r/geothermal • u/WhatMeeWorry • Sep 22 '25
US firm drills record 387 feet into granite with millimeter wave system
Amazing drilling rates of up to 16 feet (five meters) per hour through granite!
r/geothermal • u/WhatMeeWorry • Sep 22 '25
Amazing drilling rates of up to 16 feet (five meters) per hour through granite!
r/geothermal • u/ateam1984 • Apr 25 '26
r/geothermal
•
u/TheExplainer9000
•
Jun 29 '26
The company, Eavor, is pivoting from project operator to "technology provider" and actively searching for an outside candidate to take over, drill the remaining loops, and run the first-of-a-kind German facility.
r/geothermal • u/petey53 • Mar 04 '23
Ground source heating is great but installation costs are high. I decided to see if a cheapo do-it-yourself system could provide useful heating to reduce the carbon footprint of my 1885 rowhouse. I am now getting 8000-9000 BTU/hr out of about 100 ft of 1/2" pex buried 1 to 9 ft deep using a home made water-to-water heat pump made out of 2 small window ACs, 2 pumps and a Raspberry Pi computer controller. System cost about $3K.
My two storey, 14 ft wide house is about 1700 sq ft including a basement apartment. During renovations 15 years ago, I installed radiant floor heating using pex piping and a condensing natural gas boiler. Six years ago I added a 2-zone 18000 BTU/hr mini-split air source heat pump/AC with a 1 ton concealed ducted ceiling unit upstairs and a 7000 BTU wall unit in the basement. In heating mode, that off-loaded the boiler in warmer winter weather but my floors were cold unless I ran the boiler.
Since the house is attached on both sides, the heat loss is only about 18000 BTU/hr at the coldest expected temp of -18C. The gas boiler is fairly new and quite efficient, so I am not removing it, despite the fact that that makes me ineligible for government rebates. With the boiler and ASHP already working, I am not relying on the GSHP to keep from freezing. I can experiment without risk. I do not have to engineer for the worst case.
Using little digital thermometers bought on eBay, I recorded underground temperatures at 4 depths down to 5.5 ft over the 2021-2022 winter. Despite air temps down to -12C, even at a depth of only 14" the lowest temperature was 4.4C. That day the temp at 66" down was 7.5C. This convinced me that I did not need to go very deep to access warmth. My Toronto house is built on sedimentary glacial till where Lake Iroquois used to be in ancient times.
The backyard is only about 20x14 ft, not counting my paved laneway parking space. I am only using half the width (20x7) for the ground source piping. First I made a 9 ft deep hole by manually twisting a 2" PVC pipe (central vac duct pipe) into the ground. The pipe has teeth cut into its bottom end and I just twisted it down by hand and pulled up soil a few inches at a time. Using 1/2" copper street elbows I soldered together a copper spiral about 2 ft long with a 1/2" central copper return pipe. This "trombone" was inserted into the 9 ft hole with pex. Using a 3" trenching shovel I also buried about 56 ft of pex zigzagging around the yard about 1 ft deep (easy). In addition, I made a 5ft hole and packed it with 6 lengths of 1/2" pex. The two holes and the trench are connected to an inside manifold with 3 motorized valves to control the flow.
I don't have refrigeration skills, so I took the refrigeration loops out out of 2 window ACs (one old, one new) and carefully bent the copper refrigerant tubes (without breaking them, using bending tools) so that I could insert the hot "radiators" in one rectangular water vat and the cold radiators into another water vat. The system is not pressurized so that the refrigerant lines can exit the vats without needing seals. One pump (stainless steel), pumps a water/glycerin mix from the cold vat via the manifold/valves through the backyard loops and the other pump moves fluid from the hot vat to a plate heat exchanger into the pressurized floor plumbing. A bunch of cPVC piping and valves will allow floor cooling in the summer without needing the compressors. I didn't change the air conditioner wiring -- the fans are removed and the compressors and pumps just plug into computer-controlled outlets.
