r/geothermal • • Feb 21 '23

**Geothermal Heat Pump Quote and Informational Survey** A Community Resource where ground-source heat pump owners can share quotes, sizing, and experiences with the installation and performance of their units. Please fill out if you're a current or past geothermal heat pump owner!

35 Upvotes

Link to the survey: https://forms.gle/iuSqbnMks7QGt5wg9

Link to the responses: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1M7f2V_P_LibwzrkyorHcXR-sgRZZegPeWAZavaPc5dU/edit?usp=sharing

Hi all!

Let's be honest. HVACing can be stressful as a homeowner, and this can be especially true when getting geothermal installation quotes, where the limited number of installers can make it difficult to get multiple opinions and prices.

Inspired by r/heatpumps, I have created a short, public, anonymous survey where current geothermal heat pump owners can enter in information about quotes, installations, and general performance of their units. All of this data is sent directly to a spreadsheet, where both potential shoppers and current geothermal owners are then able to see and compare quotes, sizing, and satisfaction of their installations across various geographical regions!

Now here's the catch: This spreadsheet only works if the data exists. It's up to current owners, satisfied or otherwise, to fill out the survey and help inform the community about their experience. The r/heatpumps spreadsheet is a plethora of information, where quotes can be broken down in time and space thanks to the substantially larger install base. With the smaller number of geothermal installs, getting a sample size that's actually helpful for others is going to require a lot of participation. So please, if you have a couple minutes, fill out what you can in the geothermal heat pump survey, send it to other geothermal owners you know that may also be interested in helping out, and let's create something cool and useful!


r/geothermal • • 1h ago

Choosing Geo installers in Baltimore County Maryland? Who are the top dogs I should call for an estimate?

2 Upvotes

Hey all, closing on a home this week (fingers crossed) in Baltimore County. The home currently has 20+ year old Oil Heat, Conventional AC and Electric Water Heater installed in 2023. The only utilities available in my area for the foreseeable future is: Electric, Delivered Oil and Propane. Home details: 2.5 acre wooded lot, 3100sqf livable space needs to be conditioned. Home built in '74, decent amount of insulation in the attic (2 layers), 5 yo roof, and decent wood/ aluminum Anderson windows.

I received a quote from Ground Loop for a 4 ton WF Series 5 and single well for $49K not including $6300 BGE, $5000 in 2 years County Prop tax credit and then applying for GRECS; Ground loop estimated total cost of system after 10 years would be close to $14K.

I also had Constellation come out to estimate the highest efficiency Cold Weather ASHP: Carrier GreenSpeed Variable 4 ton SEER2 23 for $25K installed after all the rebates and discounts.

Who else is worth calling in my area to get a Geo quote?

All my research on Reddit and elsewhere point to Geo is the way to go. Not having previous utility bills for this house or my neighborhood I have nothing to compare what the 2 mentioned systems would cost a month from BGE providing Electric. I can only assume my oil bill alone would be $1500 minimum, who knows how high electric will be in the summer.

Any and all help is welcome. TIA


r/geothermal • • 3d ago

The Drilling Engineer Who Bet Everything on Geothermal and Built Fervo

Thumbnail
insurancedimes.com
19 Upvotes

r/geothermal • • 4d ago

Switching Geothermal Off at Breaker Over Winter

3 Upvotes

Background and use: I purchased a house that has a older geothermal unit. The unit is supposed to be preheating water and providing AC in the summer and heat in the winter. Basically it costs a fortune to use in the winter the air from the system is approx 55 degrees which works great providing low cost AC in the summer but it uses way too much electricity during the winter to heat. It basically uses electric heat 24/7 and runs up the electric bill to about $500 a month. I had a pellet stove installed which works wonders, much cheaper, and provides plenty of heat during the winter for the house.

Why I want to turn it off: The geothermal unit never really turns off. It has a mandatory setting of air circulation which pulls from an unheated area of the house and blows it around heated areas. There is no way to close off the unheated zone of the house. It blows cool air on my face at night. The air also smells bad this year I suspect mice got in there and died. I need to have the ducts cleaned out but don't have the money to do so right now.

Concern: I would like to have the unit replaced with a newer version when I have the money to do so. I am worried about the underground field (installed 2015) and whatever is circulating in them constantly. Would turning off the system at the breaker (the only way to actually fully turn off the system) corrode or cause damage to those pipes? Would there be any other harmful effects to the system by fully powering it down during the winter? G


r/geothermal • • 4d ago

410A or 454B refrigerant? Need opinions!

