r/glee • • 4d ago

Discussion Unpopular opinion: Rachel hate

13 Upvotes

Unpopular opinion, but I genuinely think Lea Michele gets way too much hate for how she behaved on Glee.

I remember when all the tweets and allegations came out and even as a Black woman, I remember thinking at the time that some of the backlash was being blown way out of proportion.

Lea comes from a Broadway background, and anyone who knows anything about the theatre industry knows just how cutthroat and competitive it can be. Your best friend today could quite literally be your competition tomorrow. From what I’ve read, Lea seemed to bring that exact same mentality onto the set of Glee. She knew she was the star of the show, she carried herself like one and I think that rubbed certain cast members up the wrong way.

I’m not saying that excuses genuinely poor treatment of people because it doesn’t. But I do think there’s a difference between someone being difficult, competitive or having a massive ego and the way Lea has been villainised over the years.

And let’s be real, the woman was ridiculously talented. In my opinion, she was arguably the most talented performer on that show with Amber Riley being her only real competition. Even then, as incredible as Mercedes was vocally, I don’t think she had quite the same theatrical range and versatility that Rachel did. Lea could deliver practically anything they gave her and there’s a reason Rachel Berry was written as the lead.

I also think people sometimes blur the lines between Rachel Berry and Lea Michele. Rachel was literally written to be ambitious, self-centred, competitive and desperate to be a star. That was the whole point of her character!

I genuinely believe that if people watched Glee for the first time today, without being influenced by all the online discourse from years ago a lot of them would see Rachel very differently.

At this point, some of the Rachel Berry hate feels incredibly forced and I think people are reluctant to admit just how much Lea contributed to making Glee what it was.


r/glee • • Dec 22 '23

Discussion Idk why people hate on Finn so much for outing Santana

0 Upvotes

Pretty much the title.

I heard about this outing scene being such a big deal because of Finn, before I watched the show. I heard how annoyed people were at the writing and Finn in general. But I was surprised to watch the scene and realise he didn’t even do it on purpose! THIS WHOLE TIME I THOUGHT HE WAS SOME AWFUL PERSON WHO PURPOSELY OUTED SANTANA OUT OF NOWHERE. But no. What Finn did was merely an accident. And one that doesn’t even make sense because in eariler episodes Brittany had already outed Santana. Like when she revealed to the school that Santana played for two different teams and the top that she gave Santana that said lesbians, the one that Santana actually wears at school later on in the episode.

So idk why Finn’s accident just like Brittany’s is more attacked. Even then I still agree that Finn messed up. I think both Brittany and Finn did, but I can understand where Finn was coming from. He said something awful and should have definitely thought before saying something like that but Santana had been riling him up. She had been bullying the new directions constantly. She continously threw dodgeballs at Rory until he cried. Completely innocent Rory who did nothing to her. Like shouldn’t we hate on Santana for that?! For embarrassing and injuring the new kid who was already getting bulling at school. And then Santana goes on to make fun of Finn’s weight which can be extremely harmful and as we’ve seen before Finn’s insecure about his body so she willing added to that problem. And she did so ruthlessly pointing out his flaws in a long rant that Finn just had to take. So he said something in the moment, the only thing that would get through to her. With no intention of outing her but just putting her in her place. Like of course he was gonna break. Becauee really what did Santana think was going to happen? That she could always get away with saying whatever she wants and have no repercussions? This isn’t the first time she has run her mouth, insulting people. Then the second someone gives it back to her we all have to feel sorry for her?

I’m not saying the outing thing wasn’t a big deal or wasn’t devastating. I did feel bad for Santana but not in the sense that I needed to blame someone more that this horrible thing happened to her. Because it was an accidnet. So I don’t think Finn deserves all the hate he gets for it. Especially since he apologised?! Santana has never said sorry for anything she has said even though she started the whole argument thing with Finn.

With all that being said even after the fact Finn was proven right. After that episode Santana started being nicer. She stopped ruthlessly insulting people. She was genuinely a better character. So to me it all went well???

