiencies -Some low voltage DC drivers can hit about 98% efficiency depending on drive current. There are AC LED drivers on the market that can peak at 97% efficiency. Some Mean Well LED drivers can hit the mid 90s% efficient. Most of the AC LED drivers you find in products are going to be in the low 90s or upper 80's percent efficient, which can depend on specific LED current levels. Drivers with a lower power factor also contribute to greater inefficiencies. Cheap capacitors in cheap lights (particularly cheap light bulbs) is a major failure mode particularly with poor thermal management.

  • Optical losses -Using secondary optics (i.e a lens) over an LED can focus the light so an LED grow light maker can post some impressive PPFD (intensity) numbers right below the light, but the PPF number (total light output) is going to drop, too. There will always be optical losses with a lens of perhaps 7-9%. This same loss applies to grow lights that have a glass/plastic/silicon cover over the LEDs for splash proofing the light. If you grow hydroponically, and a prone to splashing hydro nute solution around, it may be worth it to take this inefficiency hit to keep the salt solution away from the electronics. Electrical safety is another very important reason glass covers are used for the ingress protection they provide.

Keep in mind on LED grow light specs, some low end sellers may give specs (e.g PPF umol/sec numbers) for data sheet temperature and current ideal efficacy (i.e 25 C, lower nominal current), or may not take in to account LED driver losses when posting a umol/joule number, and not how the light actually performs in real world grow conditions. If low end Amazon/eBay style lights are giving specs better than high end lights, then don't don't do business with that seller.



Some basic facts on LEDs, light, and lights

  • The "K" in "color temperature" stands for "degrees Kelvin", not to mean "thousand". For example, it's a 2700K light, not a 2.7K light which is deep outer space cold. It's also a correlated color temperature (CCT), and not an actual approximate black body radiator color temperature like with a 2700-2800K incandescent light bulb.

  • I define "white" as any light source whose spectral output is on or fairly close to the plankian locus in the CIE 1931 color space chromaticity diagram within a certain color temperature range (2700k-6500K or so). There are many types of white light (i.e different CCT, CRI, TM-30-15 Rf, spectral power distributions), and many ways to create white, so my definition is a bit vague. Bridgelux has 1750K LEDs they call white, for example, but I certainly don't perceive them as white.

  • White LEDs (blue LEDs with a phosphor(s) for this discussion) are mass produced very well beyond any other LED lighting, which can make them cheaper through scale of economy, particularly the surface mount medium power LEDs like by Samsung. The amount of R&D into LED technology has resulted in some white LEDs having a PPE of greater than 3 uMol/joule at nominal (lower) current levels and at room temperature. They will max out at about 3.3-3.4ish uMol/joule depending on CCT and CRI, maybe slightly higher if underdriven.

  • A 450 nm blue LED will likely have a maximum practical PPE of about 3.5-3.6 umol/joule, with a maximum theoretical PPE of 3.76 umol/joule. The 3.76 umol/joule number is the ultimate barrier to white LEDs based off a 450 nm blue LED with a phosphor, and the only current way to get a higher PPE for grow lights is to add actual red LEDs to white LEDs, or if appropriate for your plant, use red and blue LEDs only (perhaps with some white thrown in).

  • There are white LEDs that use the phosphor pump from violet or ultraviolet-A LEDs. Our visibility extends down to about 400 nm, not 450 nm. They use additional broader blue phosphors instead of blue LEDs. But, violet and UV-A LEDs can never have the efficacy of blue LEDs because they have more energy in their photons. We generally wouldn't want to use these types of LEDs in grow light. Seoul Semiconductor Sunlike LEDs use violet LEDs.

  • In most cases it's one photon per photochemical reaction also known as the second law of photochemistry. This applies to photosynthesis and to phosphors. You can have multiple down conversions with phosphors and not break the second law (i.e in a white LED, a photon can be absorbed and emitted multiple times always at lower energy levels), but this does not happen with photosynthesis. This means for photosynthesis that a blue photon does not drive photosynthesis better because blue photons have more energy than green and red photons, and the extra energy in the blue photons is wasted as heat in the photosynthesis process.

  • 2700K has about 10% blue light, 4200K has about 20% blue light, 6500K has about 30% blue light. The greater the blue light content, the more compact the plant will be by reducing acid growth due to lower auxin levels. This is why people will say to use a higher color temperature in veging to suppress growth like stretching, and use lower color temperature in flowering to promote acid growth in flowering. Most higher end white LED grow lights are 3000K to 4000K.

  • Higher color temperature white LEDs will have a higher electrical efficiency, all else being equal, because less blue light is being captured by the phosphors, and the blue light emitted by the LED does not take a phosphor conversion loss hit. The total phosphor conversion loss for a white LED can be 5-20% (page 3, above paper). Because there is a higher conversion loss with lower color temperature LEDs, they will run a bit hotter than higher color temperature LEDs. Lower color temperature (and higher CRI) LEDs will also have greater total Stokes shift heating (the energy difference between the blue photon emitted from the blue LED and the other down converted photon from the phosphor is wasted as heat).

  • Some modern white LEDs may use five or more different phosphors or phosphors with multiple peaks, and I didn't really realize this until doing 1st and 2nd order derivative spectroscopic analysis on a dozen different types of Bridgelux white LEDs. The results can be seen here.. Early white LEDs were using a single yellow phosphor with blue LEDs and some still do.

  • A "perfect" white light source would be right around 4.6 uMol/joule (it can vary a bit depending on the type of white). If you had a hypothetical 100% efficient array of color LEDs and a 100% LED driver to make white light, then you'll be around 4.6 uMol/joule, give or take a little. This is a theoretical limitation for white light no matter the white light source.

  • Mixing warm white and cool white LEDs in a grow light makes no sense, and I consider it a marketing gimmick at best. An exception is if you want a variable color temperature grow light, then it makes sense to to mix warm white and cool white dimmable separately, or use dimmable warm white and blue LEDs to control the color temperature. I go with 3000K or 3500K for all around use for plant growing, but experiment with various 1750K to 6500K COBs, also (1750K is about what candle light is).

  • I consider mixing red LEDs like 630 nm and 660 nm, or 450 nm and 470 nm, to also be a marketing gimmick, unless a clear demonstration as to their combined efficacy can be demonstrated in controlled grows (temp, humidity, CO2, and lighting levels consistent and does not significantly fluctuate to remove as many variables as possible). My first non-controlled experiments were in 2008 where I found no significant difference in 450-660, 450-630, 450-630-660 nm, and white light for a leafy lettuce cultivar. I soldered up a few thousand low power 5 mm LEDs to do these early experiments.

  • There is nothing special about 6500K light for plants that may be used in veging and don't normally use it. Higher color temperature light usually have a higher luminous efficacy, and 6500K is about the highest color temperature that is tolerated for the consumer before appearing too blue. It's more often found in work spaces. 6500K is also the color temperature of the standard illuminate D65 used in photometry. 6500K has very little to do with professional grow lighting, and traditional (non-ceramic) metal halide is 4200K.

  • There is nothing special about 2700K light for plants that may be used for flowering. It's about what incandescent bulbs roughly are and is close to the color temperature for the illuminate standard A used in photometry. You typically want to use this color temperature range or a bit higher for living spaces. Traditional HPS is 2100K.

  • Although we tend to use higher color temperature white light for veging and a lower color temperature for flowering, I've gotten great veg growth with 2100K HPS for cannabis when LST (low stress training) techniques and higher lighting levels were used (500 umol/m2/sec). I've found greater growth at higher lighting levels but at lower color temperatures with various microgreens testing 2000K, 3000K, and 5000K light. If longer stems is what want (and what you get with lower lighting levels), but still want aggressive growth with larger leaves, play around with 2000K white LEDs at higher lighting levels for microgreens.

