r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 01 '13

part 1 of original lighting essay

7 Upvotes

This is part of the lighting guide

SAG's PLANT LIGHTING ARTICLE V2.0 (original essay)

Hey all,

I wanted to write this essay to help people understand lighting and how plants respond to light and to have something to link to. It's actually a very complex subject and a lot of honest mistakes are made including by people in the field of biology.

If you want a good primer on lighting theory in general I highly recommend this book. If you live near a larger university you might be able to pick up a copy in their book store at lower prices. By reading through this book, you'll have a solid foundation of lighting theory that most people interested in plant lighting lack.

1: Safety

2: Light Types

3: Light Intensity

4: Photosynthesis

5: Photomorphogenesis

6: Thermodynamics

1: SAFETY

Before any discussion we're going to talk electrical safety. I went through a 5 year union electrical apprenticeship program so I know what I'm talking about.

A 15 amp circuit with 14 gauge wire is only good for 12 amps continuous. This is 1440 watts at 120 volts. You should always derate your circuit by 20% as per the National Electrical Code for continuous loads. You should NEVER swap out a breaker with a higher value one thinking that you'll get more power out of a circuit. DON'T FUCKING DO THIS. A 20 amp circuit with 12 gauge wire is good for 16 amps continuous (1920 watts at 120 volts) and a 30 amp circuit with 10 gauge wire is good for 24 amps continuous ( 2880 watts at 120 volts). Also, circuit breakers are there to protect your property from fire or appliances damaging themselves, not to protect you from being severely shocked or electrocuted.

You can run two 600 watt HPS (11.4 amps with magnetic ballasts) and a smaller fan off a 15 amp circuit as long as there's no other load on the circuit. You need to have a 30 amp circuit or two 15 amp circuits to run two 1000 watt HPS safely on 120 volt circuits.

Lethal current starts in the 50-100 milliamp range across the chest. The “let go” current where you can't pull yourself off a circuit starts in the 20 milliamp range. This isn't going to trip a circuit breaker. A GFI (Ground Fault Interrupt also called GFCI for Ground Fault Circuit Interrupt) receptacle or GFI circuit breaker protects you from hurting yourself. They trip with an unbalanced load (when there's a ground fault) at around 5 milliamps. They work by monitoring the current in the hot and neutral wire. If this is unbalanced it means electricity is going directly to ground perhaps through your body. A GFI will save your life when working around a hydro set up with all that salt solution. How much is your life worth?

You can buy GFI power strips and cords if you don't want to wire in a GFI receptacle or install a GFI circuit breaker. Remember, they won't protect you if you're somehow energized between the hot and neutral wire. You'd have to be tinkering around with directly with live circuits for this to happen.

HID ballasts are designed for certain bulbs. Some digital ballasts can handle metal halide and high pressure sodium and some can also can multiple wattage bulbs. YOUR BALLAST MUST STATE THIS. I've read in other forums of people putting in different wattage bulbs than what the ballast was designed for and claim it works. I think these people are naĂŻve fools and just leave it at that. It doesn't matter how great of a grow op you have if there's a fire or an injury when dealing with any electrical aspect of your setup.

2: LIGHTING TYPES

High pressure sodium: the standard in HID (High Intensity Discharge) flowering. 3% blue light with higher green/amber. Comes in multiple sizes but 150 watts should be the smallest sized one should consider for a micro grow.

Metal halide: a HID lamp used for the vegetative state of a plant. The higher amounts of blue lights prevents stem elongation. I believe the 175 watt metal halide is the smallest common one used for growing.

CFL (Compact Fluorescent Lighting): very common in micro grows because they're so cheap and fairly efficient. 23 watt versions should be the smallest one used. Without a reflector, most of the light is wasted. We generally use a higher color temperature one for veging and a lower color temperature one for flowering.

LED (Light Emitting Diode): the future of grow lights. You must take all claims with grow light manufacturers at this point with a healthy dose of skepticism. I've been working with and have designed many LED grow lights for photomorphogenesis studies for years. I would never recommend them at this point in technology for flowering. A lot of people have been burned by the inflated claims made about LED grow lights. White LED spot lights, however, such as one's that can be bought at Home Depot, can put an intense amount of light on a plant due to their high luminaire efficieny. I use a 24 watt unit when I really want to drive a smaller plant to the saturation point in the veg stage.

T5: an efficient fluorescent tube that replaced the T12 for growing. Being a linear light source, they're well adapted to the screen of green growing (ScrOG) or low stress training (LST)technique.

Induction: A class of lighting that doesn't use electrodes thus prolonging the life of the bulb. They're rather pricey at this point. Some are just basically fluorescent tubes and some are plasma lamps. I have yet to read a study or seen an independent, fair grow comparison of these lamps compared to others. I would take any claims of them being X times better than HID lighting with a huge grain of salt.

I'm not aware of any other lighting type in common use. There's low pressure sodium which is actually more efficient than HPS and mercury vapor lamps which are less efficient than metal halide. Incandescent lamps are sometimes used as far red light sources. The U of WA plant growth lab uses incandescent lamps for this purpose in their $30,000 grow chambers. I'm sure halogens would work for this purpose also.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 01 '13

lighting thermodynamics

6 Upvotes

links to be added and expanded upon

6: THERMODYNAMICS

All lights produce heat. There's no such thing as a grow light that doesn't produce heat even if it were near 100% efficient (the photons themselves when absorbed and re-emitted will produce heat). THERE IS NO WAY AROUND THERMODYNAMICS. Most CFLs are close to 25-30% efficient or so; the rest is given off as heat. We can use air flow to rapidly remove heat off a light source. LEDs, being mounted to a heat sink, are very efficient at having their heat removed but this doesn't mean that they produce less heat. Wrap them in a blanket and see how hot they get- there's a good reason most of them have multiple fans. Rapid removal of heat is the key. I can blow air from a small fan directly on my 600 watt HPS bulb and that alone reduces my grow chamber temperature by 4 degrees F. Blow air on that HID bulb!


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 01 '13

photosynthesis

6 Upvotes

This is part of the light guide series

4: PHOTOSYNTHESIS

That's light intensity, we'll now move to photosynthesis and photosynthesis efficiency. The light that we're interested in for photosynthesis is about 400nm (UV-A) to 700nm (deep red) and is known as photosynthetically active radiation (PAR). It actually extends a little lower than 400nm but it's very inefficient.

The whole concept of photosynthesis that is relevant to the grower is a plant takes in water, carbon dioxide and light to make sugar and oxygen and is expressed in the simplified equation of 6 CO2 (six carbon dioxide molecules from the air) + 6 H2O (six water molecules from the roots) powered by light equals C6H12O6 (one sugar molecule that the plant uses for energy) + 6 O2 (6 oxygen molecules given off as a gas). It's all about making sugar which is transported through the plant via the phloem network. (It's important to note that the uptake of water and nutrients is via the xylem network from the roots and doesn't mean adding sugar to your soil is absorbed by the plant).

No fresh air means a low photosynthesis rate in a small volume since the carbon dioxide in the air is rapidly consumed unless CO2 enhancement is used such as a tank/regulator. Being in the same room with the plants will raise CO2 levels. A typical exhaled breath is 4500-5000 ppm CO2

THE DREADED CHARTS:

There's four charts that people often get confused: chlorophyll and other pigments dissolved in a solvent, leaf absorption, action spectra and quantum yield. If you're going off a chart that has sharp peaks and talk about very specific wavelengths needed for photosynthesis optimization, then you're probably using the wrong chart. This is the pigments dissolved in a solvent chart. Also, if you're using a chart with a really deep dip in the green/yellow/orange area then it's likely for algae or aquatic plants. This is the correct chart (PDF file chart C) for land plants and are the average of dozens of plants. The relative quantum yield chart is what we want to use since this is ultimately a measure of how much sugar is produced. Keep in mind that this is for monochromatic light only which below you'll see why is problematic and that these are relative charts and not absolute charts.

LED grow light manufactures tend to use the solvent absorption charts which are wildly off in the green/yellow/orange area to boost their claims of very high yields per watt. It's all BS. This forum gets spammed a few times per month by LED grow light manufacturers or related people. Look at the spectrum of HPS vs quantum yield charts and you'll see that it has a very high efficiency and not the 10% ballpark efficiency that is often claimed. A 600 and 1000 watt SunMaster HPS put out 215 and 358 PAR watts perspectively. This is 35.8% PAR efficient so its 31.5 % efficient with at a .87 magnetic ballast loss and 33.2% with at a .93 digital ballast loss.

Some commercially available LEDs have surpassed this number and lab samples exist that are much higher. But, if you go in to Home Depot and check out their white LED lights they're less efficient than CFL at the time of this writing (but the LED spot lights have the advantage of luminaire efficiency which for our purposes is how much light out of the light source is coupled to the plant. A CFL without a reflector or close by reflective surface above a plant would have a very low luminaire efficiency since there's a lot of wasted light).

Although red light is generally most efficient in photosynthesis, one thing that a lot of people don't understand is that green light is also actively used in photosynthesis. In fact, with a bright white light source it can be the case that adding more green rather than red or blue is how to increase photosynthesis efficiency since green can reach in to deeper chloroplasts in the leaves. The green light absorption in healthy, high nitrogen level pot leaves is in the 85-87% ballpark as can be seen in this shot of a couple of pot leaves on a 18% gray card (gray card reflects 18%, absorbs 82%) with the camera's sensor balanced to the top bounce, diffused light source. You can analyze the levels in different parts of the pic in Photoshop.

I've always found it odd that people would say that plants don't use green light or that leaves somehow reflect all green light. They generally reflect a little more green light than red or blue. That's it. An extreme case would be iceberg lettuce which absorbs around 50%. A healthy Douglas-fir tree is closer to 90% (the source is the “green rather than red or blue” research paper link just above).

Don't forget side lighting or intracanopy lighting as a strategy if one wants to boost yield per area or volume.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 01 '13

photomorphogenesis part 2

6 Upvotes

This is part of the lighting guide series

GREEN LIGHT

Green, to include yellow and amber, is the opposite of blue for most light sensitive protein reactions. Quite a few papers will include 500nm-600nm as green light. A lot of plants can not grow well at the seedling stage with green or green/red only (like basil) while others will thrive such as dwarf pea (the one on the right is pure green). Green can cause stem elongation greater than darkness in some plants and one would never normally consider growing under a pure green light source in the veg stage.

The flowering stage is where green/yellow/amber has a huge advantage. As mentioned above, green increases the amounts of auxins, which increases cellular expansion, and works in concert with another class of hormone that comes from the roots called cytokinins which helps with cellular division. We like this for flowering.

RED LIGHT

I think of red light as the main photosynthesis driver. Red is used in photoperiodism and helps regulate the circadian rhythm in plants. As far as influencing the shape of the plant, red has much less of an effect compared to blue light. It's mainly the red/far red ratio that has an influence in plant FAR RED LIGHT

Far red, as far as we're concerned (and perhaps being over simplified here), is in the 700nm to 750nm ball park. Far red in many plants will cause elongation . When ever I [light profile a plant]( (this is one of multiple stations) I always see the effect of a plant with and without far red light. In some cases, such as in radish, far red can increase growth rate. I've noticed no real effect on pot one way or the other.

ULTRAVIOLET

I really don't have a lot of experience here. It could be the case that UV-B stimulates THC production. There are a couple papers that might support this but I'd take it all with a grain of salt until more testing was done. UV-A can act like blue light in some plants.

LOW LIGHT

Auxin levels are also high at low light levels which is why plants stretch in lower light levels as per the acid growth hypothesis. Remember, there's a difference between growth as it applies to cellular elongation and growth as it applies to yield by the accumulation of sugar through photosynthesis. You can use red light to prevent stretching but blue light, particularly in the 450-470nm ballpark, has a much greater efficiency at reducing stem elongation. If you want to keep your plant alive on vacation, for example, use low levels of pure blue light to keep water uptake low and streching at a minimum. Pure 450nm blue light sources can be bought at Home Depot which can be used or modified to use various reflectors.

PHOTOPERIODISM

Most marijuana strains are a short day plant. This means it must have a certain amount of darkness to flower. We generally run a 12 hour lights on, 12 hour lights off cycle. It is possible in some strains to run as high as 14 hours of lights on, 10 hours off but this will delay flowering and you really don't gain anything in yield over time. There's also people who have played with 6 hours on, 12 hours off but I see no advantage in this since yield will be lower. Most experienced growers are just going to tell you 12/12.

A few years back some one cross bred a ruderalis strain with an indica and created a new strain call Lowryder (I think the breeder's name was Joint Doctor). This and its descendants started a new class of pot called the autoflower. You typically just run the plant at 18 hours though out its life cycle and is a day neutral plant. The disadvantage of an autoflowering plant is establishing a mother plant so you either buy seeds or seed out your own plants.

I've worked with a very wide variety of plants. I can honestly say I've never seen any harmful effects or plant stress by running veging plants in a 24 hour lighting on cycle. The advantage of doing so is the lack of additional elongation from having 6 hours of darkness, for example. Typically, after 15 minutes or so of darkness, the low light behavior kicks in so if you want your plants as compact as possible run them at 24 hours. I understand that some people may have strong differing views so you should take my 24 hour recommendation as an opinion.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 01 '13

how to build a simple light meter

6 Upvotes

This is part of the lighting guide series

How to build a simple light meter part 1 by SAG

This is being thrown in the lighting guide and will discuss how to build a very low cost light meter using a solar cell and a multi-meter. You'll gain a lot of insight in to lighting by playing around with a light meter including the lighting levels with and without a reflector, the affects of different reflective material on the walls of your grow op, optimize how far the lights are from the plants and the like.

This mini article assumes that you've read the light intensity part of the lighting guide.

You can get solar cells in the solar powered garden lights that have recently become popular. They're $3 each at Home Depot. The solar cells will be ran in photoconductive mode. This is very important, you want to measure the current of the solar cell and NOT the voltage. In photoconductive mode, a solar cell will give a linear current reading to within 1% over 7-9 orders of magnitude. If you read the voltage you'll get a nonlinear response to light intensity with a multimeter. Don't bother spending a lot of money on a multimeter and it's best to use a digital one. Essentially, you're just shorting the solar cell in to the shunt resistor in the multimeter. You can easily convert the linear current to a linear voltage using an op amp from Radio Shack which will be covered in part 2 for direct uM measurements, hook up to a microcontroller and the like.

Strip out the electronics of the solar garden light until you have nothing left but the case with solar cell and solar cell wires. Now all you have to do is hook it up to your multimeter and read the current. It's really best to put some sort of strain relief with another wire. I prefer at least a 3 feet wire so I can use the solar cell remotely from the meter. You can just twist the wires and tape them but soldering is always best. Notice the knot in the wire that acts as a strain relief. A small grommet or piece of heat shrink tubing can also be used to protect the wire at the entrance point to the solar cell module.

