r/glee • • Jan 14 '24

Why?!

I actually find myself provoked by the whole Santana in New York situation. It’s so unfair how the bully wins. Auditioning for the understudy without telling Rachel is bad enough. The worst part however is how Santana is the reason why Rachel moves out of the apartment Kurt and her had first. Santana just showing up out of nowhere moving in. It might be weird to think this is so bad haha, but I think it has to do with how I got bullied when I was a kid. Glee was about the outsiders, why did they let the bully win?

2 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

48

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '24

Rachel moving out was a decision she made by herself. She also didn't treat Santana the best by ripping up their graduation photo in front of her and then telling Elliot that Kurt and Santana kicked her out of the flat when that wasn't true. Yes, Santana plays a big role in all of this, but Rachel also was not the fairest person in this situation.

7

u/KimKardashianWho Jan 14 '24

Santana called Rachel terrible, short etc. She was mean and still a bully. So ofc Rachel didn’t want to live there anymore. I blame Santana 100%.

27

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '24

Rachel also made racist remarks towards Santana and slapped her. Santana was awful I will admit, but Rachel was also not a saint either

-8

u/lqoctn996nw Jan 14 '24

what racist remarks did rachel make?

13

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '24

"Fanny Brice is a New York Jew. You playing that role is like me being the grand marshal at the Puerto Rican Day parade."

26

u/cat_muppet Jan 14 '24

Says the one who played Maria

13

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '24

Exactly

4

u/m1b2c3 Jan 14 '24

I agree. The initial fight they both said some bad things, but Rachel tried to leave the situation that was escalating, Santana went into Rachel's private space and started berating her. I'm not one for hitting but after 3 years of insults and intimidation, Santana pushing herself into their home only to go through their things and being cruel again, Rachel had enough. Then, when Santana starts the first day of work by pushing her buttons again, Rachel moves out to get away for the situations for at least part of her day.

3

u/Aggravating-Gur-7575 Jan 15 '24

No, Santana absolutely knew what she was doing. I'd never audition for understudy of a friend who I knew would already hate the idea without still telling her first. Also. Rachel has never done anything on Glee ever to Santana. Santana was always awful to her. I'm on Rachel's side for this one

1

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '24

Rachel has never done anything on Glee ever to Santana.

You sure about that?

2

u/Aggravating-Gur-7575 Jan 19 '24

Yeah the worst thing she ever did was to Sunshine. Being ambitious and wanting solos doesn't make someone a worse person than stuff others did lol. Like look at Tina. She blamed Marley for an eating disorder. Santana was a bully to a lot of people for 3 seasons lol

41

u/Quirky_Arrival_6133 Jan 14 '24

The idea that Rachel “owned” roles was always icky to me because theatre is literally built around different people performing the same roles.

7

u/KimKardashianWho Jan 14 '24

Well, that doesn’t change the fact that Santana could have told Rachel about her plans.

2

u/FiftyOneMarks Jan 15 '24

Why? For the specific reason Santana said which is that Rachel would railroad her? Which, BY THE WAY, if we’re bringing up high school shenanigans Rachel had a tendency to do whenever anyone else remotely had a chance in the spotlight.

20

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/avadalovely Lord Tubbington's Army Jan 14 '24

Exactly my view about it. I still don’t understand why people warmed up to Rachel, because time and time again she’s shown that she hasn’t grown up. Santana grew more than Rachel has. I was bullied throughout my schooling experience, but I’ll still defend Santana for this.

15

u/Sims2Enjoy New Directions Jan 14 '24 edited Jan 14 '24

Thing is, Santana clearly did it to get under Rachel’s skin. She went for the understudy role after Rachel showed concern about Santana’s career and it annoyed her. Santana hadn’t shown interest in Broadway prior and even mocked Rachel’s interest on it on many occasions. Also from all productions going on in New York, Santana signed up for the one Rachel was working in

5

u/cwtches10 Jan 14 '24

This! Santana’s motivation was to knock Rachel down because she couldn’t stand to see her doing ‘better’ than her. There are literally thousands of opportunities in New York- she could have auditioned for anything else- Funny Girl was not the only gig in town. And if it must be Funny Girl if you were a friends you’d give her a heads up and not perform a knock off version of something she’s done before.

1

u/AdAdministrative4545 Jan 14 '24

In the theater world, relationships between the main cast and understudies can be volatile. For an understudy, that one person is all that's standing between you and your chance. You should hear the stories of food tampering and stuff that occasionally happens. It's cutthroat right from the audition slots. Individuals going into the field are warned that your friends are your friends, but one audition can change that. Sabotaging your competition is not unheard of, or unfortunately, all that rare.

So, Santana going for that role and doing Rachel's song - which you can't say she sang without intending to intimidate Rachel with it - was an aggressive move. With Santana's history bullying Rachel, it's not surprising that she reacts as negatively as she does. She and Santana have tentative friendship, at best, and it hasn't even been that for very long. Comparatively, Rachel has YEARS of Santana bullying and humiliating her for her own benefit and/or enjoyment. In that situation, I wouldn't trust Santana either, history dictates that she has no problem destroying Rachel if it suits her purpose.

