r/gallifrey • • 1d ago

Free Talk Friday /r/Gallifrey's Free Talk Fridays - Practically Only Irrelevant Notions Tackled Less Educationally, Sharply & Skilfully - Conservative, Repetitive, Abysmal Prose - 2026-11-20

9 Upvotes

Talk about whatever you want in this regular thread! Just brought some cereal? Awesome. Just ran 5 miles? Epic! Just watched Fantastic Four and recommended it to all your friends? Atta boy. Wanna bitch about Supergirl's pilot being crap? Sweet. Just walked into your Dad and his dog having some "personal time" while your sister sends snapchats of her handstands to her boyfriend leaving you in a state of perpetual confusion? Please tell us more.


Please remember that future spoilers must be tagged.


Regular Posts Schedule


r/gallifrey • • Dec 14 '25

SPOILERS The War Between the Land and the Sea 1x05 "The End of the War" Trailer and Speculation Thread Spoiler

21 Upvotes

This is the thread for all the thoughts, speculation, and comments on the trailers. if there are any, and speculation about the next episode.

YouTube Link will be added if/when available


Megathreads:

  • Live and Immediate Reactions Discussion Thread - Posted around 20 minutes prior to initial release - for all the reactions, crack-pot theories, quoting, crazy exclamations, pictures, throwaway and other one-liners.

  • Trailer and Speculation Discussion Thread - Posted when the trailer is released - For all the thoughts, speculation, and comments on the trailers and speculation about the next episode. Future content beyond the next episode should still be marked.

  • Post-Episode Discussion Thread - Posted around 30 minutes after to allow it to sink in - This is for all your indepth opinions, comments, etc about the episode.

These will be linked as they go up. If we feel your post belongs in a (different) megathread, it'll be removed and redirected there.


Want to chat about it live with other people? Join our Discord here!


What did YOU think of The Witch of the Waterfall?

Click here and add your score (e.g. TWBTLATS_04 (The Witch of the Waterfall): 8, it should look like this) and hit send. Scores are designed to match the Doctor Who Magazine system; whole numbers between 1 to 10, inclusive. (0 is used to mark an episode unwatched.)

Voting opens once the episode is over to prevent vote abuse. You should get a response within a few minutes. If you do not get a confirmation response, your scores are not counted. It may take up to several hours for the bot (i.e. it crashed or is being debugged) so give it a little while. If still down, please let us know!

See the full results of the polls so far, covering the entire main show, here.

The Witch of the Waterfall's score will be revealed next Sunday. Click here to vote for all of RTD2 era so far. Click here to vote for all of The War Between the Land and the Sea so far.


r/gallifrey • • 13h ago

DISCUSSION Doctor Who needs to get more Cosmic, more Sci-fi, and move on from RTDs overly earth/human bound approach.

118 Upvotes

Let's have less Eastenders with a side order of Sci-fi and let's actually get a proper full blood Sci-fi show that actually goes out into the universe and plays with alien worlds and alien societies, and visiting them in different times and how time changes these worlds.

Nu-who has never fully shaken off the RTD approach, to its detriment. It's not the 2000s anymore, we don't need to spend half the season on a council estate or some other mundane setting.

Pretty much every show out there is set on Earth, DW is one of the few shows that can leave it, so do so often.

Stop using the excuse of 'it's got to be relatable to the audience' for your lack of imagination to do alien characters and worlds.

Again it's not the 2000s anymore, audiences have shown they will get into alien characters and worlds, the Avatar films are​ some of the most successful films around and they are set on a alien world, and one of the most successful and loved films of this year, Project Hail Mary, was about the friendship formed between a guy and a rock alien, and look at how characters like Rocket, Groot, Chewbacca are loved by audiences..

People will care about alien characters, even very non human ones, if you do the work of making the audience care, if you have imagination, ambition and good writing to pull it off.. And DW should be aiming for that.

So let's see more alien worlds, more alien societies, mixed in with stories set throughout Earth's history..

And when we go to alien worlds it should have alien societies there not just always a human colony, like the RTD approach, humans should not be everywhere in time and space, it makes the DW universe feel tiny, it makes the Tardis less magical and special (as humans have just got everywhere it goes anyway) ​​and it's simply unimaginative, there should be stories where the only human in it is the companion, and we connect and experience the alien environment through the companion.

Actually live up to the shows concept and potential, rather than taking such a open sandbox and spending most of your time around modern day Earth.

And no the budget doesn't stop this, before anyone says. It's not difficult to make a landscape look alien, a simple cgi rings going around the sky will sell the idea that the mountain you are on is a mountain on a alien world, simple colour manipulations of the environment can sell the landscape as being alien, there are lots of things that can be done (especially in this day and age with the tech we have), so there is no excuses, it just takes imagination and ambition to do it.

​​​I hope the next era has more imagination and ambition, and doesn't just continue the RTD limited view on what the show can be (which is basically Torchwood with a few episodes set in Victorian London)


r/gallifrey • • 8h ago

DISCUSSION Good full length novels?

4 Upvotes

I've recently picked up the key to time collection and am having a great time with it. This has made me think if there's been other good novels. Not the target collection, I like those but I'm thinking about things that embellish on the original format either with classic or new stories, so they become greater than what is shown on screen. I mostly interested in the classic era but I would also read stories from 9 and 10


r/gallifrey • • 1d ago

REVIEW Here We Go Again – Deep Breath Review

25 Upvotes

This post is part of a series of reviews. To see them all, click here.

Historical information found on Shannon Sullivan's Doctor Who website (relevant page here) and the TARDIS Wiki (relevant page here). Primary/secondary source material can be found in the source sections of Sullivan's website, and rarely as inline citations on the TARDIS Wiki.

Story Information

  • Episode: Series 8, Episode 1

  • Airdate: 23rd August 2014

  • Doctors: 11th, 12th (Peter Capaldi)

  • Companion: Clara

  • Other Notable Characters: Vastra, Jenny, Strax, Courtney Woods (Ellis George), Missy (Michelle Gomez)

  • Writer: Steven Moffat

  • Director: Ben Wheatley

  • Showrunner: Steven Moffat

Review

Look, it's covered in lines. But I didn't do the frowning. Who frowned me this face? – The Doctor

I remember, back in 2014, feeling pretty down about Doctor Who. While my interest in the show had been maintained thanks to a rewatch and starting what would become my first full watch-through of the Classic era, Series 7B and "The Time of the Doctor" had left me somewhat resigned to the possibility that Doctor Who was just a bad show now. Due to starting off a new Doctor's era, plus the fact that I really was enjoying what I was watching from the Classic series, I was committed to at least giving Series 8 a shot, but, concerningly for someone who had only been watching the show for about a year and a half, I wasn't feeling optimistic.

Okay. Let's not panic just yet. Deep breath everyone. (I have been holding onto the opening to this review for years).

A big part of what made me want to commit to watching Series 8, aside from being immersed in the show thanks to William Hartnell and Patrick Troughton's runs, was "The Eleventh Hour". Knowing that Steven Moffat's last attempt at a new Doctor episode had been so good left a lot of reason for hope. But "Deep Breath" is not trying to replicate the success of "The Eleventh Hour" though, in spite of a single reference. In some ways, with "The Eleventh Hour", Steven Moffat played it safe. Knowing that he had no recurring cast members to fall back on, Moffat took a lot of care to ensure that fans would accept Matt Smith as the new Doctor. By contrast "Deep Breath" seems to want fans to consider rejecting Peter Capaldi's Doctor, so that it can talk them back around by the end of the episode.

It's a risky move. Arguably it was unsuccessful, given how much the fanbase reacted against the 12th Doctor from the jump. Still, to this day you'll see the argument that in Series 8 the 12th Doctor was too much of a jerk, and a large part of that must come from how "Deep Breath" handles its introduction of the new Doctor. But this is my review series which means it's written with my biases so, I absolutely love this introduction. On the surface level…I like grumps. I think grumpy characters are fun. But there's a better reason than that why I like this Doctor straight away. And given what Vastra says about this new Doctor it kind of makes sense that I would.

I spent a lot of space in my 11th Doctor retrospective describing Matt Smith's Doctor as a collection of masks that the Doctor put on, both for other people and for himself. And "Deep Breath" sort of acknowledges that via an angry rant from Vastra to Clara. In it she refers to the 11th Doctor's youthful exterior as a veil, comparing it to her own veil that she wears to deal with being a lizard woman living in Victorian London. I'll go more into that later, but the important part is, as the 11th Doctor became the 12th, as the old man stopped pretending to be young "the veil lifted". The Doctor has stopped trying to pretend. Or maybe, the Doctor has decided to try to stop pretending. In either case, we go from a Doctor defined by the tendency towards lying to a Doctor who will tell you the unvarnished truth, even if it hurts your feelings.

And yes, this new Doctor is a bit grumpy. He complains about the concept of a bedroom, he complains that it's cold outside, he complains that he can't tell Clara and Strax apart because they're "very similar heights", he even manages to complain that everyone around him has an English accent (because he's Scottish now you see). Early on, it's actually largely played for a joke. It's also used to create a distance between him and Clara, but we'll get to her later. As the episode advances, we start getting more of the Doctor being a bit of a jerk. He calls the entire population of Earth "pudding brains", he tries to bully a homeless man into giving him his coat (though later the Doctor buys the coat off of the man with his watch), and refers to Clara as an "egomaniac needy game player". The further into the episode we get, an obvious question starts bubbling up: is this Doctor just an asshole now?