  • CRI (color rendering index) tells us how well a light source does at accurately reproducing colors in an object relative to a natural or black body radiation source (e.g sun, incandescent bulb). It really falls flat, though, and a different standard has come out called TM-30. TM-30 doesn't actually replace CRI because they are standards from two different organizations, the CIE (International Commission on Illumination) for CRI, and ANSI/IES (American National Standards Institute/Illuminating Engineering Society) for TM-30.

  • A major problem with CRI Ra is that it only measures eight pastel, non-saturated samples in their measurement. Not included are R9 (saturated red), R10 (saturated yellow), R11 (saturated green), R12 (saturated blue), R13 (white skin tone), R14 (leaf green), and sometimes R15 (south east Asian skin tone), which had to be added over time. Most CRI 80 lights have as R9 (red) value of 0, and CRI 90 lights are an R9 value of around 50. This is why you want to use high CRI lighting around food and for photography- CRI 80 is going to give you bland looking reds because of lower red chroma (saturation).

  • CRI plays a larger role in lux to PPFD (umol/m2/sec) conversions than color temperature. Higher CRI lighting will have a greater amount of deeper reds, and deeper reds naturally have a lower luminous flux at the same radiant flux because luminous flux takes into account the sensitivity of our eyes by wavelength. In other words, the deeper reds have a lower luminous efficiency. You can see the differences in my spectroradiometer SPD charts here.

  • You should consider using higher CRI lighting with plants that are also being used for display purposes (like orchids), particularly with plants that have red or purple colors. You should also be using high CRI lighting in your kitchen and dining room or wherever food is served, particularly for red colors like a medium rare steak. You can buy CRI +90 LED light bulbs and a quick google search shows a seller with CRI +95 (Cri 98 in their photometric data sheet).

  • 100% efficient white LEDs would be fairly close to 260 lumens per watt for CRI 100, 280 lumens per watt for CRI 95, 300 lumens per watt for CRI 90, and about 320 lumens per watt for CRI 80. This can vary a bit by up to 10%.

  • Red, green, and blue LEDs to make white light looks awful for general lighting because the CRI is around 40ish. The "rendering" part in CRI is about reflected light, and a RBG white light has relatively narrow spectral power distribution rather than a broader distribution, and the accurate colors of an object won't happen.

  • What I said about objects having colors above is a lie. Objects don't have colors, light has colors and objects have specific absorption and reflection characteristics. Even that's a partial lie because color is a perception only, and we do not all perceive colors the same (e.g red-green color blind). "Color" is so much about our perception, the specific light, the specific subject, camera sensor characteristics, and different display characteristics which is why there are a multitude of different professional color standards.

  • Fidelity Index (Rf) is used with TM-30 measurements and is sort of like CRI (0-100 scale with higher being better, but CRI can also have a negative number), but there's 99 color evaluation samples with a wide range of hue (base color), chroma (amount of saturation), and lightness. It is the average amount of "color smearing" in the 99 color samples, or the average of how far off one is from the color samples. That ultra high CRI bulb above has a TM-30-15 Rf of 94, and around 60 should be the minimum for indoor lighting (higher for living areas). A US Dept of Energy TM-30 tutorial can be found here.

  • Gamut Index (Gf) with TM-30 ranges from 80-120 and is basically the amount of saturation with 100 being a neutral saturation. It is the color gamut area. Lower Gf white lights will make objects appear duller with higher Gf having colors more saturated.

  • You can have a light with the same CCT, CRI, Rf, and still be different because the simpler numbers don't tell us the spectral power distribution. There's a good reason for high end studio photographers to keep gelling their lights as needed (professional videographers have their own standards on white coming out that takes into account the sensors in their cameras).

  • Green LEDs are relatively electrically inefficient which is why they are not commonly used in grow lights. In physics/engineering this is known as the green gap (graph). We do, however, perceive green light much higher than red or blue light, so for display purposes this inefficiency matters less.

  • Red photons have a lower energy with a higher theoretical PPE of about 5.51 uMol/joule (660 nm) compared to blue of 3.76 uMol/joule (450 nm). The higher efficacy is one reason why red LEDs are being added to white LEDs, what's held them back a bit is their electrical efficiency (red and blue LEDs use different semiconductor material).

  • A red 660 nm LED that is 50% efficient would have a PPE of 2.76 umol/joule. A blue 450 nm LED that is 50% efficient would have a PPE of 1.88 umol/joule. A 450 nm blue LED can never be higher than 100% for 3.76 umol/joule, which is 68% efficient for a 660 nm red LED.

  • Red LEDs have now broken the 4 umol/joule barrier in 2020 such as the Oslon Square Hyper Red by Osram (V9 bin 4.42 umol/joule at 350 mA for 80% efficient, and 4.04 umol/joule at 700 mA for 73% efficient). Currently, most red LEDs are significantly less.

  • Osram is taking an interesting approach by having 4000K white horticulture LEDs that contain 15% less red than CRI 70 LEDs. This LED is then combined with their very efficient >4 umol/joule red LEDs.

  • In some cases far red LEDs could be added depending on your design goals. For instance, far red could potentially help drive photosynthesis more efficiently as per the Emerson effect, but also tends to cause more acid growth (stretching in stems and petioles, larger leaves), which we may or may not want. Far red can also be used to control the photoperiod in some plants. High amounts of far red may encourage "foxtailing" in cannabis, and your specific cultivar would have to be tested.

  • Adding UV LEDs are typically only used for light sensitive protein reactions effects, not as photosynthesis drivers per se. The pure UV-A grows I've done did result in slow grow and stunted plants. If I wanted to keep a tiny, important plant alive for a long duration I would be using pure UV-A. But, the effects of UV-A on a plant can be unpredictable and needs to be tested by cultivar. The theoretical maximum PPE of a 375 nm UV-A LED is 3.13 umol/joule, and the relative low photosynthesis rate is going to make them a no-go in LED lighting except for photomorphogenesis effects. Making red lettuce cultivars more red by increasing anthocyanin production, or trying to increase trichome and cannabinoid production in cannabis plants, may be reasons to use UV light.

  • UV-A light is fairly safe (it can be dangerous when you stick your eye close to a light source that appears dim yet has a high radiant flux) and at the time of this writing, only UV-A LEDs are used in LED grow lights if UV light is used. The UV-B light sources I've seen in grow lights are still tube based because UV-B LEDs are still inefficient (5-10% range). UV-C should be considered dangerous, and in testing I have damaged a number of plants with higher amounts of UV-C.

  • The main UV light sensitive protein known about currently is the UVR8 protein which is a 280-315 nm UV-B receptor, not a UV-A receptor.

  • Apogee Instruments (Bruce Bugbee's company) have come out with a SQ-610 USB sensor for "ePAR" (enhanced photosynthetic active radiation) which counts light out to 750 nm far red, and also some UV-A at decreased sensitivity. With a long pass filter it may be possible to turn this into a red/far red light meter. They also have a new SQ-640 Quantum Light Pollution USB sensor that measures from 340-1040 nm. With the right filters, this sensor could have a lot of applications beyond light pollution measurements.

  • "Hot swapping" LEDs is generally a bad practice with constant current or constant power supplies. This is where you change out an LED with the power supply still on. By lifting the load, a much higher voltage may be found in constant current power supplies. When the LED is applied, it's possible to get a very quick and short high current pulse causing damage which is accumulative. There are LED drivers where you can dial in both the maximum current and maximum voltage to make hot swapping safer. I've blown LEDs on lab power supplies because of of hot swapping and being careless.