I've measured multiple 2700K 23 watt CFLs from 3 different manufacturers with my quantum light meter. The 50uM point is about 8 inches when measured on the side of the CFL after a 10 minute warm up for a close enough absolute calibration. edit- see comments below. Even if you can't make absolute measurements you can still make highly accurate relative measurements with any lighting source. A reading of 4 milliamps (4mA) means twice as much light as 2 milliamps (2mA) regardless of light source as long as it's the same type of light source, for example. Most solar cells will be roughly twice as red light sensitive as blue light sensitive so don't expect accurate absolute measurements with a 6500K bulb, for example, when calibrated to a 2700K light source.

Also, don't assume that just because you can make accurate absolute 2700k CFL measurements that you can make accurate absolute HPS measurements. I found that with some solar cells, such as the ones I bought at Home Depot, that they read HPS (2100k) about 1.45 times too high than expected. Some I picked up at Walmart did give accurate enough absolute measurements for HPS when calibrated for 2700k. This most likely means that the Home Depot solar cells were doped (had impurities added) that made them more green light sensitive.

Being a flat sensor with a large surface area, a solar cell is inherently close to being cosine correct. On most light meters you'll see these white semi-spheres. This is to broaden the acceptance angle of the sensor of the light meter. If you measure a light strait on you should get a 100% reading. Measure to a right angle (90 degree) and you should get a 0% reading in an ideal situation. Measure at a 45 degree angle and you should get a .707% reading since cos(45)=.707. Generally speaking, all light meters strive to get as close to cosine correct as possible.

You typically want the light meter pointing strait up when taking a reading but this can depend on how your plants are oriented to the light source. In a screen of green grow you will want to take your measurements with the solar cell pointed straight up regardless where the light source is. As a side note, the refractive index of a typical leaf is about 1.4-1.55 which is higher than water of 1.33 or air of 1. This basically has the effect of “bending” the light at a steeper angle in to the leaf tissue.

You can also combine solar cells. For example, here's a 5 directional sensor head that can be used for reflective light measurements or be used for measuring light reflectors with CFLs. You want to wire the cells in parallel and they should be closely matched if you do this.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 01 '13

photomorphogenesis part 1

9 Upvotes

This is part of the lighting guide series

5: PHOTOMORPHOGENESIS

Notice how I didn't use any specific lighting wavelengths when talking about photosynthesis beyond mentioned PAR wavelengths? That's because there's little difference between 630nm red and 660nm red or 450nm and 470nm blue, for example, although red and red/orange are most efficient. It's a whole different game when we add photomorphogenesis to the equation. This means photo (light) morpho (shape) genesis (life) or how a plant responds to light and different wavelengths of light and is a very complex subject because we're dealing with light sensitive proteins and protein pathways. It's about how light defines the shape of the plant but I'll be using the term more broadly to include total plant development all the way through flowering. I'll call it PMG from here on.

There are three main protein groups (bear with me here) involved with PMG although plants can have over 1000 light sensitive proteins (arabidopsis, kind of a small “lab rat” plant in the mustard family, has close to 1400). The three main groups are the cryptochromes, the phototropins and the phytochromes. A lot of people assume the red is the opposite of blue for PMG responses. In reality for PMG responses in plants, green is the opposite of blue and far red is the opposite of red although there are some blue sensitive proteins that are green and red reversible (source: discussions with the head of the U of WA plant growth lab). I'm going to focus on the practical aspects of different spectra of light for the pot grower rather than ramble on about specific proteins and loose the audience.

BLUE LIGHT

Blue light can have a radical affect on plant growth. In my own plant light profiling experience, at least some blue light is needed is for early plant survival. It tends to reduce cellular expansion as part of the acid growth hypothesis (PDF file) by reducing auxin levels. This is why we use CFLs with a higher color temperature for veging- the higher amounts of blue relative to green help keeps the stems from elongating by reducing cellular expansion in the stem. A lower color temperature has a higher green to blue ratio which boosts cellular expansion in flowers and the higher amounts of auxins are also important in the biosynthesis of ethylene in plants which plays a role in ripening so we use it for flowering. A HPS light has about 3% blue light with high amounts of green/yellow light so it's great for flowering. I do, however, know some co-op growers that veg under HPS but I would personally recommend against this for micro grows due to elongation issues.

Check out this Big Bud. It's been hit for 7 days with 1000uM of 450nm blue light. Under white light, 1000uM would give a very high growth rate but there's been almost no new growth in the past week. According to the photosynthesis charts this shouldn't be the case. What's going on? As mentioned, blue light suppresses auxins and at this point suppression happens to the point where the plant basically doesn't grow. Notice how the leaves curl up? This is because of unequal cellular expansion. So it's also important to know what the lighting levels are of these photosynthesis charts are at (I'm not sure off the top of my head). This is an example of why I make the claim that when PMG is factored in, things become much more complex. This is also a good example of what a stressed plant looks like.

Notice some burning in the above plant? Blue light is more likely to burn leaf tissue than red light because blue photons have more energy than red photons and thus more heat to dump from the plant tissue. A 450nm photo has an energy of 2.75eV (electron volts) while a 660nm photon has an energy of 1.87eV (take 1240, divide it by the wavelength and this is how you tell the energy of a photon. It's also why blue LEDs have a larger voltage drop than red LEDs). So this blue photon has 47% more energy than the red one. Once a photon is absorbed by the plant, it doesn't matter what the wavelength is (there is a minimum energy needed to power light dependent reactions ). According to the 1st LAW of Thermodynamics, this excess energy has to go some where. Heat is the lowest form of energy and so this extra energy of blue photons is dumped as extra heat in the plant tissue.

Anyone ever try flowering under an early blue/red only LED grow light? How'd that go for you? Lower yields and longer flowering time. NASA used red/blue mainly for wheat and corn in protein production studies in hypothetical space travel research. People just sort of jumped on that bandwagon a few years back and a lot of people got burned with an overpriced, under performing product. Good for veging perhaps, not good for flowering. With sweet corn I found blue/orange might give better yields than blue/red. Remember, all these action spectra/yield charts are for monochromatic light only and don't necessarily take high lighting levels into account. You start light mixing and different protein pathways are being triggered in addition to certain proteins/pathways being triggered at high or low lighting levels in general.

Using a blue spot light with HPS for the first week of flowering can allow you to design a plant with very short internodes as can be seen with this LST Big Bud top and side.

The warped leaves that you might see with red/blue only LED lights is because the leaf veins are expanding at a different rate than the rest of the leaf tissue. A little green light added usually corrects this.

Some plants that naturally have high auxin levels, such as pole beans, can have their internodes reduced by over 95% by high amounts of blue light. It's possible in theory and practice to have a full yielding 8 inch tall pole bean plant that produces 7 inch beans with proper training and blue light use. An odd thing about pole beans is that their tendrils are blue light insensitivity so you have to use thigmomorphogenesis (touch instead of light) techniques to keep them from elongating. Another odd thing about the Kentucky Wonder pole bean is 405nm light reduces stem elongation like blue in the stem before the first set of leaves but causes elongation like green after the first set of leaves. I've asked a number of scientists about this and they just shrug and say “different protein pathways”.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 01 '13

plant lighting intensity

9 Upvotes

This is part of the lighting guide series


3: LIGHT INTENSITY

In photobiology the only unit of measurement currently used is uMol/m2/sec. It's often written micromoles s-1 m-2 or something close. It's the same thing. What it means is the equivalent of micromoles of photons falling in a one square meter area per second. A “mole” is Avogadro's constant we learned about in high school chemistry so one micromole of photons is 6.02 *1017 photons. It's a measurement of a quantum which is why plant light meters are called quantum meters. For here on for brevity, I'm just going to call this unit a uM (this unit of light is also called a uE for “micro Einstein” but this term isn't used anymore in photobiology).

TO MAKE IT EASY:

  • Full sunlight: 2000-2200uM It makes no sense to run plants at this level and it will reduce your yield.

  • Most plants saturation point: 1000-1200uM The saturation point is the lighting level where you just can't get anymore growth rate without adding CO2. A lot of this has to do with the effects of photo-respiration at higher lighting levels. If you just want high yield per area or volume without consideration of wattage, you should run you plants at this level. You want to completely blast PC case style or other stealthy, smaller micro grows at this level if you just want as much pot as possible. I run plants around this level in flowering with CO2 enhancement.

  • Most plants optimal point : 500uM Want high yields per watts claim? Run your plants at or below this level. Above about 500uM, plants start becoming CO2 limited in their growth rate but if you want good, tight nuggets this should be their minimum lighting level. This is why you need to use reflectors with CFL. Between about 50uM and 500uM the growth rate is linear with lighting levels. From 500um to 1000uM it's a compressed curve.

  • Most plants compensation point: around 30uM (I don't know the exact number for pot) This is a minimal lighting point needed for growth. “House plants” have a much lower compensation point which is why they're able to survive at normal household lighting levels.


LIGHT METERS:

Light meters that measure in lumens or lux tend to use a sensor (gallium arsenide phosphide photo diode) that have a spectral sensitivity response that is close to the human eye (posted under “fair use” for discussion proposes from the above book). Low end quantum meters in the $200-300 range use a different type of the above diode that is more appropriate for plant sensitivity. Low end quantum meters are also rather insensitive to red beyond about 640nm or so and they will give very low readings for 660nm LEDs. The lowest cost plant light meter that gives accurate enough for scientific proposes readings for plant purposes is in the $500 range and the portable Licor quantum light meter, the scientific standard, is about $800. Beyond this you need a spectrometer. I use the Green Wave spectrometer from StellerNet which was $2,700 with a few lenses, fiber optic cable and NIST tracable calibration.

All light meters, regardless of type, can give accurate relative readings as long as it's the same lighting source so don't go throwing away your $80 light meter that makes measurements in other than uM. A simple solar cell picked up at Home Depot or Walmart in those cheap solar powered garden lights can give accurate relative readings when ran in linear photoconductive mode with a multimeter (shorted out in to a multimeter and read the milliamperage, this will be the separate post).

If you want to make meaningful measurements between two different light sources then the $500 and above light meters are needed because they give a flat spectral response rather than the red peaked, lower blue sensitivity response of low end quantum light meters or strongly green peaked lumem/lux light meters. A lumens/lux meter can give quite different measurements for an LED grow light since most are heavy red/blue, than a CFL, induction, HID and the like which has higher green/yellow and should never be used as a meter in grow comparisons.


INVERSE SQUARE LAW:

A last point I want to make on light intensity is the concept that light falls off at the square of the distance also known as the inverse square law. At twice the distance one should have 1/4 the lighting, at 3 times the distance one should have 1/9 the lighting etc. This isn't exactly true when taking measurements close to a light source particularly when reflectors are involved. The general rule of thumb is that this hold true at a distance of 5 times and beyond the physical size of the light source.

I just took some side measurements of a bare 2700K, 26 watt CFL after a 5 minute warm up. At 1 inch it was 834uM. At 2 inches it was 420uM (half the light, should have been one quarter under inverse square law rule). At ten inches it was 30uM. That's almost 4 times higher at 10 inches than it should have been under inverse square law rule. Up close, the inverse square law only holds true for a theoretical point light source and not the light sources that we as growers use (CFL, HPS and the like). A LED is much closer to a point light source but still, up very close keep in mind that the inverse square law doesn't hold true- a measurement at 1mm isn't going to be a million times higher that one taken at 1000 mm.

The concept of “light penetration” has a lot to do with the inverse square law. LEDs, for example, that have a 130 degree beam angle would have much less penetration than one in the 45-60 degree range.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 01 '13

small light reflector comparison

9 Upvotes

This is part if the lighting guide series

Small Lighting Reflector Comparison (<30 watts)

TL;DR if you're not using some kind of reflector with your lights, particularly CFLs, then you're loosing half or more of the photon flux density (light intensity) on your plants and thus you'll be getting proportionally lower yields.

This mini article assumes that you've read the light intensity section of the lighting guide. To test lights or design reflectors yourself you can build a cheap light meter.

A closely matched, 5 sensor cosine correct apparatus was used without side reflectors with measurements taken with a NIST traceable Fluke 287 multimeter. Most of the testing was done with the same GE 26 watt 2700K CFL that has a few hundred hours on it.

The first test was on a CFL with no reflector in a horizontal position. The CFL is about 2 inches off the middle sensor with is about the 500uM mark. This is used as a relative baseline. All testing was done with the center sensor at the 500uM point except with the 8 inch reflector (see below). It's important to note that all testing was done in a fairly dark room and that I'm using both a top bounce external flash (bouncing the light off my ceiling) and setting my camera for best viewing of the test set up.

An important tip about reflectors- if you get down on the level of the light/reflector and can actually see the bulb then it's an inefficient reflector. The common 8 inch reflector has a 2 inch focal point (measured) since it's a hybrid parabolic, which focuses to a point, and a half spherical reflector, which focuses to a line. Most CFL are used with these reflectors are outside of the focal point and the larger the lamp the more inefficient these reflectors become. Incandescent bulbs, which would never be used in plant growing (the U of WA plant growth lab does use them in their $30,000 grow chambers as a far red light source) does fit in this focal area and these 8 inch reflectors were design for that. You'll see below that they're still very efficient for small CFL regardless.

Horizontal no reflector 3.71

Horizontal Mylar back reflector 5.5

Horizontal with cheap reflector 7.38

Vertical no reflector 4.6

Vertical with 5 inch reflector 6

Vertical with 8 inch reflector 8.66

White LED spot light 8.1 watts 3.1 (9.5 normalized) (the one on the right was used)

White LED flood 9.3 watts 3.8 (10.1 normalized)

White LED flood 16.8 watts 5.9 (8.7 normalized)

The numbers are relative; the higher the better. The LEDs were shown real numbers and when their lower wattage is taken in to account being normalized to the power of the CFL used.

So, what does the above show us? First, you're wasting a lot of light if you're not using a reflector. This applies even if the lights are in a reflective grow chamber. Second, although the LEDs may have about the same electrical efficiency as CFL, they're still more efficient since the light since the light is being shown in one direction.

The vertical 8 inch reflector was at the 1000uM point rather than the 500uM point since at this level higher level they'll be a greater efficiency since so much light is focused to a rough point. About 5 ½ inches away is the 1000uM level, being off center a little will drastically reduce this level. In other words, the light distribution is highly nonlinear and localized. This is great for blasting a cola but not necessarily the best choice for a micro garden overall.

The best reflector design is the simple aluminum foil reflector design that gives even lighting. You want to be about 3 inches away and LST or ScrOG you plants. Notice that I'm using an adapter and not wrapping the ballast with tape.

Here's how to safely use an adapter so it doesn't pop out and offers extra insulation. First, use a few pieces of tape for mechanical support and to insure that the electrified prongs are covered. Next, put a few wraps of tape around the adapter to create a tight coupling between the adapter and what you're plugging it in to (which could be a power strip). A little more electrical tape near the bulb will ensure the aluminum reflector has no chance to touch any metal parts inside the adapter. It's easy to see how much more light you're getting by using this simple reflector.

Using fluorescent long tubes? Same thing, a simple aluminum foil reflector can double the amount of light on your plants vs not using one.