If the friendship mattered to Santana, this would have been her time to prove it by supporting her friend instead of competing with her. She's already taken advantage of the fragile friendship they began after Rachel joined in to support Santana when she came out. Rachel has her faults and flaws, but she's never inflicted the type of emotional and psychological damage on Santana that Santana has prided herself on inflicting on Rachel. When she showed up in NY though, Rachel and Kurt still let her stay, took her in, and treated her fairly. It was a douche move for Santana to go for the part the way she did. And Kurt not understanding the intricacies of the situation was ridiculously out of character because he does know the realities of Broadway and, as someone who suffered from intense bullying as well, should recognize the fear and betrayal Santana's intimidation tactics would have inspired.

13

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/AdAdministrative4545 Jan 14 '24

I'm not basing my experience off of TV shows, I worked in the theaters when I was younger, performed on stages, and have friends who still perform is various capacities on both Broadway and with touring companies. You're right, it can be an awesome group that feels like family by the time the last curtain closes. But it can be a knife in your back and asshole people trying to get ahead by pushing you down. I did more music and less plays during my time performing, but I'll never forget one of my last shows, the band that had the smaller opening slot before us called us one night to let us know rehearsal times had been changed. Thankfully, our drummer was doing session tracks with another member of the crew and had the correct information cause the smaller group gave us the wrong times in hopes of making us late and getting our spots swapped. I was FLOORED, couldn't believe they were such douches, but you don't always know who you're working with and you can't just assume they're gonna be team players, just because you are. Especially in the low ranks when you're just starting out and everybody knows only one in a room of hundreds is gonna get their shot. And you absolutely spend months working along side people only to end up competing with them for roles a few months later. Until the roles are cast or the bands are booked, everybody you have to go up against is competition, you can't afford to be but so sentimental about the friendships when you're all fighting for the same dream and most of you aren't gonna get it. Some people can compete and keep it clean and some can't and until you're sure of what type of person the people next to you are, you can't let your guard down. It's stressful and exhausting. It makes you anxious, teaches you how ugly people can be, and how willing people are to step on you if they think it'll make a difference in their rise to the top. It's a shitty way to live, at least to me, so I bowed out gracefully and chased dreams that didn't come with so much doubt and insecurity. Shows and movies definitely play up the nasty side of things, but the shit they're exaggerating is based on the very real bullshit that takes behind the scenes.

14

u/cwtches10 Jan 14 '24

Glee’s general approach to bullies was quite strange all around. In the real world, someone like Rachel would probably never want to be around Santana again- but that doesn’t make a good tv show.

I generally liked the season 4 arc, it felt like Santana did grow without having a complete personality transplant and I think the Kurtcheltana dynamic they started was fun and could have been fun if it continued. Unfortunately, Santana’s actions over the understudy thing and her immediate return to using her favourite insults ruined any idea that they could be friends to me.

I also agree that Rachel shouldn’t have been the one to move out, and selfishly, as a Rachel fan, I wish we’d seen more backbone from Kurt on this one- he should have been able to emphasise with where Rachel was coming from.

14

u/JigglyKirby Jan 14 '24

Honestly both of them were right and wrong in their own way.

Rachel was right to feel mad, and even scared, of Santana for auditioning as an understudy. She was her bully all throughout HS, so she knows how Santana works. Santana wants to be famous, even if it’s the last thing she does (quote from that disco ep on s03). This was Rachel’s big break, and to possibly get outshined by your friend, who used to be your bully and is as talented as you are, is a nightmare to think about. On the other hand, she definitely was wrong on how she went about her frustrations like slapping her, saying they’re no longer friends because of that, and even the whole thing of not needing an understudy (she needed one, they always need one lmao).

Santana was right for auditioning for the role. I dont blame her at all for that. She saw an opportunity and she took it, thats how it is in that line of business. She definitely didnt need to tell Rachel she was auditioning, but as her friend i feel like she should have told her. This was Rachel’s big break. As her friend and roommate, she knows Rachel has been wanting this role, specifically for Fanny Brice, ever since she was young. I think if they talked it out beforehand and came into an agreement, Rachel wouldn’t have reacted that way. But her springing it up on Rachel without a warning brought up Rachel’s worst fears, so that was definitely on Santana lmao

4

u/Hot-Lifeguard-3176 New Directions Jan 15 '24

I’ve always wondered if Santana actually thought she would get the understudy role. Not because she lacks talent-she clearly is extremely talented-but because she didn’t fit the typical ‘look’. I do think she mostly auditioned to get on Rachel’s nerves, but like Kurt said, her having it on her resume would always look good.

