r/goodyearwelt • • Mar 30 '21

I made a pair of boots

Post image
3.1k Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • May 02 '19

Redwing Iron Rangers after 36 countries and four resoles.

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • Jan 17 '18 Bravo Take My Silver

The 2018 Beginners Boot Buying Guide

2.0k Upvotes

ACTIVE AS OF SEPTEMBER 2024

This guide has one primary purpose: to make sure you buy a good pair of shoes. It’s a minefield out there as many stores are filled with shoddy and deceptive options. But here at /r/goodyearwelt, our community is committed to educating you on quality footwear. With proper care your shoes should last years.

Here is the third version of the infamous beginners boot buying guide. Updated for 2023, this guide is a list of oft recommended and popular brands that GYW stands behind. Originally put together by, /u/chickenfark, /u/Deusis, and /u/pirieca, this evolution seeks to offer a more concise overview of well made and familiar brands this subreddit has experience with.

I would like to personally thank the many people who collaborated in the drafting threads to make this guide possible. Thanks (in alphabetical order) /u/DRAKRIDDAREN, /u/dubbysmurf, /u/feliksas, /u/m635_guy, /u/MonsieurLeDude, /u/sakizashi, /u/YourMoneyOrYourLife, for specific write-ups and everyone else who added to the discussion!

I attempted to shorten this guide to include only a curated core of solid, reliable brands. For a more exhaustive list, please check the comments and honorable mentions. The options are listed in alphabetical order at each price tier.

As you explore the world of footwear, hopefully you will encounter brands you haven’t before, and brands not listed here (check the comments to read why we excluded certain brands as well). But this guide’s goal is to give you a bit of direction before plunging into the world of high-quality boots.

Here are some other useful threads to get you up to speed:

• Leather Care guide

• Common Defects

• Sizing Thread

• GYW for women

• Brand overview for women

• Need the largest sizes?

• Do you have wide feet?

• How footwear should fit

There are many wonderful stockists other than what is listed here and you are encouraged to search more on your own. The stores/websites linked here are just a start.

Note: Where is common brand X?- Copied from an Old MFA boot guide:

ALDO, Bed Stu, Tsubo, Kenneth Cole, and ECCO make trash fashion boots, often of impossibly thin leather. They're marginally cheaper than other brands, but they're still ludicrously overpriced. There is absolutely no situation where buying one of these brands is advisable.

John Doe, there have been multiple stories here of John Doe taking people's money and not fulfilling their orders. Avoid.

Ted Baker, Cole Haan, Steve Madden and etc. make boots that are slightly better than trash fashion boots, but not by much. If you find a great deal on a pair, and they don't look terrible, you could consider them. Definitely not worth full retail.

Frye is not a boot maker any longer, just a name that was purchased. they source boots from the lowest bidder all over the world. They don’t even use the same construction methods some are decent and some crappy as hell. There’s really no way to know what you’re going to get.

Without further ado,


TIER 1: $200- $350

Canada West

Canada West makes boots in their Winnipeg, Manitoba factory. They don't sell direct to the public except through their warehouse/seconds store. They're a smaller operation that's been around since 1931 but in this organization since 1978. They have a selection of Western wear, uniform boots, workboots, and police and military boots. Quality is comparable to Red Wing with a lower price point. If you're in Winnipeg though, it's worth a stop.

Reviews

Purchasing: Here's their website, search around, Also available on Amazon.

Chevalier

Indonesian made-to-order bootmaker. Slim-profiled boots. Low prices but with large shipping fees (unless bought off Massdrop). Good looking but questionable leather quality. Read reviews before committing.

Reviews

Purchasing: Chevalier Website

Chippewa

Brand Spotlight

US-made work boot company. Became popular with the introduction of ‘Apache’ model. Similar quality and aesthetic to Thorogood. Profile synonymous with workwear bootmakers. Used to make models for LL Bean, but LL Bean switched to a different company making lower-quality boots out of Vietnam. They don't have many options online at the moment, unsure where the company is heading.

Reviews

Purchasing: Amazon, Jcrew

Danner

Brand Spotlight

US-manufactured Hiking boot brand. Best known for actual heavy boots, but also more fashion-orientated hiker models. Mountain-Light and Stumptown models in particular. Good quality if Hiker aesthetic is what you’re looking for. Solid all around.

Reviews

Purchasing: Danner Website, Amazon

Junkard

Indonesian boot company specializing in service boots that offers a good MTO service as well as a limited selection of RTW models. Their Rocado Shell cordovan models go for ~450$ with the ability to pick from any color stocked by Rocado and multiple construction options including Stitchdown, GYW, and Norwegian. Many users have positively reviewed their shell and Horween offerings while their domestic leathers have mixed reviews. Line and Whatsapp seem to be the best way to contact them, but make sure to stick with one method of communication as it seems different employees handle each one and mistakes may be made. As with most Indonesian bookmakers, occasional slip-ups with MTO specifications have been noted so make sure to confirm everything twice.

Reviews- Will have to do a manual search as most reviews aren't linked to the wiki

Purchasing: Website

Loake 1880

Brand Spotlight

A British shoemaker’s high quality line. 1880 boots are made in Northampton. Good quality, but below those of other English bootmakers. Known for dressier country boots and chukkas.

Reviews

Purchasing: Herring Shoes, Pediwear

Meermin

Brand Spotlight

A stylish Spanish shoemaker welted in China, finished in Spain. Sold exclusively through their own website, they have a variety of attractive boot options around the $250-$350 mark. Interesting GMTO options on their website as well which are regularly refreshed. Keep in mind shipping though - they come from Spain. As of 1/25/18 They have opened a store in NYC which can help with returns, but as of 2/2021 still questionable customer service and sometimes have defects.

Reviews

Purchasing: Meermin Website

Red Wing Factory Seconds

please see Red Wing listed in the next tier for more information

Great value and a popular offering due to Red Wing’s solid reputation. Factory seconds are boots and shoes with small quality control issues such as scratches, blemishes, and missed stitching. Always inspect your "seconds" boots before you wear them. They are not always in stock so be on the lookout for sales and re-stocking announcements.

Purchasing: Sierra Trading Post, Nordstrom Rack

Sagara Indonesia

Indonesian MTO bootmaker. Upper end of this price range with price hikes. Selling boots with slim lasts and chunky welts. Quality of construction seems fine. Good option, but a tad difficult to order, and quite a wait time to stomach. Not seen too many recent reviews but were well received in the past.

Reviews

Purchasing: Sagara's website

Story Et Fall

Massive rise in popularity given recent trends in men’s fashion, known for sleek chelseas and jodhpurs at cheap prices. Models range from goodyear welted, blake-stitched and cemented. The website is pretty poor at the moment, but can contact by email and see options here. Free international delivery a bonus, and have been relatively well-reviewed.

Reviews

Purchasing: Story Et Fall Website

Taft

A recent GYW addition, Taft offers sleek, fashion-forward styles at a reasonable price point. They began producing Blake-stitched shoes and boots in Spain and recently added a line of Goodyear-welted options made in Portugal. Taft is known for offering good construction, solid quality control, and great customer service. Overall, the consensus has been positive so stayed tuned this year for more reviews.

Reviews

Purchasing: Taft Website

Thorogood

American heritage bootmaker manufactured by Weinbrenner. Similar aesthetically to Red Wing, but overall slightly lower in quality- but by no means bad! Known best for moc-toe boots (some prefer their's over Red Wings). Solid entry level boot which is often found on sale. Check out the Thorogood 1892 Dodgevilles for an Iron Ranger alternative.

Reviews

Purchasing: Thorogoods Website, Amazon

Thursday Boot Co

Started in 2014 offering sleek service boot styles, Thursday Boot Co. has emerged as a leader among digitally-native brands to now offer a full line of leather goods for men and women, including sneakers, dress shoes and jackets. Their customer service gets special praise and they are known for not discounting their products. Even so this where you'll find some of the most affordable GYW footwear using Horween leathers, shell cordovan and/or Made in USA. They also produce in Mexico, Portugal and Spain depending on the model and have an active presence on Reddit with /u/Thursdayboots.

