r/github • • Jun 14 '20

GitHub to replace "master" with alternative term to avoid slavery references

https://www.zdnet.com/article/github-to-replace-master-with-alternative-term-to-avoid-slavery-references/
196 Upvotes

296 comments sorted by

View all comments

-1

u/Tom_Ov_Bedlam Jun 14 '20 edited Jun 14 '20

I was just thinking about this the other day. Why not call it "main" or "trunk' or literally anything else?

21

u/brennanfee Jun 14 '20

Because the usage "master" had nothing to do with a slavery reference. When you say "master bedroom" you are not referring to it as opposed to a "slavery bedroom" you are instead using a usage of the word that is devoid of anything to do with race.

As example, not every time the world "black" is used it is referring to skin color.

1

u/Tom_Ov_Bedlam Jun 16 '20

Conclusive evidence that the advent of the master branch was explicitly referring to the master-slave relationship.

https://twitter.com/ben_a_adams/status/1271471019971293184

0

u/brennanfee Jun 16 '20

Was it referring to humans? No.

1

u/Tom_Ov_Bedlam Jun 16 '20

Be careful not to hurt yourself doing such severe mental gymnastics.

0

u/brennanfee Jun 16 '20

I'm truly sorry the dictionary is too difficult for you. To make a calm that race was involved in the selection of a word simply because the word can be used in a racial context is the real gymnastics going on here. Master\slave is no different from usages of parent\child when talking about trees or graphs and any resemblance you think they have to the human contexts is baseless.

1

u/Tom_Ov_Bedlam Jun 16 '20

You are wrong, and it's clear that now that you understand that you want to push the goal posts for the sake of maintaining the idea that you're correct.

→ More replies (26)

1

u/brandonlive Jun 17 '20

No one is saying that race was involved in the selection of the word. That’s a straw man argument. Nor is anyone saying that all uses of “master” are problematic. But in this case, some evidence suggests that it does come from a master/slave origin (which is surprising to most of us, but that doesn’t mean we just dismiss it).

The only thing that matters is if it causes harm to some members of our communities. If it does, there’s no good reason to keep it.

The word “slave” itself isn’t tied to a particular race or necessarily “racist”, but it is explicitly tied with abuse. It’s a poor choice to describe anything in tech, and an easily avoidable one.

1

u/brennanfee Jun 17 '20

But in this case, some evidence suggests that it does come from a master/slave origin

Yes, but master/slave origin did not originate with human slavery and does not always refer to human slavery. Again, there are multiple usages and the intent is what matters.

The only thing that matters is if it causes harm to some members of our communities.

No. That is not the only thing that matters. And besides, words are only as harmful as the intent behind them. There are far more important issues to be dealt with than misplacing (yes misplacing) anger onto an area that is not part of the problem and where the negative intent never applied. Instead, we should be focusing on calling for reforms in policing. Calling for reforms in campaign finance so our politicians are beholden to their constituents and not their donors. Calling for election reforms so the people pick by vote their representatives not the representatives picking their voters. Those things would go FAR FURTHER in advancing our cause of improving race relations rather than a bunch of people who think they are "woke" focusing on issues that in no way advance the real cause of race relations.

You don't have to take my word for it. You could actually listen to the black community who could give two shits about words but would much rather we stop the police from murdering our fellow citizens.

The word “slave” itself isn’t tied to a particular race or necessarily “racist”, but it is explicitly tied with abuse.

Actually, that's the problem here. That is incorrect. That is merely one usage of that word. There are other usages, some that predated attachment to humans (a.k.a. personification).

It’s a poor choice to describe anything in tech,

Again, incorrect. But this is more of a matter of opinion, so I digress.

1

u/brandonlive Jun 18 '20

Yes, but master/slave origin did not originate with human slavery and does not always refer to human slavery. Again, there are multiple usages and the intent is what matters.

First, this is flat-out false. But your real mistake is thinking that the origin or alternate usages matter. They empathically do not.

And besides, words are only as harmful as the intent behind them.

This is not and never has been true. It’s an utterly absurd statement and I honestly have to wonder if you’re actually a sociopath based on these responses.

There are far more important issues to be dealt with than misplacing (yes misplacing) anger onto an area that is not part of the problem and where the negative intent never applied.

Perhaps you should take your own advice, as you seem to be the angry one in this conversation.

