r/gamedesign • • 5h ago

Question Background music with lyrics for a small game?

4 Upvotes

I’m curious is it fine if I put an aggressive drill track with lyrics into my game if it fits the vibe of the gameplay?

I rarely see games that have background music with lyrics and I’m worried that it will sound awkward for players.

What are your thoughts?

The game is a horror roguelike.


r/gamedesign • • 20h ago

Discussion Old roguelikes punish mechanics. Which modern games still do this?

45 Upvotes

I've been going through the mechanics of early roguelikes, and I would say they punished player a lot.

Some examples:

  • Rogue (early versions, around 1980). A wraith's hit has a chance to remove one of your experience levels.

  • NetHack. Amnesia, from a scroll or a mind flayer, makes your character forget maps of levels you explored and what your items are. The newest versions removed the map and item part.

  • ToeJam & Earl (1991). One of the presents is the Randomizer. It resets the identity of every present, so everything you had figured out is unknown again. The more presents you open, the more likely you are to hit it.

  • Angband (1990). A fire attack can destroy scrolls, staves and spellbooks in your pack. Some monsters drain a stat like strength, unless your gear sustains that stat.

Early Rogue also had the reverse, pretty cool (on paper) mechanic: a scroll of genocide. You pick one kind of monster and it never appears again in that game. Later versions of Rogue removed it.

Which modern games has mechanics like these?

Why did it mostly disappear? Did players hate it?


r/gamedesign • • 11h ago

Meta Weekly Show & Tell - November 21, 2026

3 Upvotes

Please share information about a game or rules set that you have designed! We have updated the sub rules to encourage self-promotion, but only in this thread.

Finished games, projects you are actively working on, or mods to an existing game are all fine. Links to your game are welcome, as are invitations for others to come help out with the game. Please be clear about what kind of feedback you would like from the community (play-through impressions? pedantic rules lawyering? a full critique?).

Do not post blind links without a description of what they lead to.


r/gamedesign • • 12h ago

Question Winning the “unwinnable”

0 Upvotes

I’m currently playtesting VAULT RAIDERS, where every room is a puzzle and every action is a card. this week, I had a playtester ask about a room where he was going to take massive damage in a single turn.

I wrote a community post about how to navigate out of this situation, but I’m curious: how do you approach difficulty in your games? my personal taste is making games that want to break you, so you can break them back. But I appreciate that isn’t everyone’s cup of team.

Thoughts?


r/gamedesign • • 1d ago

Discussion Does this open-ended RPG introduction give new players enough direction?

6 Upvotes

I’m designing a 3D action RPG where players can explore, fight monsters, and take guild jobs at their own pace. There’s no compulsory questline. Here’s how the first few minutes work for a combat character:

  1. The player arrives in a town with a basic weapon and registers with the Adventurers’ Guild. They can take a short combat tutorial or skip it and return later.

  2. They can practice, hunt nearby monsters, take a guild job, or leave for the next city. One beginner job is clearing a monster from the town mill. It pays coins and gives them a town map with shops, guilds, and exits already marked.

  3. Locals might suggest visiting the blacksmith or exploring a nearby area. The player finds their own way. If they head for the next city, the gate guard warns them about a boss blocking the road.

My concern is that a player who skips training and passes on the mill job might feel lost. What cue would help them choose their first goal while keeping that choice theirs?


r/gamedesign • • 7h ago

Question How would you go about making 7 characters playing at once in a game

0 Upvotes

I am raking my brain, pls help


r/gamedesign • • 1d ago

Discussion How would you lay out the first planet in a 3D action RPG with boss-gated travel?

4 Upvotes

Players start in a random remote town or city, find gear, and join a guild to gain levels and stats through missions. Roads between cities have repeatable area bosses that can mutate, and rare powerful monsters roam the wilderness. At a level threshold, the king summons the player to the capital to defeat the boss blocking travel to another kingdom. A solo or party continent boss unlocks the next continent and grants a first-clear reward. Random quests award tokens for hidden dungeons and sky temples. Clearing their bosses unlocks the planet boss. I’m still deciding the penalties for losing boss fights.

