r/github • • Jun 14 '20

GitHub to replace "master" with alternative term to avoid slavery references

https://www.zdnet.com/article/github-to-replace-master-with-alternative-term-to-avoid-slavery-references/
196 Upvotes

296 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

20

u/brennanfee Jun 14 '20

Master is an obvious indication of a domineering human relationship and very reasonably invokes images of slavery.

No, not in all usages. That's the point. The world "black" doesn't always refer to skin color. Words have different usages and often their usages are in no way related.

You can see all the varying usages here: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/master

Most of those have nothing to do with slavery or even with a notion of one human being "over" another. Only a few usages lead toward that direction people are suggesting. While the slavery thing is ONE USAGE of that word, it is patently absurd to suggest that we stop using the word in all of those other contexts.

What would need to happen here is that it would need to be demonstrated that the original individual who chose "master" for use in source control systems had the "master\slavery" context in mind... as in that was WHY they chose that word. I happen to know in this context that no, that was not the context of the selection of that word. Just like using "black" in some instances has no connection with skin color.

It's disingenuous of you to try and write it off as trivial.

No. It's disingenuous to insinuate a connection to that usage WITHOUT EVIDENCE.

1

u/Tom_Ov_Bedlam Jun 16 '20 edited Jun 16 '20

Conclusive evidence that the advent of the master branch was explicitly referring to the master-slave relationship.

https://twitter.com/ben_a_adams/status/1271471019971293184

0

u/brennanfee Jun 16 '20

Was it referring to humans? No.

1

u/Tom_Ov_Bedlam Jun 16 '20

You know what, you are such a fucking jackass.

In your obtuse, bloviated comment you explicitly stated that the master branch has nothing to do with the master/slave relationship and you demand evidence showing otherwise.

I provide it, and all you have to say is that masters and slaves have nothing to do with humans?

fuck you for trying to pretend that you have any kind of earnest interest or investment in this issue or resolving these problems.

0

u/brennanfee Jun 16 '20

In your obtuse, bloviated comment you explicitly stated that the master branch has nothing to do with the master/slave relationship and you demand evidence showing otherwise.

Because it doesn't. It has nothing to do with the human institution of slavery. Again, the words have different USAGES.

I provide it,

No, you did not "prove it". Nothing about the text shown indicates it has anything to do with humans or the human institution of slavery. It is merely a contextual relationship akin to parent\child or primary\secondary. It is categorical and that's it. Nothing about it indicates slavery or race or humanity AT ALL.

-8

u/RockJake28 Jun 14 '20

The etymology of the word shows the original meaning of the word was " a man having control or authority". Any other meanings derive from derivations upon derivations of this word. (N.B. I'm not advocating either way).

9

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

You're not advocating either way, but you happen to advocate one way twice on this post. Sure, buddy.

-6

u/RockJake28 Jun 14 '20

Ugh. Right, discussing the origins & meanings of words is not the same as advocating whether we should replace the use of "master" because of its alleged connotations to slavery.

Now, that being said, if a substantially large number of people are saying that this term is inappropriate, despite you arguing that it isn't, then maybe it's worth considering the possibility that you're not capable of understanding why it's upsetting. There's nothing wrong with that, nobody expects you to have perfect empathy in every potential situation.

Ultimately, you've got to weigh up whether your right to use "master" in this context is worth making a significant number of people uncomfortable. (Whether you think they should be uncomfortable is irrelevant, the fact of the matter is that they are.) If it is worth it, fine, continue making the argument, but the rest of us are just going to wonder why it matters so much to you.

7

u/Reincarnate26 Jun 14 '20 edited Jun 14 '20

if a substantially large number of people are saying that this term is inappropriate

But that's the whole point, a large number of people don't think the term is inappropriate. Virtually everyone in and outside of the industry agrees this is absurd.

Its like telling physicists they have to come up with a new word for "black hole", because "black" can also refer to a persons race. Its obviously not going to make a difference in the fight against racism, it starts a dangerous precedent of holding objective language used in engineering and science hostage to fleeting cultural politics, and in the end its clearly just misguided corporate PR.

To that point, I work with a very diverse team of software engineers from all over the world, and no one bats any eye when using the word "master branch", "master node", "white list" etc. There's simply no racial component behind it, because we're all mature professional adults that understand those words have multiple useful objective definitions. To be fixated on looking for a racial component to every word imaginable isn't virtuous so much as its pathological.

-4

u/RockJake28 Jun 14 '20

I'm bordering on devil's advocate here, but here we go nonetheless...

its obviously not going to make a difference

I get why you say that, but it's not entirely true. There's a strong, subconscious connection between the language we use and the way we think. In this particular case, I don't think it would be entirely unfair to make the argument that the casual use of a word that has major, and relatively recent, connections to generations of pain and suffering doesn't set the best "sub-conscious example", so to speak. (This is obviously a gross oversimplification of things people far more knowledgeable have said) However,

its just...corporate PR

That's a bingo!

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

if a substantially large number of people are saying that this term is inappropriate, despite you arguing that it isn't,

I never said that. All you had to do was ask what I think, instead of assuming. That being said, I simply don't care if someone thinks it's inappropriate.

11

u/brennanfee Jun 14 '20 edited Jun 14 '20

The etymology of the word shows the original meaning of the word was " a man having control or authority".

No it doesn't. The word originated from a derivation of meaning to be "in control" or to have achieved "high proficiency". The specific context of WHAT you were in control of or what you have "mastered" was left entirely out and for as long as up until the 12th century only referred to non-personified subjects or tasks. From the Latin magister akin to magnus, meaning "large". In essence, the verb form of magnus, to "achieve large" or to "achieve the top".

EDIT: I never thought actually learning Latin would come in handy. But just goes to show, you can never tell these things. I don't regret what felt like wasted time at the time.

EDIT2: Furthermore, the etymology isn't terribly important. The important part is the word has multiple usages and those levying that the "bad" usage is being used in the given context (of Git) would need to DEMONSTRATE that rather than assert it into being. Always remember: That which can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.

1

u/elnabo_ Jun 15 '20

To complete your point on how etymology can be useless.

Smoking is now used as french word but has no relation anymore with the original word.

First in french, smoking is no longer a verb and it refers to a tuxedo for some reason