r/BudScience • • Jul 03 '21

Quality Post GDrive with lots of papers and information.

156 Upvotes

Hey everyone.

I was sent this link a while back from a buddy. Has many folders and documents on cannabis and processing. Have fun exploring!

https://drive.google.com/drive/u/0/mobile/folders/1zOrIlrChpPteq7cmeNluCBA6tquwIvj9


r/BudScience • • Dec 30 '21

Quality Post 12/29 Isolated branch w/ CS treatment @ f51, waiting for pollen..

Thumbnail
gallery
121 Upvotes

r/BudScience • • Nov 27 '21

Quality Post Isolated branch V.3: narrower focus with sex reversal underway

Thumbnail
gallery
114 Upvotes

r/BudScience • • Feb 07 '22

Quality Post No distinction between indica and sativa says new international research. Teprene profiles play the biggest roll according to them.

Thumbnail
bedrocan.com
106 Upvotes

r/BudScience • • Aug 14 '21

Quality Post - Evil Genius at work Thought this was interesting enough to share

85 Upvotes

r/BudScience • • Aug 18 '21

Quality Post [UPCOMING AMA]Interested in a Dr. BruceBugbee AMA? It's official, It's scheduled next Tuesday on Aug, 24th for 11AM EST. Reminder link for event inside.

75 Upvotes

EDIT: ##Link to session

You will easily find it on Dr.Bruce Bugbee's profile.

 
 

Sometime ago, A bunch of you expressed an interest in Dr. Brucebugbee AMA. Well I decided to take it upon myself and reach out to him. I told him about the small following of his throughout the community and asked if would participate in a AMA. And he said yes!! The AMA is coming up on Aug, 24th 11AM EST. I hope everyone is excited as I am.  
 

If you were going to participate in the AMA, what would ask?
 

Here is a link if you want to add it to your calendar.

RemindMeBot ---- Google Calendar

I just want to add, I'm not affiliated with him in any way. I'm just a fan of his. I simply found him online and asked him, and he said yes.


r/BudScience • • Jan 15 '22

Quality Post over 100 open access cannabis papers

70 Upvotes

Sample:


r/BudScience • • Dec 03 '23

I think this counts as Science - fridge cuts held for 45 days then rooted.

Thumbnail
gallery
69 Upvotes

Cut then swapping out sterile gauze every 3 weeks. Worked once before at 45 days. Going to go 60 this time.


r/BudScience • • Nov 17 '21

New class of compounds discovered in cannabis that generate its skunk-like scent are chemically similar to those in Garlic

Thumbnail
pubs.acs.org
64 Upvotes

r/BudScience • • Dec 10 '21

Isolated Branch v.3 day 24. Concept proven despite stress on the branch.

Thumbnail
gallery
62 Upvotes

r/BudScience • • Aug 25 '21

Cannabis Yield Increased Proportionally With Light Intensity, but Additional Ultraviolet Radiation Did Not Affect Yield or Cannabinoid Content

Thumbnail
preprints.org
59 Upvotes

r/BudScience • • Jul 04 '21

Can we remove the NSFW tags on everything?

58 Upvotes

I filter NSFW content for the overabundance of sexualized material on Reddit. Growing plants is not NSFW. It makes me use all the other grow related subs because I constantly have to deal with the NSFW warnings.


r/BudScience • • Nov 11 '22

I have another 100 open access cannabis papers

52 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/HandsOnComplexity/comments/ysgekc/sags_open_cannabis_links_part_2/?

I'm adding more cannabis hemp papers because there is a lot of quality information.

I still have to go back and organize the papers with part 1.


Favorites:

Far red gets shot down (again) despite claims such as by Bruce Bugbee. The above paper is under embargo until May 2023 (likely due to some patent issues).

edit- I can see this being a very nuanced thesis and I'm very interested in seeing the grow style; eg LST takes care of the "increase in height" problem (you can veg out just fine even with 2100K HPS using aggressive LST) and the author may have had the plants further away if measuring PPFD from the very tops of the plants while not doing LST optimization. Also, about 45-50% of all far red light is reflected from leaves and far red also penetrates through leaves very well (green light, for example, has only 10-20% reflection and perhaps 80-90% absorption) and one can make an optimized for far red light grow chamber (I wonder of that is what the embargo is about?).