Well yes. Sort of. One of the core distinctions that will become important to the 12th Doctor era is the nice vs. kind distinction. The 12th Doctor, as presented here is definitely not nice. But he is kind, in his own way. He speaks his mind, always, sometimes to his detriment. Having accidentally brought a giant Tyrannosaurus Rex to Victorian London, the Doctor earnestly promises to bring her home, and seems to have genuine empathy with the massive beast. Sure he seems to abandon Clara, but he actually stays close to her, and seems to have known that she'd have backup all along. The key moment comes late in the episode, when he asks the villain of the episode, generally referred to as the half-faced man, "what do you think of the view", that is being seen by the pair from, essentially, a hot air balloon. When the half-faced man eventually admits he thinks the view is "beautiful", the Doctor disagrees. He doesn't like seeing things from far away. He prefers to be in the middle of the humans. Sure he might call them pudding brains, but the Doctor still loves humanity, and loves to be among them.

And if the 12th Doctor acts like a bit of a jerk, part of it is that he thinks he knows so much more than everyone else. That kind of certainty is a bit of a double-edged sword though. On one hand he is often right. But it only makes it harder for him to work with his friends, and he's actually not always right. Vastra, as always, understands the Doctor better than he does. And most notably, the Doctor twice mistakes the source of a mysterious note left in a newspaper, first thinking it was from Clara (while she thought it was from him), then later from the half-faced man. And on a related note, someone planted a note that completely fooled this great intellect, which he eventually realizes must have come from the mysterious woman in the shop that got Clara to phone the TARDIS in "The Bells of Saint John". This is, of course, setting up stuff for future episodes to explore. But this woman must have been one hell of a mastermind to have so completely fooled the Doctor not once but twice.

So how is the audience supposed to take all of this? I think we're supposed to be unsure of the new Doctor for most of the episode's runtime, the height of that probably coming when he seems to abandon Clara after his curiosity and confusion gets the better of him. After that point, the approach the episode takes towards presenting the 12th Doctor seems to fundamentally change. First he returns in a cool sequence where he actually pulls a mold of Matt Smith's face off of his own (not that you'd recognize it, for more see "Stray Observations"). This reveals that the Doctor was in the room throughout the previous sequence where Clara was in a pretty scary situation (you can actually see him hanging around in the background of a few shots), and then he subsequently reveals that he knew that Clara had the ability to call in backup in the form of the Paternoster Gang anytime she wanted. A series of scenes between the Doctor and the half-faced man (more on those later) do lead to the question of whether the Doctor straight up murdered the sentient droid, but also give us a lot of moments to feel sympathetic towards him. And, just in case the audience isn't fully on board, a cameo appearance from Matt Smith is entirely designed to make sure that we remember that this is, technically, still the same Doctor. How effective is this? Well it works real well on me. Then again, I found myself so fascinated by this new take on the Doctor when first watching the episode that I was an easy convert. Again, I have to point the the fact that a lot of the audience never seemed to fully warm up to Peter Capaldi's Doctor, suggesting that the harsher Doctor was always going to be a tough sell, no matter how hard the episode works to get people on board. But, as I said before, this is my review series, and I find this take on the Doctor so interesting from the outset, that I can't help but be positive towards it.

Focusing more on this episode's plot though, the giant dinosaur in the Thames is more of a fun bit for the cold open. Instead the plot properly kicks off when the dinosaur is burnt to death, and Vastra realizes, with the Doctor's prompting, that this isn't even the first time someone's been killed in that way. There have been several cases of supposed spontaneous human combustion throughout the city. Thanks to solving a puzzle designed to bring the pair together, Clara and the Doctor meet up at a small family restaurant…which turns out to be built on top of a time traveling spaceship called the Marie Antoinette…sister ship to the Madame de Pompadour. Yes, it turns out that the same thing that happened to the repair droids back in "The Girl in the Fireplace" has happened on this ship as well, only things have gotten far more out of hand, though the Doctor never quite makes the connection. The half-faced man is the sort of lead repair droid who, like the ones in "Fireplace" operates off of a clockwork base, an aesthetic that works just as well in Victorian London as it did in 18th Century France. That callback to "Fireplace" is honestly fairly minimal though, feeling like it's more there because Steven Moffat wanted to revisit the idea. Indeed one of the discarded ideas from "Fireplace", that the clockwork droids would wear real human faces to disguise themselves, ends up making its way into this episode.

What really stands out though is the half-faced man I've referenced multiple times. And that's for one reason: he's developing personhood. At one point, after Clara calls him a cyborg, the Doctor corrects her: "this isn't a man turning himself into a robot. This is a robot turning himself into a man piece by piece". While at that moment that's only referencing the various human parts that the half-faced man has grafted onto himself, it later becomes true that this is true of the half-faced man himself. The rest of the droids remain purely robots who've simply put on human disguises as camouflage. But the half-faced man different. He has personality, a reasoning ability that goes beyond that of a simple computer (or, if I may, a modern LLM), and a flair for the dramatic. When the Doctor asks him about the view, as mentioned above, he initially dismisses the question as a simple droid might, before admitting he thinks it's beautiful. Perhaps oddest of all, he has a goal beyond simple survival (which, incidentally, completes the framing of this guy as the reverse of a Cyberman, not that it's necessarily intentional). That goal is simple: he wants to reach "the promised land". Where he got such an idea in his head is not made clear in this episode, but the idea of a repair droid seeking heaven feels so incongruous that it demands that we take his personhood seriously.

This is all centered on drawing a comparison between the half-faced man and the Doctor. This is made clearest when the Doctor compares him to the ship of Theseus (technically he references a broom) and holds up a reflective tray saying "you probably don't know where you got that face from", which echoes the Doctor's questions about where he got his own face from, the comparison made even more obvious when it's shown the Doctor can see his own face reflected back at him. The Doctor also says that he too is searching for his own "promised land", presumably referring to Gallifrey. And to that point, just as the half-faced man builds himself an identity to find the promised land, the Doctor has been rebuilding himself, even if he never expects to find his promised land.

This comparison comes to a head with a simple revelation: the half-faced man doesn't actually want to continue. The Doctor works this out on his own. The half-faced man is tired of living and maybe, just maybe, is developing a bit of pity for the humans that he's killing to keep himself and the other droids operational. He's ready to die. Him dying would not only spare any other Londoners from being broken down for spare parts, but also in the more immediate term, save Clara and the Paternoster Gang who are fighting a losing battle against the clockwork droids. Just one problem: "self-destruction is against my basic programming". "And murder," says the Doctor, "is against mine". Of course we learn later that one of them lied about their basic programming. And given that the half-faced man is next seen impaled on a clocktower, that has to be true. But we never learn if the Doctor killed the half-faced man or he jumped. I have my own viewpoint on the matter, I know which one I find more satisfying both for the story that's being told and for the story that will be told with the 12th Doctor as a whole. But I would rather not say what that is. Because the point is very much in the ambiguity. The point is that just as we are still unsure of the new Doctor, we are unsure as to what he did, or did not do.

The person who is most unsure of the new Doctor in this story though is Clara. From a functional point of view, this makes sense. The companion has regularly been used as audience surrogate during a regeneration, most recently done with Rose in "The Christmas Invasion". It's a tried and true method because it works. And seeing as much of "Deep Breath" is designed to make the audience unsure of the new Doctor, it makes sense to have our companion outright reject him up until the end of the episode. For much of this episode she has difficulty even acknowledging that the angry white-haired Scotsman is still the Doctor. The issue is that Clara is better primed to accept a new Doctor than any prior companion. Frankly, it feels very much like the Impossible Girl storyline is largely forgotten after its completion in "The Name of the Doctor". To be sure, it gets referenced here, but that's a token reference. Now I do think you can make sense of this. Clara got very attached to the 11th Doctor during their time together, and Twelve is a very different, and much harsher take on the character. But, again, Clara was primed to accept this. She has personal experience of all the Doctors, including the rude ones (1st, 3rd, 6th, 9th…we had a weird thing going with the multiples of three for a while). Now, you could argue that we don't know how much Clara remembers of that, and that is fair. I think Clara's reaction to the 12th Doctor is certainly plausible. But she also feels like the least likely companion to have that particular reaction.

Which isn't to say I don't like what was done with Clara here. To the contrary, I think a lot of the writing for Clara is excellent. To this point, the character development that Clara had gotten all felt very shallow, as though the show was reluctant to let us get to know this character on a deeper level. That changes here. And the way in which Clara is unsure of the Doctor does feed into that. Clara becomes a lot messier in this episode. There's a scene where Vastra puts her on the spot and confronts her with the way she's treated the new Doctor to this point, suggesting that she only liked the pretty younger Doctor. Clara absolutely explodes at Vastra and it is honestly the first scene where Clara felt like a fully-formed human being to me. Something about the indignation of this monologue just struck a chord with me. It's not even that she's entirely telling the truth. I do think Clara held some attraction for the 11th Doctor and that was part of why she liked him. But even that feels very real to me. And it's appropriate, as this monologue is Clara insisting that she does have substance. Later on, she performs the classic "you answer my questions and I'll answer yours" interrogation technique, but the way she does it feels so significant. Starting with a memory from her first day teaching, Clara acknowledges her fear out loud but pushes through it to extract a lot more information than she ever gives.

Throughout the episode the 12th Doctor and Clara bicker, and challenge each other and the way that they do so feels so much more like a real friendship than anything we saw with Clara and Eleven. This even as Clara is unsure she can trust the Doctor is anymore, and even as she's "not sure who [he is] anymore". What changes this is the phone call from the 11th Doctor. Or more specifically the conversation that comes out of it. This is a clever bit of writing from Moffat, who brings back the 11th Doctor for one last monologue, and has him almost, but not quite get through to Clara. I'm not sure if I would have brought Smith back for this, given the risk of him overshadowing Capaldi, and to some extent I would argue that he does. But the smart thing that Moffat does is let the 12th Doctor be the one who actually convinces Clara that he's still the same person. The genuine hurt in Capaldi's voice as he tells her, "you look at me and you can't see me. Have you any idea what that's like?" seals the deal. And you can really see Clara take a good look at the 12th Doctor and see him, for the first time, as the Doctor.

