r/gamedesign • • Feb 08 '24

Discussion Dark Souls Platforming Is Actually Genius And Why You're Wrong About It

4 Upvotes

It just occurred to me that the platforming in the Dark Souls series is actually genius. And I'll be the first to say I was one of the many who complained about their clunky jump and narrow platforms. But as I was replaying Lies of P it hit me that I was still viewing this through the lens of a gamer and not a developer. I was enjoying myself and yet my same self would have lambasted the game for its shitty platforming.

In decades past we just enjoyed games... or didn't. But in this modern era with months of hype leading up to a release, with broken promises and unfulfilled potential, early reviews and shitty journalism, etc we've become so analytical and pretentious that we remove the human element. We forget to feel in favor of just thinking. And we can over-analyze to the point of creating problems where there are none or miss out on things that the past generation of developers were well aware of.

The platforming isn't the point. It's not even meant to be good necessarily. It's the emotion that it elicits. A precarious drop, good positioning and careful movement, timing, etc. It is supplementative.

And it made me wonder how many other mechanics or perceived "antiquated" ideas we've lost across time. Most recently for me it was platforming in Lies of P, the mission structure of AC6, the stealth mechanic in Elden Ring, boss run backs in Dark Souls. Surely they possessed some merit? Right? I mean a designated jump button seems like a natural evolution. But what did we lose in the process?

Which is why I think revisiting old games, playing shitty but innovative indie games, and taking risks and making mistakes in our own work is so important.

What are some "antiquated ideas" you'd like to see brought back or re-evaluated? What areas did we go wrong in?

Edit: To those of you who read this and think "well I didnt enjoy it" you're missing the point. Consider re-reading and dropping your preconceived notions and you might find you agree with me


r/gamedesign • • Dec 02 '24

Discussion Do gamers have unrealistic expectations for games in today’s climate?

23 Upvotes

I hope this fits with the subreddit, I feel like it does.

Let me start by clarifying that I’m not talking about quality here. Some of the examples I’ll probably throw out will be of poor quality, but I am talking about the style or method of execution not how well it was done. That is a separate issue. OK, let’s get into the meat of things.

Something I have noticed over the past few years is what seems to be criticism of games regarding their mechanics and gameplay loop and often times I see some of these things being criticized, in my opinion, unjustly. For example, let’s take a game like Starfield. Don’t get me wrong. I think the game definitely needed improvement, but for the most part, I enjoyed it. To me, however, it seemed like the complaints regarding things like seamless takeoff and landing transitions, all of the computer generated planets, and even the POI’s seemed almost baseless to me. People were expecting a re-skin of Skyrim or fallout four and were surprised when it was a different game. It didn’t seem fair to complain about the lack of variation in POI’s considering nobody said it was gonna have the same map layout as their previous games. It’s a brand new series with new mechanics and a totally different setting, why should the game get shit on for not having Skyrim like dungeons, who said they were gonna have dungeons like that?

Another example from Bethesda (RIP their track record lately) being fallout 76. The complaints about the lack of NPC‘s seemed weird to me considering both the setting and the genre of game (MMO). Obviously things didn’t go right for them, and I’m sure that somewhat impacted their vision of how the world would feel, but I don’t feel like that justifies some of those complaints.

So I suppose the question becomes are gamers expecting too much from games unfairly? At what point does criticism go from valid to irrelevant? Are players of different genres starting to reach out to games outside of their sphere of influence and unfairly criticizing ones they don’t feel live up to their genres standards? Is it fair to have hard-core COD fans Tearing into the realism of Helldivers 2 gunplay? And at what point should we as developers start to listen/ignore these complaints and at what point should you start to change your game accordingly?

Looking at helldivers 2 there has long been somewhat of a rift in that community regarding people who see it as a horde shooter and those who see it as a tactical shooter. Well, they can be similar genres, and they can overlap. There is definitely points at which they can be incompatible. And it doesn’t make sense to listen to a horde shooter player, saying that the enemies are too hard to kill in a tactical game. And on the flipside it doesn’t make sense to listen to a tactical player saying why is the best option to just mow everything down in a horde shooter.

