r/goodyearwelt • • Feb 28 '24

Review Buying Red Wing boots in Red Wing, Minnesota

0 Upvotes

I traveled across the US to buy a pair of boots in Red Wing, MN. I was hoping I'd be able to look at all the shoes, to discuss the leathers, soles, and laces to learn about the different options. I thought I'd get to see how they were made, perhaps even talk to one of the shoemakers. I was certain I'd get to watch the craftsmanship and handiwork of the experienced cobblers as they made the shoes. I'd assumed I'd get some measurements of my feet, and maybe even get to personalize my own pair with branding or stitching.

Instead, there was two retail employees who were both about 18 years old, who were entirely clueless about all of the boots, couldn't answer a single one of my questions, neither of them were even wearing Red Wing shoes, in fact they were both dressed like they just got out of middle school gym class. They told me uncertainly that one of the factories had shut down, and some production had been moved overseas. Many of their boots were made in Missouri now, they said. The factory in Red Wing is essentially now just used as a warehouse, for storage, although they apparently still make some of the heritage shoes there. But no one can tour it or see inside, ever since COVID, they said.

They couldn't make up for their lack of brand/shoe knowledge with their skill in sales either, showing absolutely zero interest in helping my find a pair that fit my needs (even though I was the only customer in the whole place). Rather, they asked my size and what shoe I wanted, and then followed up with a very disinterested "Ok, I'll see if we have it in that size". I found that a bit incredulous, for obvious reasons. Further still, they seemed to lack basic social skills and couldn't maintain a conversation.

The experience was identical, and I mean 100% identical to walking into any budget mall shoe store.

I still ended up buying a pair of Iron Rangers as I found that they had some "factory seconds" in the basement which were my size - mistake pairs that were heavily discounted, but seemed to me to be in nearly perfect condition. After all, I traveled all that way... I really hope the shoes make up for the soul-crushing experience.


r/goodyearwelt • • Jul 03 '18

Question Our brief side of the story and an insider view of who we are and what we stand for.

2 Upvotes

I’m sure today’s episode will be marked as the day John Doe Shoes got a fatal blow for the GYW community. Just to close the topic on our end at least, of what originated this meltdown. We would never bully a customer, we respect them and we are forever grateful that people pour they trust and money in our products. The OP made some statements basically attacking JDS and many people have done that here and we have never replied the way we did yesterday. Because both statements were simply not true and I’m not talking about subjective stuff. We were accused of increasing our prices for the pay 2 get 3 deal, completely false we actually decreased the price of some items. It was implied we were not using Horween, again false and I can prove it. Then there was the issue with the boots, at that point I haven’t seen the pictures I just saw the message of the customer implying we don’t use Horween and that their 3 pair of boots were a disaster. So far, we have had only one issue with a pay 2 get 3 order from lots of orders we have sold since we launched the deal. So, I knew it was him.

Stack all our interactions and I’m sure many people would have thought this was personal. Turns out the boots are indeed in really bad shape, but by the time I got to see the pictures it was already too late and a witch hunt had started, yesterday it was the OP who was being attacked today it’s me. I believe there were things that could have been done better by both sides, but it’s my company the one who has more things to lose out of this situation. So in my opinion that’s what happened in the last 2 days.

Since I’ve been accused of lots of things some true some just overly exaggerated, I’m here to be transparent of what actually happens and who we are, for whoever wants to get the whole picture and not just hop on the hate bandwagon towards John Doe Shoes without knowing all the facts.

When we started 5 years ago we hired a workshop that makes goodyear welted cowboys boots, wait, cheap goodyear welted cowboy’s boots. I took them a pair of John Lobbs and told them this is what I want. Of course I knew we were not getting something similar in any way, but it was just like something to inspire them and for them to try to replicate as much as possible. So, they didn’t have experience making oxfords or casual boots, the leathers they work with are cheap and finally they were in a dire financial situation, which was the real reason they accepted making me a handful of pairs.

Our first shoes were goodyear welted but that was it, not nice leathers not nice finishing. It was jut like a very pedestrian and somewhat poorly finished shoe with a goodeyar welt construction. 5 years have passed from those days. We have heavily invested in the company with new machines, courses and tools and loans to cover the payroll. Up to the point where we have this strange deal where now we actually own a part of the factory and control over our line of production. It wasn’t our objective and I really wanted none of it, but it seemed the only way to really push the buttons that will make us get where we want to be.

Along the way we have improved many things and if I put side by side a 5 year old JDS and a new one it will be day and night.

The things that prevent us from delivering a great pair of shoes 99.999% of the time are:

People who know how to make goodeyar welted shoes are usually old and they get sick often or they literally die. Nowadays workforce, well they don’t seek to make a career in goodyear welt shoemaking. They work at huge factories of mass produced cemented shoes and they work there just for a while. Finding a replacement for a worker who stops working for whatever reason is extremely hard and it takes a lot of time.

As I said before, these guys had been making cheap cowboys boots for 20 years or more prior to making our shoes. We have come a really long way in the quality output, but old habits die hard and they keep making cheap footwear so just as they are quite forgiving, passing by defects on that footwear they sometimes are the same way with JDS footwear.