Oh and the Paternoster Gang are back for what would become their final appearance. And since they've always been great, it's no surprise that they're great here again. For once it's Strax who gets the least characterization. Strax is only used for comedy here, but that comedy really lands. Especially him slipping back into "old habits" by planning to melt the Doctor with acid, only to quickly correct himself. And if there's something to be taken from Strax in this episode it's that he finally feels like he's found himself. In past Paternoster Gang episodes there was a feeling that Strax was holding onto his Sontaran programming a bit. But, while he does periodically slip into "old habits" and definitely doesn't fully understand human customs, he also feels as comfortable with himself as we've ever seen him. This is the happiest we've ever seen Strax, and that's just neat.

Jenny, meanwhile, really surprised me here. Jenny's always been the member of the Paternoster trio who's gotten the least material, because the human maid/ninja is still less interesting than the Sontaran and Silurian trying to make their way in Victorian London. But in this episode Jenny gets a lot more to do. The scene that most obviously stands out is Clara trying to get Jenny to relate to her situation by asking "If Vastra changed, if she was different, if she wasn't the person that you liked?". Jenny's response of "I don't like her, ma'am. I love her. And as to different…well, she's a lizard," is not only perfectly written, but Catrin Stewart delivers the line in a way that completely convinces you that she's speaking of the love of her life. And Jenny's just really endearing throughout this thing. After Clara's big blowup at Vastra, she explodes into applause. Her annoyance at being asked to pose when it turns out Vastra wasn't actually painting fills out the contours of that relationship surprisingly well. Jenny feels like she's a mirror to Clara in this episode in way. She has a relationship that is odd, and not just because Vastra is "a lizard". Vastra can be difficult, but the two have made it work, and Jenny is completely at peace with herself and her relationship…though the pretense of being a maid does clearly annoy her. But even that feels like it's saying something. A reminder that we're in the repressive Victorian era and that Jenny, as a lesbian, has to navigate the extreme limitations that that imposes on her.

But as always, Vastra gets the most depth. She's always been a character that understands the Doctor far better than most, and in this episode we get a sense as to why. There's a shared sense of loss, sure, but more than that, she understands what it is to be out of place. "I wear a veil" she says, "for the same reason he wore a face (…) to be accepted". That desire to be accepted by people who will never fully understand you, because no matter how long you live among them you'll never quite be one of them, that is what connects the Doctor and Vastra. In the past I've mused about why Vastra's poetic language works so well for me when so many other Moffat-written characters fall flat in similar dialogue styles. I've offered a few explanations, but since this will be my last opportunity to offer one up, this might as well be my definitive word on the subject: it works because Vastra has legitimate depths to draw on, depths that mark her as similar to the Doctor. She's lost her entire species. She's forced to view humanity, the people she lives among, as an outsider first and foremost, and that's before the part where she's a lesbian in the Victorian era. For the same reasons that I buy her understanding the Doctor so well, I buy that she has grand thoughts to offer on any number of topics. I buy that she is able to manipulate Clara into giving the Doctor a second chance, and I believe that she understands what the Doctor is going through better than he does himself. And I believe that when she notices that Clara has returned to her modern dress after being in Victorian attire for the majority of the episode, she is able to understand that as Clara subconsciously preparing for her return home. And most importantly, I buy that she knows that Clara is right, even more than I believe that Clara is right.

Through much of Series 7B, the Paternoster Gang were the best part of mediocre to bad episodes. Here though, they're a really good part of a great episode. But let me be clear: this is best they've been characterized. And I love all three of them. As for the episode itself, it takes a lot of big risks. But for my money, it hits on most of them. I understand that your mileage may vary on some of this, hell I even understand why. But I love how this episode handles its new Doctor. How seriously it takes the idea of someone becoming a whole new person who is still at their core the same person. And, while I've not found much time to talk about it, this is a really funny episode through it all. The banter between all of our leads is tremendous. Clara is finally finding her voice, and part of that is that her humor connects better. And that would be all, right? A great episode all around, and a strong start to both Series 8 and the 12th Doctor era.

Except there's one last thing that happens. The half-faced man awakens after having died. And a woman called Missy, who seems to think she's the Doctor's girlfriend, tells him he's arrived the Promised Land. I smell the beginnings of the series' arc…

Score: 8/10

Stray Observations

  • Steven Moffat and Peter Capaldi worked together to devise the 12th Doctor's personality. Moffat wanted to draw contrast between the 11th Doctor and the 12th, by giving the 12th Doctor a sharp edge as compared to the 11th Doctor's more whimsical exterior. Capaldi wanted the 12th Doctor to hew more closely to his own personality.

  • There was some conversation about having Capaldi use an accent other than his natural Glaswegian brogue, but this seems to have been dropped pretty quickly.

  • As the TARDIS Wiki notes, this is the first time a new Doctor episode has been set in Earth's past. Actually, the Wiki unnecessarily qualifies this twice: the first time by mention post-regeneration stories (sure, most of An Unearthly Child was set in the past, but the first episode of that was set in the then-present day of 1963, while "Rose" was set in the then-present day of 2005), and secondly by mentioning "pseudo-historicals" (no new Doctor episode has been a true historical either).

  • That is, unless you want to count "The Eleventh Hour", where the majority of the action was set in 2008 despite airing in 2010. Personally, I don't think that actually counts.

  • By (as far as I know) sheer coincidence, this episode aired on the 23rd of August, the same date as the eruption of Mount Vesuvius, the setting for "The Fires of Pompeii", which was of course the last time Peter Capaldi appeared in Doctor Who.

  • The Doctor not remembering the clockwork droids from "The Girl in the Fireplace" was inspired by Columbo, where the title character would often not react to references to his own past cases.

  • Missy would originally have gone by the nicknamed "Misty" instead. She was also originally imagined to be younger.

  • Vastra, referencing the T-Rex who is roughly the size of Big Ben, claims "dinosaurs were mostly this size". Maybe that's true in the Doctor Who universe, but there's simply no way that true in ours. Setting aside the nebulousness of the term "dinosaurs" (technically, a hummingbird is a dinosaur), I'm pretty positive that something the size that we see would run afoul of the square cube law, and that's before we worry about how she would find enough food. And if there were a significant quantity of T-Rexes around 315 feet tall (as opposed to the 40 feet or so of the fossils we actually have), we'd be more likely to find their bones, not less. Notably, she later refers to it as a "giant dinosaur" indicating she may have been kidding.

  • The whole sequence with the dinosaur was actually the first thing Steven Moffat conceived of, figuring he could work whatever plot he actually came up with around it. This probably explains why the dinosaur, despite being a memorable beginning, doesn't actually figure much into the episode past the cold open.

  • After learning that the Doctor just regenerated, Vastra says, "well then, here we go again". Obviously this references the Brigadier saying the same line as the Doctor is regenerating in Planet of the Spiders. I don't think more was meant to be implied by this, but the implications are nonetheless fascinating. Specifically, it implies that Vastra has some experience of regeneration. She could have met another Time Lord I suppose, but that honestly seems fairly unlikely. So failing that, this implies she's seen the Doctor regenerate before. The thing is, the options here are pretty limited. Basically it can only be after the War Doctor regenerated in to the 9th, or maybe the 8th Doctor into the War Doctor, though that too seems unlikely. Given what we know about how the Doctor and Vastra first met, that she was in the London Underground taking revenge for the deaths of her family on innocent humans, I actually really like the idea that that took place immediately after the 9th Doctor was born. Those two dealing with their traumas and losses together makes a lot of sense to me.

  • New Doctor, new title sequence. This visuals for this one were designed by Billy Hanshaw, based off of a mock up title sequence he had made for YouTube. Steven Moffat loved it (as did I when it first came out), calling it "the only new title idea [he'd] seen since 1963". And yes, it's great. The cogs and gears leading into the spiraling clock is a great look, and I even dig this version of the time vortex. The biggest change from the YouTube version to the TV one is that instead of the Doctor's face appearing on a fob watch, just his eyes appear at the end, which works great to accentuate Peter Capaldi's very prominent eyebrows. It's just a well made intro that suits the 12th Doctor perfectly.

  • As for the theme…yeesh. I will say it's grown on me a little, but I kind of suspect that's because I associate it with an era of the show I love more than the theme being better than I initially thought. The base line is perfectly fine, but the melody is this high-pitched shriek that's just really hard to listen to. That only gets accentuated because this is a much more stripped down version of the theme than Murray Gold's past versions, meaning that the melody line sticks out more.

  • One of the big criticisms this intro got was that the visuals and the theme weren't consistently synced the same way, and various other small inconsistencies. Honestly, other than the extreme situations (the logo should appear with the descending part of the melody, it just works so well) this was never something that really bugged me too much.

  • There's a bit where the Doctor is getting annoyed at everybody's English accents, and Vastra puts on a Scottish accent to help soothe him. This was Neve McIntosh doing her natural accent for a change.

  • Jenny tells Clara "the…wife doesn't like to be kept waiting". The pause before she said "wife" struck me as interesting. Like she's used to maintaining the pretense of a mistress/maid relationship, and has to remind herself that she's with someone who she can be open with about the reality of her relationship with Vastra. Sets up the next scene with Clara and Vastra quite well.

  • Strax manages to throw a newspaper to an upstairs window with such force that it knocks Clara off her feet on impact. Sometimes you forget it with Strax, but Sontarans are strong.

  • Jenny mentions that they've recruited a group called the "Paternoster irregulars" out looking for the Doctor. This is obviously a reference to Sherlock Holmes' group of street urchins who gather intelligence for him, referred to as the "Baker Street irregulars". What's interesting is that in spite of Vastra supposedly inspiring Sherlock Holmes in universe, there are surprisingly few direct references to the Holmes mythos used in the television appearances of the Paternoster gang. This episode might contain the most direct ones, aside from the Doctor literally cosplaying as Sherlock Holmes in "The Snowmen". Later Vastra straight up says "the game is afoot".

  • Jenny also makes it clear that Vastra eats some of the more evil villains that she investigates. It's played as a joke. And, admittedly, I do think it's funny but at the same time…yikes.