Want a good quad design? This is an example of a bad design (edit-now a dead link but it really sucked). If you get down on the level of the light and can see the bulbs then it's a bad design. Here is an example of an efficient quad design as can be seen in this chamber shot. Laugh all you want with how ghetto it looks- it delivers the results.

To hit the 500-600uM point with CFL, it takes about 100 watts per square foot with reflectors. So keep in mind, if you're not using proper reflectors with CFLs then you're basically cutting your yield potential in half.

edit- use Scotch Super 33+ tape! It uses a glue that is designed for higher temperatures. Cheap electrical tape has a habit of coming undone at higher temperatures.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 01 '13

Chaotic and dynamic systems links

9 Upvotes

This is an easy way to find my chaotic and dynamic systems posts. It will be greatly expanded.

analog robotics primer

simple balancing robot mentioned on HackaDay with schematics found here

chaotic tone generator for Arduino

Suggested reading

The Craft of Research, Third Edition (Chicago Guides to Writing, Editing, and Publishing) Every student should read this book no matter what their field. It's more than just how to write papers, it's a book on critical thinking skills.

Chaos: Making a New Science This is a popular level book on chaos theory that requires no math ground background. A classic.

Sync: How Order Emerges From Chaos In the Universe, Nature, and Daily Life Another popular level book with no math.

Chaos Theory Tamed Every scientist and engineer or student should read this book. It deals with discrete systems so no calculus background is required. Most all the math needed is taught in the beginning. You have to know trig, though, and the last few chapters can be daunting. This is one of those books that was a real eye opener of how the world works.

Chaos and Nonlinear Dynamics: An Introduction For Scientists and Engineers You have to know calculus for this book.

The Computational Brain (Computational Neuroscience) A very in depth book with very little math yet still explains how different types of neural networks function.

Introduction to the Math of Neural Networks Short and to the point. No calculus but not all types of neural networks are covered.

Introduction To The Theory Of Neural Computation, Volume I (Santa Fe Institute Series). This is a classic. You want to know the complete math behind different types of neural networks? Buy this book. Some calculus and not all modern neural network techniques are covered.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 01 '13

Color temperature basics

12 Upvotes

update: 18feb2018

This is part of the lighting guide series.

Color Temperature: Basic

This is another installment of the lighting guide and there will be more to come; it's only about half finished. Consider this a rough draft and after I get some feedback from beginners I'll make changes as needed to make things clearer if needed. Constructive criticism is welcomed and helps me write better guides.

There are five major points to consider when it comes to lighting:

light quantity which has already been covered in the light intensity section and using a cheap lux meter section

light quality which has been somewhat covered but will go in to some more detail here

light period known as photoperiodism. 18/6 means 18 hours on and 6 hours off, for example. I always run plants at 24/0 during veging but that's opinion. We run marijuana plants 12/12 during flowering since it's a short day plant

Light placement which will be covered in another mini article and has to do with optimizing effective leaf area index and intracanopy lighting to boost yields above normal.

lighting reflectors, both on the light and as a side reflective material, which has partially been covered but more will be added.

Color temperature originally derives from how hot a black body radiation source gets expressed in degrees Kelvin which is that same a Celsius +273. That why color temperature numbers always have a “K” after them like 2700K. The surface of the sun has a temperature of about 5800 degrees Kelvin which we consider “daylight neutral”. Of course, the lights that we work with don't actually get that hot (HPS may be 750 degrees F, CFLs are typically below 200 degrees F) so the proper term to describe color in artificial white light source is correlated color temperature which is the equivalent perceived color temperature.

Color temperature for common lights used in growing range from a orange HPS at 2100K, warm yellowish CFL at 2700K, white metal halides at 4200K (although there are other MH temps), white daylight neutral CFL at around 5500K and blueish cool CFLs at 6500K. 3500K is a good compromise if you need an all in one light for veging and flowering.

I generally recommend warm white for LED strips since the green light component does drive photosynthesis better at high lighting levels. A lower CRI will also have more of a green light component even at the same LED color temperature. CRI will be discussed in detail when I write about basic white light theory.

Why is there no green hot? Because our eyes have a very effective automatic white balance like a digital camera and by the time an object is hot enough either temperature wise or correlated color temperature wise to have a green peak it'll also have blue light in it and because of our eyes chromatic adaption), we will perceive the light as white instead of green. This blue light addition with true black body radiation sources is due to Wien's displacement law. Look at that graph in the wiki link and you can see that all white light sources have at least some blue in it. If the light source does not have red, green and blue elements to it, then it's not a white light source.

The optimal color temperature for plants depends on the specific plant, the stage of a plant's life cycle and the light intensity. The only compelling reason to use the higher color temperature during veging has to do with stem elongation. Some sources will claim that higher color temperature will help a plant bush out or something; in my experience this is not the case. You can actually help prevent excess elongation by using 5000-6500K bulbs during the first two weeks of flowering. However, light intensity also plays a major role in controlling stem elongation. I bought a 150 watt HPS specifically to determine what lighting levels for good vegetation are needed and around 500uMol/m2/sec (about 40,000 lux) will keep a plant compact with very vigorous vegetative growth. Here is a picture of a newer Jack Herer mother grown under HPS and you can see that it's a quite healthy, compact plant.

So, although there is a good rule of thumb of using higher color temperature lights during veging, a more accurate rule of thumb is that the lower the lighting levels the higher the color temperature needs to be during veging to prevent excess elongation. Remember, blue suppresses auxins and auxins are what cause elongation in the stem as per acid growth hypothesis (explained elsewhere in the lighting guide).

For flowering, the rule of thumb is to use lower color temperature lights to promote auxins. But as mentioned, higher color temperature during the first two weeks will help keep a plant more compact. This LST plant was grown under HPS but for the first two weeks a blue LED spot light modified from Home Depot was also used to raise color temperature and one can see the results. I'm a huge fan of using some additional blue light in the first two weeks and it will increase your yield per volume when done properly.

Remember, "warmer lights" have a lower color temperature with more red light, or, in the case of high pressure sodium, more amber light. "Cooler lights" have a higher color temperature (I know, seems backwards) and has more blue light.

So, this covers the basics. In the advanced version we'll discuss how not all color temperature is the same and how a 2700K LED can give different results than 2700K CFL with spectrometer pics to illustrate why. We'll go over some charts, go over chromaticity and talk about some particular plant proteins. The “blue wall” and the “red wall” concept in photobiology will also be articulated.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 13 '13

Space Bucket Electrical Safety Tips (posted to /r/SpaceBuckets)

13 Upvotes

This was posted to /r/SpaceBuckets

Space Bucket Electrical Safety Tips

As a (former) electrician for 10 years who went through a 5 year union apprenticeship program and a hardcore electronics geek, I want to give a few safety tips because I've seen some stuff that's got my spider-sense tingling. Everything is done at your own risk and liability. I just want to minimize that risk. I can add more pictures if needed- just let me know.

1- USE GCFI PROTECTION! That's Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter. You have electricity and a lot of moisture. That could be a bad combination. GFCI protects you from ground path faults. In other words, it prevents serious shocks from the wall power supply, through your body and to ground. Literally, this means a ground path to earth itself or a ground path to an object at ground potential. Twice I've had GFCI protect me from being severely shocked. You'll still fell a slight tingle but that's it. No dying, though. How cool is that!

GFCI does not protect you from hot and neutral wire shocks because it only shuts the circuit off if there's a current imbalance between the hot and neutral wire. If there is, it means current is going to ground when it's not supposed to. That's bad- it could be going through your flailing and thrashing body. A GFCI circuit does not require a ground wire to work.

GFCI can be found in breakers, receptacles, power strips or adapters How much is your life worth?

2-ALL LIGHTING SOCKETS NEED TO BE WIRED CORRECTLY! I don't care if it is just two wires. One is the hot (black) and one is the neutral (white). (note- if you have a brown and blue wire, it's almost always the case that the brown is the hot and the blue is the neutral. You'll see this in some appliances and extension cords depending where you live in the world). If the socket has pig tails (it's own wire sticking out), it's always hot wire to socket black wire and the neutral wire to the socket white wire. NO EXCEPTIONS! If there's screws instead of wires, the brass/gold colored one is for the hot wire and the silver colored one for the neutral wire (more below on this).

Why is this so important? Because when you screw in a bulb there might be a little metal exposed at the bulb's base. Wired backwards and you have an energized metal part exposed (bad). Wired correctly and you have a exposed metal part at ground potential (better). Wrap any exposed with a little tape and you have very good.

3- SPLICE WIRES CORRECTLY! With Space Buckets you're going to run in to situations where a junction box may not be able to be used so here's some open air splicing tips. If you can pull the wires apart then you have a bad splice. The preferred way is using wire nuts. Strip your wires 5/8ths of an inch, put them in the opening and twist until you can't anymore. There's a spring inside that tightens the wires together. It's not necessary to twist the wires first. You should, however, tug on each wire to make sure it's well connected after the wire nut is twisted on.

The second way is a butt splice (hehehe...he said butt. I will always be a Beavis and Butthead fan). They’re sometimes called splice crimps. Strip wires, stick them in and use pliers to crimp the aluminum tube inside as hard as possible. There are special pliers for this but any pliers can do. Again, tug on the wires to make sure they're secure.

The third way is tape and solder. Twist the wires in a rat-tail splice, solder them up and use a higher quality electrical tape preferable Scotch Super 33+ to wrap them up. 33+ has an adhesive that hold under a wide range of temperature and humidity. Look at the reviews. I only use low quality electrical tape for temporary stuff. Everything else it's 33+. Low quality electrical tape has a bad habit of becoming undone at higher temperatures and humidity.

Twist and tape alone is strongly not recommend for line voltage splicing. The same with a western union splice or a T-splice unless tape and solder is also used. Be generous with the tape and tape it tight.

4-SECURE THOSE WIRES! This means additional stain relief and to preferably use tie wraps to secure the wire tot the bucket's lid. Drill 2 small holes just big enough for the tie wrap and secure the wire to the lid that way. Sticky backs can also be used. Use some 5 minute epoxy if needed to secure the sticky back.

5-IF USING FOIL AS A REFLCTOR, IT'S A GOOD IDEA TO GROUND IT. With three conducts you'll typically have a black, white and green (or brown, blue, green or green with a yellow stripe depending where you live). That green wire is your grounding wire. Metal parts should be bonded to this green wire (intracanopy LEDs on their own, isolated low voltage power supply don't need to be grounded). You can use like a screw/nut/washer through the bucket side, through the foil and put the green wire under the washer preferably with a fork terminal stake on. If you're connecting wires to a light socket with the gold/silver screws mention above, this is the preferable way to connect the wires. Put tape over the screws with some 5 minute epoxy to make sure the tape stays in place.

The best inside the bucket reflector is flat white paint with barium sulfate added. It'll be in the high 90% range.

6-WET CONCRETE FLOORS ARE A BAD PLACE FOR A SET UP! Get them off the floor and get yourself off the floor. It's just another safety thing to keep in mind. Wet concrete has a bad habit of conducting electricity. Play it safe and think of wet concrete as standing in a mud puddle from an electrical safety stand point. This is why it's a good idea to have GFCI protection in garages.

7-PUSH THOSE PRONGS TOGETHER! Check this picture out from another subreddit. Know what the problem was? The neutral wire slot was just a bit too wide so there wasn't a snug fit. Even it everything feels snug, it may actually be 1 or 2 out of 3 that are snug. Loose connections means fire. Fire is bad (in this case, otherwise fire is your friend, but I digress...) Push the male prongs together to the point that you have to do a little wiggling to plug something in. This is really more critical wire higher current loads like electric space heaters, HPS lighting and the like but a good habit to get in to.

8-NO LINE VOLTAGE AT CANOPY LEVEL! If you use LED intracanopy lighting, use a lower voltage to drive them. I'll be showing multiple ways on how to do this in my lighting guide for people of different skill levels. I'll also be showing a safe exception to this rule.

9-USE THE CORRECT WIRE! 24 gauge telephone wire is not to be used for line voltage wiring. Ask if you're unsure.

Well, that pretty much covers it. There's other things like line voltage isolation transformers but I don't think they're needed and they're damn heavy. But, if I left anything out, post it!


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 02 '13

Selective light training primer

20 Upvotes

part of SAG's Plant Lighting Guide

EDIT 29jun2018- the patent is going to be granted for my work on the stem only which is the most important aspect of Selective Light Training.

This can be used with any type off light source for any propose including genetically modified organism research, protein research, bonsai trees, industrial scale agriculture for early stage plant growth such as apple/citrus/coffee/tea tree nurseries, etc. For industrial scale use, SLT only needs to be used in the early stage of a plant's life to get the benefits of early stage stem elongation reduction. This could allow for more productive root stocks to be used or to research on corn varieties which of course you wouldn't use in the field, just to research the protein signal transduction pathways involved in optimizing its growth. Blue on the stem of one sweet corn variety caused early flowering.

I've been researching this for about 5 years now and enough information is provided here to build a set for non-commercial use. When the pending application is published you'd have this information regardless.

SLT (selective light training) is about hitting certain parts of a plant with light for the purpose of light sensitive protein manipulation and their cascade affects through signal transduction pathways. A typical plant will have in excess of 1,000 light sensitive plant proteins. The phot1 and phot2 phototropin proteins are what's likely being manipulated with blue light. Blue causes plant cells to not elongate (as much) so hitting the stem with blue gives a more compact plant. Minus blue light can cause plant cells, such as found in leaves, to greatly expand. The problem is that with a minus blue only light source you'll also get massive stem elongation or some plants like sweet basil might not grow at all. With selective light training you get the best of both worlds with something that will be low cost to mass produce.

For use on stems, as shown in this young Jack Herer plant, with small LED arrays, you have to get the blue LED array up close to the stem with uninterrupted light. That why I use 20x55 degree oval LEDs. 20 degrees side to side allows a little aiming slop and the 55 degrees vertical insures light overlap. The LEDs can be found here. Use model number 725LB7C. These are cheap Chinese LEDs so you need to under drive them to around 10 milliamps. Putting 3 in series with a 330 ohm resistor and building an linear array allows one to use an unregulated, 12 volt power supply. All of this is to keep costs down (those LEDs are about 3 cents each out of China in quantity). I've never seen one of these blue LEDs burn out at the lower current levels. Here's a close up of how the light sticks look and even closer showing the epoxy encapsulation. No, Christmas tree lights won't work. You need a certain intensity which is why the LEDs are so close together and a specific beam width is used.

With blue light blasting the stem only, other wavelengths of light can be used on the different parts of the plant. Here's an example of sweet basil with blue on the stem and amber on the leaves which can be done in a green house with amber or minus blue filters (full sunlight also means less growth due to photorespiration. That's why shade cloths are often used). The leaves are 4 times larger than normal (that's a pic of a pic. Some files were lost) in a shorter plant. Here's an 8 inch tall pole bean that would normally be 8 feet tall and what the internodes look like. And a jalapeno pepper plant showing many more peppers per volume than otherwise possible. It's easy to test this for yourself.