How would you shape and place the continents, forests, volcanic ranges, and frozen regions, then lay out the towns, cities, capitals, roads, and boss gates? I want players starting in different places to have distinct journeys, with routes worth revisiting even when the road bosses return.


r/gamedesign • • 1d ago

Question Randomness of level for the demo

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I’m making my first puzzle roguelike and the structure of it is that there are 50 levels for the demo and each of the levels is a puzzle that needs to be solved in one minute.

For the demo to not be annoying do I have to code a completely random levels system for each run? Or can I just make 150 levels and make the game choose 50 levels randomly from the 150 I create. Does anybody have experience with this? I want it to be fun but not feel repetitive.

I’m just struggling to think of a way to make random puzzles for the game.


r/gamedesign • • 1d ago

Discussion How do you make losing feel gentle in a cozy game without making it meaningless?

2 Upvotes

I'm making Cozy Cargo, a packing puzzle roguelite that looks very cozy (little bedroom, golden hour, a cat on the bed). A run is one week, three boxes a day, and if you miss a box's target the week ends early.

Right now a loss looks like this: no game over screen, the client is just a bit disappointed, and the week closes with a "Closed Early" screen that names the box you missed. You keep half the Stamps you earned that week. Stamps are the meta currency, and they only unlock new objects and modifiers, never power.

I asked cozy players about losing this week and a few said they actually want something at stake. So I'd like the loss to keep its weight without feeling like a punishment.

What have you seen work for this ? Is naming the box you missed enough, or should the loss tell you more about why it happened ?

Steam demo | Browser demo


r/gamedesign • • 11h ago

Discussion Would you throw your teammate at an enemy if their soul was trapped in a rock?

0 Upvotes

Imagine a fantasy co-op game.

A powerful wizard traps your teammate's soul inside a stone. No legs, no weapons. You can literally put your friend in your pocket.

You could carry them to a healer and try to break the curse.

Except they still have mana.

Not enough to fly, but enough to fight gravity a little. Roll uphill, perhaps. Or change direction slightly if someone throws them.

And then comes the rather unpleasant discovery: if the stone hits an enemy, your teammate might be able to possess its body.

So now the party has two plans.

Rescue our friend.

Or throw our friend at the nearest enemy and hope they come back with legs.

I suspect the second plan would get tested remarkably quickly.

But here's what bothers me about the mechanic. If the curse turns out to be an excellent way to infiltrate enemy positions, how long before players start deliberately seeking it out?

A high-level wizard tries to take someone out of the fight and accidentally invents a new combat role.

Would you throw your teammate if they agreed to it?

More importantly, would you volunteer to be the stone?


r/gamedesign • • 1d ago

Discussion My idea for a magic system in an rpg / dungeonrunner

0 Upvotes

I'm designing an RPG magic system based on directional inputs, spell mastery, and overcasting. Would this actually be fun?

DISCLAIMER: Yes, I used AI in the making of this all the ideas are original to me but I used it to brainstorm and compile my ideas into this for feedback I think this concept is cool.

I've been brainstorming a magic system for a multiplayer-focused RPG. My goal is to make magic something players actually have to learn and master, rather than just pressing a button and watching a spell activate.

I also want to encourage teamwork between different classes without completely preventing people from playing solo.

Here's what I've come up with so far.

1. Directional Spellcasting

Instead of assigning every spell to a hotkey, players would enter directional combinations using four inputs (↑ ↓ ← →).

For example:

  • Ember: ↑ →

  • Fireball: ↑ → ↓ →

  • Inferno: ↑ → ↓ ← ↑ ↑ → ↓

Generally, the more powerful the spell, the longer or more complicated its combination.

After entering the combination, players press a separate confirmation button to cast the spell.

This solves an issue I initially thought of: different spells having overlapping combinations, especially once players start mastering them.

The idea is that experienced players would eventually memorize their spells and be able to cast them quickly without constantly checking their spellbook.

2. Individual Spell Mastery

The more you successfully use a spell, the more proficient you become with it.

Instead of mastery simply increasing damage, it would actually make the spell easier to cast.

For example, Fireball might progress like this:

  • Novice: ↑ → ↓ ← ↑ →

  • Apprentice: ↑ → ↓ ↑ →

  • Adept: ↑ → ↓ →

  • Expert: ↑ → → →

  • Master: ↑ → →

As you master the spell, its combination becomes shorter, and its mana consumption decreases.