I had already built a Raspberry Pi computer-controlled pump controller for my heated floors that has 8 power relays and 24 temperature sensors to measure temps on every zone of the house, outside and the various pipes heating the floors. It uses little relay circuit boards from eBay (about $6 each), each with four 10 amp relays. I built another controller with 12 power relays and up to 28 temperature sensors for the GSHP. Using thermistors (100 for $6 on amazon) taped tightly to the pipes and covered with insulation, I can monitor and measure how the system is working and see the underground temperatures in the backyard. Python programs have full access to all sensors and can control the compressors, pumps and valves from software. I'm still working on the software.
The system has been in operation since Oct 2022 and I continue to tweak it. The winter in Toronto has been warm and I have only had to use the gas boiler for 3 cold spells so far. The ASHP plus new GSHP can keep the house warm (22C or better) down to an average daily outside temp of -5C. Electricity usage is up and gas usage is way down. Currently it is 0C outside with 2ft snow cover, and I am pumping -12C water/glycerin out into the yard and getting it back about 2C. The compressors bring the temp up to about 27C which runs through the floors constantly. Power consumption is about 965W using a single 110V 15A circuit. I estimate a COP of about 2.7. My conclusion is that shallow ground piping can provide significant auxiliary heat and a cheap, home-made heat pump can access it.
r/geothermal • u/zrb5027 • May 26 '23
r/geothermal • u/FusionToad • Jun 10 '25
(Screengrab on the last post got the volume bar...)
r/geothermal • u/swarrenlawrence • 10d ago
CanaryMedia: "Boise plans to tap its geothermal network to heat 300 affordable homes," by Alison F. Takemura.
Boise, Idaho operates the country’s largest geothermal heating system, which pipes naturally warmed, 177ºF water from underground to about 100 buildings—including the Idaho State Capitol. "Last week, semiconductor multinational Micron Technology [headquartered in the city] gave Boise $2.5million to build on that expertise."
"The cash fills a funding gap to extend the geothermal system to a planned affordable housing development with more than 300 units." In total, the project price tag is about $140 million, according to the city.
“Boise has been Micron’s headquarters for 48 years, and investing in this community means investing in the people who call it home,” said April Arnzen, executive vice president + chief people officer at Micron + president of its philanthropic arm, the Micron Foundation.
"February, the Bloomberg Philanthropies Mayors Challenge awarded Boise $ 1million to upgrade its geothermal system for affordable housing, as well as to explore a new use for the network: Some early-stage technologies exist that could potentially harness the hot water from Boise’s system to provide cooling, according to Maria Ortega, the city’s communications senior manager."
"The clean-heat expansion will help Boise get closer to its goal of becoming carbon-neutral by 2050." Already, the city’s geothermal network cuts thousands of tons of carbon emissions every year, the equivalent of taking more than 2,000 gas-powered cars off the road.
I should also add that we also need to keep expanding the EV charging network + encourage as many of those drivers as possible into electric vehicles as swiftly as feasible. Get 'er done.
r/geothermal • u/bobwyman • Dec 23 '25
It took almost 10 years of work by NY-GEO members and others but New York has finally put an end to the "100 foot gas subsidy" that has long encouraged residents to install gas, rather than more responsible options, such as geothermal heat pumps. With the passage of this law, those wishing gas service must pay the cost of the service pipes needed to attach their buildings to the gas network. This ends the long-time practice of having existing customers pay the costs created by new customers and will save those existing customers hundreds of millions of dollars every year. The new law helps to level the competitive playing field for geothermal systems. Gov. Hochul should be commended for finally signing this law which was passed by the New York legislature many months ago. Hopefully, other states that continue to subsidize gas adoption will follow New York's example and eliminate those subsidies.
Government moves slowly, but if you're right and you're persistent, eventually the right thing will happen. It may have taken 10 years of work, but if we hadn't done that work, these subsidies would undoubtedly continue much longer.
r/geothermal • u/the_bysmuth • Nov 13 '23
In September 2023, Dandelion Energy finished a GSHP installation in our duct-free home in southern Westchester County, NY. Before we signed our contract in July 2022, I read everything I could about others’ experiences with Dandelion (including several detailed posts in this forum), so I figured it was my turn to give back. At the very end of the post, I include a few things I wish I'd known before I started.
tl;dr: I can't recommend Dandelion. They took forever; they used guesswork when sizing our system; they cut corners on drilling and trenching; their teams did not adequately communicate with each other (or, sometimes, with us); we think they caused a leak in our basement, for which they have disclaimed responsibility; and the system stopped working after installation, necessitating (so far) six service calls. Importantly, we are happy so far with the finished product, which appears (for now) to be working. But the process was stressful, and our interactions with them post-installation really left us with a bad taste in our mouths.