I’m not entirely sure what the point of this post is besides to just open up that discussion but that is something I have pondered for a few years now and I’m curious to see what everybody else thinks. Just remember those examples are not regarding the quality of the game. Don’t come at me, saying all the criticism of fallout 76 is valid because they had bugs on launch. That’s not the point of this post and that’s wrong.


r/gamedesign • • Aug 19 '23

Question Do BotW and TotK intentionally punish the player for upgrading stamina?

3 Upvotes

I noticed a thing in the two latest Zelda games.

When you completely run out of stamina, you cannot do any stamina-consuming actions (climbing, gliding) until your stamina fully recovers. This stays true when you upgrade it: if you have 3 times as much stamina and you accidentally run out of it, you have to wait 3 times as long before doing anything! Same applies to the battery mechanic from TotK.

In some sense this feels like punishment for upgrading: you increase the cost of your mistake and risk having more unfun downtime while waiting for stamina to recover. You could argue that the player still can move and perform many actions with no stamina, but chances are, if your stamina is depleted, climbing a wall was the thing you were trying to do at the moment.

Given how many affordances and quality-of-life features these games have, I believe this is done on purpose.

But how exactly does this contribute to the game design? Wouldn't it be less limiting and more fun to remove the "tired" status when your stamina reaches the "base" amount instead of the maximum amount?


r/gamedesign • • Mar 19 '26

Discussion Modern ranked matchmaking needs to accept reject based design.

0 Upvotes

In most ranked games, matchmaking is the system/algorithm which takes a global population of queued players and produce matches which maximize some or all of these properties:

  1. Players are evenly skilled

  2. Teams are evenly skilled

  3. Match discovery is fast

  4. Players have good ping/latency

  5. Role synergy

  6. Party size parity

These properties are chosen because, in general, competition among equally skilled players is the most exciting. Probably because a 50:50 odds yields the highest entropy of 1 Shannon bit, whereas once you get to 30:70 odds you lose about 0.12 bits of Shannon entropy or -12%.

In theory, the algorithm could wait until it finds what it thinks is a 50:50 but players might leave the game if the queue is too long. While 12% might be too much entropy loss, at 40:60 a game only experiences a -2.6% drop in entropy. This means matchmaking algorithms can trade off having to wait for players with choosing a less optimal game, so long as it’s within a reasonable bound.

While these 6 properties are sound and can be implemented, there seems to be a disconnect between the actual goal of the matchmaking system and what it does.

The purpose of a matchmaking system is to create games which are competitive for the player while also being enjoyable. While this does mean that rank Elo is on the line, what it doesn’t mean is that there is only one valid type of game.

Current matchmaking algorithms assume the only valid game is one which is close to a 50:50, completely neglecting the possibility for more interesting options.

For example, there may be a pool of players in the population which really want to play against a high ranked player, either because they want to improve faster or they are trying to improve their rank Elo. This player can’t decide to play against high ranked players. Let’s call this group A

Likewise, the is a pool of players which just want a win. They would want to play against low ranked players but they can’t because the system doesn’t recognize this preference. Let’s call this group B.

An ideal matchmaking system would match a team of A with a team B. Then reward and penalize weighted by the Elo as standard.

Likewise, a team of only a single role may be unfun to play against in general, but there are specific players who wouldn’t mind playing against that. This entire option is ruled out, sometimes intentionally by designers, but often unintentionally due to the matchmaking algorithms design.

This type of curated algorithm is possible, and is already deployed in other domains. Apps like TikTok, Uber, and tinder all leverage a reject based pipeline for determining what you prefer.

TikTok uses scrolling past a video as marker for rejection, Tinder lets users swipe left as rejection, and Uber allows drivers to decline rides.

Unlike all of these, most matchmaking systems penalize rejections intentionally, treating it as a laggard in the system. Games will give match making penalties if too many queued matches are declined.

Modern matchmaking should embrace rejection based match making. It will:

  1. Inform the algorithm for what matches are preferred.

  2. Improve quality of individual experience.

  3. Reduce queue times overall.

How would this be implemented?

At the UI/UX level, present the user with a match confirmation/decline window with two options. This window should include relevant information that allows the user to best align the game with their preferences, such as team/enemy rank distribution and Elo delta on win/loss, role preference, party size, and ping latency.

At a systems level, maintaining the original matchmaking algorithm maybe necessary to accommodate new players, which may not be aware of ranked nuances and might not understand declining a match. After sometime, relax this player from the original system onto the new system which explores/exploits player preferences. Potentially offering unbalanced games with the safe guard of a decline from a unsatisfied player.


r/gamedesign • • Mar 01 '25

Discussion Is This the Trend Happening in the Gaming Industry?