This leads to the next step. I can’t be as pushy or hard with our workers as I would like. They are aware of the huge leverage they have, they can be hired by another goodyear welt company in a heartbeat (it has already happened). Of course, we have taken measures to make ourselves more attractive like a better salary, an incentives program, social security you name it. But it’s still complicated. So yeah, they mess things up from time to time and I must be more patient than I would like to.

Up to this point I have to say we have an awesome workforce and I’m extremely proud of what we have achieved together in these 5 years. Some of these guys are god damn artists and certainly could be working at whatever super high end brand you can think of. If I had to describe a batch of 10 JDS that come out of the production line, I would say 3 are perfect and spotless, 3 with just very minor cosmetic defects, 2 with some cosmetic defects like maybe a little natural scar in the shaft or a not fully punched brogue, 1 with a really obvious cosmetic defect like the shaft being a very different tone because it might come from a different hide and one with a structural defect that would compromise the footwear longevity over time.

That’s where I come in to stop those last pairs from getting to the customer. I personally check 90% of the shoes we ship. And apparently since we have been getting better and better over time, I became over complacent and I stopped checking them as thoroughly as when we used to have a higher rate of mistakes. So, today’s meltdown is totally on me and a huge lesson for the future.

It’s certainly a tough day for us, but we have been here before. The day a famous website posted a review of our first shoes and they were like, meeh you are only getting a goodyear welted payless shoe, shop somewhere else, the day I forgot to answer an unsatisfied customer and he came here to protest and we had to own the fact we failed. The day a huge shipment of leather disappeared, and we lost thousands of dollars, because the insurance only covered a small part of it.

Every company and every person eventually face tough defining moments through their life. As I have said ad nauseam we are here for the long run, it hurts today but we will be back better as we have already done it in the past. I understand if a lot of people are just fed up of JDS and for the ones who still consider us an option. When you buy from us it always end up in on of these scenarios A) with a hell of a shoe on your hands B) maybe not the shoe you were expecting but with a hell of a deal if you write us an explain your concerns C ) with 100% of your money back and at least a dedicated, responsive and accommodating customer service.

I know any internet community needs a poster boy to pour hate. Today it’s us and people are like stay away from these douches go for “x” brand and I’m like wasn’t there a post a couple of months ago about that “x” brand having an extremely lousy and sneaky customer service? Naah dude JDS sucks, go for some tried and tested “Y” brand. Wait, wasn’t “Y” brand being attacked because they have decreased the quality of their shoes while increasing their prices? I’m in no way saying we are better than other brands. Every brand will have their strengths and weaknesses. I hope my long post has been useful to showcase ours and people know what they will get if they choose us.


r/goodyearwelt • • Aug 30 '18

Sale Inspect your Allen Edmonds Shoes That Were Bought on The Sale

32 Upvotes

Bought a pair of brown Normandy’s for ~$250, after the 30% deal.

They arrived two days after I ordered them, and upon opening the box looking at the shoes, there were scratches and blemishes everywhere. Note, I did not buy a pair of factory seconds, I ordered the brand new version.

All signs of defects that I found point to the shoe being used prior to being shipped to me.

Scratches on the boots, sole is worn, etc.

Your shoes might’ve not been affected, but it doesn’t hurt to check. Already sent them back for return the same day.

Evidence

Edit: don’t know why I’m getting downvoted.


r/goodyearwelt • • Jan 29 '19

Question [Update] my mismatching Viberg boot problem, and why I'm done buying Viberg products.

0 Upvotes

Original post here

Photos of the box etc I received in exchange are here. After I posted in December and thought about it, I decided that I wouldn't feel comfortable wearing those boots in bright sunlight, when the two shades of color could be clearly made out.

Here's a timeline:

  • Dec 14 bought the boots

  • Dec 22 sent Viberg pics of the boots and asked for their opinion

  • Jan 6 hadn't heard back yet, sent another email

  • Jan 8 sent some more pics figured maybe they needed them

  • Jan 11 I finally saw Viberg's phone number - it's on only one page on their web site - and called them. I didn't get an email reply until I called - almost a month after my first email.

After the call I was finally contacted by email by Christian and told that Viberg was just catching up on their emails. Ok I get that, but a month??

I was also told that the two different colors of these boots is a normal variation. I told them that I understand there is some variation in Shell but a toe box that so greatly contrasts with the rest of the boot stands out a lot more than the side of a boot that doens't quite match up.

Ok so we disagreed on that.

Christan also agreed to cover return shipping but was careful to state why: "As an apology for taking so long to reply, we will cover the exchange shipping for you." (actual quote from Christan)

In other words, "Viberg agrees to cover the cost of the exchange shipping but not because of the color mismatch, which we consider normal." (my interpretation, not an actual quote)

I just received the exchange:

  • The blue Viberg box is not just ripped but broken in - it must have been opened and closed literally tens of times.

  • The boot bags are filthy

  • And in my opinion there's a problem with the side of one boot's sole, it's a bit cracked.

I don't expect petty responses from professional companies, whether their boots cost $1200 or $12. Edit, to be clear I'm saying they shipping me dirty boot bags in a busted up box in response to the issues I had previously raised. In the US we call this "telling a customer to fuck off."

edit, oh and they didn't cover the cost of the return exchange shipping as we agreed, so I'm also out $50. Way to be petty.


r/goodyearwelt • • Oct 22 '22

Review John Lofgren Combat Boots - "the cons of online purchasing"

3 Upvotes

Pics: https://imgur.com/a/LvTE3BO

Ordered these on 15 November 2021 from S&S and received the first pair one week later.