House: Our house is ~100 years old and has no ductwork: It was heated via a boiler (oil) and steam radiators. Top to bottom, it's about 3,000 sq. ft. across 3 stories and the basement.
System details – exterior: Dandelion installed a 6-ton system requiring two wells, each dug 280 feet deep. The wells are connected to the house via pipes laid in trenches 2 feet below ground, with no insulation added to the pipes.
System details – interior: Since we don't have ductwork and had no interest in getting it installed, we opted for a system that uses ductless units (like mini-splits) powered by the GSHP. For this kind of installation, Dandelion uses Samsung DVM S units, which operate using variable refrigerant flow (VRF) rather than discrete stages. They installed two 3-ton compressors, connected to 8 ductless heads in various rooms in the house. As with more traditional ASHP-powered ductless mini-split installations, this required substantial line work (performed by Dandelion) so that each unit was provided with refrigerant, power and connectivity, and could appropriately drain condensate.



Process prior to contract signing: After our utility company (ConEd) shut off rebates for ASHP installations in May 2022 while we were in the middle of getting quotes, we reached out to Dandelion to see about ductless installations, which they had recently started doing. We had several virtual meetings with a Dandelion salesperson, who verified via Google Maps that our front yard was suitable for installation, then walked us through what the process would look like. There was a heavy emphasis placed both on the environmental aspects of electrification/GSHP installation, and also on the truly massive rebates that we would be eligible for.
When we decided to move ahead with system design, we took a large number of pictures of the interior and exterior of our house, and sent those to Dandelion. They used those to make a 3D model of our house, which they used to mock up a design of how many ductless units we would need, where lines would go, etc. Using this information, they prepared a contract, which (after discussing the details with them) we signed. Note that, at this point, no one from Dandelion had yet come to our house!
Pricing: The initial contract we signed included specs for a 7-ton system; after further system design, we signed a revised contract that changed the specs to a 6-ton system (with, mysteriously, almost no difference in price). The price breakdown for the final system design was as follows:
Costs:
2x 3-ton VRF systems (including digging, trenching, and installation) : $34,250 each * 2 = $68,500
Ductless units: $4,000 each * 8 = $32,000
Boiler removal: $1,750
Incentives [baked into contract price]:
Various Dandelion discounts [for having >1 well, >4 units, etc.]: -$8,500
ConEd Moratorium Incentive [around $0.60 per BTU of capacity]: -$45,244
Tax incentives [not included in contract price]:
NY State Income Tax Credit: -$5,000
IRA credit: Approximately -$15,000
Contract price: $48,506
Total price after tax credits: $28,500 [plus $5,000-8,000 to repave our driveway after trenching, an expected cost]
Some things to note about the pricing process:
Dandelion commits to a firm price prior to any drilling, soil sampling, etc.: It doesn't change if they hit bedrock sooner/later than they expect, for instance.
As noted, they bake utility company rebates into their pricing, but leave tax credits to homeowners. In our case, we got the best of all possible worlds: ConEd subsequently capped incentives for GSHP installations at $20K, but Dandelion had already committed to including the $45K incentive in our contract; and the IRA was subsequently passed, boosting our federal tax credits to 30% from 22%. Our final price of around $30K was equivalent to the quotes we had previously gotten for incentivized ASHP installations!
It is bizarre to me that they charge the same for every ductless unit, regardless of capacity. The units we got installed vary in size from 7.5K BTU all the way up to a monstrous 24K BTU (in the basement, which is one large room). Every one was $4K before discounts.
I have read stories online of Dandelion walking away from signed contracts, saying that a particular project no longer made financial sense for them. I was concerned that this might happen to us when their expected profit decreased by $25K overnight, but to their credit, they followed through.