  • The Doctor describes the person who left the note in the newspaper as an "egomaniac needy gameplayer sort of person". While we don't get confirmation on who actually left the note in the newspaper, only that it was neither Clara nor the Doctor, given what we'll learn about them later, this is actually a remarkably accurate diagnosis.

  • The girl who tells Clara "go on then, do it" in a flashback was originally just going to be an anonymous student. However, when later episode "The Caretaker" introduced a troublesome girl called Courtney Woods, Steven Moffat decided to have her be the one to set up the line, establishing her character early.

  • The Doctor disguises himself as a droid using a face. The cast of the face used…was that of Matt Smith's. And the weirdest part is, for something that feels like it could only be intentional, it was a complete accident. In the first take, the face of the waiter seen in an earlier scene was used, but it broke, causing the production team to have to grab a spare mask, and the one they grabbed just happened to be a cast of Matt Smith's face. Actually nuts.

  • The Doctor describes the Half-Faced Man as follows: "there's more human in you than machine". This feels like an intentional inversion of the Star Wars quote, "he's more machine now than man", referring to Vader.

  • So at one point we hear Vastra and Jenny talking to each other…without actually talking. Do they have a psychic bond? Are they understanding each other through facial expressions? Weird stuff.

  • This leads to Vastra sharing the oxygen she stores in her lungs with Jenny, that presumably being a Silurian ability. This "sharing" looks awfully like a kiss.

  • New TARDIS interior…kind of. The basics of the Series 7B interior remain the same, but now the Doctor has moved in a bunch of bookshelves, as well as a reading chair. It's a basic change, but it really does tie the room together. It feels a bit like the cozy feeling that the TV Movie console room was going for, but the room feels a lot more cohesive (which, yes, I've never been the biggest fan of the movie console room, unpopular opinion I know).

  • Oh and of course, we get new clothes for the Doctor. This look is a very stripped down look. Capaldi intentionally chose to avoid having a signature item like the 11th Doctor's bow tie or the 5th Doctor's celery, wanting something that recalled the darker outfits of the first three Doctors. His is even more simplistic, it probably most resembles the 9th Doctor's outfit. In fact, the 12th Doctor doesn't wear any neckwear, despite wearing a collared shirt. The Crombie suit, with the splash of red on the inside has a certain charm to it, but it's still a very low key look.

  • The scene with the 11th Doctor was, of course, filmed as part of the filming for "The Time of the Doctor". It was intended to be the last thing that Matt Smith filmed, but circumstances led to this not being the case.

  • The "Next Time" trailer rather cleverly disguises the premise of the next episode, making it appear to be just a standard Dalek episode. Which is only ever so slightly undermined when you remember that the title of the next episode is "Into the Dalek".

Next Time: I think it's time we reconsidered the Daleks


r/gallifrey • • 9h ago

DISCUSSION Unexplored Stories and Concepts

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/gallifrey • • 1d ago

DISCUSSION What if the cybermen said yes to the Doctors offer

11 Upvotes

Just for some context:

Theres is a deleted scene in the series 2 finale titled "Doomsday". The doctor offers the cybermen to hop away and head to the tardis, I really wonder what would've happened had the cybermen said yes, or had 10 have a brief cybermen companion.


r/gallifrey • • 16h ago

AUDIO DISCUSSION Torchwood: Ex Machina

0 Upvotes

Ex Machina is the sixth episode of the sixth Torchwood Big Finish season.

Starring Gareth David-Lloyd as Ianto Jones.

Released in September 2020, written by Alfie Shaw and directed by Scott Handcock.

Guest stars includes Jacob Dudman who of course had played the Eleventh and Twelfth Doctors for Big Finish.

Ianto as usual was fronting the Tourist Information Centre when a young woman Abi came by and says that she has no memory of her friends or family and asked for Torchwood's help on this.

What is ultimately revealed is that of a creature known as the Life-optimisation engine.

This creature had granted a request from Abi to erase memories of a traumatic event in her life but gotten out of control with it erasing memories that Abi didn't asked for.

In fact the episode title comes from Deus ex machina, meaning "god from the machine" and that is exactly what this creature is.

Intriguing how this was set, the ultimate revelation of that creature and how it got dealt with for all memories to come back.

Enjoyable interviews with the cast afterwards including David-Lloyd and Laura Aikman (Abi) revealing there had worked together before this on Waterloo Road in which they played a couple.

After this came a separate interview with write Alfie Shaw and interesting on how he came up with this story essentially because of a place that was no longer connected to him

Coincidentally at the same time I listened to this I relistened to earlier Ianto episode The Office of Never Was and that too had Ianto meeting a girl with memory loss.


r/gallifrey • • 1d ago

DISCUSSION Kinda vs. The Mutants?

7 Upvotes

Both tackle colonialism in them and both having famously weak bits of special effects (not throughout, but memorably). For me I would go with Kinda, for the most part it looks good to excellent, and more engaging throughout and one of the best episodes for Tegan. But I still rate the Mutants, I think it is a great episode for the 3rd Doctor and the villains are very hateable.

I imagine more will prefer Kinda but The Mutants is great imo


r/gallifrey • • 14h ago

MISC [Fan Script] Doctor Who Virtual Season 3, Episode 2: "The Clockwork Bazaar"

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone! Thanks for reading Episode 1 ("The Ghost in the Machine"). Here is Episode 2: "The Clockwork Bazaar", where the Doctor and 2005 Rose head to a black-market asteroid hub to decode the Gallifreyan firewall inside her—only to run straight into the Void-Brokers.

DOCTOR WHO

Season 3, Episode 2: "The Clockwork Bazaar"

───

COLD OPEN

EXT. THE CLOCKWORK BAZAAR - ASTEROID RING - NIGHT

A breathtaking, sprawling metropolis built across three interlocked asteroids orbiting a ringed gas giant. Millions of neon lanterns, spinning brass gears, and floating market stalls glow against the deep indigo sky.

Down in the crowded main promenade, alien merchants of every shape and size barter over glowing memory-orbs, bottled starlight, and clockwork trinkets.

In a quiet, shadowy alcove off the main square, the familiar wheezing groan echoes through the market chimes—and the TARDIS materializes cleanly behind a stack of brass cargo crates.

INT. TARDIS CONSOLE ROOM - CONTINUOUS

THE FIFTEENTH DOCTOR (Ncuti Gatwa) stands at the console—wearing a sleek mustard-yellow double-breasted jacket over a crisp white shirt—carefully adjusting a small, intricate copper bracelet on ROSE TYLER’S (Billie Piper) wrist.

THE DOCTOR

(Tuning the bracelet with his sonic screwdriver)

It’s an Artron dampener. Should mask your energy signature from basic scanners while we’re out in the crowd—and give our telepathic link a little extra reach so you don't have to hold my hand every five seconds.

ROSE

(Flexing her wrist, smiling slightly as the faint golden veins under her skin dim to a barely visible warm shimmer)

Not that I mind holding your hand, Doctor, but yeah—being able to walk three feet away without sparking like a faulty toaster is definitely an upgrade. Where are we, anyway?

THE DOCTOR

(Grinning broadly as he throws open the TARDIS doors)

The Clockwork Bazaar! Greatest black market for temporal tech in the seven galaxies. If there’s an external firewall-cracker capable of reading that Gallifreyan code inside you without blowing a fuse, we’ll find it right here!

EXT. THE CLOCKWORK BAZAAR - CONTINUOUS

Rose steps out onto the bustling cobblestone walkway, her eyes lighting up with genuine 2005 wonder as floating mechanical gondolas drift past neon-lit stalls.

ROSE

(Laughing in delight)

Okay, brilliant! It’s like Camden Market in space!

THE DOCTOR

(Linking his arm warmly through hers)

Better! Just remember the golden rule: stay within ten paces of me so the link holds, keep that bracelet covered, and whatever you do—don't touch the memory-jars!

High above them, perched silently on a rotating brass gear-bridge, two tall, gaunt figures in immaculate obsidian suits and smooth, featureless porcelain masks—THE VOID-BROKERS—turn their heads in unison.

In the lead Broker's gloved hand, a crystalline tuning fork begins to hum loudly, vibrating with a resonant golden light that points straight down at Rose.

VOID-BROKER LEADER

(Voice sounding like layered whispers through a speaker)

Unregistered temporal density detected. Ancient signature. High-value relic.

SMASH CUT TO OPENING TITLES.

ACT ONE

EXT. THE CLOCKWORK BAZAAR - MECHANIC'S ALLEY - NIGHT

The Doctor and Rose weave through the lively crowd, passing vendors selling holographic maps and singing crystal chimes. Rose stops briefly beside a stall displaying vintage Earth vinyl records, smiling fondly.

ROSE

(Picking up a scratched 1980s single)

Blimey. My mum had this exact record. How did it end up halfway across the universe?

THE DOCTOR

(Smirking, examining a crate of scavenged temporal coils at the next stall)

Everything lost on Earth washes up at the Bazaar eventually, Rose. Now—let's see what old Jax has tucked under the counter.

Behind the stall, a gruff, four-armed Tivolian mechanic named JAX (50s) wipes grease from his goggles as the Doctor holds up a heavy, triple-core Gallifreyan decryption prism.

JAX

(Squinting at the prism)

Careful with that, off-worlder. Salvaged it from a dead time-ship out in the Medusa Cascade. Too hot for standard circuits—burns out anything you plug it into.

THE DOCTOR

(Eyes gleaming as he inspects the facets)

Not if you ground it through a dual-heart bio-regulator. How much?

JAX

Fifty credits. Or one genuine, unedited childhood memory.

ROSE

(Stepping up beside the Doctor, blinking in surprise)

Wait—people pay with memories here?

THE DOCTOR

(Quickly stepping between Rose and Jax's glowing extraction siphon)

Not us! Credits only, Sir—freshly minted!