Am I missing something? Because Finn is clearly and most definitely forgiven.


r/glee • • Dec 27 '24

Tier List I saw other people make a tier list so I wanted to copy them. Downvote me if you feel like it.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/glee • • Dec 16 '24

Character Disc. Marley’s mom

3 Upvotes

Marley’s mom is soooo toxic it’s actually insane. At what point in Marley’s childhood did she start to project all her insecurities into her daughter and has she ever put on a brave face ??? She seems like the mom to tell you at 3 years old that Santa isn’t real so that you know everything you got was earned with her hard up and hard earned money. It started as “you gotta wear this fake j crew or you’re not gonna have friends” then it was “we should go on a diet since you’re worried about turning into me” then “ god Marley you’re bulimic now and we’re poor. No Christmas for us but I’ll be damned if you’re not gonna be healthy again”. It’s a miracle Marley’s not in some inpatient for depression but I’m not even done with her first full season so maybe it’s coming


r/glee • • May 08 '25

Discussion Anyone else find the “Lea Michele can’t read” discourse unfunny and reductive

20 Upvotes

Like, it’s genuinely so annoying, tiring, played, and not even funny. She was a guest on some influencer’s platform or podcast recently, and I can’t find any clips talking about anything else aside from that stupid meme. So annoying


r/glee • • May 21 '26

Discussion Hot Take: Blaine sucks

25 Upvotes

I’m constantly seeing stuff praising Blaine and his character and his voice and I’m breaking my silence. Blaine was an awful boyfriend, annoying character, and was very whatever when he sang. He’s never Kelly Clarksoned anybody. The og Cough Syrup is 10 times better than anything Blaine has ever done. His voice is boring, frankly. Like he ruined Superstition and like any other song he was on and I wouldn’t even consider him on the top 5 singers on the show, maybe not even top 10. Kurt should’ve gotten with Sam and Blam is ass. He should not be listen among the names of Rachel, Mercedes, and Santana. Thank you.

Edit: Downvoting because someone doesn’t like your favorite character is childish. This isn’t a serious post, chill out.

Edit 2: You are wrong and I am right as always. I will always reign, inshallah

Edit 3: Teenage dream isnt good either


r/glee • • May 20 '25

Rachel being the protagonist is so contradictive to the main theme of Glee I think anyone else being the lead wouldve made this show make more sense. A deep dive into “Rachel Wanting it more than anyone” Argument

0 Upvotes

Literally the main theme of Glee (not saying its written down anywhere) but literally what happens every episode is accepting each others differences and getting over hurdles that life puts in your way.

And they gave the “Protagonist Role” to the one person with literally NO hurdles unless you think having your nose bridge extend a centimeter further than “normal beauty standards” is a big hurdle.

I know people in this sub loves the argument Rachel wants this more than anyone but you can literally interchange that trait with any character in this show and it would have made the plot so much more substantial. If Artie wanted it more than anyone, would it have mattered to the audience?

If Rachel didn’t want it more than anything then who is she as a character?

Also I love to do a deeper dive into the “Rachel wanted it more than anyone”.

Rachel didn’t only want it more than anyone, she thinks she deserves it more than anyone, she thinks life owes her this… why? Because shes the only one with no actual obstacles in the cast. Born a girl with natural talent and parents who supported her dreams from childhood. The only thing she needed to do was to not forget words in auditions.

Kurt did want it but he had reservations, if Broadway would cast someone like him, if Broadway would let him do female songs etc. These are actual roadblocks that can keep a person from “Wanting it the msot out of everyone.” And I think if given the Protagonist role would have made him overcoming these problems an actual plotline that would tackle actual diversity and change.

Mercedes. A fat black girl. That sentence alone has mountains of road blocks. You think a girl in that year like her could dare to dream as big as Rachel? Having twice the talent but less than half the recognition for everything she does? Could someone who lived in microaggresions and racism and body shaming and bullying dare to “Want it the most and dream the biggest?” I think having a story around overcoming that would be amazing and actually protagonist-esque.

Mercedes and Kurt had actual problems and road blocks whereas Rachel could fix hers with a nose job. Kurt could never be not feminine and gay and Mercedez couldnt stop being black.

I could probably see this for most of the cast. Even Britanny with her childish and naivete wouldve made for an interesting character as we see the world through her lens. Instead we get a cruel white woman who sends asians to crack houses the moment she sniffs out talent that exceeds her.

I don’t want to even talk about Finn where his only problem was not being able to dance greatly. He literally had 0 problems and that speaks alot about how Glee tried to present itself and what it actually is. They tried to do this overcoming and diversity thing but deep inside it tells us that only white people can be protagonists who can fuck up every single episode and do the most vile stuff and yet be awarded at every turn…


r/glee • • Sep 07 '22

Rant Anyone else get so irritated at Marley? Shes so naive and i know in high school everyone can be naive but shes smart and stupid at the same time and it makes me cringe. Ruining nationals and barely apologizing to everyone😒

2 Upvotes

EDIT: sectionals***


r/glee • • Mar 27 '25

Character Disc. I hate Rachel.