Financing: Dandelion provides the option of financing the project through a bank. We were offered a loan at 4.99% with terms specifying no interest whatsoever if we pay off the entire loan within 18 months of when they schedule drilling. Since the discount for paying cash up-front was very small ($300), we took the loan.
System design: After we signed the contract, Dandelion sent someone to our house to take more detailed pictures of our front lawn, and to walk around to different rooms to take measurements and more photos, and to note where the units in each room would be likely to go. Entirely on that basis, a system designer at Dandelion performed Manual J calculations to estimate heating/cooling load. At no time did anyone at Dandelion assess our home's insulation, perform blower door tests, etc. They prepared final system design documents in October 2022, and applied for and received permits in December 2022.
System installation and timeline: Dandelion divides system installation into three phrases: Drilling, in which they drill the wells; trenching, in which they dig trenches to connect the wells to the interior of the house through the foundation; and installation, in which they install the compressors and (if getting a VRF system) the ductless units, then connect everything and turn it on. Each of these is performed by a separate team of Dandelion employees. We were told that there would be 4-6 weeks between each phase; in practice it was more like 10-12 weeks, most of which was due to their own scheduling practices.
Contract: Signed 7/8/22.
Drilling: Started 3/13/23. Dandelion's estimated duration for how long this stage would take: 3-4 days. Actual duration: 4 days.
Trenching: Started 5/31/23. Estimated duration: 2-3 days. Actual duration: 3 days.
Installation: Started 9/12/23. Estimated duration: 10 days. Actual duration: 14 days. (If we had gotten a ducted/non-VRF installation, it would have taken 3-4 days; VRF installations are a lot more work.) It seemed likely to take even longer, but toward the end, Dandelion sent over extra workers
At the time of signing, they estimated that the system would be installed by late spring or early summer 2023. It was fully installed on 9/29/23 (though it took another month to resolve problems with the system, as described below).
The work: There were some areas where the company cut corners in terms of design and execution.
Drilling: The design called for two 280-foot wells for our 6-ton system – an average of 93 feet per ton, which is certainly lower than industry rules of thumb. The drilling team accommodated our request to shift the location of one well so that they wouldn't destroy a nice holly bush, and figured out how to locate the second well so that they wouldn't need to tear up our front walkway. We were satisfied with the extent to which they cleaned up after themselves (our yard was still a muddy/grouty mess, but no more so than expected).
Trenching: The original design documents we received said that Dandelion would generally lay the pipe 4 feet below ground level, and that where this was not possible, they would insulate the pipe; however, they subsequently changed their company design standards (for most or all jobs, not just ours) to permit a 2-foot depth, with no additional insulation required – apparently, computer modeling showed that this was sufficient given the ground temperatures and glycol mix. Accordingly, the trenching team dug a 2-foot trench with pipe that connected to the wells, ran along our driveway, and punched into our foundation. However, the trenching crew unilaterally changed the punch-in location from the one agreed upon in the design documents to a different location which saved them 10 feet of trenching. We noticed that they were preparing to do this only after they had begun removing the driveway asphalt, and acquiesced because we didn't think it would make a major difference – but we were unhappy that they had not bothered to ask us.
Installation: The design documents called for some units that seemed too large to me – probably because they never actually took the measurements necessary to perform a proper Manual J. Most notably, they called for a 24K BTU unit in our basement: Our primary reason for having a unit there was to dehumidify, and I was concerned that an oversized unit would cause it to cycle on/off frequently enough that the unit wouldn't be on constantly as needed for dehumidification. When I raised this concern to the system designer prior to installation, it was dismissed.
The workers who spent three weeks in our house installing the system exercised great attention to detail. They talked with us about how the line set placements described in the design documents were suboptimal (requiring many holes in the foundation), and worked with us to find placements for each unit and line that maximized airflow, minimized lines inside the house, and minimized aesthetic effects on the exterior. They were friendly, they kept us in the loop, and they got the job done.