Again, UV light gets shot down and as far as I know is a bunch of marketing BS. I first started using UV in 2009 to get plants to not grow while keeping them alive (trying to hibernate plants).

The only benefit I've found with UV is it using selectively to try to guess what's going on with some light sensitive proteins.


edit:

this is an interesting paper to me because it contradicts my past claims but this was at only 400 uMol/m2/sec with no side lighting (I have to crank up the nitrogen with high light/side light):


r/BudScience • • Jun 05 '25

Bruce Bugbee video collection

51 Upvotes

If you are in to cannabis science then you've likely heard of Bruce Bugbee, a professor at Utah State University and founder of Apogee instruments. Bugbee has been instrumental in exposing the cannabis myths and bro-science prevalent on so many cannabis forums using data driven research.

This is giving a quick TL;DR and commentary on some videos with Bruce Bugbee as it relates to cannabis. Most people are not going to read papers so if you having an online discussion and need a source, just link here or directly to one of the videos. I did this before with his Reddit AMA:

I want to give a shout out to Nigel Gale who is another PhD-level cannabis scientists that makes Youtube videos.


UV & IR

UV light does not boost cannabinoid levels and too much longer wavelength IR can cause unwanted tissue heating. He is not talking about far red light in this video. As a caveat, there is one study that showed UV-A bumping up the THC levels in the finger leaves but not the buds (it's in this sub).

There is no evidence UV bumps up total terpenes, but may increase some while decreasing others. Keep this in mind when a salesman like MIGRO tries to peddle a UV-B light claiming 40% more terpenes. His light failed in academic 3rd party testing using his protocol, and his claim appears to be based on cherry-picking data rather than replicated science. We the evidence we have, the most one can say is that the flavor profile may change.

Notice that Bugbee states that multiple wavelengths and dosages were tested up to the point of burning plants, with no boost in cannabinoids.

Much of the UV myth gets back to the work and misunderstanding of Lydon (Bugbee misspelled his name) particularly this paper below.

When Bugbee talks IR as "heat", that is typically mid and long wavelength that might be 3000 to 14,000 nm or so. As examples, an HPS bulb that is 800 degrees F would have an IR peak of 4100 nm, while an 125 degree F LED light will have an 8900 nm peak. This is infrared as a black body radiation source.

Bugbee did find that 850 nm NIR, found in night vision video cameras that uses NIR LEDs, did delay flowering in cannabis in one study at high levels in a study (NIR is near infrared radiation). An important point is that mid and long wave infrared does not interact with the phytochrome protein group, while 850 nm NIR does a little. Far red light can also delay flowering in short day plants like cannabis.

BTW, getting back to UV, keep in mind that there is UV-A, UV-B, and UV-C. With UV-A it is the cryptochrome proteins that are being expressed more, with UV-B it is the UVR8 protein, no known protein for UV-C for our purposes. Don't assume UV-A and UV-B will have identical reactions in plants.


How Dark is Dark Enough?

0.006 uMol/m2/sec for cannabis or about triple full moonlight.

He gives a nice rule of thumb where in the grow area if it is so dark that you cannot read a large print book then it is dark enough.

Towards the middle of the video he is giving charts for red light and give the number 0.01 uMol/m2/sec. Towards the end he discusses temperature and night light pollution.


Bleaching

This pertains to red light bleaching. Buds in some strains start having bleaching issues of the buds when you have a red light PPFD starting around 600 uMol/m2/sec. For the 600 uMol/m2/sec claim, would that make a difference if using 660 or 630 nm LEDs? As per ANSI/ASABE S640 red is 600-700 nm. (light sensitive protein responses can be fairly wavelength specific)

The mechanism itself of red light bleaching is still unknown. I used to think it was damage to the top layer of chlorophyll from the high absorption of red light, but apparently that is wrong, because the buds just grow like that without any pigments (if there were carotenoids the buds would be yellow but there is not even that, just white).

What is known is that there is no actual photobleaching going on.


48 hours of darkness before harvest

"It's a lack of evidence that it helps".