Actually, that's the problem here. That is incorrect. That is merely one usage of that word. There are other usages, some that predated attachment to humans (a.k.a. personification).

It seems like you’re just gaslighting now. The word slave literally comes from Slav, as in Slavic origin - because Slavs were often forced into slavery in the Middle Ages. Every dictionary definition for the word is explicitly tied to abuse, except for the modern engineering usage that our industry agreed a long time ago is problematic and should be retired.

It is a poor choice to describe anything in tech. In most cases, primary and secondary are superior alternatives both in terms of unintended harm and actual descriptiveness.

1

u/brennanfee Jun 18 '20

First, this is flat-out false.

No. It's not. The origin was a verb akin to "to drudge" or "labor". It was not personified until quite a bit later.

But your real mistake is thinking that the origin or alternate usages matter.

Yes... my entire point is that the alternate usages matter. How a word or phrase is used is dependent on the context. That is WHY words have multiple usages. To be literally used in different situations.

They empathically do not.

So... when you say emphatically... I'm unclear now... do you mean:

  1. uttered, or to be uttered, with emphasis; strongly expressive.

  2. using emphasis in speech or action.

  3. forceful; insistent:

  4. very impressive or significant; strongly marked; striking:

  5. clearly or boldly outlined:

I mean... if multiple usages don't matter than I really don't know what you are trying to say. Oh, and if you were intending "forceful; insistent" than I am offended that you are rejecting my position outright. That's just rude. I mean, I should just be able to say something without support or evidence and just have you accept it right? By not doing so you are in essence calling me a liar and... frankly, I'm offended. You should be ashamed of yourself for offending me without proper empathy to my point of view.

In conclusion: Offense is subjective. Anything can be taken out of context. The usage and intent matter.

This is not and never has been true.

Clearly not familiar with something most six-year-olds understand: Sticks and stones may break my bones but words can never hurt me.

A cop held his knee to a man's throat for 8 minutes and 46 seconds. And THIS is what you get your panties in a twist about (oh, I should be careful because out of context that phrase could be very offensive). Did I mean literal panties? Was I denigrating women? Was I denigrating your masculinity (if you are a man)? Was I speaking ill of an inanimate article of clothing? Or merely using a common idiom that means "to get upset about"? I better watch out for the "literal" police and PC cops. Lord knows I shouldn't get the benefit of the doubt now should I?

How about we solve the murder of a person and prevent others rather than haggle on word choice (especially when it is completely innocuous and unimportant wording at that).

It’s an utterly absurd statement and I honestly have to wonder if you’re actually a sociopath based on these responses.

Well, given your propensity for assuming the negative in the "other" I doubt you would spend much time either trying to verify or understand my intent here. That very empathy you speak of should urge you to verify what the other person is saying rather than assuming negatively on their personality or intent. "Otherness", the death knell to your inclusivity can be created on more divisions than simply skin color. Assuming the other persons' goal was to harm you or slight you is to inject an "us" versus "them" mentality into the conversation that otherwise might not be there. That is not a way to come to understanding, but a way to divide it.

Perhaps you should take your own advice, as you seem to be the angry one in this conversation.

I'm angry that a man was MURDERED (many actually) by the very people we hire to protect us... and instead of talking about that people like you are injecting ill intent into areas that have absolutely no bearing on the social issue of the day. It is laughable that you and others actually think this is either important or would accomplish anything worthwhile.

The word slave literally comes from Slav, as in Slavic origin - because Slavs were often forced into slavery in the Middle Ages.

And there you go. You are INCORRECT. The word is MUCH older than that. Middle English in fact (sclave). A few hundred years before it was personified onto the Slavic peoples. And even then it was converted from a verb (as in something you do - to drudge) to a noun. But hey, why let facts get in the way.

And besides... the usage in computer systems is non-personified. So it is irrelevant.

except for the modern engineering usage

Wow. So, you agree there is a usage that does not carry the negative connotation and yet continue to argue that the negative forms were intended in the specific usage in question? Wow. That takes some gall (especially without evidence).

that our industry agreed a long time ago is problematic and should be retired.

Um... when? When did that happen. I must have missed the memo.

It is a poor choice to describe anything in tech.

And that is your OPINION. You are INFERRING a context into being. And you are free, in a free society, to do that. But you are not free to blame a person without scrutiny unless their intent can be demonstrated to be negative. Your intent is the one that comes into question.