Not all plants react the same and it is strain specific (sweet basil, lettuce leaf basil and purple basil react differently). Here's a mystery skunk giving to me where I can get 4-5 internodes per inch, even at lower main lighting levels. The red is anthocyanin build up, not a nutrient deficiency. Excess stem elongation is a thing of the past with most plants using this technique and you will get more growth per area or volume. For short day plants, use the light sticks for veg growth and the first two weeks of flowering only. Here's an example of using the light sticks with intracanopy lighting. Notice the fan. Here's what it looks like about with 3 weeks to go also using intracanopy lighting. I've hit 3.4 ounes per square foot equivalent (this is 2/3rds of a square foot) in soil with this plant but while also using intracanopy lighting. Being more compact with SLT makes intracanopy lighting more efficient.

Here's Purple Arrow that had selective lighting training (it's a low yielding strain). This plant has not been topped and shows how different strains can give morphological differences. The blue light on the stem tends to produce plants that are not as wide but you have to test the strain to see how well SLT works for that strain. Once again, this allows more plants per area and more yield with intracanopy lighting. Intracanopy lighting often requires foliar nitrogen feeding and will produce a higher thermal load in your grow area as well as more humidity from the increased photosynthesis rate.

You can not just use blue side lighting to pull this off. The leaves tend to grow downwards with blue side lighting blocking light from hitting the stem. You must get the blue light in close to the stem which is the difference between side lighting or intracanopy lighting and selective light training.

Also, I should point out that the blue LEDs only need to be used on the growing parts of a plant (zone of division and zone of elongation). I've tested this with hardwoods, like Fuji Apple on a P-22 rootstock, and it does work for making more compact grafts as long as you hit the growing part of a hardwood before the bark has formed. More compact apple trees means more productive root stocks may be used. Coffee is usually cut back to six feet or so each year. More lower branching from SLT could mean higher yields. If should also allow new bonsai tree techniques. There's a whole lot of testing yet to be done with hardwoods.

Intracanopy light will be covered in the lighting guide. They are very different concepts. One is for intracanopy photosynthesis and one is for targeted and selective light sensitive plant protein manipulation.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 01 '13

Code for a simple chaotic tone generator that uses the logistic map equation

7 Upvotes
This is for the Arduino system and will run on an ATtiny85 just fine with minor changes.     Just copy and paste the below in to your sketch. Formatting done for clarity here.

//

//

// chaotic tone generator based on the equation for the logistic map

// http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logistic_map for explaination

// by SuperAngryGuy of Reddit

// use speaker on pin 6 (UNO) with a 330 ohm resistor in series, add potentiometer in    series to control volume. Change pin number as needed.

// LOGISTIC CONSTANT r must greater than 0, less than 4

//----some r values to play with-----

// 3.50 to 3.54 period 4 oscillations

// 3.54 to 3.57 period doubling, period 8, 16, etc

// 3.57 onset of chaos, notice the difference at 3.7

// 3.828 Intermittency, regular pulses with chaotic bursts, very interesting number

// 3.83 period 3 oscillation, an "island of stability"

// 3.86 back to chaos

// 3.78 I like this value, it's almost like a song

//------------------------------------------------------------

//

float x = 0.2;    // starting value must be greater then zero, less than 1

float x1 = x;     // starting value must be greater then zero, less than 1

float temp;      // temporary number while computing logistic map equation

float temp1;    // temporary number while computing logistic map equation

float num;      // number variable to scale logistic map numbers higher for tone generation

 char pinout = 6;    // tone on pin 6 for UNO, use 330 ohm resistor with a speaker

int delayTime = 115;    // this is the tone time in mSec, play with this value

int optionDelay;    // optional time delay value for variable tone length

float r;    // the LOGISTIC CONSTANT, must be >0 and <4, we use 3.5000 to 3.9900 here //-------------------------------------------------------------

//

void setup(){

Serial.begin(9600);} // set up serial output to terminal

//----------------------------------------------------------------

//

void loop(){

// **x = ((r * x1) * (1.0 - x1)) THIS IS THE LOGISTIC MAP EQUATION**

r = map(analogRead(3),0,1023,35000,39900); //convert 10 bit analog to digital    potentiometer on analog pin 3 to 35000 to 39900. Change pin number as needed.

               //change to 3500,3990 for lower resolution if potentiometer is too sensitive

r /= 10000.0; // convert 35000-39900 to 3.5000 to 3.9900 as LOGISTIC CONSTANT

              // change to r /= 1000.0 if lower resolution change above is made
              // this gives us our 3.5000 to 3.9900 variable

//--computing LOGISTIC MAP EQUATION--

//

x1 = x; // input previous number, this makes the equation recursive

temp = (1.0 - x1); // this bounds the output from greater than zero to less than one

temp1 = (r * x1); // multiply with the LOGISTIC CONSTANT

x = (temp * temp1); // this gives the final value for x

//

//--the below is all about scaling the logistic map variable x to a higher value for tone generation

//--x itself is not changed--you should play around with this, it was trial and error

//

num = x + 1; // x will be .01 to .99, we need this between 1.01 and 1.99 to start

num = num * num; // square num, we want to make the number higher

num = num + 1; // add 1 to num

num = num * num; // square num

num = num + 1; // add 1 to num

num = num * num * num; // cube num, this spreads the tones out

num = num / 32; // divide num by 32, use lower number for higher frequencies

num = num + 40; // make sure the tones are above 40 hertz, try commenting this out

//

//--------serial print and tone generation------------------------------

//

Serial.print(r,4); //print out LOGISTIC CONSTANT to 4 decimal places

Serial.print("    "); //print some spaces

Serial.print(num,8); //print out logistic tone number to 8 decimal places

Serial.println(); //move cursor to next line

tone(pinout, num); //generate tone on pinout, pin 6 for UNO, num is auto rounded for tone

//optionDelay = analogRead(0); //option time delay value with potentiometer on analog  pin 0

                        //replace delayTime with optionDelay below if using this

delay(delayTime); //tone time, play with this value, try delay(num/2), delay(num/3) or analog input optionDelay 

}

r/HandsOnComplexity • • May 02 '21

Arduino links for the botanist

53 Upvotes

last update: May 2021

main links page

Part of SAG's Plant Lighting Guide

this will be edited as needed



quick notes on sensors

Don't use resistive moisture sensors for soil like shown in many of the papers below. You want to use capacitive moisture sensors instead. Resistive sensors tend to not last long due to damage from electrolysis. If you do use a resistive moisture sensor then power on the sensor through a digital pin as needed, wait perhaps 1 mSec for everything to stabilize, do your A/D measurement, and then power down the sensor again until the next measurement is needed. This will minimize electrolysis damage long term and you will quickly kill a resistive sensor that is left powered on.

Capacitive soil moisture sensors can be left on all the time and do not have the above electrolysis issue assuming they are properly sealed including the all of electronics. They are not affected by soil (fertilizer) salts content unlike resistive sensors. The orientation and placement of a capacitive sensor will make a difference in their output in soil containers so you may have to play around a bit to get the more ideal reading range you want. I've seen this cause issues and you generally want the circuit board side facing inwards with the common generic capacitive v1.2 soil moisture sensor.

I would avoid the DHT11 humidity/temperature sensor shown in many papers below. I prefer the BME280 because I can set a bunch up and actually have them read the same under the same conditions consistently, which can be a problem with very low cost humidity sensors like the DHT11. The BME280 on protoboards are pretty cheap out of China, if in the US then check out eBay for US sellers at a pretty low cost (around $4 and you get an air pressure sensor in addition). The MCP9808 is one of the better lower cost temperature sensors that I also tested.

The Arduino type lux sensors that I've tested are pretty close to cosine correct (this is so, so important and why your phone makes a poor light meter). Assuming you know the lux to Âľmol m-2 s-1 PPFD conversion value for your light source, then a lux sensor can be used for plant lighting. I discuss this more in my article on using a lux meter as a plant light meter with links to supporting literature. Be sure that you can verify the lux measurement readings with a calibrated full spectrum quantum light meter for higher academic use. The TSL2591 can also be used for ultra high dynamic range two channel spectrophotometry.

Most of the latest spectral sensors like the $16 10-channel AS7341 spectrometer are not cosine correct so may need a secondary optic depending on your application (probably not as a general purpose spectrophotometer). The AS7341 could be made in to a full spectrum quantum light meter saving you >$500, when cosine corrected with a thin piece of white opaque plastic spaced properly, and a great sign of where lower cost spectrometry and light measurement is headed. The AS72652 can be used as a low cost red/far red light sensor also saving you >$500. The TCS3200 color sensor is being used as a SPAD meter replacement in some papers saving >$1,000. The TCS34725 color sensor is cosine correct and can fairly accurately measure color temperature with the AdaFruit library.

For carbon dioxide measurements, you ideally want to use dual channel NDIR type sensors although most of the lower cost ones are single channel. When first working around CO2 sensors, you need to be aware that you are constantly breathing out about 45,000 ppm CO2 and this is going to affect the sensor on the lab bench. It's a good idea to give lower cost NDIR sensors a several day burn-in period before relying on them. The MH-Z14A is an example of a lower cost but fairly accurate CO2 sensor with official library support.

The $7 VL53L0X laser range finder can be used to monitor plant growth or for cheap 3D scanning with a small tube over the sensor reduce the FOV. You may want to do some averaging with the sensor output.



grow related systems



farming and agriculture



measurements and lab gear



misc


r/HandsOnComplexity • • May 10 '21

Directed energy weapons links

38 Upvotes

Directed energy weapons links

main links page

SAG's plant lighting guide


high power microwave


vircator


marx generator


flux compression generator


pulse power


nanosecond pulsers


electromagnetic pulses


laser weapons


railgun and coilgun


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Apr 22 '13

LED and LED Grow Lights Part One: Heat

39 Upvotes

LED and LED GROW LIGHTS PART 1

This is going in the Lighting Guide as part of a LED and LED grow light series and will be 5-6000 words long when complete. First I give some theoretical back ground then I'll show how to build LED grow lights including explaining powering them then a bunch of measurements. If you have a question or want clarification then ask below: I'll answer, find an answer or say I don't know. If you have a question pertaining to your specific set up or a light that you want to build, PM me instead and I'll help you.

It will help greatly if you read the Lighting Guide first. Point out mistakes! I can also go back and make edits. Mistakes means I've learned something and I enjoy learning.

I want to start off by explaining the difference between natural scientific law and theory. A scientific law is an observation while theory gives the how and why. Johann Kepler, for example, was able to give his 3 Laws of Planetary Motion without understanding any theory of gravity. It wasn't until Einstein did his work on relativity that macro scale gravity was understood

(BTW, as a historical note, Einstein never received a Nobel Prize for his work on gravity and relativity, he got one for explaining the photoelectric effect. He was a mathematical prodigy who pissed off so many people that he couldn't get an academic position which is why he ended up working as a patent examiner after he was a PhD in physics.)

I mention the above because of the Laws of Thermodynamics. They pertain to LED grow lights like every thing else.

Moore's Law is NOT a natural scientific law! I've had people try to use that example to try to refute the Laws of Thermodynamics. If you're making statements contrary to the Laws of Thermodynamics then you're a crackpot (I never understood free energy types. I'll quickly delete any free energy non-sense). There is a form of energy transfer besides the one's listed below used in photosynthesis that will be covered in another mini article.

There are 3 ways that a LED/LED grow light has energy removed, heat being the lowest form of energy. Since photosynthesis is fairly inefficient, most all the energy input in to a grow chamber, for example, is converted to heat.


Radiation: this is mostly optical energy put out by the LED itself if the fixture does not also use convection (fans). Electrical efficiency plays a big role here. At the time of this writing there are Philips LEDs that are 40% efficient for red and just over 50% for blue. These are top bin LEDs and are still rather expensive. Green/yellow/amber LEDs are much less efficient since they don't need to be as efficient. Most colored LEDs are not used in grow lights but rather “Disney Land” style display lighting. Our eyes are more sensitive to these wavelengths which is why they don't need to be as efficient (there is some speculation on my part here).

The most efficient amber LED that I know of is the Philips amber PC LED which is a blue LED with an amber phosphor. This is a bit of a catch-22 since green is actually more efficient at driving photosynthesis at the higher lighting levels we use (front page Lighting Guide). .

There is also black body radiation where heat is radiated away from the fixture or from the LED (LEDs can get quite hot). Darker objects will have a higher emissivity and will be more efficient in removing heat than shiny objects. The emissivity of most leaves are 0.95 so they are good at both absorbing and removing heat. Plain aluminum has a very low emissivity so while aluminum is very good at conducting heat, it's poor at radiating heat. Painting or galvanizing an aluminum heat sink black makes them significantly better at radiating heat. Black tends to be slightly higher

An 8 watt LED module on some aluminum ran 20 degrees above ambient unpainted but 12 degrees painted black. If you want something to run cooler that is shiny, try painting it black. I'll do the same with other LED lights. Try using a black spray paint that also advertises itself to work as a primer.

Take an engine of a sports car and chrome it. It might run perhaps 40 degrees F hotter than normal not because the chrome acts as an insulating layer but because the emissivity is being lowered by being shinier. There's a good reason that car radiators are black. Same with most wood stoves being black.

So, in the same way that black/dark can absorb heat better, it can also radiate heat better than shinier objects. Due to the low emissivity of polished or plain aluminum, non-contact thermometers should not be used to measure their temperature since non-contact thermometers will be calibrated for a much higher emissivity. Your measurements will likely be way off.


Conduction: this is heat removed from the LED itself by being thermally bonded to a heat sink. Aluminum, copper and brass are good heat conductors. Steel by comparison, is a relatively poor heat conductor. This is why heat sinks tend to use more expensive aluminum rather than steel.

A liquid can also conduct away heat edit- this is actually a form of convection. A car radiator would be an example. Sometimes when testing LEDs, I'll put them in oil to over power them and see what happens. The oil helps keep them cool. A lot of large electrical transformers are oil filled to conduct heat away from the coils.


Convection: this is heat removed from a LED grow light using airflow or a liquid. It's a very efficient way to remove heat and why people make the mistake that LEDs do not produce as much heat as other lights. There is no way around the laws of thermodynamics- heat is energy input minus work performed. Turn off the fans of a LED grow light and see how hot it gets.

HID lighting like high pressure sodium or metal halides use radiation and convection to remove heat but not conduction although there are water cooled HID lighting kits and 15,000 watt IMAX style arc lamps are also water cooled. Since the heat is not being removed as efficiently the bulb itself will be much hotter. Directly blasting a HPS bulb with air can significantly keep a grow tent cooler. This is the same with fluorescent lighting to include induction lighting.

I want to digress and point something out. Smaller induction lights are less electrically efficient than CFL, LEDs and HID lighting and larger induction lights are about as efficient as T5 fluorescent lights. Don't waste your money on induction lights. They only make sense in situations where it would be expensive to change out the bulbs such as street lighting or high bay lighting since the bulbs will last longer (2019 edit- LEDs are now a better option). For grow lights they do not make sense since there are lower cost and more efficient alternatives. Their bulbs have a large surface area so they don't get particularly hot, like T12 fluorescent tubes don't get that hot, but will produce as much total heat as any other light.