Price: 940 USD (including DHL shipping).

Build: John Lofgren Combat Boots in Olive CXL (1ST Boots) / Dark Olive CXL (2nd Boots)

Size and fit: 11E; they fit like an 11 EE Redwing IRs.

Story time: Back then I was kinda new to high-end boots and was buying everything that I liked on line; I had already bought various MTO boots from various American and Asian bootmakers and couldn’t wait the 3-10 months period, when I saw these on Standard and Strange I bought them instantly.

I placed the order and chose the size I was wearing in Redwing IR; luckily, these are wider and they fit my feet way better than the Iron rangers.

I received the first boots one week or so after I placed the order and as soon as I opened the box, I was shocked and sickened by the sight of the loose grain on the right boot.

(The photos I’ve attached were taken literally 10 seconds after I opened the box)

I directly emailed “standard and strange” with photos showing the loose grain, she replied that this is normal in Horween CXL leathers, (I know that CXL is prone to creasing, but this is not creasing).

S&S gave me the option of returning them and have them replaced with another pair, which I did (I paid the expedited UPS as I’m not in USA). I asked her to send me photos of the replacement pair before shipping it to me.

S&S sent me photos prior to shipping the replacement boots and told me that this pair “also has grain break”, what she was referring to is creasing at the shaft, which will be under the jeans, so I didn’t care about it; however, the photos were taken in a dark place and she never mentioned that it’s a different color, I simply thought because there’s no light the boots looked darker; also, she didn’t mention that the captoe is crooked.

After around 2 weeks, I received the second pair, which was in a different color, (olive VS dark olive).

The boots also have a crooked captoe…

Having paid close to 1200 USD (between shipping and original price) I simply accepted my fate.

If you want to look past the obvious, the boots are very well made, they smell good, the fit is good, stitching and clicking are good.

I however, cannot ignore all what I’ve experienced purchasing these boots and as a result, in the past 10 months I’ve worn them 3-4 times only.


r/goodyearwelt • • Jan 26 '20

Question Are We Screwing Our Feet?

29 Upvotes

Hey all. I’ve been excited (okay, obsessed) with building out my boot collection, until running into a wall. I started reading about the benefits of minimalist shoes which promote a more natural, barefoot-style way of walking. AKA “Zero Drop” footwear. Apparently wearing flat (no heel) shoes with ultra wide toe boxes can prevent and/or fix many joint and spinal issues. It made me question every single pair of boots I own, and am eyeing to purchase. I want a pair of chunky-healed White’s goddammit! But, could it be that we’re all screwing our ankles, knees, and lower backs with this fetish?

You can checkout some of the articles I read: Lose Your Shoes and The Best Batefoot Shoes.... A google search would turn up many others, and many pertain strictly to running shoes, but it’s clear the concept applies universally to all footwear.

Some examples of the companies making footwear for the barefoot way of life are Prime Trotter, Vivo Barefoot, Lem’s Shoes, Softstar.

No, these are not boots you dream of owning, or donning at work, or at your next party. Some are downright embarrassing!! But ... knee braces, walkers and wheel chairs aren’t making it to the cover of GQ or Vogue either folks.

Thoughts? Any other brands you know of, along the lines of Prime Trotter, that are striking the balance? Most importantly, does White’s or Truman do zero-drop?!! (Don’t answer that).


r/goodyearwelt • • Mar 25 '24

General Discussion Disposable Shoes: There's room in every collection

0 Upvotes

I'm into GYW boots/shoes for the same reasons as everyone else: when you get to a certain age, you start to value things that are not disposable goods. I get it.

However, there is a reason why we live in a disposable society: because it's more economical to do so. 99% of the people out there just wear regular foam and cemented construction shoes because it makes economic sense, and even practical sense when it comes to athletic and hiking footwear. Even Rose Anvil surprised me when he said that his go-to shoe working in his workshop is a pair of disposable Blundstone chelseas.

When I want to wear a good shoe, I wear a properly made GYW boot. But there are times where I'm in a situation where I don't want to be wearing my finest boots/shoes, and that's where a "disposable" shoe/boot is really the go-to shoe, eg. a pair of Doc Martens. I also find that there are some events that are so infrequent that I would never wear out a sole: and these are the perfect events to buy a cheaper "disposable" shoe for.

Then there are times where I'm running errands at Walmart, and I don't care to be wearing nice boots/shoes, and these are also the perfect time to wear out a disposable shoe, rather than wearing out a nice GYW boot.

So why am I bothering to write all of this? Because I was thinking that there are some shoes out there that get a lot of negative press that don't deserve it. For example, Doc Martens - sure they are disposable shoes and don't compare to proper GYW boots, but maybe they don't have to compare? Yes, they have weak foam midsoles, but if you think of them as disposable - once the sole wears out, you just chuck out the shoe so the foam longevity doesn't matter. I think they have their uses if you intend them NOT for high-wear activities (eg. casual occasions). If you want a particular type of shoe for a particular occasion, then you need to buy pairs of shoes for each of these occasions and it's not cheap if these are all expensive GYW boots.

Then there's regular classic sneakers like Reeboks, and it makes way more sense buying a pair of those instead of Common Projects, since for less than $100 you could just get a new pair of Reeboks with new clean leather instead of wasting time trying to maintain the leather of the CP sneakers.