0 Upvotes

The gaming industry is reaching a point where maintaining AAA titles is becoming unsustainable. Large studios spend enormous budgets, leading shareholders and executives to push for games that will sell as widely as possible. Their directive is: "Make a cinematic game that appeals to the masses and sells in large numbers."

As a result, cinematic AAA titles are developed, and their promotional videos focus on mood, general story elements, and genre—presented in a way that resembles a movie rather than a game. This approach was initially thought to be effective. However, gamers quickly became aware of the overproduction of such cinematic games and grew disappointed, realizing that these titles were not truly designed to provide new gaming experiences.

Eventually, only those who enjoy cinematic, story-driven games continued purchasing AAA titles. As a result, studios struggled to recoup development costs, and the more they invested in production, the greater their financial risks became. This inevitably led to mass layoffs.

What does this mean? It shows that the audience for cinematic, story-driven games is only a fraction of the gaming market. Gamers care about the actual quality of gameplay and are becoming less inclined to buy repetitive, mass-produced titles in the same genre. Consequently, the strategy of "making games more cinematic to appeal to a broader audience" is backfiring, as many consumers turn away from such products. Those who enjoy cinematic games will still buy them, but those who have grown tired of the trend will look elsewhere.

Where do they go? Toward games that offer innovative mechanics and new gameplay experiences. This is why many players are shifting toward indie and AA games—they see them as more interesting because AAA titles have become predictable and unoriginal.

So, what should AAA studios do? They need to recognize that their market has shrunk. Instead of aiming for a broad audience, they must accurately assess the real demand for cinematic games and set realistic budgets that allow them to recoup costs and turn a profit. This means reevaluating market size and development costs. If necessary, they may even realize that maintaining excessively large studios is no longer viable and will need to downsize accordingly.

Right now, we are witnessing the beginning of this shift.


r/gamedesign • • Sep 22 '25

Question Why does every modern AAA game feel like they're built on the same framework?

0 Upvotes

It feels like there's only a formula with no experimentation. It's either live service, open world or a linear cinematic game. Not much else.


r/gamedesign • • Dec 06 '24 Take My Silver

Discussion The philosophy of the battling system of Pokémon was a game-changer when it came out

2 Upvotes

When Pokémon came out in 1996, it called itself an RPG, for lack of a better term. Pokémon is the only creature-capturing adventure I have ever known, but I have played other RPGs and I think I can propose an analyse of what made Pokémon alternative or disrupting at that time, compared to blockbusters like Final Fantasy or Secret of Mana.

So let’s get started with the Collection System,

since Pokémon was equipped with a Pokédex and an idea of Catching Them All, came the fact that every Enemy the player encounters should be able to become a friend at some point in the game, or, to give into the analogy to RPGs, a Hero. That’s a crucial point to oppose classic RPGs, because in RPGs you have a maximum of a dozen Heroes with their weaknesses and strengths, but a plethora of different Enemies and Bosses with very specific sets of Stats and Skills not at all accessible to the Heroes. The Bosses for example will oppose a challenge with a hundred or thousand-fold amount of HP, something one cannot imagine in Pokémon.

Second différence is, the Physical/Special split does not work in Pokémon like it does in other RPGs. In RPGs you have Classes for your Heroes, often defining their Attack and Intelligence Stats as well as presence or absence of Magic. Every non-Magic Move bears no damage modifier, in other words, every piece of Equipment a Hero can use as a Weapon will deal Normal Type damage until Enchanted by Magic. In Pokémon, the creatures don’t have access to Weapons (well duh) but use parts of their bodies (think Bite, Wing Attack, etc.), and certain of these Moves get a Type.

With Pokémon also comes mandatory defensive typing. I call it that because in classical RPGs, every Hero starts naked with the Normal-type, the only Weakness you can get to Magic or Elements are presented in form of trade-off from an equipment (ie. this Armor strenghtens your Fire Magic by 25% but makes you weak to Water magic by 25%), in Pokémon these Resistances and Weaknesses are built in the Types themselves, and there are very few Types to cover the whole roster of creatures, when you think about it. In comparison, Megami Tensei gets hundreds of Personas, Enemies and Bosses with each its very own set of Weaknesses, Resistances, Immunities, Drains and Repels.