While the Doctor haggles with Jax over a pouch of coins, Rose notices a small, frightened alien child—KIP (10)—crouched behind a stack of crates, clutching a glowing blue memory-orb while two hulking Bazaar enforcers stalk down the alley looking for him.

ENFORCER

(Barking at nearby merchants)

Little thief stole a Grade-A memory core from the Guild! Find him!

Without thinking, Rose steps slightly out of the Doctor's line of sight, ducking behind the crates to shield Kip.

ROSE

(Whispering softly to the boy)

Hey, stay quiet. Keep your head down, I’ve got you.

Across the alley, the Void-Broker Leader and three masked Brokers step silently out of the shadows, blocking the exit. Because Rose stepped just past the ten-pace limit of the copper dampener, a hairline crack of golden Artron energy flares brightly across her neck.

The Void-Broker Leader raises its crystalline tuning fork—sending a sharp, invisible sonic pulse straight at Rose's bracelet.

CRACK!

The copper dampener shatters on Rose's wrist, falling in pieces to the cobblestones!

ROSE (CONT'D)

(Gasping as the telepathic link with the Doctor violently snaps)

Doctor!

Before the Doctor can spin around, two Void-Brokers lunge forward, slapping a cold, heavy Null-Collar around Rose’s neck—instantly sealing off her energy flares and muting her voice to a muffled gasp!

THE DOCTOR

(Spinning around in horror as the Brokers drag Rose backward through a heavily shielded dimensional curtain)

Rose!! No—stop!

The Doctor sprints forward, firing his sonic screwdriver at the shimmering curtain—only for the barrier to violently deflect his sonic beam in a shower of sparks before slamming shut with a deafening thunderclap.

The Doctor stares at the sealed wall, gripping the decryption prism tightly as his jaw sets in cold, fierce determination.

THE DOCTOR (CONT'D)

(Low, dangerous)

Deadlocked dimensional fold. Smart. Good thing I didn't walk here.

He spins on his heel and sprints flat-out back toward the TARDIS alcove.

ACT TWO

INT. THE VOID-BROKERS' AUCTION HALL - NIGHT

A sleek, circular amphitheater suspended in a hidden pocket-fold beneath the central asteroid, lit by cold blue spotlights. Dozens of wealthy, masked alien collectors sit in tiered velvet booths, holding glowing bidding paddles.

In the center of the rotating glass stage stands Rose—the heavy Null-Collar locked around her throat, suppressing her golden veins so she looks completely human, though she glares fiercely at the crowd.

Beside her stands the Void-Broker Leader, addressing the amphitheater through its eerie, layered voice.

VOID-BROKER LEADER

(Gesturing toward Rose)

Esteemed collectors of the Guild. Tonight, we present an unprecedented anomaly. Beneath this primitive human shell lies a compressed, encrypted memory-matrix of unknown origin—radiating pure, primordial temporal energy! Bidding for full neural extraction begins at ten million credits!

Rose tugs furiously at the Null-Collar, trying to shout, though the collar’s dampener field only lets out a faint, strained whisper.

ROSE

(Straining against the collar)

Let me... go...!

Paddles shoot up across the velvet booths as holographic bids climb rapidly past fifteen million.

VOID-BROKER LEADER

Fifteen million! Going once... going twice...

Suddenly, a deep, resonant, unmistakable VWORP! VWORP! VWORP! echoes deafeningly through the amphitheater—shaking the glass floor and drowning out the bidding!

VOID-BROKER LEADER (CONT'D)

(Turning its featureless mask in alarm)

Impossible! This pocket-fold is deadlocked! What is breaching the perimeter?!

With a final, triumphant wheeze and a gust of temporal wind, the TARDIS materializes directly on the glass auction stage—its sheer momentum knocking two Void-Brokers off their feet and sending wealthy collectors scrambling backward in their booths!

The TARDIS doors fly open. THE DOCTOR steps out onto the glass stage—sonic screwdriver buzzing in one hand, decryption prism tucked into his mustard-yellow coat—flashing a dazzling, theatrical grin at the amphitheater.

THE DOCTOR

(Voice booming across the hall)

Sold! To the man in the blue box! Sorry to crash the party, folks—terrible acoustics in here, by the way—but you’re trying to auction off my friend, and she is strictly not for sale!

Four armed Bazaar enforcers storm down the amphitheater steps onto the stage, aiming heavy pulse-rifles straight at the Doctor and the TARDIS doors.

Beside him, Rose sees the rifles aimed at him. Panic surges through her chest—and even through the heavy Null-Collar, a tiny, desperate spark of golden Artron energy pulses against the metal lock.

THE DOCTOR (CONT'D)

(Eyes darting to Rose, realizing the Null-Collar is choking her internal energy pressure)

Wait—don't shoot! If one stray plasma bolt hits that collar around her neck, you’ll crack the containment field! Do you have any idea what happens when an ungrounded Time Vortex matrix decompresses inside a pocket dimension?!

VOID-BROKER LEADER

(Stepping forward, raising its neural-disruptor)

Explain.

THE DOCTOR

(Stepping smoothly between Rose and the enforcers' rifles)

She isn't a storage drive, you idiots! She’s a living fusion core! That collar isn't protecting you—it’s acting like a cork in a shaken bottle! Every second you keep that energy compressed inside her human cells, the pressure builds! Take it off right now, or this entire pocket-fold collapses into nothing!

ACT THREE

INT. THE VOID-BROKERS' AUCTION HALL - CONTINUOUS

The wealthy collectors in the booths murmur nervously, lowering their bidding paddles as they eye the pulsing blue police box parked in the center of their stage.

The Void-Broker Leader steps closer to the Doctor, aiming its sleek neural-disruptor directly at his chest while keeping one hand on the Null-Collar's control remote.

VOID-BROKER LEADER

(Coldly)

A clever bluff, traveler. Even with a time capsule, you are outnumbered. Our scanners confirm the data inside her is dormant. Once our extraction needles pierce her cortex, we will siphon the archive cleanly before any overload occurs.

The Void-Broker Leader presses a button on its remote. Two massive, spider-like mechanical Extraction Needles descend from the ceiling directly over Rose’s head, humming with lethal blue electricity.

Rose struggles violently against the magnetic floor restraints, looking at the Doctor with fierce trust—refusing to panic.

THE DOCTOR

(Voice dropping low, dangerous, all humor gone)

You put those needles anywhere near her mind, and you won't just get data. You’ll wake up something ancient that will burn your entire Guild to ash.

VOID-BROKER LEADER

Proceed with extraction.

As the glowing needles drop toward Rose’s temples, the Doctor doesn't reach for a weapon or make a dramatic gesture. He simply stops, stands completely still, and closes his eyes in deep concentration—projecting his Time Lord telepathy straight across the stage through the Null-Collar's interference field to reach Rose’s mind.

HUMMMMM.

Inside Rose’s head, she suddenly hears the steady, familiar thump-thump, thump-thump of the Doctor's two hearts.

THE DOCTOR (V.O. TELEPATHIC)

(Calm, anchoring her)

I’ve got you, Rose. Don't fight the collar—focus on my rhythm. Just a tiny spark, right into the lock.

Rose locks eyes with the Doctor, nods once, and channels a single, razor-thin thread of golden Artron energy straight into the Null-Collar's circuit board.

ZAP!

The Null-Collar shorts out in a burst of golden sparks, falling open onto the glass stage!

The exact second the collar drops, the full, unmasked harmonic resonance of the encrypted Gallifreyan database inside her floods the amphitheater—not as an explosion, but as an overwhelming, deafening symphony of billions of voices whispering in Old High Gallifreyan, vibrating through every crystal and glass panel in the room!

ACT FOUR

INT. THE VOID-BROKERS' AUCTION HALL - CONTINUOUS

CRACK! SHATTER!

Every crystalline tuning fork and memory-orb in the amphitheater explodes simultaneously from the sheer sonic frequency of the Gallifreyan code!

The Void-Brokers stagger backward, clutching their porcelain masks as their neural sensors overload with centuries of compressed Time Lord history they cannot comprehend.

VOID-BROKER LEADER

(Screaming in static distortion as its mask cracks down the middle)

Too much! The data—it is infinite! Shut it down!

The Doctor vaults across the stage, grabbing Rose’s hands and immediately pressing his forehead to hers—restoring their full telepathic link.

THE DOCTOR

(Firmly, soothing the roaring golden light pulsing across her arms)

Close the door, Rose! Pull it back in—match my hearts!

Rose exhales sharply, leaning against him as the deafening whispers fade back into silence, leaving only the steady, warm golden glow beneath her skin.

With the TARDIS doors standing wide open just five feet behind them, the Doctor grabs the fallen remote, uses his sonic screwdriver to pop open Rose's magnetic floor restraints, and pulls her swiftly toward the blue box as the Bazaar enforcers scramble to recover their weapons.

ROSE

(Breathless, grinning as she leaps through the TARDIS doors ahead of him)

Told you I wasn't for sale!

THE DOCTOR

(Stopping at the threshold, giving the dazed Void-Brokers a jaunty, theatrical bow)

And keep the change!

He slams the wooden doors shut just as plasma bolts scorch the outer shell—and the TARDIS vanishes off the glass stage in a triumphant gust of wind!

ENDING

INT. TARDIS CONSOLE ROOM - LATER

The TARDIS doors are sealed tight, cruising smoothly through the swirling Time Vortex.

Rose sits on the jump-seat, rubbing her neck where the Null-Collar had been, while the Doctor stands at the console—plugging the triple-core decryption prism he bought from Jax into the TARDIS's main diagnostic port.

ROSE

(Watching sparks jump across the console screen)

Did it work? Can you read the code now?

The Doctor leans closely over the monitor. The decryption prism spins rapidly, projecting a massive, three-dimensional hologram of swirling golden Gallifreyan script above the console—before a deep, crimson firewall slams down across the projection with a heavy electronic thud.