5 Upvotes

I don’t know if I’m allowed to post this… [Delete if not.] But I really do hate her throughout the entirety of the show. And if/when you binge it (which I’m currently doing), you can see very clearly how manipulative she is. I think she’s the only character that has beef’d with and manipulated every single other character throughout the show.

And she was the -worst- to Finn & Santana! If Ryan Murphy didn’t love Lea as much as he did (so much that he has explicitly said if she didn’t want to do the show- he would just cancel it), I don’t think her story would have turned out the way it did.

What really pushed me to post this/over the edge is: I’m currently watching the episode where the glee club ends in Season 5 (episode 13) and Rachel truly believes it in her altercation with Santana where she says “I’m better than you” in front of the entire Glee Club. /Then/ moments after says to Mercedes in the bathroom “I thought it was always me and you vs. everybody” when she’s never done anything for Mercedes throughout the show beside be her tormentor. In fact, she was the /most/ terrible to her out of everyone on the team. And to hear Mercedes respond saying that Santana was her biggest tormentor when the only time they really beef’d was over Puck was crazy to me. 🤯

Then for Rachel to cry and say she’s (Santana) always like that in New York when Santana had done nothing but support Rachel the /entire/ time she was living with them.. is wild. Not to mention: Rachel was the one who said “we were never really friends” despite Santana always making clear that she’s been bothered by Rachel, thinks things of her “but has love for her” in the last few episodes..

Idk. Maybe I’ll delete this tomorrow. (Probably not now) But.. it’s all just so wild.

I’ve been rewatching it in front of friends and family- and no matter what plot, what episode, what season.. they’re always so thrown off when they watch a full two episodes because they see /something/ that Rachel is doing is terrible.

** Edited to fix grammar, but the post is still the same.


r/glee • • Nov 22 '22

Kurt hummel hate rant

0 Upvotes

hi, I'm new to this I recently just started watching glee. I'm currently in the second season and I can't stan Kurt. 1. He has a victim complex that makes everyone seem to like the bad ones. He doesn't admit he had an obsessive crush on Finn and says Finn is homophobic. He literally was so toxic for Mercedes when trying to lose weight. He hates the popular kids but loves their attention. He thinks he is a fashionista but has a horrible fashion sense. I myself am bi and proud, but he hits on straight guys or tries to persuade them into being something they are not. that being said, he is a bad representation of the lgbtq+ community. He is mean, selfish, and proud: when he tryouts to the wicked song vs Rachel and when he would call his friends "mentally filled" for believing in god.


r/glee • • Jan 08 '22

Glee Yearbook!

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/glee • • May 11 '24

From the perspective of a completely blind woman, I think that Rachel was the proper choice for Maria for my side story.

0 Upvotes

As far as the WSS thing with rachel and mercedes was concerned I really do feel that rachel was the proper pick for Maria right from the word go, mercedes didn’t fit the voice or the personality, her audition was confident and powerful ware as Rachel’s was naïve and innocent, which is what is, she also showed amazing maturity whin it came to being double cast along side mercedes for the part, it was mercedes who through the childish tantrum at being double cast, rahcel didn’t and I’m sorry but rachel has that classical soprano that maria calls for ware as mercedes doesn’t. Now, before anyone comes at me and starts screaming racist at the tops of there longs please remember I’m completely blind so I’m basing this assessment upon vocals and personality, and nothing more.


r/glee • • May 13 '26

Opinion hot take: santana isnt really a good person shes super mean and bullies people for almost no reason

0 Upvotes

r/glee • • Jan 14 '24

Why?!

2 Upvotes

I actually find myself provoked by the whole Santana in New York situation. It’s so unfair how the bully wins. Auditioning for the understudy without telling Rachel is bad enough. The worst part however is how Santana is the reason why Rachel moves out of the apartment Kurt and her had first. Santana just showing up out of nowhere moving in. It might be weird to think this is so bad haha, but I think it has to do with how I got bullied when I was a kid. Glee was about the outsiders, why did they let the bully win?


r/glee • • Sep 07 '22

To the people supporting/applauding Lea Michele's role in Funny Girl...

0 Upvotes

Let me ask you a question.

If this was your school bully.

The person who discriminated against you and your peers.

Who was egoistic and acted like a famewhore.

Who was classist and treated those who were clearly "below" them like garbage.

Who did the same thing throughout their entire life and never showed remorse or apologised.