This means two players using the same spell could have completely different experiences depending on how much time they've invested in mastering it.

Mastery would ideally be earned through meaningful spell usage rather than standing around spamming spells.

3. Mana, Intelligence, and Equipment

Every spell consumes mana, with more powerful spells generally costing more.

Mana consumption would scale with several factors:

  • Intelligence: Higher Intelligence reduces mana costs.

  • Spell Mastery: The more experienced you are with a particular spell, the cheaper it becomes.

  • Equipment: Certain armor, staffs, and accessories provide mana-efficiency bonuses.

  • Skill Trees: Players can invest in abilities that reduce mana consumption.

These bonuses would have diminishing returns to prevent players from eventually casting powerful spells for almost no mana.

Maximum mana and regeneration would be separate mechanics that still need balancing.

4. Overcasting — My Favorite Mechanic So Far

What happens when a player tries to cast a spell without enough mana?

Instead of simply preventing the cast, I want players to be able to overcast.

Overcasting allows a spell to succeed even if the player doesn't have enough mana, but it comes with potentially severe consequences.

I've thought of two penalties:

Mana Exhaustion

  • The spell successfully casts.

  • The player suffers a 30% magical damage reduction.

  • Their mana continues regenerating.

  • The debuff disappears once their mana bar completely refills.

Mana Fracture

  • The spell successfully casts.

  • The player's mana bar physically shatters.

  • They can no longer cast mana-consuming spells.

  • Natural mana regeneration stops.

  • Their mana bar must be repaired through a Cleric's Soul Healing spell or a special magical restoration item.

Visually, I'd love for the mana bar to actually crack and leak magical energy when fractured.

I'm considering having smaller mana deficits cause Exhaustion and larger deficits cause Fracture.

Overcasting again while already exhausted could also cause an immediate fracture.

This would make overcasting a genuine risk-versus-reward mechanic, especially during difficult boss fights.

5. Class Synergies

This is where I think the system could become really interesting in multiplayer.

Imagine two players:

Pyromage — High Burst DPS

A Pyromage specializes in powerful fire spells and aggressive overcasting, sacrificing mana stability for damage.

Arcane Cleric — Healing and Soul Restoration

An Arcane Cleric specializes in restoring health, repairing fractured mana bars, transferring mana, and protecting teammates.

During a boss fight, the Pyromage could intentionally overcast an extremely powerful spell, completely fracturing their mana bar.

The Cleric could then use Soul Mend to repair the fracture, allowing the Pyromage to continue fighting.

This would create opportunities for coordinated teams to build strategies around dangerous magical abilities.

Some possible Cleric skills include:

  • Soul Mend: Repairs fractured mana.

  • Mana Transfer: Transfers mana to an ally.

  • Soul Ward: Reduces overcasting penalties.

  • Divine Reconstitution: Repairs a fracture, restores mana, and temporarily empowers an ally.

These are still concepts rather than finalized abilities.

6. Combining Spells Between Classes

I also want compatible spells from different classes to interact with each other.

For example:

Inferno + Cyclone = Firestorm

A Pyromage creates an inferno while a Wind Mage summons a cyclone, producing a massive moving fire tornado.

Absolute Zero + Crushing Blow = Shatter

A Cryomage freezes an enemy, allowing a Warrior to deal massive stagger or armor-breaking damage.

Divine Barrier + Soul Mend = Sanctuary

A Paladin and Cleric combine their abilities to create a protective zone that heals allies and stabilizes mana.

Water + Lightning = Conduction

Lightning spreads through soaked enemies, potentially chaining between multiple targets.

I want these interactions to reward actual coordination and timing rather than simply providing passive damage bonuses.

7. Team-Focused Dungeons and Solo Play

My RPG would primarily encourage cooperative dungeon running.

Solo dungeons would still be possible, but considerably more difficult.

Solo players could compensate through:

  • Healing companions or familiars

  • Mana-restoring pets

  • Specialized self-sustaining builds

  • Restoration consumables

  • Defensive equipment

However, these wouldn't completely replace the benefits of having an actual coordinated party.

I want bringing different classes to feel genuinely valuable.

8. Party-Size Healing Debuffs

Another idea I had was reducing individual self-healing effectiveness as party size increases.