Some induction grow light companies, such as Inda-gro, give a bunch of numbers that are complete non-sense as they pertain to grow lights and make claims about their performance which are completely false. I can make such statements without worrying about legal action because the truth is never considered slander (they have also plagiarized my work in the past so I enjoy slamming them). Look up induction lights used for commercial/industrial applications and you'll get the true numbers because there will be lighting engineers that will independently verify their performance. Most growers do not use light meters or test their lights.


A quick note on heat sinks

Heat sinks for LEDs only need to remove the heat energy from the energy input to the LED that is not radiated away as light. For example, a 100 watt LED that is 50% efficient only needs to be rated for 50 watts, not 100 watts.

link to part 2


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Feb 01 '13

Using a lux meter as a plant light meter

65 Upvotes

"Lumens are for humans"...unless you understand lighting theory

Part of SAG's Lighting Guide

last update: 20 JAN 2022 -added tl;dr, edited cannabis lighting level numbers



TL;DR

  • A lux meter must have cosine correction to make accurate measurements in most IRL measurements. Your phone likely does not have cosine correction and the white plastic over the sensor with a proper lux meter is the cosine correction. A phone app can not reliably correct for this error. Is your phone model reading going to read the same as another person's model? I can get 50-90% errors with any app I use including Photone in IRL conditions and not just a simple bench test.

  • You want a lux meter with a remote sensor head so you can make proper measurements with the lux sensor itself facing straight up rather than necessarily at the light source to get a true cosine correct lighting level measurement. You need to be able to scan around accurately no matter the sensor orientation. These are also important reasons why we do not rely on a phone as a light meter for what we do in any horticulture lighting.

  • You only use a lux meter with white light sources, not blurple lights, for absolute measurements. Use 70 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec to get within 10% for most white LED grow lights, use 55 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec for direct sunlight. A proper lux meter can be used with any visible light source for relative readings including blurple lights.

  • Minimum indoor light: Cannabis veg >30,000 lux. Cannabis flowering >40,000 lux. Use more light if there is unwanted stretching in veg, pump up the volume in flowering. Cannabis starts light saturation starting around 100,000 lux under ideal conditions.

  • Look up "LX-1010B" as an example mass produced generic lux meter to buy. It should cost about $20-25 shipped in the US and uses a cosine corrected silicon photo diode with a spectral correction filter.

  • Below is theory, explanations and rantings. The above is all most people need to know for cannabis lighting.

  • pic of 50% error with the Photone app --why you should not trust phone apps



Bit of ranting

Only use a lux meter with white light sources, not "bluple" red/blue dominate grow lights unless you know the lux to PPFD in umol/m2/sec conversion factor. I absolutely do not recommend using lux meters for professional or academic use as a PAR (photosynthetic active radiation) meter unless verified with a calibrated full spectrum quantum light meter. A hobbyist who does not want to spend >$500 on a full spectrum quantum light meter should be using lux meters. Lumens and lux are not the same thing; lumens should be thought of as total light output (for example, a 100 watt incandescent light bulb puts out about 1600 lumens of light), and lux the light intensity at a point in space.

Your phone is an unreliable general purpose lux meter because it may or more likely may not have cosine correction (what the round white piece of plastic does in actual lux meters). It does not matter what app is used because this is a hardware limitation. I automatically discount claims based on a phone's light intensity readings for this reason alone. It is very, very important that any phone, sensor, or meter used for a general purpose light readings has cosine correction (more on this below but it gets in to measurement angles and the angular response between the light meter and the light source).

There are too many variables in asking how far away should my light be from a plant such as power output, light fixture geometry (e.g. COB vs quantum light board, how the COBs are laid out in the light fixture), light/LED beam angle, plant type, and how many hours per day the light is on, etc. Spend $20 and use a light meter instead of guessing.



Rough lux lighting levels for cannabis

This is close to the lux readings that we want with a lux light meter as measured at the top of the plant canopy level for cannabis with white light CRI 80:

  • 5 klx -unrooting cuttings (you don't want too much light)

  • 15 klx -lower end for seedlings (more light and/or higher CCT if stretching)

  • 30 klx -lower end for veging (robust growth, keeps stretching down)

  • 40 klx -lower end for flowering (you don't want loose buds)

  • 100 klx -cannabis yields are linear to around this point under ideal conditions

note- cannabis seedlings can typically handle >40 klx and if your plant is doing fine then you should use more light rather than less



quick lux to PPFD in umol/m2/sec conversions

  • 55 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec sunlight

  • 63 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec white light CRI 90

  • 70 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec white light CRI 80

  • 80 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec HPS

These general numbers will get you within 10% of a true white lighting level reading for most white light sources. Many, many dozens of different LEDs were tested starting from 2011. These numbers are not valid for white lights with a CCT (correlated color temperature) of below 2700K or above 6500K (the K stands for degrees Kelvin, not the number one thousand).

As a guess I would use 60 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec for a white light with some red LEDs. Your results may vary due to the specific red to white LED ratio and the specific wavelength of the LEDs due to binning tolerances. A 660 nm LED may really be a 650 nm or 670 nm LED and this can read about three times off with a lux meter 670 nm has a relative sensitivity of 0.032, while 650 nm is 0.107, with an ideal lux meter. That's the problem particularly with the red heavy "blurple" lights and using lux meters.

CRI or color rendering index is more important than the CCT in conversion values because higher CRI lighting has a greater amount of deeper red light (light in the 650-660 nm area) that is not as sensitive to a lux meter. More on this below.

With non-white light sources like the "blurple" or red/blue dominate grow lights, if you know the lux to PPFD conversion value of the blurple light being used then the lux meter will work as an accurate PAR meter for that specific light.

For Bridgelux phosphors use these conversion values for a higher accuracy:

https://www.reddit.com/r/HandsOnComplexity/comments/gr1rcf/bridgelux_phosphor_guide/



Some tips about lighting levels

I've done closer to 35,000 lux with cannabis seedlings with great success and the above is a general guide. But the harder you push your plant, the easier and faster problems can develop. I personally use continuous, 24 hour lighting for the non-flowering stages. There's a lot of debate on this 24 hour argument versus an 18/6 etc lighting schedule with good points on both sides.

The answer to "should I run my plants 24 hours per day?" entirely depends on what you are trying to get the plants to do and factors such as lighting levels (really high lighting levels causes damage to certain proteins involved with photosynthesis over time and it takes a certain amount of time for these proteins to be repaired in darkness or at very low lighting levels).

In many cases you will have more success with rooting cuttings by using less light per day such as 18 hours per day.

If your plant is distressed from nutrient deficiencies and the likeuse less light until it recovers.

Higher lighting levels will result in lowers yields per watt but can generate higher yields per area/volume. Under lighting and intracanopy lighting can also be used for higher yields in addition to top lighting. You absolutely will get better yields by properly using side and intracanopy lighting rather than just using top lighting alone. You can get to a very high DLI (daily light integral or how much light the plant receives in 24 hours), well beyond normal, by lighting up the lowers leaves that may not normally be lit up.

It is mainly the blue light that keeps a plant compact. Green can reverse blue light effects. Red can also keep a plant more compact that is reversed by far red light. Lights that have a lower CRI tend to have more green light even at the same color temperature but this is not always the case.

When using a light meter, it is typically best to use it with the sensor/meter pointing straight up rather than directly at the light source. That little white semi-sphere or flat piece of plastic you see with the light meter compensates for this (the cosine correction mentioned above). You can get very inaccurate off axis readings if your light meter is pointed at the light source. Let the little piece of white plastic do its job at cosine correction.

If you ever read about "light quantity" then lighting levels are being discussed. If you read about "light quality" then the lighting spectrum is being discussed.



Notes on lux meters, quantum light meters and spectrometers

Lux meters try to get this spectral response curve (the black curve) and typically use an inexpensive silicon photodiode with a particular filter that rolls off the red end. The photodiode naturally has a blue roll off and this, with economy of scale, allows pretty accurate meters to be made cheaply compared to quantum light meters. That filter is just a cheap greenish piece of plastic with this spectral response.

The high end quantum light meters uses a silicon diode with a very expensive spectral response flattening curve made for silicon diodes and an expensive thin film optical band pass filter to only read 400-700 nm light evenly. That's why there is a big price jump in meters prices like in the Apogee Sq-520. These meters also use a digital smoothing filter so the readings aren't bouncing all over the place. If you're serious about lighting you'll get a full spectrum quantum light meter.

One of the lower end meters I have, the cheaper Hydrofarm quantum light meter has a multi-channel spectral sensors. It's 4 channel, 100 KHz I2C data protocol that transmits 3 times per second so readings bounce around. This meter also shuts off every two minutes, was made of really cheap plastic, the battery life was low, and the battery had to be replaced with USB power supply/volt regulator because it was about to rupture. Mine will read green 525 nm LEDs 50% too low. Do not buy this meter.

Another meter I have, one of the Light Scouts, uses a special type of photodiode that coincidentally has a natural response curve that pretty close to the flat PAR curve we want. This means that the expensive filters do not have to be used and why you find quantum light meters that are under $500. But they do not work with 660 nm LEDs reliably (they have a sharp 650 nm cutoff) so they should never be used for pro/academic purposes. I used it for HPS and it was within 1% true.

A new type of meters/sensors out are the Apogee 340-1040 nm Extended Photon Flux Density (ePFD) and 380-750 nm Extended Photosynthetically Active Radiation (ePAR) series of meters/sensors that still reads flat across PAR. A significant advantage with these newer types of meters is the potential to use fairly cheap filters with them and turn the in to red/far red light meters or to maybe measure chlorophyll fluorescence and give us an idea of photosynthesis efficiency. The ePFD 340-1040 nm has the potential to be used with a with variety of filters (some types can get quite expensive) that could perhaps be used to measure in vivo leaf moisture content, for example.

A quantum light meter is called "quantum" because their measurement is in the amount a photons hitting a specific point in space per second and a photon is a quanta of light. A lux meter is called "lux" since they measure luminous flux.

Although we measure the PPFD in umol/m2/sec (micro moles of photons per square meter per second), we do not actually measure all the light in a square meter. It is equivalence to a square meter measurement. Same with a lumen/lux measurement- we are not necessarily making a true measurement in a square meter area but an equivalent measurement (one lumen is one lux per square meter). Any measurement made is only valid for that particular space being measured.

For red/blue "blurple" lighting and for professional or academic use for all lighting, I recommend either the Apogee MQ-500 full spectrum quantum light meter or the Apogee SQ-520 full spectrum quantum light sensor. I use the SQ-520 since I may spend a lot of time with a light meter/sensor and don't want to look at a tiny display. The only other light meter I can recommend that I also have some (but not much) hands on experience with are the LiCor light meters but they are very expensive. There are also

For pro/academic use or advanced hobby use, get the MQ-500 if you are doing more field use, get the SQ-520 if you are doing more lab use and don't need to be portable. The SQ-520 comes with a 15 feet long USB cable which I thought was ridiculous at first until I started using it. You can use the SQ-520 with a Windows tablet computer (get 4 GB of RAM, not 2 GB of RAM with a Windows tablet). It also works with Mac but not Android.

According to Bruce Bugbee, founder of Apogee Instruments and the Director of the Crop Physiology Laboratory at Utah State University, your light meter should never have more than a 5% error over 400-700 nm for academic purposes. A lux meter should keep you within 10% error for most white light sources as per my testing as long as a rough conversion value is known. $20 well spent and you'll learn a lot about lighting.

I do not really recommend handheld spectrometers for advanced horticulture light work since they are not very versatile (relatively speaking compared to a spectrometer with a fiber optic input) and most of the cheaper ones have a reduced resolution of only 15 nm or so. That's not going to work for many botanical measurements particularly for red edge and chlorophyll fluorescence work. You also want a spectrometer with an integration time of at least a few minutes.

If you are going to drop a bunch of money then get a USB spectrometer with a fiber optic probe for about twice the price as handheld including NIST traceable calibration and a few probe heads (cosine and a narrow 2-3 degree lens). You should PM me before buying a spectrometer if thinking on going cheap so that I can further articulate why you should spend more money than you realize on this level of lab gear. Two popular spectrometer makers are Stellarnet and Ocean Optics

As a strong warning on light meters, I have seen a person selling a homemade quantum light meter that has an amateurish 3D printed case (just no). For $650 I consider this a complete rip off in my opinion and the $550 professional Apogee MQ-500 is a better deal. I have some of the LCD displays used in the NukeHeads meter (I believe the cheap SSD1306 0.96 inch version) and they are not good for reading in full sunlight in my experience.

Unlike the NukeHeads meter above, the MQ-500 can also be factory recalibrated, has a data logging feature, and a four year warranty. The Apogee SQ-520 is about $350 (that can also be used as a programmed stand alone data logger) and is the same sensor as the MQ-500 and the NukeHeads meter. Don't pay more for less and never buy Ardruino based homemade lab gear. I will DIY my own lab gear but never buy other's complete DIY lab gear.

Quantum light meters and lux meters are basically worthless for far red lights and far red LEDs. For those you need a spectrometer, a far red sensitive spectral sensor, or something like an Apogee SQ-620 which is PAR and far red sensitive. Red/far red spectral sensors for microcontrollers start at about $25.

https://www.sparkfun.com/products/14351

18 channel spectrometers useful for botany work start at $50.

https://www.tindie.com/products/onehorse/compact-as7265x-spectrometer/

https://www.sparkfun.com/products/15050



A bit more theory

You don't actually need to know this stuff for making simple measurements.

Here's the conversion charts for using a lux meter as a quantum light meter. This is the lux to PPFD (photosynthetic photon flux density) conversion.

PI curve explained Cannabis is a lot higher than the specific curves shown.

Compensation point explained. The compensation point for annuals may be perhaps 20 umol/m2/sec (1400 lux) depending on the plant. BTW, what makes a "house plant" a "house plant" is they often have a very low compensation point and are perennials that tend not to elongate too much in lower lighting levels. This is a generalization.

The umol/m2/sec measurement of light is from 400 nm to 700 nm which is PAR (photosynthetically active radiation and take some of those charts with a grain of salt). It is the unit of light intensity in horticulture lighting. It is always a "PPFD of 300 umol/m2/sec", for example, and never "300 PPFD" or "300 PAR". I can always tell if I'm dealing with a hobbyist who likely does not understand the subject matter if they are misusing terms. More on core concepts in horticulture lighting theory can be found here.

The conversion factor for blurple grow lights can be all over the place. For example, as measured with my own spectrometer, instead of 70 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec, a red 647nm LED was at a 10.3 conversion factor, and a red 620nm LED at 44. A blue 462nm LED measured in at 12.8.

To put it another way, with a lux meter a 460 nm LED can read about 50% higher than a 450 nm LED although they may put out the same light when measured by a quantum light meter. A 630 nm LED may read three times higher than a 660 nm LED with a lux meter but the same with a more appropriate quantum light meter. What do you actually have in your "blurple" red/blue dominate grow light? This is why a lux meter should never be used to try to get a lighting measurement from other than a white light source.