"We don't recommend two days of darkness". The darkness is stopping the synthesis of cannabinoids and terpenes, and does not increase resin but halts production. Much of everything shuts down because there's almost no transpiration, and Bugbee makes the point about things degrading from that amount time in the dark, rather then 12 hours of darkness. Much of the metabolism is light driven.

Plants also respire in darkness and get smaller. I don't know how much this makes a difference to dry yield, though, when he says this. But, you are loosing two days of photosynthesis which is why he mentions lower yields.

He makes the point that you should just chop the plant and have it dry slower, which is about equivalent

BTW, from my own measurements, it takes about 30-60 seconds for a plant to "wake up" (enzyme activation), and maybe 3-5 minutes to "go to sleep" (enzyme deactivation), for the enzymes associated with photosynthesis. What I do is use a space bucket attached to a fiber optic probe connected to my spectroradiometer, and turn the light on and off, and analyze the amount of far red chlorophyll fluorescence the plant gives off when the light is turned back on.

Around 1-2 percent of the light absorbed by a plant is readmitted as far red fluorescent light, with higher amounts means photosynthesis is less efficient at a given PPFD. Your plant is always being irradiated with small amounts of far red light when exposed to any PAR light.

This busts the myth that plants require a long time to wake up.

Here's what it looks like on a time series graph on my spectroradiometer (every line is 2 seconds):


48 Hours Of LIGHT Before Harvest! (NOT DARK!)

There is no evidence that cannabis benefits with 48 hours of light before harvest. This myth makes no sense.

Cool temperatures might help in the end.


Sweeteners in the Root Zone

Adding carbohydrates and sugars to the grow medium has been shown not to work. What you get is a bacteria population explosion that quickly consumes the sugars to basically no benefit to the plant (I have been saying this online for about 15 years now). People adding these commercial bud sweeteners you can buy, or adding molasses, could be fooling themselves and falling for confirmation bias.

However, molasses has trace amounts of micronutes, small amounts of potassium, tiny amounts of nitrogen, and you can find non-cannabis studies on their benefits in poor quality soils. The increased microbes may also help breakdown organic matter in the soil which does not matter for most indoor growers including soil growers. Blackstrap molasses can have an NPK of 1-0-5 and has much less sugar.

There is little evidence that plants can uptake carbos and sugars through their roots in any significant amounts. There is an interesting paper showing a positive efficacy in pumping sucrose directly into a plants stem that I analyze here:


temperature

Mid 80s F in veg and the beginning of flower then cool it off in week 2 or 3 of flowering. There is a study I posted here about how even in the lower 80s F in flowering can reduce cannabinoids (I was wrong in what i used to say, yet again).

It could be the case that the tropical sativas can handle higher temperatures with no reduction in THC.


humidity

Bugbee makes the observation that people over worry about humidity. Keep it low enough to keep pathogens down (powdery mildew, botrytis which is strain specific to how prone they are to them) such as around 60% with good airflow. Below 40% makes the plant transpire too much.


How VPD Relates to Nutrient Uptake

Vapor pressure deficit relates to humidity at different temperatures. Keep the VPD between one and two.

A VPD of two means that the water if flowering through the plant twice as fast as a VPD of one, everything else being equal. This relates to transpiration rates. At a higher VPD you want to use less fertilizer so you don't get a build up of fertilizer salts.


Benefits of CO2

Running your CO2 at 1200 ppm will give 30% greater yield than normal at a higher PPFD. Adding more is not beneficial. Try to stay above 800-1000 ppm.

Bugbee has a history of really emphasizing the benefits of CO2. When you look at the benefits versus the costs, it's irrational not to use CO2 as long as other environmental parameters can be kept in check.

If you're a beginner, don't bother with cheap CO2 generating gimmicks like vinegar and baking soda. You need consistent amounts in a fairly narrow range. Get a 5 or 20 pound CO2 tank with ideally a regulator, solenoid, and digital CO2 sensor/controller. Expect to pay $400-500 but refills are pretty cheap. Commercial growers use natural gas or propane to generate CO2.