6

u/Sims2Enjoy New Directions Jan 14 '24

Both acted incredibly childish, Santana clearly signed up to get under Rachel’s skin. Like it was right after Rachel showed concern for Santana’s career and it upset Santana, also the fact Santana had no interest on Broadway prior(And even mocked Rachel’s interest) plus from all productions going on in New York Santana went on to be Rachel’s understudy. And Rachel allowed Santana to get under her skin by acting rather gatekeep-y about the situation, like if Rachel had pretended not to care is likely Santana would’ve moved on into something else

8

u/Beautiful-View-5256 Jan 14 '24

You don’t think Rachel is a bully?

-2

u/Last_Lifeguard3536 gothic!tina Jan 14 '24

when did she ever bully santana

2

u/Beautiful-View-5256 Jan 14 '24

She bullied everyone. Constantly. All the time

2

u/Last_Lifeguard3536 gothic!tina Jan 14 '24

please give me a specific example of rachel bullying santana without santana initiating anything first before the funny girl drama

1

u/FiftyOneMarks Jan 15 '24

They asked if OP thought Rachel was a bully not if Rachel bullied Santana…

2

u/Last_Lifeguard3536 gothic!tina Jan 15 '24

but they said that rachel bullied everyone

0

u/FiftyOneMarks Jan 15 '24

Read the first comment you replied to not the one you made an assumption on.

2

u/Last_Lifeguard3536 gothic!tina Jan 15 '24

i did read it

the point of the thread is the funny girl drama between santana and rachel

rachel bullying others has nothing to do with the drama. if she had bullied santana, then it would. but she didn’t

1

u/m1b2c3 Jan 15 '24

Rachel didn't bully others and certainly didn't bully Santana.

Some people around here have a very loose definition of being a bully. Rachel unlike Santana did not " habitually seeks to harm or intimidate those whom they perceive as vulnerable."

If Rachel is considered to be a bully than we have to consider Mercedes, Artie, Tina and Kurt bullies as well.

4

u/Last_Lifeguard3536 gothic!tina Jan 15 '24

oh yeah i completely agree.

was rachel mean at times? yes. but not once did she bully anyone. she was very ambitious and wanted roles/solos for herself but she hardly insulted anyone (especially without them initiating it first) or constantly attacked them, unliked santana

3

u/Last_Lifeguard3536 gothic!tina Jan 15 '24

ngl you kind of ate me up with this comment lol

2

u/Humble-Kitchen Feb 03 '24

I still maintain that while Santana has done things maliciously in the past this was not one of them. She auditioned to be an understudy after having Kurt and Rachel encourage to do something to showcasing her talents at a time she was feeling insecure about it and finding her place in NY. She probably thought why not and when she got it yes that'll look amazing on my resume. After Rachel basically tells her she not talent enough for the role, etc that's when it took a turn. The were friends at the time but Rachel is still Rachel she would've had the same reaction whether Santana told her or not but as a friend why wouldn't you be happy for your friend being your understudy especially over some random?

4

u/pinkwonderwall Jan 14 '24

Rachel was also a bully, so it’s bully on bully violence as far as I’m concerned.

4

u/camrenisreal23 Jan 14 '24

Santana was definitely wrong. She was so afraid of Rachel one upping her that she went and purposely auditioned for that role to bring Rachel down. Only after Rachel mentioned Santana's jobs. Santana was so scared of Rachel out doing her and Santana might've only peaked in High School. She went to make sure Rachel knew her place. Rachel reacted badly at points but everyone in the glee club knew how much Rachel worked for Broadway and to have someone who mocked you about it take a understudy role, is wild to me.

3

u/cwtches10 Jan 14 '24

And, this comes after Rachel includes Santana in her photoshoot.

It’s literally foreshadowed- when Santana gets the advert she tells Rachel that she hopes she can be as supportive and cool when she gets something, and we know she can’t.

1

u/jacqrosee santana lopez’s bitch Jan 14 '24

this is such a divisive issue and while rachel acted very childish and poorly in this scenario, i have to side with her on this one. life-long dreams are not to be fucked with, period.

0

u/m1b2c3 Jan 14 '24 edited Jan 15 '24

People act like Rachel had much choice but to leave at that time. She had no safe place at home or at work.

ETA; Down voted yet again. She either stayed where she knew it would be awful, or leave. Santana probably wouldn't have left on her own, so for her own mental health she left.

2

u/Last_Lifeguard3536 gothic!tina Jan 15 '24

hey, don’t worry about the downvotes. unfortunately some people are never going to change their minds even if they’re wrong.

0

u/m1b2c3 Jan 15 '24 edited Jan 15 '24

I get down voted for everything and anything, so no worries but thanks.

ETA: Thanks down voters for proving my point.

-2

u/Santana_delRey Jan 14 '24

If it makes you feel any better, her only big break was in a vaginal fungus commercial

0

u/Alice_Anesthesia Jan 16 '24

One of my favorite lines came from this rommate situation after she searched through everything in the apartment. "you went through all of our stuff??" "yeah, that's thing i do." 😭