All of this is to balance the stuff we read and watch on youtube. It sometimes seems that we all gotta get on the bandwagon and laugh at disposable shoes, but the more I think of it, the more obvious it is that a balanced viewpoint is kinder to your wallet and arguably more fun too.


r/goodyearwelt • • Sep 29 '23

Review Hand-made Chosen One by Iron Boots in Seidel Bison

5 Upvotes

This is my 1st post ever, so apologies in advance for not knowing the format and/or offending anyone with my comments. Having learnt so much from generous web people that have shared their insights, I feel that I have a perspective that is not normally discussed.

Ever so often there is talk about buying a pair of leather boots as an investment. What does this mean? To an ex-banker like me, "investment" usually refers to buying something in the hope of a profit later on. A better definition, especially with boots, would be FOMO (either missing out completely or having to buy it at a much higher price later). Also, don't forget the satisfaction of handling, wearing & growing with the boots which for collectors is the real fear - not having that experience!

With this Chosen One, Iron Boots were happy to make one up just for me, in about 3 mths!? MTO's usually mean batch processing, min orders, economies of scale etc. One pair is bespoke style. Not just me apparently, everyone can be treated special too. How long can Iron Boots keep this up and the prices down? Other MTO bootmakers of this calibre usually have waiting lists and production times in excess of a year! Worth investing!

But if there is increasing demand why not just increase supply? That is the problem, demand is really limited to the few growing collectors; it is the supply of the raw materials and the skilled labour that forms the bottleneck. Of course production can be automated but the more automation, the less attractive the boot is to collectors. "All Iron Boots are fully handmade by Kaishu Zhang (Founder) and 5 teammates together in a small shop. They are built in handwelt or hand stitchdown, with channelled insole construction, which are stronger and last longer than normal Goodyear welted shoes/boots made by machines. Each pair is 100% hand welted, hand last, hand bottomed, and also hand-sewn outsole stitch." How many can they make by hand? Demographics everywhere has everyone short staffed. Investment boots surely!

As for materials, Iron Boots has a long list of different leathers, from Russian Reindeer to French Calf. Bison is the leather of my Chosen One and there are only two surviving species of Bison left in the world. Limited supply? Whichever leather you choose, think about where the leathers comes from. Competition for the land to graze the bovines, from Developers, Factories not to mention ever expanding residential, means smaller and smaller yields of leather material at this quality. The big boys such as LVMH have locked up their supply in advance and thus control the volume, quality and pricing of what the rest of the market can get. Monopolies are great for investment!

Unlike high-end boots, leather goods such as ladies' handbags, men's wallets & belts & other high end leather accessories are ever popular and very profitable and thus compete for the very same raw leather material that boots are made of. This is one of the reasons why LVMH and the rest of the industry, have bought out several high-end tanneries - something called vertical integration and supply chain integrity. What happens when more and more tanneries are locked up? Prices for raw materials will inevitably go up.

This Chosen One's leather is produced by the 4th Gen family run Seidel Tannery from Milwaukee, USA. There are only a handful of Tanneries left with such expertise in America. With all the Woke & environmental pressures, it is hard to see Seidel increasing supply as it is located next to high-end condos near the banks of the Milwaukee River. In fact, they have given up raw tanning (the yuppies in the condos don't like the smell apparently?) and buy in wet blue stock instead. Efficiency & substitution is a slippery slope to the end of tradition. Collectors invest in tradition.

Finally, we come to the country of manufacture - China. Other than the few boot collectors who are aware of the handful of chinese bootmakers, China-made boots at this price range, are not really in demand, yet. This Chosen One features :-

• high SPI (depends on construction, usually 7-10)

• Handwelted stitchdown with fudging (usually machine Goodyear welted)

• wool as filler (instead of cork)

• leather shank (instead of steel)

• leather as stiffener for both toe and heel (instead of plastic/cardboard)

• extremely high quality leather lining (similar of some competitor's upper leather)

My Chosen One are as well made and maybe even better than most of the other boots in my collection. Quality is not the problem here but rather the perception of chinese quality. Most American boot collectors will prefer to buy USA-made boots, most Europeans will stay within their own country of manufacture while the Asians (ex-Japan) are only just beginning to get the boot bug. They will have no problem buying chinese-made boots and when they do, these boots will become investment grade triple-plus. Heck what am I talking about - just wait until the chinese themselves in China realise what is on their doorstep!

As a collector, I feel that Iron Boots Chosen One is a good investment for all the reasons mentioned. In fact, I don't see how they can make it cheaper than the US$800 I paid in Jan 2023. If I am right, the same boots will either be priced higher in future, become more rare (increased production time) and/or cease to exist in this current form (material or production changes - usually for efficiency or substitution). If so, then I have made a great investment!

TL:DR: The Chosen One Iron Boots are a great investment.


r/goodyearwelt • • Nov 22 '24

Review Groundies Panama Sneaker 6 week review

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

I bought these Groundies Panama sneakers 6 weeks ago. I wanted to try a barefoot shoe which wasn't absolutely vomit inducing in terms of looks and in my research I found Groundies. It is a German brand which makes their shoes in Portugal, which is essencial as I am European. I got these for 120€ including shipping instead of the 130€+10€ shipping, due to a coupon found on couponbirds.com.