Reviews

Purchasing: Amazon, Thursday's Website

William Lennon

William Lennon boots are hand-made in the UK. Order-to-delivery time is 8-12 weeks, since there is actually little stock on the shelves, and most items are built only after order. Their boots are Blake-stitched and then brass riveted, the brass rivet machinery being one of 3 still in existence in the world! What sets William Lennon apart from other bootmakers is that they offer customizable options for 200£ all in. One can have their choice of most Horween or other leather, full lining, a bellows tongue, brogueing, and the like. Libs, the owner and great granddaughter of the founder, will help you to make it. If you're interested in a lovely boot that will last you for years with minimal care, consider buying from William Lennon. *See also Rufflander

Reviews

Purchasing: Website

Wolverine

Brand Spotlight

Oft-recommended American workwear bootmaker. Particularly well known for 1000 Mile range. Decent aesthetic with varying QC. Many examples have been subject to poor creasing. Extensively customizable, Viable at regular sale prices; Do not pay the retail of around $350-$400. ~$200 is a fairer price (Hence why in this price range). Despite some QC issues, overall an attractive boot with the potential for beautiful chromexcel. Note: only their "1000 Mile" line is time-tested, no verdict on other Wolverine models and the BLVD

Reviews

Purchasing: Amazon, Wolverine's Customizer


Tier 2: $350-$450

Allen Edmonds

Brand Spotlight

Quintessential American menswear company but recently there have been quality control issues. The Higgins Mill Boot are a staple and Daltons are another popular offering if looking for something dressier. Not completely MIUSA, some assembly done in Latin America then finished in USA. A wide range of factory seconds also offered at lower prices. Many deals are to be found on ebay as well. A good option during their numerous sales. Do not buy at full retail price. 30% off is standard.

Reviews

Purchasing: Allen Edmonds Website, Shoe Bank (Allen Edmonds’ factory seconds website)

Grant Stone

VOTED BRAND OF 2019 and 2022

A newer company producing boots and shoes in Xiamen, China. Featuring classic style inspirations with a modern perspective and attention to craftsmanship, Grant Stone offers true value. They currently offer a collection of boots (plain-toe and hand-stitched Norwegian Split-Toe/NST) and bluchers (plain toe-bluchers/PTB and longwings), with additional products in the pipeline. See our resident Grant-Stone expert /u/m635_guy 's reviews for more information.

Reviews- going to have to do a manual search as most aren't linked in the resources

Purchasing: Website

Parkhurst

VOTED BRAND OF 2020

Buffalo, NY based Parkhurst has become synonymous with customer service and outreach thanks to the efforts of it's owner and founder Andrew. The RTW stock does tend to move fast. Offering ~30 interesting and varied leathers the brand successfully launched their MTO program in early 2020 providing a radically affordable and accessible introduction to the MTO process. Parkhurst has supply deals with CF Stead, Horween, and Maryam allowing unique leather offerings not seen elsewhere in this price range. As of 2021 the company has changed to more natural interior construction materials as well. As of February 2021, boots are made only in D width, but wide versions are planned. The owner responds quite quickly to queries and comments through Instagram and email as well as takes an active roll in the construction and inspection himself.

Purchasing: Website

Quoddy

Traditional Made-in-Maine shoemaker, specialising in handsewn moccasin styles. Renowned for wide range, quality leathers, and comfort. Also have a brilliant MTO program with no upcharge, allowing for full customisation.

Reviews

Purchasing: Quoddy website

Rancourt

Handmade in Maine, Rancourt is an American manufacturer known for their casual loafer, boat shoe and moccasin offerings, Rancourt has expanded their line to include more formal shoes and boots available in a large variety of materials. They utilize two types of construction, hand sewn moccasin and blake stitched for both boots and shoes. Rancourt offers their Made to Fit program to help take the guesswork out of sizing and is always open to custom orders. The Custom tab of their site allows for the personalization of the shoe or boot and it takes about three weeks from order to delivery. Generally well received, and makers of the most gorgeous boat shoe in existence.

Reviews

Purchasing: Rancourt Website, Huckberry

Red Wing

Brand Spotlight

The standard to which workwear styles are compared. Known for Iron Ranger, heritage, and moc-toe boots. Solid construction and respectable QC. Operates own tannery (SB Foot), which keeps leather quality high at this price point. Hard to go wrong. Can be had at a lower price with frequent sales. Released many sleeker styles. May be the most popular shoemaker on Reddit.

Reviews (warning – about a billion of them)

Purchasing: Bakers, RedWing. Also numerous department stores and high end clothing shops, as well as their own stores. Everywhere from Amazon to unique online retailers.

Sanders

Sanders & Sanders make classic Northamptonshire boots of good quality. Often contracted by other brands (Thom Browne, Mark McNairy) to manufacture their boots. Good styles, often with chunky welts. Good value when considered alongside other Northampton makers. Can be found cheap.

Reviews

Purchasing: Website


Tier 3: $450-$750

Alden

Brand Spotlight

Quality American shoemaker. Known for classic styles, attractive lasts and nice detailing. Can occasionally falter on QC, but that is perhaps mostly down to massive hike in popularity recently. Well known for the Indy boot. Shell cordovan options are highly sought after and very good, some wait years for certain shell models. Hard to go wrong. Please note, most options are in the $500-$700, their shell can be priced much higher.

VOTED BRAND OF 2017

/u/Jolsen77 descibes them "they don’t give a crap about your trends, your GMTO requests, your demand for rare shell colors, your desire for faster turnaround. They don’t care. They're going to keep doing what they do, and I expect that they’ll retain their soul and be around a heck of a lot longer than AE."

Reviews

Purchasing: Moulded Shoe- For orthopedic lasts, The Shoe Mart - Sign up for newsletter for access to seconds quality boots for purchase., Leffot,Trunk Clothiers, J.Crew – sell a number of Alden options on occasion, including the much revered shell cordovan boots. See also Alden DC, Alden Madison, Alden Brick and Mortar, and others

Alfred Sargent

A classic English bootmaker. Manufactured out of Northamptonshire, they are a bit hard to come by, since they have no standalone stores. Have collaborated with J. Crew, and worked on behalf of Peal & Co.

Reviews

Purchasing: Herring, A Fine Pair of Shoes, Tredders

Carlos Santos

Hailing from North Portugal, Carlos Santos makes sleek, quality footwear at ~$400 price point. A European VAT of 21% applies, and puts Santos on par with European Red Wing pricing. Santos offers a unique patina service with the ability to order shoes and boots in the patina of your choice, and Santos quality approaches but is not quite on par with Carmina. A relative newcomer, there are some early rumblings on the use of crust leather on both their patina service and MTO offerings.

Reviews

Purchasing: Unfortunately Santos is not sold through brick and mortar stores in the U.S., so buying online is the only option for American customers. skoaktiebolaget has a great selection of Santos footwear and an excellent reputation.

Carmina

Brand Spotlight

High quality Spanish maker on the dressier end of the spectrum. Incredibly attractive boots with top quality construction. A darling of /r/goodyearwelt having organised exclusive GMTOs through them. Recent price hike makes them slightly less good value, but still one of the best quality/price ratios out there.

Reviews

Purchasing: Carmina website, Skoaktiebolaget

Crockett & Jones

Brand Spotlight

Quintessential English bootmaker, manufactured in Northamptonshire. Known for high quality and attractive models. Variety of leather options available including shell. Skye and Islay models are particularly popular. Please note, some of their models are in the $600-$700 but other options are much more expensive.

Reviews

Purchasing: C&J Stores, Barney's, Pediwear

Cheaney

Another classically British bootmaker. Known for their sturdy country and pebble grain boots. Quality akin to other English makers in this tier. Recently revamped website and store in London. Expanding and improving constantly.

Reviews

Purchasing: Cheaney Website, Herring

Dayton

Brand spotlight

High quality, Canadian, made-to-order work boots. Renowned for their charcoal nubuck options. Have done successful GMTOs with /r/goodyearwelt in the past. Small operation means exceedingly long wait times though in certain cases.

Reviews

Purchasing: Dayton website

Enzo Bonafe

Italian shoemaker known for high quality MTO shoes and boots in many syles. High quality/price ratio given the MTO offers and handwelted construction. Ever-growing in popularity and for good reason. Generally on the dressier side of the scale. Please note shell options can be $800+.

Reviews

Purchasing: Skoaktiebolaget, Solegarb Shop Mehra MTO

MOTO

Japanese brand known in particular for their simple designs and hand-dyed shell, which has some incredible color to it. They don’t cater for large sizes, and are pretty difficult to get a hold of.