  • A silver mirror is fundamentally different than white although they can have the same reflectivity. The the main difference is that the mirror has a specular reflection where the phase information of the photons is preserved if the mirror surface is very smooth, and white has a diffuse reflection with photons being scattered. A mirror, being made out of a conductor, has a bunch of free electrons. These free electrons can oscillate when the photon strikes them, and this oscillation itself creates another photon i.e an opposing oscillating electric field is created that cancels out the original electromagnetic wave. Because these free electrons are not bound and have no discrete energy states, they have a broad range of energy levels they can oscillate at and a broad range of wavelengths of light that they'll reflect. This electric field interference also prevents photons from penetrating more than a few nanometers into the mirror's surface. I'm greatly simplifying all of this.

  • If you have issues with cheap LED light bulbs burning out then stop buying such cheap light bulbs. Like most everything in life, you get what you pay for, and buy cheap buy twice.



Heat sink tips

  • Only the energy input not radiated as light needs to be taken in to account for LED heat sink calculations. This is called thermal wattage. For example, a 100 watt COB that is 50% efficient would need a heat sink good for 50 watts of heat. A 100 watt COB that is 80% efficient would need a heat sink good for 20 watts of heat.

  • A heat sink has a thermal rating or heat dissipation in units of °C/W, or the rise of the heat sink in degrees C per watt of heat on the heat sink. If I have a 100 watt COB that is 50% efficient (so 50 watts of heat) and want the heat sink to rise no more than 10 degrees C, I would need a heat sink with a heat dissipation of 0.2 °C/W. If I use a fan it may be 0.4 to 2 °C/W, depending on how much air the fan pushes and the particular heat sink geometry.

  • I often size heat sinks that prevent the LEDs from going above 85-125 C for safety, and then use a quite fan to keep them at a temperature I want them to be. This provides an inherent fail-safe feature when experimenting.

  • Rule of thumb I use: I try not to go above 125 degrees F (52 C), or where I can keep my finger on the heat sink for 4 seconds. My personal do not go over temperature is 145 degrees F (63 C), or where I can keep my finger on the heat sink for an honest one second. I've had second degree burns from electronics more than once.

  • Temperature measuring tip: When working with a heat sink and a constant current power supply, you can monitor the voltage on the LEDs to see very tiny temperature variations that might not normally be measured with a temperature probe. With a constant voltage power supply, you can monitor the current to see very tiny temperature variations. This is because the I/V curves for LEDs are temperature dependent, and strings of LEDs make very high resolution temperature sensors. I use a 50,000 count data logging Fluke 287 for this purpose (I recommend a 6000 count multimeter for lower cost DIY. Every low cost meter I've ever tested reads within their listed specs when referenced to my Fluke 287, except for the occasional generic $5 meter that companies like Harbor Freight give away for free).

  • 6063 aluminum alloy is the alloy with the highest thermal conductivity (around 210 W/mā‹…K), and most common in heat sinks. The trade off is that 6063 is a softer alloy so common 6061 alloy (around 167 W/mā‹…K) may be used instead in some cases. I've seen sellers advertise about using "aircraft grade aluminum" like 7075 alloy for metal core PCBs for LEDs, which is inferior for our uses (around 140 W/mā‹…K). For comparison, copper is closer to 400 W/mā‹…K, and steel is closer to 45 W/mā‹…K.

  • For a Vero 29 running at 120 watts I use a generic $30 CPU cooler with a fan and call it good. I've seen coolers half that price that should also work.

  • I can run a Bridgelux gen 7 Vero 29 at 50 watts on the COB on a 40 mm heat sink with a 40 mm fan mounted about 1 cm above the heat sink to improve airflow. To be clear, I'm saying I "can" do this, and not I "should" do this! In these sort of experimental setups I'll use a bimetalic normally closed thermal cutout switch on the heat sink that trips at 70 C (158 F). I don't recommend beginners push DIY setups this hard.

  • It is critically important that a thermal compound paste or thermal adhesive is used between the LED and the heat sink. You only want a thin layer, and I always twist the LED around a bit to get rid of air bubbles and get better overall thermal contact. If it's a heat sink/LED I'll never reuse then I'll use a thermal adhesive and just glue the LED down. Thermal pads can work at lower power levels but won't work as well as a compound/adhesive.

  • When making mounting holes in a heat sink you can use a stainless steel screw as a tap. Drill a whole just smaller than the diameter of the screw, force the screw in to the much softer aluminum cutting the threads in the process (I use a ratcheting screwdriver for this), back the screw out, take a fine file and smooth out the burs completely, and you have a drilled and tapped mounting hole.



Power supply tips

  • Get a Mean Well LED driver for DIY. The XLG are constant power and one work quite well with a Vero 18 or a Vero 29. A Vero 18 or 29 can be quickly interchanged at the same power level so you can rapidly measure the differences between the two if needed.

  • I often use lab power supplies as LED drivers. If you only get one lab power supply make sure it's a linear power supply and not a noisy switching power supply. Lower cost linear power supplies typically have a fan that will turn on at certain current levels while more expensive and much heavier ones are entirely passive cooled.

  • Power supplies have historically been the weak link in an LED grow light system and cheap capacitors are the main issue.

  • The cheap boost converters you can buy on Amazon and eBay will work, but don't expect more than about 6 months use out of them. Again, it's the capacitors that tend to fail.



MacAdam ellipses and steps

The MacAdam ellipses, or SDCM (standard deviation of color matching), as used here are standard deviations of perceived color differences in LED binning including white LEDs. The higher the step or standard deviation, the lower the binning tolerances which lowers LED costs. Sylvania has a good, simple write up on this concept with a convenient graph below.

  • MacAdam Ellipses: What are MacAdam Ellipses or color ovals?

  • To make it simple and practical, only in a 1-step MacAdam ellipse for white LEDs are any variations in the white light unperceived to most all people with a trained person. In a 2-step MacAdam ellipse variations may just be perceivable to a trained eye, and in a 3-step MacAdam ellipse variations may be just perceivable to an untrained eye. Common quality white LED lighting for residential use tend to be two or three step, but can be 4-step and still be withing ANSI (American National Standards Institute) tolerances, which was causing issues in the past (a relative of mine is a commercial/industrial electrical contractor, and didn't understand why not all the thousand plus LED bulbs installed appeared the same. He didn't understand how white LED binning worked at the time).

  • With LED grow lights we don't really care about minor variations in light, and the Samsung LM301H (horticulture) series of medium power LEDs use a 5-step MacAdam ellipse binning, while the LM301B (general illumination) uses a 3-step MacAdam ellipse binning. In other words, the LM301H has a lot more binning slop that is basically irrelevant to plant growth, but could be relevant for general illumination. The highest MacAdam step number used with LEDs is seven.

Don't worry if you can perceive slight color differences in the LEDs of LED grow lights! Your plants don't care.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Apr 22 '13

LED and LED Grow Lights Part One: Heat

39 Upvotes

LED and LED GROW LIGHTS PART 1

This is going in the Lighting Guide as part of a LED and LED grow light series and will be 5-6000 words long when complete. First I give some theoretical back ground then I'll show how to build LED grow lights including explaining powering them then a bunch of measurements. If you have a question or want clarification then ask below: I'll answer, find an answer or say I don't know. If you have a question pertaining to your specific set up or a light that you want to build, PM me instead and I'll help you.

It will help greatly if you read the Lighting Guide first. Point out mistakes! I can also go back and make edits. Mistakes means I've learned something and I enjoy learning.

I want to start off by explaining the difference between natural scientific law and theory. A scientific law is an observation while theory gives the how and why. Johann Kepler, for example, was able to give his 3 Laws of Planetary Motion without understanding any theory of gravity. It wasn't until Einstein did his work on relativity that macro scale gravity was understood

(BTW, as a historical note, Einstein never received a Nobel Prize for his work on gravity and relativity, he got one for explaining the photoelectric effect. He was a mathematical prodigy who pissed off so many people that he couldn't get an academic position which is why he ended up working as a patent examiner after he was a PhD in physics.)