Amusingly, there is a Reddit post somewhere that the OP ran some ducting from his bedroom to his grow chamber, and he measured the CO2 ppm in his bedroom at about 1000 ppm so that was being pump into the chamber. That's a really novel and creative way to do CO2 enhancement.

CO2 sensors start at about $20 and CO2 meters can be bought for under 100. You can gain a lot of insight by doing the measurements. Never buy an "eCO2" meter/sensor because they don't actually measure true CO2 levels; they are just cheap VOC sensors running an algorithm to guess true CO2 levels.


High Levels of Phosphorus

Bugbee is putting up the number 30 ppm for elemental phosphorus and there's some studies I have posted here that are showing around 50 ppm are optimal. I'm around 100 ppm (General Hydroponics Flora bottle mic 1-1-1 at EC 1.6) and most people are going to use more of the bloom at a higher EC than me so perhaps 150-250 ppm P.

He is saying that there is no difference in yield for 30 ppm and 90 ppm in a high THC cultivar in a study, but did benefit a lower THC cultivar. So this is likely strain specific.

In the second half Bugbee makes a point about how phosphorus can build up in the buds. I'm sure most of us have smoked and tasted over-fertilized buds before.

Keep in mind that these are hydroponic number claims that have complete nutrient availability.


Organics vs. Synthetics

Do Organics Produce Better Quality?

Bugbee makes a point about how we should recycle all of our wastes as composted fertilizer. His critique about organics is the high amounts of phosphorus, the lack of precision, and the negative effects it can have on the environment such as algae blooms. I find this ironic because organic is all about being healthier.

However, synthetics can offer more precision.

Does organic make a better yield and quality? No, it can be lower quality with less yield compared to precision synthetic fertilizers. Organic fertilizers breakdown to the same fertilizers as the synthetics.

Does living soil create better plants? No, not for quality or yield. Don't let this stop you if you want to use living soils, though, just be realistic.

Keep in mind that Bugbee does a hell of a lot of fertilizer and medium testing besides just light testing when he makes these claims. There's always someone that gets all upset whenever anyone criticizes organic, particularly on anecdotal quality, and you should just do what you want to do- it is not worth the argument.

Most of us are indoor growers. Is there a difference outdoors for organics? I personally avoid even more expensive organic food because I think it's wasteful and less productive. Norman Borlaug had the right idea with developing high yielding monocultrue grain crops, that uses synthetic fertilizers, and helped prevent mass starvation. "The man that saved a billion lives"....when a well respected scientist wins a Nobel Peace Prize for his work (1970).


Do Organic Fertilizers Really Provide A Better Terpene Profile?

Bugbee is saying that there is no good evidence to support the claim that organics improves the terpene profile. Again, lots of online arguments here and I would not be surprised if arguments broke out below. If they do expect me to be like "the plural of anecdote is not data".

Bugbee makes the point that if is does work, it would likely be the stress of not having proper nutrition rather than the organics themselves. Again, organics breakdown to the same as synthetic fertilizers but with less precision.


Adding Microbes

Adding microbes does not help with inert grow mediums (eg. hydroponics) and synthetic fertilizers. The nutes are already bioavailable. The exception is legumes and nitrogen fixing microbes (anecdotally I've seen this work very well outdoors in soil).

There are various companies selling microbe additives and I'm not aware of any of them showing their data, just large claims.

Keep in mind that Bugbee is talking about inert grow mediums.


Effects of Flushing

If you over fertilize then there can be a benefit to flushing. Otherwise, there is no benefit. Why are you over fertilizing?

Growing without nitrogen for the last few weeks appears to be beneficial. However, keep in mind that his data is for industrial hemp, and although his relative boosts in THC is impressive, the absolute increase is much less so.


Effects of Potassium Silicate

You'll sometimes see people promoting silica online. Bugbee claims it's "very valuable" but not essential. He is not providing any data of its efficacy, particularly for cannabis, and until we see the study then it's reasonable to have skepticism about adding silica.

Silica is supposed to make plants with stronger cell walls and increase tolerance to stress. A lot of the studies are for how plants react to some kind of stressor and adding silica. Most positive results come from cereal and grasses.


r/BudScience • • Sep 16 '22

Cannabis seedlings found to inherit antifungal bacteria from mother plant.