Reviews

Purchasing: MOTO Website

Nicks

VOTED BRAND OF 2021

Pacific Northwest custom bootmaker. Family owned business that has been building handmade boots for over 50 years, owned and operated all within the United States. Known for sturdy workwear boots, also offers a line of casual heritage boots. Robust, full leather midsole and insole, excellent arch support, and great bang for your buck. Most boots fully customizable but longer lead times than Whites. Cleaner finishing than White's, thick and unique leather, and super heavy, Nicks makes a great stitchdown boot.

Reviews

Purchasing: Nicks Website

Oak Street Bootmaker

Brand Spotlight

US Workwear style boots. Known for attractive trench boots with a modern aesthetic, captoe boots, moc-style handsewns, and a recently released Stitchdown boot. Have had issues with puckering in the past. Can be found on sale occasionally.

Reviews

Purchasing: Oak Street Bootmakers, End

Rider Boot Co

US-designed, Italian made blake-rapid boots. Attractive designs, with top drawer quality and pleasing last shapes. Ron makes some highly attractive and well sought-after options. Have also operated successful shell cordovan GMTOs. Usually in upper end of this tier, but recent Massdrops have meant they’ve been attainable at much cheaper prices.

Reviews

Purchasing: Rider Boot Website

R. M. Williams

Brand Spotlight

Aussie bootmaker now more prized for attractive and fashionable boots. Best known for their Chelsea boots, which are the only wholecut chelsea at this price point. Also do lace ups, which have been reviewed but are pretty hard to come by. Buying from Australia is much more cost effective.

Please note, some users report R.M. Williams has made several price hikes, but with declining quality, in recent years after being purchased by another company

Reviews

Purchasing: Website, Boots Online

Tricker’s

Brand Spotlight

Renowned English shoemaker, manufactured in Northamptonshire. Very well constructed, and are known for having reputable QC. Best known for use of chunky natural welts. Wide range of leathers and styles, as well as an extensive MTO/GMTO service. Also offer shell at a higher pricepoint.

Reviews

Purchasing: Tricker’s Website

Wesco - West Coast Shoe Company

Pacific Northwest Bootmaker known for sturdy work boots and a variety of engineer boots. Founded in 1918 this family owned business has been around, and stuck around for a reason. They make very quality boots with a higher level of finishing and attention to detail than is generally found in other PNW makers, but you pay more because of this. All of their offerings are fully customizable but expect long (up to a year) leads times.

Purchasing: Direct, Bakers, Standard & Strange, and Division Road

White’s

Pacific Northwest Bootmaker known for solid work boots and heritage boots- the "M.P. Boot" with high quality construction. White's makes boots for forest firefighters as well as daily wear, so you know they're going to be tough. Handwelted with a rolled welt and logger heels but can be made with a block heel. White’s Bounty Hunter is an incredibly customizable boot (see /u/cathpah[+2]’s ordering guide here that can be made to almost anyone’s tastes. You could knock down walls in these. Some of the better made boots out there and easily among the heaviest and most durable boots on the market. Decent good quality control, but occasionally finishing can be clunky. Released a slimmer service boot

bonus white's/Nicks album

VOTED BRAND OF 2018:

One of the last true American Heritage bootmakers, White's Made-To-Order program allows one to design a boot from scratch down to the little details. While sometimes the finishing is a bit clunky, they remain some of the heaviest, most durable boots around. Customer service through Baker's Boots is undoubtedly some of the best on the market.

Great leather quality, a rolled welt, and the reputation as the most heavy-duty boots round, White's is a brand to be reckoned with.

Reviews

Purchasing: Baker’s Shoe, Whites, Brooklyn Clothing, Division Road. Also multiple smaller retailers offering make-ups.

Yuketen

Interesting shoemaker specialising in both handsewn mocs, GYW boots, and hybrids between the two. Well-known in particular for handsewn Maine Guide boots and Eric boots. Interesting if quite eccentric designs. Can often be had at cheaper prices and on sale.

Reviews

Purchasing: Website, Mr. Porter


Tier 5: $750+

Made to order boots in any material from some of the best shoemakers in the world. There would be too many to list, but we have put in some reviews of high end shoes that have been conducted by users in /r/goodyearwelt. When you start to look at options over $1,000, (example, John Lobb) you can begin to go bespoke, at which point you can have anything you desire. For a good rundown of such makers if you’d like to investigate further, I would strongly suggest reading the discussion of shoemakers by The Parisian Gentleman:

Edward Green

Top of the line English Bootmaker. Revered for their high quality, impeccable designs, and high price tag. The Galway boot is considered a grail for many. Most popular styles are those in grain/calf or suede/calf makeups. Please note, much more expensive than other options listed in this tier.

Reviews

Purchasing: Edward Green, Leffot

Vass

Brand Spotlight

Hungarian shoemaker, known for impeccable quality and beautiful designs on more formal end of the spectrum. Different styles and lasts to choose from. Particularly known for good brogue designs and a variety of shell options. Can be had for cheaper than $700, but you can also go a bit crazy with them.

Reviews

Purchasing: Website, No Man Walks Alone, Shop Mehra

Viberg

Brand Spotlight

Viberg makes high quality boots out of Victoria, Canada. Prized for their slim toe boxes, attractive styles and lasts, interesting and varied use of leathers, and unique collaborations. Expect new releases to sell out fast, and rarely go on sale. No exaggeration, shell options sell out literally in seconds. Recently started using GYW construction alongside stitchdown options. However, in recent years there have been a few reported QC issues around here, distant customer service from Viberg directly, and Viberg no longer offers resoles. Note, limited widths for sizing.

Reviews

Purchasing: Viberg website, Brooklyn Clothing Company, Division Road

Full list of Stockists

Collaborators: (3sixteen, Haven, Rivet and Hide, Gentry, 14oz Berlin, Notre, Superdenim, Kafka, the Bureau Belfast, Dee Cee Style, Blue Owl Workshop, Stuf|f, Withered Fig etc.)


HONORABLE MENTIONS

These brands were on previous guides, but removed for brevity.

Adelante

Made in Mexico brand. Focusing on ethical production. Multiple widths available.

Bexley

French manufacturer. A very good entry-level option based upon other redditor's experiences.

Fracap

Quality Italian-made Hiker boots. Comparable to Danner, arguably with a more attractive aesthetic.

Jack Erwin

Budget American shoemaker. Range of goodyear welted and blake-stitched boots and dress shoes. Average reviews.


r/goodyearwelt • • Jun 27 '20

I don’t know if this constitutes as goodyear welt, but I cleaned up some ice skates I found in an abandoned skating rink.

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • Nov 25 '25

Cordwaining I’m a hobbyist bootmaker and I finished another pair

Thumbnail
gallery
1.7k Upvotes

This is my ninth pair and my best-executed. I'm reasonably happy with the result, but I haven't delivered them yet. I'll be REALLY happy if they fit.

I always get this question, so before you ask, I don't make boots for Reddit folks. Sorry! My bootmaking distribution is limited to me, and to people I know personally who have the same size feet as me. And I'm working to clear my in-process list of everyone who's not in the first category<3

Credit for the ming-boggling photography goes a prominent boot photographer whose style is recognizable from the photos, but whose name I'm declining to mention in case it breaks the doxing rule.

Specs: *Upper - Badalassi Carlo Minerva in Caffe *Lining - soft veg lining meant for tooling. Fully lined, seamless around the heel *Tongue - Gusseted, Cloe veg calf. I was amazed at the color match between these two hides. *Sole - Hand-stitched Vibram 430 with matching heel. *Welt - 360deg hand welt. Black top, natural Tokonole edges *Wooden shank *Six eyelets *Structured toe and heel *Custom last *Flat waxed laces

To give credit where credit's due, this pair was directly inspired by Goto-San's brand White Kloud. Frankly, I copied details directly from his designs, or attempted to (I don't have a fraction of his hard-earned skill or experience). You might be bristling at my IP theft, but I feel okay about it because 1) these boots are a gift for a family member, 2) no one's making money off them, and 3) I'm a hobbyist. This would be unacceptable if I were running a business, but I do this for fun, I do it to make art, and I'm still learning. I think copying the greats is acceptable at this point.

Anyway, the standout feature of this pair is the leather. The customer requested "so dark brown it's almost black," and the Caffe is exactly what he was looking for. This was my first time working with Badalassi Carlo and I look forward to using it again, even though this hide was close to 3mm in places and very difficult to last. The heel counter is double-layered, so around the heel the layers are lining, counter, quarters, counter cover. This was A LOT to welt through, and the result is a very stiff heel cup.