THE DOCTOR

(Frowning deeply, staring at the crimson barrier)

Only a fraction. Whoever built this firewall didn't just lock the data—they tied it directly to your cellular stability. If I force the lock open from here, the feedback could wipe out your human biology completely.

He walks over to Rose, sitting beside her and resting a steady hand over hers so their telepathic link hums warmly between them. Noticeably, the golden glow beneath Rose's skin pulses slightly brighter than it did in Episode 1—showing the energy inside her is slowly growing stronger.

ROSE

(Looking down at the brighter golden veins on her wrist, trying to sound brave)

It’s getting stronger, isn't it? Every time we use it, it gets harder to hold back.

THE DOCTOR

(Voice soft, fiercely protective)

Which means we don't have forever to figure this out. One more stop—one more frequency test—and if I can't crack that firewall safely... we’re going to have to take a much bigger risk.

He stands up, offering her a warm, encouraging smile as he reaches for the console levers.

THE DOCTOR (CONT'D)

Until then—stay close to me, Rose Tyler. Always.

As the TARDIS dematerializes deeper into the Vortex, the camera lingers on the holographic firewall hovering over the console—where a single, unmistakable Seal of Rassilon flickers briefly inside the crimson code before fading out.

SMASH TO BLACK.

END OF EPISODE 2.

With that Seal of Rassilon flickering inside the crimson firewall—and Rose's Artron energy growing stronger every time she uses it—which Gallifreyan faction or figure do you think engineered this protocol?


r/gallifrey • • 19h ago

DISCUSSION Are all Doctors the same character?

0 Upvotes

I've been arguing with several people about whether all incarnations of the Doctor are the same character. I believe they are, since they share the same memories, history and identity, but my opponents insist that each incarnation is a separate character and seem unwilling to consider arguments to the contrary. I've brought up the scene in the Tower of London dungeon in Day of the Doctor, where the Tenth and Eleventh Doctors meet the War Doctor, as well as Rose having very different relationships with the Ninth and Tenth Doctors despite being in love with the same person.

What do you think? I'm interested in your arguments.

PS. For thoughts who interested, I'm building an fun MTG Vorthos deck and intend to name Doctor with her ability 😅

PPS. Adding more context. The game which I play has a card for each Doctor and specific card I'm playing asking me to name a "character" in the game (when I'm allowed to play any card with this character on it). I want to name "Doctor" and play all Doctors.


r/gallifrey • • 1d ago

MISC Binder Short Story

0 Upvotes

I have a DW short story in the works where a Trans Man Companion is given a futuristic binder that constantly adapts to the situation.

Now originally, the idea was that the Doctor finds it and gives it to them, BUT I'm wondering would it be better for the Companion to find it by himself


r/gallifrey • • 1d ago

AUDIO NEWS Big Finish Podcast Notes / Misc. Doctor Who News Roundup - 20/11/2026

Thumbnail
reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/gallifrey • • 1d ago

MISC i cant watch the next doctor

0 Upvotes

So basically i live in europe so i don't have access to bbc.

And i tried a lot of streaming site, but none of them have this epiose

PLEASE did someone know how i can watch this episode in vo for free ?


r/gallifrey • • 1d ago

DISCUSSION I like the time lords, there so supernatural but so human so close to the average elite class the daleks are evil so openly evil you are hard to see them, the cybermen are futuristic fears the fears of technology there common in today's world but not here for now but the time lords?There just elites

0 Upvotes

They have so much potential so much to call out the elites so much potential to mimic the common world to call out the hypocrisy of not just the elites not just the master, not just rassilon not just the rani but the elite class while also pointing out the hypocrisy of humans by showing them I know time lords are shown like this already but I always thought they could have had so much more the hypocrisy of political parties, hypocrisy of environmentalists, of conspiracy theorists, religion all could have been called out in a doctor who way so much potential that's why I like the time lords and gallifriens being called out as a mirror to humans instead of a fantastic mutations or cyborgs but the closest to us in looks can be the most human in all ways so much fun ideas and the timeless child 100% at least in my opinion should have been rassilon to show the evil of the race and also the evil trauma can create


r/gallifrey • • 2d ago

MISC Wayne Yip (or more specifically Wayne Che Yip) (Class/Doctor Who director)

0 Upvotes

https://www.imdb.com/name/nm3408764/?ref_=nv_sr_srsg_0_tt_1_nm_7_in_0_q_Wayne%20Yip

Yip made his Whoniverse debut with the antepenultimate episode of Class, Detained.

Directed by Wayne Yip, the first of two episodes of the series he directed. The other is the next episode The Metaphysical Engine, or What Quill Did.

Yip later directed on parent Doctor Who with The Lie of the Land & Empress of Mars with Peter Capaldi and Resolution with Jodie Whittaker.

Outside of the Whoniverse, Yip’s other work included Secret Diary of a Call Girl starring Billie Piper, Utopia, Misfits,Salem, Dirk Gently’s Holistic Detective Agency, Cloak & Dagger, Preacher, in a different Class, that of Deadly Class, Doom Patrol, Happy!, Treadstone, Hunters (in which he reunited with Greg Austin), The Wheel of Time, The Lord of the Rings: Rings of Power & Fallout.

Marking ten years since he made his Whoniverse debut with Detained.


r/gallifrey • • 2d ago

AUDIO DISCUSSION What next for my audios?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/gallifrey • • 3d ago

MISC David Tennant addresses Doctor Who's future survival: "It depends who gets it"

57 Upvotes

David Tennant addresses Doctor Who's future survival: "It depends who gets it":

https://www.radiotimes.com/tv/sci-fi/david-tennant-doctor-who-future-survival-tender-newsupdate


r/gallifrey • • 2d ago

MISC Doctor Who?

0 Upvotes

Please help me with my college research by completing the following survey. The more responses the better. Thanks in advance for taking the time.

Doctor Who?


r/gallifrey • • 2d ago

MISC [Fan Script] Doctor Who Virtual Season 3, Episode 1: "The Echo in the Vortex" — Picking up directly after The Reality War Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I've been writing an 8-episode virtual Season 3 for the Fifteenth Doctor (Ncuti Gatwa) that picks up immediately where The Reality War left off—exploring the mystery of Billie Piper's return through classic Time Lord lore rather than simple nostalgia.

Instead of making her a standard clone or a trick, Episode 1 introduces the idea that a hidden Gallifreyan contingency protocol was triggered inside the Time Vortex when the Doctor's regeneration energy collided with it.

Here is Episode 1: "The Ghost In The Machine":

DOCTOR WHO

Season 3, Episode 1: "The Ghost in the Machine"

───

COLD OPEN

EXT. DEEP SPACE - TARDIS THRESHOLD - CONTINUOUS (FROM "THE REALITY WAR")

The TARDIS hovers in the silent void of space, its double wooden doors thrown wide open.

Standing squarely on the threshold, engulfed in roaring golden regeneration fire after shifting reality to save Poppy, is THE FIFTEENTH DOCTOR (Ncuti Gatwa), wearing his plain white t-shirt, striped denim vest, matching striped denim kilt with attached braces over denim trousers, and black boots.

As the blinding golden light swells and reshapes his features, the regeneration briefly resolves into the unmistakable face of Rose Tyler.

ROSE Tyler

(Breathless, wide-eyed)

Oh, hello!

CRACK!

A violent, thunderous harmonic snap echoes across the void. The regeneration energy violently reverses polarity, snapping backward into the Doctor’s chest. Rose Tyler’s face vanishes instantly—restoring Ncuti Gatwa as the Fifteenth Doctor.

INT. TARDIS CONSOLE ROOM - CONTINUOUS

The Doctor gasps, thrown backward by the recoil, crashing onto the grated floor beside the central console. He clutches his chest, breathing heavily, stunned to still be in his own skin.

THE DOCTOR

(Whispering, checking his own hands)

What...? No. No, no, that was it. That was the end...

Before the open wooden doors can swing shut, the massive cloud of expelled golden Time Vortex energy hanging outside in space stops drifting. Drawn inward by the hum of the TARDIS's telepathic circuits, the glowing mist seeps back inside across the threshold like liquid starlight.

The Doctor scrambles backward against the console railing, eyes wide, as the golden light gathers in the center of the console room floor.

With a soft, resonant chime, the energy condenses, weaves together, and prints a solid human form onto the metal deck.

The golden glare fades. Lying on the floor—dressed in a simple, makeshift dark jacket and jeans woven from raw temporal matter, with hairline veins of gold light pulsing faintly beneath her skin—is ROSE TYLER (Billie Piper).

She gasps, sucking in her first breath, sitting up quickly and looking around the unfamiliar, gleaming white-and-brass console room in shock.

ROSE

(Breathless, looking at her hands, then up at the Doctor)

Where am I? What happened to the platform? The Daleks—the Bad Wolf—I was just...

She freezes as she locks eyes with the Fifteenth Doctor. She looks at his face—completely unfamiliar—yet she feels an instant, undeniable pull of recognition.

ROSE (CONT'D)

(Voice trembling, backing up slightly)

Who are you? Where's the Doctor? What did you do to him?!

THE DOCTOR

(Frozen in absolute shock, staring at her)

Rose... Rose Tyler? It’s me! I’m the Doctor! I changed my face—you're supposed to be human, living your life! Satellite Five was lifetimes ago for me! How are you—

Suddenly, Rose cries out, clutching her chest. Bright, jagged arcs of golden Artron energy flare painfully across her skin and shoot out from her fingertips, scorch-marking the console railing.

ROSE

(Gasping in agony)

It's burning! It's too much—my head feels like it's going to split wide open! I don't know what's happening to me!

The Doctor’s shock instantly vanishes, replaced by pure protective instinct. He lunges forward, dropping to his knees beside her and placing his fingers gently on either side of her temples.

THE DOCTOR

(Firm, soothing, anchoring her)

Don't fight it, Rose! Your human cells weren't built to hold a storm this big alone. Let me in—match my rhythm. Two hearts, steady and slow.