This would specifically apply to personal healing sources, not dedicated support classes.

For example, a Pyromage using a health potion from their inventory would receive less healing in a six-player party than when playing solo.

The reduction could vary depending on the player's class.

However, a Cleric's healing spells would remain fully effective regardless of party size.

The purpose is to encourage larger parties to rely on dedicated support characters rather than having every DPS player sustain themselves indefinitely through inventory healing.

Solo players would retain their full self-healing effectiveness.

9. What Still Needs Balancing?

There are quite a few things I haven't finalized:

  • How fast directional combinations should be entered

  • Whether incorrect combinations should have penalties

  • Exactly how much mastery should shorten combinations

  • Mana regeneration speed

  • How much Intelligence should affect mana efficiency

  • When overcasting causes Exhaustion versus Fracture

  • How strong cooperative spell combinations should be

  • How much personal healing should decrease with party size

  • Whether players should have fixed classes or flexible skill trees

I don't expect every mechanic to work perfectly without testing, but I think they could create a pretty interesting foundation.

Final Thoughts

The main idea is that magic should reward player skill, character progression, and teamwork simultaneously.

A beginner mage might struggle to execute longer combinations, while an experienced mage can cast the same spells quickly and efficiently.

A solo player might need to carefully manage their mana, while a coordinated team could take greater risks through overcasting and support abilities.

I especially like the possibility of players discovering unexpected spell combinations and developing strategies around different class synergies.

I'd love some feedback on three things:

  1. Would directional spellcasting actually be enjoyable during fast-paced combat, or would it become tedious?

  2. Does the overcasting system sound like an interesting risk-versus-reward mechanic, or would Mana Fracture be too punishing?

  3. Would these mechanics genuinely encourage teamwork, or would they make certain support classes feel mandatory?

I'm still in the brainstorming/design stage, so criticism and suggestions are welcome!


r/gamedesign • • 15h ago

Discussion Our bot found a stage that could never end because of one healer

0 Upvotes

Bot run of stage 2 in our TD: a healer got blocked by three level 1 soldiers and just stood there healing 60 HP every 8 s. With 80% magic resist the soldiers and a mage tower couldn't kill it, and it never leaked, so the wave never ended.

Dropped its magic resist to 50% and it dies now, but that only fixes this one case. Do you add a hard rule for this (no healing while blocked, a wave timer) or just tune numbers and let the bots catch the next one?


r/gamedesign • • 1d ago

Question What are your thoughts and opinions on a multiplayer fps where everyone can heal everyone else on the team, but no one can heal themselves?

2 Upvotes

This would be for a base versus base kind of deal, where you can repair base defenses and heal teammates.

But rather than having a class or an item, I was thinking about having it a single key that everyone can use, but you cannot use it on yourself.

I was thinking it would encourage cooperation and sticking together as a team.

But I also know that this is going to amplify how bad non-team players are.

I can see myself being incredibly frustrated when a teammate is just picking their nose and I desperately need healing.


r/gamedesign • • 16h ago

Question Design question: after a chase, should police heat drop as soon as you break line of sight, or only after you stay hidden for a while?

0 Upvotes

Hey r/gamedesign, I'm on the small team behind Heistfest, a getaway-driving game, and we keep going back and forth on how police heat should cool down.

Option A: break line of sight and the heat starts dropping right away. It feels fair and readable, and it rewards smart driving. The downside is that ducking behind one building can feel too easy.

Option B: once you're out of sight, you have to stay hidden for a set time (say, idling in an alley or a parking garage) before the heat drops. It builds tension and makes hiding spots matter, but waiting can feel like dead time.

We're leaning toward a mix: line of sight starts a short countdown, and a patrol car that drives past resets it. But we're curious how you'd weigh readability against tension here.

What games do this well, and what made the cool-down feel good or bad to you?

(Disclosure: I work on the game. Steam page if useful: https://store.steampowered.com/app/1451220/?utm_source=reddit&utm_campaign=oct21-anniversary&utm_content=ext-gamedesign-1121)


r/gamedesign • • 1d ago

Question Looking for feedback on a class progression system for my upcoming FPS!

2 Upvotes

I'm developing a grounded, modern military FPS called RULES OF ENGAGEMENT, and I'm currently working on its class and archetype progression.