I mention the above because of the Laws of Thermodynamics. They pertain to LED grow lights like every thing else.

Moore's Law is NOT a natural scientific law! I've had people try to use that example to try to refute the Laws of Thermodynamics. If you're making statements contrary to the Laws of Thermodynamics then you're a crackpot (I never understood free energy types. I'll quickly delete any free energy non-sense). There is a form of energy transfer besides the one's listed below used in photosynthesis that will be covered in another mini article.

There are 3 ways that a LED/LED grow light has energy removed, heat being the lowest form of energy. Since photosynthesis is fairly inefficient, most all the energy input in to a grow chamber, for example, is converted to heat.


Radiation: this is mostly optical energy put out by the LED itself if the fixture does not also use convection (fans). Electrical efficiency plays a big role here. At the time of this writing there are Philips LEDs that are 40% efficient for red and just over 50% for blue. These are top bin LEDs and are still rather expensive. Green/yellow/amber LEDs are much less efficient since they don't need to be as efficient. Most colored LEDs are not used in grow lights but rather ā€œDisney Landā€ style display lighting. Our eyes are more sensitive to these wavelengths which is why they don't need to be as efficient (there is some speculation on my part here).

The most efficient amber LED that I know of is the Philips amber PC LED which is a blue LED with an amber phosphor. This is a bit of a catch-22 since green is actually more efficient at driving photosynthesis at the higher lighting levels we use (front page Lighting Guide). .

There is also black body radiation where heat is radiated away from the fixture or from the LED (LEDs can get quite hot). Darker objects will have a higher emissivity and will be more efficient in removing heat than shiny objects. The emissivity of most leaves are 0.95 so they are good at both absorbing and removing heat. Plain aluminum has a very low emissivity so while aluminum is very good at conducting heat, it's poor at radiating heat. Painting or galvanizing an aluminum heat sink black makes them significantly better at radiating heat. Black tends to be slightly higher

An 8 watt LED module on some aluminum ran 20 degrees above ambient unpainted but 12 degrees painted black. If you want something to run cooler that is shiny, try painting it black. I'll do the same with other LED lights. Try using a black spray paint that also advertises itself to work as a primer.

Take an engine of a sports car and chrome it. It might run perhaps 40 degrees F hotter than normal not because the chrome acts as an insulating layer but because the emissivity is being lowered by being shinier. There's a good reason that car radiators are black. Same with most wood stoves being black.

So, in the same way that black/dark can absorb heat better, it can also radiate heat better than shinier objects. Due to the low emissivity of polished or plain aluminum, non-contact thermometers should not be used to measure their temperature since non-contact thermometers will be calibrated for a much higher emissivity. Your measurements will likely be way off.


Conduction: this is heat removed from the LED itself by being thermally bonded to a heat sink. Aluminum, copper and brass are good heat conductors. Steel by comparison, is a relatively poor heat conductor. This is why heat sinks tend to use more expensive aluminum rather than steel.

A liquid can also conduct away heat edit- this is actually a form of convection. A car radiator would be an example. Sometimes when testing LEDs, I'll put them in oil to over power them and see what happens. The oil helps keep them cool. A lot of large electrical transformers are oil filled to conduct heat away from the coils.


Convection: this is heat removed from a LED grow light using airflow or a liquid. It's a very efficient way to remove heat and why people make the mistake that LEDs do not produce as much heat as other lights. There is no way around the laws of thermodynamics- heat is energy input minus work performed. Turn off the fans of a LED grow light and see how hot it gets.

HID lighting like high pressure sodium or metal halides use radiation and convection to remove heat but not conduction although there are water cooled HID lighting kits and 15,000 watt IMAX style arc lamps are also water cooled. Since the heat is not being removed as efficiently the bulb itself will be much hotter. Directly blasting a HPS bulb with air can significantly keep a grow tent cooler. This is the same with fluorescent lighting to include induction lighting.

I want to digress and point something out. Smaller induction lights are less electrically efficient than CFL, LEDs and HID lighting and larger induction lights are about as efficient as T5 fluorescent lights. Don't waste your money on induction lights. They only make sense in situations where it would be expensive to change out the bulbs such as street lighting or high bay lighting since the bulbs will last longer (2019 edit- LEDs are now a better option). For grow lights they do not make sense since there are lower cost and more efficient alternatives. Their bulbs have a large surface area so they don't get particularly hot, like T12 fluorescent tubes don't get that hot, but will produce as much total heat as any other light.

Some induction grow light companies, such as Inda-gro, give a bunch of numbers that are complete non-sense as they pertain to grow lights and make claims about their performance which are completely false. I can make such statements without worrying about legal action because the truth is never considered slander (they have also plagiarized my work in the past so I enjoy slamming them). Look up induction lights used for commercial/industrial applications and you'll get the true numbers because there will be lighting engineers that will independently verify their performance. Most growers do not use light meters or test their lights.


A quick note on heat sinks

Heat sinks for LEDs only need to remove the heat energy from the energy input to the LED that is not radiated away as light. For example, a 100 watt LED that is 50% efficient only needs to be rated for 50 watts, not 100 watts.

link to part 2


r/HandsOnComplexity • • May 10 '21

Directed energy weapons links

38 Upvotes

Directed energy weapons links

main links page

SAG's plant lighting guide


high power microwave


vircator


marx generator


flux compression generator


pulse power


nanosecond pulsers


electromagnetic pulses


laser weapons


railgun and coilgun


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Aug 17 '19

line voltage COBs and electrical safety

35 Upvotes

Part of SAG's lighting guide.

The best 3 minute video on electrical safety on the Internet.


Why I'm writing this

This is written in response to people using or wanting to make DIY line voltage AC driverless COB "suicide lights", and a discussion on electrical safety in general.

This is also a very strong critique of a few people not taking line voltage electrical safety seriously. I've seen naive people telling others that line voltage is not dangerous and people like this should be condemned. I've also seen "experts" who are not. People saying they don't touch their dangerous lights when they are plugged in (sigh...). People who use a faulty appeal to authority are a particular danger and an example will be articulated below.

It only takes a single mistake to have a life altering injury from line voltage.


The problem

People have posted about their line voltage COB lights before on /r/SpaceBuckets and literally wondered why their heat sink is being energized. I don't know but it only takes a single strand of loose wire to energize a conductor like a heat sink or there could be some some sort of internal fault in the COB packaging with your heat sink that has no grounding. These line voltage COBs are being made as cheaply as possible and you can expect corners to be cut. They are electrically inefficient compared to name brand COBs and tend to have a shorter life span.

Even in my testing of a commercial line voltage COB light I found that they can be unsafe. Why in this case? Because the manufacturer snipped off the grounding wire. The son of a bitch was so cheap that they would not spend ten cents to actually do a proper ground bond in a light fixture with a metal housing. And this was a light being advertised for outdoor use and advertised as water proof. Electricians just looooove metal fixtures that have no grounding. /s in case it was not obvious and an electrician starts swinging a pipe bender around.

Just because you can find it on Amazon does not mean that the electrical device is safe. In US/Canada at least Walmart, Home Depot and the like will only sell stuff that is UL/ETL/CSA listed for safety because they understand lawsuits from selling dangerous devices. Good luck trying to bring legal action against a Chinese importer for an injury or death. CE is not recognized in North America, only nationally recognized testing labs are. I absolutely do not trust a CE mark and below you will see why.

Just because it is sold on Amazon does not mean it's safe. It is quite likely that a COB light from Walmart and the like are safely grounded and should be safe as long as they are not modified.


Cavalier attitudes and electrical safety

To those who say and tell others online that line voltage is not dangerous- would you strip back a line wire and a neutral wire, because ā€œit's not dangerous, lolā€, energize the line wire and hold it in one hand, because ā€œit's not dangerous, lolā€, and with your other hand grab on to the neutral wire? How about grabbing those wires really tight and then get back to me.