Let's imagine this person became famous, everyone knew their name, and rather than getting karma handed to them, ended up getting what they wanted - their dream role they've wanted since they were a little kid.

Never mind the fact that people (rightfully) called them out, take into account that they ended up winning, which to you, and other people they bullied, would be a slap in the face.

Would you support them?

And if your answer is yes - why?


r/glee • • Apr 13 '25

As she should see

Post image
0 Upvotes

People in this sub seem to be forgetting that Lea is literally racist and my comment on the one post kept getting downvoted and was locked by the mods for “targeting.” I get liking Rachel as a character, as I do too, but supporting Lea and ignoring her behavior when actually BLACK people are saying her apology wasn’t enough makes you just as bad as she is.


r/glee • • Mar 10 '23

The queer baiting Faberry subtext was maddening

0 Upvotes

When you were singing that song you were singing it to Finn, and only Finn, right? You’re the most prettiest girl I’ve ever seen, Quinn. I’m not gonna let you ruin your life by marrying Finn Hudson.


r/glee • • Sep 14 '24

My extreme dislike/hate/loathing of Finn Hudson (Please let me explain before getting upset) Repost after putting a mean nickname for Finn

0 Upvotes

Btw my apologies for adding that before. Lesson learned but still doesn't change my opinion minus the nickname. He still did and was as bad or even worse the most if not all of my list.

I know there are characters that many think are mean and terrible Sue, Santana, Bree, Kitty, etc... But they get called out by both fans of the show or other cast members.

Disclaimer: This is separate from my feelings/opinions on Cory Monteith I have absolutely nothing against him at all infact most of his costars say he was a nice guy and was really sweet and I never met him so I am going to go with that.

The difference with Finn is he is mean, hateful, sometimes downright vicious and/or cruel. a wee bit homophobic, smug a**hole, rude, obtuse, and the list goes on. But he is still painted as this can do no wrong, hero, sh*t don't stink, nice guy, gods gift character by both fans and characters. It is so devastatingly frustrating to watch, I have almost wished plenty of times that I can get my hands on some Snixx juice and go all Lima heights on him freaking seriously annoyed by him.

Btw I thought about posting a list of my unpopular opinions should I?


r/glee • • Oct 10 '13

My bone to pick with both Beatles episodes

0 Upvotes

Despite being a a long time, MAJOR gleek.. During both episodes of the Beatles specials.. I got kind of bored. I felt like there was TOO much singing. And it wouldn't be an issue if there was different songs. Problem 1- due to the songs having to all be from a single artist, the songs didn't really fit the story line of the character at that point in time. As soon as an interesting plot point happens, they break into an irrelevant song.
Problem 2- Glee's age demographic is 12-17yo girls and gays. And however much people try and deny it, it's true. So having such young people watching songs from artists they're not really familiar with will make people loose interest. The only reason I know 'here comes the sun' is due to bee movie.

Thoughts?


r/glee • • Jul 20 '24

Why do Lea Michele fans make excuses for her past behavior ?

6 Upvotes

Feel free to ignore this it’s just something I was thinking abt and couldn’t get it off my mind.

Now I wanna start of by saying I myself don’t mind Lea for who she is now in present time I however do not agree with her behavior and the things she said and did in the past and I think she should be held accountable for these things.

I was thinking abt something to do with one of the girls from dance moms and people that like her blaming her rude behavior on her anxiety and stuff and it made me think abt how some people that are like hardcore Lea fans that just believe she didn’t do shit claim her behavior was okay bc she was mourning Cory and all that, and I wanna know why ? Like, I like her but I’m not gonna act like she didn’t do what she did. Sure she’s acknowledged it in recent years and expressed her regret but yet some people still act like she just didn’t do it and I don’t understand it.

Pretty sure there aren’t any Lea fans on here but still figured I’d put it out there anyhow. Hopefully I don’t end up getting bashed or whatever 😭.

PS : I know the shit Lea did was terrible and I do not agree with her past actions.


r/glee • • Mar 10 '25

Character Disc. Finn was an awful brother and always made Kurt’s issues about himself

0 Upvotes

P.S. I don’t care that he was a midwestern teenager in the 2010s. All that tells me is he’s a midwestern dick.

Finn Hudson was an awful awful person, I don’t understand the appeal of him as a leader but whatever.

What I want to talk about is how awful he was as a brother. I get that Finn and Kurt started off rocky with the whole crush situation and whatever, but since the lamp incident literally everytime something happens to Kurt, he stands back and makes up some bullshit self centered excuse about needing to be the quarterback again or how it will make him look bad.