2 Upvotes

We are installing a geothermal unit in our new build. Our contractor offered us the choice on refrigerant. Let me first say, I know very little in this area- generally my husband’s territory. Online research seems to point to 454B as 410A is being phased down and likely get much more expensive. I read it’s flammable. Is that a concern? Any other information or considerations you could offer?


r/geothermal • • 6d ago

Fervo now has $12B in orders for its geothermal power tech

Thumbnail
techcrunch.com
14 Upvotes

r/geothermal • • 6d ago

upgrade from WF E-Series to 5-series

1 Upvotes

It is almost a perfect swap/upgrade from my 2005 system to a new 5-series. Anybody done this in 2026, and what did you pay to remove the old a replace with the new? did you install the desuperheater also? any other accessories?

thanks


r/geothermal • • 6d ago

Open Loop Discharge

2 Upvotes

Previous homeowner had the geothermal installed as an open loop with the discharge directly to the ground surface. Basically, a 1” PVC tube that just runs water out a small hill (less than 10% grade) in our back yard. He kept the water flow turned down really low. When we had the unit serviced, the tech increased the flow (3.5ton unit flow is around 7-10pm). The water turns an area about 20-feet wide by 80-feet long into a muddy mess.

I am installing a drywall to manage the water. We live in an area where the frost line is 3-feet. However, the discharge line is maybe 1-foot deep at best (and the last 6-10 feet are less than 6-inches). It has been this way for 30 years!

The drywell itself is approx 4-feet tall x 2-feet wide x 4-feet long. I was thinking a 5-foot x 5-foot pit with 2-foot gravel base and 1-foot of soil on top.

At 3-feet our soil becomes sandy and handle the water. And, I’ll have a small manhole and pop-off just in case.

Any thoughts or concerns?


r/geothermal • • 7d ago

Geothermal Utilities Power Wave of US Affordable Housing with 40% Energy Savings

Thumbnail
goodnewsnetwork.org
16 Upvotes

r/geothermal • • 8d ago

WaterFurnace Synergy3D Wiring Help

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I am installing a used Synergy3D unit. It was previously used as a closed loop system, but my house has an open loop. I am having the darndest time figuring out where to wire in the 24v call signal to my well pump relay, and the 24v call to my solenoid water valve to open.

My understanding is that I can wire them in parallel with either the Acc Com + Acc No (which already runs to a solenoid valve for my refrigerant), or Y1 as both are live when the compressor is running. A third option is the tap the Compressor Contactor Coil for 24V. This information has been deduced, and not proven anywhere in the manual that I can find. I can find no dedicated spots for the wiring.

My questions is either 1.) Where is the proper place to wire both 24v call signals, or 2.) Are there any concerns with having all of these small systems in parallel? Maybe have the well call on Acc Com + Acc No, and the valve on Y1 + Ground or vice versa.

Attached are photos of the wiring diagram, a picture of the board, a picture of the unit in my backyard en route to the basement, and the unit piper and wired for testing.

Edit: Photos are blurry. Please reach out for clear photos.


r/geothermal • • 11d ago

Boise District Geothermal Heat

Post image
44 Upvotes

CanaryMedia: "Boise plans to tap its geothermal network to heat 300 affordable homes," by Alison F. Takemura. 

Boise, Idaho operates the country’s largest geothermal heating system, which pipes naturally warmed, 177ºF water from underground to about 100 buildings—including the Idaho State Capitol. "Last week, semiconductor multinational Micron Technology [headquartered in the city] gave Boise $2.5million to build on that expertise." 

"The cash fills a funding gap to extend the geothermal system to a planned affordable housing development with more than 300 units." In total, the project price tag is about $140 million, according to the city. 

“Boise has been Micron’s headquarters for 48 years, and investing in this community means investing in the people who call it home,” said April Arnzen, executive vice president + chief people officer at Micron + president of its philanthropic arm, the Micron Foundation. 

"February, the Bloomberg Philanthropies Mayors Challenge awarded Boise $ 1million to upgrade its geothermal system for affordable housing, as well as to explore a new use for the network: Some early-stage technologies exist that could potentially harness the hot water from Boise’s system to provide cooling, according to Maria Ortega, the city’s communications senior manager." 

"The clean-heat expansion will help Boise get closer to its goal of becoming carbon-neutral by 2050." Already, the city’s geothermal network cuts thousands of tons of carbon emissions every year, the equivalent of taking more than 2,000 gas-powered cars off the road. 

I should also add that we also need to keep expanding the EV charging network + encourage as many of those drivers as possible into electric vehicles as swiftly as feasible. Get 'er done.


r/geothermal • • 11d ago

Who makes the best Geothermal unit in US right now?