Grab on to that energized line wire with your hand wet from hydroponic solution and stand barefoot on a damp basement concrete floor because ā€œit's not dangerous, lolā€.

If you are not willing to do the above then you need to start reflecting on what you are telling people online that line voltage is not dangerous assuming you have a certain level of self-awareness. I know a person who did accidental grab the energized line wire while barefoot on a damp concrete floor with a hydroponic setup. Did it kill her? No, it just dropped her ass and she learned real quick (she also did not have GFCI protection). As an electrician I've got all sorts of these anecdotes. I know a person who became part of a neutral wire in series and ended up with nerve damage from the electrical shock.

But...but...but...I got shocked once and it didn't kill me! (I had a person use this argument once) Well, I've been in a car accident once and it didn't kill me either. It does not mean that car accidents are not dangerous. And it's arrogant to think that your one experience applies to everyone else.

But...but...but...I don't touch the suicide light when it's plugged in! Then you know how dangerous it is and you're a complete fool. You can't fix stupid but others can learn from the stupid person by not doing what they are doing.

But...but...but...in my country! I honestly don't care how things are done in your country and standards are not going to be lowered for everyone else because "that's the way we do things in my country". That is complete non-sense. If I write about electrical safety in my country while proclaiming expert status in the field, which I do to an extent I can claim that status as an industrial electrician, I also assume certain liabilities and will not hesitate to go before a judge if it came down to that. Will the anonymous person telling you that these line voltage COBs are not dangerous be willing to do the same? Talk is cheap and your safety should not be.


Faulty appeal to authority

When people discuss electrical safety in particular it's never a bad idea to do a call out and question what their credentials are. An "engineer" is not a professional electrical expert when they are a software engineer, as an example, and is a faulty appeal to authority when they do not understand the subject matter.

A person on /r/SpaceBuckets was once claiming to be an "engineer", messed up a guide on Ohm's Law including a simple problem example because he did not actually understand the material (the LED has a voltage drop, yo), didn't understand how LEDs work (I run LEDs constant voltage without a resistor all the time on a lab power supply when testing them and they have a specific I-V curve. You also can not model an LED as a resistor. And the actual internal resistance of an LED is so low it's usually not considered in almost all circuits), and stated that he was going to be doing a write up on electrical safety. In the comments section he revealed that he was a software engineer rather than an electrical/electronics engineer. This is misleading rubbish because when you talk about electronics and claim to be an engineer people are assuming a type of engineer.

And the "engineer" said he was going to be writing an electrical safety guide....there is a good reason I won't hesitate to do a call out. Why would a layman who does not know the material write a guide about electrical safety when bad information can get people injured or killed? It's stuff like this where I live up to my user name.

When people discuss electrical safety it's never a bad idea to question their credentials. The sources of my information are coming from electrical engineers along with my training as an electrician and not some anonymous person on the Internet with no established history. I do strongly encourage more professional electrical engineers and electricians to bring up electrical safety when dealing with the layman.


Ohm's Law and how almost everyone is measuring body resistance wrong

An argument I've seen is one can take a multimeter, grab the probes, and measure their hand to hand resistance. Hey, I'm reading 100,000 ohms so I can not have a dangerous level of current flowing through me! But that is not how body resistance actually works at higher voltages or how insulation is tested. For that you do a dielectric withstand test and measure the resistance of the body or insulation under test closer to the voltage where the wires or your body will be at with line voltage or at higher voltages.

Electricians/field engineers/some technicians may use a special tool called a ā€œhigh pot testerā€ or ā€œhigh potential testerā€ where potential means voltage. If you are an electrician you may know them by a trade name of Megger and you may ā€œmeg out the wiresā€. An example of where I did extensive megging was in parking lot lighting with splices directly in water. There was also lots and lots of megging going on when I spent three months rebuilding the Seattle Monorail trains in 1998 as a newer journeyman (that was a surprisingly complex 700 volt DC four speed electromechanical motor control system fused at 10,000 amps).

You need to measure an insulator, like human skin, at a higher voltage to take in to account dielectric breakdown and dielectric breakdown of skin/tissue is a non-linear process as it is with any other insulator. Just because you measure that 100K ohms hand to hand at one volt on your multimeter does not mean it's still going to be at 100K ohms at 230 volts, as an example, because the higher voltage is able to punch through the insulation which is going to change the resistance hand to hand. The amount of time being shocked can also affect dielectric breakdown conditions and the amount of current flow.

Once dielectric breakdown occurs the resistance can be as low as 500 ohms and possibly lower. At 200 volts, for example, you just went from 2 mA which is a very mild shock to perhaps >400 mA which is deadly if the current path goes through the heart. Are you always going to get a complete dielectric breakdown at this 200 volts example? No. Should you treat electricity with enough respect knowing that you can have such a dielectric breakdown? Yeah, you should particularly if you understand ventricular fibrillation.

What makes line voltage so dangerous is that there is a very low electrical system impedance. If you do not understand the previous sentence then you have no business working line voltage. Current is what kills but the voltage drives the current as per Ohm's Law. And the resistance can change by voltage levels.

One way I can instantly tell if someone understands electrical safety is if they do or do not understand the dielectric breakdown of the skin issue at different voltage levels and understanding that it is a non-linear problem. People saying that you can just measure skin resistance with a multimeter, which may output only a few volts for a resistance test, and apply that to line voltage electrical safety do not know what they are talking about and should be ignored as a source for electrical safety information. I see this all over the Internet.


Ingress protection

Ingress protection has to do with the mechanical protection of the electrical device. Less ingress protection may mean you can't stick your finger on energized parts. Really high ingress protection will be water proof.

A line voltage COB with the line wire exposed has no ingress protection. That means that it is unsafe. Period. If you do not understand ingress protection then you have no business as a beginner building line voltage electrical devices like line voltage COB lights.

Kapton tape is not line voltage ingress protection for our purposes. I've seen people posting pics of line voltage COBs with Kapton tape as their "ingress protection". Just no.

But...but...but...what if I make the DIY line voltage COB safe with good ingress protection? You are still showing off something that is inherently dangerous to make which other people will follow. Is their AC line voltage COB setup also safe? There comes a point where a line needs to be drawn in the sand.

Good ingress protection means on a practical level that you would let a two year old toddler play with the energized device unattended without risk of electrical injury. I'm not saying that you should do this, and it does depend on the electrical device of course, but that is the practical standard that you should be going for.

Remember that electrical codes and safety guidelines are typically written in blood.


Soldering and line voltage

I can look back at the quality of the soldering I was doing from +20 years ago and cringe at those circuit boards. Sloppy with cold solder joints partially from using a $5 Radio Shack soldering iron that was not temperature controlled. If you have no experience with soldering then you should gain some experience with something that is not a safety risk like a line voltage COB. There are soldering practice kits made with the absolute beginner in mind.

Cold solder joints in particular are problematic because they may work for awhile before failing. If I want to troubleshoot a circuit board the first thing I do is check for power then I'm looking around for cold solder joints (the third thing is check the capacitors). I have seen wires with cold solder joints pop off of circuit boards. The last thing you want with a line voltage COB is your wires popping off and dangling around.

BTW, if you have issues with solder balling up then you may want to try using an eutectic 63/37 solder instead of more common 60/40 solder beyond proper use of solder flux (you don't always need solder flux since there is already flux in most common electrical solders. For surface mount soldering you probably should use solder flux).

I have seen cold solder joints more than once before when people have posted pics on /r/SpaceBuckets of their line voltage COB light.

The two hurdles for beginners getting in to electronics are learning how to solder and learning while also intuitively understanding Ohm's Law. There are good temperature controlled soldering irons in the $30 range but I've used a Weller WTCPT for 15 years now without problems with the tips lasing for many thousands of solder joints. I've seen cheap tips give out after a few hundred.