I come from a background of wearing leather dress shoes and having a passion for shoes so I want to give my opinion based on my knowledge.

I measured my feet and my largest foot is 27,5cm long and 10,5cm wide. I chose a size 44, which was 29cm long and about 10cm wide. The shoes came in a box: no extra laces or other goodies. They fit reasonably well and I the anatomic last is very comfortable for walking, but I've bought a size 45 since then and, even though they have excess space in terms of length, they are perfect in terms of width. I would choose the size which fits your feet's width, not just look at the length. The last looked less wide on the website's photos but the upper's pattern hides the shape. It could've done it a bit better though, by rotating the suede part on the front. I initially thought the toebox was too low but a single wear proved me wrong. They do look a bit long and clownish if you wear trousers with a small hem. Also, I have feet with a low instel and although they are relatively secure, the eyelets nearly touch each other when I lace them, so they arent the best for my type of feet (super wide and low).

The suede is good quality and easy to clean with a suede eraser. The smooth leather is thin and has some pigment, which shows through the quick creasing. The lasting board is a kind of felt material, perhaps the same as the lining which they say is microfibre. Compared to other sneakers of mine with which I wear a full leather insole, my feet get much more humid at the end of the day, so I rotate them every 3 days. I would love to make my own insoles for them but they didnt come with removable insoles so I cant copy the shape. I wouldve also preferred a leather lining which can absorb the humidity of my feet. A plus is that there is an internal counter cover, albeit it is made of the same (inferior compared to leather) lining.

The lasting board is strobel stitched and the cup soles are sidewall stitched to the upper, which was a pleasant surprise in terms of quality.

The sole seems a bit thin. I understand that these types of shoes are meant to help you feel the ground but I am a bit weary of their durability. For 120€ I expect them to last more than a couple of years. They have also been squeaking a lot, which I dont appreciate.

The laces are good quality but too long and they are hard to tie right now. I suspect this is due to the eyelets being simple holes through the suede as this didnt use to happen to my Idrese sneakers. I like the detail of the loop on the tongue, which means the tongue stays where I want it to.

In conclusion, I like these shoe so far. I think they are a good choice for this niche so far and I hope they can improve their lining quality and consider having a leather lasting board. I hope other brands, specially dress shoe brands, get inspired to make wider shoes with a more anatomic last so I can buy them without having to spend a fortune on bespoke shoes. I want to try JOA Barefoot sneakers next, which should be a step up in terms of materials and quality. What are your thoughts?


r/goodyearwelt • • Mar 08 '25

Review JOA Barefoot Phalanx Review

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

TLDR: I like these sneakers and would buy them again.

Hi guys! I’m delving deeper and deeper into the barefoot casual sneaker world so I decided to try out what I would call a ‘luxury’ brand inside this niche: JOA barefoot. I’ll be comparing it with my other barefoot sneakers from Groundies and with my other normie shaped higher quality sneakers from Idrese. I’m also a classic dress shoe nerd so I’ll also approach this review from that angle.

The website (https://joabarefoot.com/) is clear and simple: you have 1 model of sneaker in various colors and leathers and the price you see is the price you pay, as shipping is included for the world. They offer free exchanges in the EU for the first 30 days after the delivery date. All sneakers cost 175€ in total, and I couldn’t find a discount code after scouring the internet, so that’s what I paid.

Purchasing process and sizing: Starting with the purchasing process, I decided to contact JOA by email with some sizing questions, as my Groundies Panamas in size 44 with the barefoot last are a bit too tight width-wise for my feet, which are 27,5cm long and 10,5cm wide. I was unsure if I should size up, but they responded by saying the size 44 would fit well. I was a bit skeptical at first but, after seeing that my size 45 Groundies were 9.7 cm wide and the JOA 44’s were 10.2cm wide, I gave them a shot. Fortunately, they were right and the width feels pretty spot on, with not a lot of excess room but still roomy enough for me to spread my toes and work out my arch if I want to.

Unboxing: The shoes arrived in a box inside a delivery box. Both are good boxes. Inside I found a thank you note with my name written by hand, a tote bag, a pair of extra white shoelaces and a pair of removable insoles. The insoles are a poron-type material with leather on top. Strangely, the leather was too large for the poron, so I had to cut it with scissors to make them fit inside the shoes. It was a 30 seconds job but something JOA should check during quality control. Overall I liked the unboxing experience.

The shoes: Moving onto the raison d’être of this avis, I was pleasantly surprised with them. The last fits me very well compared to most shoes. I have very low volume feet and, when wearing them with the insoles, I feel very locked in therefore I don’t need to tie my shoelaces too tightly.

The toe box is less tall than the Groundies, so I don’t have too much room to wiggle my toes upwards, but I can splay them comfortably. They are wider than the same sized Groundies on the barefoot last (9,7cm) which I appreciate.

The leather is chrome tanned and on the thinner side, but good quality (it has a distinct “leather” smell). It creases attractively. There is a small patch of grey suede on the top of the heel. The lining is also quite good, probably the same leather. My feet feel significantly less sweaty at the end of the day than when I wear my Groundies sneakers, which is huge for me. The heel counter cover is made out of microfibre, but feels very similarly to suede and locks my heel well, so I don’t know why they chose this when they could’ve chosen suede. I will evaluate the durability during their lifetime. I can’t find a single stitch out of place, so kudos to quality control.