The problem here is that the more the extreme left does these sorts of (fascist) things... the less we will have a free society. So, in the end you will lose what you are arguing for anyway. You won't be free to speak or to take offense and the goal of more inclusivity will be a far off memory.

Instead, I work toward actual inclusivity within our society. I push for all adults to be able to marry whoever they want. I push for all adults to be able to use the bathroom that fits the gender they identify with most. I want Priests and Pastors to stop raping our children or face jail time rather than protection from the churches. I want police to protect us once again rather than murder us. I want people of all faiths to be able to worship in accordance with their beliefs but not use those beliefs as a mechanism to discriminate against others. I want no one, ever, to be fired from a job because of who they pray to (including nothing at all), what the color of their skin is, what the gender or gender identity is, what their sexual orientation is. I push for all citizens being able to vote, no questions. I push for legal changes that provide the legal protections we all need in order to provide a more equal society. My guess is you want these things too.

But most importantly... I vote. THAT is making a difference. I often wonder when these red herring "issues" come up how many people "pushing" for them in social media actually vote. My guess is that if even 1/3 of them actually got off their asses and voted we would not see people like Trump winning let alone even running. Perhaps when society is actually more equal, we won't need to walk on eggshells with what words we use as though that is the problem. Scoring "woke" points in social media is without merit, without honor, and entirely pointless.

→ More replies (0)

-21

u/Tom_Ov_Bedlam Jun 14 '20

Master is an obvious indication of a domineering human relationship and very reasonably invokes images of slavery.

It's disingenuous of you to try and write it off as trivial.

20

u/brennanfee Jun 14 '20

Master is an obvious indication of a domineering human relationship and very reasonably invokes images of slavery.

No, not in all usages. That's the point. The world "black" doesn't always refer to skin color. Words have different usages and often their usages are in no way related.

You can see all the varying usages here: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/master

Most of those have nothing to do with slavery or even with a notion of one human being "over" another. Only a few usages lead toward that direction people are suggesting. While the slavery thing is ONE USAGE of that word, it is patently absurd to suggest that we stop using the word in all of those other contexts.

What would need to happen here is that it would need to be demonstrated that the original individual who chose "master" for use in source control systems had the "master\slavery" context in mind... as in that was WHY they chose that word. I happen to know in this context that no, that was not the context of the selection of that word. Just like using "black" in some instances has no connection with skin color.

It's disingenuous of you to try and write it off as trivial.

No. It's disingenuous to insinuate a connection to that usage WITHOUT EVIDENCE.

1

u/Tom_Ov_Bedlam Jun 16 '20 edited Jun 16 '20

Conclusive evidence that the advent of the master branch was explicitly referring to the master-slave relationship.

https://twitter.com/ben_a_adams/status/1271471019971293184

0

u/brennanfee Jun 16 '20

Was it referring to humans? No.

1

u/Tom_Ov_Bedlam Jun 16 '20

You know what, you are such a fucking jackass.

In your obtuse, bloviated comment you explicitly stated that the master branch has nothing to do with the master/slave relationship and you demand evidence showing otherwise.

I provide it, and all you have to say is that masters and slaves have nothing to do with humans?

fuck you for trying to pretend that you have any kind of earnest interest or investment in this issue or resolving these problems.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

[deleted]

0

u/Tom_Ov_Bedlam Jun 15 '20

That's incredibly petty and not what I'm saying at all.

1

u/ShotgunJed Jun 16 '20

So Master's degree isn't racist but Master bedroom is?

1

u/Tom_Ov_Bedlam Jun 16 '20

Why are you putting words in my mouth?

0

u/ShotgunJed Jun 16 '20

Well then can you describe exactly which words that contain "master" in it are racist and which ones aren't? A couple of good examples would be great. Vagueness isn't entirely useful here in this situation if we are to truly solve this social issue.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '20

There are actually many devs who prefer the word 'master'. 'trunk' is from SVN terminology, and it confused a lot of devs, since branches don't merge back to trunk, in a literal sense.

Having the word 'master' used makes sense, as its the final, true copy of the code

1

u/brandonlive Jun 17 '20

That isn’t a very accurate description of how “master” is typically used in Git.

The guy who says he originally chose that term says he wishes he had chosen “main”.

1

u/assassinator42 Jun 18 '20

He also seems to think the connotation to slavery in the US is much stronger than it actually is.

1

u/brandonlive Jun 18 '20

What do you mean by that?

→ More replies (1)