What about lights that plug in to a light socket? They have no ground.

E26/27 light bulbs and the like have no ground since they use a two conductor lighting socket. They are supposed to have an insulation rating to ensure that there is no electrical shock hazard. Remove the cover of a light bulb to get more light on your plants and you just removed the protection. The line voltage circuit board found in LED light bulbs are not isolated from ground and there can be well over 100 volts exposed.

Even then I have found lights that failed my own safety inspections. A test that I do is to reverse the polarity of the line wire and the neutral wire since reverse polarity is a common problem with receptacles particularly in residential environments where the layman is more likely to do their own electrical work. You can buy a receptacle tester to make sure this does not happen or to test your own house.

Here is a light bulb I bought off Amazon that is on reverse polarity with the light switch turned to the off position. Notice how by merely touching the heat sink how I can get the LEDs to light up dimly. This is because there is an AC electrical fault somewhere and illustrates how these cheap no-name Chinese light bulbs can still be problematic when plugged in. In no way should this ever happen and the cheap bulb can light up like this due to body capacitance.

That bulb also has a CE mark on it, with exposed line voltage electrical, which is why I think the CE self-certification program is non-sense when misused like this. An engineering joke is that CE really stands for "China export" rather than "ConformitƩ EuropƩene" ("European Conformity") and a CE marking does not indicate that a product have been approved as safe by the EU or by another authority. CE usually does not need to be tested by a third party for safety. Here's a UK study on CE mark with an important point of "Whilst we are pleased to report that all of the branded chargers passed the conformity tests, not one of the unbranded chargers were considered to be safe, yet all carried the CE mark."

With that same bulb I can hook up line voltage to the heat sink and get those LEDs to light much brighter. In no way should this ever happen that the LEDs light up since the metal heat sink is supposed to be completely isolated.

An issue with some LED light bulbs that have a heavy heat sink is that this puts extra stress on the base itself and I've had numerous instances of the base breaking. This is very unlikely to happen with small LED light bulbs from Walmart etc but could be a major fail for some of these larger LED lights that simply plug in to a light socket particularly if they are not vertical.

Amazon is selling cheap and dangerous lights. And the CE mark is utter non-sense when it is so easily misused from products out of China.


But my phone charger does not have a ground.

Your phone charger is in a plastic case and is double insulated so does not need a ground. There literally is nothing to ground. Look for the square inside a square for a double insulation mark. The output should also be isolated from ground potential.


What about external LED drivers?

External drivers like the Mean Well LED drivers, as opposed to the onboard drivers found in line voltage COBs, are almost always isolated from ground with their DC outputs. You can ideally take the positive or negative leads used to drive the LED(s) to ground and have no current flow. The danger from them would be at higher voltages and getting a shock from the positive to negative skin contact.

External LED drivers keep you off line voltage which is the compelling reason to use them for DIY use. The better ones are "UR" marked, with a reverse "UR", which means it has been tested for safety for a factory install component of an electrical device (as opposed to a UL marking for a field install of a complete electrical device although there are plenty of ANSI/UL 8750 listed LED drivers).

Good external drivers like by Mean Well can also have up to a five year warranty and the drivers usually fail before the LEDs do. You can forget about a warranty on cheap, generic Chinese made products.

It is a misnomer to say that most "driverless" COBs have no LED driver. The ones that I've examined have an on board constant current linear power supply as the driver. In the mid 2000's I was building 5mm LED grow lights (before high power LEDs were available) that were line voltage using an LM317 linear voltage regulator as a constant current source since the LM317 can float off ground which is why it can work directly off line voltage through a bridge rectifier/capacitor. That line voltage driver would be considered "driverless" in modern parlance. I don't do this anymore since LED drivers are now so cheap, common, reliable, and safe.


What's a safe voltage?

30-50 volts AC, 60-75 volts DC (or is it?)

The answer above was after researching various sources such as the National Electrical Code, peer reviewed engineering sources, European safety directives, and a whole lot of guessing from various potentially unreliable forums like Quora.

There has never been a known case of a person dying from a shock of 50 volts to ground or less outside welding equipment. expert source. There have been cases of <80 volt electrocution deaths. source

The US military considers 50 volts the maximum voltage one can work with without de-energizing the system. source

Article 725 of the National Electrical Code states that a class 1 power limited circuit may only be up to 30 volts AC or DC. source

The EU's extra-low voltage directive says 50 volts AC, but as high as 120 volts DC. source Or is it 30 volts RMS AC and 60 volts DC. source

A line phone system is a higher impedance 48 volts DC on-hook but 90 volts AC 20 Hz current limited when being rung. I've been mildly shocked off a phone system back when electricians sometimes worked on 66 blocks.

As a journeyman electrician (I've been out of the trade for awhile) I would hesitate to let a new 1st year apprentice work with energized 48 volts AC which you'll find with some low voltage transformers. If you're on a ladder and get a mild shock you can still fall from the ladder due to reacting to the shock. My ass would be complete toast if a 1st year apprentice got hurt like this.

AC is considered more dangerous than DC. This was determined experimentally in 1956 by CF Dalziel of the U of CA (Berkeley). source It can take perhaps five times the current in DC to have the same affect on the body as AC for electrical shocks. But this does not mean you can have five times higher DC voltage and be safe because of the non-linear dielectric break down problem.

This is another reason to use an external DC LED driver as the DC output of the LED driver is simply safer to work with than AC.

Even those 50 volt AC, 60-75 volt DC numbers above can be bit controversial. There's a good reason why lab power supplies typically do not go above 30 volts.


Modifying LED light bulbs

You can remove the white translucent case from an LED light bulb to directly expose the LEDs to the plant for roughly 50% more light. You are also now exposing yourself to potentially dangerous voltage levels that are not isolated from ground by removing this electrically insulative cover. That cover is part of the bulb's ingress protection and now you have none.

The removing the case trick is something I started doing back in about 2010(?) when LED light bulbs were just hitting the market. Back then you were paying about $25 for a light bulb that was much less efficient than CFLs. They were also using much higher quality LED drivers that were safer to use.

Today it is common to find capacitive power supplies that are not isolated from ground. You can have dangerously high voltage levels that can also have dangerously high current levels in a ground fault.

People need to be aware that a deadly condition can exist that if you were to grab the energized circuit board with one hand and your other hand is at ground potential that it is possible for a lethal amount of current to flow through your heart.

I've only seen a single example of people modifying LED light bulbs and also providing proper ingress protection by using a glass shield. I strongly encourage people who modify these bulbs to at least have some sort of clear plastic or glass shield covering the exposed line voltage circuit board.


Is GFCI/RCD going to save my life?

Yes.

Ground fault circuit interrupter, often called a residual current device, measures the current between the line (hot) and the neutral wires. If there is a current imbalance that means that there is a ground fault and the GFCI receptacle/circuit breaker will turn off typically at 5 mA (if you have a 220-240 volt system then it typically turns off at 10 mA). In an industrial environment GFCI circuit breakers frequently can be adjusted for the ground fault current trip point.

If you are growing in a garage then you need GFCI/RCD protection. Damp concrete floors are notorious for conducting electricity (pure water is an electrical insulator- it's the dissolved stuff in the water that makes it conduct electricity).

GFCI/RCD does not rely on the grounding wire to work and will work even if only the line and neutral wires are going to the receptacle. There is an input and an output to a GFCI receptacle- every receptacle that is wired to the output of a GFCI receptacle will also have GFCI protection even if they are not a GFCI receptacle.

If you do not have GFCI protection then you can always buy an adapter if you do not want to replace the receptacle.

It is really important to note that GFCI will not protect you from a hot to neutral electrical shock, only a line to ground shock.