13 Upvotes

Bought the house in 1998, with a 1 year old WaterFurnace system. Three 150’ grouted wells, plastic pipe.

So it’s 30 years old, and has been very trouble free…a circulation motor, had a slight leak at one of the connecting hoses, and had the water loop flushed and new methanol installed over the 30 years. Thins thing has been awesome. Last week it quit, had a tech over and it was just a bad temp sensor on one of the refrigerant lines.

So…it’s 30, which is great, but I feel it’s on borrowed time, and I should replace it, before it fails in the dead of winter in an emergency.

Thinking about either buying a unit and letting it sit until it fails(prices keep rising, inflation hedge) or having it replaced when the contractor is slow and will do it at a discount.

Thoughts?


r/geothermal • • 12d ago

Geothermal is heating up. Can the grid keep up?

Thumbnail politico.com
4 Upvotes

r/geothermal • • 12d ago

Waterfurnace envision fan continuously running

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/geothermal • • 13d ago

Chicagoland Area?

2 Upvotes

Bought a home with geothermal. Based on a search of the sub, it seems people haven’t historically had much luck with contractors in the Chicago area.

Curious if anyone has had recent luck with identifying service providers?

Not looking for install, just maintenance, repair, replace, etc. We’d are hoping for options instead of the service provider that the previous owners of the home used on a regular basis.


r/geothermal • • 12d ago

refrigerant reversal valve or ruptured pressure tank?

1 Upvotes

A few days ago, our ClimateMaster Tranquility 27 stopped producing heat. The fan worked, but it blew only room-temperature air. We flipped the circuit breaker, but the geothermal wouldn't turn back on. The thermostat also went blank and wouldn't turn on.

A technician was able to get to turn the geothermal back on and set it to emergency heat. He's convinced that the problem is a stuck refrigerant reversal valve and TXV.

However, my wife noticed that our water pressure tank was whistling and rattling like an idling truck. Could we have a ruptured pressure tank that is causing the geothermal to do a lockout shutdown?


r/geothermal • • 13d ago

Expectations

1 Upvotes

Needing to replace a dying 4 ton Geo system. We are in Illinois and the quotes are all over the place ( I inquired estimates from 5 companies- none use the same system so cannot compare apples to apples unfortunately). For a middle of the road (not the budget basic and not Bentley white glove install) 4 ton single zone Geo electric heat pump, what is the average cost for heat pump only install? Loops are still good.


r/geothermal • • 13d ago

Vaillant heat pump with Solaredge inverter

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/geothermal • • 14d ago

New House. - What to look for

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Have an offer accepted for a new home. Has geothermal heating and cooling. These are the systems. We are getting an inspection, but anything to look for based on these units?


r/geothermal • • 16d ago

HVAC Geothermal System Service in Maine?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/geothermal • • 16d ago

Geothermal thermostat

Post image
1 Upvotes

The fan works but the ac and the heat wont turn on. No one can come out and we are having cooler weather so would like to hopefully be able to get this to work. My mom has a geothermal unit. And this is the Honeywell Home X2P Programmable Thermostat (RTH20B) digital thermostat.


r/geothermal • • 17d ago

Geothermal waterfunace replacement, Quebec

3 Upvotes

We need to replace an 19yo waterfunace series 3 and just got a quote for $29,000 (pre-tax). Our original system cost $17000 including drilling. Does this make any sense? Gotta say, this quote was a lot higher than expected! We are getting another quote to compare


r/geothermal • • 20d ago

Water cooled heat pump

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/geothermal • • 22d ago

28 Year old Ground loop Geothermal Condo Unit

2 Upvotes

I bought a condo with an geothermal HVAC. This is a second home for us in an area where my kids and grandkids live in Central PA (Harrisburg). My utilities are inexpensive because I keep thermostat 55 in winter and 78 in summer. Its an interior unit.I can tract my electric use daily in 15 min increments. I feel the unit should be replaced simply due to age but I'm not sure the cost justifies it yet because even this inefficient unit doesn't create high bills as we are there a few days a month. Occasionally, we are there for longer periods. What I have noticed is the cooling still seems pretty efficient. I had the unit serviced, inspected and cleaned. Is there suggestions for me to improve the heating efficiency? Its a pig in the winter. Could just the heating side be replaced? Is a highly experienced geothermal tech needed to optimize efficiency? I had a local HVAC guy I've worked with before Service the unit. He said he's worked on geothermal before. He said the unit is old, should be replaced in the near future but is safe and operating well. Just curious on how to best manage this on a budget. Thanks for sharing your expertise and knowledge.