As usual for my boots, they're fully lined and the heel lining is seamless. No pics of that, unfortunately. A seamless heel lining is kind of extravagant, but I think it's really cool and a major flex. It's also good for the boot's longevity, since stitches can't pop if they don't exist.

I'm still working out my feelings on gussetted tongues. He won't be wearing these for any activities that would call for it, necessarily. I like the shape it gives the instep area, and as with the seamless heel lining, it's a bit of a flex. Especially paired with a full lining. You don't see many fully-lined boots with a gusseted tongue, and for good reason: it's really hard to do.

I don't have a sole stitcher, so I continue to stitch soles by hand.

Edge finishing is my least favorite thing, but in my quest to emulate White Kloud, I increased the effort I normally invest in edge finishing. The result is probably the best I've achieved, but definitely worth improving.

Thanks for checking them out! On to the next pair! (Maryam crust cordovan, they're gonna be NUTS)


r/goodyearwelt • • Dec 27 '20

Picture Special - Yohei Fukuda bespoke seamless wholecut

Thumbnail
gallery
1.6k Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • Jan 07 '25

Original Content Self made Barefoot boots

Thumbnail
gallery
1.5k Upvotes

I know many in this sub likely aren’t too fond of barefoot shoes, but after having been exclusively wearing them now for the past 5 years I can no longer tolerate elevated heels and tapered toe-boxes, which means I’ve had to give up wearing traditional style boots for the past few years.

Despite my searching, it seems no barefoot shoe brands are interested in stepping in to produce traditional, heritage style boots. There are a few odd examples, but for the most part nothing existed which matched the PNW heritage styling I was looking for, but with zero-drop and a wide, natural toe-box. So last year I decided to take up cordwaining and make my own, so far I’ve made 5 pairs, all with the intent of using the best materials available and trying to keep an aesthetically appealing profile to them while maintaining zero-drop and a natural toe-box.

All boots are entirely hand stitched using Ritza Tiger thread, 0.6mm for the uppers and 1.2mm for a 360 stitchdown to the midsole and then a second row 270 stitchdown to the outsole. All are lined in the vamp with 2.5-3oz Haas calfskin, have 11-12oz Hermann Oak veg tan insoles, and 9-10 iron J&FJ Baker leather midsoles. Specs for the individual boots are as follows: 1 — 8” height, 6oz Wickett & Craig English Bridle in Medium Brown Roughout with a Vibram Kletterlift sole. 2 — 6” height, 7oz Conceria Walpier Buttero in Natural with a Vibram Kletterlift sole. 3 — 8” height, 7oz Conceria Walpier Buttero in Olive with a Vibram Kletterlift sole. 4 — 7” height, 6oz Horween Waxed Flesh Chromexcel in Dark Brown with a Vibram Kletterlift sole. 5 — 6” height, 7oz SB Foot Dawson Black with a Vibram Dupla sole.


r/goodyearwelt • • Dec 18 '20 Diamonds are Forever

GYW-FAQ GYW for Women – Brands and Notes

1.4k Upvotes

Intro

Strap in, folks. I’ve been on the hunt for high-quality black leather women’s boots for myself and put together these notes in case they are helpful. Sadly, the linked guides for women have all been deleted and I figure something is better than nothing.

Hopefully this is a starting point and others can contribute, because I don’t know anything. What I lack in useful technical knowledge, I’ve attempted to make up for with a shit ton of links.

Brands that make women’s Goodyear welted (GYW) boots and shoes

Roughly in order of least to most expensive.

Other things I investigated that didn’t work out

  • Nisolo makes fashion shoes and boots that are not GYW. They used to have a question about GYW in their FAQ and produce a men's GYW boot, the Luciano. Both the question and boot have been removed from their site. "Ethically made" but be aware that they failed to deliver their "Five for Five" program in 2024 and went into foreclosure in 2025. Strongly recommend against buying from Nisolo.

  • Some, not all, of Bed Stu’s boots are GYW, including the Nandi Chelsea boot and the tall, wide calf Jacqueline boot. I don’t know anything else about them but the Beginners Boot Buying Guide says, “Bed Stuy are terrible boots; do not buy them.”

  • Trask came up in my searches but as far as I can tell, none of their women’s styles are GYW.

  • I’ve seen Rider Boot Company mentioned but they don't have any women-specific models currently.

  • Some Dr. Martens boots say they are GYW, like the 1460, a lace-up boot, and 2976, a Chelsea boot. However, because of their heat-fused construction, they may be difficult or impossible to resole.

  • Poppy Barley is a B Corp making high-quality footwear for women. It looks like they are no longer using GYW construction, at least for their women's styles.

  • I used to have NPS Shoes listed separately from Solovair, but all of my links broke. NPS Solovair is still listed above.

  • Truman Boots used to have a small selection of women’s boots but there are currently none listed. A user shared a negative MTO experience: Suede heeled boots MTO experience by u/optimizedMediocrity.

  • American Duchess has beautiful, well-reviewed, historically-inspired shoes. Some pairs say they have a double layer welt.

  • Thorogood had affordable women's Oxfords with GYW construction when this post was first written, but none of their women's options are GYW as of a 2023 update.

  • When this post was published, Wolverine had a couple options, including the 1000 Mile (made in USA) and the Marcelle (made in Mexico). As of a 2023 update, Wolverine doesn't have any GYW women's options on their site, but you may still be able to find them from other retailers. Reviews: 1000 Mile by u/PlumLion, 1000 Mile by u/ffrve, 1000 Mile by u/BennetSisterNumber6, 1000 Mile by u/JupiterIsBeautiful

  • Most Timberland boots are not GYW. Back in 2020 they had one GYW women's pair, the PRO Rigmaster Alloy Toy Work Boots, but as of a 2023 update they were no longer available.

  • All of the shoes in Beckett Simonon's women's line are cemented.

  • White’s used to list the Line Scout Lace-to-Toe, a firefighter boot, in women’s sizing on their website but no longer does. I think the Lady Packer, with stitchdown construction, is a women's boot. There are probably people who won't like this comment, but IMO, a lot of their chunky-heeled boots could easily lean feminine.

  • Ranch Road Boots ceased operations in 2023. Their boots were Western-inspired, made in Spain, and all GYW. Some interesting boots like the U.S. Marine Corps-inspired Current Issue alongside more traditional Western boots like Firebird and everyday options like Agave Rand.

  • Oak Tree Farms made romantic shoes, short boots, and tall boots. They closed in May 2025.

  • Sutro looks to have shut down in fall 2024. At one point they had seven GYW boots for women, including a few Chelsea boot options, the lace-up Mendelle, and the low cut Ocean. Truly pointy toes and zippers are hard to find in women's GYW boots, and the Polk had both. Reviews mixed at best. Sizes 5-11.

Notes

Hope it’s okay that I tagged various reviewers.

Check out the excellent comments by u/Stoic_sasquatch about options for "women's" shoes in "men's" sizing.

I didn’t link to examples of women wearing men’s boots but by all means, women, wear men’s boots if you want! Men, wear women’s boots if you want! People, wear stuff you love!

I realize that there are high-quality boots that are not GYW, and low-quality boots that are GYW, but since that’s even further outside my area of expertise, I tried to stick with "just GYW" here. The comments include some Blake stitch and Stitchdown suggestions.

Entirely possible that I made mistakes, left out useful information, or missed brands. Please let me know and I’ll gladly edit the post. I'm not on Reddit much anymore, but feel free to let me know of updates in comments and I'll add them to the post eventually.

Last updated July 7, 2025


r/goodyearwelt • • Dec 23 '19

Image(s) The r/goodyearwelt X r/rawdenim collaboration we've all been waiting for.

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • Dec 30 '16

Image(s) It's the 30th and I'm turning 30 today. Here are the nearly 30 pairs of Østmo boots and shoes I've made over the course of 2016

Thumbnail
imgur.com
1.3k Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • Oct 05 '20

My Corcoran jump boots compared to my grandpa’s combat boots he wore in Korea

Thumbnail
gallery
1.2k Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • Oct 18 '17 Bravo

Updated Introductory Leather Care Guide

1.2k Upvotes

This starting-point guide, originally composed by u/a_robot_with_dreams and u/6t5g is designed to cover the basics of leather care for leather shoes, sneakers, and leather goods.

Note, I use the term "boots" interchangeably with shoes/leather/et cetera.

This guide is updated and active as of NOVEMBER 2026.

NO AI USED IN CREATING THIS GUIDE

5 Basics:

1: Do Less.

  • Your leather is naturally tough and resilient.