And finally, you also have the fact that Defense and Offense must be symmetrical, there is not a single type that’s only used offensively. Add that to the 3 facts quoted above and you get yourself a terribly strict set of rules for the balancing.

Now I will also talk about the Types themselves. Because of the rules I defined above, every Pokémon would have to enter a category or Class. In RPGs you get Classes like Warrior, Clerk or Thief, in Pokémon the defensive typings are the Classes. And we will see Game Freak has done particularly well with the design of the typings. 

1/ Normal, Fighting and Ghost

Normal Type is our RPG hero. He’s bare and attacks with his tail or teeth . He gets destroyed by the Fighting Type because Fighting Type kicks ass. He is immune to Ghost Type because Normal Type and Ghost Type do not share the same realm, conversely Ghost Type is immune to Normal Type and Fighting Type, but weirdly enough, Fighting Type is not immune to Ghost Type, we're explaining why later. Also note, the Fighting Type can shatter Rock Type, Ice Type and Steel Type because all Fighting Types are really karate champions.

 2/ Fire, Water, Electric, Ground

Of all the Pokémon types, those are the ones that propose an experience closest to the usual RPGs, ie. Magic with the mastery of the Elements. It is funny Electric Type can fry a Flying Type bird, Fire Type can roast a Bug Type, but somewhat these things do not hit super-effectively the Normal Type, which is given to mammals. Fair enough to the comparison to RPGs: Heroes come with no specific damage multipliers in their defensive builds, as we mentioned earlier.

 3/ Ice, Rock

Ice Type and Rock Type are weirdos because in most games they would be merged with their close cousins Water Type and Ground Type, though other games also have an effective Ice/Water Magic split; just like Pokémon, or we also find games that have an Ice Magic without a Water Magic.

 4/ Grass

The Grass Type is weird in Pokémon because it has nothing in common with how grass is treated in other games featuring it (usually with some variation of Wood, or Mother Earth). This all comes to the Type's design philosophy where it becomes effective against Water Type because plants take nutrients from water, it is a shortcut because Water Type is given to fish Pokémon, but I have not seen a plant taking nutrients from a live fish in one split-second. Grass Type is also vulnerable to Flying Type and Bug Type because birds and insects eat plants and fruits, which makes sense if you imagine Bulbasaur is not a toad but a toad-like plant made of foliage, literally the same biology as a ripe peach.

5/ Flying, Bug, Water, Grass

These 4 Types are funny because they are systematically given to species who represent them, namely birds, insects, aquatic animals and plants. It puts them in opposition with mammals, who have nothing special and become Normal Type, unless... 

6/ Fighting, Psychic, Dark

This trio must be my favourite in Pokémon, because it certainly has the most influential Moves, Fighting Type Moves are all around in competitive, Psychic Type was Overpowered in Gen I and Dark Type was a welcome addition to balance it in Gen II. So to sum it up, Psychic Type represents the wise and powerful mind, the abstraction, the science; Fighting Type represents karate, good heart and training, which are highly valued in the Japanese society, and Dark Type was named "Bad Type" in Japanese, meaning really delinquents and other troublemakers or cheaters. So there you have it, Fighting Type chads always come to the help of Psychic Type nerds when they get bullied by Dark Types, even though Psychic Types can cause damage to them because of their large intellect.

 7/ Poison, Ghost, Dragon, Dark, Steel, Fairy

I made this grouping more as a leftovers, but these truly must be the wildest Types Pokémon has, if we compare them to classical RPG content. Poison and Ghost are usually limited to Status Effects to Inflict to the Hero (Poisoned or Cursed), but in Pokémon they have actual match-ups, again from their physical interactions: the Ghost Type scaring the nerd Psychic Type, or the Poison Type infecting the vegetal Grass Type and corrupting the Fairy Type. As for the Steel type, if it had been implemented in other RPGs, it would have merely been in the form of the weapons used by the Hero, or through the elusive Pierce, Slash and Strike Moves used in the Megami Tensei series. But no, in Pokémon it has a huge defensive use too, with multiple Resistances and Immunity from Poison. Dark, Steel and Fairy go into representation and abstraction. In my opinion, Dragon type can be tied to evil, power-hungry, unfathomable strength and fury (beats Dark Type at it, try me) and Fairy to holy, healing, God fighting against Demons. And Steel Type comes to represent the industry life (with Pokémon like Magneton, for example). Actually, Poison Types and Steel Types always make for great designs for Pokémons living in urban biomes. 