This is the lux conversion table by wavelength of light.

Here's a few examples of light as measured in power by spectrum and how our eyes and a lux meter would perceive it. Here's a 2700K CFL as a true spectrum and how a lux meter reads it. Notice how much the red/green (the middle and right spike) ratio changes. This is because our eyes and lux meters are much more green sensitive. This is a solar spectrum on a cloudy day and how our eyes/lux meter perceives it.

For white LEDs with a CRI of 90 use 65 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec. This is because a CRI 90 white light have deeper reds which will not read as high on a lux meter although they may output the same amount of light as read on a quantum light meter. Protip- your food will look much better with CRI 90 lighting particularly red meats. If you are a chef you would want to use CRI 90 white lighting and not CRI 80 lighting which will have a R9 rating of 0. CRI affects lux readings more than the CCT because of the additional deep red light than CRI 90 lights will have. I also use high CRI lighting at my lab bench. The link below talks about R9.

https://www.waveformlighting.com/tech/what-is-cri-r9-and-why-is-it-important

When comparing two different light sources in a grow comparison, they must be done at the same lighting intensity. Why? First, photosynthesis isn't somewhat linear except between about 50 to around 300 or so umol/m2/sec, strongly depending on the plant. This is due to processes like photorespiration and non-photochemical quenching. Second, many plant proteins are expressed at different lighting intensities which can and will affect plant growth and development. Third, chloroplasts can move to the side walls at higher intensities of blue light lowering plant photosynthesis efficiency. This is called cytoplasmic streaming and is done as a form of photoprotection. An example can be seen here in this sped up 4 second video.

Do not use a cheap analog lux meter. I've tested one type and it was way off (the analog ones had impedance matching problems with the analog scale so were giving bad readings in brighter light). These cheap 3 in 1 light meters, pH meters, and moisture meters are worthless.

BTW, for photography and video, you should always use lights that have a CRI of 90 or higher to get your reds and yellows to show true. It's actually much more complicated than that and you start running in to the TM-30-15 standard and newer standards just started to being used and being worked out.



So, what is white?

This is a deceptively tricky question and it depends who you ask and what industry they are in.

To me it's simple- a white light is any light that has a chromaticity coordinate on the Plankian locus of the CIE 1931 color space within a certain color temperature range with a Duv of +/- 0.006 (or so...ish). See...simple! /s.

Some people might define white as the CIE Standard Illuminant D65 and declare that the white point. But there are other standard illuminants for white. But really if the white light is the only light source and our eyes can use its chromatic adaptation to make the light appear white then it's a white light source.

Try going to a paint store and ask for white paint and they might give you 30 or so choices for white. Your white teeth would look horrible if they where a bright "equal energy white" which is a white that has a flat spectral power distribution. White can mean different things to different people.

The pro video industry are coming up with very detailed standards just for their industry on what is white and how it relates to reflected light.

A camera can use an 18% gray card to get white for the shooting situation instead of the less reliable auto white balance. I often just use a white piece of paper to set my white balance.

Different people may use different color spaces so even defining color may not be very clear cut. Is it red, green blue for the primary colors or is it really red, yellow, blue? What about the heathens that use subtractive CMYK (cyan, magenta, yellow, and black) color model?

So, different people might have different definitions of what's white. But the lower the CRI, the higher the y chromaticity coordinate which means more green light, and lux meters are more sensitive to green light, and that's why CRI plays an important role in a lux to PPFD conversion value more so than color temperature which is more of a red to blue light ratio. This is top of the deeper reds at higher CRI that lux meters are not as sensitive to.

Red, green, blue LEDs together can make a white light source but the CRI (color rendering index) is going to be so low that everything is going to look horrible. In this case it is because the red/green/blue LEDs have strong spectral spikes with large gaps in the visible spectrum so the colors of objects may not look correct. That's why we use typically blue LEDs with broad phosphors instead that do not have these large gaps. Yellow and orange in particular may not render correctly with red/green/blue LEDs. Plants generally do not care, though, but some plants can be hypersensitive.



CRI and the best tip you'll get on LED light bulbs

It's about the color temperature AND the CRI in deciding what bulb to get.

As an aside, get CRI 90 or above LED bulbs, also called high CRI LED light bulbs or high CRI lightning, in your kitchen and your dining room. I'd honestly put them in any living space and pick whatever color temperature that makes you happy (e.g. warmer in living spaces, cooler in work spaces). Any restaurant should only be using high CRI LED lighting particularly if they serve a lot of red meat (wow, people do not understand this. Bridgelux makes white LEDs just for food and has ultra high CRI COBs that have come out). Same with any fashion display/photography or other type of display/photography where colors are important. (and for god's sake, use an off camera light source(s) for display and food photography. don't crap on your own products by using bad lighting)

Even at an electronics or other work station high CRI lighting will make a very noticeable difference if anything red is involved. Make sure that the LED light bulb is not going to interfere with your electronics, though, from that dirty (radio frequency interference prone) LED power supply. Some bulbs up close will interfere with my RF spectrum analyzer and oscilloscopes.

If you have orchids around or growing plants for display purposes that have red/pink/purple in them (e.g. orchids, tomato, African violet), then you want to use high CRI lighting so your plants look extra popping. Don't put all that work in to your plant just to make it look dull.

Most people would likely not need to get higher than CRI 90 for general living but who knows what future trends will be. But, the higher the CRI, the lower the luminous efficacy (lumens per watt) will be so the are electricity usage costs to consider particularly in a commercial environment.

CRI 80 lighting has very dull, lifeless reds and lame off colors that makes me want to vomit in rage (and not in the good way, the bad way). CRI 97 and above makes colors really pop and what you want for higher end photography although you may still may need to gel the light even with color temperature control.

Keep the lower CRI 80 lighting in the garage and the shed or for outdoor lighting or install them at your ex's place. There are very high efficacy CRI 65-70 white LEDs that you might find in a warehouse and street lighting which is a big improvement over HPS with a color temperature of 2100K and a CRI in the mid 20's.

You'll also find CRI 70 white LEDs in some grow lights. It makes a lot of sense when added with 660 nm red LEDs because the CRI 70 light will naturally be much lower in the deeper reds and it's more energy efficient to add the red LEDs rather than generate the extra red light through a phophor (remember, green LEDs are inefficient compared to red/blue LEDs).

Red/green/blue only novelty LED light bulbs will have a CRI of around 45 and are horrible as a white light source. This is why a white LED is often added to help bring the CRI up a bit.

Now, take this knowledge and tell every bar and restaurant owner to buy a pack of high or very high CRI LED lights bulbs just to try out and see the difference. My work here is done.



PPFD, DLI, PPE, PPF, and PAR

Read up on core concepts in horticulture lighting

  • PPFD or photosynthetic photon flux density is lighting intensity at a point in space in umol/m2/sec also written umol m-2 sec-1. Use the conversions above (e.g. 70 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec for CRI 80). umol is often written as Îźmol.

  • DLI or daily light integral is the amount of light per day in mol/m2/day or mol m-2 day-1. DLI uses "mol" for moles and not "umol" for micro moles! For every 100 umol/m2/sec multiply that by 8.6 and then multiply that by the ratio of the on time of the light in hours per day (e.g. 18 hours per day and you multiply that by 0.75 since 18/24 = 0.75). A PPFD of 300 umol/m2/sec on for 18 hours per day will give a DLI of 19.35 mol/m2/day, as an example.

  • PPE or photosynthetic photon efficacy is the amount of light generated per joule of energy written umol/joule or umol joule-1. Since a joule is one watt per second it can also be written umol/watt/sec or umol watt-1 sec-1. In Dec 2019 high end Samsung quantum boards will have a PPE of 2.5-2.7 umol/joule. Low end cheap Chinese grow lights will be around a PPE of 1.3 umol/joule. Osram has red LEDs that are 4.0 umol/joule and above.

  • PPF or photosynthetic photon flux is the total amount of light given off by a light source and written umol/sec. To get the PPF multiply the PPE by the true wattage of the light source. A "100 watt equivalent" 1600 lumen white light bulb gives off about 20 umol/sec of light +/- 10% depending on specific CRI and CCT. ANSI/ASABE S640 along with the DLC does or will define PPF as umol/sec and not being the same as PPFD.

  • PAR or photosynthetically active radiation is light from 400 nm to 700 nm. It is a description of what we measure, not a unit of measurement. There is no "300 PAR", as an example, just like there is no "300 water" or "300 power".



A quick DLI cheat

  • Want a DLI of 17 mol/m2/day for lettuce 18 hours per day? 17,000 lux gets your pretty close. Need a DLI of 30 mol/m2/day for peppers for 18 hours per day? 30,000 lux gets you pretty close.



Sources



Secret bonus material

If you are a botanist or one in training or interested in the subject then you should know about Norman Borlaug, the man who saved a billion lives. This guy would go in to countries and in many cases double that county's grain output in a matter of years. Mind = blown.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norman_Borlaug

http://www.agbioworld.org/biotech-info/topics/borlaug/special.html

https://reason.com/2009/09/13/norman-borlaug-the-man-who-sav/

https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=norman+borlaug


r/HandsOnComplexity • • May 26 '20

Bridgelux phosphor guide

32 Upvotes

Spectrum charts, conversion factors, and color ratios of the Bridgelux COB array LEDs

updated 11 June 2020

part of SAG's Plant Lighting Guide

Using a lux meter as a plant light meter (only use a lux meter with white light sources)


The conversion factor is luminous flux (lux) to photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD) in uMol/m2/sec (micro moles per square meter per second) of PAR (photosynthetic active radiation 400-700 nm). This is so that low cost lux meters can be used as plant lighting meters.

The color ratios will not add up to 100. Blue is 400-499 nm, green is 500-599 nm, red is 600-699nm, far red is 700-799nm.

This is the second order derivative of the Bridgelux phosphors. This was specifically a CRI 97 COB. Each of the major downward dips is a different phosphor and is way more complex than I thought it would be. The saturated one on the far left is the phosphor pump blue LED (the wavelength is downshifted or shifted to the right slightly with this technique). Derivative spectroscopy is a powerful analytical chemistry technique that allows one to look at chlorophyll A and B separately in living leaves in vivo, for example, that may not show up very well if at all with more traditional spectroscopy techniques in vivo.

The average wavelength of phosphor pump blue LEDs in my samples was about 453.5 nm.

Vero 10's, Vero 18's and Vero 29's were tested here. In many cases multiple samples of the same phosphor type were tested.

The below backs my claim that you can use 70 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec for CRI 80, and 63 lux = 1 umol/m2/sec for CRI 90 and be within 10%. That 1750K LED is an exception.


1750K cri 80 -This is an oddball LED

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 49 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:08....green:25....red:57....far red:06


2000K cri 65

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 70 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:05....green:41....red:49....far red:02


2700K cri 80

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 72 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:11....green:42....red:36....far red:02


2700K cri 90

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 63 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:06....green:19....red:22....far red:02


3000K cri 80

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 73 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:16....green:45....red:37....far red:02


3000K cri 90

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 65 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:09....green:22....red:23....far red:02


3000K cri 97

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 59 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:14....green:36....red:41....far red:04


3500K cri 80

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 74 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:20....green:47....red:31....far red:01


4000K cri 80

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 74 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:11....green:24....red:14....far red:01


4000K cri 90

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 68 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:20....green:40....red:31....far red:02


5000k cri 70

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 75 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:13....green:22....red:09....far red:01


5000K cri 80

lux to PPFD conversion factor: 76 lux = 1 uMol/m2/sec

blue:26....green:50....red:21....far red:01



r/HandsOnComplexity • • Sep 03 '13

1st try with the Ekrof Space Bucket

32 Upvotes

note- this project would not be safe with modern LED light bulbs and should not be duplicated. You should never remove the dome from LED light bulbs or modify LED light bulbs by removing the circuit board.

edit- 6jun2017 Read the disclaimer found below on removing the cover from modern LED light bulbs.

https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceBuckets/comments/6fdmsn/dismantled_led_globes/dihxuha/


So, here's my first try with the Ekrof Space Bucket. The Space Bucket subreddit can be found here.

Keep in mind that bulbs are about twice as efficient today than when this was originally published.


Specs:

56 watts LEDs including power supplies from the, 49 watts on the LEDs, warm white. Seven 8 watt lights/modules- 4 on top, 3 on the side. Cost about $35 subsidized by the local power company. Side and intracanopy lighting is about increasing the effective leaf area index (the amount of leaves receiving direct light). Lights held in place by 5 minute epoxy.

Here is an up close of the LED lights used. Put a bulb that has all the LEDs shining in one direction in double plastics bags and smash the glass. Pick and file as needed. During picking there were tiny bits of glass flying up in my face so use eye protection. I put 4 on a bucket lid.

The lamps were wired in parallel with solder and heat shrink tubing wire connections to the light sockets used. Scotch Super 33+ (the best standard electrical tape) was wrapped around the connection to provide good electrical and mechanical isolation. Four were daisy chained together so I had only one LED light cord to deal with from the lid. Here's the underside of the lid, when the LEDs are lit up and with the Mylar applied. Rubber glue with a brush was used to cement the Mylar to the bucket lid. You can see the ducting on the underside from the 90 degree PVC bend.

Single 40mm fan, temps never go above 3 degrees F above ambient. 1.5 degrees typical.

LED heat sinks are outside the Space Bucket!. The side light is a the same LED light as the top of the lids but the LED module is removed and mounted on 1/8th aluminum that is 1 ½ inch wide and 8 inches long. Here are a bunch of examples (big pic alert) of how I remove the LED modules but still use the lighting power supply. This means I'm working with safe, low voltage lights around the plant canopy. Speaker wire was used for the low voltage lighting and the speaker wire is soldered to the output of the light's power supply, heat shrink tubing, wire stress relieved with a tie-wrap and taped up with the Scotch Super 33+ electrical tape.

So, I get custom lighting with no electronics work beyond a little bit of soldering. Do at you own risk but for fast and easy bucket side lighting, this is an easy ay to go. You can typically use heat grease and screw the module down but I just use 5 minute epoxy around the edge of the LED module. Allow 5 hours to cure other wise you may end up with a gooey mess.

Single bucket, no extensions. White painted black. Aluminum foil on the inside (I've busted the burning myth so many times that I put it on the front page of my lighting guide, with examples, to kill the debate).

In testing flat white paint, unpainted white bucket, Panda Plastic white sheeting, Mylar and aluminum foil, Mylar and the foil came out on top with a virtual tie.

Solar cells inside bucket

light testing set up with spectrometer and Fluke 287

week 7 inside bucket with foil

Grand Daddy Purple, a fairly low yielding indica (note, I can get +3 oz per square foot under HPS with intracanopy LED lighting in soil off a related strain, Purple Arrow). 60 days flowering, right out of the cloning aeroponic chamber. I did leave it in the aero chamber an extra 7 days to rapidly build up the roots while doing a foliar feeding.