A soft, warm harmonic chord hums through the TARDIS. Through their telepathic link, the violent golden sparks across Rose's skin instantly subside, settling into a faint, steady golden glow beneath her collarbone.

Rose exhales a long, shaky breath, leaning against his shoulder as she looks up at him—completely aware of who she is, yet utterly terrified of what she has become.

ROSE

(Whispering)

What am I, Doctor?

THE DOCTOR

(Looking down at her, grim and determined)

I don't know yet, Rose. But we're going to find out.

SMASH CUT TO OPENING TITLES.

───

ACT ONE

INT. TARDIS CONSOLE ROOM - MINUTES LATER

The TARDIS doors swing shut on their own. THE DOCTOR stands at the console—now wearing a sharp, tailored burgundy velvet blazer over a dark graphic tee (a fresh outfit for a fresh adventure)—frantically scanning ROSE with his sonic screwdriver while keeping one hand lightly resting against her wrist to maintain their telepathic link.

Rose sits on the jump-seat, looking at her hands. Every time the Doctor pulls his hand back even an inch, the faint golden glow beneath her skin flickers aggressively.

ROSE

(Looking around the massive console room, then squinting at his face)

You’ve redecorated. What happened to the coral? And you’ve got a whole new body—no leather jacket, no big ears, just... you. Last thing I remember, I was standing on Satellite Five, looking into the heart of the TARDIS, and then everything went gold. What happened after the Dalek Emperor? Did we make it? What happened to me?

The Doctor pauses his scan, his expression turning deeply serious. He pulls his sonic screwdriver down and looks at her carefully.

THE DOCTOR

(Firmly, gently holding up a hand)

No. Stop right there, Rose. I can't tell you.

ROSE

(Frowning, confused)

Can't tell me? Why? You're my Doctor—we travel together! What happened to us after Satellite Five?

THE DOCTOR

(Kneeling in front of her so they are eye-to-eye)

Because your mind was printed from the exact moment you looked into the Vortex on Satellite Five. To you, everything after that hasn't happened yet. And what you are right now—a living human blueprint woven out of Time Lord energy—is completely uncharted territory, Rose. Even for me, this has never happened before.

He glances at the sparking telemetry monitors, lowering his voice.

THE DOCTOR (CONT'D)

If I tell you your own future, I don't know if it'll fracture the timeline—or cause a temporal paradox that tears your energy matrix apart from the inside. So no spoilers. Not a single word about what comes after Satellite Five. Understand?

Rose stares at him, processing the weight in his eyes, before giving a slow, reluctant nod.

ROSE

(Quietly)

Okay. No spoilers. Just... tell me I'm still me.

THE DOCTOR

(A warm, reassuring smile breaking across his face)

You remember Powell Estate? Jackie? Mickey? Travelling in the blue box?

ROSE

(Smiling back through her nerves)

Every second of it.

THE DOCTOR

Then you’re Rose Tyler. Don't you ever doubt that. Now—the TARDIS sensors are overloaded by the temporal feedback, so I can't run a deep cellular diagnostic in here. We need an external high-output solar array to read your energy frequency safely.

The Doctor spins back to the console, throwing levers with energetic flair.

THE DOCTOR (CONT'D)

Good thing I know the best orbital lighthouse in the Mutter’s Spiral! Helios-9. Quiet, automated, blindingly bright—and completely empty!

VWORP! VWORP! VWORP!

INT. HELIOS-9 SOLAR LIGHTHOUSE - OBSERVATION DECK - DAY

A sleek, cavernous glass-and-brass observatory orbiting dangerously close to a roaring, blindingly bright white star. Heavy polarized shutters filter the intense solar glare.

The TARDIS materializes cleanly in the center of the deck. The doors open, and the Doctor steps out, extending a hand to Rose. As she steps out beside him, she shields her eyes from the massive white sun filling the panoramic windows.

ROSE

(Breathless, grinning despite herself)

Okay... yeah. Definitely still the Doctor. New face, same terrible habit of parking right next to exploding stars.

THE DOCTOR

(Beaming, linking his fingers briefly with hers to keep their telepathic buffer steady)

It’s a stable white dwarf, thank you very much! Right—computer terminal’s over there. Stay close to me so the link holds.

Suddenly, a metallic CLANG echoes from the upper catwalk.

The Doctor freezes. Behind a bank of dead computer servers, a disheveled engineer in a scorched yellow jumpsuit—CAPTAIN VANCE (40s)—steps out, aiming a heavy plasma-welder at them with shaking hands. Behind him, a terrified young technician, MIRA (20s), clutches a portable battery pack to her chest.

VANCE

(Voice hoarse with exhaustion)

Don't move! Turn off your lights—turn off every power cell you’ve got right now, or you’ll bring them down on us!

THE DOCTOR

(Raising his hands calmly, stepping slightly in front of Rose)

Whoa, easy! Friends! Just passing through! I’m the Doctor, and this is Rose. I thought Helios-9 was automated?

MIRA

(Whispering frantically)

It was! Until the swarm hit the relay three days ago! They ate the main reactors, drained the backup cells, and killed half the crew!

ROSE

(Frowning, stepping beside the Doctor)

Ate the reactors? What’s out here in the middle of a sun?

Above them, against the polarized glass dome, a faint, eerie fluttering sound begins—like thousands of dry leaves scraping against metal.

The Doctor looks up. Pressed against the exterior glass are dozens of massive, six-foot-wide Aether-Moths—stunning, translucent bioluminescent creatures with wings made of shifting ultraviolet light and needle-sharp proboscises designed to pierce hulls and siphon pure energy.

As the creatures look down through the glass, their compound eyes lock directly onto Rose—sensing the massive reservoir of golden Time Vortex energy humming inside her chest.

VANCE

(Horrified, staring at Rose’s glowing collar)

What is she?! Why is she lighting up like a beacon?!

THE DOCTOR

(Eyes widening as the Aether-Moths begin slamming their needle-like beaks violently against the reinforced glass)

Oh, brilliant. Energy parasites from the corona! And Rose is a five-star buffet! Run!

───

ACT TWO

INT. HELIOS-9 - CENTRAL REACTOR CORRIDOR - CONTINUOUS

CRASH!

A pane of reinforced dome glass shatters above the observation deck. Three massive Aether-Moths swoop inside, their ultraviolet wings casting eerie shadows down the steel corridors as they shriek in a high-pitched harmonic frequency.

The Doctor, Rose, Vance, and Mira sprint through a heavy bulkhead door. The Doctor slaps the manual override, sealing the blast door just as an Aether-Moth slams against the steel—its needle-like proboscis punching halfway through the metal and sparking wildly as it tries to siphon power from the door's wiring.

MIRA

(Pressing herself against the wall, hyperventilating)

They’re tearing through the hull! The life-support batteries only have twenty minutes left before the solar shielding drops and the sun cooks us alive!

VANCE

(Glaring suspiciously at Rose)

They were dormant until you walked in! They didn't even care about our emergency reserve cells until she lit up!

ROSE

(Stepping forward, defensive, though her golden veins flicker nervously)

Hey, I didn't ask to be a giant battery! And I’m not letting anyone get hurt because of me!

THE DOCTOR

(Stepping smoothly between Vance and Rose, radiating calm command)

Nobody’s getting cooked, Captain! Give me five minutes at your auxiliary telemetry console. I can run a quick bio-scan on Rose, figure out what frequency she’s broadcasting, and use the station’s solar dish to broadcast a decoy signal that’ll lead every single moth straight out into the sun's corona!

VANCE

The auxiliary console is in the lower sub-station—and the main lift is dead!

THE DOCTOR

(Grinning, pulling out his sonic screwdriver)

Good thing I brought my own transport! Stay here, seal the vents, and keep your power packs switched off! Rose—with me!

Before they can turn back toward the TARDIS, the ceiling ventilation grate rips open above them.

Two Aether-Moths drop silently into the narrow corridor, blocking their path back to the observation deck. Their wings flare blindingly bright, emitting a psychic hum that disrupts the air—and violently snaps the telepathic link between the Doctor and Rose.

ROSE

(Gasping, dropping to one knee as her golden veins flare out of control)

Doctor—the link! I can't feel you—it’s burning again!

THE DOCTOR

(Reaching out, trying to push through the moths' static field)

Hold on, Rose! Don't let it surge—if you release a pulse in here, they’ll swarm the whole deck!

One of the Aether-Moths lunges straight at Rose, its sharp proboscis aimed directly at her chest.

Instinctively, Rose throws her hands up to shield her face. A blinding shockwave of raw golden Time Vortex energy erupts from her palms—blasting the creature backward down the corridor in a shower of harmless golden sparks.

Instead of injuring the moth, the pure Artron energy supercharges it—making it double in size, its wings burning with intense golden fire as it screeches in ecstatic hunger, calling the entire swarm outside straight toward their section of the station.

VANCE

(Staring in terror at the supercharged moth)

She’s feeding them! She’s making them stronger!

───

ACT THREE

INT. HELIOS-9 - LOWER SUB-STATION - MINUTES LATER

The Doctor grabs Rose’s hand, pulling her through a narrow maintenance hatch into the dimly lit lower sub-station while Vance and Mira seal the hatch behind them.

The station shudders violently as dozens of supercharged Aether-Moths slam against the outer hull, the metal groaning under their assault.

The Doctor immediately presses his forehead gently against Rose’s, re-establishing their telepathic link. Instantly, the blinding golden flares under her skin calm down, settling back into a steady hum.

ROSE

(Breathless, tears of frustration in her eyes)

I’m sorry, Doctor. I didn't mean to—when it lunged at me, the power just... reacted on its own. Like it was protecting me.

THE DOCTOR

(Softly, holding her shoulders)

Hey. Don't apologize for surviving. That energy isn't a weapon—it’s an instinct. Now stay right beside me while I hook up the telemetry scanner.