2: You don't need to treat your boots out-of-the box.

  • 99% of the time you do not need to do anything for your new boots. Put them on and wear them.

3: But check your new boots for common defects.

  • Inspect for defects, ask the Daily Questions thread, talk to respective Customer Service as needed. Note that a welt joint is not a damaged welt.

  • A few light scuffs on the boot is fine - likely from the boots shifting around in the box. Just brush and wear.

4: Your leather will have some wrinkles.

  • A bit of wrinkled and creased leather is normal, this is called "break" or "grain break" (there really is not a standard term). You can read more about leather creasing from Horween. However, if your boot is covered in wrinkles, an exchange or return may be in order. Note, I am yet to ever see real loose grain.

  • Loose Grain: In 10+ years and thousands of photos of boots, I have maybe seen loose grain twice. Note Here how the leather is just covered in wrinkles and heavy grain break - before they have even been worn. Note how it is uniform all over these are supposed to be a smooth leather, not pebble grain. That STILL may not be loose grain but I would absolutely return or exchange.

5: Brush the Vamp!

  • Brush and get the dirt and dust off the Vamp of your boots, and out of the creases! If left dirty, over the months, the dirt and particles in the creases will act like a "sandpaper" and this can lead to long term cracking in the leather - even with conditioning/oiling. Almost all the cracking leather I see on 5+ year old boots is always on the vamp. While you want to regularly brush the whole boot, pay special attention to the vamp.

Here is the bare-minimum information you need:

Daily Maintenance:

  • 1: Insert Cedar Shoe Trees.

  • 2: Brush with a horsehair brush.

  • 3: That's it. Enjoy your durable leather.

Basic Maintenance Steps for a Deep Clean:

  • 1: Brush.

  • 2: Clean if necessary (wipe, leather cleaner, etc. detailed steps further down).

  • 3: Wait until leather dries (some people like to wait over night).

  • 4: Apply conditioner (detailed steps further down. Use Bick4 if you don't want to read).

  • 5: Wait ~30min minimum (again some people like to wait over night).

  • 6: Brush.

Introduction to Care Methods

Prevent dirt buildup and salt/water damage:

Dirt buildup is among the biggest causes of leather damage and cracking. The simplest thing you can to to ensure longevity is keep your boots and shoes clean and dry.

Brushing with a horsehair or bristle brush is the simplest and best form of regular maintenance you can do for leather footwear.

Ensure your leather remains well conditioned:

  • A general rule is to condition every 1 - 2 months if you wear your boots in hard conditions (hiking, soaked through, muddy etc), and every 2-5 months otherwise.** These are very general time periods and you should consult the Daily questions thread if you are unsure.

  • Here is an example of what conditioning a long-unconditioned shoe can do

But do not over-condition/oil your leather:

  • Avoid over-conditioning. Over-conditioning is even worse than under-conditioning. If you put on too much conditioner/oil your leather can lose its color, become saggy, and wrinkle.

Cedar Shoe Trees and Rest

Cedar Shoe Trees:

Cedar Shoe trees are vital to absorbing moisture, providing antimicrobial properties, reducing toe spring, and allowing leather to retain its shape.

  • There is no reason not to be using cedar shoe trees.

  • There is no major difference in cedar shoe trees, however, lasted shoe trees are exceedingly rare and even the craziest of shoe aficionados rarely own lasted shoe trees. Here is u/m635_guy 's shoe tree guide.

  • No. You do not need Boot Trees. Shoe trees are fine.

  • Some people prefer to use removable inserts. If you are concerned about sweating too much in your shoes or moisture absorption, here is an actual sock guide.

Rest:

All leather shoes should rest 24 hours after wearing with a cedar shoe tree inserted. Your shoes need time to dry out in order to increase their longevity. To be real, wearing your shoes and boots two or three days in a row won't ruin them but if you want to maximize the longevity of your shoes/boots, rest between wears.

On the extreme end of what happens from not giving your leather boots time to dry between wears, please refer to This infamous case of a user's Iron Rangers interior literally disintegrating from constant wear and sweat/moisture build-up.

All About Conditioners

Application:

Many conditioners can be applied by hand. Be sure to apply small amounts. When in doubt, apply less.

  • Do Not apply external sources of heat (e.g. hair dryer). Heating the leather does not "open the pores" or similar bogus. The only thing you will cause is over-absorption of a product into the leather; the reason a product is not absorbed under normal conditions is because there is too much product.

Please do not place your boots in the oven.

Conditioning if you also polish you shoes?

If your shoes have a layer of wax or polish on them, the conditioner/oil will just sit on the surface, blocked by the wax layer. You will need to remove the wax/polish before conditioning. See "Leather Cleaners" below.

Conditioning dirty boots?

As with polish/wax, if there is a layer of dirt on your boots, the dirt will block absorption of conditioner. Clean first, then condition/oil.

Leather Conditioners:

Here are 7 conditioners commonly prescribed on r/goodyearwelt. This list is by no means exhaustive. There are dozens of specialty products, colored creams, and polishes on the market.

Think of this as a jumping-off point for you to learn about care products.

  • Bick 4: A solid, basic conditioner. Offers good penetration of the leather and once fully dried (in my experience overnight) it can be brushed to a nice neutral shine.

  • Lexol: Use Bick 4 if you can instead.

  • Venetian Shoe Cream: "VSC"- High shine. VSC has many similarities to a polish and once brushed will leave your shoes with an excellent shine. Allegedly Nick Horween's favorite conditioner for Chromexcel leather. Personally, my favorite as well.

  • Venetian Leather Balm: A more concentrated formula of VSC. Excellent on Waxed Flesh Leathers.

  • Red Wing Products: I have received mixed reviews on their oils and creams. Some products such as their "All Weather Boot Oil" will darken your leather. These products may find a niche with certain boot owners but just starting out it is safer to use Bick 4.

  • Saphir Renovateur: High shine once brushed but slightly more absorption than VSC. Can darken lighter leathers in my experience- great if you want to add more depth but be warned if you like how your shoe is. Made with mink oil. Will be a little bit more oily than VSC

  • Saphir Greasy Leather Cream: Personally I like VSC better but some people prefer it for their boots. Not as shiny as VSC, more matte.

Please know higher priced does not mean the best option. Bick 4 can be better than a colored Saphir Cream for you depending on circumstances. Some users like to apply a thin coat of Bick 4 for maintenance followed by a thin application of VSC/Saphir for shine

  • Coconut Oil should NOT be used. Coconut oil was passing fad several years ago however it is very easy to over-apply and saturate your leather with. Return that tub you bought back to Trader Joes and purchase some Bick 4.

  • Food Grade Oils/Products - Please do not use anything that can rot or be eaten. Leather is not your skin. It is a bovine-industrial, manmade marvel designed to defy nature. Using petroleum-based conditioners is fine.

  • Obenauf’s LP should really only be used on boots that undergo extreme duress (e.g. Hunter, Wildlife photographer, construction worker, you walk in a mile of mud daily). If you live in the city or suburbs, you do not need to apply LP. Although you may want to protect your new investment, leather is naturally water resistant and the best idea is to condition it well and rely on its natural resilience. Obenaufs LP will also Darken and remove depth of color from your shoes. It can also cause leathers to become saggy and greasy when over-applied.

Leather Cleaners/ Cleaning

Note: If you are attempting to remove a small stain or spill, often heavy scrubbing and treatment will only enlarge the stain or remove the finish from your boot. Sometimes the best method is to do nothing and let the stain blend with time. Consult the "Daily Questions" thread posted for advice.

Here are three primary leather cleaning products best used to clean excess dirt and grime off your shoes/boots after heavy wear. However, many times wiping down your boots with a damp cloth will suffice.

Again, as stated above regularly brushing your boots is the best maintenance you can perform.

Leather cleaners should be used sparingly. After using a leather cleaner be sure to let dry, then condition. Save leather cleaners for when your boots really need it.

  • Damp Cloth with Water: Surprise! The best method for removing light dirt and grime beyond brushing.

  • Lexol Leather Cleaner: A safe and reliable cleaner, follow instructions on the bottle. To err on the side of caution, avoid intense scrubbing.

  • Saddle Soap: More abrasive, can scrub the finish off a pair of shoes. Good for removing wax buildup. Use with discretion. Lexol Leather Cleaner is generally a safer alternative for beginners. I am not going to explain chemistry here, but Saddle Soap can be really rough on some leathers. I do not recommend using regularly.