Thumbnail
mdpi.com
51 Upvotes

r/BudScience • • Dec 21 '21

Intentional male parts emerging on the bloom segment of the isolated branch. Colloidal silver treatment.

Thumbnail
gallery
51 Upvotes

r/BudScience • • Dec 30 '22

Quality Post Spraying female flowering plants with Salicylic Acid or GABA resulted in higher THC yields

49 Upvotes

Takeaways:

  • Spraying salicylic acid (SA) and gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) can affect the expression of key genes involved in the cannabinoid biosynthesis pathway in cannabis plants

  • SA treatment resulted in increased expression of the THCAS gene, while it decreased the expression of the CBDAS, OLS, and PT genes

  • GABA treatment resulted in increased expression of the THCAS gene at 0.1 mM

  • SA treatment increased the THC content and decreased the CBD content in cannabis plants

It appears that plants treated at 1mM/L SA resulted in a two-fold THC content (%/dry weight).

Link to the article: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S092666901930161X (available in sci-hub but I won't link).


r/BudScience • • Dec 15 '21

Cannabis plants have an inherent ability to absorb heavy metals from the soil, making them useful for remediating contaminated sites and this ability to soak up toxic metals may also make cannabis dangerous for consumers who ingest it

Thumbnail
psu.edu
49 Upvotes

r/BudScience • • May 20 '22

added 39 cannabis papers to my cannabis links page

47 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/HandsOnComplexity/comments/s4wcmh/sags_open_access_cannabis_links/

These are the added papers below. I sill have to organize them. Most of these papers have a 2022 publish date.






r/BudScience • • Jul 17 '21

Indoor Pruning Guide for Indoor Cannabis Cultivars - Two Parts

Thumbnail
mmjdaily.com
46 Upvotes

r/BudScience • • Feb 16 '22

Quality Post I'm doing data collection and testing of cheap generic "quantum boards" to UL 1598 standards. The first three failed badly.

45 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceBuckets/comments/su3rch/another_cheap_quantum_board_failed_very_rough/

I'm preparing an article for my lighting guide and publishing early data. In the article I'm going to go into detail of what UL 1598 (luminaires) means, including specific volt/amp levels, and how the hobbyist can do some of this testing. I'm also going to discuss what a UL 8800 grow light is and why you should use them for pro use.

In the comments in the space bucket sub I'm taking requests for the next light for me to safety test.

edited slight mistake


r/BudScience • • Dec 03 '21

“Here’s the chemistry behind marijuana’s skunky scent” - summary article on a study posted earlier, link in comments

Thumbnail
sciencenews.org
45 Upvotes

r/BudScience • • Sep 14 '21

Quality Post Shape Matters: Plant Architecture Affects Chemical Uniformity in Large-Size Medical Cannabis Plants

Thumbnail
mdpi.com
45 Upvotes

r/BudScience • • Dec 29 '25

Data over gut feeling: What 5,000+ grows reveal about yield, lights, nutrients & setups.

43 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

today’s post shares some results from a hobby project.

About me

For several years, I worked in banking and finance, focusing on machine learning and statistical analysis of large, often quite messy datasets.
In my spare time, I have been involved with cannabis cultivation for a while, so it was a natural step to combine these two areas.

Starting point

Growdiaries is a large, publicly accessible data source.
Different writing styles, incomplete information, widely varying grower experience levels, and numerous outliers make this data quite challenging to work with.

Hypothesis and approach

The basic idea was: if you collect and clean enough datasets, you might uncover patterns and trends that go beyond individual experiences.
To explore this, I started a hobby project in which I systematically collected, cleaned, and analyzed data from over 5,000 documented grows.

The goal is not to find “absolute truth”, but to:

  • Make general trends visible

  • Put comparisons on a more reliable footing

  • Check common assumptions and myths against numbers

At irregular intervals, I will publish different analyses, depending on what the data supports.
Constructive feedback, criticism, or new research questions are very welcome.

First analysis: lamp brands over 150 W

For the first step, I looked at lighting – one of the most frequently debated topics in indoor cultivation.
The central question is: if we only consider grows with lamps over 150 W, which brand gives growers, on average, the best yield‑to‑power ratio (g/W)?