And that’s it, that’s my analyse of what makes Pokémon so special compared to other RPG adventures, and probably why Game Freak only felt compelled to add 3 new Types over the years as they balanced the Battling System. 

What would it be if we had a Chrono Trigger or a Secret of Mana with Heroes or Enemies replaced by Pokémon? How would it be if Megami Tensei used Pokémon invocations instead of divinities and folkloric figures? Discuss in the comments and I hope you enjoyed this as much as I enjoyed writing it!!!


r/gamedesign • • 22d ago

Discussion Is yugioh fixable?

0 Upvotes

It's not a card game where you outthink the foe during the match. It's a game where you set up an unbreakable board turn one from a single card combo starter designed to search anything and special summon half your deck and your foe surrenderd unless he got lucky and drew hand traps.

It's a game decided by luck except when it's decided by who bought better cards. They banned The Geriatric Sentry since 1996 and they still sold Kewl Tunes Bass Boosted Reverb Fart with the exact same effect plus ten more. The card is 1255 words long at .1 point font. World record.

Is it possible to fix the fundamental game design flaws of Yugioh or is it simply destined to always be this way?

Don't talk about what Konami might do, we know what they might do, they'll get worse. Instead say high IQ smart theoretical game design stuff, if you can.


r/gamedesign • • Aug 06 '26

Discussion Does Discord kill games with Proximity Chat?

1 Upvotes

Discord (and other online calling platforms) does a disservice to games with proximity chat being a core pillar of the game (in my opinion).

Don’t get me wrong. I love discord for gaming, but when games add in proximity chat as a core part of the experience, I think Discord voice chat can ruin that experience.

An example of this would be when my friends and I played REPO for the first time. They all were online for an hour or two before I got on and were all freely communicating via Discord and not utilizing the in-games proximity chat. I made the argument that I think it would be more fun if we muted each other while in-game and strictly did proximity chat. It instantly made the game far more intense and really made us lean into the walkie-talkies/radios in the game more and we had a blast doing it. Now that is the only way we play it because of how much fun we had.

For the sake of game design, I think having to talk to your allies in game rather than Discord in say an open world survival game or extraction shooter makes for a much more immersive overall experience. In only communicating through in-game, you now have to be cognoscente of your proximity to team mates, utilize radios and walkie talkies more, and makes the world feel more natural and immersive as you hear your own conversations reverb off the world around you. I think it can also make for a much more immersive experience for PVP because now people can overhear you and maybe hack into your radio chatter if they can use a device to pick up on the signal.

My overall question for this is would you play a game, that STRONGLY encourages you to use in-game proximity chat (kind of think like Arc Raiders when playing with random teammates)? Or would this turn you off to a game. Obviously you can always have on the push to talk features but then it takes away the need for communication devices and such.

I understand that just because I think it would be better, it doesn’t mean the overall player base would agree so I’d love your input on this topic! 😁


r/gamedesign • • Nov 11 '23

Discussion Hot Take: Almost Every Game That Uses "Leveling Up" As a Core Mechanic Is Doing It Wrong

0 Upvotes

And no, I'm not talking about level-scaling. That is an entirely different rant.

So, the standard trope, the standard design philosophy, in my experience, is this:

Your player controls a character or a party, and that character or those characters have a level, that level increases as a reward for doing the main gameplay thing, and increases in level grant, to a first approximation, quantitative increases in power, with occasional qualitative increases in power sprinkled in at arbitrary points but never so much that they disrupt the quantitative power curve.

And everything around you approximately matches you on that power curve.

I'm going to use World of Warcraft as an example here, because it is one of the most blatant and well-known examples: In World of Warcraft (before they just did level-scaling instead), each zone had everything in it in a very narrow range of levels. And the reason for this is because low-level entities and high-level entities were not merely mis-matched; there was an additional mechanic where anything more than a small level-difference would inflict exponential penalties. Anything ten levels below you would give you zero experience and, approximately, wouldn't be able to hit you, and anything 10 levels above you would be effectively infinitely above you in power. This was true even if the two entities 10 levels apart had the same combat stats.