Miracle-Gro Moisture Control soil. With ultra high lighting levels you either need to go hydroponics or use a soil that holds more moisture. You can add vermiculite or something but I hate vermiculite and perlite. When I first started growing in 1995 I used a 50/50 blend ebb and flow. Crap got everywhere! They're like little static electric magnets. Ignore the time release fertilizer claim- that's more suited to low light house plants and insignificant to this type of growing.

Fertilizer- General Hydroponics 3 part Flora series at 1200 ppm, pH 6.5. I had to use a 50/50 grow/bloom mixture due to the higher lighting levels. A bloom mixture alone isn't going to cut it as I found out due to chlorosis (chlorophyll breakdown from too low of nitrogen). Every 3 days I would flush the plant with plain water at pH 6.8 (remember, peat is acidic) and then add the fertilizer solution at 1200 ppm. Plain water flush for the last 10 days.

Here's the GDP at 14 days flowering

top at 22 days

side at 4 weeks

side at 8 weeks

front at 8 weeks

top at 8 weeks

macro at 8 weeks

in bucket at 7 weeks This is how the plant was grown. The foil is to minimize side light waste.

So, I missed my projected goal of 28 grams by 2 grams. The nugs were surprisingly dense with all the extra photosynthesis going on.

I will get harvest pics up in the perma-link. My new plant and set up are far superior and I should be in the ~40-50 gram range which will be a separate post.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Mar 14 '21

Cannabis, basil, lettuce, tomato, pepper lighting

33 Upvotes

Cannabis, basil, lettuce, tomato, pepper lighting links

last update: March 2021

main papers link page

SAG's Plant Lighting Guide main page


Cannabis lighting


Basil lighting


Lettuce lighting


Tomato lighting


Pepper lighting


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Nov 11 '22

SAG's Open Cannabis Links part 2

34 Upvotes

11 NOV 2022

Part of SAG's Lighting Guide


I ran in to the 40,000 character limit with part 1

I still have to take time to organize everything! I have over 250 papers to go over and reorganize. This is less than half of all cannabis papers that have now been published.




Most interesting and contradicts Bruce Bugbee:









80 ________________________________________________________

90 _____________________________________________


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Sep 17 '13

LED and LED GROW LIGHTS PART 2: Beam Angle

35 Upvotes

LEDs and LED Grow Lights Part 2 in the lighting guide: Beam Angle

Please, no linking to grow lights and asking my or others opinions of specific ones on here. PM me such questions. It's to prevent flame wars, to keep bias down and for no free advertising. I'll tell you up front, at this point in time I would not use LED grow lights only in large scale grow operations.

LEDs, LED grow lights and plant growth can be difficult because it's a interdisciplinary knowledge set. There's electronics including the power supply types/design and LED electrical characteristics, thermodynamics explained here, photometry, photobiology including light sensitive proteins, photometry, general botany and stuff I'm probably forgetting at the moment. We'll focus on the LED's here and I'll try writing to the layman. Actually building LED grow lights step 1 has just about been completed (pics done, needs some wordsmith). Things like heat and voltage drop will be covered there.

A quick note- after checking over 30 different white LEDs comparing lux to radiant flux and uMol/meter2 /sec, you can use a cheap digital lux meter with white LEDs. 70 lux = 1 uMol/meter2 /sec within 10% over 2800K-7000k white LEDs. 67 lux = 1uMol within 5 % with warm white LEDs. The higher the color temperature the greater the variance. Read the lighting guide if you didn't understand the above or ask below what section to read. A lux meter is no good for absolute measurements with color LEDs.

Penetration and beam angle

Repeat after me: a 3 watt LED does not necessarily have better penetration than a 1 watt LED. I've seen such discussions in multiple forums multiple times.

Let's say we have a single LED that is a (theoretical) point light source. It's light output will follow the square of distance law of light drop off in this case. At one foot we have one unit of light which covers one square feet, at two feet from the LED we have Âź unit of light which is 4 square feet, at 3 feet from the LED we have 1/9 unit of light which covers 9 square feet etc.

But, what if we had a 1 watt LED with a 60 degree light beam output and the 3 watt LED with a 120 degree output. What LED penetrates the plant canopy better? The one watt LED is going to penetrate better since its light is 4 times more focused (simplifying here). I have a 100 watt LED at 120 degrees and a typical 0.005 watt laser pointer (lasers are rated on their true optical power output unlike LEDs) at what ever degrees it is. The tiny laser has better penetration. I can focus it to put tiny burn holes on the bottom leaves of a typical indoor plant in a few seconds with better optics than a cheap laser pointer.

Plant canopy penetration is a function of both optical power output and how focused that light source is. This is a huge consideration when building or buying a LED grow light. Growing lettuce without much vertical space? Get a LED grow light with wider beam angles. Growing a 3 foot tall plant where you want the bottom leaves receiving a lager amount of light? Get a LED grow light with a narrow beam angle but have the light higher (further away from the plant) than a light with a wider beam angle.

Beware that some LED grow light manufacturers/importers might make a caparison and have the ruler or whatever say 12 inches from their light (A) and a competitors light (B). So A with a light meter puts out at that 12 inches so much more light than B, maybe even twice as much as their competitor!!! No, check the beam angle of both the lights. I've seen this trick so many times by people in the trade. In most forums it's not under standing beam angle and light drop off. You just need to put the light closer if using shorter plants or low stress training and a screen of green.

Linear lights, sources such as fluorescent tubes have such a wide beam angle which is distributed along the bulb, are great for lettuce which can then be stacked on shelves.

In most grow situations, the closer your light source is to the plant, the wider the beam angle you want:

Short plants = wider beam angle

Tall plants = narrow beam angles and have the light up a little higher so that you're not light saturating the upper leaves

It may help to think of wider beam angle LED grow lights as relatively closer to florescent tube like lighting and narrow beam angle LED grow lights like HID lighting with a small, horizontal and narrow hood and use them appropriately as an analogy.

A lot of distributors are coming out with multi-beam angle LEDs. The ratio of wide angle to short angle would he a handy piece of information to know as well as their general spectrum (red, far red, blue, etc)

link to part 3


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Sep 17 '13

LED and LED GROW LIGHTS PART 3: Color and White LEDs

40 Upvotes

LEDs and LED Grow Lights Part 3 lighting guide: color and white LEDs

Why not green LEDs? Come on SAG, your always dropping that green is better than white drives photosynthesis link (front page, lighting guide). Well, I typically use that to make a point that HPS light, which is high in green and yellow/orange, is a very efficient grow light and to refute a lot of claims about green light and photosynthesis found in many biology/botany text books and put out by LED grow lights distributors.

Why not use green LEDs then.....? Their electrically inefficient compared to blue and red LEDs is very low. BAM! That's it. White LEDs, which are just blue LEDs with a phosphor, can put out more green than green LEDs per watt in some cases. It's sometimes known as the “green valley” in LED semiconductor physics and here's a good intro Tech Review article on green LEDs.

The only reason why I use green LEDs is for plant and plant lighting R&D. Although I do use high power red/green/blue LEDs, it's typically a blue LED with a green phosphor as shown in the first pic. The yellow looking LEDs are actually warm white 3000K LEDs. I'll sometimes use warm white LEDs with a yellow filter to make a broad band minus blue plant light source. No blue light on the leaves, blue light on the stems of sweet basil is the key to making them four times larger than normal. No blue light what so every with sweet basil and you have a plant that will not grow. Damned if I know why. Some sort of blue light sensitive protein cascade effect. I also tend not to build over 100 watt LED lights. Things scale up and smaller light engines can be built in an hour or two at a very low cost.

So what is the best ratio of colored LED? Don't know. Gotta experiment. Different plants, different results. 1 red :1white is a good place to start to keep it simple. Photosynthesis can be roughly measured using the lighting levels at the leaf and then measuring the chlorophyll florescence on the front and back of the leaf (and knowing the leaf thickness) then you can get charts like this and this using LEDs and cheap lasers as my light source and try to interpret the results.

What I can tell you is that from a photosynthesis stand point there is not much difference between 630 and 660nm, for example. These solvent/chlorophyll charts for chlorophyll you see on Wikipedia don't have much meaning. 680nm. That's peak absorption wavelength of most green leaves. You need a spectrometer and a chlorotic leaf to really see it. On the other hand, why use a wavelength that will quickly become absorbed in the first few layers of chloroplasts (which contain the chlorophyll).

So, what's up with white LEDs? They're simply blue LEDs with a phosphor like found in fluorescent lighting like CFLs, induction lights, T8s and the like. But white LEDs excite the phosphor with blue photosynthetic active radiation (top chart in the link is for dissolved pigments, the second one is for green algae. Green land plants is not shown) rather than not photosynthetically useful ultraviolet radiation. It's called PAR.

Here's why the above is a big deal- white LEDs are basically 100% PAR including the blue light (radiation) that excites the phosphor. Fluorescent lighting must use more energetic photons which also excite the phosphor but here's the big sticking point: the energy difference between mercury vapor ultraviolet photon the photon the phosphor releases as PAR is wasted as heat. The greater the difference in wavelength between the two photons, or the Stokes shift, the more inefficient the lighting source becomes.

Here's an example. Mercury vapor in fluorescent lighting generates an ultraviolet photon of 254nm or an energy of 4.88 electron volts (1240 / photon wavelength = electron volts of energy). We'll call middle PAR 555nm or 2.23 electron volts. We just lost 2.65 electron volts of energy. We're now at 46% maximum theoretical efficiency due to the Stokes shift alone. It just goes down from there when the quantum efficiency of the phosphor which requires a triple phosphor instead of a single phosphor found in most white LEDs.

There are red LEDs that you can buy at the time of this writing that are +40% electrically efficient (electrical energy in, number of photons out), blues that are +50% efficient and whites that put out 140 lumens per watt, up to 200 at reduced power levels. No traditional fluorescent technology, including induction lights, come near these numbers.

Well great, lets put lots of blues in there since it's most efficient. No, a blue 450nm photon has an energy of 2.76 electron volts while a red 650nm photon 1.91 electron volts. It takes less energy to generate a red photon so while blue is more electrically efficient, red is more energy efficient.

Also, there's 2 photo systems a photosynthetic reaction center, PS1 ans PSII. It's part of the very important Z scheme. They require 2 photons to complete, one 680nm and one 700nm or an average of about 1.78 electron volts of energy. That red 650nm photon lost 0.18 electron volts due to heat from this mismatch and the blue LED 0.98. Wasted heat. Plant thermodynamics.

Remember, with LEDs, it's the current level that mainly determines how many photons are generated. With a “12 volt” power supply I can use 3 blue/white LEDs or 5 reds in series. LEDs in series always have the same current levels so there's 2 extra LEDs at the same total power levels. We pay for the price of a blue photon by having to use LEDs with a higher voltage drop. Around 3.4 volts or so. A red LED perhaps 2.2 volts.

Part 4 on choosing LEDs and LED grow lights will be from some posts over the last few months. Then we'll get our hands dirty and build our own LED grow lights.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Oct 16 '13

LED and LED Grow lights part 4: building your first LED grow light

53 Upvotes

This is part of the LED series of the Lighting Guide.

edit 2019- this is a bit obsolete now and there are better ways to builb LED drivers if you don't wish to build a linear constant current driver.

So, here's a step by step for a simple 10 watt LED light. After this we'll move up to 100 watt LEDs that are about $8 for white and $20 for color at the time of this writing. In the last 9 months they have mostly dropped half in price. These 10 watt white LEDs can be bought for about $1.40 off EBay. The compelling reason for learning to build you own lights is flexibility and safety. You must know how to use a soldering iron. Here's a video on soldering. Let me know if you need more help with soldering.

Common tools used. The tools on the bottom from left to right are wire strippers, needle nose pliers, clippers (I'm lost without them) and forceps which are nice for surface mount work. The wire is stranded 22 gauge. The solder is 0.032 inch. You can pick up a cheap soldering iron at Radio Shack but the more expensive units are far superior.

My soldering iron is temperature controlled by changing tips. It'll go from 600-800 degrees F and I always have it set to 800 degrees for fast consistency. I'd rather go cheap on a multimeter than a soldering iron if you're going to do a lot of soldering. Speaking of which, a cheap digital multimeter should be another tool you should have. Just plan on $20. I checked a wide variety of cheap digital multimeters and none was off by more than 3% compared to a Fluke 287 with a fresh NIST tracable calibration.

I say the same thing about cheap digital light meters. A group I tested where good enough for white light sources and in the $20 range. I just bought a $13 one to work with an integration sphere for white light sources and for quick general measurements. It'll be calibrated to a NIST traceable spectrometer, though



The simplest way: SAG, just tell me how to do it without all the extra stuff!

Get a 10 watt warm white LED

Get a power supply

Get a heat sink

Boom, baby-you're in business. You still need to solder. With bigger LEDs like the 100 watt ones get power supplies that are rated at about 1/2 to 2/3rds current levels. The thermal load is easier to manage, the LEDs will last longer and they'll be significantly more electrically efficient at lower drive currents.



A few useful links:

Ohm's Law calculator. You need to know Ohm's Law but the resistive circuit analysis is all we need. You'll learn this below. Ignore the time varying and reactive circuits in the wiki link.

how to soldering video Let me know if you need more help with soldering.

1-3 amp buck converters. I love these- they make good PC fan speed controllers.

150 watt dc-dc boost converter. I replace the capacitors. The stock capacitors have a high fail rate when driving higher voltage white LEDs.

LED power supplies on ebay PM me if you need help finding what's best for you.

LM317 in constant current mode.. Take 1.25, divide by the resistor in ohms and that how many amps you get.

I keep a stock of 1.3 ohm, 2 ohm and 2.2 ohm, two watt resistors on hand.



The build We'll do a quick constant voltage so some stuff can be explained and then go in to a more appropriate constant current set up.

1---bend side terminals up and melt some solder on them. Pre-soldering makes soldering the wire much easier. Bending the terminals up a little makes sire they don't contact the heat sink.

2---up close shot of soldered terminal

3---up close shot without solder

4---put a thin layer of heat grease on the back of the LED. Radio shack will have plenty of varieties. [You just need the cheap stuff.] (http://www.radioshack.com/product/index.jsp?productId=15438946) ignore the comment, it lasts long term

5----mount them to the heat sink middle of the heat sink. Use aluminum stock 1/8th inch thick, 1 1/2-2 inches wide and 8-10 inches long. There's a few ways of doing this. Screws and washers, screws that fit the out indentations, screws that fit in the small holes, 5 minute epoxy around the edges (I often do this), thermal epoxy, adhesive thermal pads. If you use 5 minute epoxy, give it 5 hours to cure otherwise you'll end up with a gooey mess.

6---optionally mount the buck converter to the heat sink with a spacer. Those are 4-40 screws that Home Depot should have.

7---shot of heat sink, 1 ohm resistor and buck converter before every thing is solder. Pre-soldering everything makes soldering components together easier. Once done solder everything together. <NOTE TO SELF- put up a schematic here>

8---As mentioned, we'll play with constant voltage first. Apply at least 12 volts to the primary side of the buck converter. You can use an old lap top computer supply, 12 volt "wall wart" or the like.