Pro tip- both the grounding wire and the neutral wire are grounded conductors but only the third grounding wire is referred to as such (usually the green, yellow and green, or bare wire). The grounding wire is typically referred to as the ground wire or as "earth".


Is AFCI going to help keep my place from burning down?

Yes.

Arc-fault circuit interrupter (AFCI) is different than GFCI in that instead of detecting ground faults the circuit detects series and parallel electrical arcing. If you bought a newer place in the US/Canada then all of your commonly used circuits will have AFCI interrupters (except for maybe the bathroom because the bathroom is not considered a habitable room).

Series arcing can be from loose or corroded electrical connections and there may be a few hundred electrical connections on a home.

Parallel arcing is often from damaged wire insulation such as found in an electrical appliance power cord. The damaged insulation can allow the line voltage wire and the grounding or neutral wire to slowly come in contact with each other which can cause arcing.

An AFCI works by detecting high amounts of broad band electrical noise, or radio frequency interference, on the wires or electrical device caused by arcing. Many AFCI devices, particularly the earlier AFCI devices when they first came on the market, will also have a built in 30mA GFCI circuit. This higher 30mA current trip point is more to protect equipment rather than people.

regular circuit breaker- protects the wires and equipment from over loads and short circuits

GFCI- protects you from electrical shocks due to ground faults

AFCI- helps protects everything from fires

A circuit breaker that incorporates GFCI and AFCI will cost about $50.


Should I trust a non-contact voltage tester?

No- test it first.

As an electrician I always had a non-contact voltage tester on me but I've seen false negatives before with them. You must keep test them on a known live circuit.

I've also had a Wiggy solenoid voltage tester basically fly apart in my hand testing a 480 volt AC three phase circuit but this is a rarity and I do trust this type of voltage tester. You can test wires without looking at the tester.

BTW, some higher impedance multimeters can give false readings in some cases. A common test is a neutral to ground voltage test to insure that there is less than two (or one) volts from the neutral to ground. A lower impedance multimeter like a Fluke 117 can be used instead.


Why aren't more people dying from tasers/stun guns?

What kills people with electricity is the current path, amount of current, and the duration that the current is flowing.

Tasers/stuns guns reach about 40-50,000 volts, which is limited by the distance between the electrodes in the spark gap, and then quickly drops down closer to a few thousand volts when in skin contact. But these are short duration pulses of tens of microseconds making the average current fairly low.

Stun guns are not reaching "a million volts", or what ever, and claims like that are deceptive advertisement.


A cheap and safe five gallon COB grow light

30 watts of LEDs is more than enough to properly light up a five gallon space bucket with a high quality COB. A Vero 18 ran at 28 volts and one amp can drive the top of the plant canopy to about 1400 umol/m2/sec which is saturating a cannabis plant. Keep the light 6-8 inches above the plant or perhaps a little more.

Vero 18 gen 7 3500K 28 volt version

Lower cost Mean Well driver for Vero 18

Then you need a heat sink that is rated for 15 watts of heat (assuming that 30 watt COB is 50% electrically efficient) and material to mount the LED to the heat sink. This will outperform any cheap AC COB and is safe enough for the beginner.


Some of these YouTubers are being ridiculously unsafe!

A call out I'm going to do here is the Migro channel on YouTube and his complete disregard for electrical safety.

The video in question that I'm critiquing is this one on an AC driverless grow light.

You can see in the video that the grow light is not even being grounded. Any competent person skilled in the art should have given that grow light an instant fail and stopped the testing until the manufacturer spent ten cents to correct the problem. To reiterate, your safety is not even worth ten...fucking...cents to the person who designed this light. And this person is apparently not giving a damn here, either, judging how he is ignoring the safety warnings being given in the comment section.

And then he is grabbing the energized exposed line voltage device on the circuit board itself in his hand like it's nothing. This is profoundly reckless conduct that other people who are also very naive about electrical safety will emulate and why I'm so vocal about line voltage COBs and these very foolish people like this person who are so cavalier about electrical safety.

This person getting watts and joules confused in the video to the point I can't understand what he is trying to convey is one thing, his made up measurements like "PPFD per watt" don't make any sense at all nor does his odd "159 PAR claim" (is that 159 watts/m2 of PAR? I've been rightly called out in an academic setting by a full professor for saying "micro moles" instead of "micro moles per square meter per second" and the correct terminology should be used), it just shows that he lacks some very basic understanding on the subject matter that he is presenting himself to be an authority on. But the lack of basic electrical safety practices should be utterly condemned.

I've said it before and I'll say it again: IF YOU ARE GOING TO PLAY THE ROLE OF TEACHER THEN YOU HAVE AN ETHICAL DUTY TO PUT OUT ACCURATE AND SAFE INFORMATION WHILE SHOWING SAFE PRACTICES. PERIOD. ffs

Anyone can look like they know what they talking about to a layman on YouTube by waving a light meter under a light. Plenty of people on YouTube do it, and Migro is actually better than most, but watch out for people trying to sell something or if they are receiving free stuff. People who are receiving free stuff often will never do a negative review.

BTW, I've never seen anything remotely close to a legit side by side grow test on YouTube and take them all with a big lump of salt. The plants need the exact same conditions and your population number needs to be at least nine for a basic test (power=0.8, P<0.05) or 20 for a more accurate test (power=0.8, P<0.01) or 75 for a larger field test (power=0.9, P<0.01).


Driverless line voltage COBs are the now and the future

At the end of the day the wallet talks and AC driverless COBs are going to become more popular. There is going to come a time where a 100 watt driverless COB that is 80% electrically efficient (an efficacy of above 3 umol/joule) and is going to cost around $5 for the COB itself. It is inevitable.

But these cheap ass COBs are still going to be cutting corners particularly in the on board driver itself and it is usually the driver that gives out rather than the LEDs.

So the danger is going to increase as these DIY "suicide lights" become more common. This type of work should be rejected for the DIY hobby community and people encouraged to use external LED drivers that are much safer for the beginner to use which will isolate you off ground from potentially deadly shock hazards. As mentioned above, DC is safer than AC.


In conclusion

I understand that many people want to go as cheap as possible on their lighting but there is a point where you need to put a price on your own safety. What's it worth to you?

If you want to be unsafe yourself then all I can say is do it before you breed and have at it. But most people simply are not going to understand the dangers particularly when most people online have never even heard of the dielectric breakdown of the skin issue and higher voltages.

Just say no to DIY AC driverless "suicide lights" and use a proper external LED driver with a high quality COB instead. If you post about them on /r/SpaceBuckets I'll respond if you need help but my no PM policy for helping people build their own grow lights unfortunately needs to stay in place due to the amount of people who were asking for help and the time involved.

So, in conclusion....your wife is cheating on you, your mother is lying when she says she loves you, your children view you as a meal ticket, your dog secretly wants to move in with your next door neighbor, your cat just threw up on your bed (again), nobody on Reddit likes you, but SAG actually cares.

Just say no to DIY driverless AC COB "suicide" lights.


A few sources

Ohm's Law Calculator

Big Clive on YouTube. I believe Big Clive is a lineman (a type of electrician) and he does a lot of testing of cheap Chinese electrical devices as well as discussing electricity in general.

Electroboom on YouTube. Mehdi Sadaghar is an electrical engineer that talks about electrical safety with his own brand of humor thrown in.

Dave Jones and EEVlog is the best electrical engineering forum on the Internet. His videos on free energy and solar road ways are funny with how frustrated he can get with people's rubbish.

Mike Holt electrical forum. This is a great resource for electricians.

A COMPLETE ELECTRICAL HAZARD CLASSIFICATION SYSTEM AND ITS APPLICATION This in an industry wide paper on electrical safety.

EFFECTS OF ELECTRICAL SHOCK ON MAN Dalziel (1956). This is an earlier very complete study on electrical shocks. It has a bunch of pictures of people getting electrical shocks for science, which is nice.