This is a good example, because it demonstrates an enforced, purposeful example of an RPGlike game missing the point of Levels, which they eventually took to its logical conclusion of just level-scaling everything and making your Level truly meaningless.

What then, is the point of Levels?

It's exactly what you expect, exactly what it was originally imagined to be.

It's to quantify the power of your characters, of your party and their enemies, and create an explicit progression along a power curve.

If the level of a given piece of content is based on when it happens in the story and not on how digetically powerful that entity is relative to everything else in the story, then you don't have a measure of explicit progression along a power curve. You have a calendar.

Thank you for listening to my TED talk.

(Discussion I'm hoping for: Ideas for mechanics and balance tricks to make a game where a max level character can meaningfully interact with a 1st level character, a zone can have both 1st level content and max level content in a digetically satisfying way, and quest design for a world with fully digetic level-ups.)

(I have framed the-way-most-games-use-Levels in this way, as a problem, on purpose: I hope to generate discussion about how that problem might be solved, not discussion about how it isn't a problem or shouldn't be solved. If you feel like all is as it should be and I'm crazy for thinking otherwise, please, don't waste your time saying so.)


r/gamedesign • • Dec 01 '21

Discussion Do you even know what an "Idea" is?

0 Upvotes

Inspired by a recent post wherein the replies peddled out the sentiment "Ideas are a dime a dozen" in some or another form as though this is an adequate condemnation of the concept of "My idea was stolen", what are you calling an "Idea"? By following that thinking a bit it would lead to reason that there is nothing in terms of either quality or amount of detail that separates out ideas from one another in terms of being worth investigation and investment. Experiencing practicality shows this isn't remotely true: everything comes from an idea and certain ideas are worth lifetimes of dedication more than others; certain ideas are worth litigating for lifetimes in order to maintain this concept. Every game at some point was an idea, and the things that make up the game came from ideas as well.

To you who feel "ideas are a dime a dozen", as it pertains to game design, what do you mean? Is there something to qualifying the idea as "good"/"bad" "worth"/"worthless" or does that not matter because all ideas are just the same? What are you trying to say?


r/gamedesign • • Jun 22 '24

Discussion Would Elden ring have sold less... if it was easier?

0 Upvotes

Considering how Elden Ring have reached a quite frankly legendary status, with over 25 million sales, as well as having a total of two years in essentially a chokehold with its mere presence, there is no disputing that fromsoft and Elden Ring are massive successes.

And Miyazaki has come out in recent interviews, stating that he has no interest in making elden ring (or future games) easier for that matter, and as predicted, producing the usual discussion and argument regarding easier difficulties.

(My stance is that Fromsoft has no reason to change their approach in the slightest, considering huge sales, their fanbase loves it, the critics seem to love it and the devs are satisfied, so no reason to change that then, right?)

But what struck me, and made me consider...
Would Elden Ring have sold 25 million copies, if it had an easy mode?
It is the standard argument you hear from people that want an easier option, that so many more could play the game.

But a big part of Elden Ring's charm and reputation is reliant on their difficulty.
(Aka, the game is challenging, but at the same time it is as hard as you make it to be. You can grind as much as you want, you can explore as much as you want. If you are struggling, you can go and do something else and come back later, and have an easier time on average)
And reducing it / making the game more "approachable" could maybe reduce that view for the public, reducing the amount of talk and discussion about them.

Or am I wrong?
Would an easy difficulty mode have increased or decreased sales?


r/gamedesign • • Dec 01 '23

Discussion ENOUGH! Stop displaying "0%" when HP remain

0 Upvotes

OK. Look, I get it. Many times, when you're making your game, you have to decide how to display the damage and health and all that good stuff. And your combat system has characters who have thousands, heck, maybe even millions of hit points. But to make it easier on the eyes for the player, you make the game display those remaining HP as a % of the max HP, or a colorful little bar that fills or empties as current HP changes, or whatever. Great. Cute. That's fine.

HOWEVER when that HP gets down to less than 1%, the visual representation has got to switch from rounding properly to rounding improperly. There is nothing more maddening than a tough fight, where I take my opponent down to "0%" HP but he's still running around just fine, like nothing. Knock that off! The HP display has gotta stay at 1% until the guy is dead. I don't care if he has 1 HP out of 1,000,000,000,000 max HP, do not show me "0%" health. 0% means "none" it means "dead" it means "KO'ed" it does not mean "closer to 0% than 1%."