  • Saphir Renomat: If you are new to footwear, you should not be using this. Not a cleaner as much as a nuclear option for stain removal and stripping wax, oils, et cetera off a shoe.

Every now and then, it is important to clean the welt of your shoes. Using a tooth brush or q-tip, wipe the welt. u/6t5g likes to say that a clean welt is the mark of someone who truly takes care of their shoes.

Salt Stains:

Heavy salt stains come from stepping in puddles, not from salty dust on the surface.

Those mid-winter puddles of melted ice and snow that are 5% salt by weight, when you step in those the brine soaks into your leather, then you get the salt stains with the precipitating border.

Salt stains must be treated as they will dry out your leather.

For salt stains, simply wipe your boots down with a damp rag using a 50/50 water-vinegar mix.

Scuffs/ Cuts:

If your shoes develop a scuff, it is relatively easy to treat. For pull up leathers or shell cordovan, use your thumb and a tiny amount of conditioner to rub away. It will come out, with time and pressure; leather tends to have many self healing properties.

Sometimes, unfortunately, you cannot make a scuff in regular leather disappear, only cover it up. Alternatively, you can use thin layers of polish to fill and cover the scuff.

Polish/ Creams:

Make sure your shoes are completely dry before polishing. For dress shoes, you will want to apply polish. Similarly to conditioner, apply polish in small layers amounts using a brush or cloth in concentric circles and mild pressure. Do not apply much polish to any area that gets wear and crease, such as the vamp.

Wax based polishes apply some pigment, while providing protection and improving the smoothness of the finish. In addition, they allow for the development of a mirror shine. The trick to developing a mirror shine is to use several thin layers of wax polish, a few drops of water, and an incredible amount of practice and patience. Developing a mirror shine is tough and every person usually develops their own tricks to doing so.

Shoe creams with a matching pigment from Saphir or your shoe's manufacturer can provide a nice even color over a shoe, but will remove some depth of color.

It is good practice to strip the excess wax polish from your dress shoes every three to six months, then condition and rebuild. We suggest using Saphir Renomat to strip any dress shoes, then conditioning with your preferred product.

Some Unique Leathers + Care

Chromexcel:

  • CXL is one of the most fatty, oily, and easiest leathers to care for. At the absolute maximum I would recommend conditioning at most once every 6 months as a general rule.

  • It is a really durable leather. u/varnu's Viberg Natty CXL Boots have allegedly never been conditioned once in their entirity- only spot treatments of VSC and greasy leather cream as needed.

Oiled Leathers:

  • Generally take Bick4 or neutral conditioners the best.

  • Venetian Shoe Cream will leave a polished shine over top. Great for chromexcel but arguably not the conditioner you would want to use on oiled leathers. Bick4 works fine.

Shell Cordovan:

One note: Alden Shell Cordovan seems to have an extra polish or finish applied and as such may not absorb conditioners as well. Brush heavily, and care for on a case-by-case basis.

  • Conditioning Shell Cordovan:

    • Bick4 works well sparingly.

    • Venetian Shoe Cream works well on Shell.

    • Saphir Shell Cordovan Cream is more a polish and can cause buildup on shell - I am not a huge fan of Saphir Cordovan Cream because I find it too waxy.

  • Discussion on Shell Care is an in-depth discussion and Q/A on Shell Cordovan.

    • Another Shell Cordovan Care Guide

    • Be sure to apply lightly, as shell is already highly impregnated with oils. Follow conditioning with another brushing/buffing. Due to shell’s oily nature, it will develop a waxy buildup in the rolls. Simply wipe this away with a damp cloth. There also appears to be some truth to the deer bone rumors. It does seem to be highly effective in removing scuffs and scratches (I had a video here but it has been removed) in shell and other highly oiled leathers, although you can usually achieve the same effects with your thumb and a little bit of oil. This video is also a good watch, but we consider this much attention and care to be overkill for shell cordovan.

Suede, Nubuck, and Roughout Leathers:

We do not advise applying any topical products, as that can ruin the nap. Apply conditioner to the interior of the boot. Nano Tarrago is good to mention too.

  • Point of contention: Some users argue that suede does not need to be conditioned. Ask the "Daily Questions" thread for personal clarification. However if you do condition:

    • If there is a lining interior the boot you can mix lexol with water in a spray bottle and spray it onto the roughout to give an even application. Brush occasionally using a suede brush. Some apply products for water resistance, but that is not necessary. If you do so, we recommend Allen Edmonds' or Bick's sprays. Always follow recommended application.

    • Saphir also has a range of suede/nubuck/rough out products, including a spray conditioner, and a water repellent spray. The Saphir Renovateur spray is a great way to bring back some of the color to suede, as well as condition it. There are several different colors and a neutral spray so choose accordingly. All you have to do is give it a light spray across the surface, and let it sit. The Saphir Invulner waterproofing spray is great for protecting suede from the rain if you end up getting caught in a storm. It provides a layer of protection, almost like Rain X on your windshield, and essentially makes rain bead up and roll off your shoes. You would apply it the same way that you would the conditioner. These are optional depending on the user and not necessarily vital.

Scotch grain or Zug grain:

For true Scotch grain or Zug grain, we suggest brush/wipe and condition treatment similarly to shell cordovan. For pebbled grain shoes, we suggest regular treatment. If you are unsure, we can almost guarantee you they are pebbled grain.

Waxed Flesh Leathers:

Glossary and More Information

Terms to Know

  • Tanning: the process of converting an animal hide into usable leather

  • Parts of a shoe

  • Internal Parts

  • The construction process determines how the bottom of a shoe is put together. Here are the types of stitched constructions

  • u/foggyflute's Excellent Illustrations on construction types.

  • Last: the shape that a shoe is built on

  • Genuine leather: a meaningless and often confusing term that indicates some amount of leather content- both high quality and inferior products may use this term. For example, a "Genuine Leather" boot. Many "genuine leather" shoes and belts you see at the mall are simply a canvas or padded cloth base with a thin coating of leather over top.

At the same time, quality manufacturers, such as Red Wing, sometimes stamp "genuine leather" onto the bottom of their shoes. More reading on Genuine Leather can be found here

  • Top Grain leather: again, not a specific ranked grade. Top Grain means the "not suede" part of leather, usually means something (embossing or sanding) has been done to the surface. Can still be a great leather. It’s not much cheaper than full grain like some articles say: The price difference between Horween Cavalier (top grain) and Chromexcel (full grain) is insignificant". Here is the full write-up.

  • Full-grain leather: another nuanced term. Please read in depth this piece written by u/nstarleather for more information.

  • What is Shell Cordovan? From u/CrizzleLovesYou:

    • Horse hide is from the hide, or sides of the horse and does not include any shell. Horsebutt is the thicker rear of the horse and CAN include the shell, but doesn't always. Viberg is famous for working the shell portion of the horsebutt in well and Clinch is known as one of the best as they practically always produce the signature rolls. Shell is an inner layer (subcutaneous?) of any equestrian animals booty and is only present in that family of animals. Since the top layer is gone there is no separation so it forms rolls instead of creases like other leathers. Its harder and more durable than other leathers and is vegtan only, it also has a much longer tanning process and I believe each horse only makes about 2 pairs of boots roughly. There are only a few shell tanneries in operation today, the main and most famous one being Horween who started producing shell specifically for footwear thanks to a contract with Alden that essentially saved the business decades ago. There is one Japanese tannery (shinki), a few Italian ones (though potentially only 2 producers of raw shell and the unfinished shell gets finished at other tanneries), a british tannery of which I've never seen the shell used in footwear and the south american one as well which is the cheapest of the lot. There's plenty of good and more accurate histories of shell out there as well and I may have an error or two in this wall of text so apologies ahead of time.*

Basic Summary of the Tanning Process

Leather is the result of tanning raw animal skins, making it more durable and less susceptible to decomposition processes. The tanning process has many variations to produce many different types of leather, although few specifics are known outside of the industry. According to Nick Horween, the general tanning process is as follows: receive hide, cut/trim hides, wash and soak, dehair, flesh, bate, pickle, tan, press, sort, split, shave, re-tan, condition, dry, apply stain/color, adjust color, adjust feel, iron/plate, trim/sort, pack, and ship.

Although there are variations, we can discuss some generalities about leather. Its workwear heritage can be attributed to its tough, water-resistant, and hardwearing nature. In addition, leather can develop a beautiful patina with time, adding to its character.