The tongue isn’t gusseted (duh!) and it has a small loop in the middle which means they don’t slide. I love this. I was also shocked when I saw that the eyelets were backed by metal eyelets, which is the first time I see this. I like this compared to full metal eyelets, as the full metal eyelets on my Idrese sneakers rusted and also caught a lot of the hairs of my brush when I cleaned them. The laces fit into the eyelets and are a good size for my feet. I HATE THE LENGTH OF THE GROUNDIES LACES as I’m constantly stepping on the laces and untying them.

The outsole is sidewall stitched to the leather, which is good, but it is much thinner than the Idrese sole which was a Margom outsole. I think this sole is 4mm thick. I’m more into the wide toe box aspect of barefoot shoes than the flexibility or the thin outsole aspects, so I’d prefer a thicker outsole which would be more durable. Why have a sidewall stitch if the soles are going to disintegrate quickly and I have to buy a new sneaker in 1 year’s time? If someone from JOA could tell me if they have a resole service I’d appreciate it, especially since I can easily ship my shoes to a Portuguese factory. One thing that caught me off-guard was the fact that the soles looked slightly light-grayish instead of white when they arrived, which I wasn’t expecting, but after 2 weeks of wear you can’t notice it with the normal wear and tear.

In terms of construction, I can see that they are strobel stitched, have a black material on top of the lasting board and are covered with a thin piece of leather. I don’t know what materials are inside, so JOA could elucidate us on that topic.

In conclusion, I really like these sneakers. They are a bit more expensive than Groundies (you can get them for about 120€ with a discount code), but for the price they look and feel more expensive than Groundies and much closer to the Idrese Nunos than I would’ve thought (which cost 270€ nowadays). Worth 50% more? Personally, yes, especially due to the sleeker and wider last (they definitely don’t look like clown shoes), the extra goodies they came with and, paramountly, because they absorb my sweat much more effectively. I like them so much that I am saving up to buy my 2nd pair, in the sage green sage style. JOA does offer a 10% discount to people who write a review on their website so I’ll be writing a smaller review and linking to this one. I hope this review is useful, and I’d say that I agree with most points of this review (https://barefootuniverse.com/joa-barefoot-review/).


r/goodyearwelt • • Dec 11 '24

Discussion A Footwear Philosophy: Realigning Values: Function, Quality and Sustainability. 

0 Upvotes

A Footwear Philosophy: Realigning Values: Function, Quality and Sustainability. 

by Andrew Turriff

https://www.instagram.com/andrewturriff/?hl=en

The footwear world has become overly focused on aesthetics, and long entrenched industry tradition and convention, very often neglecting the functional needs of the human foot or the shoe's purpose as a tool. While contemporary footwear can be undeniably beautiful, it frequently prioritizes style over function, hindering natural foot movement and contributing to various foot problems which can contribute to further issues throughout the body and musculoskeletal system.

The mass production of disposable “fast fashion” footwear pollutes our planet and ignores the potential of footwear as a tool for enhancing our lives. We need to shift our focus to creating practical high quality footwear that is truly useful. 

We can make footwear that compliments our modern active lifestyle. We can promote healthy feet and bodies by allowing space to spread out in our shoes to promote natural movement. We can also minimize our environmental impact by creating versatile footwear that lasts.

For millennia, footwear served as a simple, practical tool: a shield against harsh terrains and climates. The earliest known footwear was crafted from leather and plant materials, prioritizing function. These primordial shoes were typically minimal and flexible, designed to protect the foot and facilitate movement. 

As civilizations evolved, so too did the purpose of footwear. Elite social classes began wearing decorative shoes as a status symbol, flaunting their wealth and power. The ancient Egyptians, as far back as 3500 BCE, adorned their feet with decorative, heeled footwear. Later in the 10th century CE, the Persian cavalry adopted heeled boots to help stay in their stirrups while riding—long before practical use of the heel for riding morphed into a fashion statement at the expense of practicality and function. Today, shoes continue to be symbols of status and wealth. Marketing campaigns encourage us to use footwear as a way to express ourselves and project a certain image, even if this comes at the cost of our comfort and health or at the expense of the shoe's functionality.

Beyond the fashion industry, even the sub-group of medical and podiatry footwear seems to increasingly prioritize form over function. Shoes marketed as "healthy" or "orthopaedic" often sacrifice fit, comfort, and natural foot movement for aesthetics.

During my five years working in a podiatry clinic making orthopaedic footwear, I observed a growing trend of fashion-focused footwear designs among the footwear intended for people with foot ailments. Brands would rely on marketing and “innovative technology” rather than conventional podiatry principles to sell their products. The result is a market filled with narrow, overly cushioned shoes that offer temporary relief but fail to address underlying foot issues or empower the wearer to heal their foot and overall physical health.

Performance athletic footwear also misses the practical mark. Big-name performance footwear boasts “industry-leading technology” that helps you get faster or stronger. And yet, it’s rare to see a performance shoe designed with the foot's natural shape or function in mind. This undervaluing of the foot's shape and function as a complex performance structure can lead to poor biomechanics and injury.

Furthermore, it is almost unheard of for a performance shoe to be made using durable, natural materials or a repairable method of construction. They produce throwaway products, in some cases designed to be worn for just one or two competitions.