The Doctor jacks his sonic screwdriver into the sub-station’s main console, routing the station's external solar sensors onto a cracked holographic screen.

As the diagnostic bars scan Rose’s silhouette, the Doctor’s playful energy suddenly vanishes. His face goes completely pale as lines of ancient, complex Gallifreyan circular script begin scrolling rapidly across the monitor alongside her human DNA helix.

MIRA

(Looking at the screen, confused)

What kind of code is that? That’s not Federation standard.

ROSE

(Stepping closer, staring at the swirling Gallifreyan symbols—and hearing a faint, distant whisper of voices in her mind)

Doctor... I recognize those circles. Why do I know what those symbols mean?

THE DOCTOR

(Whispering, completely stunned)

No... impossible. That’s Matrix code. Old High Gallifreyan. Rose, you aren't just made of Time Lord energy. There’s an entire compressed data-structure woven into your cellular matrix. Something vast. Something ancient.

VANCE

(Alarmed as the hull groans louder, cracks forming in the bulkhead)

Whatever she is, we’ve got ninety seconds before the outer hull breaches and the solar radiation fries us! Your decoy plan, Doctor—now!

The Doctor’s mind races, looking from the terrified crew, to the cracking hull, to the massive golden energy signature pulsing on the scanner beside Rose.

THE DOCTOR

**(**Eyes lighting up with a sudden, daring idea)

The station’s power cells are dead—we don't have enough juice to broadcast a decoy signal into the corona. Unless...

He turns slowly to look at Rose.

THE DOCTOR (CONT'D)

Rose, remember on Satellite Five? You didn't hold the Vortex inside you. You let it flow through you. If I use the sub-station’s solar dish to channel a controlled stream of your energy straight out into the sun's corona, the moths will chase the trail all the way out into deep space!

ROSE

(Stepping up to the console without a second of hesitation, eyes glowing faintly with gold)

Tell me where to put my hands, Doctor.

VANCE

(Grabbing his plasma-welder, stepping beside Mira at the hatch)

If she blows the dish, we’re dead anyway. Let’s reinforce the door—buy them time!

───

ACT FOUR

INT. HELIOS-9 - LOWER SUB-STATION - CONTINUOUS

BOOM!

The maintenance hatch blows inward. Three massive, golden-charged Aether-Moths force their way into the sub-station, shrieking deafeningly as they dive straight toward Rose.

Vance fires his plasma-welder into the ceiling pipes, unleashing a blinding cloud of steam that momentarily blinds the creatures, while Mira cranks the manual dish alignment wheel.

At the main console, the Doctor places his hands over Rose’s on the conductive brass conductors—maintaining their telepathic link so he acts as her safety valve.

THE DOCTOR

(Shouting over the shrieking moths and alarms)

Steady, Rose! Don't dump it all at once—just open the valve a fraction! Let me guide the frequency!

ROSE

(Closing her eyes, focusing on the warm golden hum inside her chest)

I’ve got it! Now, Doctor!

Rose releases a controlled, brilliant ribbon of golden Artron light into the console conductors.The energy shoots up through the station’s external solar dish, firing a dazzling, mile-wide beam of pure golden light straight out into the roaring white corona of the star.

Instantly, the three Aether-Moths inside the sub-station stop inches from Vance and Mira. Drawn by the massive, irresistible buffet of pure Time Vortex energy streaking across space, they turn and dart back out through the breached hatch—joining the entire external swarm as thousands of bioluminescent moths chase the golden trail out into the solar winds.

Rose gasps, pulling her hands back from the console as the beam cuts out. She stumbles slightly, exhausted, and the Doctor catches her immediately, steadying her with their telepathic link.

Silence falls over the sub-station, broken only by the hum of the solar shielding kicking back online.

MIRA

(Looking out the viewport as the golden swarm disappears into the distance)

They’re gone... the shields are holding! We’re safe!

VANCE

(Lowering his welder, looking at Rose with newfound respect)

I don't know what you are, Rose Tyler... but thank you.

───

ENDING

INT. TARDIS CONSOLE ROOM - LATER

The TARDIS doors swing shut, sealing out the bright glare of Helios-9.

Rose sits quietly on the steps beneath the central rotor, wrapped in a spare blanket, staring down at her hands. The golden veins beneath her skin are calm now, pulsing softly in sync with the TARDIS engines.

The Doctor walks over, carrying two steaming mugs of tea, and sits down beside her on the steps. He hands her a mug, keeping his shoulder pressed lightly against hers so their telepathic link stays intact.

ROSE

(Taking a sip, looking up at him with quiet honesty)

I saw things when I opened up that energy, Doctor. Just for a split second. Towers made of glass. Red grass. Millions of voices whispering in a language I shouldn't know.

The Doctor’s smile fades slightly, his eyes growing deep and serious as he looks at the scanner screen—where the cryptic Gallifreyan circular script still glows faintly.

ROSE (CONT'D)

(Softly)

You still don't know what I am, do you?

THE DOCTOR

(Resting a reassuring hand over hers, looking her dead in the eye)

Not yet. That code inside you is locked behind a firewall even I can't crack from in here. It’s old, Rose—older than my last few faces. And we are completely off the map.

He stands up, offering her his hand with a warm, fierce determination.

THE DOCTOR (CONT'D)

So here’s the deal: no spoilers about your future, and you stay close to me so I can keep that energy steady. Wherever we go next, we’re going to find out who put that archive inside you—and why they chose Rose Tyler.

Rose takes his hand, standing beside him at the console as the Doctor pulls the dematerialization lever.

As the TARDIS takes flight into the Time Vortex, the camera pans slowly toward the glowing scanner screen—zooming in on the spinning Gallifreyan circular symbols pulsing in rhythm with Rose’s heartbeat.

SMASH TO BLACK.

END OF EPISODE 1.


r/gallifrey • • 3d ago

MISC Why Was Revenge Of The Cybermen Rewatched Endlessly?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
11 Upvotes

r/gallifrey • • 3d ago

MISC Looking for Pudsey tenth anniversary

7 Upvotes

November 18 2026 marks ten years since the release of Looking for Pudsey:

https://tardis.fandom.com/wiki/Looking_for_Pudsey_(TV_story)

This has Eddie Redmayne who in the midst of filming for Fantastic Beasts find himself in the search for Pudsey the bear and contacts several famous people on the phone for this search.

Among them is Peter Capaldi as the Doctor.


r/gallifrey • • 3d ago

MISC Class: Detained tenth anniversary

0 Upvotes

November 19 2026 marks ten years since the original broadcast of Detained, the antepenultimate episode of Class.

Coincidentally it was on Katherine Kelly's birthday but ironically appears very little as Quill here.

Written by series creator Patrick Ness.

Directed by Wayne Yip, the first of two episodes of the series he directed. The other is the next episode The Metaphysical Engine, or What Quill Did.

Yip later directed on parent Doctor Who with The Lie of the Land & Empress of Mars with Peter Capaldi and Resolution with Jodie Whittaker.

Outside of the Whoniverse, Yip's other work included Secret Diary of a Call Girl starring Billie Piper, Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency, in a different Class, that of Deadly Class, Hunters (in which he reunited with Greg Austin), The Wheel of Time & The Lord of the Rings: Rings of Power.

Detained starts with Miss Quill placing Charlie in detention with April, Ram, Tanya and Matteusz.

The detention is for 45 minutes while Quill will be elsewhere attending to urgent matters.

Not long after Quill leaves, a meteor flies through a tear in space-time and displaces the classroom with the five kids are in to an unknown location that has been described as being outside of both time and space.

With the five kids there is also a small meteor in the classroom.

Whoever holds the meteor forces the person to reveal unsettlingly and personal truths.

Eventually it is revealed that the meteor is the consciousness of a murderous prisoner and the kids are now in his augmented prison cell.

Charlie eventually realised that he has more guilt than the prisoner and thus this enabled him to defeat the prisoner and return the kids back to Coal Hill.

However it is not quite over as the meteor still needs to house a prisoner and Charlie being the guiltiest, the meteor attempts to detain him.

Charlie then got saved when the meteor was fired upon by a returning Quill.

Quill is now noticeably different as she now has long hair and a scar below her left eye and she revealed that the arn has been removed from her head.

Hence why she is able to use a gun and that she is no longer Charlie's slave and has her free will back.

Quill expressed distress with the day she just had even though it has been 45 minutes for the kids. The next episode The Metaphysical Engine, or What Quill Did will reveal that it is set concurrent to Detained and will show what Quill was doing while the kids had their detention.

Detained makes for an intense and standout episode of the series with it showing the kids revealing their truths reflecting on the tenseness of the situation and culminating with Quill turning up at the end with a surprisingly new look and setting the stage for the audience on The Metaphysical Engine, or What Quill Did.


r/gallifrey • • 4d ago

DISCUSSION In anticipation of the 60th soundtrack, what is your favourite of Murray’s scores?

10 Upvotes

Which season or era of Doctor Who that Murray Gold has scored stands out as your favourite of his works? For me, it might be S5 with S3 coming a close second


r/gallifrey • • 4d ago

DISCUSSION 2028 or 2029?

16 Upvotes

In light of recent news I thought I would ask the question...when do we think the show is coming back? The official tender documents said 2028/29 so which do we think?

It also probably heavily depends on who gets chosen. We know they get notified in March 2027, I imagine someone like Hat Trick (with Jed Mercurio already on board) would presumably have a bigger head start than a company without a writer (and possible talent) already attached. Even so though, going from pre-production in March 2027 to having a full series ready to broadcast for 2028 (even late 2028) seems slightly unlikely given modern TV practices. Definitely not impossible, but I get the sense they will want to take their time. Like I said it all depends on who gets chosen but I could potentially see it working out with a Christmas special in 2028 to launch the new series and then a series in early 2029 (maybe even in January?)

Although, March 2027 - October 2028 is 19 months so maybe that is plenty of time? It all just depends on how they want to go about it I suppose!