COMBINATION AFCIs: WHAT THEY WILL AND WILL NOT DO This is a really interesting paper on the development of AFCI that also get a bit in to the politics of the NEMA and UL.

What's in your socket? This is a good UK study on the safety of electrical sockets.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Sep 17 '13

LED and LED GROW LIGHTS PART 2: Beam Angle

35 Upvotes

LEDs and LED Grow Lights Part 2 in the lighting guide: Beam Angle

Please, no linking to grow lights and asking my or others opinions of specific ones on here. PM me such questions. It's to prevent flame wars, to keep bias down and for no free advertising. I'll tell you up front, at this point in time I would not use LED grow lights only in large scale grow operations.

LEDs, LED grow lights and plant growth can be difficult because it's a interdisciplinary knowledge set. There's electronics including the power supply types/design and LED electrical characteristics, thermodynamics explained here, photometry, photobiology including light sensitive proteins, photometry, general botany and stuff I'm probably forgetting at the moment. We'll focus on the LED's here and I'll try writing to the layman. Actually building LED grow lights step 1 has just about been completed (pics done, needs some wordsmith). Things like heat and voltage drop will be covered there.

A quick note- after checking over 30 different white LEDs comparing lux to radiant flux and uMol/meter2 /sec, you can use a cheap digital lux meter with white LEDs. 70 lux = 1 uMol/meter2 /sec within 10% over 2800K-7000k white LEDs. 67 lux = 1uMol within 5 % with warm white LEDs. The higher the color temperature the greater the variance. Read the lighting guide if you didn't understand the above or ask below what section to read. A lux meter is no good for absolute measurements with color LEDs.

Penetration and beam angle

Repeat after me: a 3 watt LED does not necessarily have better penetration than a 1 watt LED. I've seen such discussions in multiple forums multiple times.

Let's say we have a single LED that is a (theoretical) point light source. It's light output will follow the square of distance law of light drop off in this case. At one foot we have one unit of light which covers one square feet, at two feet from the LED we have ¼ unit of light which is 4 square feet, at 3 feet from the LED we have 1/9 unit of light which covers 9 square feet etc.

But, what if we had a 1 watt LED with a 60 degree light beam output and the 3 watt LED with a 120 degree output. What LED penetrates the plant canopy better? The one watt LED is going to penetrate better since its light is 4 times more focused (simplifying here). I have a 100 watt LED at 120 degrees and a typical 0.005 watt laser pointer (lasers are rated on their true optical power output unlike LEDs) at what ever degrees it is. The tiny laser has better penetration. I can focus it to put tiny burn holes on the bottom leaves of a typical indoor plant in a few seconds with better optics than a cheap laser pointer.

Plant canopy penetration is a function of both optical power output and how focused that light source is. This is a huge consideration when building or buying a LED grow light. Growing lettuce without much vertical space? Get a LED grow light with wider beam angles. Growing a 3 foot tall plant where you want the bottom leaves receiving a lager amount of light? Get a LED grow light with a narrow beam angle but have the light higher (further away from the plant) than a light with a wider beam angle.

Beware that some LED grow light manufacturers/importers might make a caparison and have the ruler or whatever say 12 inches from their light (A) and a competitors light (B). So A with a light meter puts out at that 12 inches so much more light than B, maybe even twice as much as their competitor!!! No, check the beam angle of both the lights. I've seen this trick so many times by people in the trade. In most forums it's not under standing beam angle and light drop off. You just need to put the light closer if using shorter plants or low stress training and a screen of green.

Linear lights, sources such as fluorescent tubes have such a wide beam angle which is distributed along the bulb, are great for lettuce which can then be stacked on shelves.

In most grow situations, the closer your light source is to the plant, the wider the beam angle you want:

Short plants = wider beam angle

Tall plants = narrow beam angles and have the light up a little higher so that you're not light saturating the upper leaves

It may help to think of wider beam angle LED grow lights as relatively closer to florescent tube like lighting and narrow beam angle LED grow lights like HID lighting with a small, horizontal and narrow hood and use them appropriately as an analogy.

A lot of distributors are coming out with multi-beam angle LEDs. The ratio of wide angle to short angle would he a handy piece of information to know as well as their general spectrum (red, far red, blue, etc)

link to part 3


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Nov 11 '22

SAG's Open Cannabis Links part 2

34 Upvotes

11 NOV 2022

Part of SAG's Lighting Guide


I ran in to the 40,000 character limit with part 1

I still have to take time to organize everything! I have over 250 papers to go over and reorganize. This is less than half of all cannabis papers that have now been published.




Most interesting and contradicts Bruce Bugbee:









80 ________________________________________________________

90 _____________________________________________


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Mar 14 '21

Light Measurement, LED Grow Light Systems, and Spectral Characteristics

34 Upvotes

Light Measurement, LED Grow Light Systems, and Spectral Characteristics

last update: March 2021

main papers link page

SAG's Plant Lighting Guide main page


light meters and measurement


LED grow lights and systems


Spectral measurements and characteristics


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Mar 14 '21

Cannabis, basil, lettuce, tomato, pepper lighting

33 Upvotes

Cannabis, basil, lettuce, tomato, pepper lighting links

last update: March 2021

main papers link page

SAG's Plant Lighting Guide main page


Cannabis lighting


Basil lighting


Lettuce lighting


Tomato lighting


Pepper lighting


r/HandsOnComplexity • • May 26 '20

Bridgelux phosphor guide

32 Upvotes

Spectrum charts, conversion factors, and color ratios of the Bridgelux COB array LEDs

updated 11 June 2020

part of SAG's Plant Lighting Guide

Using a lux meter as a plant light meter (only use a lux meter with white light sources)


The conversion factor is luminous flux (lux) to photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD) in uMol/m2/sec (micro moles per square meter per second) of PAR (photosynthetic active radiation 400-700 nm). This is so that low cost lux meters can be used as plant lighting meters.

The color ratios will not add up to 100. Blue is 400-499 nm, green is 500-599 nm, red is 600-699nm, far red is 700-799nm.

This is the second order derivative of the Bridgelux phosphors. This was specifically a CRI 97 COB. Each of the major downward dips is a different phosphor and is way more complex than I thought it would be. The saturated one on the far left is the phosphor pump blue LED (the wavelength is downshifted or shifted to the right slightly with this technique). Derivative spectroscopy is a powerful analytical chemistry technique that allows one to look at chlorophyll A and B separately in living leaves in vivo, for example, that may not show up very well if at all with more traditional spectroscopy techniques in vivo.

The average wavelength of phosphor pump blue LEDs in my samples was about 453.5 nm.

Vero 10's, Vero 18's and Vero 29's were tested here. In many cases multiple samples of the same phosphor type were tested.

The below backs my claim that you can use 70 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec for CRI 80, and 63 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec for CRI 90 and be within 10%. That 1750K LED is an exception.


1750K cri 80 -This is an oddball LED

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 49 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:08....green:25....red:57....far red:06


2000K cri 65

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 70 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:05....green:41....red:49....far red:02


2700K cri 80

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 72 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:11....green:42....red:36....far red:02


2700K cri 90

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 63 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:06....green:19....red:22....far red:02


3000K cri 80

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 73 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:16....green:45....red:37....far red:02


3000K cri 90

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 65 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:09....green:22....red:23....far red:02


3000K cri 97

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 59 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:14....green:36....red:41....far red:04


3500K cri 80

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 74 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:20....green:47....red:31....far red:01


4000K cri 80

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 74 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:11....green:24....red:14....far red:01


4000K cri 90

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 68 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:20....green:40....red:31....far red:02


5000k cri 70

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 75 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:13....green:22....red:09....far red:01


5000K cri 80

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 76 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:26....green:50....red:21....far red:01