On the other end of the footwear spectrum are shoes that were developed as a tool: work boots, hiking boots, and military boots. These are styles that I myself fell in love with. These shoes are often built using premium, durable, long-lasting materials and constructed using methods expressly designed to be repaired. Many of the styles were developed 100 years ago or more, and are still being made the same way. I love seeing traditional techniques meticulously recreated in beautiful modern interpretations of old workwear styles. While I value these traditions, they should not prevent us from building on the craft to create more footwear that is simply more practical for modern life.

One of the issues with heritage footwear is that our understanding of the human body has evolved. Conventional-style heritage workwear boots and shoes were developed as a tool. However, the old-fashioned way of making footwear—still championed and practiced by incredible hand-makers today—ultimately restricts the full potential of our feet and bodies. From a foot-functional perspective, these old styles were designed to protect but also hold the foot rigidly in place to alleviate the discomfort of a long day. 

But we now know that feet do not perform at their best when rigidly encased. Your feet are at their best when they are free to splay and grip and stabilize. We now know that if we have strong feet, it helps our overall alignment and posture. Stronger, healthier feet are associated with better balance and strength throughout our entire body. Your feet can be strengthened. We can prepare our bodies better for a long day of work rather than perpetuating the need for overly supportive footwear. 

Similar to the heritage work boot, beautifully crafted dress shoes can be amazingly made pieces of art. In terms of a dress shoe and the functionality of the foot, the overall construction often creates something lighter and more flexible than the workwear style boots and shoes. Unfortunately, they are still designed to keep the mid- and rear-foot rigid, and the elegant design of the lasts, while beautiful, is also incredibly stylized and impractical. Think about how you feel after wearing these shoes all day. They can be beautiful objects, but they do not prioritize comfort or human function.

Not only has our understanding of the body and our feet changed, but our lifestyles have as well, and continue to change constantly. We need versatile footwear for our varied lives. Modern consumerism would have us believe that we need 15 pairs of niche footwear. It’s ok to have a few pairs of shoes—in fact letting the materials rest and dry out naturally in between wears will help extend their life. What we need, though, is a few pairs of practical, useful footwear that can come with us wherever our lives take us.

I have become personally interested in the area of “barefoot” footwear and consider this area to have the most potential to create functional, useful shoes. As a consumer I moved through various segments of the footwear industry before settling on barefoot shoes. The most significant contribution barefoot footwear has made to my life is a heightened awareness of my gait, and the impact I was placing on my joints. Rather than use my muscles for support and cushion, I was relying on my shoes and joints to take a lot of my daily impact. This left me feeling stiff and brittle. Barefoot footwear has revitalized my movement, showing me the need to strengthen my intrinsic muscles. Along with smarter training, moving to barefoot-style footwear has restored fluidity and mobility to my life.

Barefoot shoes seem to finally prioritize function. However, like other segments of the footwear world, barefoot shoes are still most often constructed with cost effectiveness in mind. They are generally made using synthetic materials and mass production techniques. These synthetic materials don't move naturally with our bodies. They trap moisture and sweat, and are prone to premature wear and tear. Natural materials offer superior breathability, durability, and comfort. I urge barefoot shoe creators to prioritize natural materials. Given their simplistic design, barefoot shoes have the potential for exceptional durability and longevity. Using synthetic materials for the uppers compromises this potential lifespan. While this might not be the most profitable business model, prioritizing longevity may contribute to a more sustainable future.

I also encourage barefoot shoe creators to avoid fear-mongering tactics to attract customers. Instead of scaring people into the barefoot lifestyle, we should focus on showcasing the positive outcomes of proper foot function. By demonstrating how patience and training can restore strength and mobility, we can empower individuals to take control of their body's movement and well-being. The human body is an incredible tool, capable of remarkable feats with the right training and discipline.

It's time to reclaim the purpose, functionality, and comfort of footwear. Footwear should enhance our natural movement. I believe we do not need to forego beautiful aesthetics in this quest—however, this alone cannot be prioritized above the primary purpose of footwear to facilitate natural movement. 

Footwear should be versatile and adaptive to our ever-changing world and our ever-changing lifestyle. It should be made from real, natural materials that last and move well with your feet. It should be made in a way that can be repaired. By prioritizing function, comfort, materials, sustainability and versatility, shoes can truly be a functional, beautiful tool that enhances our lives and allows us to move freely and comfortably, without compromise.


r/goodyearwelt • • May 07 '18

Review [First Impressions] Video Thursday Boots Aviator Color #18

Thumbnail
youtube.com
10 Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • Mar 06 '20

Just got an email that the grail boot / shoe from TAFT is available!

1 Upvotes

https://taftclothing.com/collections/new-releases/products/the-grail-boot-in-coffee

I've been excited about these since I saw the pictures! Just picked up the grail boot in coffee


r/goodyearwelt • • Jun 08 '14

You guys will appreciate this, these puppies have seen it all (4 years of almost continuous wear)

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • Feb 16 '26 Bravo

Discussion Hand painted patina on well-worn Wolverine Winchester 1000 mile boots

Thumbnail
gallery
61 Upvotes

Fifteen years ago, I got a pair of Wolverine 1000 mile boots, the Winchester model in light brown. Wingtip brogue, long-nosed odd little things that I wore into the ground and had resoled a few times. I'm not gonna do the "look, I actually walked a thousand miles! in 1000 mile boo-" thing, partly because I didn't do the actual math, but they had seen some road for sure. They ended up being distinctly two-toned, where the upper was a much different darker brown than the vamp, a battle-scarred nostalgic pair I ended up storing away.