Identifying quality leather is not an easy process and is best done through experience and there are many manufacturers who will disguise the quality of leather goods (for example, stitching a layer of thin leather over a foam belt). Moreover, it’s largely dependent on the type of leather used. Better leathers have more consistent grain, less variation in finish and thickness, and are not corrected or treated. Other than that, we suggest time spent reading about and experiencing leather.

In Conclusion

Leather care may seem intimidating but it is quite enjoyable to develop your own style of care.

Leather is inherently resilient, but we want to maximize its life. Through excellent care, we can make an investment last a lifetime.

Good luck!


r/goodyearwelt • • Jul 14 '20

Question My GYW story, addiction, and why I'm stepping away

1.1k Upvotes

First, this is an alt I've created specifically for this post - I'm just not comfortable posting from my main for numerous reasons.

Some of you might find this post, read it, and think, "What a loser. This guy can't stop himself from buying pieces of dead animal that attach to your feet". Looking at this story as it's written, I'd tend to agree with you. I've spent over $10,000+ and probably owned over 40-50 different pairs of shoes and boots in the past 2 years. For even an above-average income, that feels like an insane amount of money. In most respects, I think of myself as a level-headed, reasonable guy. But it's shocking how much money a person can spend with a combination of a rational need (resoleable, sustainable footwear), addictive personality, and social media/materialism's grinding hype machine.

You might also think, "What a drama queen. This guy is going to fill up this WYSIWYG editor with that many words about how he bought too many shoes?". This post might be a little self-indulgent, but my hope is someone else finds it, relates, and realizes they are at -or beyond - their version of "enough" too.

I'm writing this post to share with all of you, but also to help jumpstart the process of letting go of this hobby for myself. I have enough shoes and boots to last me a literal lifetime, and even if I sold half of my pairs I'd still be set. I've spent $7k in the past 12 months on footwear, and that's not even the issue. For me, this hobby was an addiction - it's the time, energy, and the brainspace that concerns me. The opportunity cost of spending time on the internet discussing footwear with strangers and looking at instagram boot shots rather than being present with family and friends. I'm too old, with too many special people depending on my measly skills, time and attention to keep this going. And my pocketbook is finally tapped.

My Start

I was living in a big city, traveling to high-profile clients in dress shoes, where the cemented sole would make a "clap" sound each time I took a step, as it came further ungluged and slapped the midsole. Like waiting too long for a haircut - I had let these shoes live too long. I remember thinking how arduous the dress shoe buying process was and remember the rows of $49 - $129 dress shoes at DSW, where I'd try to find the most streamlined, basic dress shoe amongst a sea of dress/sneaker hybrids and over-brogued corrected grain leather. That's when I remembered I had $300 lined up in my wedding budget for shoes.

I grabbed my first pair of Allen Edmonds in Walnut Fifth Ave as seconds, $211. I remember walking over to my significant other in jubilation - how is it possible you could get such nice shoes at this price? My last DSW pair was $70, but at 3x the price I could resole these at least 8-10x over. Plus they flat out looked so much better. I'd never cared about business dress before, but this was an upgrade. I justified grabbing a pair of brown Bartletts off eBay for $150 lightly used to rotate my shoes, again, blown away by the "upgrade" of lambskin lining and such a soft leather.

For awhile, I was perfectly ok with this setup - I still wore sneakers on the weekends with my occasional Kenneth Cole waterproof boots in the rain. Maybe 6 months passed, and I bought an unlined suede loafer from AE which was a revelation in comfort. Other than that though, I was pretty happy with what I had.

Like my old hobbies of gaming, raw denim, soccer, and etc. Reddit has something for everyone. I found r/malefashionadvice, r/frugalmalefashion, and eventually r/goodyearwelt and dove in.

New Revelations

I was surprised, but not blown away by what I discovered on this sub at first. I read through a few reviews, one of which was for a pair of Monkey boots which, at the time, was the ugliest footwear I had ever set eyes on. I remember conversation about Alden and Tricker's, Viberg and Crockett & Jones, but didn't really notice much difference in my walnut oxford versus whatever dress shoe Alden was putting out for 2-3x the price I could get AE seconds for. I remember actually posting something to the effect of "I don't understand why someone would buy these Viberg CXL boots for $600+ when you can get Higgins Mills for $250" and getting ruthlessly downvoted. I was new, and naive.

I was pretty determined to stay in my AE-world and shut this door until I saw Withered Fig x Viberg's Marvington II's. I was blown away by how good a boot could look. That leather, brass eyelets, natural welt and cream mini ripple had a workwear but somewhat subtle streetwear vibe that I knew I had to have. But the price was astounding. $700 for boots was flat out insulting to my face. I knew I could find something cheaper. I contacted Indonesian bootmakers on IG, MTO bootmakers like Parkhurst and Mark Albert, and even looked at Alden's mildly less expensive and less interesting options in Tobacco chamois. None were the same, but I wasn't shelling out $700. I ended up buying a couple cheaper options, an while I got the jist of what I wanted, it wasn't the real thing.

Thus started me checking all the resale sites - eBay, Grailed, and Poshmark - daily, sometimes every couple hours. I set up notifications, researched B/S/T threads for used pricing, and messaged WF's IG accountholder almost every week asking if a restock was planned yet. About 3 months in, I found a Grailed ad for the boots - lightly used and one full size bigger than what I think I needed - for $400. I stupidly offered $350 and the rest is history. When I got the boots, I swore never to size incorrectly (though an insole and thick socks still make them fit fine) again, and I also swore I wouldn't bother buying lower quality boots than these either. Viberg addiction engaged.

The Deep End

Viberg and Alden were now firmly my taste. I felt like I had to "round out" my collection with natural CXL, brown CXL, snuff suede, horsebutt, and even some shell. I needed a commando sole for who knows what, dainite for the office, and mini ripple for the weekends. And my taste constantly changed: some days, I wanted a moc toe Indy, other days I was into a Grant Stone LWB, but ultimately I didn't have the money for this addiction.

My brain turned to what I could sell. A PS4, maybe the nice peacoat I bought, or maybe I could downgrade my car for something cheaper. I had a 401k account with $5k from a job I hated.

That's where I should have stopped. I was in a full-on addiction, ready to sell real assets at a determent to myself, to buy stuff I didn't need. I didn't, though. I liquidated that 401k and ended up ~$3800 to spend on whatever the hell I wanted, and I was going to buy the boots I wanted. I spent hours per night - getting home from work at 6, looking at boots, making posts here asking for opinions, checking eBay hourly, and putting all my personal fitness, diet, and other hobbies on hold. My significant other would ask what I was doing sometimes, "I'm just browsing", I'd say. My other username probably asked a couple hundred questions in this simple questions thread. I posted daily on styleforum. I have folders full of boot pictures, called "boot hype pics".

I started looking at non-boot research as a chore. Making dinner - chore. Exercising - chore. There wasn't enjoyment in going to get a coffee anymore, even if I could go wear my boots, because I wasn't researching boots. What if someone posted something up on eBay and I missed it? It's Friday at Noon, maybe I should go to lunch after Division Road's newest release comes out. These are actual thoughts that went through my head, and after I got my Chipotle back to the office, I'd flip through IG stories to see what various posters had gotten recently.

In 2018, I'd read 38 books, watched a ton of new movies, eaten at new restaurants, and meditated daily. I did yoga, lifted weights, and spent time with family. I didn't do most of those things in 2019 and into 2020. Granted, covid happened. But my SO and my relationship, even with the normal strains of having a child, new jobs, new city, etc - just feels a little more distant than it has.

In the last 12 months, I've purchased 8 pairs of Vibergs, 2 pairs of Aldens, 3 AEs, and pairs from Oak Street, Parkhurst, Grant Stone, Mark Albert, Truman, RM Williams, and Loake. Many of those I've purchased pre-owned or at big discounts, but I have dropped $700 on brand new Vibergs more than once. And as you'd guess, I spent every bit of that 401k money, without telling my SO. When new boots come in, they ship to my office and I sneak them into the rest of my rotation hoping she doesn't notice. When she does, I occasionally lie and tell her she just hasn't noticed them yet, or I haven't worn them in awhile. It's messed up, childish, and unfair. I know from watching similar topics touch this vein, there are a few posters that will come down hard on me, but admitting it is the hardest part.