Basement leak: On the final day that the installation team was in our house, bracketing cables to the wall of our mechanical room and preparing the system to be turned on, it was pouring rain outside, and water began leaking through the foundation into the room from two places in the wall where they were doing work. We captured the water in a bucket and, needing a temporary solution to continue working, they plugged the holes with spray-in insulation. The outside location from which the water was leaking was a point in the driveway several feet from where trenching had occurred. Relevantly, our basement had not previously sprung any leaks in the two years that we have owned the house, including during Hurricane Ida in 2021. Dandelion has categorically denied all responsibility for the leak – even though it occurred for the first time ever in a wall that they had recently drilled into (upstairs), and directly behind line sets that they had attached to it.
System not working: 1.5 weeks after the system was installed, the air handlers threw errors and stopped working, at which point we called Dandelion to send repair technicians. This commenced a month-long process in which Dandelion sent technicians on six separate occasions to try to fix the problem. During one particularly eventful week, they sent three different technicians on four service calls; each time, we began by telling the current technician what the previous technician had tried and found. It turns out that both compressors had been under-pressurized and, in one case, may also have been under-filled with refrigerant. The units now seem to be working, which is good because it is November and we need heat!
What the system is like: When the system is working (as it has now been doing for the past two weeks), it has been great. With our steam radiators, we had to heat the house altogether or not at all, and we relied on overhead fans for cooling. The ability to heat/cool individual rooms to specified air temperatures is everything I hoped it would be. Every other aspect of our home is non-smart by choice, but – with the system connected to wi-fi – we have the ability to control each unit not only using remotes but also from our phones. We sleep better and we no longer need to bundle up before going into the kitchen in the morning. I look forward to giving the system a proper heating test in very cold weather in the coming months, and a proper cooling and dehumidification test next summer. Fingers crossed that it holds up!
What I wish I'd known before we started: If I were doing things over again, I would get air sealing and insulation work performed first, and then pay to get blower door tests performed and a Manual J completed based on empirical data. Then, I would only sign off on a heat pump system that used those numbers to determine heating/cooling loads for each room, which would correctly size both individual units and also the compressors.
When I called 5-6 companies in spring 2022 to see if they would install a ductless GSHP system, all of the others told me either that it wasn't possible or (in one case) that I should "run far away from any company that tells you they can do it". Dandelion was the only company with a ductless product, and the only one that said they could install ground loops in our modest front yard, so we had a Hobson's choice: We could either go with them, or not at all. Now that I know more about the system we got installed (Samsung DVM S Water), I might approach things from the other direction, by looking for other contractors via Samsung's contractor network and then asking if they install GSHP systems.
The entire process took about four months longer than expected (five including the necessary fixes). The contract we signed said that "Time is not of the essence", so we knew that we had no recourse for things taking a while, but some of the delays were a little ridiculous.
Do I recommend Dandelion: No. I would really, really like to, but I can't. They took forever; they used guesswork when sizing our system; they cut corners on drilling and trenching; their teams did not communicate with each other (and sometimes did not communicate adequately with us); they shrugged off our basement leak, for which we think they are responsible; and they necessitated (at least?) six visits by technicians to get the system working after installation. Importantly, we are (for now) happy with the finished product. But the process was stressful, and the last six weeks really left us with a bad taste in our mouths.
r/geothermal • u/morlandhvac • May 07 '26
My pet project is finally done!
I consolidated over 30 years worth of our service records, public data from a few different sources, and paper maps from well and boring companies in my area to create a high-def map of the entire state of Ohio and which loop type is likely to best suit any piece of ground in the state. It has helped tremendously in speeding up quotes and getting the right materials where they need to be.
Hope this is helpful to someone!
r/geothermal • u/valhamman • Sep 24 '26
r/geothermal • u/ThePastyWhite • Mar 01 '25
Several years ago I decided to do my own wells for a Geothermal HVAC unit.
Today, I am making that a reality.
600 ft in total. 6-100 ft wells.
This is for a 3 ton 5-series Water Furnace geothermal unit.
I am currently at 15 ft on my first well. Stopped to eat and get fuel for the rest of the dig.
Wish me luck y'all!
r/geothermal • u/bobwyman • Oct 30 '25
Rep. Mike Thompson [D-CA-4] and 114 other members of the House are co-sponsoring H.R.5862, the American Energy Independence and Affordability Act, whose primary purpose is to restore the many energy-related provisions which were eliminated by Public Law 119–21 (aka: the Big Ugly Bill). Of significant interest to this group will be the restoration of §25D tax residential energy tax credits and 5-year depreciation for §48 commercial energy property.