I was made aware of a local artisan who used a Spanish technique to strip the color entirely from the leather on dress shoes and then hand paint unique patinas onto them, giving them a new life. I thought it was an interesting project, and remembered my Wolverine beaters. I was quite pleased with the result. Here, you can see the evolution, the first few pictures being the finalized form, hand painted and refinished, then the color stripping and painting phases, and what they looked like to begin with in their normal, worn state as a reference.

AFTER (Images 1-4)

Deep tobacco-to-burnt-sienna gradient with two-tone hand-painted patina.

Leather revived, shaft structured, toe cap burnished. Broguing actually looks intentional now.

BEFORE & PROCESS (Images 5-10):

Color: Faded tan/caramel chromexcel (oxidized, dried out, uneven)

Daily beatings. Toe cap worn smooth, creasing heavy, shaft collapsed, etc.


r/goodyearwelt • • Oct 08 '14

Discussion My Iron Rangers are dead (irreparable) after 2 years of wear. These are fashion boots, not work or even daily wear boots. Review and pics inside. (xpost:malefashionadvice)

Thumbnail
reddit.com
8 Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • Jul 10 '24

AMA I bought four pair of Goodyear hand welted shoes from Indian artisanal BlkBrd. AMA

13 Upvotes

(Disclaimer: I am really not an expert and those are actually the first high quality shoes I purchase)

So I traveled in India and I was very interested in accessing affordable premium quality stuff.

This country has huge potential yet there is so little information around. I took a look at some Goodyear/Hand welt shoemakers, including Blkbrd, Bridlen, Kozasko, Costoso Italiano (lol), Royale Peacock, Dmodot.. Most of them are based in Agra.

After reviewing the little that I found online I restricted my interested on BlkBrd and Bridlen for "reliability" and finally to BlkBrd merely for preference in the designs available and the possibility to chose the leather.

All of them have direct chat options on WhatsApp which is really neat cause they are always available to explain and show details of their materials making process.

I ended up purchasing 4 pairs from Blkbrd, two with their locally sourced leather and two with a premium upgrade:

  1. A black full brogue Oxford, with their locally available leather

  2. A brown Cap Toe painted patina Oxford in their locally available Crust

  3. A navy blue spiral/whole cut Monk in imported italian Zonta museum leather

  4. A Burgundy Chelsea boot in imported Horween hatch grain leather (the same leather that appeared in the only other post about this shoemaker)

The stitching in the Brogue and the Monk is concealed (they even sent me a video of the making process)

I am really pleased with what I received, the shoes are heavy, sturdy and well refined. If I have to find something I didn't like too much is some creasing in the neck of the boot (it looks like it was bent during transportation. I hope I can just fix it while wearing it, or with a shoe tree)

They also sent me a coiple of real cow horns carved to make shoehorns

I open this post to share what I got, ask me anything 😁


r/goodyearwelt • • Jul 30 '15

Boot Buying 101

2 Upvotes

/r/buyitforlife directed me over here for some boot buying wisdom. Below is my original post:

I am looking to get myself a good pair of work-style boots that can be work everyday for years to come. I've searched high and low to find a decent guide on buying them, but all I find are lists of brands and styles. What makes boots like the Wolverine 1000 Mile such a good boot? What about the Red Wing Heritage collection? I'd like to be educated. For what it's worth, the 1000 Miles are my front runner at the moment, but things could change.

That being said, I'm not looking for a steel toe, work boot. I'm looking for good, everyday use boots. Something that will work casually, but if I had to do a little work, they would hold up. What are your thought?


r/goodyearwelt • • Aug 15 '24

General Discussion QOTD WFAYWT GD 08-15-2024

Post image
0 Upvotes

Which one of y'all waiting fer "boot season" and who all with me sweating balls out here in boots an jeans cause Jesus loves us? 🤠


r/goodyearwelt • • Jun 05 '24

General Discussion QOTD WFAYWT GD 2024-06-05

Post image
0 Upvotes

QOTD: (see pic)

Or just shoot it, cheers! 🍻😊


r/goodyearwelt • • May 12 '24

Discussion 1000 Mile cap toe fake

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Was looking at the 1000 mile cap toe boot since there has been a sale going on. Does anyone know if the cap toe is real or is it just a design. The pictures make it seem like it’s not a real cap toe and the way they word design description seems off. Not really sure what to think since Wolverine is known for cutting corners. Also what do you guys think of the value of a 1000 mile boot for $280. (Sale price). Is it even worth it or should I save for a better boot.


r/goodyearwelt • • Mar 13 '16

Shoe Trees. Mixed Verdicts. Confusion.

0 Upvotes

this comment has been deleted in response to the 2023 reddit protest


r/goodyearwelt • • May 12 '18

Review Thursday Boot Co. Mahogany Wingtip Brogue Review.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
0 Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • Mar 12 '25

General Discussion QOTD WSAYWT GD humpday edition 03-12-2025

Post image
0 Upvotes

QOTD: Ever find some really cool footwear that you really like but probably wouldn't wear much? If so, did you still cop?

Or just shoot it 📷👞👞🥾🥾