There are six main classes, each with three archetypes:

  • Assault: Assault, Breacher, Pointman

  • Engineer: Engineer, Mechanic, Citadel

  • Medic: Medic, Field Surgeon, Rescue Specialist

  • Support: Support, Observer, Gunner

  • Recon: Recon, Sniper, Ghost

  • Specialist: Specialist, Renegade, Saboteur

The current idea is to have players choose a Focus Class at Level 1, then unlock class perks, archetypes, and eventually specializations from other classes as they level up.

For example:

  • Level 1: Choose Focus Class

  • Level 2: Class Perk

  • Level 5: First Focus Class Archetype

  • Level 7: First Archetype from another class

I'm still figuring out the overall level requirements, progression speed, and how players should unlock everything.

What do you think? Does this sound like a worthwhile progression system? Would you change the unlock structure, or do you think certain things should be earned through gameplay rather than overall level?

I'd appreciate any feedback.

Sean O'Connor ||-//


r/gamedesign • • 1d ago

Question Thoughts on pursuing education in Game Design as someone with professional comp. engineering experience?

10 Upvotes

I'm 24, Portuguese, with a master's in Computer's Engineering. I've been working full time at a local company for the last three years. I feel pretty lucky be in what feels like a stable position in life, but have found programming and computer science in general to be very unfulfilling, especially as of the last few years where AI has essentially reshaped the landscape into something unrecognizable.

I always intended to eventually move to game development but have found over the years that I am mostly interested in the creative game design process, which is something I have no qualification, experience, or portfolio for to land a position in. Having been running a full time job for years now and under the pressure of never actually "making it", it's hard to want to find the time and energy to work on personal portfolio projects.

Would you say pursuing formal education in game design would work out for me in this situation, specifically in regards to helping me find an entry level job and developing a portfolio? I'm not aiming to just hop into a team and start being an "idea guy", but I would love to go into a degree knowing that, by the end, I will be guided towards entry level positions that could lead me to game design positions, and that I will have formally recognized qualifications and a portfolio that could help that process.

I'm worried that pursuing a degree like this would set me back in terms of my current qualifications and work experience in Computer Engineering, and that a portfolio and a niche degree might not really make up for that. The world of computer science is moving at an alarming rate, and taking a break to study game design might just lose me the comfortable position I've landed. Would it just be best to "lock in" and cram some hours into a personal portfolio on my own? Are there good "middle term" options that you could share?


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Question What made you a better game designer?

57 Upvotes

There are thousands of mechanics, different types of players, and so many things to learn about game design.

But forget all that for a second.

What was that one thing you learned that made you feel like you actually leveled up as a game designer?


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Question What’s your favorite leveling up system?

21 Upvotes

Hi,

So i really love the leveling up system of skyrim.
Hit with a one handed sword and u gain exp in that. Block with a shield and u get exp in that and so on…

I also love the leveling system of souls games.
Preferably i would like to sell some stuff i don’t need to have more currency to level up more.

I guess my favorite way would be one, where i could raid. Take everything with me and then sell like 90% of it to get currency to level up. But i also wouldn’t wanna give up the leveling system of skyrim.

I feel like for gamers it’s instantly rewarding when you know that your fighting itself is making you stronger.
In God of War (classics) for instance u would get those red orbs each time u’d kill an enemy.
So therefore i loved running around and killing side enemies as well because i wanted to become as op as possible.

I was wondering today what my perfect leveling up system in an RPG would look like. I don’t want to exchange one for the other but at the same time i don’t want to loose the profits of one or the other.

Thanks for reading if u came this far.
What do u think? Are my eyes bigger than my stomach, is there beauty in leaving something valueable?
And what is your favorite way of leveling up? What would u recommend? 😇


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Question How do you know when a core loop is solid enough to build around?

6 Upvotes

I'm at the point in a project where the core loop (resource gathering -> light crafting -> short exploration) feels playable but a little thin. It works in a 5-10 minute session, but I keep second-guessing whether it's actually worth expanding into a full game or if I should keep iterating on it first.

What usually tells you the loop has enough legs? Do you look for a certain level of player engagement in testing, a specific number of natural variations, or something else? Would be useful to hear how other people have made that call.