Yes, I know that's what it literally, actually, mathematically means. I know it's a rounding thing. I'm saying you have got to fudge it. Mess it up on purpose. Make it say "1%" from 1% until the actual 0%. Or let it be 0% but the whole number/bar flashes red, so that I can tell that my target is not actually dead even though the number/bar is showing that he has no HP remaining. I should not be getting the visual representation of Sub Zero being dead when he is not, in fact, dead, and is now uppercutting my character's head clean off of their body.

Thanks for hearing me out

EDIT: while looking the subject up in this sub, to see what had been discussed, I found this cool thread https://www.reddit.com/r/gamedesign/comments/6f53v8/hp_more_than_just_numbers/ and I don't think anyone ever came up with a good answer to the OP's question. Worth a look


r/gamedesign • • Sep 22 '23

Question why do games have stories that break the immersion? what's the design philosophy?

1 Upvotes

for example, skyrim, breath of the wild, and gta are examples of this.

in skyrim, the dragons are attacking and you have to save the town from the dragons!!

but if you decide to just go and collect cheesewheels nothing happens and the dragons just wait for you to kill them

in breath of the wild, you have to save hyrule from ganon before zelda's power can't hold him anymore!!

but if you decide to just go and throw chickens off cliffs and collect poop and go sailing, nothing happens and ganon just waits for you to kill him

in gta v, franklin always mentions how he wants to be a better person and "stop all that gangbanging"!!

but if you decide to just go ahead and steal cars and murder a prostitute, nothing happens and franklin will continuously say he's trying to be a better person

these always break the immersion for me as the storyline makes me want to rush through the game as fast as possible because the entire world is at stake or something, but then I skip through 80% of the games content. but if I just go ahead and actually enjoy the content of the game knowing the world is at stake while every NPC tells me that the end is nigh and nothing happens, it just utterly ruins the game altogether and ruins any immersion..

why do games do this?


r/gamedesign • • Sep 27 '24

Discussion The consequences of the Steam demo meta

0 Upvotes

With the demo meta on Steam being the new standard (with a whopping 3000+ demos slated to be in this upcoming Steam Next Fest), what does this mean for the state of game design?

To me, it seems like it will reduce the viability of smaller-scale linear narrative and storytelling games. It will likely also impact more experimental games which don't have an immediate hook, since capturing the audience's attention within the first 10 minutes (or less!) of a demo.


r/gamedesign • • Mar 14 '26

Discussion Why don’t we have RPGs that combine Souls combat with full co-op campaigns?

0 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about this lately.

Games like Elden Ring have incredible combat, while Baldur’s Gate 3 shows how amazing full co-op RPG campaigns can be.

But I don’t think we really have a game that combines both:

• Souls-like combat

• a huge RPG world

• a full co-op campaign for 3–4 players

It feels like a huge gap in the market.

Is there a technical reason this type of game doesn’t exist yet, or is it just that studios haven’t tried it?


r/gamedesign • • Mar 19 '26

Discussion What makes a level memorable by gameplay? Try the “level where...” test

2 Upvotes

If you can summarize a level as “the level where…”, it probably stuck.
ᅟ

Quick exercise (20 seconds)

Think of a level you still remember years later. You should be able to compress it into one sentence starting with: “The level where…”

Does this work for you?
ᅟ

A few memorable examples (gameplay-first)

● Super Mario Galaxy 2 — “A Stroll Down Rolling Lane”:
The level where you’re a rolling ball on a track, like a pinball / race minigame.

● Yoshi's Island — "2-1: Visit Koopa And Para-Koopa":
The level where you're stuck in a tetris-style game, avoiding being crushed.

● Super Mario Bros. 3 — “Giant Land” world:
The world where everything is giant. (fantasy)

ᅟ

Takeaways: Patterns from memorable levels

● Namability: A memorable level usually has a single and unique dominant idea you can name fast. That sentence is what sticks in the player's mind:

● Fantasy & Player story: The orchestration of mechanics and dynamics is thought to create a story: (“I’m a pinball racing ball”, “Everything is giant”, “Being a character inside a deadly tetris game")

● Memorable = Once: If two levels provide the same story, they may blend together in memory.