Interpretation notes

These results do not directly show which lamp is “better” or “worse”.
They rather reflect how successful growers are with certain brands, including all differences in setup, experience, and genetics.

For example, brand X might mainly be used by very experienced growers who would probably achieve similarly good results with other lamps as well.
Because such effects cannot be cleanly separated out with the current data, the evaluations should be seen as a basis for hypotheses and discussion, not as definitive verdicts.

Methodology

Data basis

  • Over 5,000 documented grows from Growdiaries

Filters

  • Only grows with lamps over 150 W

  • Only brands with at least 50 mentions

  • Exclusion of datasets with unrealistic values (over 2.5 g/W or below 0.1 g/W) to reduce obvious input errors and extreme outliers

These steps help to minimize statistical noise and heavily distorted entries, making the results a bit more robust.

Results (descriptive)

Brands with generally higher values

  • SANlight: Despite a relatively low median, the upper whisker is long and there are several high values, indicating that some very efficient grows were achieved with this brand.

  • Lumatek: Stands out with a comparatively high median and a fairly tall upper box, suggesting that more efficient grows occur more frequently in this dataset.

Caution in interpretation

Differences in median and spread suggest that certain brands in this dataset are more often associated with higher g/Watt values than others.
At the same time, it remains unclear how much of this is driven by grower experience, setup quality, genetics, or growing medium, since these influences could not be adjusted for in the aggregation.

Overall, Lumatek and SANlight appear more often in efficient grows within this sample, while Mars Hydro and ViparSpectra tend to cluster in the lower to mid efficiency range.
However, this comes with the clear caveat that these are brand‑aggregated observations, not controlled comparison tests.

Outlook

In the coming weeks, planned analyses include:

  • Relationship between EC and yield

  • Relationship between nutrient brand and yield

  • Possibly models that predict yield and then analyze which variables (crop steering, etc.) influence the predictions. At the moment, it seems that the data structure and standardization are only partially suitable for more advanced modeling, and such models usually become reliable only with several million datapoints. Still, a small example model is sketched in the comments.

This whole project is an open learning exercise, and further questions and your participation in the topic are very welcome.


r/BudScience • • Aug 27 '21

A State of the Budscience - Please Give Subreddit Feedback Here!

43 Upvotes

Hey everyone. I founded this subreddit a few months ago. Since then, several people have joined what I can only consider the best mod team possible. These people are responsible for the growth and direction of what is turning out to be a valuable and impressive resource. And they do it all because they believe in a good resource of vetted, reliable, and science based facts freely available for everyone. I wanted to say thank you to the entire mod team and everyone who's posted or commented so far.

This is OUR subreddit. This is our database for information we consider very valuable. I know you have a choice of several halfass, obnoxious subreddits full of pure garbage and shitty science. Thank you for choosing ours. But, it being OUR subreddit, I thought I would sticky a post here about what YOU want and don't want. I encourage anyone to post a few things you DO want to see, and a few things you DON'T. I, like you, am not at all concerned with the number of subscribers here, but only concerned with the quality of the posts. I like to think of this subreddit as growing a pot plant itself. And as we all know that takes time, adjustment, and patience to do properly.

I love the references to articles on very particular aspects of growing, i.e. lighting, curing, flushing. That is what I like to see that I think would get lost anywhere else. I think posts like these are the backbone of this subreddit.

I'm not sure about questions. What I don't want is this place to become a sort of call center for people too fucking lazy to google simple shit. I don't want to be shitty to people, but I do get frustrated when people ask things without researching themselves. Specific questions about deeper scientific concepts I think are cool. Something that maybe has conflicting opinions to start a good debate. But holy shit I loathe every single "is this ready yet growmies" post.

Also, very importantly, I just had to point out how impressive getting Dr. Bruce Bugbee to do an AMA for this subreddit is. I had literally nothing to do with it, so that shows you just how awesome the people involved are here.

This is a link to the thank you thread for the people who put it together.

And a link to the link to the link to the AMA

So let us know what sucks and what doesn't! Let's keep growing this plant!