First incident that really made my blood boil was him raging at Kurt for not telling him that Burt was in the hospital. I get that at this point they’re practically brothers, but he’s not your dad!!!! At least ask Kurt if he’s okay or something instead of storming in like an angry giant!

The next one is him refusing to stand up to Karovsky for him, because he didn’t want to get hurt, wanted to be the leader on the football team and all that bullshit. Basically, he didn’t want to hurt his nonexistent rep. Then at the wedding, he makes this big speech about how he’ll always be there for him, but the thing is if the other glee guys hadn’t stepped in, he would’ve continued not caring.

I think the thing I hate the most is he has this dirty habit of being a dick the entire episode then at the end he makes some bullshit speech about how he’ll make sure to step up THEN NEVER ACTUALLY DOES!!

Anyways, I hate this guy.


r/glee • • Apr 09 '24

Character Disc. Mercedes does not understand what it means to be on a competition team

0 Upvotes

"You're crazy for not letting me shine" - Mercedes to Mr. Schue in 3x03 was...

Quite possibly the WORST possible moment the writers could have had Mercedes say that line. Everyone tends to comment that Mercedes was an under-utilized vocalist in the New Directions, and I agree. However, it wasn't after failing to get a ballad solo that Mercedes said the line.

Instead, she says it during booty camp, attended by almost the entire ND even those who can dance like Santana and Brittany. She was the worst at the dance move, and so was not being tapped out by Mike or Mr. Schue. And no, this wasn't just Mr. Schue being biased, as Mike was instructing too, and he was watching Mercedes specifically even before Mr. Schue arrived. Mercedes wasn't performing, was shown to be lazy throughout the episode. And then proceeds to get defensive about it.

I don't like Mercedes, and this is exactly why. On every team I've ever played on, there were people who performed worse at certain elements of whatever sport (be it speed, strength, skill, etc). That was fine, not everyone has the same starting point. But when you've identified that weakness, you should be putting in extra effort in behind the scenes to mitigate that gap. You should NEVER complain that you're being criticized for being bad at something you're not good at. You owe it to yourself and to your teammates to close the gap to them in your own time, as they're all also making their own sacrifices for the sake of the team.

"Stop picking on me. You're always singling me out, making me look bad," she says. That's exactly what Mr. Schue SHOULD be doing when you're weak at a certain thing. As you don't put in extra effort in practice, diet, etc, you can't expect to catch up to the rest of the group, and you sure as hell can't expect the coach to stop criticizing you.

Don't even get me started on arriving to practice 30 minutes late. In High School, we were forced to be at practice at least 20 minutes before it started. If you were 30 minutes late, you're getting some kind of punishment for sure. Either by your teammates, who cared about you and the team enough to be there on time. Or by the coach, whose JOB it is to instill good values in his students.

And then to later quit the team because of it???

Finally, to those who say "Mercedes is a good team member for singing backup majority of the time"... that's not being a good team member. That's simply the expectation. Not everyone is the MVP. Benchwarmers a lot of the time don't even get to play a game. If the goal of the Glee club was to "participate" in Sectionals, then I understand the frustration about not being utilized. But if the goal is to compete and win, you have to accept what coach says your role is, and if you want a bigger role, you earn it by working harder, not by complaining (and yes I know Rachel complained a lot, I'm not absolving her of anything with this).


r/glee • • Sep 21 '23

Opinion To you - how did Finn die?

1 Upvotes

They leave it open in the show, and for some people that's frustrating and other's that's due to respect for Cory. But in the absence of no official answer (at least last time I checked nothing 'official' had been stated) - what do you attribute to Finn's death in the show?

I'm sad to admit my own head canon would either be suicide or accidental OD - and not because of what happened to Cory but because Ryan Murphy was a sicko and had worked drugs into Finn's story line through his father.

Every rewatch I feel more of what is left unsaid in Finn's story, and that probably is due to Cory, but Finn's story line in the show (to me) does reflect someone on a downward spiral.

What's your own head canon?

edit: phrasing


r/glee • • Feb 28 '24

Character Disc. i lost all respect for santana when she auditioned for funny girl with don’t rain on my parade. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

regardless of your feelings about rachel, she has worked her entire life to be on broadway, and to play her favorite character and biggest inspiration is remarkable.

for santana to know all this and not only audition for the show, but sing don’t rain on my parade a.k.a. one of the most important songs in the world to rachel was the meanest thing i’ve ever seen someone do on television. she just completely undermined her life’s work and had no remorse.