Of course, this bill has no chance of passage while Republicans continue to control the House, however, it is still useful in that it clarifies just how much was lost when PL 119-21 passed. Also, it sets down text that can be easily picked up and moved forward once Democrats regain the ability to participate in the legislative process.
r/geothermal • u/Natural_Dark_2387 • Nov 28 '23
r/geothermal • u/zrb5027 • Feb 21 '23
Link to the survey: https://forms.gle/iuSqbnMks7QGt5wg9
Link to the responses: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1M7f2V_P_LibwzrkyorHcXR-sgRZZegPeWAZavaPc5dU/edit?usp=sharing
Hi all!
Let's be honest. HVACing can be stressful as a homeowner, and this can be especially true when getting geothermal installation quotes, where the limited number of installers can make it difficult to get multiple opinions and prices.
Inspired by r/heatpumps, I have created a short, public, anonymous survey where current geothermal heat pump owners can enter in information about quotes, installations, and general performance of their units. All of this data is sent directly to a spreadsheet, where both potential shoppers and current geothermal owners are then able to see and compare quotes, sizing, and satisfaction of their installations across various geographical regions!
Now here's the catch: This spreadsheet only works if the data exists. It's up to current owners, satisfied or otherwise, to fill out the survey and help inform the community about their experience. The r/heatpumps spreadsheet is a plethora of information, where quotes can be broken down in time and space thanks to the substantially larger install base. With the smaller number of geothermal installs, getting a sample size that's actually helpful for others is going to require a lot of participation. So please, if you have a couple minutes, fill out what you can in the geothermal heat pump survey, send it to other geothermal owners you know that may also be interested in helping out, and let's create something cool and useful!
r/geothermal • u/craftythedog • Jan 29 '26
r/geothermal • u/Paniolo_Man • Jan 10 '26
A picture I took last week of the Cove Fort Power Plant. This is one of Utah's 3 operating geothermal plants. Ormat plans to expand this plant by adding at least 20 MW of additional capacity. More recently they've been hard at work adding additional cooling capacity to the existing plant.
East of here Fervo is wrapping up phase 1 of Cape Station, which will produce 90MW of enhanced geothermal. They'll bring an additional 400MW online in 2028. There are several other projects in varying stages of development nearby.
r/geothermal • u/bobwyman • Dec 17 '25
Kari Rau, of Colorado Geothermal Drilling, recently posted a map of systems they've installed in Colorado over the years. For those who are concerned that "GHP isn't popular," I think this map should give them some comfort in demonstrating that others have adopted the technology.
I think the industry would be well served if others were to prepare such maps and if we could get better statistics on GHP usage in the USA. Today, while we have detailed knowledge of solar, wind, and hydro installations, due to reporting by industry and government, there is virtually no detailed, public information on GHP installations. Ideally, we would have not only statistics describing the number of systems installed, but also of their energy harvesting capacity. Until GHP has statistical data similar to that of other renewable energy technologies, it will be very hard to get policy makers to shift more of their focus to GHP.
r/geothermal • u/bobwyman • May 13 '25
The House Ways and Means Committee draft reconciliation bill proposes eliminating the 30% Section 25D - Residential clean energy credit (including those for geothermal systems) after Jan 1, 2026. (See: SEC. 112006. TERMINATION OF RESIDENTIAL CLEAN ENERGY CREDIT. page 221). If passed, only systems installed before the end of this calendar year would receive the tax credit. They also propose more rapidly phasing out the Section 48 commercial credit for geothermal. It would end on Jan 1, 2032, instead of Jan 1, 2035.
The justification for these cuts appears to be a desire to provide funds that will allow making permanent the 2017 TCJA tax cuts.
The draft bill also cuts most other energy tax credits and most of what was in the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) passed during Biden's Administration. Here's a list of some other the sections which impact energy:
SEC. 112002. TERMINATION OF CLEAN VEHICLE CREDIT.
SEC. 112003. TERMINATION OF QUALIFIED COMMERCIAL CLEAN VEHICLES CREDIT.