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Question Minmaxing in RPGs

2 Upvotes

Do you intentionally design your game to allow players to minmax certain stats or battle advantages? Why or why not?

What are some ways you’ve seen this done in a way that’s fun? What about the opposite (it breaking the game and making it not fun)?

Minmaxing as far as I understand is the art of neglecting one seemingly superior resource or stat for one that seems less than, in order to achieve a specific goal.

Example: getting a falcon sword in Dragon Quest when you could get a Dragonsbane sword. Falcon sword does less damage but hits twice. You would be minmaxing for the sake of metal slime farming.


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Discussion Making a main weapon that doubles as a tool?

15 Upvotes

Essentially, it's a weapon that can fight, but also used as a tool for puzzle solving and exploration. A exmaple to me being Shovel Knight's shovel blade. It both can be used to attack stuff, but can also pogo bounce off enemies/objects, and can dig/toss up dirt. DIG even expanded upon it via letting him dig through deep walls of dirt, adding to some pretty satisfying movment.


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Question How do you decide whether to double down on a mechanic or strip it out entirely?

3 Upvotes

I'm in the middle of prototyping a resource management game where one system lets players convert excess materials into temporary map vision. It creates some interesting short term decisions and nice visual feedback, but it also keeps pulling focus away from the main tension of limited storage space.

Every time I try to tune it, the loop either becomes too strong (players just stockpile for vision bursts) or too weak (it gets ignored). I'm struggling to tell if the problem is the numbers, the presentation, or if the mechanic simply doesn't belong.

For people who've faced similar situations, what usually helps you make the call to invest more time versus cutting it and moving on?


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Question Positional synergies on a hex board: how do you avoid "just cluster everything"?

11 Upvotes

I am trying to design jokers in a hex grid based city building roguelike. The scoring mechanism is straightforward (value * multiplier) and buildings depend on the board. However, in Balatro, positioning in a row gives a simple positional bonus. But in a hex grid there are many more options. This is what I am struggling with.

If giving a bonus for each adjacent piece, it will collapse quickly. In every scenario, the best option will be a clump of tiles. So far, things have worked better by doing:

  • Need space: Score based on number of empty tiles adjacent to that stone (adjacent, 2 away, and in the entire realm). This competes with everything else in the game.

  • Like company: Score based on number of other stones within 2 spaces. If these two are placed adjacent to each other, they compete with each other meaning we get the desired decision making.

  • Based on shape: Score based on how many tiles on a river/road (depending on the stone), or long sea coast. So we build a particular shape.

Would be great to hear from people who have done similar scoring:

  • What conditions did you find gave interesting decisions? (lines, circles, distance, facing, unique, edge, fully enclosed)

  • How do you avoid the adjacency bonuses combining into a single optimal design?

  • Do you know any good games to look at? We have looked at Islanders, Dorfromantik, Balatro, and Combolands.


r/gamedesign • • 2d ago

Question Help with Game Mechanic Tutorial and indications!

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone! Feel free to watch the clip before reading the explanation below, I’d love to know if the mechanic makes sense on its own first.

clip:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VSNWsZiW_aM

I’m making a two-player co-op puzzle platformer called Invertus. At a recent showcase, people gave really encouraging feedback, though most didn't pick up on the core mechanic right away without me explaining it:

Invert:

  • How Invert works: Holding the Invert button while not moving, shows particle indicators on the affected platforms. When you release the button, all platforms flip colors (white to black or black to white) except the one the inverting player is standing on.

  • In co-op: If I invert, everything flips except the platform under me (even the platform my partner is standing on will flip). If my partner inverts, everything flips except the platform under them.

  • What playtesters missed: Many didn't realize you can hold the button to preview/charge it with those platform particles, and the "everything except what I'm standing on" exception wasn't immediately obvious. Players also didn't understand that they can't invert while moving.

I could add a tutorial popup explaining the rules, but I'd much rather teach it through visual indicators, subtle hints, or level design. How would you communicate this clearly in-world so players figure it out naturally?

here is the link to my game on https://nicoleraskin.itch.io/invertus, feel free to try it out. The tutorial is a bit dumb (meant for xbox), but you can join as two players on the same keyboard, pressing the ~ button! There are instructions on the Itch Page.