Spin that little screw on the blue, rectangular potentiometer about 20 complete turns counter clockwise. This will ensure the output voltage is a minimum. Measure the voltage across the one ohm resistor. Turn the screw clockwise until it reads 0.7 volts. This will mean 0.7 amps of current are flowering through the circuit. The LED will be quite bright at this point. Wear sunglasses or put an object in front of the LED to block the light from your eyes.

As a build hint, wait 15 minutes for everything to warm up and reach thermal equilibrium and then redial the voltage is down to .7 amps which is 70% of the current and call it good for a very simple set up. I like the 4 second rule- if you can keep your finger on the heat sink for 4 seconds then you're good to go. I do run some 100 watt LEDs this way but with a thermal cut out switch (another article).



constant current

I'll do LEDs constant voltage but I mostly do constant current. It all has to do with thermal runaway. The hotter the LED gets the lower the voltage drop across the LED. This allows more current to flow. This extra heat from the increased current causes a further voltage drop across the LED that allows even more current to flow. The device may heat up to the point of destroying itself. That's thermal runaway in a nutshell.

This is why we use a constant current source with LEDs- when the LEDs get hotter and the voltage drop decreases, instead of allowing more current to flow, the voltage to the LED is dropped to maintain a consistent current. No thermal runaway.

Now, you can buy constant current power supplies and just be done with it. But, in future projects we'll be modulating the LEDs for experimentation and dynamic spectrum controllable lighting using the Arduino microcontroller or in analog only.

We start with removing the 1 ohm power resistor and solder in a LM317 with a 2 ohm resistor. Since there's a constant 1.25 volts dropped across the resistor, 1.25 volts / 2 ohms = 0.612 amps. Around a 60-65% current levels is about what the experiment board can handle with a single 10 watt LED.

lm317 set up with the 1 ohm resistor removed

lm317 up close

lm2596 removed If you have a 12-15 volt power supply then you can get rid of the lm2596 and just use the LM317.

LED on It can be very intense on the eyes



some LM317 resistor values (amps, resistor value, resistor wattage rating)

1.25 amps    1 ohm        2 watt

1 amp        1.25 ohm     2 watt

0.7 amp      1.79 ohm     2 watt

0.63 amp     2 ohm        2 watt

0.5 amp      2.5 ohm      1 watt

0.31 amp     4 ohm        1 watt

0.25 amp     5 ohm        1 watt

0.125 amp    10 ohm       1/2 watt

Remember, you can use multiple resistors in series and/or parallel to hit the amperage you want.



So, ask for clarifications or things I should add to above. Working with 100 watt LEDs, a bit on side lighting, low cost DIY heat sink design and temperature control will be the next article.


r/HandsOnComplexity • • Aug 04 '21

Testing the most dangerous light (bloom plus grow BP1000) so far and why I'm such a cynic against shills

142 Upvotes

Testing the most dangerous light so far and some strong criticism

part of SAG's Lighting Guide

This is the light tested:

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B082Y1PMWF?psc=1&ref=ppx_yo2_dt_b_product_details

As a disclaimer, as always, I bought this light myself so there is no conflict of interest.

edit- spelling and just a bit of wordwmithing



The electrical safety test

Click the link on the light above and look at the one star ratings. What do you see? A bunch of people getting electrical shocks and the light overheating. When I first examined the light the first thing I noticed was some plastic insulators like this that immediately raised a red flag.

https://imgur.com/a/ZBKR8E3

Upon really close inspection I noticed that there was a thermal pad between the heat sink and the MCPCB (metal core printed circuit board and where all the parts are mounted). A thermal pad provides electrical insulation.

https://imgur.com/a/Azrfxdc

Hmmm....what's going on here? To confirm my suspicion I tested for continuity between the MCPCB and the heat sink and found them to be electrically isolated. So we have an energized circuit board that is not grounded although most people who don't know how to properly test lights would not notice, with a very thin plastic film over the energized components that does not provide adequate ingress protection, creating a situation that will get people killed although the light does appear grounded.

It's bullshit like this that is going to get people killed, and why I have an issue with people who have no idea what they are doing performing light "tests". How many of these YouTubers, who look like they know what they are doing by waving a light meter under a light, do you think would actually catch this fatal flaw in this light? None of them would because as far as I know none of them are properly trained or understand electrical safety.

You want to see a YouTuber who gets electrical safety? Check out the fellow electrician Big Clive.

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCtM5z2gkrGRuWd0JQMx76qA

I didn't even need to do a light meter test because what's the point if I'd never recommend the light in the first place. I did, though, and about eight inches away from the center is the 1000 umol/m2/sec point.



Thermal imaging pics

Here's some thermal shots of the light tested:

https://imgur.com/a/nkfLHb2 (2 thermal pics)

It's important to note that on the backside of the light, in the pic with my thermal imaging camera, the light appears to be fairly cool with a hot spot on the label. What's going on? The heat sink has a very low emissivity while that label has a very high emissivity that gives a true temperature reading. This is the problem with using cheap non-contact thermometers.

The light measures 70 degrees F above ambient and my rule is that a grow light should never run above 145 degrees F. This is a partial failure and why people are getting burns off the light beyond electrical shocks. I say partial failure because a small fan could keep the temperature down. Heat kills LEDs faster.



Spectroradiometer pics

https://imgur.com/a/FUrXAn8 (2 spectrometer pics)

The first pic is my spectroradiometer in "scope" mode which gives me a raw output. The second pic is what's called a "second order derivative" which is used in analytical chemistry and really allows me to get in close and analyze the phosphors used. Every major downward dip is a different phosphor so these modern white LEDs have a lot more going on that what is shown in the data sheets. I use the same technique to analyze pigments and some proteins in plant leaves.

I'm not aware of anyone on the internet outside academia that gets into actually analyzing the phosphors in LEDs, let alone analyzing pigments and proteins.



What's under the hood

https://imgur.com/a/fBEVeHA (4 under the hood pics)

The line and neutral are going through power resistors, which is then rectified, smoothed out with a capacitor, and this higher voltage DC is then fed to the LEDs though linear current regulators in parallel. If you want to make something cheap and dangerous then this is the way to do it. The capacitor is going to be a major fail point particularly at higher temperatures.



MY RANT (and why I'm such a cynic)

The layman gets so impressed with people waving a light meter under a light, maybe doing a grid test, but none of them are doing a safety test to see if the light is going to kill people. I could probably train a monkey to wave a light meter under a light. That's hyperbole of course, but I could train someone in an hour or two to do most any test that you see on YouTube because waving around a light meter is trivial. Right?

Additionally, when I first get a light I'm not making non-sense shills posts on /r/spacebuckets about "herp-a-derp I got this free light, anyone else have this one? I'm going to put a plant under it and keep making a bunch more posts of this free light. Because it's free advertisement for this person who gave me a free light, and I'm too corrupt to get it. I'm even going to do shout outs to the person who gave it to me for free because fuck it, I got a free light and everyone has a price, mine just happens to be low". It's hard to be unbiased when receiving free stuff, and non-sense to compare lights when the lighting levels are not known, right?

This shilling problem was so bad on /r/microgrowery, at one point around 2016 with the mods receiving free lights, posts were being removed and people banned for promoting other lights. There are good reasons I'm proudly banned from /r/microgrowery for calling out non-sense. /r/microgrowery was quite literally founded on corruption, and the original mod was given the boot when publicly called out. When I started making waves about direct sidebar links to pirated grow books, a practice that Reddit admins would not allow today, the current head mod (Codine) threatened to sabotage my lighting guide with misinformation, which is why I made my own subreddit to protect the integrity of my lighting guide (PMs are forever archived!). This all sounds pretty corrupt, right?

The mods of /r/hydroponics were allowing stickied posts by MarsHydro, and MarsHydro was deleting posts on their own subreddit about people getting electrical shocks off their lights which others have confirmed to me about the electrical shock issue. It's very fair to ask, what's in it for the mods? MarsHydro also plays the non-sense "600w" game which is highly misleading. That sounds pretty corrupt, right?

In 2007 I was active with GreenPineLane, the first forum dedicated solely to LED grow lights. The head mod received a free 100 true watt light that had LEDs that were 15% efficient. The person who gave him the light claimed it would perform as well as a 400 watt HPS that would be around 30% efficient. The mod claimed this seemed right after trying to grow a single tomato plant. But I did some severe call outs because we all know that this would be utter non-sense and therefore corrupt, right?

The first grow light on the market was the LGM5 by Solaroasis that used 5 mm low power LEDs and cost well over $30 per watt. source. The person was claiming this 6-9 watt low power light could compete with HPS. When put to the test it could barely grow a tomato seedling without sever elongation. Complete and utter bullshit, right?

Eric Biksa, a public figure so there is no Reddit TOS violation, was writing in Maximum Grow magazine in early 2008 that LED lights were 10-20 times better than HPS while also claiming to be a world class hydro expert at age 24 despite no training. In summer 2008 in response to his non-sense, I wrote a 3000 word essay calling him and the whole LED grow light industry out for being founded on fraud at the time which can be seen here (a huge mistake was saying little light energy was converted to mass when I really meant that photosynthesis itself was very inefficient). The editor loved the essay because she wanted balance in the claims, the publisher hated it because he did not want to upset the LED grow light manufactures who bought advertisement space, so instead of an article it was published as a letter to the editor (it only meant I would not be paid $500 for the essay which was not the point). That would have been pretty corrupt of the publisher, right?

LEDGirl of HydroGrowLED fame was claiming in 2009 that she could get 2 grams per watt and in 2015 that she could get 4 times the yield per watt over HPS. I called her out in real life and believe me, LEDGirl is just as much as an unstable nutcase IRL as she is online. Four times the yield per watt over HPS is a corrupt non-sense claim even by today's standards, right?

I've seen MIGRO straight up grab energized circuit boards without a ground and handle it carelessly. That's either suicidal or a person who is utterly clueless on safety (people in the comments were trying to warn him). He'll also tell people to remove the covers from LED light bulbs which is very dangerous. He's first and foremost a salesman and acting grossly irresponsible, right? (I have many critiques of MIGRO, including having a weak grasp on actual theory, such as making up his own units like PPFD/W(???) and not understanding efficacy vs efficiency as well as being a bit naive on science in general, but I believe he basically operates in good faith for a salesman- he's also good at waving light meters around).

LEDTonic sells a cheap generic light that is twice the price per watt than any other light, and says 12 watts of cheap LEDs per square foot is adequate. source. This is one of the worst deals I've ever seen in all of LED grow lighting. Don't do business with people, who in my opinion, are scammers. Once a scammer always a scammer, right?

MostlySafe is such bullshit that he claims he created the whole concept of space buckets and used to sell homemade shoddy quality $600 space buckets! archived. He literally doxxed me when I called him out. That's pretty fucking cowardly, right?

If you're publicly shilling a free light then you are fair game for criticism, and I will publicly call you out on it, because you made it public. I've been calling people out for ten years on Reddit, have been doxxed three times for it so far, I've literally lawyered up when legal threats were made by MostlySafe against me and three other people including the head mod on /r/spacebuckets, and I'm not going to change. Nobody is going to control my or anybody else's hobby, right?

I have never accepted a free light, I'm not trying to sell anything, never done affiliate links, don't make any money off my guide, back my claims with links to hundreds of sources, back my claims with calibrated lab gear if I don't have another source, and I'm guessing I'm doing something right with over 5,000 subscribers. When I first wrote my lighting guide I was telling people not to use LED grow lights for commercial purposes because back then LEDs could not compete with HPS, which I received a lot of criticism for, and it would have been corrupt to say otherwise. Right...?



Affiliate links

You'll see people promoting lights with affiliate links. Most of the time they have never tested those lights and it's all bullshit if that's the case. They are less interested in the truth, and are more interested in a sale. Not all of them, but most of them. I understand some affiliate links keeps some websites going. But if people are writing lighting guides full of affiliate links then how can they truly be unbiased? Enough said.



N=1 and how not to do a test

N=1 means the plant count (population number) used in a test. It's complete non-sense to only use a single plant because you are not going to catch false positives and false negatives known as type 1 and type 2 errors.

Here is a YouTube video that uses an N=1 test that has over 800,000 views by Albo Pepper:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sfihE4IuFuU

It's such non-sense that the plant under the CFL light was allowed to dry out. How is this even remotely a legitimate test? What does this say about the person performing the test? You'll see stuff like this all the time on YouTube. IS THIS THE BEST GROW LIGHT OF <insert year here>!!!! Non-sense. What does best grow light even mean?

Even in academia, I was once volunteering at a plant growth lab to get some hands on lab experience. I open up a $300,000 plant growth chamber, picked up a tray of arabidopsis thaliana (a model plant used in botany), and they were all dried out. Photosynthesis shuts down before wilting happens. How can this be a legitimate test with such sloppy procedures? Non-sense.

Bruce Bugbee discusses this problem and how hard it can be to do a legitimate test. I've never seen a legitimate test done in the hobby community. The conditions must be identical, and Bugbee himself articulates this and how hard large scale cannabis testing can be. Almost always seedlings are used in tests because clones, being genetically identical, can hide type one and two errors if they have specific mutations. Seedlings provide a little bit of genetic variability so your test does not get stuck in some type one or type two error.

How many plants do you need for a test? N=7 would be the absolute minimum for p<0.05 at power = 0.8 for a SN = 1.6. This is what I was taught at the plant growth lab I volunteered at. Most tests are done with dozens of plants if not hundreds of plants, though. This applies for lighting tests, root tests, or any other type of grow chamber plant test. Arabidopsis thaliana is a tiny long day plant with an eight week life cycle, which is one reason why it's used as a model plant beyond having many variants available with specific genes knocked out. It's also why seedlings are sometimes used in studies, and you can get N>100 in even small containers that will fit in a space bucket.

N>100 microgreen radish seedlings in two gallon space buckets under a table at 2000K, 3000K, and 5000K. 215 uMol/m2/sec, DLI 17 mol/m2/day.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P-value

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power_of_a_test

http://www.3rs-reduction.co.uk/html/6__power_and_sample_size.html



In conclusion

The light above sucks, YouTubers mostly suck, LEDTonic sucks, the doxxer MostlySafe sucks, shills promoting free stuff suck, affiliate link people suck if they have not at least used the lights, corrupt people in general suck, Star Wars episode eight power sucks, auto-tune music sucks, the US army (infantry) sucked, jumping out of a C-130 with a partial parachute malfunction sucked, covid sucks, white supremacists suck, legalizing pot in WA state but not allowing small private recreational grows sucks, the other people who have doxxed me suck, the deer who keep jumping in front of my car suck, the IMF sucks, Star Wars episode eight power sucks again, Jesus cult door knockers suck, that time I did four hits of LSD by myself sucked, that time pepper spray went off in my pocket sucked, the time I had a gout attack and then stubbed my gout swollen toe sucked, and Star Wars episodes one and nine also sucked (but not as bad as episode eight, it's a scientific fact that episode five was the best).