SEC. 112004. TERMINATION OF ALTERNATIVE FUEL VEHICLE REFUELING PROPERTY CREDIT.
SEC. 112005. TERMINATION OF ENERGY EFFICIENT HOME IMPROVEMENT CREDIT.
SEC. 112006. TERMINATION OF RESIDENTIAL CLEAN ENERGY CREDIT. (25D)
SEC. 112007. TERMINATION OF NEW ENERGY EFFICIENT HOME CREDIT.
SEC. 112008. PHASE-OUT AND RESTRICTIONS ON CLEAN ELECTRICITY PRODUCTION CREDIT.
SEC. 112009. PHASE-OUT AND RESTRICTIONS ON CLEAN ELECTRICITY INVESTMENT CREDIT.
SEC. 112010. REPEAL OF TRANSFERABILITY OF CLEAN FUEL PRODUCTION CREDIT.
SEC. 112011. RESTRICTIONS ON CARBON OXIDE SEQUESTRATION CREDIT.
SEC. 112012. PHASE-OUT AND RESTRICTIONS ON ZERO- EMISSION NUCLEAR POWER PRODUCTION CREDIT.
SEC. 112013. TERMINATION OF CLEAN HYDROGEN PRODUCTION CREDIT.
SEC. 112014. PHASE-OUT AND RESTRICTIONS ON ADVANCED MANUFACTURING PRODUCTION CREDIT.
SEC. 112015. PHASE-OUT OF CREDIT FOR CERTAIN ENERGY PROPERTY. (Section 48, commercial)
r/geothermal • u/Vailhem • Jul 14 '26
r/geothermal • u/IsThatDaveByChance • Feb 04 '26
I read a lot of posts on this subreddit before making the switch to geothermal and wanted to share my experience and pay it forward.
I live outside of Boston, MA on the South Shore, and we just finished our first full year with Dandelion. The system was turned on in the spring of 2024. First question answered: would I recommend Dandelion? I’m a solid “meh” on them as a company. Most of the stories you read here will sound familiar. I had to spend a lot of advocating and follow-up, to the point where the operations director eventually gave me his cell phone so we could move things along. Lots of new people, lots of subcontractors. I think the electrician changed three times. That said, the work did get done, and having dealt with contractors before, the experience wasn’t outside the error bars of past projects.
Our system cost $59,120, which included a 5-ton Enertech unit, an upgrade from 150-amp to 200-amp service, and duct modifications limited to the basement. Massachusetts offered a $15K rebate, which Dandelion collected directly. The remaining $44,120 was financed on a 0% loan, and we received a 30% federal tax credit ($13,236), bringing the true cost to $30,884. We also priced out replacing our AC and furnace with reasonably efficient models, and estimates came in around $18–20K. Everything is expensive here.
I’ve tracked our electricity usage and natural gas costs, and in 2025 we saved $1,482.92 compared to our previous system, using current rates of $0.2977 per kWh for electricity and $2.24 per therm for natural gas. I also ran some “what-if” scenarios assuming we had gone with a high-efficiency air-source heat pump instead. In that case, the geothermal savings drop to roughly $700–900 per year. Still better than the old system, but not as strong as geothermal. All in, I’m looking at an 11–15 year ROI compared to a traditional gas system/air source heat pump combo. Since the well should last 80+ years, replacing the internal unit decades from now should be significantly cheaper.
Lessons learned: While I didn’t love working with Dandelion, there really wasn’t anyone else locally doing geothermal retrofits at scale. Most companies I spoke with focused on new construction, and the few that did retrofits were more expensive. Would I do geothermal again in 2026? Probably not. The 30% federal tax credit has expired, and Massachusetts reduced the rebate from $15K to $12.5K. Combined with high electricity costs, geothermal is no longer as compelling compared to natural gas and a air-source heat pump.
TL;DR
Dandelion installation was frustrating
Net geothermal cost: ~$30.9K after rebates and tax credit
Annual savings vs old system: ~$1,500/year
Savings vs high-efficiency natural gas / air-source heat pump combo: ~$700–900/year
~11–15 year ROI compared to traditional HE system
With reduced incentives and high electric rates, geothermal is harder to justify today in Massachusetts