● Expectation break: They can also create a memorable moment, after a norm & codes has been established ("Everything is giant now"; "Mario Galaxy,but now there is a pinball racing game level")
ᅟ

⚠️ Small pitfall from personal experience:

● I've noticed in my game that providing levels that are too special too soon without having clearly established the core game, can confuse players about the game's identity.

● So now, I've put ~30 mins of classic levels first, before having level stories like "A labyrinth where you shift walls to make your way"
ᅟ

Your turn: share your “level where…”

Drop your gameplay-first most memorable level as:

  • Game — Level “The level where…”

  • Why it stuck (fantasy, twist, new dynamics, rule inversion, landmark moment, etc.)

And let's see which other patterns show up across different genres.
ᅟ

Bonus for you:

  • If you're making a game, write down the story of all your memorable levels. Notice the variety of experiences you provide to your player :)


r/gamedesign • • Feb 13 '25

Discussion Does gaming skill important for game designer?

4 Upvotes

People always said a good game designer would play 10 hrs of 10 game over 100 hrs on a single game, and I agree with that. And I also agree that being a good mechanic doesn’t make you a good driver.

I think every experiences you have are transferable to game design skill, so being good at gaming maybe not that critical for being good game designer

What do you think?


r/gamedesign • • Aug 11 '17

Discussion FPS Designers: A sniper rifle is just a rifle that is very accurate at long range. It's not a magic gun that does 100x the damage of a regular gun.

0 Upvotes

The point of a sniper rifle is that you can hit something from really far away. In almost every FPS, though, it's a miraculous super weapon that does several orders of magnitude more damage than normal guns, even heavy caliber weapons designed to puncture materials.

/rant


r/gamedesign • • Nov 20 '23

Discussion Which game has a great concept but a poor execution?

0 Upvotes

For me it’s Overwatch. I really like the team based online multiplayer idea, but there are some fundamental flaws in Overwatch’s execution:

  • First person and real time: this design decision means that players don’t know where or in what state their team mates are in, makes it harder to coordinate

  • Rando matchmaking: putting strangers together and expecting them to cooperate while giving them no tools to do so (Overwatch 2 did eventually get the signal system, or whatever it’s called)

  • Play of the game: celebrates individualism in a game about cooperating, wrong incentives

  • Bad management: too many to list

What’s a game you think has a great concept but poor execution?


r/gamedesign • • Nov 18 '25

Discussion I was thinking about how the Claire Obscure Expedition 33 team got together. Does it happen often that people randomly find eachother to create something absolutely beautiful? I wonder if I could one day join a game developing team. Either as a writer or style artist. I love video games.

0 Upvotes

I love video games and Expedition 33 ignited a spark, that I haven't felt for a while with video games. I just wonder sometimes, how it would be if I was a creator instead of a consumer.


r/gamedesign • • Apr 04 '15

Videogames Are Broken Toys

Thumbnail
keithburgun.net
2 Upvotes

r/gamedesign • • Sep 19 '24

Discussion The actual RPG character classes

0 Upvotes

We have the typical classes like "fighter" and "rogue" and "ranger", and we basically know what they do. But sometimes a ranger can do fighter things, and vice versa. And some classes fill more than one role, like how "paladins" are usually both fighters and healers. I want to boil down every character class niche to it's most basic element to make a "true" list of all character classes. Here's what I've come up with so far:

  • Melee combatant

  • Ranged combatant

  • Magic combatant

  • Sneaky combatant

  • Tank

  • Healer

  • Buffer

  • Debuffer

  • Summoner (includes classes with an animal companion)

  • Battlefield controller

  • Skill monkey

  • Item-user/crafter

  • Enemy ability-stealer (blue mages from FF)

And that's all I can think of. Are there any other roles for RPG classes that I'm missing?

And bear in mind these are "niches". Tanks are often also melee combatants, but dealing damage and taking hits so that the rest of the party doesn't have to are technically two different roles.


r/gamedesign • • Dec 19 '22

Discussion What is the psychology behind Lego’s?

7 Upvotes

I always thought that games are about creating an experience of flow, and that flow is created by having a goal, a challenge and clear feedback. But lego’s does not seem to have a real challenge in the same way that most games have. So what makes lego’s so fun?