Time to get out

I realized I'm just not getting much done this year. I'm not present. I feel like I even have less to talk about with normal people. My brain feels like it's almost atrophying from all of the social media and aesthetic analysis I'm doing on other dude's footwear. I keep a good job, stay in good shape, keep my family afloat, and generally lead a happy life. But hours go by on weekends where I've spent staring at other dude's feet. I lust during weeknights at new releases from Division Road, Standard & Strange, and other retailers who are pumping out amazing looking collaborations that I love to look at. I could probably be doing something more with my life. Even if the black hole is only 8 hours per week - that's 8 hours that could go to guitar practice, running, reading, or anything else that contributes to me becoming a better person rather than a better dressed person.

I realized that after diving into the "deep end" in gaming, raw denim, and other hobbies that have consumed my life in the past and I either just outgrew or didn't have enough time for - that I have an addictive personality. There's a special set of ingredients - usually a functional need, a tight-knit community, a dash of exclusivity - all of which is like an addictive drug for me.

But it's time to stop.

I haven't figured out how to step away yet. I'm still checking r/goodyearwelt, Styleforum, Grailed, eBay, and Instagram daily. I go to bed dreaming about the next boots I want to buy - even though they're certainly going to overlap with something else already in my collection. I've debated maybe buying the two more pairs I want, sign something in blood and burn it in a fire to make a pact with myself and stop cold turkey - delete everything from social media, ban yourself from this sub and styleforum, and block all your favorite retailers (jk about the sign it in blood part). I've also considered limiting myself a little more -maybe I stick with this, but allow myself only 15 minutes a day. Maybe new makeups will come out, and I'll want them so bad I'll sell two pairs that I already have and get the new one, and that will help whittle down my collection (ha, hopeful addict's brain speaking).

I would love recommendations though, on a practical or realistic approach to walk away.

I've learned it's ok to have and enjoy nice things. But becoming so attached to them, and the lust for more is toxic for me, and I'm sure for others. I'm not a perfect person and I certainly regret the secretive, weird, and desperate behavior I've exhibited, for something so material as footwear.

I'll leave you with this quote that gives me some comfort. It's about attachment, and that it's perfectly ok to like nice things, but don't define yourself with them. Thanks for reading, and I hope you can either relate and find a new start, or avoid becoming sucked into this hobby or another to the detriment of healthy things you'll pursue.

‘Every morning I drink from my favorite teacup. I hold it in my hands and feel the warmth of the cup from the hot liquid it contains. I breathe in the aroma of my tea and enjoy my mornings in this way. But in my mind, the teacup is already broken.’

EDIT:

I half expected this post would get deleted as it isn’t a review or novel discussion, and had no expectation it would get even a few comments on it. Thank you for everyone’s support and outreach, I appreciate it!

I’m planning to take tangible steps, which include at least removing the problem at the source (deleting or blocking anything that enables me: including social media, reddit, etc). I do think it’s worth talking to a professional as well, so I will be taking steps to do that.


r/goodyearwelt • • Jul 09 '26

Cordwaining Handwelted derby boots I made for my dad

Thumbnail
gallery
1.1k Upvotes

I made these derby boots for my dad. I wanted to make him a pair because he has a wide forefoot and narrow heel so he’s never had boots fit him properly, along with quality materials and construction. I’ve also been thinking that I might take custom orders after I graduate from college, so I’m trying to get practice making boots for friends and family.

I chose an anatomical last from Spenlé in Germany but ordered through ShoemakerCraft. I ordered the lasts to fit his joint but had to build it up in the toes and match it to his measurements by removing material in the heel. I also made a custom pattern, a classic derby style. I chose a thin leather midsole and a Dr. Sole jade outsole for a nice balance between flexibility and sturdiness. Handwelted with bakers insole, seat stitched, and pegged rand/heel seat. The uppers are Horween CXL horsebutt strip, with a bellows tongue that’s been carefully skived at the fold.

These are the first boots I’ve made during my summer internship with Unsung House, using methods and techniques they’ve been teaching me. I used to always make boots without a sander. I’d do all the bottom work with my Japanese knife, including heel shaping, which is very difficult to do by hand. I’ve been using a line finisher at the internship and it saves so much time and energy, and it’s been less of a steep learning curve than I expected. The sole stitcher has more of a learning curve because I like making my welts tight. this pair has a little wider welt than I normally do, and the stitching turned out great. The internship is awesome, it’s a really great shop and everyone is super nice and helpful with teaching me. I feel very grateful for the experience.

This week I’ll be finishing up a pair of engineer boots. They’ll be my first engineers, so I’m excited! My dad will be getting his boots around his birthday.

My first pair of derby boots were made on a pattern and last combo from Etsy, and the overall proportions were bad and the lasts were clunky. The second pair had too thick of a counter and were lasted tilting a little too far back. I’ve learned a lot since then, and with the help of the team at Unsung House, I feel like these are by far the best derbies I’ve made. The proportions are nice to my eye, especially considering how anatomical the last is. The waist is pretty narrow and the heel is tight. Heel balancing on these anatomical German lasts is very difficult and unusual, but other than that the build process felt smooth. I hope my dad puts good wear on these boots!


r/goodyearwelt • • Oct 06 '25

Cordwaining black bespoke boots i made for my cousin

Thumbnail
gallery
1.1k Upvotes

these are fully lined with a 1.8mm combi tanned german cow hide that i dyed green in the quarters. the upper leather is 2.5mm chrometan cowhide. the tongue is gusseted. heel and toe stiffeners are 2.5 mm veg tan from germany. the insoles are 6mm buffalo bend from italy. midsoles and heels are oak bark bend from tannery martin.
the shank isvsteel with pegged leather cover. sheet cork filler in the front.
360° handwelt construction with 270° hidden channel sole stitch (with handmade flax thread), blindwelted in the medial waist.
the heels are pegged and nailed (the way i learned).
the heel rubber is fixed with long brass nails, outsole with brass screws.
the edge finish is natural. no dye, only wax ironed in. (got to love that redish colour that the martin leather takes on!)
waist is dyed in the same green as the lining.
the only machines used are my mechanical postbed machine (adler 7-1) and a small sanding motor for working on the rubber parts.

there are also a few pictures of the making. i hope you like those beasts :) let me know what you would have made differently or if you have any questions.

if you want, you can check out my instagram for more pictures of my boots: https://www.instagram.com/charly.boots/?next=%2F#
i have many posts about bootmaking techniques too...


r/goodyearwelt • • Feb 27 '25

Cordwaining Boots I made last month

Thumbnail
gallery
1.1k Upvotes

Last month I did an independent study at my school (Risd) where I made boots and I also TAed for the cowboy boot making class. I ended up making 3 pairs of boots, 2 were handwelted and the lace to toe was double stitch down nail down. It was really amazing to be able to focus on boot making, I’ve been learning about the craft since high school and I only made 2 pairs before this. I really learned a lot over the month and it’s so nice to have 3 pairs of boots that I made in my rotation. They all fit me well and I’ve broken them in except the lace to toe boot is still a little stiff. I used horween leather and dr soles for all the boots. The monkey boot is cxl, derby is latigo, and the lace to toe boot is a 2 tone combo. I have so many more ideas for boots that I want to make but I’ll have to wait till the summer because this semester is going to be really busy.


r/goodyearwelt • • Jan 05 '20

Image(s) Viberg Natural Shell Service Boots - 12 months.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
1.0k Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • Mar 01 '24

Cordwaining Intimidation be damned! I hand made my boots from scratch!

Thumbnail
gallery
1.0k Upvotes

Update from last week when I only had one boot, I now have a pair! Im beyond pleased with how they turned out. Kicking myself for not making an attempt long ago but excited to continue down this rabbit hole! These are Horween dublin 6/7 oz with a vibram cristy sole. Was trying to make a sort of munson style toe box and think they look pretty darned schnazzy! Appreciate all the knowledge yall share here, it finally gave me the courage to tackle a looong held ambition.


r/goodyearwelt • • Aug 17 '20

My shoe collection - 30 pairs (15 bespoke)

Thumbnail
gallery
991 Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • Jun 08 '20

Meermin Cherry Shinki Cordovan Service boot

Post image
976 Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • Feb 17 '21

My first homemade boots after 100 hours of wear.

Thumbnail
gallery
947 Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • Dec 18 '17

Image(s) I made a pair of boots myself

Thumbnail
imgur.com
930 Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • Apr 07 '22

Original Content 108 years old and 54 years old boots I have at home. A proof that good boots can last you a lifetime.

Thumbnail
gallery
890 Upvotes

r/goodyearwelt • • Sep 23 '21

Cordwaining Finished making some boots out of Marine Field Roughout

Thumbnail
gallery
881 Upvotes